Scope Clause_ The Regional Airlines' Capacity Cap Explained

Warship And Aircraft
72 followers
Spend enough time following aviation in the United States, and you're bound to hear the term
scope clause. So what exactly is it? Why does it exist, and how does it impact air operations?
More specifically, how does it affect the business of running an airline?
That's something we'll cover in today's video.
The scope clause acts as a contract between airlines and pilots unions.
Its role is to limit the size of aircraft the regional affiliate may fly. The clause
impacts aircraft, pilots, and the route networks of major airlines.
Regarding the airline industry, a scope clause limits the number of passengers a regional
aircraft can carry. Currently, the hard cap is 76 passengers. But it gets even more specific
in that there is also a limit on a regional plane's certified maximum take-off weight,
which cannot exceed £86,000. Additionally, each major US airlines union has a way of capping the
number of regional jets that can operate on behalf of the mainline brand. One example could be
placing a limit on the percentage of the mainline's fleet or a specific number of aircraft.
It's important to know that it's pilots unions that have negotiated and implemented scope clauses,
and not the airlines. Pilot unions have used scope clauses since before the deregulation
of the industry. From the outset, scope clauses, like many other protections,
were implemented as safeguards to work rules. The airline industry is heavily influenced by
socio-political and economic factors, which have led to downturns, with recent examples being post
9-11, the Great Recession of 2008, and the COVID-19 pandemic. If the economic conditions
during a contract negotiation are poor, wages and work rules could more easily be negotiated
below previous standards. For this reason, pilots unions in the US have included scope clauses as
an immovable stipulation for decades. Airline operations changed drastically
in the US in the early 1980s. Seeking to compete for lower prices and grow their markets,
airlines created what you might call alter-ego operations that used separate aircraft and
pilots from their already established staff and resources. These separate airlines were
owned by the major airline or a holding company and operated under the marketing
and brand of the mainline carrier. However, most crucially, the separate airline staff,
not represented by unions at the time, were paid at a reduced rate compared to their counterparts
working with the mainline brand. This allowed airlines to increase flight frequency and lower
ticket prices while lowering costs. The scope clause ensures that mainline
airlines hire pilots rather than outsource flying. If large airlines want to grow their
regional operations, they must first expand their mainline operations or create a new
agreement with their pilots union. Scope clauses protect pilots hired on mainlines,
but a lesser understood value is to protect regional pilots. Pilots at regional carriers
can get hired on mainlines sooner because the airlines need to staff the planes they are
required to operate. For example, an airline limited to using regional planes for 40% of
its mainline fleet would need to grow its fleet as a requirement to employing more regional pilots.
To expand its mainline fleet, the airline would almost certainly need to hire more pilots,
and some of the most likely candidates would be regional pilots.
So what does this look like in the real world? Well, US airlines do their best to operate types
of aircraft that match the market demand. This is why you might fly a 170-seat Boeing 737 to
a Mexican destination in the winter and a 76-seat CRJ900 in the summer.
You might also see rules that don't make as much sense, like a 170-seat plane operating
in a small city with a load factor below 60%. This happens when an airline has deployed its
entire regional fleet but still needs to cover a route. This is why route planning is so complex
and exciting, as it changes by the season. In a perfect world, an airline might like to
operate aircraft in the 90-120 seat range to accommodate market demand.
However, because of the scope clause, these aircraft's pilots must be mainline employees.
This in itself would make the operation of these planes unfeasible in a lot of small markets.
Aircraft manufacturers are likewise affected by the US scope clause. Bombardier's CRJ program,
since acquired and closed by Mitsubishi, and Embraer's E-Jets, made sure to offer aircraft
that precisely met such regulations. Most of these aircraft families operate in the US,
and regional carriers fly them because they make economic sense under the scope clause.
Embraer is massively successful in the US market with its E-Jet program,
having enjoyed strong demand for the type in the country.
However, Embraer has yet to secure a single order for the evolved E175E2.
Even a recent major American Airlines order for up to 133 Embraer E175s is for the E1 version.
Why would the airline settle for a less efficient jet when its more advanced successor
is available? Well, a key factor is that the scope clause excludes its operation. Indeed,
its newer, more efficient, geared turbofan engines exceed the £86,000 weight restriction
in the scope clause. The US market needs airliners that seat between 90 and 130 passengers,
falling between the 76-seat larger regional jets and narrowbodies like the Boeing 737-700 or Airbus
A319. Embraer once controlled this market share, having delivered E190-E195 aircraft to American
Airlines and JetBlue. However, with American Airlines having stored these aircraft, and JetBlue
phasing them out, this market share is firmly controlled by the Airbus A220.
Delta Air Lines operates the A220 today, as does JetBlue, and by orders placed,
these carriers are among the largest operators of the type. Pilots love flying the plane,
and passenger reviews have been outstanding. To their credit, passengers are also known to
enjoy the CRJ-900 and Embraer 175, which boast some of the best legroom in their respective
airlines' fleets due to the ability to carry more than 76 passengers if the scope clause were not
in place. The bottom line is that the scope clause is a fascinating factor that has a
tangible effect on how airlines operate and how Americans travel. Indeed, it's something that has
industry-wide repercussions in the US market. The regulations implemented by pilot's unions
protect work and compensation rules for all airline pilots and have a visible effect on
the planes that passengers fly. Industry analysts have posited that regional airlines might no
longer be viable models for airlines after pilot wage increases. However, the validity of these
musings is long from being determined. As long as regional airlines are in the US,
the scope clause will also exist. What do you think of scope clauses?
Are you in favor of them? Share your thoughts by leaving a comment down below.
