Catholic vs Protestant: Do Catholics Glorify Mary and Cheat Jesus?

What God did?
17 followers
2 Video Views·May 16, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
I love being Catholic, but you give Mary too much attention. Every time you say Mary, why
not say Jesus? Give Him all the glory and honor. I'm so glad you asked that question
because when I was a Protestant, I thought the exact same thing. The problem is, is when
I was a Protestant, I believed that there was a pie. The pumpkin pie had eight slices
in it and all eight slices went to Jesus. Jesus alone. To Jesus alone. Jesus gets everything.
All glory to Jesus. All glory and honor to Jesus.
Then you look over at Catholics and they say, let's talk about Mary. You just took one
of the eight slices and gave it to Mary. Let's talk about the Pope. You just took a slice
and gave it to the Pope. Then you say, ah, my priest, I go to confession to my priest.
You just took a slice and gave it to your priest. As you talk about Catholic devotion
and Catholic life as a Protestant, you're watching those eight slices be passed around
to angels and Popes and Mary and Joseph and St. Anthony. Pretty soon you're like, there's
only one slice left for Jesus. You Catholics have given seven slices of pumpkin pie to
all these other people and yet Jesus is the Son of God and he gets one piece. That's wrong.
You're saying don't give any slices to Mary.
As a Protestant, as I studied Catholicism, I had an epiphany at one point and I realized
that I was looking at this question in terms of zero-sum theology. I thought, okay, there's
eight slices of pie. We got to get all eight slices to Jesus. But then I realized that
Catholics don't think like that. It's not about a slice of pie with eight slices. Instead,
it is a model of participation. It is not a plus and minus game. It is a multiplication
division game. I'll use an example from my own life. I met
my wife Joy, fell deeply in love with her, asked her to marry me, we got married. A year
later we had a baby, beautiful little boy, our firstborn son. When that baby was born,
if you think about it like a pumpkin pie, it's not that I had eight slices for Joy in
my marriage and then when the baby was born, I gave one slice to the baby and now Joy got
seven. Then a couple of years later, Joy had twins, two little girls. It's not that my
love for Joy was now seven pieces of pie and then I took two and gave those to the twins,
so now Joy has five of my slices of my love and then those three kids get three slices.
Eventually, we had eight kids. The pie is gone. There is nothing left. But in the economy
of love and in the economy of family, love magnifies. So what I found is when I married
my wife and then we had a baby, I loved the baby and then because of the baby, I loved
Joy more. Then we had two more kids, twins. Instead of loving Joy three-fourths less
than I had before, that multiplied my love for Joy even more so that when we had eight
kids eventually, my love for my wife magnified. It multiplied. If I had thought about my love
for my wife as pieces of pie, I would have robbed her and given to the kids and I would
have loved her less, but that's not actually how it works. As a matter of fact, I also
began to love her parents, her mom and her dad and her sisters and then her sister's
husbands and then their kids. The whole family grew and the love grew and it magnified and
my love for my wife increased despite all these extra people being brought in and that
is Catholicism. When a person gets to heaven and becomes a saint, it's not that God loves
everyone in heaven one percent less because there's now another person, one less sliver
of pie because there's a new saint and then another saint and then another saint and then
God's love is getting whittled away. No, God's love magnifies. For every new saint, there
is more majesty, more glory. So it's kind of like saying to me, hey, quit talking about
your kids, talk about your wife. You're taking away from your wife when you talk about how
lovely your kids are. No, actually when I talk about how lovely my kids are, I'm actually
magnifying my wife because she's their mother. She bore them, raised them, taught them, nurtured
them. The success of my children is wrapped up in the success of my wife and in mine.
And that's how Catholics think of it, right? So if I talk about Mary, I'm not taking away
from Jesus. It's not a competition. Jesus is saying, you talked about my mom for eight
minutes, but she only talked about me for five minutes. You stole from me. That's not
how it works. Mary says, my soul magnifies the Lord. Gospel of Luke. So when you see
Mary, Jesus is magnified. When I learn about different saints and how Jesus saved them
from certain sins, led them into persecutions, martyrdoms, and they were victorious, my fascination
and appreciation for the grace of Jesus in them is an appreciation for Jesus Christ.
It's not a competition. It's not a sibling rivalry. And once I finally understand that
that's how I think about my own life and my parents and my family and my wife and my kids,
I'm going to talk about my wife. I'm going to talk about my various children and that's all
good. I'm going to talk about Jesus. I'm going to talk about his mother. Because if it was just
talk about Jesus, the New Testament would just be Jesus, Jesus, Jesus. It would never talk about
Peter or Paul or John or the blessed Virgin Mary or Joseph or the three wise men or the shepherds
or Mary Magdalene. You see, all of these things bring glory to Jesus.
So that's the key. I'm glad you brought that up. And it gave me the opportunity to share my story
and how my mindset changed on understanding how Jesus is understood in the Catholic church
with relation to sacraments, clergy, hierarchy, Pope, Mary, apostles, angels,
saints. It's all one glory fest, right? Everything you hear is about the glory.
