When Does The Sun Look Like Any Other Star? Will Voyager Ever Lose The Sun?

Universe Unveiled
2 followers
Hello it's Scott Manley here. Voyager 1 is the most distant human created object. It was launched
in 1977 and as I speak it is about 166 astronomical units from the sun and getting further away at
about 3.5 AU per year. And it is experiencing the fall of night not because the planet is turning
and the sun is setting but because it is going further and further away from the sun.
And I sort of got it into my head to try and figure out just how dark things are,
how far it will go and what things would look like if you were out there.
So I did the math and at 166 AU the sun has a magnitude of minus 15.7 and that
maybe doesn't mean much to you but the moon, the full moon under perfect circumstances has
magnitude of about minus 12.74. So this is still three magnitudes brighter than the full moon.
Now this is space engine and I just changed the settings to lock in the exposure settings from
when it was pointed directly at the sun. So the sun is still bright enough that it is washing out
all but the brightest stars at this point. I'm sure you've all experienced what a full
moon is like. It's easy to see what you're doing and at 166 AU the sun is still 16 times brighter
than the full moon. Although interestingly it's not as bright as a full earth as seen from the
surface of the moon. The way we figure this out is with the magnitude distance relationship. The sun's
visible magnitude is minus 26.83 which means it's really bright. The full moon's apparent
magnitude is minus 12.74. You take the difference between those you get 14.09. Now your distance
factor is then 10 to the power of this magnitude difference divided by 5. So that's 10 to the power
2.86828. That's 658 AU where the sun becomes as faint as the full moon. So yeah about 668
astronomical units out. The human eye is working more or less just fine but you are very cold.
It's interesting to note that if you calculate the orbit of a parabolic comet it takes about
a thousand years to reach that distance so there are no comets which humans have actually
definitively got the orbital elements for that we know have reached this distance. Although
there's many old like ancient comets that have probably reached this distance after visiting
the inner solar system. Basically what I'm saying is there's nothing in living memory that has got
so far from the sun where the sun is you know merely one of the brightest stars. So we can
apply this magnitude distance relationship to figure out how far you'd be to you make the sun
look the same as say any other celestial body that we have that you have seen right. And so
Mercury that's the third brightest natural celestial body. Obviously the ISS is actually
slightly brighter and sometimes we get you know satellite flares are brighter.
But that gets that's about a magnitude of minus 4.2 and yeah to get the sun being that faint you
have to go out something like 30,000 astronomical units. That is 194 light days half a light year
before the sun is merely a bright star in the sky. But it still outshines Sirius which has
magnitude of minus 1.46. To make it even fainter than Sirius you have to go out to 118,000 AU,
686 light days. Basically two light years out and only then is the sun fainter than the brightest
star that we have in the sky from Earth. And you know just as an aside I sort of get interested
to wonder what are the brightest stars in other star systems skies and I found a Gliese 710
which is about one light year from New Serpentis and in its skies New Serpentis would be
magnitude minus 5.5 which is pretty damn bright. But also I found out that Gliese 710
is projected to pass very close to the sun in about 1.3 million years. It's going to pass
within a quarter of a light year and while future humanity will no doubt be saying that's a pretty
cool star and watch it slowly move across the sky, a million years after that there'll be
comets coming down because it flew through the Oort cloud. So anyway doing these kind of
calculations with magnitudes and stuff is actually pretty simple you know it's something you learn as
a first year astronomy student but a lot of you might be wondering where the heck the actual
magnitude system comes from? Why do we use magnitudes? Why don't we use you know like
absolute energy fluxes or something that's metric? The magnitude system goes back over 2,000 years.
We've got to start with Hipparchus who published probably the first star catalogue. He catalogued
a whole bunch of constellations, supposedly 850 stars and not only did he catalogue the positions
but he also talked about the brightnesses. They were a brilliant light of second degree or they
were faint right this was a rough estimate based on the human eye. Now then a couple of hundred
years later Ptolemy comes along and he actually assigns numbers. There's first magnitude star,
second magnitude so on and so forth down to sixth and basically the lower the number the brighter
the star and it's generally believed that the way he did this was by waiting for darkness and
watching the stars emerge and the ones that emerged first were the brightest. Now as time goes on other
people create catalogues, Al-Sufi, Tycho Brahe but the big change would be the invention of the
telescope. Now astronomers have a new tool and they can look deeper into the sky not only can they
magnify stuff but they can actually see fainter stars and that means they need to extend their
magnitude system and there's a big problem because the human eye isn't really that great at figuring
out how bright something is unless it's placed next to something of similar brightness they can
say that one is brighter than the other but when you've got a telescope your field of view is so
stopped down suddenly you can't see those two stars to compare them so there's a whole bunch
of variations that we get over the next few centuries as astronomers try to catalogue the
skies and so in the early 19th century we get to see the first tools to help standardise this.
They start working with like you know smoked glass that will try to reduce the magnitude by
a certain known amount and then there's a guy called Carl von Steinhill who develops a telescope
that can basically use a split lens to look at two stars so you can compare against a standard object
and then in 1861 a guy called Friedrich Zollner developed well the Zollner photometer and this
would generate a standard candle right using a kerosene flame they would have a set of polarising
prisms which would allow them to adjust the exact brightness until it matched and then they could
read out the values and this was basically what was used until photography took over
but apparently these devices were in use into the 1940s but there was still the problem that
the original scale of one through six was absolutely arbitrary defined by some like
ancient greek and no one was really sure how to extend it to these fainter objects.
Now an important part of this is because it comes from the human eye it's following the way the
human eye responds to light and that is a sort of logarithmic process so people looked at applying
various ratios between the magnitudes so that the first magnitude was maybe three times as bright
as the second magnitude. William Dawes was using a factor of four but the one that would win
was a guy called William Pogson who was interested in asteroid and in 1856 he wrote a paper where he
basically predicted the magnitudes of a bunch of minor planets for the following year. This was
the kind of publication that would be completely forgotten about today if it wasn't for the
footnotes. He writes about trying to pick the right value and he settles on having each magnitude be
different by a factor of 2.52 because if they chose that value then five magnitudes of difference
would be a factor of a hundred in the brightness and that made the calculation suddenly so much
easier. It meant suddenly you could use base 10 logarithms everywhere you could eliminate a whole
bunch of extra computation if you used this magic number. It was one of many possible ways of fitting
modern observational techniques to old systems but it was the one that simplified the amount of work
and that's why it ended up winning. So yeah if you have a difference of five magnitudes that's a
difference of 100 in terms of brightness. Now when we're talking about distances remember that goes
as the inverse square so you take the square root of that turns out that five magnitudes is 10 times
further away or 10 times closer if it's five magnitudes brighter. For things that can be
observed from earth we're typically talking anything from minus 30 to plus 30 magnitudes
and given that you know five magnitudes is a factor of 100 that's a range of 10 to the power 24 or a
trillion trillion and this range isn't set in stone or anything. As we develop bigger and bigger
telescopes we will be able to see higher and higher magnitude stars that are fainter and equally if
there's something really bright it could be even more negative than the sun. For example if you
pointed your telescope at a relatively nearby nuclear explosion and for that reason of course
distance is actually important and we have the concept of the absolute magnitude and the apparent
magnitude. I've mostly been talking about the apparent magnitude that is like what we actually
see on earth but in order to make comparisons of the intrinsic properties of stars we have the
absolute magnitude which is where you recalibrate its apparent magnitude to what it would look like
if it were 10 parsecs away and for example the star Rigel it is one of the brightest stars in our
night sky and its absolute magnitude is minus 7.84 it is a staggeringly bright blue star but it is
also about a thousand light years away that is about 310 parsecs that's 31 times the absolute
magnitude calibration distance of 10 parsecs so take the log 10 of that right log 10 31 and
multiply that number by 5 and you get 7.45 which you can see how a 7 minus 7.8 magnitude gets
reduced down to basically a zero with magnitude star just by that distance equation. Our sun by
comparison is an absolute wimp at 10 parsecs its magnitude is 4.8 it's basically a fifth magnitude
star that most people would overlook and there are fainter stars still Proxima Centauri is this
tiny little red dwarf and its absolute magnitude is 15.6 so that's 10 000 times fainter than the
sun and from earth its apparent magnitude is about 11 it's basically invisible unless you've got a
but consider that it is part of the Alpha Centauri system it's like you know a few thousand
astronomical units out if there was a planet around like Alpha Centauri A or B then I think
the Proxima Centauri would barely be visible as like a third magnitude star in their skies.
Anyway that was a quite a diversion my original question had been you know how far do you have
go from the solar system before the sun just looks like any other star and depending upon
what your definition of any other star is you you might need to go half a light year you might need
to go two light years but yeah you don't have to go that far away from the sun before it's the least
important thing in the sky well at least in astronomical terms i'm scott manley fly safe
