Property Tax NIGHTMARE: From $15K to $91K Overnight

Financial Freedom
10 followers
#finance
#financement
0:00 Major property tax spike
3:32 View of the bay
3:43 Why is this happening?
7:14 Regrets moving to Florida
9:26 I get interviewed by a fan!
19:19 Unsustainable HOA increases
20:31 Ohio getting rid of property taxes
People are on the verge of losing their homes over the egregious property tax increases that many are facing across the United States. In this extreme example in Pompano Beach, Florida, one couple saw their property tax bill go from $15,000 a year to $91,000 a year due to renovations and their property being reassessed. Here's how you can avoid having this happen to you.
What would you do if your property tax bill went from $15,000 a year to $91,000 per year?
Yeah, that's not a typo. You heard that correctly. $91,000 a year. $15,000 is already a lot,
far more than most people pay, but if your bill went up like that, I'm sure most people would
completely just fall over and die. I mean, I've never even heard of such an extreme example like
this, but once I read this story, the reason of why this happened is even more sinister because
as homeowners, we are incentivized to maintain our homes, right? Especially if you have the money,
you want to keep your house in nice livable condition and keep up on the maintenance of
your house. Well, that's exactly what happened to this couple from Pompano Beach, Florida.
They bought this house back in 2002 and fast forward to 2021, the house needed renovations,
big-time renovations, because turns out they had a big termite infestation, the roof was starting
to fail, they needed to get a new roof, and they figured since they're going to be tearing the
whole house apart to do these renovations, let's add a second story onto the home as well. And they
would rather fix up this house and buy a new one because this house had sentimental value for them.
Now, the wife is actually a real estate attorney, and she anticipated that the property taxes would
increase, but I'm sure nobody ever thought it was going to be by this much. So they started the
renovations in 2021, and after construction was complete in 2023, their taxes went from $15,000
a year to $91,000 per year. The reason behind this? The remodeling of the house triggered a
full reassessment of the property's value, and because other homes in the neighborhood have been
selling for very high prices, this increased the value of the home, especially in the eyes of the
county, exponentially. Originally, they bought this house back in 2002 for $650,000, and today
the house is assessed at over $4.4 million. And that, my friends, is how you go from having a
$15,000 a year property tax bill to $91,000. So essentially, these people are being punished
by the county to renovate their house, and to maintain it, and be a good homeowner,
and keep property values in the neighborhood up. They're being punished for that, versus if they
just let the house rot, leave the termite infestation going, let the roof leak, and let
the place decay, then they would actually be rewarded with that lower property tax bill that
they traditionally had. Now, before even completing these renovations, they checked with the Broward
County Tax Collector's Office to confirm that they would be able to keep their homestead exemption on
the property, because they would have to relocate temporarily while renovations were being done.
And they did confirm that that would be the case, and it would be fine. And their hope was,
when they moved back into the home, that only the value of the new addition that they added
to the home would be reassessed at the current market value, not the property as a whole.
And apparently, under Florida law, once a property is deemed substantially improved,
it can be treated as new construction, removing the protections that had capped the home's assessed
value for years. Doesn't sound too good. So even though they own the house since 2002,
this house was treated as a brand new house. And they actually tried to fight this reassessment
using their contractor invoices, appraisal documentation, historical records of improvements.
None of that mattered. The final assessed value remained at the $4.4 million. So if you're going
to make substantial improvements to your property, like adding an addition, or adding an extra floor
like they did, or major structural changes, that's enough to have the entire property reassessed. So
whatever you're paying right now in taxes isn't even going to be close to a real reflection of
what you're going to be paying in the future. And obviously, the comps in the neighborhood
really didn't help them in their favor, because one of the houses recently had just sold for $4.9
million right before they completed their renovation. So the comparable values surrounding
them were sky high and supported that reassessment. And you know, this is the funny part about
homeownership, right? Everybody wants to see the value of their property go up, and boy did these
people see the value of their property go up. Buying it for $650,000, and now it's worth $4.4
million. But what is the cost to that? What is the cost to maintain that house over the years?
It doesn't even say how much money they spent on renovations. It had to have been at least a
couple hundred thousand dollars putting on an addition, plus termite damage, all of the kinds
of things that they did, and now get hitting with an almost six-figure per year property tax bill
by just trying to maintain your house? And you know, the worst part is that most of that increase
that they had to pay is due to inflation, right? If we didn't see this huge uptick in inflation
during the pandemic, there's no way that their reassessed value of that home would have came in
at over $4 million. If things would have remained steady and the way they were before the pandemic,
maybe, maybe these houses would have been assessed for $2 million. You know, I'm sure
it's probably double because of inflation. So yeah, they still would have been hit with an
increase, but nothing like this. And this shows you that there are real world consequences to
this inflation. All this government printed money and all these bad stimulus programs we
had during the pandemic, people are still paying for them today in various different ways that you
might not have thought of. Nobody should be put in this situation where they have to give up their
home because they can no longer afford the property taxes. That's why I'm glad they're
looking at a lot of different things here in Florida now to potentially knock out property
taxes significantly, or maybe even eliminate them altogether eventually. And essentially,
this couple is now hoping and praying that there is going to be significant property tax reform
here in Florida to help lower that bill because they did all these renovations on the house.
Number one, because the house has sentimental value, but also their plan was to retire in this
house. So you're keeping it and you want to stay in this house long term. So of course, you want
to make it as nice as possible and have it as comfortable as possible to fit your retirement
needs. And then now this now you might end up having to move out because it's too expensive
to keep. I mean, that's egregious, guys. Even if the property tax bill doubled to 30 grand,
that would already be outrageous. But obviously, this is just so far above and beyond what it
should be. It's just kind of unfathomable. And so, you know, a lot of people moved here to Florida
over the past five years thinking this was going to be the retirement destination. This is going
to be the place to be because of how cheap it is compared to where I'm coming from.
Also, I don't like the lockdowns. I don't like being forced to stay at home and wear a mask and
all this other crap like these other states were doing. So Florida is the perfect place to be.
And it was for a while until now. Wow, guys, I am walking past the beach here and all over.
Just look how clear the water is today. It makes me just want to go out there and get in.
That is beautiful. That's one thing you don't see when you go to California.
And you even had a lot of wealthy people relocate here to Florida in hopes of dodging taxes from
their home state because after all, we have no state income tax here in Florida, nor do we have
a state tax. And that can really save you millions of dollars in your lifetime if you are wealthy
enough. Even if it only saves you a few hundred thousand dollars, if you're on the lower end of
things, that's a lot of money, guys. But, you know, the thing that has happened here is that
the cost of living has exploded, most notably with property taxes and homeowners insurance.
In fact, in Florida, between 2019 and 2024, property taxes rose about 47.5 percent. And
that's just like the average. Some people have seen much greater increases, as you can see.
Nationwide, for a $300,000 house right now, people are paying about $2,300 per year for homeowners
insurance. But in Florida, you're paying $5,400 a year for that same $300,000 residence.
And it's to the point now where a lot of Florida homeowners are paying more for their property
taxes and insurance than they are for their mortgage payments. Even as a real estate agent,
I never thought I would see the day when HOA fees, property taxes, and insurance
would actually outnumber the amount of money you have to pay for your principal and interest
payments. On top of that, it's been harder and harder to find insurance policies that
are affordable here in Florida. So that's what makes so many people here go without it now.
Yeah. You do?
Utah? Nice to meet you.
Yeah. What are you doing out here on vacation?
Awesome. Where's the next stop?
Sweet. Do you have a timeline? You're just going as long as it takes, huh?
That's awesome, man.
You got me.
Well, tell everybody what you like about my channel. I'm curious to know.
And it's useful for me looking into real estate and stuff like that. I can kind of
feel what's going on here. Okay.
Cool. I appreciate that.
Here in Florida or in general?
Here in Florida. Let me just get us both in here.
Here in Florida, prices are dropping pretty much everywhere in Florida. Here in Miami,
they have kind of remained stable, but I'm seeing a lot of houses here with big price cuts. Like
I see a house for sale, it's not uncommon to see a $200,000, $300,000 price cut. But of course,
they're asking too much to begin with. But if you go to the West Coast of Florida, where you've
already been, a lot of houses there have already dropped in value like 10%. So it's actually,
it's getting to be a better time to buy. Is it where it was in 2019? Of course not.
But it's getting there. And I think if the situation just continues like it is now,
we're going to get there eventually. Our price is going to go back to where they were nominally in
2019? Maybe not. But adjusted for inflation, I think it's very reasonable to think that.
Because you have all these houses piling up on the market, no one's buying them. And a lot of
them are damaged from the hurricane, especially over there on the West Coast. So people don't
want that. It's like, what's the odds that it's going to get hit again? And there's no protections
that have been made. These houses are still on ground level. You're just sitting there asking for
the next storm. Yeah. We drove through Pine Island and a lot of the homes there, I would say probably
like 30% of the homes there were in shambles. Yeah. And what happens is a lot of flippers,
they'll come in and just make it look good and erase some of that flood damage and everything.
And people who are unsuspecting come down to Florida like, oh, look at this house. It sold
a couple of years ago for $500. Now I can buy it for $400. But you don't know what happened.
You don't really know the history. Yeah. Yeah. That sounds pretty accurate. There was, I would
say, 50% of the properties along the coast right there on the island we have for sale signs. Oh,
yeah. Absolutely. Over there is ground zero right now for the housing crash, so to speak.
Absolutely. In Miami, I think we're going to get hit. Maybe not quite as hard, but it's hard to
say. We did last time around back in 2008. And now you're seeing a lot of these condos sitting
on the market for a very long time. People can't afford these HOA fees. Nobody wants to pay the
special assessments that are coming. And it's like, what's going to happen? These properties
are sitting on the market. If you want to sell it, eventually what has to happen? Yeah. Well,
I'm hoping. Well, I feel bad if it were to happen, but I'd love for that to happen and I can get in.
Yeah. I think it's going to be a great opportunity for people within the next three or four or five
years, you know, to come back to Florida and buy again. I think it's going to be good. But right
now you're kind of picking up a falling knife. Yeah. So that's good information. Thank you.
Yeah. You'll make it into the video, man. There's so many things I want to pick your brain about
too. Just from watching your videos and kind of like, you know, you don't get like a long-term
update on situations and things like that. So it's like, I have so many questions all the time
for you, but I never comment on them. Well, feel free to write me an email if you need to. Yeah.
Do you mind if I take up some more of your time? Sure. If you've got another question, let me
switch sides here. Go ahead. Yeah. What's going on with the whole insurance? I was just talking
about that. Yeah. So right now in Florida, you know, people are paying like $5,400 a year on
average for a $300,000 home across the country. That's $2,300 people are paying. Yeah. So it's
more than double what the average homeowner pays nationwide. So it's expensive, you know,
and I was just covering a story right now before I ran into you about people that saw their property
tax bill go from $15,000 per year to $91,000 per year. And it's all because of just doing
renovations on the house. The house was old. It needed work. It had termite damage and they're
being punished. You know, they had, they didn't addition as well, but still there was enough
changes to the house that the County said, well, we're going to reassess this house for the full
value based on the new comps and they're getting hit with that. So it's crazy, man. Yeah. That would
put a lot of people in a tough situation. Exactly. Even, even if it were to just double that would
already be bad, you know, from 15 to 30, but 15 to 90. I mean, that's, I've never heard of a thing
like that until now, actually. So the fact that these things are happening here, I mean, you have
a lot of people leaving because they just can't afford it and I don't blame them, you know? So
insurance is still a huge issue. A lot of people in Florida are deciding to go without insurance.
If you have no mortgage. One of my insurance buddies told me that if you don't have a mortgage,
he still recommends you have insurance, but you can go without the wind insurance and just have
flood insurance and regular homeowner's insurance. And that will save you a ton of money. So that's
a good way to do it. If you can afford to pay cash for a house because the deductibles are so high
on wind anyways. And most of the damage that comes from say a hurricane is all usually flood damage.
It's usually not the wind that causes the most damage. Yeah. That's kind of like how in California
are they charged for a quick insurance, but the deductible is like a hundred, 150,000. Right.
Right. Exactly. And the same thing's happening over there with the fire insurance. People don't
want to, you know, they don't want to cover people that have, you know, risk for that. And that's the
biggest risk, you know, the most likely thing to happen. Insurance industries are cutting it down,
you know? Yeah. So are there multiple insurance companies that are writing policies here now?
Yes. I know the last time I was watching your video, you could only get like one provider.
Yeah. Me, I can only get one. I'm only eligible for citizens as of January,
February. I think I had to renew my insurance this year and I still only can qualify for citizens,
but there are a lot of new providers coming into the state that are starting to write policies,
but that's kind of a double-edged sword too. Cause like, yeah, they're coming back and there
are new companies coming in, but they have a term for those companies. And I can't remember
it off the top of my head. It was called something like a non-qualified or something like that.
There's a term for this type of insurance company where essentially they don't actually have enough
money to pay out all of the claims that they may receive, you know, but they're able to operate
anyways. So it's also... Cross your fingers when you have to make a claim.
Yeah. I feel like when you have insurance these days, even if you don't live in Florida,
don't really have insurance because the deductibles are so high that first of all,
most of it's going to come out of your pocket anyways. And then if you make a claim, you're
looking at increased rates or maybe even getting dropped. So having insurance is almost just like
a formality at this point. You know, I was in a similar situation with our apartment in Anaheim.
Somebody had ran into the garage and I wanted to make a claim, but the deductible is so high. And
not only that, I was scared my premium would go up and, or I'd be dropped. So I ended up just
paying out of my pocket. Yeah. So I felt like, why am I even paying insurance? It's the weirdest
feeling. It's like a punishment. It's like a necessary thing you have to have. And even if
you don't, you know, have a mortgage, you're worried about being sued or whatever. So people
still hang on to it and worry of the worst case scenario, but it's, it's becoming a racket, man.
Okay. Well, thanks for your time. I appreciate you giving me some intel.
Absolutely. This was fun to do like a little impromptu thing here. I'm glad you reached out
to me and said hello. Yeah. Well, it's nice to meet you too, Victor. All right, man. Take care.
Shout out to Victor. So like, I was just talking to Victor about all these increases. He was just
asking all the same things that I was basically talking about before I ran into him. And obviously
the HOA fees here with condos and even homeowners associations with houses are getting out of
control as well. And this is something that just people that moved here never anticipated, even me
guys, like I've been here for a long time now. I've been a Florida resident for 17 years, I think
now. Yeah. I moved here in 2008 and I never thought it would be this expensive to live here
because when I moved to Miami, even being in Miami beach with an ocean view apartment was actually
pretty affordable paying $900 a month in rent. You know, like, yeah, that's more than some
people's mortgages, but being on the beach, I mean, you can't beat that. And finding something
like that today is actually impossible. Back in August of 2024, Redfin came out with a report
saying that the monthly HOA fees, the median price increased 17.2% in Tampa, Florida, compared to
just 5.7% on a national level. Miami actually has the highest median monthly HOA fees of any of the
43 metros that Redfin analyzed. So this is just a huge problem for people that live here in Florida,
but even more so if you're here in Miami. And that's why we are just running into this glut of
unsold inventory here in Florida. When it comes to South Florida, we have all these condos going
unsold due to the high assessments and high HOA fees. You got other parts of Florida, like I was
talking to with Victor, that you have all these homes that were damaged by storms that people
don't want, and they're still trying to charge top dollar for these houses. Like, in reality,
those houses are a teardown in my opinion, because if you were to buy one of those houses,
you're just sitting there hoping and praying that it's not going to go underwater again
with no actual real protection. You know, those houses need to be rebuilt higher above sea level
on stilts, something in order to prevent the next flood, because it's inevitable. Whenever that
hurricane comes, it's going to happen again. And a few weeks ago, I made a video talking about how a
lot of people are starting to revolt against property taxes in different states all across
the country. So far, Florida is kind of like the leader on this with all of the proposals that are
moving forward, or they're looking at doing. But Ohio is the next state that is looking at
eliminating property taxes. In fact, the Ohio ballot board voted on May 14th to certify a
constitutional amendment to ban property taxes in Ohio. So the advocates for this must collect 413,487
voter signatures in order to get their amendment on the ballot. And they hope to make it onto the
November ballot of this year. They have a deadline in July for signatures, though, so it might not happen
in 2025. But if it does, they'll beat Florida to the race. And maybe Ohio could end up being
the first state to actually eliminate property taxes if they can gather enough steam behind
this movement. I hope they do, guys, because this whole thing is getting out of hand. I mean, this
whole story is wrapped around how egregious the property tax increases have been. They're facing
a similar set of issues like we have here in Florida. Property values have skyrocketed, so have
the assessed values. And now people are paying way more for the same property and not really getting
anything extra in return from the local governments in terms of service, maintenance, or amenities.
And of course, this plan is not popular at all with the local school districts. We can't do that.
We can't eliminate property taxes. Who's going to pay for the schools? Well, I got an idea. How about
everybody who has kids? How about they pay for it? You got to pay for everything else for your kids,
so why does the community at large have to subsidize your kid going to school? If you're
going to have children, you should be financially fit and responsible enough to pay for the expenses
that go along with it. I think that's pretty fair. It's not unreasonable to ask you to pay for
everything that your kid needs, guys. And also, let's face it, there are a lot of wealthy people
out there that have children. Maybe they can step up to the plate and pay a little extra for
everybody else's kid. If they believe so heavily in having kids and they want their kids to have
the best education possible, step up to the plate. Donate some of your millions. Why does the average
Joe have to subsidize it? Why do grandparents, childless people, people who can't have kids,
why does everybody have to pitch into the pot? Even here in Florida, one of the reforms that's
on the table is giving people a $500,000 homestead exemption, which would eliminate
all local property taxes for a lot of Florida homeowners with an exemption that high.
But school taxes are exempt from that exemption, so you would still have to pay the school taxes.
That's how closely guarded this whole situation is with the school taxes. And listen, I'm not saying
here that I have the perfect solution to this, and that should be the exact answer, right?
But I'm just saying people need to start thinking outside the box. How were schools paid for before
there was a property tax? Let's go back and look at that. Let's get creative and start looking at
some ideas that could work instead of just saying, oh no, we can't lower property taxes because of
the school. Well, we can do anything we want. This is the United States of America. Why don't we just
think a little bit harder and use our heads and come up with an amicable solution? That's what I
think we should do. Now, obviously, property taxes cover more than just the schools. They also pay for
libraries and local infrastructure projects. But even that is questionable, because if you live
in an area where the roads are crumbling and your property taxes are high, you really have to wonder
where is this money really going? But these local governments are freaking out and wondering how
they're going to pay for all these services, and the schools are freaking out as well. And I think
people should start already looking at different ways to fund these things right now, because with
the momentum that this no property tax movement has right now, I think it's just a matter of time
before a state passes a no property tax movement or at least a giant reduction in property taxes
like we're looking at here in Florida. And they're going to be forced to find alternative sources of
revenue sooner or later. Anyways, it was really cool to run into Victor out here. I wish him a safe
road trip back to Utah. Sounds super fun. And if you ever see me out in the wild like that, guys,
don't be afraid to stop and chat with me, but I am going to put you in the video. Like some people
want to stop and talk to me, but then they don't want to be in the video. So if you see me shooting
the video, you're going to be in the video. So I think the moral of the story here is today, if
you're planning on doing any major renovations on a property, get ready for that tax bill to go up.
I don't know what the laws are in other states, but at least here in Florida, we have seen now
that there can be a substantial increase in your property taxes if you're to renovate a house that
you've owned for a long time and have a much lower cost basis for. So be careful with this stuff.
Think twice before moving down here and look into all the expenses before you really do it,
because Florida is not the cheap retirement haven that it used to be. So if you enjoyed this video,
make sure you subscribe to the channel. And if you don't want to wait for my next video to come out,
check out this one on the screen right over here, and I'll see you in the next one.
