The Rocky Mountain Instinct was bred for the very hills that we got to test it on, or near enough. Based in Vancouver, the Canadian brand certainly isn't short of the terrain where a bike like the Instinct shines. BC, in fairness, by its sheer variety, has something for most bike categories. However, when it comes to backcountry riding and pedal loops, riding the mid-travel aggressive bikes here can be the perfect companion for some of the lesser-known gems, as well as some of the modern classics.
Peddle, peddle, peddle. This is... I need like a bazillion more psi in here.
Maybe a bazillion and two.
This is so soft.
Here we have the Rocky Mountain Instinct with 140 millimeters of travel, a 150
mil fork, and a carbon fiber frame. This thing weighs in at 14.2 kilos and might
just be the most adjustable bike we have on test. It has in-frame storage, chainstay adjustment,
a four position flip chip, and reach adjustment, making this a bike that can truly be anything you
want it to be. But is it a good bike? Rocky does use the unfortunate terminology of quiver killer
for this bike, but given all that adjustment, it might just hold true. You can really make it
anything from a sharper handling thing to something a little more splayed out, ready for steeper
terrain. As to how it performs in those modes, we will get into that with some first impressions
and then the full review. Oh my god. Oh my god. Okay, supple, comfortable, maybe elements of comfort
I don't necessarily like. 80% of the stroke, all the bloody time. Oh my god, the noise. There's just
no damping. And then you get your weight over the back and the front just goes so light. You go so
far into the stroke so quickly, the front comes off the ground. What is that? What is that? Okay,
so that speed, it feels good. Smooth, medium speed turns, but then even like those bumps,
and it's unstable. So that was actually my first run of the bike. And I had to sum up how I felt
in three words. I can't actually remember what they were. But we've got this highly sophisticated.
People think we use teleprompters. No, we got this. Yeah, secret notes from the sky.
So, oh, so the words that I chose to sum up my first impressions of the Rocky
were unstable, light, and undermining. Underwhelming? Undermining. It says
undermining. Undermining, huh. Undermining, I presume. Yeah, not off to the best start really.
Not to the best start. You've ridden this bike quite a lot. Do you think that was fair for
initial impressions as they go? Yeah, I think it is. Yeah, there's things that we'll get into it a
bit, but there are things you can do to try to counteract those initial impressions. But it's
not a bike that you just hop on and everything feels magical and perfect right from the start.
And if we move away from the idea of initial first impressions, and once you've lived with
the bike for a bit, are those kind of baked into what the bike is? I think some instability can be.
Yeah, like the shock tune on this bike is very light compression tune, it feels like. And I
think that can cause you to feel like the rear wheel is moving a lot, possibly when you don't
want it to. So it can feel like you're having trouble. You don't have the level of support that
some of these other bikes have. But isn't that a bit, you know, for our viewers at home, we're
always talking about how sensitive or supple shocks are. And now we're seeing a wheel move too much.
Is that fair? Yeah, I think it is. I mean, you want a range. Ideally, you know, in an ideal world,
your bike comes and it's got a little compression dials on the rear shock. You could open it up and
get a lot of grip, or you can close it down and have a little bit more support. But if you're
too far on one side of the spectrum, it's hard to ever get enough support. So I think that that's
kind of where this bike falls as far as what we found. Well, before we get to the descending and
talk about, you know, the kind of the really granular side of that, we've got some points
on climbing. So this is the lightest frame on test. Oh, sorry, I think one of the lightest
frames. Yeah, I think it might be. How is it on the climbs? I mean, I felt that I kind of liked
the position. It's got quite a long rear end, it's got quite a planted front. But I mean,
it might become a bit of a theme. I found it hard to really move past that sort of wallowy
mid-stroke. It's a very progressive bike. And so you sit quite deep. What were your impressions
climbing on the bike? Yeah, I mean, and we'll touch more on this, but the adjustability,
I think you can find the sweet spots. You could almost make it a climber's bike if you wanted or
buy some more towards the descending. But yeah, in a higher setting, a higher geometry setting,
and the shorter chainstays, I found it felt like a kind of like you would think a trail bike would
feel. It does move a little bit more than some of the other more, again, more supportive bikes,
but you do kind of get deeper and you get to watch pedal strikes because if it's moving that much,
your pedal are getting closer to the ground. So not the most efficient per se. You might want to
even use that climb switch, which a lot of these bikes you can get away without using the climb
switch. But this one, yeah, it is pretty active. Yeah, I was using the climb switch a lot. And then
you do get something more efficient, but you do wave goodbye to a lot of that grip as well.
And the tracking definitely becomes noticeably worse. Although it felt like, as we move on to
the next question we've got here, which is how does suspension feel on climbs? It just felt like
sitting so deep. And it's also, again, that compression, which would funnily enough help
the descending as well, but also help just get a bit more platform. Yeah, it's kind of like sitting
up a little bit more solid. Even when you're really technical jumbles of rocks and things,
if you can kind of stay above it and kind of glide up them rather than just getting sucked
into every single hole. And again, that translates into the sense. But yeah, so climbing-wise,
light bike, you can have the geometry to make it feel like that lighter trail bike.
It has lots of traction, so if it's super slippery, that rear wheel does stay on the ground
pretty well, but you just don't have the level of composure, I'd say, for techie climbs.
And the last of our questions that were kind of sourced between all of the editors and the
production team on here who have either ridden the bike or seen us riding and either praising
or complaining about the bikes. Does the ride height come into play on the climbs? Now,
that's something you've already mentioned. This is a bike I did quite a lot of climbing on,
and I would say, yeah, actually, it really does. It's hard to just feel like, you know,
almost to a fault, I'd say. And it's, you know, again, we talk about sensitivity,
but sensitivity and instability are essentially the same thing, but just tuned. And it's fine,
like a nice spot. And it sounds kind of daft to think that a bike with this much travel that
could be ridden on really rowdy enduro tracks, at least it could be intended to, you're going
to get something that's unstable going at slow speed climbs. But I would say there are elements
of that as well. Yeah, so the bottom bracket height on this bike is pretty low, no matter
the geometry setting. So when you get the low bottom bracket and then a lighter compression
tune or more active shock, it does kind of exacerbate the whole, everything that's happening.
Basically, your pedals are getting pretty close to the ground. So it's again, probably a knock
on it when it comes to overall climbing performance. Absolutely. And, you know,
you mentioned that about sort of the adjustability, the bottom bracket height,
this does have a wide window of adjustability and you can get a really nice balance for and
after on the bike. It would just be interesting to climb on this bike with a bit more of a
sportive feel on the shock. For the descending portion, I'm going to pass you over this
highly official document. All right. Let's see what we've got. Our first question. It's comparing
the suspension versus the geometry. So if you have really good geometry and maybe not as good
suspension, does that make up for it? It's one for the philosophers, eh? You know, it's funny,
the geometry of this bike, everything about it to look at it on a chart in the sort of
theoretical world. This bike is going to be so good at going high speed. It's going to offer you
so much stability. It's going to just let you absolutely crack on. And in some ways, the
geometry sort of plays into the weaknesses of the damping tube because what it says it's going to do
is in direct contradiction to what the shock can offer. Yeah, it was an interesting bike to ride.
Would you agree with that? Yeah, it's a busy feeling bike. You know, when you're going down,
you just feel like there's a lot of the suspension's moving, possibly more than you
want it to. You kind of want that calm. We've got the Canyon Spectral at that review. We're
going to mention how composed that bike is, like the shock tune. That's another 140 mil bike,
but just a drastically different feel. You know, that one just feels like it stays settled. You
can go plow through a rock garden and just kind of stays like that, where this one, it wants to go
just like this. You know, it's just kind of, it's sucking up the bumps kind of, but then it just
kind of gets overwhelmed and you just can't really push into it the way you'd want to.
Exactly. And, you know, we talked about the sort of the different ways you can describe
suspension feel early on with the instability thing, but also I'd say that sometimes,
great example, and similar on that spot as well, had a really nice suspension feel,
and it feels like the wheel's coming into the stroke. When on the Rocky, it feels like the
rider's mass is falling. And there's a ton of geometry adjustments on this, including chainstay,
which you can change by 10 millimeters. So our next question, how useful are those geometry
adjustments? Do you think it's good that it has that many, or would you rather have just
one bike and you can't change it? It's funny. It's kind of, I love the idea of adjustment,
but, and it's, it definitely isn't a criticism, but it almost means that it's hedging the bets
in so many different ways. And it basically says to the end consumer, you make the bike good.
You're right. They can't be wrong if there's this many things, like here, it's all this,
we gave you the ingredients, you messed it up. Yeah. It's, so it's like one of those, you know,
those HelloFresh, like eat at home kits. It sends you the ingredients and then you end up not
following the recipe. And you're like, why, why does it taste as good? I do fundamentally like it.
I just think that it's not, there's too much adjustment. I think mate, to be honest, I would
probably be saying something different about it. If I was able to really enjoy the geometry
because of the shock, I find that we're in a position where, you know, we've all ridden this
bike a lot and we all found that in its shorter setting, less, like I said, less leverage on the
shock, but also the, um, the neutrally steeper modes because they were more linear on the shock.
And so all of this adjustments, like on paper, it's really cool, but it's also like, you know,
come on now. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. My favorite settings, any settings ended up being that
shorter chainstay position. The, I used a little bit shorter reach adjust, which I think that's,
which is, yeah. If we're talking about geometry adjustments, this has a reach adjust head setting
cup, headset cup, you can just switch it out. So you can bring the reach back or forward,
depending on what you'd like. And I was able to shorten it up a little bit and you can,
that's cool. If it had, it could get rid of all the adjustments and just leave reach adjust.
And I think that's a really cool, effective one to, for sizing wise, you know? And then,
and then, yeah, the more steeper setting, it was actually pretty good too.
But it's interesting how like this, the trail bike market is one of the non-racing
sort of categories. And we often talk about downhill bikes, the adjustment, how amazing that
is. And so it seems a bit of a inconsistency to complain about it now. Um, but just, just
to that in mind, I'd say that if you run a SRAM, uh, 1-2-1 T-type, you would be,
Yeah, it cuts off an adjustment. So you, in order to run this, in order to run SRAM's
T-type derailleur, you end up with a longer chainstay setting. So you've knocked away one
hole setting, which that's not anyone's fault really, but kind of, you know, it's like you
have the adjustment, but then you can't. But to me, it highlights the fact that
they have an adjustment there, which has then really pulls it away from what the shock wants
to do. And that's what I think is interesting is it's like, if you're going to commit to one,
maybe one size or maybe fewer adjustments, cause it used to be ride nine, I think.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm glad that it's dropped.
Ride four now. But it just means that like, maybe there isn't so much an
onus on optimizing that one particular setting. And it kind of leaves a gray area about what the
bike is ultimately end up going to be. Yeah. It's a bit of a confused bike. And I think
that kind of brings us to the next question, where the bike shined. Where's the, you know,
if you had this bike in the ideal scenario for it.
That's, um, that's a really interesting question.
I just jumped you. Yeah. I mean, for me, like,
get in here. This bike, you can make, I think it's definitely more of a trail bike than a
mini Enduro bike, even though on paper you can make it really slack and really long. But I think
in order to get the most out of it, if you treat it as a trail bike, it's fairly light.
Um, and it's, you know, pretty active. So you can just kind of make it as like a,
a shorter travel, do it all trail bike rather than trying to push it to the limits
or even partially to the limits. Whilst I would say that I think a coil shock on this bike
with more compression. That'd be interesting too. It'd be very interesting to at least try.
Um, but I don't really understand, you know, without going too off script here,
I don't really understand. No, they, they made this in, I guess they're in Vancouver.
Yeah. Like surely they, I don't know. Yeah. I don't want to. And so, yeah, I think the takeaway
is a different shock tune could probably dramatically change this bike. And we've
kind of had that with some other Rockies in the past. I think I don't exactly know where the
disconnect is happening, but just for their tunes, haven't been matching our preferences
and it's not just us, it's more, um, editors as well. So it's, yeah, I don't know. They're
just kind of going for a more active field and I think they could kind of tone it back a little
bit and really make a good bike. Yeah. And also it's worth pointing out that the OE tune that
brands set up on isn't the one that maybe they give their professional riders, et cetera. You
know, you can get lots of different tunes and that's part of making a bike sort of really
optimized final product. All right. Well, getting close to the end of our descending questions,
did it live up to expectations? Uh, after you. It didn't live up to my expectations. It looks good.
Like this bike looks really good on the geometry on paper, but actually like the physical looks of
it, it looks nice and sleek and modern. You're like, this bike's going to be fun. I can make
it crazy slack. It's going to be like a mini Enduro thing. And then it's not. And then you're
like, well, I'll just steepen up and make it a cool trail bike thing. And then it's not as much.
It's just kind of like, I don't know. You know, this is in some ways exactly the inverse,
like lived experience of the spot. I looked about and I thought, yeah, that bike is so much fun.
So good. But Kaz, when I saw you roll, roll down that rock face and the noise that came out of both
my God, the bottom out heard around the world. That was bad. That's worse than it should have
been. Yeah. It just summed up kind of where the bike was at. You know, like I looked at the
geometry. I thought this is going to be absolutely amazing. Yeah. And it was just a case of like an
unexpected ball. Yeah. It just doesn't quite live up to it. But speaking of noise, we should toss
to the garage and see what this bike is like to live with. All right. We are now in the garage
with the Rocky Mountain Instinct going to talk about some of the little features that make it
more or less livable. I'm going to start off with one of the strong suits of this bike. It has,
I think, the best frame storage of the bunch. It's a huge opening. We'll have some measurements
later. It's got an air tag mount, which is kind of cool. Just generally a very usable system.
Super easy to take off, feels watertight, does not rattle at all. Now this bike has the most
adjustments on test and I found that overall they're very easy to make. This four position
is something you could just do with a multi-tool trail side if you want to. The chainstay adjustment
is a bit more involved. It only takes about 10 minutes. I actually did it in the gondola one day
and then the reach adjustment is just a matter of either flipping those cups around or putting
a different one in if you want the zero reach setting. Again, a pretty easy thing to do.
Finally, the least livable thing about this bike is the noise that it makes. We found that no matter
what we did, there was always some rattling, some clanging. It just felt like it wasn't necessarily
the frame being more resonant. There's just a lot of noise coming from different places on the bike.
We tried to isolate it to the in-frame storage area. It wasn't just that. Part of it is just
the cables moving, even though it has clamps at the entry and exit. Overall, just kind of a noisy
bike. A bit frustrating for some, but maybe not a deal breaker for everybody. As an overall livable
bike, I'm going to give this a pretty high rating. I think the adjustments are easy to make, not too
complicated. Overall, the shock is accessible, the parts are easy to work on, and nothing is too weird
or proprietary. I'm going to give it a pretty good score in that sense. Now, we're going to head back
into the house, finish up our thoughts on the review, and see who this bike is for.
So that was Dario running us through what this bike is like to live with. Let's talk about the
pros and the cons. Do you want to go pros or cons? Yeah, we'll start with the pros. Pros.
Pros, I think the biggest pro is that level of adjustability. Just a huge range of options,
everything from reach to chainstay length to your suspension progression. That's a huge pro
for this bike. Other pros, pretty light. If you want to build up a nice lightweight trail bike,
it's got that, and good storage. In-frame storage works well, plenty of room for all your snacks.
Absolutely. I think the cons would be the arguably under-damped shock. I would say it's noisy.
I would say that if you want to run T-type, you'll be locked in to the one adjustment that we've found
played worst with the current shock tube. So if those are the pros and cons, who's this bike for
then? I think it's for someone that's wanting that kind of more general trail bike. I don't
think it's your person that's looking for the mini enduro bike or whatever phrase you want to call
it. It's somebody that doesn't mind tinkering a little bit. With a new shock tube, I think this
bike could work really well. It could also be for someone that wants a bike that fits them well. If
they're having trouble finding themselves in between sizes on other brands, this one offers
a level of adjustment. You could really fine-tune it to those exact numbers that you want. Well,
that's it. I think in some ways it's a mountain bike. In other ways, it's kind of like a project.
If you took it on trying to get your perfect sort of trail bike and wanted to maybe visit
how compression damping can really change the feel of a ride, you could get something
really, really special. That's our review on the Rocky Mountain Instinct. Thank you very much for
watching and please don't forget to like and subscribe to keep in touch with all the field
test content.