Step into an enchanted forest where fairies meddle in love affairs, nobles chase romance, and a troupe of actors stumbles into chaos. Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream blends humor, fantasy, and romance in one of the Bard’s most beloved plays. Discover why this masterpiece continues to inspire stage, film, and audiences worldwide. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #movies#talk shows #classic films #American traditions #Hollywood#showbiz#theater#cinema#entertainment#celebrity#famous#actors#drama#motion picture
Fill the well with melody
Sing in a sweet lullaby
Fill the well, fill the well
Sing in a sweet lullaby
Fill the well with melody
Sing, sing in a sweet lullaby
Lullaby, lullaby
So goodnight with lullaby
Lullaby
Wake up, Rebecca.
What a dream was here.
A dream?
Have you then slumbered when our work is at hand?
Perchance not.
Perhaps it was not a dream,
but a vision, some enchantment of the woods.
Woods?
But we are not in the woods, sister.
Aye, but I dreamed I walked in the woods,
and fairy folk of all kinds did gamble in the hollows all about me.
To truth, it must have been some enchantment of slumber
that you did fancy these happenings.
Perchance you are right.
Methinks it was only a midsummer night's dream.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
More than 20 years after their release,
the Lord of the Rings trilogy, as made by Peter Jackson,
is still considered one of the best film trilogies ever put to film.
Yes, those films are so beloved,
and I think they inspired a lot of other filmmakers
to make these really epic movies.
It's kind of funny because if you look at the attention span
of modern people, I would say the attention span
has gotten significantly less.
Yet there are a lot more really long modern films
than classic films.
Most classic films are under two hours.
That's a good point.
Now, although these movies are really beloved,
I've always felt that what they're missing
is the classic beauty
and that almost antique quality
of the books by Tolkien.
So I've often wondered what a classic film
from the golden era of Hollywood
would have been like based on Lord of the Rings.
I think it would be a lot like A Midsummer Night's Dream from 1935.
This movie is very unique
because it's one of the only classic Hollywood films
based on a Shakespeare play.
And it's also one of the only classic American films
that's a fantasy film,
so you're not going to find many other movies like it.
This is a Warner Brothers film
produced by Henry Blank and Hal B. Wallace.
It was directed by Max Reinhart and William Dieterle
If you know the plot of A Midsummer Night's Dream,
this follows it very closely.
But the basic idea is that a young Athenian maid, Hermia,
is very much in love with a young Athenian gentleman, Lysander.
But her father refuses to let them marry
because he prefers for her to marry Demetrius.
Since they have no other choice,
they escape to the woods so that they can get married.
But little do they know
that the woods that night are full of fairies
reveling and dancing,
led by Queen Titania, the queen of the fairies,
and her king, Oberon.
The fairies play some tricks
on the four young Athenian lovers
who wander into the woods,
including Hermia and Lysander,
as well as Demetrius, who is pursuing Hermia,
and Helena, who is pursuing Demetrius,
as well as the mischievous Puck,
a half-man, half-goat boy
who uses some love potions
to cause a lot of mischief among the Athenians
and even with Queen Titania.
Meanwhile, a band of actors have wandered into the woods
to rehearse a performance of Pyramus and Thisbe,
which they plan to perform at the king's wedding in a few days.
A lot of confusions ensue there
when one of the actors, Bottom the Weaver,
is given a spell which makes him have the head of a donkey.
There's a lot of misunderstandings
and hilarious errors that occur
during the midsummer night and its dream.
You mentioned that this film is notable
for being one of the only classic Hollywood adaptations
of a Shakespeare work.
That's true.
And it's not only based on it,
but it features all the Shakespearean text.
Yes, it does.
It's spoken in iambic pentameter,
and although there are very few, if any, British actors in it,
there's one or two,
they really all have very good diction, I think,
in the way they speak.
They speak with a sort of British-esque accent,
if not a complete British accent,
but they really stay true
to the Shakespearean roots of the piece,
and I think they really do it justice.
It's interesting to consider how this work came to the screen
because it really was quite an unusual production.
Of course, I think it was part of a movement
which took place in the mid-30s,
particularly at Warner Brothers,
to return to classical arts and classicism.
And this is very much because of the Motion Picture Production Code.
In 1934, it was not adopted
because it had technically been in place since 1930,
but it was taken more seriously
with the formation of the Production Code Administration.
And before that, Warner Brothers was noted
for being the worst studio
in terms of making really violent gangster films
and just really controversial.
Usually very modern pieces, right?
Very modern, controversial, dirty, violent, what have you.
And so to show that they were taking a whole new step,
they really started making these classic films
such as the swashbuckling pictures and this.
It's like, let's turn to the classics.
Let's make Shakespeare.
Right.
But this particular production,
the idea to put it on came from Hal B. Wallace, the producer,
because he saw a production of it at the Hollywood Bowl in 1934.
Right.
And Olivia de Havilland was playing Hermia in that production,
is that correct?
Yes, and Mickey Rooney was playing Puck.
They were the only actors from that production
which ended up being in the movie.
But it was directed by Max Reinhardt,
the great Austrian director
who is considered one of the best stage directors.
Is it true that this was his only American film?
Yes, it was.
Wow.
He didn't even speak English at the time.
He was in America because he was a refugee
from the Nazis in Europe since he was Jewish.
He was very artistic in his style.
He loved using a lot of music and dance in his stage productions.
The production was so extravagant,
they had to disassemble the shell
and bring in all this grass and trees.
It was crazy.
There were 500 people on stage.
So elaborate.
And that kind of grandeur was very impressive
to Hollywood people like Hal B. Wallace.
Now, Jack Warner was not too keen on the idea
because the last Shakespeare work he tried to make,
The Taming of the Shrew in 1929, was a big flop.
So he was like, let's not do Shakespeare.
Was that a silent?
Yes.
Well, that's the problem.
You can't do Shakespeare in a silent film.
Especially a work like Midsummer Night's Dream.
So they were willing to take the chance,
and it was considered one of those pieces
which is to gain favor and to advance the studio's prestige
even more than making money.
But there are conflicting reports on whether it made money.
Really?
Yeah, the International Movie Database said it did turn a profit,
whereas some other sources I've read said that it did not make a profit.
It was a financial failure.
Interesting. Nobody knows.
No one's really sure.
It's a Midsummer Night's mystery.
It definitely was an artistic success.
And because of Max Reinhardt and his great artistic
but not necessarily practical style,
William Dieterle was his assistant and the assistant director.
And he translated for him, right?
Yes, he did.
Because he also was a German speaker and a refugee from Europe.
There were so many qualities which you could use in a movie
that you couldn't use on stage, like cinematography.
There's a lot of use of filters, I noticed.
Yes, there is.
The sparkly filter on the camera eyes.
I don't know if that would be a lens or if that was done in post-production.
It looks like a lens to me, but it's a filter.
I don't personally know the answer to that.
And then effects, I understand, with the trees,
having spider webs over them with the sparkles and make everything glitter.
And they even painted the trees orange
because it gave them a glow in black and orange.
Yes, they used orange aluminum paint
because the director was complaining that it was too hard to see the trees.
That's really interesting.
It was too dark in the black and white film.
I can see that would be a problem in black and white.
So they thinned out the trees and did all those effects.
And those effects were done by Hal Moore, who was the cinematographer,
but he was not the original cinematographer.
The first cinematographer was fired because they didn't like what he did.
And so Hal Moore ended up reshooting everything that he did.
Wow, that must have cost a lot of money.
Yes.
And because he did such a great job,
he was not on any of the ballots for the Academy Awards
since he wasn't the original cinematographer.
But so many people knew that he had done a great job,
that he was a write-in.
They wrote his name, and he ended up winning Best Cinematographer.
That's amazing.
And he was the only person to win on the write-in.
And after that, they made a rule that there would be no write-ins
because it was too messy.
But he won, and as did Best Film Editing,
making it the first movie to win for both Best Film Editing
and Best Cinematography.
I can see why.
It's so unique.
If you really love classic movies,
or if you haven't really seen any classic movies,
either way, I think this film will surprise you.
It's just sort of in a category all its own.
I guess I say that about a lot of movies.
But there's just something so unique about this film.
And speaking about how the Lord of the Rings movies,
people always say it holds up so well after 20 years.
Let's take a look at how well this holds up after 90 years.
Exactly 90 years now.
The special effects are just wild,
especially right when the fairies first appear.
Because before that, it's real.
It's in ancient Greece.
It's real, beautiful sets, gorgeous costumes.
You can see money all over it, in a good way.
But it's an opulent court piece.
Right.
But then the whole mood changes.
They start out with some beautiful establishing shots of nature.
Real nature.
Real animals.
You don't always see that in old movies.
Frogs of really beautiful nature.
And then starting off with little Mickey Rooney,
this puck kind of rising up out of the leaves.
And then all the fairies appearing.
The shot of the first time you see Titania and sort of Glen.
And then there's this giant tree.
It has this sort of cloudy, not a staircase.
It's more like a circular ramp all the way around it.
And the fairies go dancing up.
It's double exposure.
Yes.
All of it.
But it's just gorgeous.
And what I love about the technology of double exposure
is that it sometimes can create this almost unintentional, I think,
kind of a see-through effect.
Yes.
And I think that's so perfect for fairies,
because they're not quite corporeal.
And especially in that first moment when they're first appearing,
before they've really taken shape fully.
That's true.
And whether it was a financial success or not,
it definitely was well regarded by many critics,
although some had some criticism.
And it was nominated for Best Picture.
Was there a main criticism that a lot of people had of it?
The main criticism was the Hollywoodization
or the Americanization of it.
As we mentioned, there were very few British actors in this.
And some people found it kind of comical
to have these very American actors doing it.
But definitely the person who got the most criticism
was Dick Powell as Lysander.
He himself did not think he was right on the part
and asked to be taken off the production.
It's kind of a tough one.
I feel like if you know who Dick Powell is,
it's kind of, wait, really?
Dick Powell's doing Shakespeare?
He was such a song and dance fellow at the time.
I don't know who Dick Powell is.
He does the job.
I don't have any issue with his performance.
Maybe it's a little silly, but I think it's supposed to be.
All the Athenians are more on the comical side.
Yes.
I think the two men especially,
Demetrius and Lysander, are kind of comedic
and I think the girls maybe play it a little straighter.
Especially Olivia de Havilland.
She's so lovely in this part.
And this is interesting because it was her film debut
since she had been in the Hollywood Bowl production.
Technically, two other movies she made after this
were released first,
but this was the first Hollywood film she made
and it was the beginning of a very long
and successful career for her.
I think the actor who's actually the most funny,
if you will, when you know who he is to be in this,
is James Cagney.
100%.
He was a gangster actor.
Yeah, talking about Warner Brothers films,
a lot of the most famous early ones were...
Public Enemy, later in the Roaring Twenties.
James Cagney, or White Heat even later.
He had a noticeable New York accent,
which he kind of tried to turn into a British accent here.
He did a good job, but people thought he was great.
And he is great.
His performance...
The two standout performances in this for me
are James Cagney and Mickey Rooney.
There's a lot of crazy redhead energy in this movie.
They are both just so committed
and so fully thrown into the role to the point
it's just off the wall.
But it's great, especially to really, really see
someone playing against type in James Cagney's case.
But even though it's not really what you would call
a musical in the traditional sense,
he does, I would say, the most singing
and even does a little dancing.
And he was a song and dance performer,
but he didn't get to show that off in movies that often.
So it's nice he gets to here.
He really gets to show so much range in this movie.
He kind of gets to show everything he can do.
And seeing this really intensely comedic side of him
is amazing.
But he's so serious about it.
That's what makes it so funny.
Yeah.
That's the difference between him and Dick Powell.
Yes.
Dick Powell's kind of mugging.
He's kind of trying to be funny.
He always...
I mean, he's always like that.
That's just kind of his personality.
But yeah, James Cagney is really creating
a very different persona for himself.
And then little 13-year-old McInerney
is just a bundle of energy the whole time
and just like screaming, laughing.
There are so many wild noises made by human voices
in this movie.
You just won't believe it.
There is a lot of laughing, screaming, crying,
animal noises.
And an interesting behind-the-scenes bit of trivia
about that is that McInerney actually broke his leg
part of the way through filming.
So some of the time it's a double.
If you're looking for it, you can see.
I think his double's a little taller than he is.
Yeah, his double was George Braxton,
who was in several other movies with him.
He was in several of the Andy Hardy movies.
Oh, okay.
And they kind of wheeled him around
on some sort of a bicycle behind the bushes,
I understand.
But it's really done well.
They worked around that so well.
And Jack Warner was very angry about that.
But it's the difficulties of a production.
Those are the breaks.
No pun intended.
But it really isn't that noticeable.
If you don't know that, if you're not looking for it,
whenever there's close-ups and it's always his voice,
he's fully dominating the role,
even if he couldn't do all the physicality.
I love the musical and artistic content
which is in this movie.
It has a fabulous score by Felix Mendelssohn
because he wrote his Midsummer Night's Dream.
And that was used as music in the stage production,
so it was also used here.
But that wasn't long enough for this whole movie.
That's right.
It's a very long movie.
Over two hours.
Quite unusual for the time.
Yes, two hours and 13 minutes.
So they hired Erich Wolfgang Korngold,
who was a great German composer in his own right,
to arrange the music and to make a full score,
rather than just playing the same themes over and over again.
And to do that, he had to reorchestrate several sections
to make them sound different,
include other pieces by Mendelssohn,
and even write a few bridges himself.
But he didn't want to take any screen credit as a composer,
simply as an arranger,
because he thought that Mendelssohn should get the credit
for being the composer here.
Shows a lot of artistic integrity.
And had he written any film scores?
No, he hadn't.
This was his first work in Hollywood,
and then he would go back to Germany
before coming back to America in 1938
to, again, escape the Nazis
and to write The Adventures of Robin Hood,
after which he stayed in the United States
and wrote a lot of film scores for Warner Brothers.
So this was his introduction to filmmaking.
Right.
That music throughout, it's beautiful strings
and the different horn players,
but it's not just background music.
It's part of the story,
because several times there are these hilarious little...
I don't know what you could even call them.
They're like little elves, little gnomes, little gremlins.
Because they're obviously dwarves, midgets of some kind,
but wearing these really amazing masks with funny ears
so they don't look human.
And they're playing these odd little instruments.
I can't even think of what to compare this to.
It's similar to, like, a Disney cartoon.
But these are real people.
They're not animated.
They are, in fact, people.
I love that detail.
There isn't anything animated.
It's all real people.
They just use special effects.
I think there might be a couple of puppets somewhere in there.
But usually they're people.
So it isn't like with the Disney films,
late 60s, where it's partial animation.
It's all real people, and they're flying.
Presumably they were on cables at the same time.
There is some impressive flying in this movie,
and I didn't see any cables on it.
I don't know if they could erase it.
Maybe.
I don't know if they had the technology to do that.
They had the capability to erase things.
It was just a lot harder.
It was very hard because they would have had to
hand do it on every frame.
But they could.
And it's a very...
High qualities are available of this film,
so you can see all the details
that could perhaps give away the special effects,
but they don't.
The cinematography is also notable
for using a lot of extreme close-ups.
Yeah.
You saw that sometimes in classic films,
but not as...
It wasn't as popular then.
Strange observation.
I think you see it more in Warner Brothers films.
I guess every studio has a style,
even more so than the studio system was so strong
at the time.
Yes, probably the two strongest styles
were MGM and Warner Brothers.
Definitely.
And this really showcases Warner talent.
And I think you can kind of tell
when it's a foreign director,
not like a regular American movie director.
The German impressionism, you see that.
Right.
And it being artistic doesn't necessarily mean
it's European.
Americans had a lot of appreciation for...
But the way it's a lot art for art's sake.
Yes.
I think you see that slower European piece.
And in addition to all the beautiful music,
there's also some lovely vocal music.
Yes, there is.
Voices, the fairy chorus, you hear them.
And solo singing.
And notably, some very beautiful dancing.
There's a lovely lead dancer.
And the choreography was done by Nijinska,
who was the sister of the famous ballet dancer
Václav Nijinsky.
And Busby Berkeley, another notable film choreographer,
came to the set to watch her work,
but apparently he behaved disruptively
and she asked to have him barred from the set,
which is kind of a funny story.
No more details on that one.
Well, she was from the Ballets Russes.
It's amazing seeing ballet from this time period
because the style is so different from modern ballet.
And while it's not really strict ballet
because they're not on point,
it's a bit more lyrical, I'd say.
But the style, she uses so much of the arms,
especially with the lead dancer.
Her exit is so dramatic.
She's kind of draped over the fellow's shoulder
and you just see her hands disappearing into the night.
It's just gorgeous.
And even Anita Louise sings very nicely,
Queen Titania, to sing the fairy lullaby,
which is from the Shakespeare play.
So is that her voice?
It's hard to tell.
There really isn't information available
whether it is or not.
It sounds like her voice, but you never know.
If it is, she's very good.
An important part of the look of this film
is, of course, the costumes.
An interesting blend of styles here
because, as was typical in Shakespeare's day,
court costumes of the era, the Elizabethan era,
are the basic look,
but with some ancient Greek touches.
So for all the mortals,
you have a blend of Elizabethan British
and ancient Greece
because they have the panniers
and the, you know, sometimes even the hairdos,
but with some touches like
armored breastplates for the men
and some use of togas
although some of the men are in tights and ruffs
and different hair styling.
But in the woods,
the fairies really divert from either style
and have more of an ancient mythology look,
drawing on old paintings,
but with a bit of 1930s chorus girl thrown in,
especially the dancers.
The use of...
Because classically, I think these characters
would be in white gowns,
like a white empire bodice
or a flowing sheath dress.
But instead, Titania has like a sparkly silver dress
that's made out of really nothing
but not quite even sequins.
It's more like...
It's almost like fringe.
It's sort of like tinsel.
It's like sparkly kind of fringe
and then I think some kind of a white bodice under it.
And that's sort of the look for all the...
sort of the fairy core, if you call it that.
For all of them,
they have that very distinct look.
It's really unlike a style I have seen anywhere else.
Maybe a bit reminiscent
to the early Ziegfeld follies.
And the male fairies are wearing
sort of like bodysuits with bat wings.
Yeah, they're basically dressed like ballet dancers.
My outfit is inspired by the first costume
worn by Hermia.
She goes into the woods with Lysander.
It is the classic Elizabethan pannier style
with the cinched waist,
beautiful pearl jewelry to match
and shoes of the era as well.
My dress is inspired by Titania's costume.
Long, flowing and ethereal
with lots of sparkly beads.
She has a little white wreath of flowers on her head
and her very long hair is down and flowing.
Speaking of costumes,
it's interesting to note
what were the challenges of doing this work,
a Shakespeare work.
Shakespeare, although you'd think,
oh, it's a classic,
so that's going to mean it's somehow...
it's decent compared to modern times.
Shakespeare was known for having a lot of innuendos
and sometimes very bawdy humor.
So great care had to be taken
in creating a work of this kind
as well as some potentially difficult subjects
such as the fact that the actors
are putting on the play Pyramus and Thisbe
and at the time it was traditional
for men to play all the roles.
Right.
And so Joey Brown's character
is dressed up like a woman
and they had to make it strictly comical
and not inappropriate in any way
or too vulgar.
I heard the interesting story
that he accepted the role of Flute,
as the character's named,
without knowing that he would have to
dress in drag for it
and he was very uncomfortable with that
so they kind of played on that
for his performance.
Like, great, your character's
supposed to be uncomfortable too.
I think...
I don't know how accurate this is
to the text if they changed it all,
but a scene when they decide
to rest for the night,
Lysander and Hermia,
and he wants to be beside her
and she says,
lie farther off, dear.
Yes.
It's very beautiful,
showing she's a very innocent maiden
but spoken very beautifully
and affectionately.
And the other thing that would be
a great temptation
to be controversial in a work of this sort
would be costumes.
Right.
With the typical Shakespearean
you could have perhaps
low necklines,
but now we've got ancient Greece,
we've got a bunch of fairies
running around in the woods
and like you said,
the costumes are reminiscent
of the Ziegfeld Follies
which were next to nude
a lot of times.
So they did a great job
of using the sheath,
the tinsel,
over bodysuits
and to really create
that it's a very
neutral look,
I'd say.
It's very innocent,
very childlike.
Yes.
You know what I mean?
Yeah, the Ziegfeld Follies
would be the tinsel
and then nothing under it.
Right, but they have
lots of bodysuits
so there's not much skin showing.
And it's not in a distracting way either.
Like, oh look, that's lined.
It's just something about,
I don't know if it's thicker
than it looks
or it just really is
done nicely so it doesn't
look provocative at all.
Yeah, because they don't
seem like provocative women.
They seem really like fairies.
They're not human.
Very elfin.
They did a great job
of capturing that
magical pixie quality
and not making it
a bunch of fairies
running around naked in the woods
like a lot of paintings
will depict.
Absolutely.
So it's a great example
of right here at the beginning
of the code
when they were just figuring out
how to do it,
doing an excellent job
with some very difficult
subject matter.
Yes.
And the result is
an extremely entertaining,
artistic, and unique film.
You're not going to see
many things like this.
We've been talking
quite a bit about
Lord of the Rings
and how it compares to this
and I think
if you really like
Lord of the Rings
or Game of Thrones
or any other
one of the fantasy stories,
or if you're a real
Shakespeare fan,
I think you would really,
really enjoy this movie
because it's so artistic
and sort of lofty
in the way it was made
that I don't,
I think it sort of defies
being locked into an era.
That's right.
Even though it isn't
black and white,
the visuals are so amazing
and they're not at all
hindered by the lack of color.
That's a good point.
And what always makes
a film easier to enjoy
is if it's in a clear copy.
And there are many
beautiful copies
available of this film.
You can rent or purchase it
on Amazon Prime Video,
on YouTube,
and many other
streaming services.
You can also buy it
on DVD,
where it's been
beautifully remastered.
You can find it
either on Amazon
or Barnes & Noble.
As we discussed,
with the advent of the code,
Hollywood,
and Warner Brothers
in particular,
really tried to go back
to a classic style.
One of the ways
they did this
was by making
swashbuckling films
featuring damsels
in distress
and sword fights.
Join us next time
as we recommend
our pick for your
first classic
swashbuckling film.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.