Preston Manning: Mark Carney will be Canada’s LAST Prime Minister

Canada Prime Ministers
27 followers
48 Video Views·May 13, 2025
On today’s episode of the Candice Malcolm Show, Candice interviews former Leader of the Opposition Preston Manning on the issue of Western Independence.
Preston Manning made it clear that the biggest threat to Canada is not President Trump, it’s Western dissatisfaction with Canada.
Hi, I'm Candace Malcolm and this is the Candace Malcolm Show.
I hope everyone had a wonderful weekend and to all of the mothers out there,
happy Mother's Day. I hope you were spoiled.
And I hope you had a wonderful time. Of course,
I'm a mother of four small children and my kids absolutely love Mother's Day.
They've been making Mother's Day cards for like a month.
And as soon as Mother's Day was over, as soon as they gave me the cards,
they started immediately on making their Father's Day cards.
So it was all very fun and very cute.
I want to give a quick shout out though to my own mother,
because so much of the reason that my life is the way it is and the way that I
am able to have four kids and also run a business and be a journalist and have a
podcast is because my mom actually lives with us and she does so much.
So having a,
basically a stay at home grandmother is like the best gift that we could give to
our children. And she's actually out on her own adventure right now.
She's not here. She is in Spain.
So her and her sister have decided to go off on sort of the adventure of a
lifetime. They're doing the Way of St.
James, or as it's called in Spanish, the Camino de Santiago,
where they're basically walking across Spain,
doing an 800 kilometer pilgrimage from Balboa.
They flew into Madrid and then up to Alboa,
and then they are walking across the country, a 30 day trek,
and they're really having the adventure of lifetime.
So I'm so proud of my mom for going and doing this with her sister,
having this time for herself, for her health and her faith and everything like
that. And we really miss you and we can't wait for you to come home, grandma.
Okay. Now to get to the news today, I am very pleased.
This is an interview I've been trying to set up for some time because this
person is so relevant to the conversation that we are having in Canada.
Right now I'm talking about Preston Manning.
Preston is the founder and the leader of the Reform Party.
He led that party from 1987 to 2000,
and he was the leader of the official opposition 1997 to
2000 and always just a voice of wisdom in these troublesome times,
especially talking about the pathway towards independence or the question of
independence for Western Canada and for Alberta. So Preston, welcome to the show.
Thank you so much for joining us today.
Well, thanks for having me. That was a good reference to Mother's Day too.
That's a, that's a very important point to make.
Well, thank you. Thank you. Okay. So I haven't spoken to you in a while.
We had you on the show a few months ago and we were talking a little bit about
this issue, but obviously it's really flared up. So first of all,
why don't you just tell me what your reaction to the recent election was?
Were you surprised to see the Liberals get reelected?
And what do you make of Mark Kearney as the prime minister?
Well, the election shifted from the expectation was that Mr.
Trudeau was going to be the prime minister and the liberal leader.
And the official opposition was well tuned up to deal with
all the inadequacies of the nine years of Trudeau reign.
But of course, when that changed and President Trump intervening himself
in our election and Mr. Kearney becoming the quickly
becoming the leader of the Liberals, the whole scene changed.
And the I'm disappointed with the election results because like a lot of
Canadians, particularly in Western Canada,
we wanted a change in administration, just a complete change.
And the fact that that didn't happen has led to a lot of unrest and
discouragement with the results of the election.
Well, you had a really interesting op-ed in the Globe and Mail back on April 2nd,
the headline that they gave it.
I don't know if you wrote this or if that's just what the editor put,
but Mark Kearney poses a threat to national unity.
And so you write that politicians, the media voters in central Canada,
whether they realize or not,
the greatest threat to national unity is emerging not from Quebec,
but on the Western front, again,
revealed by recent Polaris survey on account of mismanagement of national
affairs by the Liberal government and its consistent failure to address those
issues of greatest concern to Western Canadians.
Large numbers of Westerners simply will not stand for another four years of
Liberal government, no matter who leads it.
So I'm wondering what compelled you to write this op-ed in the Globe and Mail.
And what do you make of the sort of, I mean, it went, you know,
it was really noticed by the elites in central Canada.
Many of them didn't like it at all.
And what did you make of the backlash to this piece?
Well, I, I, I'm glad that the Globe managed to print it.
It's not in line really with the Globe's own editorial policy,
but I think it's a message that voters and elites in central Canada
need to hear that there's enormous unrest in the West and
dissatisfaction with the way the federations manage,
particularly the intrusion of the federal government in the natural
resources sector, which are so fundamental, not just to the Western economy,
but to the entire economy. There's no pipelines bill.
There's bans on making it difficult for energy to get to
seaboard. That, that, that unrest is just building and building. And,
and there's an indifference to it in, in central Canada.
They think this is just some kind of regional whining.
And I think it's a lot more serious than that.
The central Canadian media often always seem to think this is
just an Alberta phenomena. And the polling shows,
this is much broader than Alberta. It's just as strong.
This feeling of unrest is just as strong in Saskatchewan,
in rural parts of Manitoba and in Eastern,
Central and Northern British Columbia.
So I wrote that to try to get the voters in central Canada and the Atlantic
Canada to realize that if you reelect a Liberal government and you have the
population to do it,
you're going to see an increase in this Western unrest rather than a
decrease in it. It'll be interesting to see the polls,
if polling is being done as to the post election to see if that Western
sentiment increased or stayed the same or decreased as a result of the election.
I expect it will have increased.
Well, there has been some polling and I'll get to that in a minute,
but I just wanted to highlight a few more pieces from your op-ed and just get
you to reply. I mean, first of all, that line there,
that no matter who leads the Liberal party,
a large number of Westerners will simply not stand for another four years.
You also write to voters, particularly in Central Atlantic Canada,
you need to recognize that a vote for the Kearney Liberals is a vote for Western
secession, a vote to break up Canada as we know it.
And then you finish a piece by saying the next prime minister of Canada,
if it remains,
Mark Kearney would be identified in the history books tragically and needlessly
as the last prime minister of a united Canada.
And so I'm just wondering if you could elaborate on that.
Do you really think that Western Canada is at the point where it won't last
another four years,
it won't stand for it and that that is perhaps how Mark Kearney will go down?
I think it's the combination.
The Quebec secession sentiment is there as well.
It looks like the party Quebecois is destined to form the next government in
Quebec.
The first plank in their platform is to hold another referendum on the secession
issue. So you're going to have that continued problem,
probably increased on the Eastern front.
And then you combine that with this unrest in Western Canada,
dissatisfaction with the way the Federation is working.
Those are two forces that if they start operating at the same time have the
potential to blow the country apart.
And what's most worrisome in Western Canada is the utter indifference of the
central Canadian elites and media to this phenomenon and even the misreporting
on it. They keep thinking it's just an Alberta phenomenon.
It's polling shows it's broader than Alberta.
They also think that the only thing that's being talked about is secessions,
the separation. That's not the only thing that's been talked about.
The other thing that's being talked about is how could the Federation,
the federal government react in such a way as to diminish that unrest.
That's just as much on the table.
It's been advocated by Premier Smith and Premier Mo of Saskatchewan.
So there's other options besides separation, but it's not all Alberta.
There's other options other than secession,
but central Canada and the elites better pay attention to it.
It's got the potential to wreck the Federation.
Well, you say that central elites might be indifferent to it. In some ways,
it seems like they're deliberately hostile.
I'll point to this Toronto Star article op-ed.
It wasn't even an op-ed, Preston,
because it was written by someone who writes for the paper, a business columnist.
And the title is,
is it time for Alberta to go alone and break from Canada?
And the sort of way that the Toronto Star was promoting this was let them go.
Yes, it's time for Alberta to go, let them go.
As in like there's some kind of a burden to the rest of Canada.
Reading that as an Albertan,
what goes through your head when you see that kind of thing?
Well, that's typical of the Toronto Star. In fact,
if you wanted to fan the flames of secession in Western
Canada,
the best way to do it would be to give every Westerner a subscription to the
Toronto Star. Because A, the indifference,
B, the hostility,
and C, the ignorance of the role that
the Western provinces, particularly Alberta, play in the Federation.
The revenue that is generated for the national government,
the proportion of GDP that is generated,
particularly by the petroleum industry,
that just indicates a complete ignorance of the relevance of that
fact and its relevance to even to central Canada.
Well, it is something that I think a lot of Albertans know is how much Alberta
contributes to the rest of the country above and beyond what it gets back in
services. I don't know that that's common knowledge to folks in Ontario and
Quebec, although it should be.
I'm curious to hear your thoughts Preston on how Premier Daniel Smith has sort
of responded. So the day after the election,
April 30th,
she came out and announced changes to the Citizens Initiative Act,
which basically lowers the threshold by which a referendum can be prompted
through a sort of a democratic process where signatures
requirement went from 20% of all voters down to 10% of all voters and the
threshold timeline was increased.
And then last week Premier Smith came out and announced what she calls the
Alberta Accord,
which is a plan to basically guarantee more pipelines for the future.
She made four major demands,
including a corridor to get Alberta energy and
oil to tide water in the Pacific Arctic and Atlantic.
She said that they wanted the feds to stop interfering with the development of
natural resources, including getting rid of the no new pipelines law,
Bill C-69, as well as the oil tanker ban.
They also demanded that the government refrain from imposing export tax or any
restrictions on Alberta's natural resources. And finally,
basically an end to equalization,
that they wanted to create a new formula whereby big,
wealthy provinces like Quebec, Ontario and British Columbia,
no longer get the transfers from Alberta.
So what do you make of Premier Smith's actions and sort of what she's
laying out on the table here?
Well, I think it's a responsible approach.
I think it's supported by a large number of Albertans.
And the approach she is basically taking says that there's a list of
conditions that have to be met by the federal government and the federal
parliament for the West to remain content within the federation.
And she spells them out. Premier Mo has done the same thing.
And I think her list is correct.
It's very much based on this fundamental fact that apparently a large numbers of
people in Canada don't get that the biggest economic strength of this country
is its natural resources. Canada is the largest country,
second largest country in the world by land mass,
which means you have the second largest or maybe the largest stock of natural
resources, agriculture, energy, mining, forestry, and the fishery.
And the fact that under the Trudeau administration,
those sectors were treated as relics from the past and environmentally
detrimental liabilities.
But when those are the building blocks of the Canadian economy and what she's
doing is asserting there's certain things that have to be done to remove the
obstructions to the development of those sectors by the federal government.
And that's not just in Alberta's interest, that's in the national interest.
And the ball is now in the federal government's court and people are going to
watch the throne speech, not just the speech.
There's been talk, talk, talk about all this for a long time.
They're going to watch whether there's any action on the part of the federal
government to address those things on her list.
And in terms of the referendum, of course, Alberta, again,
Western Canada tends to favor more democratic
mechanisms, referendum, citizens initiatives,
freer votes in the legislatures and the parliament.
And this is quite in accordance with that tradition.
And basically the referendum gives people a chance who want a particular
position to be adopted by the governments to have to have a
referendum to see how much support there is for it.
Well, you mentioned earlier about having popular support and you'd be curious to
see what the polling numbers show.
Well, last week we did get some polls.
So according to a new poll released by City News, 36 percent of Albertans
and a majority of UCP voters want to leave Canada.
An Angus Reid poll also found that roughly half the people in both,
to your point, Alberta and Saskatchewan would be interested in
independence. And so I'm wondering, though, like, I mean,
Canada's constitution does allow for provinces to separate.
If there's a popular will, there's a formula.
Do you think that there really is that type of sentiment enough to push this over?
Well, I think the sentiment is out there.
What those polls don't mention, there are other options besides separation,
like what the premier is offering.
There are several others.
And I'm involved with a group that wants to put on what we're calling a
Canada West Assembly, where you would get a bunch of representative
people from the four provinces, almost like a legislature, and then have these
major propositions for what should the West do put in front of that
and subject to cross-examination and debate and everything else.
And one of the options certainly would be the secession option.
But again, secession to do what? To form an independent country?
Maybe that's one option.
Secession to form an independent country that would end up in some kind of union
with the United States. That's another option.
All of those should be put on the table.
Too much of this is done in the back rooms and the small
groups working on it.
Don't get it out in front of a democratic forum and have those options looked at.
And then take some votes as to which ones would be best to recommend to the
provincial governments.
One of those is the secession one.
It's not nearly as simple as people think it is.
You could hold one of those referendums.
Quebec is further along this road than the West is.
But suppose you have to have, according to the Clarity Act, you have to have
a clear question and a clear majority on it.
So let's suppose, let's take Quebec, it could be the West.
You have a question, should Quebec secede from the Canadian Federation and form a
new country? Clear question.
And then you've got to get a clear majority.
And there's a big argument, what's a clear majority?
But it's probably 60 percent plus.
But suppose you get it.
Suppose you get that.
So what's going to happen then?
Is that entity going to secede automatically and get out of the Federation?
No, no.
What that'll trigger is a big federal-provincial constitutional conference
triggered by a crisis and focused on that particular problem.
But that's all that that triggers.
And then you're basically going to have a debate about whether you can
reconfederation.
And that would happen whether Quebec does it or whether Alberta does it.
It's not simple.
And a lot of these people that are advocating that just think it's that simple.
That idea should get in front of some people that know what it's all about.
And not antagonistic to it, but just say, here, you should understand
constitutional law.
And it's not as simple as you make it.
Right. And so, I mean, just to go back to your op-ed in the Globe and Mail, you
predicted that Carney, if he's re-elected, might be identified, you said, would
then be identified in the history books as the last prime minister of a united
Canada. So presumably you do foresee something like this happening in the next
four years.
Well, no, if the federal government responded to some of this, then some
of this could be averted.
But there's a real skepticism in the West.
I mean, Mr. Carney's done a 180 degree turn on, he used to be a
total champion of climate change.
Now that's been put in the background.
The Liberal Party was opposed to hydrocarbon energy development, opposed
to pipelines, etc.
And now he professes to be in favour of these things.
Standing behind him at present, and he's going to maybe change this tomorrow, was
a cabinet of 23 people who just three months before were saying exactly the
opposite of what he's been saying.
So you can forgive Westerners for being pretty sceptical.
And they'll be sceptical about the throne speech, too.
More words, more words, probably words that try to address it.
Where's the action?
And that's what the premiers are watching.
One of the things that relates to this is, if I was in the federal
government's shoes and wanted to send a signal to the provinces to try to
reduce this federal-provincial conflict, which virtually exists with every
provincial government, I would introduce an act respecting provincial
jurisdiction. And what that act would do is amend the major statutes, the
federal statutes, that authorize intervention in areas of provincial
jurisdiction, like the Canada Health Act.
Health is a provincial responsibility, but the federal government intervenes
under the Canada Health Act.
Natural resources development, the Constitution is perfectly clear that this
is in provincial jurisdiction.
But the federal government passes legislation that directly interferes with
it. The Impact Assessment Act, the No Pipelines Act, there's half a dozen of
them. And then municipal government, the Constitution is perfectly clear.
Municipal government and municipalities is a provincial responsibility.
The federal government intervenes through the Canada Housing Act and through the
Canada Mortgage Bank Act, where the mortgage bank makes big loans to
municipalities without even talking to the provincial government.
And then the Constitution also says property and civil rights is a provincial
responsibility. The federal government intervened in that area through the
Emergency Act and the Courts Even Act mentioned that some of that intervention
was unconstitutional.
So if the federal government passes statutes like that, pulling back out of
those areas by amending the statutes and give it the power to do that, that would
be a pretty clear signal to the provinces that the federal government
understands the basis of unrest.
But more speeches, more press conferences saying we're going to do something,
et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
I don't think that it's going to take some action to remove the skepticism on
that, on those points.
Well, I think it's granted.
I mean, just the recent election that we just fought, I mean, this issue was
basically never raised.
I don't think I heard anyone put the question to Mark Carney.
The focus of the campaign was almost entirely on our relationship with the
United States, on President Donald Trump, potential tariffs.
If anything, we had two federal debates.
One of them was in French, where the entire debate was basically focused on
Quebec and how to appease them and how to give them more.
And I don't think that Alberta was even mentioned.
So what kind of hope do you have that Mark Carney cares about this?
I mean, he doubled down on Bill 69.
He said he's not getting rid of it.
So is there any expectation that he will meet any of Daniel Smith's silver
Well, the skepticism is that he won't.
Now, that puts the ball in his court to prove that that's not the case.
But the other thing that, again, rankles Westerners, no part of North America has
had more experience with populism, not just populist movements, populist
governments, populist movements that became governments than Western Canada.
If anybody ought to be able to figure out a strategy of how to deal with Donald
Trump, because he's on top of a populist movement.
In fact, the whole axis for looking at the political landscape, I think, has
changed. The old landscape of it's all left, right or center, if we're the left,
right and center. No, that's not the axis anymore.
The axis is this way.
Bottom up democratic populist movement versus political parts dominated by
aristocratic elites.
That that's the new axis.
And if you want to interpret the American landscape, that that's what's happened
there. You've got this bottom up populist movement that put a leader at the top.
Whether he's a populist or not, time's going to tell.
But he's on top of a populist movement.
Well, by Western Canada's experience, how do you get to the leader of a populist
movement? Not necessarily by going to Washington.
I mean, maybe there's a place for that.
You get to him through his own followers.
That's how you get to him.
Trump has to pay attention to the people that got him there.
And one of the promises he made to the people that got him there was he'd lower
their cost of living.
Now, what tariffs and counter tariffs do is increase.
It's a consumer that ends up paying in those nonproductive tariff wars.
So I think there's a way to get to Trump if you want to say reduces policy on
tariffs. It's not to counter tariffs, although you can maybe make a short term
argument for them. It's by getting to his followers.
And when Premier Smith went down and got on one of these big American talk shows
that's got 30, 40 million followers, that's what she's doing.
She's getting to Trump's constituency.
And there's going to be senatorial elections in a third of the states in 2026.
Canadians ought to be involved in those and get anti-tariff Republicans to get into
the Senate. And Western Canada has some wisdom on how you deal with populist
movements and populist governments.
Central Canada doesn't have the foggiest notion about it.
And most of those commentators, I say to political science students, particularly
if your prof is still talking about politics, left, right, center, left, right,
center, left, right, center, ask him, does he also think the earth is flat?
He's operating in a framework that I think doesn't exist.
I'm curious to hear your thoughts on the Oval Office bilateral meeting that we saw
last week between President Trump and Mark Carney, because it seems to me that if
you're watching online and you saw the commentary from Axe and YouTube, it was
very critical of Mark Carney.
And it basically said this guy was out of his league and Trump basically just had
him for breakfast. Whereas if you're watching the traditional media, the CBC and
others, they were very complimentary of Mark Carney, saying that he was sort of
masterful playing a game of chess.
And my own perspective is that I think Trump kind of humiliated him.
Like he gets that Mark Carney is there because of Donald Trump.
And like they're sort of denying that.
Like Donald Trump came in, he created this huge political problem in Canada.
And Mark Carney was seen as the one who could solve it.
Mark Carney got elected basically off of bashing Donald Trump.
And Trump almost kind of appreciates that.
He was having fun with Carney, sort of saying like, you know, this is one of the
greatest political comebacks of all time, even better than mine.
Right. And almost kind of taking credit for the fact that he was there laughing at the
fact that Carney had been bashing him, maybe open to some kind of a discussion or
debate. But in my perspective, it seems that Carney was unwilling to make the
concessions. Right. Like like Trump is concerned about the trade imbalance.
Carney has no interest in reducing many of our own barriers and our own subsidies
and our own sort of supply management issues.
And he was more interested in just hitting back like dollar for dollar tariffs and
all that kind of stuff. So I'm curious to hear your thoughts on that on that
exchange. Well, for one thing, I find it embarrassing from a Democratic standpoint
that an American president can dominate and almost dictate a Canadian election.
The fact that there was a fair increase or holding the line on the voter turnout.
What does that say about Canadian democracy, that only a threat and statements by an
American president can get people to wave the flag and be patriotic?
Like what does it is there not enough in this country, regardless of who the American
president is, to be proud of?
Is not our economic strength through the resource sector something that should make
you proud? Is not our history, although it gets trashed by the professors at a lot of
the universities and teachers, haven't we got enough to be proud of regardless of
what the president of the United States does?
I find that embarrassing and worrisome that that's what it takes to get Canadians to
feel patriotic, act patriotic and wave the flag.
I think we've got to be proud of them, regardless of who the president is.
100 percent. OK, well, I did I have one question, just sort of imagining a future
independent Western Canada, Alberta.
One thing that often gets raised is, say Alberta and Saskatchewan did decide to leave
Canada and go it alone, they would be landlocked.
And so they potentially would be met by the same kinds of issues where they can't get
their product to tidewater because they would still have to deal with Canada.
So that's an assumption that this worry is just confined to Alberta and Saskatchewan.
It isn't. It's broader.
It does go into Manitoba so that you could get access to Atlantic through a port at
Churchill. It's it's very strong in British Columbia, including in the area that has
the deepest deepwater port in the country.
Like it's if you just confine it to those two provinces, yes, you've got this landlocked
problem. But if you broaden it out to the entire West and that that goes away.
Well, one of it doesn't go away, but there's ways of meeting it.
Well, one of the other challenges, and this is one that a lot of the people that talk
about secession haven't addressed, is what will be the status of indigenous groups that
have treaty arrangements with the Crown and with the federal government under those
circumstances? How is that going to be handled?
It's one of the challenges.
One of the proposals will be that they be treated as be given municipal status.
But will some of them will some of them settle for that?
Back in 95, when people forget that there was a referendum in Quebec that came within
34,000, if 34,000 people out of four and a half million had changed their minds, you
would have had a yes vote for secession from Quebec.
And I was a member of Parliament at that time.
We had representatives from the Northern Cree come to our office and say, we don't care
what Quebec does. We are under federal jurisdiction.
We expect the federal government to continue to deal with us and look after us.
And so what would happen?
And some of these people were quite threatening.
We can do some real damage to Quebec Hydro's towers in our area.
Maybe blink the lights in New York was one of the phrases that were used.
Maybe that would get some attention to our concern.
Wow. There's issues like that that would have to be resolved and not easy.
Interesting. And yeah, we are still sort of dealing with those concerns, whereas some
First Nations in Alberta say you can't do this.
Juno News talked to constitutional lawyers and said there isn't standing for them to
block a citizen's initiative like this.
So that's definitely an interesting, outstanding issue.
Well, Preston, we always really appreciate your time.
And sorry, did you have any final thoughts on that?
Well, just on just what you said there, this business is trying to shut up the people that
want something different, secession or whatever the options are.
I don't think that's a democratic way.
I think the democratic way is let them put that position together.
There's about 10 groups working on this and behind and they're not unified.
Let them get their position together and let them get it out in front of the public and
let the public have a kick at it.
I think by suppressing the talk about these things, you do more damage than getting them
out and having a genuine political discord.
And if this assembly we're talking about comes about, one of the things we're hoping is
to demonstrate maybe for a week or 10 days what genuine democratic discourse is about.
It doesn't occur in the legislatures now that are just partisan divided.
It certainly doesn't occur in the Parliament of Canada, and I know about that.
But can we not for 10 days have people present positions clearly and they're listened to?
Can we not have them cross-examined by asking questions and getting answers?
Can those people not be obliged to listen to other people?
We're going to listen to you, but you've got to listen to something else.
And can you not take some votes at the end that indicate how much support there is for
a particular proposition?
Where today is there genuine democratic discourse?
Hopefully, maybe this assembly can demonstrate it and demonstrate it on an issue of the
future position of the West in the Federation.
Well, it's so interesting, President Manning, thank you so much for your time, your
insights. We're really looking forward to, I hope that comes to fruition and maybe we
will have some real debate and real democratic discussions in this country.
Thank you so much for everything.
Well, thank you for having me.
All right, folks, that's all the time we have for today.
Thank you so much for tuning in.
Candace Malcolm is The Candace Malcolm Show.
Thank you and God bless.
You're watching Juno News, Canada's fastest growing independent news network.
Our team works day and night to bring you nationwide coverage of the issues that
matter. Honest reporting of the stories that put Canadians first.
From far and wide, Juno is doing the work to turn the dial in the right direction,
bringing you the news from the field and in the studio, wherever it takes us.
We get the job done for you, for Canada.
Subscribe today and help us replace the CBC.
Go to Junonews.com to join the fight.
