Samsung S25 Edge Hands on - What were they Thinking?

Technical Sea
259 followers
Hands on with the Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge including testing its camera! Thin phones are back people 😅 Take your personal data back with Incogni - use code MRWHOSETHEBOSS at the link below and get 60% off an annual plan: http://incogni.com/mrwhosetheboss
#technicalworld #emergingtechnologies #trendingtechnical
This is Samsung's brand new S25 Edge.
It's just 5.8 millimeters thick,
which makes it almost 30% thinner than the S25 Ultra.
And it's looking very likely that this is just the start
of an entire wave of ultra slim high-end phones.
And so clearly, I have questions.
Firstly, how?
How have they built a phone
that much thinner than their others?
Secondly, why?
Like, who's asking for these thin phones?
What's the supposed benefit?
And then finally, should you really consider buying it?
Or is this actually just a very pretty-looking money trap?
So the how part of this equation is pretty simple.
Samsung have made this phone so thin
by taking their top-end Galaxy S25 Ultra
and chopping things up.
The Edge has two fewer cameras.
There's no three-time zoom camera.
There's no five-time zoom camera.
And this whole laser autofocus thing over here,
that's gone too.
And while the phone does still keep an ultrawide camera,
that's been downgraded.
So instead of the 50 megapixel one on the Ultra,
the Edge has 12.
But that is not all.
There's no S Pen baked inside,
like there is on the Ultra.
The screen doesn't have that absolutely amazing
anti-reflective coating that improves visibility.
The speakers, I was sitting there doing some blind testing,
and exactly as you'd expect,
given that there's less space inside the phone,
the ones on the Edge have quite a bit less of a thump
than the ones on the Ultra.
All finished off by also a significantly smaller battery.
3,900 milliamp hours on the Edge
compared to 5,000 milliamp hours.
Now, if the question you're asking me is,
has all of this feature cutting
made the phone feel better in the hands?
My answer would be, hell yeah.
Picking this phone up was very reminiscent
of my first time picking up a MacBook Air
or one of the new iPads.
30% thinner and 25% lighter
might not sound like transformative figures,
but they absolutely feel like them.
And I think it feels particularly good
because unlike most light phones,
which achieve that lightness by using cheap plastic,
this is light while still having
that premium titanium construction
and the top-end Gorilla Glass Ceramic 2 on its screen.
It just feels cool that you can have this form factor
while still having most modern luxuries
like an ultra bright, almost borderless display,
like all the AI shenanigans,
like Samsung's extremely good object eraser
and generative AI editor.
Here is where it gets a little bit strange.
While Samsung have managed to make this phone thinner
by cutting all these features down,
the one thing they haven't cut is the price.
The S25 Edge is releasing at 1,099 pounds here in the UK,
which, yes, is 150 pounds cheaper
than what the S25 Ultra launched at,
but then if you look at what you can get
to the S25 Ultra for now, it's the same price.
Like, exactly, from Samsung.
So, what?
You can either buy the phone with everything
or you can buy the phone without everything
and you pay the same, which brings me to the why.
Why then did Samsung make something
that when you glance at the spec sheet
looks like they lost a bet with the design intern?
Well, here is why I think it's not a stupid idea.
If you're a consumer and you got a high income,
I don't think it's a crazy idea
that you might want to spend 1,100 pounds on a phone.
It's like the single possession
that you're gonna be spending most of your spare time on
for maybe the next five years.
But then previously,
if you'd looked at Samsung's phone lineup before the Edge,
you'd have run into a bit of a block.
That if you're not a particularly techie consumer,
if you're not someone who's specifically looking
for 100 times space zoom on your camera
or this incredibly advanced smart pencil-like experience
embedded within the phone,
then you don't really have any incentive
to spend more than the 850 pounds
that you would need to buy an S25+.
That might actually be the better phone for you
than the Ultra because it's just slimmer and more compact.
And so I think the reason that the S25 Edge exists
is to create an alternate path.
You want to spend more,
you don't really crave all the extra tech
from going down the Ultra line,
so this allows you to spend that extra on style instead.
Now it does have a few things in common with the Ultra.
Like it still has the same top of the line
200 megapixel camera
that only Samsung's Ultra phones have previously had.
They have flattened the lens structure to keep it slim,
which does seem to make the output slightly softer
than that of the S25 Ultra.
I took this photo like six times
and every time it was slightly less good,
but still better than what you would get on an S25+.
Same for the Ultra Wide.
While the quality isn't as good as the Ultras,
at least this Ultra Wide does still have autofocus
like that one,
which means you can also use it for close-up macro shots.
This Ceramic 2 glass on the front
is similar in strength to the Ultra
and stronger than the Victus 2 glass
that you get on pretty much any other Samsung phone.
And also, shout out to this real-time visual AI feature,
which has come out since the S25's launch.
The execution isn't perfect,
but the concept of it is insane.
So you know how you can already do real-time chats
with Gemini using Gemini Live?
This is like that,
but you can now also be on a video call with it,
which means things like,
you can pick up a coffee maker, for example,
and be like, is this where I put the beans?
And it will literally look at where your finger is pointing
and say, yes, but you also need to buy a filter.
I can send you a link to one if you want.
It's really cool tech.
But broadly speaking, my point is that
even though price-wise, the Edge is closer to an Ultra,
feature-wise, it's way closer to the Plus.
Somewhat similar to what happens
if you buy one of Samsung's Z Flip phones.
You're paying more than what you would be
for one of Samsung's more traditional devices
for an aesthetic, a vibe,
as opposed to actually getting better tech.
And so the way that I see this S25 Edge is
it's giving people another option for expression,
if that's what they want,
that doesn't involve a folding phone,
which, as we've seen, is still a niche thing
that not everyone wants.
And to be honest,
separate to whether or not I'm gonna recommend this,
we're getting there,
I think this is smart.
This idea of a thin premium flagship
is something that I think we're about to see a lot of
over the next couple of years.
Apple's almost definitely about to do it later this year.
Others will follow.
And I do think that there are plenty of customers out there
who are gonna find this exciting.
Because, well, to you and I,
the idea of a thin phone might make us think,
well, didn't we try that 10 years ago
and didn't it, like, not work at all?
Well, I think it's pretty safe to say
that the tech community is going to be
largely against thinness at all costs
because of the durability concerns
and the fact that you get, well, less of the tech.
There are still two things that I would consider
in the S25 Edge's favor.
A, that materials are a lot better now than they used to be.
Like, this is gonna be more delicate than a thicker phone,
but it's going to be a lot less delicate
than something like the iPhone 6 Plus from back in the day.
And then B is just that,
if you're someone who cares a bit less
about the tech in 2025,
which feels more likely than ever before
because the changes in the tech
are becoming harder to notice,
then you can so see how the option to buy a phone
that's just straight up 30% thinner
is actually going to feel like
the way more noticeable change
than even bigger camera sensors,
even faster charging, even brighter screens.
You know, the usual stuff
that we might pay more attention to.
So that's why I think Samsung's making it.
But it's a very different question
as to whether or not you should buy it.
I would say this.
I think it's completely fine to go for a cool phone
at the cost of some functionality.
I mean, as far as I'm concerned,
we make decisions like this all the time
with the clothes we wear,
the cars we drive, the bags we carry.
You don't always have to spec optimize
if something makes you happy.
Like this is the kind of phone that I'd be looking at
and my first thought would be,
oh, my mom, she'd love this.
Something that's luxury in all the ways
that she needs it to be
while cutting out all the stuff
that she either isn't going to know
or isn't going to care about
to also be able to have this show-stopping thinness.
However, there are two things
that would make me very nervous to recommend this.
One is the great case dilemma.
It's this really counterintuitive thing
where if you're buying an ultra thin phone like this,
then you'd probably want a proper hard-backed thick case
more than ever.
But then if you put a proper hard-backed thick case on,
you're then defeating half the point
of sacrificing all these features to have a thinner phone.
Wouldn't it just be better at that point
to go for a thicker phone
that is stronger and more feature rich
and then have a thinner case?
And then the second even bigger issue really
is the battery size.
Because while I do think that chopping out pro features
like telephoto cameras and S-Pens
is actually completely justified
because there are so many people
who just will not even touch them,
I wouldn't put battery in that same category.
I think the vast, vast majority of people,
no matter how techie they are,
would benefit from a big battery.
Like mum, if we're using that example.
She has never once complained about camera quality
with her last few phones,
but she absolutely runs into battery issues.
It's probably like the one single spec that unites us all.
And so the idea of paying that ultra premium price
for a phone with a battery that's not even just average,
but actually small by today's standards
is not something that I would be rushing out to do.
They do say it's all day battery,
but generally with phone companies,
what that actually means is,
don't think about it too much.
If this was a more energy dense silicon carbon battery,
this would be a different conversation, but it isn't.
Which means I think it's likely
within a few years of using this,
when the honeymoon phase of going for something suave
has run dry and the battery has degraded,
that you might regret prioritizing thinness.
That is if you haven't already snapped the thing by then.
And now while I show you the camera in action,
one thing that I've been massively appreciating
about my own phone recently
is the stark drop-off in junk calls and spam emails.
You get them because every fricking service nowadays,
from your supermarket to that wifi login
at the weird backstreet cafe that you went to once,
wants you to create an account,
fill in every detail about you
to be able to reach you in as many ways as possible.
And the more times that you hand that data out,
the more likely it is that it's going to end up
in the hands of bad actors.
So if you're like me, splashing out your details
ever since the day you signed up to Neopets in 2002,
there's gonna be a lot.
So I started using Incogni, our sponsor in 2023.
It's kind of like the Liam Neeson of data privacy.
It finds the people who took your data
and it politely insists that they take it down.
It handles any follow-ups and legal bits
that may come with that.
And to be honest, I think the best part of it
is the custom removals.
You know, there's times when you Google yourself
and you find a little bit more personal information
than you wanted to share.
Here, you can just ping the link to Incogni
and then watch it disappear.
So link below to get Incogni,
which with the code boss, you can get for a 60% discount.
