Mathematics and the Universe | Brian Greene

Math for our world
17 followers
I mean, a lot of the great scientists, physicists of earlier days did draw a very clear association
between the mathematical underpinnings that they were struggling to understand and the
mind of God, because it feels like God must have been a fantastically astute mathematician
who had been able to sort of set up the world to function according to these mathematical
laws. And if at some point you want to speak about it today, I'd be happy to. I have a
somewhat different view of mathematics today than even I did 30 years ago. I certainly
held to a similar perspective as some of the greats of years ago articulated, much like
you were making reference to. But I now see mathematics more as the invention of the human
mind as opposed to the discovery of the fundamental language of reality.
Yeah, so why don't we explore that a little bit now? Because I think we've already before,
like you didn't use the metaphor of mathematics as a language. So you were introduced by your
father to a way of interacting with the world, seeing these algorithms, noticing that can
be enjoyable as a game, but then also can be applied to investigating the world. So
the language is metaphor, we've mentioned. Maybe tell me a little bit more. Is it helpful
to describe mathematics as one human language among many, or where does that metaphor work
and where does it fall short?
Yeah, so it's interesting that you refer to thinking of math as a language as a metaphorical
way of using the terminology. I would press even further. I would say mathematics itself
emerges from the human capacity to function with metaphors. When you look at the history
of ordinary spoken language, as of course many linguists have done over the centuries,
it is astounding if you've never seen it before, how widespread the use of metaphor
is in our language. You take some of the driest sentences that may be used to articulate some
statute in some arcane part of the legal system, the driest kind of language that you would
imagine, not the language of poets. Even in sentences of that sort, when you go word
by word and you trace the origin of those words, you find that almost all of them are
metaphorical. They began as words that had a very concrete association to things in the
physical world, and over time that meaning shifted to a far looser, more poetic version
of whatever idea that word was ultimately able to conjure up in the minds of listeners or readers.
And I see mathematics as an extension of that natural growth of metaphorical thinking that
our species went through. Metaphor is symbolism, and what mathematics is, it takes that to the
next level where you articulate, using symbols, things about the external world. But it's our
minds, in my view, that are conjuring up these useful, symbolic representations of things that
we experience. And so what is math? We encounter the external world, we have this capacity to
find patterns, which is how we survive. We encapsulate those patterns by inventing ideas, like the
circle or the triangle or the number pi or radius or diameter or the exponential function or the
square root function, because these symbolic representations we find have utility in organizing
our perceptions about the external world. So to me, when we talk about Einstein's equations or
Maxwell's equations, these are equations that human beings came up with using symbols and mathematical
structures that other human beings came up with. Einstein made use of the ideas of Riemannian
geometry, Riemann, and it was other scientists and mathematicians like Gauss and Lobachevsky
and other thinkers of an earlier age who, again, in this metaphorical, symbolic way, found the
structures necessary to describe curved surfaces. Einstein then builds upon that with his own
metaphorical, symbolic thinking to describe the curvature of space-time in this mathematical
language. And so to me, it's a beautiful story in which human beings, in order to survive, articulate
patterns in the physical world. Then once they survive, they have the luxury to articulate
patterns about things that we don't directly experience in the physical world. And that's
where you get the equations of physics.
