Astrology in the old and present civilization #ladaduncheva#ladadunchevavideos#ladadunchevay In this educational video, Dr. David Miano explores the origins and historical development of the zodiac system. He delves into ancient civilizations' contributions to astrology, examining archaeological and textual evidence to trace the zodiac's evolution over time. Babylonian Origins: The zodiac system began with the Babylonians, who divided the sky into twelve equal parts, each associated with specific constellations.
Greek Influence: The Greeks adopted and modified the Babylonian system, introducing the concept of the "zodiakos kyklos" or "circle of animals," which forms the basis of the modern zodiac.
Astronomical Observations: Dr. Miano discusses how ancient astronomers used the zodiac for calendrical and navigational purposes, aligning celestial events with terrestrial activities.
Cultural Significance: The video highlights the zodiac's role in various cultures, including its integration into religious and mythological frameworks.
Evolution Over Time: The presentation covers how the zodiac has changed due to astronomical phenomena like the precession of the equinoxes, affecting the alignment of zodiac signs with their corresponding constellations.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations,
please subscribe. If you would like to support the channel and become part of our Ancient History
fan community, visit patreon.com slash world of antiquity. We're going to talk about the stars
today. Specifically, I want to see if we can ascertain the age of the zodiac. How far back
does it go? We'll walk through the evidence and then look at some claims made about it
that challenge the views of mainstream scholarship, including in an episode of Ancient Aliens.
There are bound to be some things here you didn't know, so stick around.
Myths of Ancient History is aimed at dispelling common misconceptions about the past.
If you're interested in ancient history, lost civilizations, and secrets from antiquity,
I encourage you to subscribe to this channel, because you will get plenty of that kind of
material. And if you find this particular video valuable, please hit the like button
and comment below with your favorite takeaway. And feel free to ask any clarification questions
that you may have. If we're going to be technical about it, I'm really going to
be talking about the origins of the constellations that make up the zodiac, rather than just the
zodiac itself. That's because the constellations came first, and the zodiac came second.
So, where do we begin? The 12 constellations of the zodiac are among a larger group of 48
constellations that we inherited from the ancient Romans. You might say, wait a minute,
the constellations have been around since before humans even existed. Don't you mean we just
inherited the names of the constellations from the Romans? Well, yeah, but the forms of the
constellations too, and the images that went with them. Yes, they are natural phenomena,
but a constellation, being a group of stars that remind us of something we're familiar with,
is a subjective construct. Who says which stars are supposed to be viewed together?
Humans do. Now, yes, some groupings of stars, because they are in close proximity and might
create a shape that piques our interest, are more likely to get called a constellation. But exactly
how many stars make up a constellation, and what someone decides that constellation looks like,
whether an animal or a person or whatever, is all in their own minds. It's like people looking at
clouds and seeing different objects. The Chinese, for example, looking at pretty much the same sky,
came up with a different set of constellations and identified them as different entities.
The Maya probably had their own set of constellations as well, although at this point
we still don't know exactly what they were. Granted, because certain groups of stars attract
attention, there's bound to be some similarity among various cultures as to what they see as
a constellation. And it's entirely possible for two people in different parts of the world
to look up at the same constellation and think of the same animal, if they both know of the animal,
even though they never had any contact whatsoever. So tracing origins can be tricky. When we try to
ascertain continuity and influence, we have to look for specific and unique characteristics
in sufficient quantity. Now, as for the 48 constellations we got from the Romans,
the Romans in turn got them from the Greeks. Ptolemy of Alexandria in the 2nd century CE
wrote the influential star catalog Mathematicae Syntachis, also known as the Almagest, which
presented the 48 constellations in their final form. There were other catalogs that preceded his,
though. Hipparchus, perhaps the greatest Greek astronomer of them all, since he's the one who
discovered precession, I'll get to that later, who lived in the 2nd century BCE, and before him,
Eratos of Ptolemy and Eudoxus of Cnidus were sources for Ptolemy. But the Greek map of the sky
wasn't original. It probably was based on two different earlier systems. One came from Babylon,
we know this, and the other came most likely from Mediterranean sailors who used it for navigation.
The Minoans of Crete are a likely candidate for the source of that system. Now, for our purposes,
since we're discussing the constellations of the Zodiac, we're going to look at the Babylonian
system because Babylon is where the Greeks got it from. When Alexander the Great conquered Babylon
in the 4th century BCE, the Greeks began to familiarize themselves with Babylonian astronomy
and astrology. One type of text that the Greeks found in Babylon were astrometric diaries,
which are books of precise measurement of planetary positions. The positions of the
planets were recorded in degrees, minutes, and seconds of arc relative to the position
of the 12 signs of the Zodiac and some other related stars. Alexander's successors,
who were very interested in astrology, incorporated the Zodiac into their own system,
and that is how it entered the Greek world. Although the Zodiac itself is Babylonian,
the word Zodiac is Greek. It means a circle of animals. Eudoxus, in his book,
wrote about how the Babylonians used the Zodiac for horoscopes. His book no longer exists,
but we have ancient writers tell us what was in it. Many of the Babylonian astrometric diaries,
which Eudoxus consulted, do still exist, you may be happy to know, dating between 650 and 60 BCE,
but the Zodiac didn't become part of them until around 420 BCE. Scholars believe that's because
the Zodiac wasn't invented until just before that time. I don't mean the constellations that
happened to make up the Zodiac. They had a much longer history. I mean the organization of the
system of the Zodiac into 12 equal signs used for astrological purposes. You see, because the
Babylonians were doing astronomy for centuries by then, and the Zodiac is never mentioned in any of
their prior documents, even though the individual constellations are, it's reasonable to assume
that the Zodiac was a later invention. So, around 500 BCE, the Babylonians invented 12 signs to
correspond to 12 known constellations that the sun passes through in each of the 12 months of the
year. Let's go back further in time. An important surviving document from Babylon is the Mülapin,
an astronomical compendium, of which many copies were made, and we have pieces of a bunch of them.
Our oldest copy is from 687 BCE, but the astronomical observations in it appear to
date to around 1000 BCE, and we determined that from the positions of the heavenly bodies in the
descriptions, so much earlier than the astrometric diaries I was just talking about. No Zodiac is in
the Mülapin, but it has a complete catalog of 71 stars, planets, and constellations. The
constellations are numerous, and yes, the ones that would later become part of the Zodiac are
in it, all 12 of them. They're not grouped together, just mixed in with a bunch of others,
but they're there. There are a handful of other non-zodiacal constellations that the Greeks later
picked up in there too. As for the symbols that represent the constellations in the Mülapin,
some of them already have their classical form. Cancer is a crab, Leo is a lion,
Taurus is a bull, Libra is a pair of scales, Scorpius is a scorpion, Gemini is the twins,
in this case Lugalgira and Mesolamtaea, Aquarius is the Mesopotamian god Ea,
who is associated with water, Virgo is the goddess Shala, though not a virgin,
and Sagittarius is a god named Pabilsag, who is sometimes depicted as part man, part horse.
On the other hand, Ares is a shepherd or farmer, not a ram. Capricornus, instead of being a goat,
is a hybrid goat-fish, and Pisces is not a fish, but a swallow. It would seem then that the Greeks
changed Ares into a ram, Capricornus into a goat, and Pisces into a fish. Why did they do that?
Perhaps because of the other non-Babylonian traditions they'd received.
Going further back in time in Babylon, we come to the three stars each lists. These are tablets
that date to around 1100 BCE, and there are a number of them. Only some of the constellations
of the Zodiac appear on these lists, and that's as far back as we can go with Mesopotamian
astronomical texts. But contemporary with these lists, and going back even a little further
to 1350 BCE or so, are the kuduru, or boundary stones, which have curses on them that were
written to protect the land on which they were placed. Although they are not astronomical texts,
they do contain symbols on them which may represent constellations. The symbols they
contain include Taurus, Leo, Scorpius, Sagittarius, Capricornus, Aquarius, and probably Virgo and
Ares. Forerunners to Gemini and Pisces may be on them too, but Libra and Cancer are nowhere to be
found, even though we have more than 100 of these boundary stones. Of the 12 constellations that
later make up the Zodiac, Libra and Cancer are probably late inventions. Cancer's stars are
rather faint, so it doesn't really stand out in the night sky. Libra is described in Babylonian
texts as the Claws of Scorpius, which indicate that originally it was not a separate constellation,
but simply part of Scorpius. Then after it was separated from Scorpius, at some time before the
three stars each lists, it became the Scales. But it took some time for that to catch on,
because it was sometimes called the Claws and sometimes the Scales. It wasn't until the time of
Julius Caesar that the Scales completely superseded the Claws. Nevertheless, many
scholars believe that the symbols on the Quduru simply represent gods and that there's insufficient
justification to assume that they're constellations. Yes, we know gods were often used as symbols of
constellations in the time of the astronomical texts, but we simply don't know whether they did
earlier. These symbols may just simply refer to gods and that's it. Currently, there's no way of
knowing. Moving backwards in time from here, we get to the Sumerian period. In the surviving texts,
no constellations are named, and there in fact is no indication the Sumerians even had
constellations. But as with the Quduru, there is imagery that has been interpreted as such.
Bulls and lions appear often in Sumerian imagery, especially on cylinder seals, where they're often
placed in the sky or with stars. These could be the constellations of Taurus and Leo. Less
frequently but still there is the sign of the scorpion, probably Scorpius. It just so happens
that in the Sumerian period, these three constellations plus Aquarius marked the four
cardinal points of the ecliptic. The ecliptic, in case you don't know, is the circular path that
the sun makes in a year, and the four cardinal points are set 90 degrees apart on it. The fact
that these four constellations were major ones and never varied in their symbology throughout
Mesopotamian history, and were important in their positions in the Sumerian period, suggests that
they could be the oldest of the constellations that would later comprise the zodiac, and were
created around 3200 BCE, give or take. We're already treading on unstable ground, but there
are researchers who have suggested that some of the constellations have their origins even
further back in history. What is the basis for these claims? We'll look at these claims momentarily,
but first, a necessary evil. This is a community-supported channel. If you're enjoying the
information I've been presenting in this video, and in others like it, there are a few ways you
can support the channel to help keep it alive and keep the videos coming. The very best way
is by becoming a patron over on Patreon, for just two dollars per month. You can find that at
patreon.com slash world of antiquity. If you want to help the channel out without directly donating
money, you can do it indirectly, simply by watching every video all the way through, without skipping
the ads. That way, instead of you having to send me money, the advertisers do. Either way, I very much
appreciate your support. Now, as for the claims that the constellations of the zodiac might be
even older, what do we have? Well, one piece of evidence is art found on the walls of Paleolithic
caves in Europe, long, long before the Sumerians. These have been studied, and have indicated to
some researchers that certain images are of constellations. Julian de Huy, for example, has used
phylogenetics to support the idea that the myth of the cosmic hunt associated with the Big Dipper
goes back that far. In his book, Before Orion, Bernie Taylor examines El Castillo cave in Spain,
and makes a case that several of the constellations that would later become part of the Greek catalog
appear there on the walls. But most of these are non-zodiacal constellations.
Now, I must say that because the images on the walls here are not entirely clear, and depend
somewhat on the imagination of the viewer, I don't know if we can objectively demonstrate what is
being depicted. But if we could, I wouldn't rule out the possibility that some of the constellations
represented at El Castillo made their way through the generations to the Mediterranean, and then into
Minoan culture, and from there into Greek culture. That's feasible, I would say. But are there any
links to the star maps of Babylon? This is Taylor's outline of the constellations in the Gallery of
Discs in the El Castillo cave. There are a few that match, or sort of match, what we see in Babylon.
And remember, the image, or symbol, has to match in order for us to posit a link. Because these
constellations can be seen in many places, and if they're called something different, and associated
with a different symbol, then it's likely that we're looking at an independent tradition.
Now, from the zodiac, Leo the lion is a match. You might be able to make the case that Pisces is a
match. A dolphin or a whale here matches the fish. But since the original image for Pisces in Babylon
appears to have been a swallow, and only a fish later on, there's reason to doubt a direct link.
As I mentioned before, Leo is among the zodiacal constellations that probably have the earliest
origins. Even though it was most likely during the Sumerian period that it, along with Aquarius,
Taurus, and Scorpius, marked the four cardinal points of the ecliptic, and were thus associated,
that doesn't mean all four of those constellation symbols were invented then. Is it possible that
tradition of calling the Leo constellation a lion goes back to Paleolithic times? I think it's
possible. But how did it get to Mesopotamia? That I couldn't tell you. Now, there have been some
other, less convincing claims about the age of the zodiac. You can hear about some fairly
outlandish theories in an episode of Ancient Aliens called The Constellation Code. Let's
take a look at them, and I'll tell you why I don't think they hold up.
She noticed what appeared to be a landscape lion. It just sort of reared up at her, quite literally.
And she examined this and wondered whether this was the Leo figure of the zodiac.
Then she saw next to it this large, giant figure, which she felt was part of some kind of
collective of landscape effigies that had been laid down by ancient hands.
And one by one, she found that they actually represented the 12 signs of the zodiac.
Glastonbury zodiac is so large that you can only really see it from the sky.
These zodiac signs are marked by rivers, streams, roads, field boundaries.
Pisces is actually two fishes, and one of the fishes is Wirial Hill.
The other side of the road we have Aries. They were actually creating
certain parts of the zodiac as earthworks, as shapes, deliberately.
The shapes look so much like man-made features that Maltwood published a book about them
and called it The Temple of the Stars.
So here we have some ideas that go back to the 1930s, but certainly not in scientific
or archaeological circles. Catherine Maltwood's ideas about the Glastonbury zodiac, which she
believed was created by the Sumerians, yeah apparently the Sumerians were in Glastonbury,
and which she connected to the Holy Grail in Arthurian legend and her astrological beliefs,
didn't actually achieve much of any attention until 1969, when an article by Mary Kane in
magazine Gandalf's Garden popularized it. Mary Kane made alterations to Maltwood's scheme,
changing the outlines of Capricorn, Libra, and Leo, turning Scorpius upside down,
and adding the image of a monk to Gemini. Then from there it made its way into ancient
astronaut suppositions, which rejected Maltwood's Sumerian dating and pushed the Glastonbury zodiac
back into the early stone age. There are three main weaknesses in the Glastonbury
zodiac hypothesis. The first is one that you may be thinking of already, and which I mentioned at
the beginning of the video. Just as anyone can look up into the sky at a group of stars and
note how they resemble a shape meaningful to the onlooker, so the same can be done with lines and
dots seen in an aerial view of a landscape. Anyone can see patterns in random objects,
in fact it's a human propensity. And the shapes that are seen depend on the cultural expectations
of the viewer. Hey look at that! It's Spongebob! And here's Patrick! And Mr. Krabs! I'm sure you
see my point. It's a Rorschach test. Images extracted in this way do not exist objectively,
but merely in the minds of those who see them. Second, the shapes do not in fact match all that
well with the signs of the zodiac. In the zodiac, Cancer is not a ship, Libra is not a dove,
and Aquarius is not a phoenix. The third weakness in the hypothesis is fatal. Catherine Maltwood
used modern features in the landscape to establish the details of her images, including roads,
drainage ditches, and paths that can be demonstrated not to have existed before early
modern times. She even used signs of agricultural activity in her own time, including a haystack,
which she saw as the eye of Capricornus. Paths dating back to Neolithic times do exist here,
but none of them were used in Maltwood's outlines of the constellations.
While it was received with much skepticism, proponents say there is ample evidence around
the region to suggest these formations have been created by artificial means,
and that almost every field and hill in the area has been modified in some way.
One of the most important ones is called Ponter's Ball. Now this is a large, mile-long,
pointed earthwork which is exactly where the Capricorn effigy's horn is in the zodiac.
Ponter's Ball is a linear earthwork about 15 feet high that was built either as a territorial
boundary or as a dike when this was swampland. Some archaeologists have dated it to the 3rd
century BCE. Others have proposed a medieval date in the 12th century. I've seen no evidence
presented to suggest it comes from the Stone Age. What we have here is an attempt to date
the entire zodiac by appealing to the presumed antiquity of a tiny portion of the whole.
Since it's already been established that Maltwood's zodiac effigies incorporate elements
from many different time periods, a Stone Age horn for Capricornus, even if definitively
demonstrated, would do nothing to unify the date for the creation of all the signs.
Even more significant is a massive hill called Glastonbury Tor. Many researchers are convinced
that this is a man-made feature, and based on its shape, some have even suggested it could be
hiding an ancient pyramid. Glastonbury Tor is the most significant part of the whole Somerset
landscape. On top of it we have St Michael's Tower, a 14th century construction, but the main site
itself has terraces carved around it like a labyrinth coming up from ground level all the
If there really is a labyrinthine design marked out on the slopes of Glastonbury Tor,
it's not just pre-Roman, it must be pre-Celtic. It must even date back to the megalithic times.
I don't follow the logic of the statement that if there are the remains of a labyrinth on the Tor,
then it must be pre-Celtic, much less from megalithic times. I think the argument is
based on the idea that the terraces on the hill seem to form a labyrinthine design similar to
what is often called the classical labyrinth design, which has been seen in other places.
Whether these designs are linked in some way would be a topic for another video,
but the fact is we don't know whether the design on Glastonbury Tor matches any of the others,
because weathering, trampling, and shifting of the soil has made it unclear what the original
design was. And since the other instances of this labyrinth design are from many different time
periods, that means it can appear whenever, and so that would leave the time of the making of
the labyrinth on the Tor up in the air. The summit and shoulder of Glastonbury Tor was
excavated between 1964 and 1966. Most of the remains were from medieval times.
There was no evidence of structures from Roman or prehistoric times, but they did find some
remains of Roman and Samian pottery. The only items from prehistoric times were flints and
a greenstone axe, certainly nothing suggesting high technology. Could there be something
underneath it that hasn't yet been discovered? Sure, it's possible, but that possibility doesn't
eliminate the flaws in Maltwood's claims about the zodiac being enshrined in the landscape.
Ollantri, Italy. June 2019. Ancient astronaut theorist Giorgio Tsoukalos is in the heart of
the Italian peninsula, about 50 miles southeast of Rome. He is here to investigate the
astronomical alignment of the finest megalithic construction in Italy, the city's Acropolis.
All right, Giulio. Hello, Giorgio, how are you? Good to see you again. Nice to see you again.
What a fantastic place. Welcome to the Acropolis. I cannot wait to see all of this.
I've been waiting for years to see this. Amazing. For expert insight, he has enlisted the help of
Dr. Giulio Magli, a professor of Archeoastronomy from the Polytechnic University in Milan, Italy.
The imposing megalithic citadel was built on top of the hill and is defined by six huge walls.
The shape of the Acropolis, when viewed from the sky, has led some to suggest that it was
built to create a lasting commemoration of the site's connection to the stars.
All right, so what do we see here? Yes, you see, the Acropolis has a very regular shape.
It is a polygon very similar to the polygons of the walls. Okay. And this very regular shape
has nothing to do with the morphology of the hill, because you know a hill can be
random. Right. But they wanted it exactly as it is. So are you saying that this mount here was
cut artificially? Yes. That is incredible. So why?
They wanted such a strange shape. There is a theory, which might be sound, that they wanted
the Acropolis to have the shape of a constellation. And the edges of the Acropolis correspond to the
brightest stars of the constellation Gemini. So we are looking at the outline of Gemini here.
It may well be. Wow. May well be. What's really interesting here is that the entire
mountaintop has been artificially shaped so that it is in the shape of the constellation of Gemini.
And then you have to wonder, why was it built in this shape? Because something of significance
happened here a long time ago. What is your speculation how old this place really could be?
Okay. Standard archaeology claims that this was made by the Romans. But Romans' techniques were,
of course, very good, but based on horizontal planes and relatively small stones. So it is
very difficult to believe that this was made by the Romans. It must be older. I went and found
Mali's full article on the dating of the Alatri Acropolis. And what Ancient Aliens does not tell
you is that Mali dates the Acropolis to between the 8th and 4th centuries BCE. That's only a few
hundred years earlier, not 10,000. So while he indeed believes it was not constructed by the
Romans, he doesn't date it to the Stone Age or attribute the structure to a lost advanced
civilization in the way that Ancient Aliens wants you to believe he does. Disappointingly, although
the episode is 42 minutes long, the Glastonbury Zodiac and the Alatri Acropolis are the only two
pieces of physical evidence provided for the supposed prehistoric origin of the Zodiac. The
rest of the episode just assumes its prehistoric origin and then builds upon that assumption.
It's fair to say that approaching this subject, or any subject, with certain deficiencies in
knowledge about one or more aspects of that subject, it's going to leave a person at a
loss for words. If we're going to talk about astronomy and astrology in ancient times and
prehistoric times, expertise in just one area, archaeology for example, isn't going to cut it.
Interdisciplinary collaboration ought to be the rule of thumb. Bringing archaeologists or
anthropologists together with astronomers or archaeoastronomers and comparative religion
scholars, even wildlife biologists and depth psychologists, is going to make for much more
informed and comprehensive studies of this subject matter. So what are your thoughts? Do you
know of any other evidences, perhaps stronger ones, that the Zodiac goes back to times earlier than
the Sumerians? Let me know in the comments below. Our discussion, however, is not over. I want to
look at a claim having to do with the Zodiac and Gobekli Tepe. A physicist from the University
of Edinburgh in Scotland has made some grand claims about images that were found on stone
pillars at this stone age site. Is there evidence of the Zodiac there? That will be the subject of
the next video in the series. If you don't want to miss it, don't forget to subscribe and ding the
bell so you get notified. Thanks for watching all the way to the end. Your support is much appreciated.