This is the full version of Jan Jekielek’s interview with Brian Lee Crowley. The interview was originally released on Epoch TV on March 10, 2025.
“Donald Trump is looming so large in the Canadian consciousness right now,” says Brian Lee Crowley.
“And I have seen a lot of my compatriots running around like chickens with their heads cut off, saying, ‘Oh my God, Donald Trump is a mad man. You can’t understand what he’s doing. There’s no rhyme or reason to it.’ And I looked at what Donald Trump was doing, and I thought, ‘Okay, I don’t have to like it. That’s a separate question. But if the question is, ’Can I understand it?' The answer is yes.”
Crowley is the founder and managing director of the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, a Canadian think tank whose work is often cited by the Canadian Parliament.
“What exactly is the difference between Canada and America, or Canadians and Americans? It’s not that it’s difficult to answer because there aren’t differences. It’s difficult to answer because the differences are subtle and hard to express,” says Crowley.
“Remember that America broke away through a violent revolution from the crown and the United Kingdom—from Great Britain. Canadians never experienced that.”
In this episode, Brian Lee Crowley and Jan Jekielek discuss the recent election in Canada, Trump’s comments about Canada as America’s 51st state, and what the future of United States–Canada relations may look like.
“Canada exports 50 percent of everything made in the private sector, and the vast bulk of that, like 90 percent, goes to the United States. But [in] the United States, by contrast, foreign trade, or international trade, only represents barely 25 percent of the amount of the American economy, and that’s diversified across all of its trade partners. So, while for Canada, the relationship with the United States is existential, for America, the relationship with Canada is convenient, nice—not existential.”
CHAPTER TITLES 0:00:00 - Introduction to Canadian Consciousness and Trump's Influence 0:00:34 - The Subtle Differences Between Canada and the United States 0:01:36 - Canadian Election and Trump's Impact 0:04:45 - Polling Shifts and Election Dynamics 0:06:55 - Canadian Identity and Oppositional Nationalism 0:10:45 - Understanding Trump's Strategic Approach 0:21:09 - Trump's Negotiation Tactics and Deal-Making 0:22:35 - Canada-US Relations and the China Factor 0:27:50 - Economic Integration of North America 0:35:12 - Canada's Security Challenges and NATO Obligations 0:40:25 - US-Canada Defense Relationship 0:45:49 - Gardeners vs. Designers: A Philosophical Perspective 0:51:06 - COVID-19 and the Role of Experts 0:55:35 - The McDonald Laurier Institute: Origins and Impact 0:59:18 - Concluding Thoughts on Canada-US Relations
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
Donald Trump is looming so large in the
Canadian consciousness right now. I have
seen a lot of my compatriots, you know,
running around like chickens with their
heads cut off saying, "Oh my god, Donald
Trump is a mad man. You can't understand
what he's doing. There's no rhyme or
reason to it." I looked at what Donald
Trump was doing and I thought, "Okay, I
don't have to like it." But if the
question is, can I understand it? The
answer is yes. Brian Lee Crowley is the
founder and managing director of the
McDonald Laurier Institute, a major
Canadian think tank whose work is often
cited by the Canadian Parliament. What
exactly is the difference between Canada
and America? It's not that it's
difficult to answer because there aren't
differences. It's difficult to answer
because the differences are subtle and
hard to express. In this episode, we
dive into the recent election in Canada,
Trump's comments about Canada as
America's 51st state, and what the
future of US Canada relations may look
like. Canada exports 50% of everything
made in the private sector. Uh, and the
vast bulk of that, like 90% goes to the
United States. By contrast, you know,
foreign trade or international trade
only represents barely 25% of the the
American economy. So while for Canada
the relationship with the United States
is
existential, for America the
relationship with Canada is convenient,
nice, not existential. This is American
Thought Leaders and I'm Yan
Kelly. Brian Lee Crowley, such a
pleasure to have you on American Thought
Leaders. Yeah. And thanks so much for
having me. I suppose I should call it
Canadian thought leaders. Well, that
that'd be a good that'd be a good
choice. But so so what happened with the
Canadian election and what did uh US
President Donald Trump have to do with
it? Very interesting question. Y several
things happened to change politics in
Canada quite radically in a very short
time. One was that uh uh Prime Minister
Justin Trudeau who had become deeply
unpopular suddenly left. He was
basically forced out by his party.
Second, Donald Trump came to power in
Washington. Uh,
and as a result of these changes, uh,
the the assumption that everybody had
made that Pierre Palev and the
Conservative Party were going to waltz
into power sort of, uh, unopposed
suddenly came crashing down partly
because uh, there was a now a new leader
of the Liberal Party. He had a
completely different profile than Justin
Trudeau, Mark Carney, former governor of
the Bank of Canada, Governor of the Bank
of England. Uh someone who seemed to be
to a lot of people uh you know, a calm,
competent, technocratic kind of leader.
And that seemed to I think a number of
Canadians the perfect response to Donald
Trump who started talking about Canada's
the 51st state and uh how how happy
America would be to annex Canada and and
this this makes Canadians deeply
nervous. You know, the whole one of the
important reasons why Canada exists as a
country is because at several points in
our
history, we kind of asked ourselves, do
we want to be Americans? And the answer
was no. We want to, yes, we're we're a
new world country. Uh, you know, we
share many characteristics with America,
but we're not Americans. We want to have
our own model of a new world society
that's different from Europe, different
from the old countries uh but that has
the same you know values freedom and
enterprise and all those other things
just as much as America does uh but
comes to different conclusions about the
role of government pursuit of the common
good etc etc. So in that context, uh
Donald
Trump's musings about making Canada the
51st state and so on and how Canada has
nothing constructive or useful to offer
the United States made many Canadians
deeply anxious. And I think Mark Carney
stepped into that situation and said,
"I'm the guy who can represent Canada in
an effective way visa v Donald Trump."
And
Canadians, not not in large numbers, but
enough Canadians accepted that argument
that he just squeaked past the
Conservatives. you know, 43% of the
popular vote for the Liberals, almost 42
for the Conservatives, not much in the
difference, uh, but, uh, enough to win
enough seats to form a government. For a
while, it seemed like it was almost
based on the polling, right? It seemed
like it would almost be a blowout for
the Liberals, but then that shifted,
too. And I find that really interesting.
Uh, do you have thoughts on that? Yes.
So I I think the early stages of the
campaign uh Donald Trump I think drove
the anxiety levels of Canadians who
cared about these issues to
unprecedented heights and uh the issues
that had previously been the ones that
we thought were going to dominate in the
election campaign in Canada um cost of
living um efficiency of government and
so on, levels of
taxation, these things started to come
back to the four. Ultimately, what
happened was the liberals went from
being just streets ahead in the polls to
almost level pegging with the
conservatives. And um it was in that
state of public opinion that the voting
actually happened. I've spent the last
however many months explaining to
Americans uh in Washington DC that
Canadians have this kind of oppositional
identity and I think what you said kind
of explains it a little bit like they
there's an element of the Canadian
identity which is clearly I am not
American and I remember that growing up
uh in Canada as well. was it was very
distinctive and very important actually
and I and and later only later did I
realize that that seemed odd to have an
oppositional identity but but that you
know Prime Minister Trudeau famously
described Canada as a postnational state
but I and I wonder I guess seeing what
we saw I guess that kind of proves that
it's not because whatever those embers
of of of of Canadian nationalism that
that that existed still they came
drawaring back in the last few months
right even as it was even as it is this
kind of oppositional identity it's a
very difficult question to answer what
exactly is the difference between Canada
and America or Canadians and Americans
uh and that's it it's not that it's
difficult to answer because there aren't
differences it's difficult to answer
because the differences are subtle and
hard to press. I always like to go back
to the difference
between the founding documents of Canada
and the United States. In the United
States, you have a society uh in which
in this wonderful immortal phrase,
people are free to pursue life, liberty,
and happiness. Life, liberty, and the
pursuit of happiness.
Um, those were not the values that we
chose to highlight when we wrote down in
our constitution what it was that we
were about. We talk we chose to talk
instead about peace, order, and good
government. And you see, I think those
phrases
actually summarize in a shorthand
way some some slightly different angles
on, you know, what's the purpose of
government? What how do people fit into
a larger society? What are we trying to
do together? Uh remember that America
broke away through a a a violent
revolution from uh from the crown and
the United Kingdom from Great Britain.
Canadians never experienced that. In
fact, people often talk about the 13
colonies forgetting that there were
actually 16 colonies, 13 of whom
rebelled and three of whom remained
loyal to the crown. So even back at the
time of the revolution, there were parts
of what became Canada who said, "Yeah,
that's not the route we want to
go." We tend to be uh people who believe
more in uh the the quiet thoughtful
evolution of institutions rather than
like liking this idea of oh, you know,
if you don't like what you got now, a
radical break, start again, reinvent.
um that that seems to us a very American
way of thinking about things. I don't
say that in a critical way. I'm I'm a
great admirer of American. But um Canada
has chosen an evolutionary path
uh in which we put a little more
emphasis on the idea of the common good.
A little less emphasis on the idea of
individual liberty as the beall and
endall. We're great believers in
individual freedom. Uh but we don't
think that individual freedom is the
entire answer to the purpose of Canada.
Uh we think individual freedom in the
context of uh an ordered society that
believes that we collectively can do
things together that
individually we would find difficult.
From the outside those differences don't
appear very great. you know, uh,
Europeans come to Canada, they say, "Why
are you so fussed
about not being thought
Americans?" Um, but from the
inside, the differences to us
are quite obvious.
And without in any way feeling that it
means that we're superior to to America.
Uh it does make us feel that we've
chosen a slightly different path in
North America. Uh and it's one, you
know, that our ancestors fought and
suffered and paid for and that we have
inherited and it's
ours and that matters to us. you in some
of your recent writings, you've gone to
great pains to try to explain
um I guess
the way of thinking or the approach of
US President Trump and the Trump
administration. And I thought, you know,
reading this, I I thought to myself, I
think you understand it better than
probably a lot of a lot of Americans.
not, you know, obviously not a majority
of Americans, but as some and maybe I I
wanted you to kind of reprise that for
me a little bit here. One of the reasons
I've been thinking about this is because
uh precisely because uh Donald Trump is
looming so large in the Canadian
consciousness right now.
Um, and I I have seen a lot of my
compatriots, you know, running around
like chickens with their heads cut off
saying, "Oh my god, Donald Trump is a
mad man. You can't understand what he's
doing. There's no rhyme or reason to
it." And I I looked at what Donald Trump
was doing and I thought, "Okay, I I
don't have to like it. That's a that's a
that's a separate question." But if the
question is, can I understand it? The
answer is yes. There were there were
three sort of major themes that kind of
leapt out at
me. Uh one is that Donald Trump believes
in his guts that America is the top
nation in the world. It's the most
important country. It's the one that
sets the stage for almost every other
important relationship alliance you know
trading relationship and so uh
and he feels that America has gone
through a period of decline has lost
some of
that top nation status it's being
challenged by uh some other countries uh
and I believe that he sees it as his
role as president to restore America to
this top nation status. Now, I mentioned
that so that's number one. I mentioned
that there are countries that are
challenging America in in this top
nation status. And of course, the the
one that comes immediately to mind uh is
China. And I believe that uh Donald
Trump has in the back of his mind in
almost every issue that he wrestles with
whether it's trade or defense or
national security or even the drug
trade, fentinel, etc., etc. He has in
the back of his mind, China is our great
rival. China is our competitor and China
is using many of these issues that
America must wrestle with uh as sticks
to beat America with. Um I mentioned the
drug trade. I think it's a beautiful
example of that. Clearly uh China has a
political strategy behind its trading
relationship with the United States in a
way that uh you know most other Western
countries would not. They don't mix
trade and politics the way that China
does.
Uh and
so given his preoccupation with
returning America to the top nation
status, to removing any ambiguity about
that
uh and to his sense that top nation
status must mean a muscular response to
China. The third thing I add to that is
that Trump believes
that as America has failed to live up to
its responsibilities to be top nation,
there are certain parts of American
society that have suffered as a result.
And uh you know the the kind of people
we're talking about of course are are
the ones who were immortalized in JD
Vance's book uh Hillbilly Elegy. the
kind of people he grew up with, the
communities that he knew, sometimes
referred to as the rust belt, uh, or the
flyover states or however you like to
think about it. Um I I I believe that uh
Donald Trump thinks
that these people who form a I think the
bedrock of his political support are
people who have been forgotten and left
behind by an America u abandoning its
vocation to be top nation, refusing to
uh stand up to China, etc., etc., etc.
And Donald Trump wants to be the tribune
of these people. He wants to be their
champion. Think about a very famous
phrase widely associated with Donald
Trump. Drill, baby, drill. Okay, people
think that this is just, you know, Trump
in one of his macho moods saying, you
know, oh, uh, uh, uh, you know, I'm I'm
going to preside over, you know, huge
expansion of the oil and gas industry.
And so, it's it's much more than that.
You see, I think Trump has come to
understand the extent to which energy
and particularly oil and gas
uh are tremendously powerful tools. And
back to this theme of restoring
America's greatness, returning it to top
nation status, he would look back at the
1970s, for example, when uh uh America
went through two oil crises, one caused
by OPEC, the Organization of Petroleum
Exporting Countries, putting a an
embargo on exports to the United States,
uh which caused I I remember it well, it
caused huge cues around gas stations,
you
know, states brought in 50 m an hour
speed limits uh in order to make people
drive slower and use less gas.
Um and then there was the Iranian
revolution which again later in the 70s
terribly disrupted the world oil supply
and caused another energy crisis in the
United States. And you might recall that
uh as a result, America had rules about
uh you know, you couldn't export oil
from the United States. Uh America was a
was very dependent on oil from the
Middle East in particular. Uh and this
uh was a a source of great weakness for
the United States. And Donald Trump then
sees how uh you know the fracking
revolution, the huge increase in uh uh
uh the amount of oil being produced by
the United States and America's
transformation from a net oil consumer
to a net oil exporter
uh in fact the largest exporter in the
world bigger than anybody else uh has
fundamentally changed the American
economy, American national security uh
and he wants to push that even further
and he thinks that drill baby drill is
in part an industrial strategy. It's the
idea that uh America should double down
on its abil on its incredible
technological pro prowess and its
ability to produce vast quantities of
energy in a cost effective way and uh
not only improve America's national
security but unlock uh a lot of economic
activity that requires access to cheap
reliable energy. So I I think all of
these things actually
uh can he's woven them
together in a strategy for America. Um
and
again, you know, agree, disagree, if if
you want to understand anything that
Donald Trump does, I think if you refer
back to these these four things, top
nation, challenge of China, uh uh you
know, recovering the promise of America
for the people who were left behind and
um uh you know, cheap plentiful energy
is the bedrock of a of of an American
economic renaissance. you will
understand almost everything that Donald
Trump does. Why is it lost on so many
people? See, I think it's because people
get distracted by Donald Trump's tactics
and they forget to think about strategy.
Donald Trump
is is the inheritor of a great
tradition, great American tradition of
um showman. You know, he's a kind of a
Barnaman Bailey figure, isn't he? And
part of what he wants to do, and this
goes right back to um the art of the
deal, you know, I I've often believed if
people tell you who they are, you should
believe them. And I I think Donald Trump
has been quite open about who he is.
Donald Trump conceives himself as a
great dealmaker. you know, all of the
things that I've described, you know,
the relationship with China, the uh the
the energy renaissance, uh America's top
nation, uh restoring, uh it's trading
dominance, all of these things, uh he
sees them all as deals that he can
strike. If you sort of inquire into
Donald Trump's personality, his
character, how he goes about making
deals, one of the things that comes
through crystal clear is he says the my
starting point for any major negotiation
is I convince the people I'm negotiating
with that I am the craziest man in the
room. If they don't do what I want them
to do, I will bring everything crashing
down.
And people listen to him, they say, "Oh
my god, he's going to tear everything
down. He's a crazy man." Um, I I
actually think what he's doing is he's
saying, "Look up here at this shiny,
frightening object I'm waving in your
face." When he's actually busy doing
something quite different. Uh, you know,
tariffs would be a good example. You
know, people say, "Oh, you know, Trump
blinked over the tariffs and you know,
he one day he's saying there's going to
be 100% tariffs, the next day it's 150%
tariffs on China, and then something
else the next day, and then it's
suspended." And so, and they think,
"Well, he doesn't know what he's doing."
Oh, I think I I think he knows exactly
what he's doing. I think he's scaring
the pants off the people that he wants
to make deals with and bringing them to
the table. Now, you can like it or not
like it, but I I actually find all these
people running around saying, "Oh my
god, he's a crazy man. You can't
understand what he's doing. He's a he's
he's a
maniac." They're actually playing his
game. They're letting him distract them
with the shiny object up here and and
and and getting caught up in his tactics
and forgetting to think about his
strategy. And I think his strategy is
quite clear. It's very very interesting
to me um at the moment that
um Prime Minister Carney um of the two
candidates um at least all the reports
that I've seen would is the one that's
more uh more positively inclined towards
communist China than Pivvier. You've
argued that it's through President
Donald Trump's rhetoric, you know, it
was almost intentional. I think you
believe it was intentional. He wanted to
see Carney
elected. Um but given what you just told
me about his, you know, priorities visa
v China that that those two things seem
at
odds or do they? For what it's worth, my
view is that
uh Donald
Trump looks at the rest of the
world through an American lens. He the
question he asks himself is not how
should I understand Mark Carney as a
Canadian but what is the significance of
Mark Carney to me as the leader of
America when he looks at Mark Carney
he's going to see a guy with a a you
know a big degree from a fancy
university you know he's an
international technocrat he's been
central bank governor in both Canada and
the United Kingdom He's the
quintessential Davos man. I I'm here to
tell you he is everything Donald Trump
despises. Uh
and on top of that he is as you have
properly pointed out um close to China.
The party who represents has been uh
uh an an active promoter of China as an
important party partner for for Canada
for many years. Um, and I I I I think
that Donald Trump
sees Mark Carney as the kind of
negotiating partner he can get the
better of. I I think Donald Trump is
going to say behind closed doors, "Look,
buddy,
uh there is no alternative for Canada to
its relationship with the United States.
Uh, but America doesn't need Canada very
much. Canada really needs America.
You're going to do what I'm going to
tell you or I am really going to put the
boots to you. Uh, and I think that Mark
Carney, as some of his own advisers have
written, uh, is now that the election is
out of the way and now that he's reaped
the political benefits of presenting
himself as the guy who can most
effectively represent Canada, he's going
to make a quiet deal with Donald Trump,
which gives Donald Trump pretty much
everything he wants because he doesn't
have much alternative. And I don't think
he's going to be very successful in
standing up to Donald Trump. I know he'd
like to think he he can and I don't
think he's got a lot of cards in his
hand and I think Donald Trump likes it
just fine that way.
Um see I believe uh there many people
who don't like this but I believe it's a
a profound truth about North America is
that there is a single North American
economy. There are not two national
economies in North America, an American
and a
Canadian that somehow, you know, trade
finished products with each
other. Uh there is a single North
American economy deeply
integrated. Uh which happens to fall
under the jurisdiction of two separate
nation states, Canada and the United
States. There are bits of it that fall
under the government of Canada and bits
of it that fall under the government of
the of the United States. But that
political jurisdiction doesn't make two
separate economies. We have one uh you
know they but you know what they say
that you know the average uh North
American car for example crosses the
border something like five or six times
as it moves through the production
process and goes to different plants in
either Canada or the United States
because the industry is so integrated.
The the industry doesn't think of itself
as an American industry and a Canadian
industry. uh they think of themselves as
a single uh uh um uh combined uh um uh
continental industry. Um think about uh
think about the oil industry. Um you
know, America likes to boast about the
fact quite properly likes to boast about
the fact that it's now exporting 10
million barrels of oil a day. Largest
oil exporter in the world. What they
often forget to mention is that almost
half of that is made possible by over 4
million barrels of oil that they import
every day from
Canada. If they didn't have access to
Canadian oil, they wouldn't be nearly
the energy overachiever that they think
they are. Canada's the fourth largest
oil producer in the world and literally
90% of that production goes to the
United States. uh and in fact, you know,
the entire refinery complex on the on
the US Gulf Coast uh is toolled up to to
process the kind of oil that Canada
exports and can't process much of the
oil that is produced by fracking in the
United States. So, America fracks,
exports that oil, brings oil in from
Canada, processes it, and uh serves
American consumers. So, and I could
multiply the examples over and over. The
point is
that Canada is one of the most export
dependent countries in the world. This
is a huge degree of trade reliance. Uh
um and literally 85 to 90% of that goes
to the United States. Again, because we
don't exist as a separate economy that
only sends finished products to the
United States. we are deeply intertwined
in these complex production processes. I
I'll just add I I have a particular
example because in in my LinkedIn feeds
uh an old classmate of mine from high
school uh represents uh the Canadian
auto parts makers and he's scored some
wins because these Canadian auto parts
are very important to
American manufacturing of autos. Is this
Flavio? That's right. You see, most
people in their minds that when they
think about trade, they think, okay,
France produces wine and Japan produces
cars and France sends wine to Japan in
exchange for cars. This is not at all
the relationship that Canada and the
United States have. There's nothing like
it. Roughly 60% of the trade across the
border is actually what they call
intrafirm trade. In other words, it's
taking place between parts of the same
company. They they do some part of their
production process in Canada, then they
send that to another part of their
production process in the United States,
and it may come back as back to this
idea that cars cross the border four,
five, six times while they're being
made. And and you can multiply this
across many sectors. So the idea that
you know I I I hear this rubbish all the
time about Canadians say oh you know we
should uncouple from the United States
and we should you know we shouldn't give
up our sovereignty
uh a as if oh instead of sending our car
parts to the United States we're going
to send them to Europe or Japan or
whatever. And I you know my reaction to
that is you obviously know nothing about
how cars are made. You know, the idea
that I hear sometimes people say, "Oh,
well, you know, we should we should
reduce our dependence on the United
States and join the European Union." I
think what what
like are you seriously suggesting that
this deep economic integration between
Canada and the United States that has
been built up literally over centuries
can overnight somehow be cut apart with
a pair of scissors and and will have
exactly the same relationship tomorrow
with the European Union. This is just
this is just nonsensical.
So the the reason we're having this
conversation is you said so why is it
that that Donald Trump has all the
cards? Right. Right. Because so far
we've been talking about how Canada is
actually kind of important to the US.
Yes. In all these ways, right? So here
what about this other the the the other
side the big piece I guess? Right. So so
but so I' I've talked about the fact
that okay Canada exports 50% of
everything made in the private sector.
Uh and the vast bulk of that like 90%
goes to the United States. But the
United States, by contrast, you know,
foreign trade or international trade
only represents barely 25% of the the
American economy and that's diversified
across all of its trade partners. So
while for Canada, the relationship with
the United States is
existential, for America, the
relationship with Canada
is
convenient,
nice, not existential.
not
existential. Uh
so
when Donald Trump says we don't get
anything useful from Canada, he's
talking
rubbish. If he had said instead,
um we like our relationship with Canada
and we get some nice things from Canada,
but you know, we could get them from
somewhere else. And um uh it would be
slightly inconvenient for us to have to
do that. But we could do it. If he'd
said that, he would have been saying the
truth. But then again, that that's but
but isn't he starting at his ne with his
negotiating position here that you
described earlier, right? With the sort
of the the extreme negotiating position.
Oh, of course. I I I I I I didn't mean
to say, you know, that somehow it was
surprising that Donald Trump was not
saying the
truth. This is part of his negotiating
tactic, right? He he he
knows Canada's vulnerability to the
United States and he knows that for
Canada there is no realistic
alternative.
uh
and he's basically signaling to
Canadians he knows this
uh
and uh he's going
to have high expectations of any
negotiations that will take place
between Canada and the United States
over you know the nature of our trade
and other relationships. Let me let me
put it a different way. Canada has, I
think it is fair to say, been failing to
keep up its end of the bargain with the
United States. Uh, its end of the
bargain being, you know, we will be a
reliable ally on defense. We have not
been a reliable ally on defense. That we
will be the country that will look after
the Arctic flank of North America. We
have not been looking after the Arctic
flank of North America. that we will be
uh you know enforcing the rule of law in
Canada and ensuring that Canada cannot
be used as a launching pad for uh you
know uh drug trade with the United
States. I think he exaggerates to some
extent the degree to which this happens.
But uh there's no doubt that uh Canada
is part of the international network
that is uh flooding the United States
with fentanyl. And by the way uh the I
think the biggest role that we play in
that is that we have become a haven for
moneyaundering for the people who are
actually behind the drug trade which is
mostly China.
Um and uh uh so those are just a few
examples of ways in which I I I think
America is entitled to say to Canada,
you've not been holding up your end of
the bargain. And that's one of the
reasons why I have been uh urging uh
people on both sides of the border to
think about what I call a grand bargain
between Canada and the United States.
Let's not let's not get caught in the
weeds on the trade relationship. It's
very important. Let's make sure we get
that right. But, you know, there's
border management issues, there's
defense issues, there's national
security issues, uh, you know, drug
trade issues, uh, organized crime
issues, all of which touch on the Canada
US relationship. And we should sit down
with Donald Trump. He's the great
dealmaker. Say to him, Mr. Trump. Uh, we
are prepared to negotiate across this
whole range of issues and to help define
a a a grand bargain that will be in
Canada's interest. We're not here to
sell out Canada's interest, but that you
will be able to sell to Americans as a
great deal that you have negotiated on
their behalf and that is in their
interest. And I think I I think there's
a lot of scope to do that. You know, I'm
just thinking to myself this morning,
Sam Cooper uh has an article talking
about how uh the Canadian authorities
are refusing or did at one point refuse
to cooperate with the DEA around
carfentinyl
uh production. Cleo Pascal on this show
some time ago, a fellow Canadian over at
FDD. She's described Canada as a kind of
a net security detractor for the United
States at the moment, as you alluded to.
And so Canada is essentially deeply
reliant on the US for its security at
the moment. So like like in in my in my
view this is something
that the current administration in the
US wants to get in order for that for
those relationships to make sense. I'm
curious about your thoughts on this.
Yeah. Well, so look, Canada was a
founding member of NATO, the North
American Treaty Organization.
uh the the purpose of NATO was to
protect uh the liberal democracies from
external threats in the post-war world
where you know Germany and France were a
smoking ruin, Britain had been destroyed
by the war effort. uh America was rich
and powerful uh and was willing to put
that wealth and power on the line to
make sure that uh you know the the the
liberal democracies particularly in
Europe could not be bullied and um uh
and taken over by particularly the
Soviet
Union.
Uh now that was a long time ago. NATO
was uh founded I think I'm right in
saying in
49. Uh
and part of Donald Trump's uh whole
approach to the rest of the world is to
say look uh all of our so-called allies
and I'm using his language uh have been
free riding on America's defense effort.
you know, 70 years after the the
founding of NATO, basically they're
still contributing only a fraction to
their collective defense that America is
contributing. Uh, and Canada, uh, one of
those founding members of NATO is one of
the worst lagards. You know, we sign up
for a treaty that in article 5 commits
all the members of the alliance to the
proposition that if a member of the
alliance is invaded by another country,
it will be regarded as an attack on all
of those countries and everyone will
come to the defense of the um of the
country so attacked. Uh, Article 5, by
the way, has only been invoked once, and
that was um uh when America asked its
allies to help them invade Afghanistan
because they had been the um the uh the
launching pad for 9/11. Um back to uh
Canada uh you know NATO several years
ago said look you know we America is
correct that uh uh you know the other
allies are you know not living up to
their obligations and uh we need to fix
this. And so uh NATO made a formal
uh declaration that uh the the target
for all the NATO members uh in terms of
defense spending that all of them were
expected to spend a minimum of 2% of
their GDP. So 2% of their national
wealth generated every year should
should be spent on defense. Canada is
like down around 1.3. We're we're one of
the two or three worst performing
members of the NATO alliance. And in
private meetings, you know, our previous
prime minister, Justin Trudeau, said
explicitly, it's been reported uh in the
media, uh said explicitly to his NATO
partners, we're never going to reach 2%.
Don't don't expect us to do this. you
know, he gives he paid lip service to it
in public, but uh he made it very clear
that u Canada had other things to do
with its money. Uh well, George W. Bush
uh and Barack Obama and Trump won and
Joe Biden, all of them, Democrat,
Republican, doesn't matter. They all
said to the NATO alliance, "You guys
have got to do a better job on defense
spending." Almost everybody else in the
alliance has made some progress. Some
some countries have done really way more
than was asked for and they're mostly
countries close to Russia because
they're frightened to death of Russia.
Poland and the Baltic republics and so
on. Um, and Canada has just stood back
and said, "Sorry, we're, you know, we
have we we have other things we want to
do with that money." Uh, so they wanted
all the benefits of being a member of
the NATO club, but they didn't want to
pay the due. The US needs to protect
Canada from my and from my viewpoint.
Even if there was no NATO, it would it
wouldn't Well, this is a fair point. I
mean, you know, uh, uh, America would
never allow another country to invade
Canada because next stop would be
America, wouldn't it? So, can I can I
just build on that just for a sec? So,
you know, to me, this extensive deep
infiltration of Canada by the Chinese
Communist Party, I think, is part of
this discussion that the US is trying to
to this this negotiation, right? That's
not just about tariffs. I guess that's
what I'm saying. Well, no, no. I
completely agree and and uh while I
personally am skeptical that uh the
current government of Canada will take a
hard line on China, uh I am very hopeful
that that America should I think quite
properly say and by the way, you cannot
be a backdoor of access for the Chinese
to America.
This is a perfectly legitimate thing for
America to ask for. Uh that will be a
tough pill for the uh for the Liberal
Party of Canada to uh to swallow because
they have you know to to a considerable
extent hitched their wagon to uh to
China as a as a rising
power. Uh but I really think for all the
reasons that we've talked about uh
Canada's profound
vulnerability to hostility from America,
China's complete inability to step in
and be for us what America is terms of a
trade partner, security partner, a
defense partner. Well, and and also I
might add, being a totalitarian state
that is actively eradicating entire
groups of its own
people on almost every level, China is a
in my view a poor partner for for Canada
and you know it it wants Canada's
resources but is not the least bit
interested in uh any kind of more
serious uh you know Canadian in
manufacturers or processed uh goods. Um
you know, people complain about our
relationship with the United States
because they think it's all about
natural resources. I don't think that's
correct, but people say it. Uh uh if if
we were to deepen our relationship with
China, I'm here to tell you that China
would only care about us as a storehouse
of natural resources that they would be
able to dominate. So, uh, in in every
way, China is a poor, uh, it in indeed
not just a poor substitute, a a a
completely impossible substitute for our
relationship with the United States. And
if the United States puts it in the
starkkest possible terms, look, you can
either have uh a close relationship with
the United States, which seems to be
something you want and is clearly in
your interest, or whether you want to
have a closer relationship with China
because the two are not compatible. What
do you think about this interest that
the US administration has in Greenland?
Well, this is a very interesting uh
example of I think people
being distracted by Trumpian tactics and
not thinking carefully enough about
Trumpian strategy. You know, Trump makes
a lot of noise about uh annexing
Greenland or buying it from
Denmark. Uh just like he makes a lot of
noise about Canada, the 51st state. What
he is doing in my view is he is
softening up both the Danes and the
Greenlanders
uh for a negotiation over what it is
that Donald Trump really needs from
Greenland. America's had a relationship
with Greenland for years. They've got a,
you know, military bases and all. Uh if
Trump wants more of that, which I
believe he does, um I think Greenland is
perfectly willing to give him that.
Uh what what he's doing is he's
softening them
up with the threat of annexation. Uh
back to this idea that he loves to scare
his negotiating partners before they
ever get to the table. Uh and and so
when he gets to the table and he says,
"Well, actually what I really want is I
want five," I'm just picking numbers out
of there. "I want five military bases in
Greenland. I want you to cut all ties
with China. I want uh Greenland to be uh
you know, sort of an unsinkable aircraft
carrier in a in a critical passage
connecting the Arctic to uh uh the
Atlantic, etc., etc., etc." Uh, and the
Greenlanders will say, "Yes, where do we
sign? I think that's what he's after in
his uh uh in his meanderings about
Greenland." And uh I think he'll get it.
Um, you know, is it necessary for him to
go through all this stuff about, you
know, I'm going to buy Greenland? Um,
this is how Trump does business. I want
to talk before we before we actually
finish a little bit about your book.
Yes. gardeners versus designers. So tell
me about that. Well, you know, I I don't
want to talk about it in the abstract.
Let me let me talk about uh something
quite concrete because, you know, the
idea behind gardeners versus designers
is there's two ways to think about the
world. There's two ways to organize
ourselves as communities that organize
ourselves uh you know to to
to achieve our our our goals. Um, one
way of doing it is is to put the
technocrats in charge. You know, the the
civil servants, the the the people who
have fancy university degrees and who
study things, you know, as a as as a guy
once knew, he said, uh, you're one of
these people who knows everything about
the left side of the titly and nothing
about the right side of the titly. So
you know uh all these people who have
all these fancy degrees and study the
world and know everything about all the
statistical uh representations you can
make of economic activity and so on. So
that that that that's one way of you
know organizing you put those people in
charge and say okay you tell us what to
do because you're the smart people you
know how to organize
things. Um, and a lot of people think
that, you see, there's no alternative to
that.
Uh, but what I was trying to get at in
gardeners versus designers is there's
actually a far better alternative, a far
far more effective one. And let me let
me give you a a concrete
example. Uh, fellow I I I knew um late
professor of uh political
uh thought at university in the UK,
Norman Barry. He said, "Look, there were
two universities in the Midwest in the
United States, founded at about the same
time." And at one of them, you know,
these these kind of designer people, you
know, the the the smart people with
university degrees that I talked about,
uh
they designed the campus so that it
looked beautiful from 30,000 ft. All
these fancy symmetrical pathways and
everything.
The only problem was that these fancy
symmetrical pathways didn't lead
students to the places they needed to
go. And so they were always tramping
across the lawn to get to where they
wanted to go. And and this made ugly
pathways in the in the lawn. And so the
students and the and the administrators
were always fighting over this. Um he
said at the other
university they did something completely
different. They said, "hm, why don't we
find out where people actually want to
go
first and then we'll landscape around
that?" That's exactly what they did.
They they just they didn't bother
landscaping for a couple of years. they
just let people go where they needed to
go, you know, and so
people in their walking around the
campus marked out those pathways that
were most effective in getting them from
the university residence to the
bookstore to their classroom and to the
student union and so on. And then the,
you know, the admin university
administrators came along afterwards and
simply paved
over the pathways that the students had
designed for themselves. They they
didn't need some fancy
uh authority with university degrees and
reams of statistics
uh to tell them what they wanted to do
and how to do it. And so in that
university the the students and the
administration at least on this question
uh coexisted quite happily. You know
believe me social order is necessary for
all of us to succeed. you know, if if
you don't have police and courts and
contracts and all these other things,
you know, you you you won't have
economic success, you won't be able to
own a house and not have it, you know,
vandalized and you won't you won't be
able to have a car because it'll be
stolen. So, you need all of these
things. Absolutely. The question is uh
are we going to be the kind of society
in
which people at the top tell us how to
behave, tell us where to invest our
money, tell us what kind of jobs we
want, tell us what kind of university
degrees we should have, tell us, you
know, what kind of uh cities we want to
live in, etc., etc. Are we going to be
the kind of society in which people make
those decisions for themselves and then
the the role of you know the people in
charge is to come along and say okay how
can we support you in the decisions that
you've made and this is the that's
that's really the essence of this
contrast I'm drawing between gardeners
and designers. I mean it's such a
foundational issue and I think you know
this is this question is really what
I've
been I don't know looking at from all
sorts of different vantage points over
the last you know five six years and you
know co the whole way that we responded
to it as various societies or elements
of society was the kind of the case in
point. Yes. Um I completely agree. I
thought co was the was the the high
watermark of of
designer the the designer approach to
things.
people sort of handed over to these
uh smart people, you know, with their
briefcases and reams of statistics and
so
on. Huge amount of control over their
lives. And I I was quite fascinated to
see how many people were willing to hand
over control of their lives to these
people. And it, don't get me wrong, it's
not that uh it's not that I thought that
uh you know we shouldn't have had public
health experts and we shouldn't have
been debating what the right answer or
how we as a society should organize
ourselves in response to CO. is not that
uh the the the the what what I'm saying
is you know the fact that there were
experts uh doesn't mean that the that
the experiences that the rest of us had
uh and and the knowledge we had about
our own lives and how we could organize
ourselves to carry out our activities
and still protect ourselves with co all
of that was treated as irrelevant and
useless and the only thing that mattered
was these you know high-powered people
with fancy degrees and Um what's what's
interesting is you know we were told
well we must defer to the experts
uh uh in in public health because
otherwise we'll be endangering
everybody. But then
you surely
people realize that well okay but then
all these people in different countries
who supposedly were the great experts
actually recommended different things in
different places and at different times.
at one point, you know, oh, masks are
completely useless. They won't they
won't do anything for you. And then, you
know, a couple of weeks later, oh my
god, everybody's got to wear a mask or
they should be arrested. I
mean, the idea that there was some
obvious expert single answer to what we
should do about CO was completely
disproven by the CO experience. a friend
of mine uh is uh the head of a very
large car parts manufacturer in Canada
and he said you know the thing was we
understood in our particular industry
how to protect our workers from the
danger of catching CO and we could have
still carried on our economic activities
but nobody was interested. Nobody wanted
to go to the trouble of saying to us,
"Okay, show us how you can protect your
workers. We're not going to tell you how
to do it. You show us that you can do it
effectively and we won't interfere with
you. You carry on doing your thing
during CO." But no, we couldn't we
couldn't do that. We couldn't trust
anybody to take the knowledge that was
obvious to us all about the dangers of
CO and how it was transmitted and how
you protected yourself. We couldn't
trust people to organize themselves
intelligently. uh in order to be able to
carry on their activities and protect
themselves from no we all had to be
locked in our
houses for months at a time and
forbidden in some cases you know from
going to the park
uh uh um because you know these these
experts
uh knew everything and we knew nothing
and I I I I hope in
retrospect that people have come to
understand that while expertise has its
place and I'm not in any way saying that
we should ignore experts and that they
have nothing to teach us. I'm saying
that uh uh we must still retain the
ability to apply our own intelligence
and experience to what experts want to
tell us and we are the ones who should
have the final say about how we live our
lives and not the experts.
Um, as we finish up, um, the McDonald
Laurier Institute is probably one of my
favorite think tanks. Um, I've over the
years keep coming across reports coming
out of it. Uh, speakers, I see it on
people's resumes who I'm interested in
and who who I admire. Um, just very
briefly as we actually finish, just tell
me a little bit about it.
Well, you know, I I I had a fancy job
here in Ottawa a few years ago as the uh
what's called the Clifford Clark
visiting economist at uh at the Ministry
of Finance. And it so that that's that
that person is brought in from the
outside as the sort of one man or one
woman in-house economic policy think
tank and and gadfly for the entire
federal government. It's quite an
interesting position. And a after I'd
been in this job for two years and it's
a limited appointment, two years. So I
was about to go home and I said, "Well,
what have I learned from my experience
here?" And I, uh, answer number one, I
learned that Ottawa is in a terrible
mess.
Uh, it, you know, spending out of
control programs that don't achieve
anything. Uh, nobody in charge. Uh, and
I said, "Okay, so but but what can I do
about that?" Uh, and it occurred to me
that Ottawa was the only G7 capital that
didn't have a national think tank in the
capital talking about national policy
issues to national policy makers, the
national media, and the national
electorate. I thought this was a huge
hole in our democratic infrastructure,
and I set out to fill it because I'm a
think tanker. So that that's kind of
shocking given where I come from where
there's a lot of think tanks. Oh, there
the last at last count in Washington
there were 400 think tanks. Uh and and
I'm glad you mentioned Washington
because um uh in setting out to do this,
I was inspired by what I what I call the
full service think tanks in Washington.
You know, there's there's there's a
bunch of very specialized think tanks.
think about healthcare, defense policy,
national security, but there's a there's
a handful of them that try to think
about everything Washington does.
Heritage, Ko, Brookings, Woodro,
Wilson, AEI. Um, and I was inspired by
them uh to try and create something
analogous in Ottawa. And the McDonald
Lori Institute
is that creation. It is a gardener
creation, by the way. Uh it it it it
grew out of uh our experience uh with
uh you know the the problems of the
federal government, what was going on in
other countries. Uh and
um you know we're we just a few weeks
ago celebrated our 15th anniversary. Um
we're the most mentioned think tank in
the Canadian Parliament. Uh we've been
blacklisted by the Kremlin. Uh I think a
dozen of our senior fellows have been
sanctioned by the Kremlin. We've been
denounced by Beijing. Uh the the
ambassador from China here
regularly tells everybody not to pay any
attention to us. Uh which I regard as a
great badge of honor. Um so uh it has
grown
uh enormously in a what I think of as a
relatively short period of time and
become rather a fixture uh not only in
Canada but we've now opened uh our own
uh branch office in Washington to talk
about the Canada US relationship the
center for North American prosperity and
security which is a long ugly name which
gives the fabulous acronym of
Syninnapse. Uh and um
uh I think that this has really proven
uh the the concept that I had at the
very beginning that uh there was this
big hole in Ottawa that needed filling.
Wonderful. Well, uh Brian Lee Crowley,
it's such a pleasure to have had you on.
All the pleasure was mine. Thank you all
for joining Brian Lee Crowley and me on
this episode of American Thought
Leaders. I'm your host, Yana Kellik.