What are the UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer's plans for illegal immigration? | BBC Newscast

UK Prime Ministers
23 followers
28 Video Views·May 17, 2025
Today, the UK is in talks with other countries to set up overseas “return hubs” for failed asylum seekers.
Adam and Chris are joined by Caitriona Perry chief presenter for BBC News and diplomatic correspondent James Landale.
They also discuss the will they, won’t they have the last 24 hours over a meeting between Putin, Trump and Zelensky.
When we had a Conservative government and Keir Starmer was the leader of the opposition,
he was opposed to their policy of sending asylum seekers to Rwanda.
Now Keir Starmer is the Prime Minister and he's talking about sending
failed asylum seekers to countries like Albania.
So, what's the difference?
We will discuss on this episode of the BBC's daily news podcast, Newscast.
Hello, it's Adam in the Newscast studio.
And Chris in the studio.
And it's James also in the studio.
And it's Katrina in the Washington studio.
We'll talk about all matters Trump in a second and the bizarre case of who's going to Turkey
to negotiate peace in Ukraine or not.
But Chris, first of all, I wanted to talk about Keir Starmer going to Albania
and this slightly odd situation we had where he was in Albania,
but launching a sort of policy that Albania isn't going to,
a deal that Albania is never going to do with him.
Yes.
Just explain what's going on.
There was this curious mismatch today between the most eye-catching idea
that the Prime Minister was floating and the backdrop that he chose to float it.
So, this is the idea around illegal migration.
It's been, for the government, a real week of talking about migration,
trying to look muscular.
This idea around illegal migration, you have these so-called return hubs.
So, people who have exhausted legal avenues in the UK to stay,
they are failed asylum seekers,
but where the government might fear that they will find mechanisms
to try and delay, put off their deportation,
perhaps changing their circumstances, starting a family,
losing their paperwork, that kind of stuff,
could be sent to a return hub en route, in theory,
to being returned to their home country.
So, the government is talking to a handful of European countries.
We think broadly in the Balkans about that idea.
They're not naming which countries yet.
There aren't any deals there yet to be signed.
There he is in Albania,
which has a migrants deal with Italy across the Adriatic.
Prime Minister's there because the European political community,
that organisation that is the EU plus others, is meeting on Friday.
He's talking up this idea of return hubs,
and so, perfectly reasonably, the question is,
well, what about doing one with Albania?
He has stood next to the Albanian Prime Minister at the time,
and the Albanian Prime Minister says,
no, no, no, not with you guys, or indeed with anyone else.
We've done one with Italy,
or an arrangement with Italy around migrants,
and that is that.
Now, Downing Street are trying to say,
look, we never thought there would be one with Albania,
but it is a little bit, I mean, you know,
awkward in terms of what it looks like.
It's a reminder of just the challenge of trying to find
workable solutions or parts of a solution
to dealing with the small boats issue.
12,000 people now, this calendar year,
have crossed the Channel by small boat.
Let's hear a little bit of what Kirstarmer said
when he was in Albania.
We are in talks with a number of countries
about return hubs,
and I see them as a really important innovation,
and that is consistent with the work that we've done
in relation to UK-Albania reduction in numbers,
the work that we've done on law enforcement arrangements
with other countries,
the return agreements that we've put in place,
the record number of returns,
and what I'd like to do is add return hubs to that.
We are in those talks,
and therefore, at the appropriate time,
I'll be able to give you further details
in relation to it.
And James, we should just clarify
that at first listen,
the return hub might sound a little bit
like the Rwanda program
that the previous government had,
but this is different.
Yeah, the Rwanda scheme
was where people would be sent to Rwanda
where their claim would be assessed.
This is a scheme where these are people
who their assessment has already been completed,
and then they haven't succeeded,
and they have been sent out.
So it is a different scheme,
but it still involves a degree of the process
taking place outside of the UK
as an attempt to deter.
And Chris, this has been quite a big week
in the government's conversation about immigration.
This is the first time you and I
have actually chatted about
the Prime Minister's speech on Monday.
And that phrase, it's really lodged in my brain,
which is a sign of a successful political phrase
for the people who agree with it
or disagree with it, love it or hate it.
The idea that Britain could become
an island of strangers.
How do you think that phrase has kind of
lodged in the Westminster minds now?
Obviously, there's not one mind at Westminster,
but you know what I mean.
Well, I think the key observation
is that it has lodged in the mind
in so much as these things ever can.
I think it has.
And Downing Street knew what they were doing.
Not everyone in the Labour Party is happy with it.
I think they feel that they have got
to be seen to be muscular
and that in delivering ideas
that they hope will point to a trend over time
of reducing the net migration figures,
that's going to take some time.
And in the meantime,
they want language that shows their intent.
What we will get next week, next Thursday,
is the next set that come every six months,
the next set of net migration figures.
They will be considerably down.
We know that from the visas that have been granted.
What we don't know is the emigration element,
which obviously is the other side of the equation
as far as net migration is concerned,
taking the emigration off the immigration.
The number will be well down,
but it'll still be in the three, 400,000 probably.
And the aim from the measures
that the government announced the other day,
and which will come in there,
some will be short term,
some will require legislation
in the next couple of years.
It's a squeeze it by about another 100,000 a year
by the end of the parliament.
But they need to be able to,
they are of the view,
they need to be able to demonstrate
that that was that downward trend.
And they're willing to repeat the language.
The Prime Minister repeated the phrase
that Prime Minister's questions on Wednesday.
Did they deliberately echo Enoch Powell
or was that just to happen?
When he said rivers of blood in 1968.
There's a phrase in that same speech.
There was an expression,
I can't remember precisely,
where Enoch Powell used that phrase, strangers.
So was it a deliberate echo?
Or do people even know who Enoch Powell was these days?
It's a fair question, isn't it?
We could do an old newscast episode about that speech.
Yeah, I mean, so I've asked that question
and I've not got a straight answer,
is the honest truth.
I would be surprised if those compiling a speech like that
weren't aware of the history of that kind of phrase,
would be my kind of hunch.
And they make the argument
that if you look at the paragraph, if you like,
that the Prime Minister said,
the overall context is arguably pretty different
from what we heard a generation or two ago.
But I think, yeah,
the desire to grab people's attention with that phrase
from someone who a matter of a couple of years ago
was talking up the merits of freedom of movement,
was talking about a second referendum
as far as Brexit is concerned, et cetera, et cetera.
It's one heck of a move.
And also then the whole conversation
about whether the scale of that rhetoric
is that matched by the actual scale of the reforms
to the immigration system
that the government is imposing
on which there's lots of different views.
Katrina, to go back to where we started
when talking about this idea of people being sent
to somewhere like Albania
after they exhausted all their legal avenues,
maybe multiple attempts through the UK's asylum system.
I just wonder from America
and what Donald Trump's administration is doing
with sending people to various places,
whether that sounds like a very kind of like
low calorie approach
as opposed to what the American administration
is currently doing.
Well, definitely the language is a lot more polite, isn't it?
I mean, you're talking about return hubs here.
They're called deportation centres
and everything about it's quite harsh from the outset.
There's no attempt to make it sound polite or nice.
And as we've seen in the last few months,
people are just being rounded up off the streets sometimes
when they come in for regular appointments
with immigration officials.
They're being detained without due process largely,
which is why we're seeing all of these lawsuits
about so much of this.
And, you know, President Trump's plans have been broadly
actually very efficient and effective.
If you look at the numbers of people
who are crossing the borders here,
it's way, way down since he came into office.
But many of those policies are mired up
in various court proceedings
and it will be many months before they're unwound
and we see just where they land.
Yeah, and I know there's multiple court processes going on,
but does it look like his agenda
is going to be stymied by the courts
or is he going to be able to get some wins here?
Well, there are so many different initiatives
that he's taking on.
I mean, the big one today that we're focusing on
is the Supreme Court has been hearing arguments
about President Trump's efforts to restrict
or ban entirely this birthright citizenship,
which basically under the constitution
it's been broadly interpreted since 1898
that if you're born in America,
you have an automatic right to citizenship.
Now, there are some exceptions
if you're born to diplomats, for example,
you're taught to have an allegiance
to another jurisdiction
so your children don't get citizenship
if you're here illegally, undocumented,
if you don't have paperwork,
if you have criminal endeavors and so on.
But it's always been taught that that is the law
until President Trump signed an executive order.
One of the first he signed actually
upon coming into office the second time
three judges at federal courts have banned it
and they've issued nationwide injunctions,
which means they've banned it not just in their state,
but for the whole country
until it's weeds its way
right up through the Supreme Court.
So the Trump administration has challenged these bans
as you would imagine it would,
but it sought to challenge them
not on what they're actually trying to do
in terms of remove that citizenship entitlement,
but they've challenged it on the legality
of nationwide jurisdiction.
So they've been hearing those arguments this morning,
but in hearing those arguments,
the Supreme Court has also been hearing
what's at the crux of it.
So they're very divided
based on the questions they've been asking
and interestingly, Justice Brett Kavanaugh,
who's one of President Trump's appointees
the first time around,
he's been asking the question,
well, what are hospitals supposed to do
with babies when they're born then
if they're not citizens
or if there isn't a nationwide ban,
you're born in New York and you're a citizen,
you're born across the bridge in New Jersey
because maybe you're in a taxi or an ambulance
and you didn't get to the hospital on time,
your mom didn't get to the hospital on time,
suddenly you're not a citizen.
So we'll have to wait for that ruling to come down,
but that has the potential to impact a lot
of what President Trump is doing,
not just on immigration and citizenship,
but on many other things
where they're having these nationwide bans
or temporary injunctions issued.
Yeah, and it's interesting because people say,
oh, this returns hub that the UK wants to set up
somewhere in the Western Balkans,
they're copying what Italy is doing with Albania.
It's like, well, actually,
the Italian courts have stepped in
and stopped Italy doing it.
So you had the Rwanda policy being challenged
in the courts in the UK,
you've got the Italian policy being challenged
in the Italian courts,
you've got Donald Trump being challenged
in the American courts.
It's a reminder that reforming immigration systems,
because it's to do with people's lives and their rights,
quite easy to announce something
and a different thing to actually implement it.
Completely that, completely that.
And that's, I think, exactly what we're seeing
so many Western governments wrestle with, aren't we?
And I think that's going to go on for,
it's going to be one of the stories
of the next generation, I think.
Decades.
If you look at the demographics,
particularly in Africa,
the scale of the birth rate is so high
that there's, you know,
if you talk to African leaders,
they're all worried about migration within Africa
as people go from poorer parts to wealthy parts.
And then ultimately,
the impact that that will have
of other people trying to move out of Africa
to other parts of Europe
where you've got population declines
and ageing populations.
You know, this is not something
that's just going to be here for,
you know, it's not just about fixing the boat.
It's a much longer problem.
Chris, you mentioned this meeting,
the other reason Keir Starmer is in Albania
is for this European political community.
European political communities
is going to be a big theme the next few days
because there's then another big UK-EU meeting on Monday
where we're going to get the reset in action.
Yeah, we are.
Reset of the relationship between London and Brussels.
Yeah, so the EU sort of top brass will be in London
and there'll be the flags and the handshakes
and all the rest of it.
And this will be the sense of what this
much talked about, quote unquote, reset,
that is the language that the prime minister
has been using since the election,
best part of a year ago,
are all stacks up to.
There's going to be a meeting I hear
of the EU ambassadors on Sunday
to sign off where they've got up to.
Someone was saying to me today,
there's a little bit of a parallel
with the arrangement we saw with Donald Trump
a couple of weeks ago.
In other words, there'll be a sort of
heads of chapters kind of sense to it
and then plenty more discussions to come in the mix.
And this is where it's all a bit deja vu
from the Brexit years.
Fish movement in this context,
youth mobility.
Be curious to see how that is badged
because there's a real nervousness
on this side of the channel about that
looking or smelling like free movement,
even if it is time limited and age limited,
which by the definition of youth mobility,
it's going to be or likely to be.
What else is there?
Your old favorite of sanitary and phytosanitary
whole business of animal products being moved around.
Dynamic alignment.
The idea of, you know,
does the UK sign up to EU rules
that over time might change
and the UK will have to accept those changes.
Hugely contested area
as far as the post Brexit settlement is concerned
into James's territory of defence and security.
That's in the mix too.
So yeah, it'd be quite a thing really, I think.
Oh, and will there be direct oversight
by the European Court of Justice
or will there be an independent arbitration panel
where the EU side can ask
the European Court of Justice for an opinion
that can be then copied and pasted
and sent to the independent arbitration panel?
I can't wait.
How will I sleep on Sunday night?
I hope you're...
Knowing that that's about to be revealed.
If only we had somebody who was deep in the weeds,
who had a nerd like fascination for EU rules.
I don't know, you know, is there one to hand?
And also doesn't have to be on the news
all day on the day it happens.
So we can actually read it.
Yeah, no, exactly.
Completely.
Isn't the interesting question
is whether or not any of this stacks up
to meet the challenge of the era?
Yes.
Because there is a risk that we end up
looking at minutiae.
I mean, you know, in the big grand scheme of things,
youth mobility, fighter sanitary, all of that,
you know, it's low grade stuff.
The real substantial engagement
between the UK and European nations at the moment
is over Ukraine and is over the defence of this continent
against Russia in the years going forward.
And fundamentally, you know, that's my patch.
So, you know, sort of that,
I would say that's more important.
But I think that is, for me, the interesting question.
Katrina, we're recording this episode
of Newscast on Thursday evening,
and everyone's sort of playing a sort of game
of guess who where in Turkey,
because a few days ago,
we would have thought like all the main players,
maybe not Donald Trump,
but all the main players
in the Russia-Ukraine conflict
were going to go to Turkey
to have face to face talks,
not necessarily talks that would come up
with like a final deal on the conflict,
but something that would seem quite momentous.
And on tonight, on Thursday night,
we're like, hang on, who's actually who's there?
It's not not even the B list or the C list.
That's it.
And we're slightly still guessing as well,
because President Trump has teased
just in the last hour or two
that when he's leaving the Middle East,
that he's almost destination unknown.
Probably Washington, D.C., he said.
But you never know.
I'll go where I need to be or words to that effect.
So still very much teasing.
But yeah, as you say, as of now,
the talks in Istanbul on Friday are,
you know, the Ukrainian defense minister
will be there.
The U.S. Secretary of State, Marco Rubio,
who, of course, is also
the national security advisor,
the director of USAID
and the head of the National Archives.
He will be there.
And then it's a Russian presidential advisor
and again, some, you know,
lower level individuals there.
So not what we had taught,
not what President Putin himself,
we have to remember,
was the one who put forward
the notion of having these high level talks
in the first place.
And as we know, as of last night,
his name not on that attendance list.
Is there still a will he won't he element?
Might he turn up?
Who knows?
So I'm just going to revise what I said.
It sounds like from the Russian side,
it's C list.
From the Ukrainian side, it's B list.
And the American side, it's B list.
But with the prospect of the A list.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah.
James, what's your take on
this moment we're at now?
Because a few days ago,
it sounds like this was going to,
this could be one of those pivots in the conflict.
And now it's just a sort of,
it's more of a well than a pivot.
I hope I make light of an important subject, obviously.
I personally, I was always skeptical
because the bottom line is
I have yet to see any evidence
that Russia, Vladimir Putin,
has changed his position
and is willing actually to negotiate
in any shape or form whatsoever.
And therefore,
even if there is some kind of engagement
face to face between some Ukrainians
and some Russians or whatever level,
you know, clearly that is a thing
because it hasn't happened since 2022.
But the bottom line is
that we're in exactly the same position.
You've got the Ukrainians,
you've got Zelensky desperately trying to stay in
with the Russians by saying,
look, I'm willing, I'm willing to do anything.
I will, I'll do a 30 day ceasefire.
You ask that, I'll do it.
You want me to talk and talk, go to Turkey,
I'll go to Turkey.
I'll talk to whoever you want me to talk to.
And just to stay on board,
you've got the Europeans
trying to keep the pressure on Putin
by saying to the Americans,
look, it's Putin who is slowing this down.
He's the refusenikid.
And yet you've got the Americans
still refusing to give any kind of pressure on Putin,
put a time scale,
anything that actually sort of says,
yeah, you've really got to come to the table.
Because if you think about it,
Donald Trump's now in his third position.
Since Saturday, on Saturday,
when he sat down and had that conversation
with all the three, you know,
would you remember that picture of Starmer and Macron
met around the mobile phone
in with President Zelensky and they agreed,
okay, we've got a plan.
We demand a 30 days unconditional ceasefire.
And if not, we'll put massive new sanctions on.
The next day, Putin says,
oh, no, let's have some talks in Turkey on Thursday.
So Trump says, oh, okay, let's do that.
Right, completely undermining
the United European American strategy.
And then today has sort of become a bit of a farce.
And so on his plane, Trump said,
look, this is only going to get sorted
if I meet Putin, if we see each other,
which is now the third position
and one that undermines the Ukrainians
because essentially we're back in the same place,
which is that this is a Trump-Putin conversation
that can solve the problem.
Which is basically back to square one.
We're still where we are.
The Europeans and the Ukrainians are hoping
that eventually the penny will drop in Washington.
That the Russians are never going to come around to this.
And that actually the only way Putin will come to the table
if some pressure is leveraged.
The problem is that Donald Trump is widely seen
not only to want to end the war in Ukraine,
but also to have a rapprochement
between Washington and Moscow.
To have a reset of the US-Russian relationship.
Those two are different priorities.
And nobody really knows which is the primary issue for him.
Because it's entirely possible that Donald Trump could say,
lose interest in Ukraine,
while still maintaining his desire
to have a new relationship.
He talks a lot about business negotiation, business deals.
You know, Steve Whitcock, his envoy, echoes that language.
Katrina, can you help us out on that?
Yeah, I would just say two things that happen
in the Middle East or are happening
might slightly inspire President Putin
to maybe make a move.
But I agree with James,
he hasn't made any evidence in that regard yet.
But President Trump lifting the sanctions on Syria
and it looks like they're about to do a deal with Iran as well
and will lift the sanctions
or at least most of the economic sanctions on Iran.
So President Trump is doing things
that other American presidents don't do.
And would traditionally be a deeply unpopular thing
to do lifting sanctions
without actually seeing anything upfront
as the reason for lifting those sanctions.
So, you know, if there's anything
that maybe might move Putin along,
maybe it's the concept of these sanctions might be lifted.
What he is, it seems to be ultimately looking for.
The big gray area though, is of course,
President Trump threatened extra sanctions
if President Putin didn't move towards peace.
So is he actually going to do that
given that he does want this warmer relationship
that James has been describing there?
So, I mean, we're kind of in the realm of total
and other guesswork here with individuals
that are, you know, playing.
I don't know if it's chess
or it's some kind of, you know,
one-upmanship thing that's going on,
but there's definitely some kind of mind games happening.
Or like chess, but with the rules of monopoly.
I was really struck on the last episode of Newscast that I did,
which you can listen to on BBC Sounds.
And I was chatting to the other Chris, Chris Steele,
the former MI6 officer, who's a Russia analyst.
And he was saying, and Steve Rosenberg, our Moscow colleague,
was saying that the amount of anti-British rhetoric
and propaganda coming out of the Kremlin now is massive.
I think sometimes the UK is a proxy.
And if you have a Russian media
that isn't entirely sure
what Vladimir Putin's attitude to Donald Trump is,
and you need to have a good kicking of the West,
you can't be explicit with the Americans
because they don't want to be too hard on the Americans
if suddenly Putin comes and turns around
and there is a recent.
So, as well as just going for Zelensky,
then you need to go for somebody else in the West
who is supporting Zelensky.
And therefore, they might as well go for us
because we're the British
and there's a history to all of that.
Some Russians, there's a sort of romantic heart
back to their past connections with France.
We've all read our Tolstoy.
And so, occasionally, they'd like to pick on us.
But also, for me, it's like the Iranians,
America is the big Satan, we're the little Satan.
We're always seen as the sort of little mini-me.
And the gag, of course, is always that the Iranians
is the last remaining country that thinks
that the UK is still a great power on the world
because we're always to blame for everything.
Literally, it's beyond the competence
of most British governments.
But I think that's probably a factor, as well,
in the Russian media barrage
simply because the British government,
led by Boris Johnson, got in early
in support of Ukraine.
And so, we sort of always,
we're lodged into the Russian psyche in that regard.
It all makes sense.
James, thank you very much.
Thank you very much.
And Chris and Katrina, your annotated copies
of War and Peace are in the posts.
Thank you.
That was spectacular, Adam.
The best newscast ever.
Ah, at last, somebody gussed about me.
Right, that's all for this episode of Newscast.
Thank you very much for watching.
See you again soon.
Bye-bye.
Bye.
