10 Low Calorie Protein Ice Cream Recipes

Famous Food
347 followers
If you love high protein, low calorie ice cream, the Ninja Creamy is an amazing investment.
If you know how to use it, the possibilities are endless. You can make pretty much any ice cream
flavor for a fraction of the calories of a normal pint. But the biggest issue with the Ninja Creamy
in my opinion is it's not that intuitive or easy to use. Creating the perfect pint actually takes
a lot of trial and error, money spent on ingredients, and time. But lucky for you guys,
you don't have to lift a finger. I've spent probably hundreds of hours at this point
testing different Ninja Creamy recipes in order to find the creamiest, most delicious ones.
Hi, if you're new here, I'm Amanda, aka FitFoodAE, and today I've compiled 10 of my best
high protein, low calorie ice cream recipes using the Ninja Creamy. So if you're excited
to see these recipes, please give this video a like, subscribe, and share it with your friends
as it really helps the channel and I post new videos every week. And with that, let's get
started. So first up, we've got classic vanilla. I know a lot of you guys don't like mix-ins and
you just like, you know, the classic plain recipes. So let's get right to it. We're gonna add two
types of milk. So unsweetened almond milk and Fairlife skim milk, which is like a higher protein
milk. Of course, we're using PE Science vanilla and some fat-free vanilla pudding mix. Gotta add
sweetener. I use some monk fruit and we're gonna mix it all together. There's probably better ways
of doing this. I would say maybe try like an immersion blender thing. Guys, you have to freeze
it for 24 hours. If you freeze it for like six hours, it's gonna be chalky and it's not gonna
work very well. Then we're gonna do the light ice cream setting first. You're gonna see it's a
little bit powdery, so we're gonna add a tablespoon of water and then mix it on the re-spin. And there
you go, super creamy pint of French vanilla. So delicious and under 200 calories for the entire
thing. You're probably not even gonna finish it because it's literally so much ice cream, but you
might and that's totally fine. So next up we got chocolate. Out of the three like classic flavors,
vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, this one is my favorite. So we're gonna use the same two milks
here. By the way, you could just use like regular milk if you don't have Fairlife skim milk, but
it's a bit higher protein, which I love. PE Science chocolate truffle is my favorite. And then we're
gonna add some cocoa powder, which is essential, and some fat-free chocolate pudding mix. Gotta
add sweetener because the sweetener decreases once you freeze the ice cream. Again, put it in
the freezer for 24 hours. We're gonna do the same things here. So light ice cream setting, add a
touch of water, and then re-spin. And we got this creamy, delicious chocolate ice cream for 160
calories for the entire pint. Tastes just like my childhood. Next up we got strawberry. This has the
perfect amount of meltiness in this video. Oh my god, I wish I had this in front of me. So this
one's like a little more complicated out of the three, but not really. We're adding strawberry
jello mix, as well as some chopped blended strawberries. This gives it that flavor and that
pink perfect color. Matches my nails, which I love. Let me go back to that nail color. Same things
here guys. Freeze for 24 hours, light ice cream setting, tiny bit of water, and then re-spin.
Honestly, simple as that for these three recipes. This looks so good and creamy. Again, 180 calories
for the entire pint. These three recipes are when I actually started perfecting Ninja Creamy. Before
that I was kind of just a fish out of water. So next up we got some mix-ins. We're starting
off cookies and cream. This is a very popular flavor in my childhood. So same milks here guys.
You can also use All Fair Life if you want. Cookies and cream protein from PE Science,
vanilla pudding mix, and that same monk fruit sweetener. Then we're gonna combine it together.
Again, make sure the lid doesn't fall off when you're doing this. Same thing here. Freezing it
for 24 hours. So in case you didn't know guys, if you're adding mix-ins like those Oreos, you don't
add it before you freeze it. We're gonna add it after as you guys can see. So we're gonna do the
light ice cream setting. So this is a little bit different than the first three because we're doing
light ice cream setting. Oh, oh, are we okay here? It's a little bit hard to get on sometimes.
And then after that, we're gonna take the Oreos. I just use like the classic Oreos,
along with a tablespoon of water. Now I would say put the Oreos in the middle. That's usually
what works the best. Like dig a little hole in the middle and then add the mix-ins. So we're
gonna do the mix-in setting instead of the re-spin. That's the difference here. So I decided to crush
a little bit more Oreo on top, you know, just to give it a bit more flavor. And then there you have
it. This looks amazing. Still just over 200 calories, even though we added mix-ins because,
you know, usually mix-ins up the calories by so much, but you can make this macro-friendly.
Still around 200 calories. Perfect for dessert if you're in a cut. What do you guys think of
coffee ice cream? Because that's what we have up next. This one's a little bit different. It's very
unique. So we've got the skim milk, unsweetened almond milk, and then cold brew coffee to give
it that flavor and that color. So maybe don't eat this at night. Caramel macchiato ice cream,
again, you can kind of use whatever, but that's what I had on hand. This time I used brown monk
fruit instead of regular, again, just to give it that like coffee flavor. So I know we normally
eat, well, I guess I normally eat ice cream at night. I don't know about you guys, but
maybe because of the caffeine, don't eat this at night. Does the caffeine still stay in it
even after you like make it ice cream? I honestly don't know guys, but
anyway, we're going to prepare it on the light ice cream setting here. You can get the lid off.
By the way, be super gentle with like the lids and the parts and stuff because I bent the plastic
of one of my lids and now it doesn't fit in, doesn't work. And when I say one of my lids,
I mean I did that like probably three times. And we're going to add a bit of dark chocolate
here because I wanted to give it kind of like a mocha kind of spin, but this is pretty optional.
Again, I put the dark chocolate in the middle there so it mixes in better. We're going to do
the mix in setting and then yeah, it's going to give it that like Starbucks java chip kind of
esque thing there. So creamy and delicious. You know, I'm a Canadian creator because we got some
ice cream here, but I didn't actually use like real maple syrup. I used ED Smith to make it
lower in calories, but that's still fine. We got the two milks here. Then I use snickerdoodle
protein powder because it made the most sense to me as well as some cinnamon because again,
we're going to give it that like cinnamon maple-esque kind of like comfort vibe.
It's going to mix that all together. By the way, guys, I don't know if I'm the only one that
notices this. I'm sure other people notice. Whenever I post Ninja Creamy videos, I get so
many views. And then when I post videos with other recipes on them, I get significantly less view. So
I love making Ninja Creamy videos. I really do. But if you guys can show some love to my other
recipes, that would be great. Oh, this literally reminds me of like a Wendy's Frosty texture.
And a little bit of more maple syrup on top. This is so good. Under 200 calories for the
whole thing. Channel your inner Canadian by making this recipe. So now we're coming into
the Ben and Jerry's coffee cats. So this one is the half-baked coffee cat. I love half-baked from
Ben and Jerry's, but obviously their pints are so, so high in calories. So we're going to make
them at home. We got Ben and Jerry's at home. So what I decided to use for the mix-ins are
Pillsbury edible cookie dough. They have a version that's edible. So we don't want salmonella over
here. And then I use a little bit of a crushed up alpha prime brownie. So these are protein
brownies. They're so good. My discount code 515 gets you money off and they're great to add into
these recipes. So they add a little bit of extra protein. You'll see here that I'm scraping around
the edges. This is optional. It's just to like, make it less icy and make it more blended. So if
you remember to do that, great. So we added the cookie dough in the middle, sprinkled the alpha
prime brownie on top, and then optional, you can add a little bit more cookie dough on top if
you're feeling, feeling fancy. Obviously, this one's a little bit higher in calories, closer to
300. But again, with those mix-ins, that's pretty tough to beat. So, so good. So we got Cherry
Garcia. This is still a popular Ben and Jerry's one, maybe less popular than Half Bake, but you
guys tell me. So we've got the same base here, unsweetened almond milk and fair life skim milk.
Again, if you want to use regular milk, that's totally fine. By the way, guys, if you're a new
viewer, you might not know this, but if you watch all my videos, you know that I work with PE Science.
I absolutely love their whey casein blend protein. Use it in all my recipes. So in this recipe, we
use vanilla. If you do want to purchase from PE Science, please use my discount code 515 or the
link in the description. But otherwise, any other protein powder works fine. So same thing here,
we're going to use the light ice cream setting after freezing it for 24 hours. I scraped the
edges a bit and added a little bit of almond milk. Again, you can add almond milk or water,
but make sure to do that before you do the re-spin or the mix-in. We're adding some
maraschino cherries here. I absolutely love maraschino cherries. I could probably like eat
them by the handful, which would be kind of weird. They're so full of sugar, but it doesn't really
matter, does it? So again, going with the Cherry Garcia theme, we got those cherries and we got
chocolate chunks, and then we're going to do the mix-in setting. Make sure they're all blended in
there, and then there you go. It actually blended super well, and I didn't even bother to add more
on top because we just got so many mix-ins chock-full in there. Guys, this next one, one of
my favorites, peanut butter cup. Just look how chock-full peanut butter cups it is in that peanut
butter color. So same here, we've got the protein milk and unsweetened almond milk, peanut butter
protein, or you can use vanilla if you don't have it. And then secret ingredient, well not so secret,
is the powdered peanut butter. That's really going to give it that peanut butter flavor. You'll see
that I'm adding xanthan gum. So this particular hack, if you will, I kind of found out later in
the game. Guys, I would highly recommend adding one gram of xanthan gum to all of these recipes.
It just makes the ice cream less icy, more blended, and just like more consistent throughout. So I
would highly recommend adding one gram of that. Honestly, just one gram, no more than that. Or a
little bit of trouble opening the lid this time, but that's fine. So we're going to do light ice
cream setting. So after the splash of almond milk, we're adding one Reese's peanut butter
cup in there. And then we're going to use the mix-in setting. Super simple. This one turned
out so well. I crumbled a bit more peanut butter cup on top. And guys, this is actually one of my
favorite recipes out of the 10. I would highly recommend you try this. By the way, comment down
below and let me know which other recipes you want to see. Happy to try other flavors. I've
been seeing people comment pistachio, but guys, I hate pistachio and I'm not going to try that one.
So comment anything else besides that. So lastly, we got chocolate brownie. This one's delicious.
We're using an alpha prime brownie again. This is another Ben & Jerry's remake. We got protein
milk and unsweetened almond milk to start as per usual. Then we're going to add some chocolate
protein. Again, this is one of my favorites from PE Science. Some unsweetened cocoa powder,
fat-free pudding mix. I meant to use chocolate, but I guess I ran out, so we use vanilla.
Dampen gum and sweetener. And again, make sure to not have the lid fall off when you're shaking it
and store it for 24 hours. If you really don't have 24 hours, I would say the minimum to store
it in would be like 20 hours in order to yield the best result. So we're going to do light ice
cream setting again and we're going to add the mix in. So we're going to take that almond milk
and then add half of an alpha prime brownie. I would highly recommend you buy these guys. They
are so moist and delicious. They taste like regular brownies. Use the mix in setting.
Then we're going to sprinkle a little bit more on top because why the heck not?
And there you have it. We're all done. I absolutely love this flavor. Give me a comment
down below and let me know which flavor you're most excited to try out of these 10. If you
enjoyed this video, then I'm sure you're looking for more ninja creamy recipes, obviously. So I'm
going to link a couple other videos here that you should watch after this. And please give this
video a like, subscribe, and share with your friends as it really helps the channel and I
post new videos every week. And with that, I will see you guys next time. Bye!
