Mercedes GLE vs BMW X5 comparison REVIEW - what’s the best SUV?

Cars Arena
18 followers
May 10, 2025
Mercedes GLE versus BMW X5, who is the king of premium SUVs?
We're going to find out for you here today together with Thomas Nautico in 4K full screen
full length.
Let's go with this super interesting comparison.
We already had Mercedes GLC versus BMW X3.
We had the S-Class versus 7 Series, E-Class against the 5 Series, and always it turned
out differently.
How will it turn out today?
Here, we start with the Mercedes GLE.
Both have been facelifted quite recently, actually.
This one is here the AMG line, so you have a sportier accentuation in the lower part
and one horizontal spoke here in the grille and this beautiful micro star pattern.
There's also the base version available that will have two spokes here and not such a sporty
graphic in the lower part, and actually, I would say for the GLE, I would prefer it like
this here in the AMG line, or what would you prefer?
With the BMW X5, this is the X line.
Since the facelift, this is also the base look with a more brighter look, kind of off-road
accentuation-ish, I would call it that way.
You can also get the M Sport Pack, then you have sportier design, especially in the lower
side graphic.
There's even an M Performance parts available that makes it even sportier, but maybe too
much.
So, I would pick them as they stand here right now, the X5 as the X line, more the off-road-ish
look, but with the GLE, the sportier look with the AMG line, or what would you go for?
Well, when we take a look at the side profile and about the length, they are both 194 inches
in length, so 4.94m and 4.92m, so more or less the same in length.
Also, 19 to 22-inch wheels, these here are 20-inch wheels with the BMW.
On the Mercedes GLE, we have 21-inch, so a little bigger, sportier look.
Suspension-wise, it's really interesting.
So, the BMW starts with an adaptive suspension already, and then it goes optional to an air
suspension.
Special thing is that here, it's also optionally rear axle steering available.
With the GLE, you upgrade from the standard suspension to the air suspension as well,
and then optional, optional, the e-active body control that you can also lean the car
into the corners.
We also have it equipped here today, I'll tell you more about it if that's really necessary.
Just rear axle steering is not available here with the Mercedes GLE.
So, maybe in the US, it doesn't make too big of a difference, but in Europe, it would actually,
especially for narrow city situations.
Then, towards the rear, the facelift also upgraded there a little bit here for the GLE
with the more modern graphic.
There we go, and I'll look through fake exhaust alert because these here are clear fake exhaust
for the GLE, whereas the X5 has fake exhaust tips, but the real exhaust does run through
here, through these tips.
In the X line, once again, you have these brighter accentuations in the lower part,
I think overall, very cool look, and also here, the tail lamps, very horizontally drawn
turning indicators.
The car is, indeed, way different with the BMW since the facelift in this arrow design
with the pulsing effect, Mercedes more in a classic style.
The colors, by the way, high-tech silver for the Mercedes and Blue Ridge Mountain for the
BMW.
Which one would you go for from the exterior, BMW or Mercedes?
Tell me in the comments.
These are two key fobs, they both have a very nice styling.
Which one would you prefer?
The Mercedes one is a little bit heavier, the BMW one is a little bit lighter, and door
closing sounds, GLE first, that's a nice sound.
Inside of the door, soft touch here, a little bit softer for your elbow.
Inside door pockets, however, hard pack, there's just this rubber bottom, so no felt on the
inside.
Interior, let's go here, Mercedes GLE.
Since the facelift, you now have these horizontal lines here as an additional design element,
and I talked to Leah about that earlier, and she actually suggested that it looks like
sunshades on the house or on the flat, on the outside, so I think it's a matter of preference.
I found it actually quite cool, I have to say, and then you also get this soft touch
dashboard, a lot of air vent design definitely here, then a carbon fiber decal element.
Of course, you can pick different ones.
What I prefer with the GLE, that although it has been facelifted, you still have the
manual climate control here, so you can easily control it while driving, I do prefer that.
Actually, BMW had that, but deleted it for the facelift, 2 times 12.3-inch has also been
updated then here with the software in the infotainment system, pretty clean design.
This lower touchpad here, I would prefer a real turning knob for that one, though, so
this, you can control it like this or then as touch here in the screen, actually.
You also have some nice off-road gauges, by the way, not only here in the main infotainment
system, but also then here in the instruments, then middle console is like with this tool,
yeah, off-road to hold tight things, then air suspension, you could put up and down
here, split armrest with USB-C charging underneath, and also nice closing sound, a lot of high
gloss black then here as the cover, slide it open, then you have adaptive cupholders,
they work pretty well, also here, move them a little bit more open and then push them
here and then they go down, why not, inductive charging pad also in the front and two more
USB-C chargings, then the steering wheel has been updated here in the AMG design, it means
two horizontal spokes, however, now in the facelift, hashtag capacitive BS buttons, so
it looks cleaner, but to control them and, you know, swipe in the head-up display or
the instrument menu sometimes fails and you also have a head-up display and you can even
pick different modes for this one. Seats here in the GLE, animal skin spec, however, the
Artico leatherette would also be available, in general, the material is quite stiff and
quality-wise cannot keep up with the BMW, indeed, it's a good comfort in general here,
headroom 189, 602, a lot left, there is a panoramic roof available, by the way, if you
like, and this is the problem, so here in the middle console, this is softer, but then
this one is not entirely hard, but definitely harder and sometimes your elbow is exactly
here and that is actually too hard for your elbow while driving, so this is a design fail
from the positioning. Rear seating, the inside of the doors, by the way, is also soft touch
on the top part, that's nice, however, the door pockets, neither in the front nor in
the rear are covered on the inside, both hard pack, hmm, for that price, really, however,
then, the rear seating, you fall a little bit backwards on that bench, we have a lot
of legroom, look at that, so a lot of legroom left even if a tall driver is driving and
headroom is also no problem at all, a lot of space here and also quite good in the comfort,
I'm really looking forward how it does compare to the X5. Inside of the rear door, same theme
here, top soft, lower part hard pack, and then seating position in the rear, since we
also have the sensor fin here, it's way softer, more comfortable, indeed, also for the rear
passengers, wow, it's way more comfortable here in the X5 just from the seating itself,
headroom, there's some left here too, but the GLE had more headroom than the X5 and
also you can see a massive difference in legroom, so the GLE has way more legroom here, however,
then, the seating comfort, especially for tall adults is actually better in the X5,
it still is okay from the space here, yeah, the question is what is more important to you,
more legroom or the better seating comfort itself on the surfaces. Door closing sound with the X5,
also really nice, couldn't really say which one I prefer, it's both really cool,
then inside of the doors, also soft touch here everywhere, also good build quality,
but here inside of the door pocket, also hard pack with both vehicles, that's disappointing
indeed. Then, the cockpit, this is here the normal steering wheel, there's also an M Sport
available, it looks sportier, but I would actually prefer this one because it just looks cleaner in
a way, the X5 still has real buttons on the steering wheel and with nice clicking sound,
so I would prefer this then in that case. Seats, these ones are the sensor fin seats,
so they are animal free, more sustainable, animal friendly and also the so-called Einsatzhöhe,
like, you know, like this top bolt string here, how it goes deep in there and also the quilting
on it, black or also bright styling available, these ones are standard actually for the X5 and
also the, wow, best in comfort overall, actually among the most comfortable seats in the whole
industry at this moment, both from ergonomics and from the surface, so this is very well done
and indeed, way more seating comfort than in the GLE. Also here, this lower part here,
you can put this one a little bit longer then for long legs, it's also very helpful and you can even
adjust just not only like the whole back part of the seat, but only here the very top, you know,
just the very top area you can move backwards or forward. Cockpit in front of the X5,
deco element here in wood, isn't Lia's favorite, she says, it looks a little bit too old school,
I love the wood deco elements, however, I usually prefer the matte wood and not the shiny wood,
nevertheless, you can also pick non-wood deco elements, different choice available.
Since the facelift, you also have this illuminated X5 badge here and a new mechanism here to control
the middle air vents and this one screen design now in a curved way, 12.3, 14.5,
so a little bit bigger on the right side, bigger than with the GLE. The thing is,
it looks cool and modern, however, the AC unit is now in the screen and that's what I don't like
before, it was here, so pre-facelift. Then again, the Apple CarPlay connection, the wireless one,
is better now with the facelift because there's a new software version, so there's pro and con
coming with that facelift here. Then, in the lower part, that's actually cool, there's still a
turning and pressing knob where you can also control the infotainment system with, I preferred
here in the BMW, you slide this one open, also adaptive cupholders, they're also heated and
cooled if you like, inductive charging pad, however, this one is not cooled, this is a problem,
the phone does overheat when inductive charging. Also, split armrest opening here with some space
and USB-C charging and the thing is that here, I don't have a problem with the elbow because it's
always in that area and I'm never with the elbow on that area in the front, so here it's always
soft when you rest your elbow like this. Headroom, by the way, also plenty available, oh, here also
with a nice microfiber ceiling. Digital instruments look like this, they come alive when you start up
the vehicle and then you also can have an RPM meter if you like, on the left side would be the
speed, but you also have it digitalized in the middle part and you also get a head-up display.
And now, Lia is showing us the sun visor here, you can actually make it a little bit longer in the
X5, also nice microfiber covering here for the sun blind, so that's good, it's also the same in the
GLE. Now, in the GLE, yeah, material-wise, no comparison actually, so this is way cheaper from the material
indeed, so with the BMW, it was like soft microfiber, here it's harder and could you make it longer
actually? No, but not possible, so yeah, that's the point for the X5 then. Yes, for the trunk, it's
interesting here, the X5 has this split, so there's one part in the top and then you can move down the
second part right here and this is maybe cool like for picnic situations because you can really sit
down here and have a nice picnic and so on. Of course, you can also let it just up and take
things in and out. Size-wise, it doesn't make too big of a difference, 650 liters for the X5,
a couple of liters less for the GLE, but doesn't make any major differences. Width here, 1 meters
and 10 or 43 inches, that's good, and the length here is also a little bit over a meter or 40
inches, that's good, as well as for the height, this is like 80 centimeters or 31 inches. By the way,
pretty cool, look at that, here my suitcase is lying on that and this here has a gas strut
like underneath the cover, that's amazing, right, and then you can put more things in there or maybe
spare tire and also like how it clicks in here, that's cool. However, facelifts do not always
bring good things. So, here they removed this remote folding mechanism, so to fold the seats
then I have to go around in the X5, yeah, and I didn't have to do that before. Always a nice effect
like, you know, see that it's both closed and simultaneously, sometimes you, you know, just by
mistake, not intentionally close the lower lip, you have to pay attention to that. Then, the GLE,
there we go, and the width here with the GLE, once again, 1 meters 10 or 43 inches, length comparable
meter or 40 inches, and here also in the height, oh, there's actually also a little bit at 83
centimeters or 33 inches, so that's interesting, although the X5 leads in liter, the GLE here looks
better actually. This one, no gas truck, but a lot of space underneath, so maybe it's the thing,
yeah, you can see here that GLE loses the liter figures here because it's a little bit, you know,
like cut off here, whereas the X5 continues a little bit more here, that's maybe the thing.
We can put down the car because we have the air suspension, so we're better loading in and out,
but then again, there's also no remote release. So, I mean, at that price point,
there definitely should be one, shouldn't there? So, and we can push it around like this. I always
love that shot here. Hulk is opening both hoods. So, there we go, the BMW 3.0-liter six-cylinder
or then in the top spec, a 4.0-liter eight-cylinder in the M Performance model and the True M model,
and that's basically it. So, the petrol and diesel side and the plug-in hybrid is also based on the
six-cylinder. With the Mercedes, you also have the 3.0-liter six-cylinder diesel and petrol.
However, you also start with 2.0-liter four-cylinder petrol and diesel depending on the
market if it's available and their plug-in hybrids are also based on the four-cylinder.
However, there's just one 53 AMG version plug-in hybrid that's also based on the six-cylinder,
then there's once again also a 4.0-liter eight-cylinder then for the AMG model, for example.
Well, so, with Mercedes, let's say the engine lineup is a little bit more complicated,
but they still offer a lot of cylinders on both sides, and we both have 3.0-liter six-cylinders
here as a comparison for you today. Alright, Thomas' comparison driving lounge starting with
the BMW X5. We switch here to the sport mode and we get like this preload from the gears from 50
kilometers an hour. Let's go. 150. Nice. 170. 180, and now we are paying attention that we don't
crash into someone. That was very good acceleration here for the 3.0-liter six-cylinder, in this case
the diesel. Five and a half seconds in the acceleration figure. That was really decent
and also a very nice refined sound, actually, so you don't feel like always bad sound because
it's a diesel. That's not happening here in the six-cylinder diesel, actually, and it's a very
smooth power on the road, definitely. Here, the steering wheel without M Sport, I really have to
say, I told you earlier that looks-wise, I found it actually better, and it is actually better to
control as well because somehow I sometimes feel the M Sport steering wheels have some kind of
asymmetrical feeling to it, and this one here definitely feels
more natural and symmetrical. That's very interesting. Leah is now thinking, ah, that's
Thomas OCD again. Yeah, about that. Maybe I'm car OCD-ish, you know, you know, maybe I have to
make that up. I don't know. Interesting is, by the way, here in the sport mode BMW,
because we recently did a comparison sport mode and then the S-shifting mode versus sport mode
and D-shifting mode because when you are in an Audi or Mercedes and you go sport mode,
it automatically switches to the S-shifting mode. Here, it's separate, so here it says S6.
One more time, it says D, so the sport mode and the sport-shifting mode is separated here in the
BMW. That's interesting, and the thing is that the S-shifting mode is good when you have, like,
tight bends and you have acceleration and braking and back and forth, back and forth,
but here for the best performance, it's not necessarily the best setting, so that's why
I kept it in the sport driving mode but kept it in normal shifting mode because then maybe
some shifting times might not be ideal. The last time we tested with the BMW
four-cylinder diesel, it was actually a second quicker in the sport driving mode and D-shifting
mode. Very interesting, isn't it? Now, here, 120 kilometers an hour. I can also go back to the
comfort mode and the air suspension is also set on the softer mode. This one here equipped with
the optional air suspension and we're driving a large SUV on the German Autobahn at 130 kilometers
an hour, 80 miles an hour, and it is very silent, good noise insulation. It's super comfortable.
The seats are a dream, the so-called Einsitzhöhe, such a good, like, one of the best leatherette
out there, and not only the best leatherette, one of the best seats out there at this moment.
Leah, your comment?
I'm talking about the car here. Please pay attention. Yeah, but that's the case. I mean,
she's, like, she's, like, dreaming away because the seats are so comfortable indeed, so there's
always the sign, like, where when your passenger is not paying attention, it's, like, so relaxed,
you know. I mean, I was just doing, like, full acceleration. She's, like,
so relaxed and comfortable here. So, yeah, definitely proves my point. Best comfort here
in the seats and you can go long way journeys, no problem at all, mileage and mileage, that's
very excellent, and the steering feel here is good, fine nuances, transport on the road,
and I always feel that the SUV steering feel here is better at the BMWs than, for example,
with some of their sedans, and that's kind of astonishing, you know. I'm not sure why that is.
If the SUVs, the big ones, are all built in the US factory in Spartanburg, maybe these guys in
the factory there think, like, hey, let's make a better steering setup than with the sedans that
are built in Germany. I have no idea why that is or in Mexico, of course, for the 3 Series for the
North American market, whereas the 3 Series for Europe is built in Germany. So, here also,
when you're just in the comfort mode, there's always the pin-down available,
and then you get good drive. Here, of course, the torque from the diesel sets in.
For the North American market, the 3.0-liter 6-cylinder petrol will be the most relevant,
of course, but it's definitely comparable for the performance and so on. It's a great engine
and also interesting, talking about engines, that recent consumer reports show very good
reliability figures for BMW, which hasn't been the case, like, maybe, like, 10, 20 years back,
and, you know, they had, like, a reputation of, ah, they're money pits and so on,
great in driving, but then when you buy and own for a long time, money pits,
but here BMW has massively increased reliability in the rankings. That is very astonishing,
really good, actually, whereas with Mercedes, they went actually downhill with that. So,
that's definitely a factor to consider here as well, but such a relaxing ride on the motorway,
and although you're driving, like, a large SUV, it doesn't shake up much and so on,
even in comfort mode. When you are in the sport mode, then the air suspension is,
you know, a little bit stiffer, gives you more feedback, but it's not that you would,
you know, when you get in the vehicle from the suspension, you would directly not notice which
suspension mode the car is actually set in, which is, I think, rather a good thing,
because you can drive it in any mode, and it will be good both in the comfort and the
sportiness side. Do you need the air suspension in the BMW X5? I would say no, it's good,
definitely, but the normal adaptive suspension is so good that you do not miss an air suspension,
so I would recommend, you know, or when you buy used or something, it's no problem which
suspension the vehicle is equipped with. If you think about buying long-term, it might be even
better not to have the air suspension because at some point when there is a repair after a long
time, then it's easier to fix the base suspension than the air suspension, for example. Oh,
there's a German police, by the way, you know, blind spot monitor, also in the side mirrors.
We can also test the cruise control feature here. I can change the mode for, like, normal
speed limiter and just the normal cruise control between the assisted driving and here assisted
driving. The car is basically steering itself. Of course, you have to keep your hands at the
steering wheel, but you see here there are no hectic movements. The car is being centralized
in a very smooth way, and now when the motorway is slightly turning to the left, you can see
it's still being kept relatively smooth. So, overall, that is really, I mean, such a flawless
driving experience here with the BMW X5. I wonder if the GLE can be even better than that.
And, now, the Mercedes GLE, let's put here to the sport mode, and let's also accelerate here
from, yeah, from 50 kilometers an hour. Let's go. 130. 150. Nice. 170. 180.
Plop. 200 kilometers an hour. 124 miles an hour. I mean, we're driving a large SUV and
still feels really good. Even wind noise is pretty good at that speed, so that is nice.
Yeah, it drives really well. New steering wheel with this facelift here for the GLE. Also,
it's very nice to control. The steering has massively been improved. It's more direct,
more feedback. Just here in the very, yeah, this like very, you know, something happens here on the
left lane. So, in this, you know, very low degree angle, there the BMW has more feeling,
more direct input, but then to the outside, it's definitely better, and it was also astonishing
that with the GLE, you need a little bit more force to steer it, especially in the sport mode.
So, the BMW steering, to me, a little bit better. I mean, yes, it's a little bit lighter,
but at the same time, it has more natural feeling to it. So, both on a very good level,
but the BMW steering a little bit better. Suspension-wise, I do prefer the air suspension
of the Mercedes. I feel that if you go with the standard suspension, then the BMW is better. If
you go with the air suspension, this one here has a more likable setup. Why? Especially when I'm
here in the comfort mode, this air suspension here, when I like, there's bumps in the road,
it just has a little softer setup. It, you know, gives you this air carpet right, whereas the BMW
is a little bit more direct, and I prefer that if you have an air suspension, you also feel
clearly that you have an air suspension. That's what I prefer here with the GLE,
although we have here 21-inch wheels mounted and 20-inch with the X5. So, suspension-wise,
both are super comfortable, and here also, let's say like normal motorway speeds, like
you're 130 kilometers an hour, 80 miles an hour, it's very silent here. So, both are very silent.
That's very, very well done. So, super comfortable ride for both on the motorway. Seats, clearly,
the BMW X5 is the winner. These seats here are the animal skin seats. You also get the article
leatherette, but in both cases, the BMW leatherette seats, they are better than all of the other seat
choices you would have for both cars, basically. So, they clearly need it and give so much more
comfort while driving. Also, the base ergonomics of the seats is better with the BMW. So, you see,
it's here, you know, I prefer this one. In other respects, I prefer the other one. It really
depends, you know. Controlling it while driving, both touchscreens are quite far away. It's not
meant to be done like that. Here, you still have this lower controller, but that's also
why I touch, so it doesn't give you the best feeling. The only thing is the clearly better
interface while driving. See that I still have the manual climate unit. I control that one way
easier while driving. That one has been, you know, has been deleted with the facelift of the X5.
Not a good decision, I feel, because then they would be quite even in that respect. Yeah, really,
here, like when running straight, then they have, see here, doesn't do anything on the road.
Some might prefer that. I don't. So, with the X5, I have a more fine feeling of what I'm doing in
that angle. Then, also, when I'm doing a lane change here, like in a normal comfort mode,
it's very nice, very well done. Here, which is a unique feature, you have the curved mode.
This is a special suspension system with hydraulics, and then,
I'm not sure if you can see it on camera, but the car leans into the corner. It's not
too much, not too extreme, but you feel and see it, and if you do these dry tests, you might say,
yeah, this is an advantage then, especially for a passenger. Lia also said she does like it at
first, but then you said, like, bit by bit, it's a little bit, it became a little bit stranger,
you know. So, it's a cool feature to show off, but we were both not very certain if we would
drive like that, like, forever, you know. So, it's not really needed. US vehicles are usually
not equipped with that anymore. You can't really pick it. In Europe, it's still available.
Yeah, it's an interesting feature, but you don't really need it in that respect.
You don't have the rear-axle steering that you would have in the X5 as an option.
We didn't have it today, but you can get it as an X5 option, while the diesel really has,
in German, we would say, like, it has a lot of pressure, dude. Yeah, that works very well with
the diesel. So, the only thing is that with the BMW, you don't feel at all that you are driving
a diesel, especially in a low-speed area. It doesn't happen at all that you would feel it's
a diesel because it has, like, very, you know, like, instant acceleration. Here, the Mercedes
diesel feels more like a diesel. So, it has a slight delay at first, and then the whole pressure
comes, like, the whole torque sets in. Acceleration-wise doesn't make a big difference.
So, on paper here, like, 0.1 seconds, this one here is slower, but that's about it. Excellent
motorway SUVs, for sure, both. I think it's more about, really, that the seating comfort,
that is the biggest difference, also while driving, and steering a little bit, but since
they both do basically everything in driving so well, the pure driving experience is not the
biggest difference between these two cars. Slight nuances, yes, but both excellent, but what does
it mean for the final conclusion? It's going to be a tough one, so let's start. Exterior-wise,
I think it's really a matter of preference, and, well, I prefer the AMG line for the GLE and the
standard, the X line for the X5, but they're both very beautiful in the front. So, exterior-wise,
I think I'm kind of undecided. Interior-wise, just from the visual part, from the looks,
I prefer the Mercedes GLE. Then again, with the X5, the seating comfort is way better with this
sensor-finned seat, so this is a huge difference, indeed. Then again, the GLE has more legroom in
the rear. Trunk was actually very well comparable, both very well usable. They both drive exceptionally
well. Base suspension, I would prefer the X5. With the air suspension, I would prefer the GLE because
it has a little bit softer setup. The e-active body control, the super extra suspension is not
really needed. The diesel engine here, direct in comparison, the X5 was a little bit more
responsive from the engine, and also, the consumption was lower, like 8 litres on 1km
for the BMW, 9.5 litres for the GLE, so quite notable difference, 30 mpg US or 35 mpg UK
for the X5, but only about 25 mpg US or 30 mpg UK for the GLE. Pricing, also very interesting.
Here, as the test vehicles that are specced today, €116,000 for the BMW X5 and €128,000 for the
Mercedes GLE. Of course, a little bit less if you don't pick this e-active body control, but in most
cases, the GLE will be a little bit more expensive. Again, it always depends on the individual spec.
They both come very close, and they are both excellent vehicles, no doubt about that.
Reliability figures, especially from the US, Consumer Reports indicate lately that BMW,
as a whole brand, has better reliability rankings. Mercedes dropped down significantly there,
and since they test US vehicles, GLE and the GLS are built in the US, so that comes quite close in
that respect. So, when you think about buying and owning and keeping it, then that speaks for the
X5. Leasing then, of course, is something different because you don't carry the risk for that if you
just lease it two or three years under warranty and so on. Overall, taking from all these factors,
the question is what is most important to you. If I would prefer one or the other on design and
exterior, that is not the most important to me. To me, the seating comfort indeed is crucial while
driving, and that is way better with the X5, and, of course, if I buy and own, the reliability aspect.
So, the thing is I love both vehicles, really like to drive both vehicles, but when I just like,
you know, from my gut feeling, would decide which one could I keep still tomorrow and want to drive
with it every day, in that respect then, and everything combined what we mentioned, I would
keep the BMW X5 here today. Which one would you go for and tell me why, tell me in the comments,
and also tune in our other comparisons, Mercedes versus BMW has always been close and very
interesting, and sometimes I go this way, sometimes I go that way. By the way, also,
if it's also a very interesting aspect I want to mention, between GLE and GLC, the smaller brother,
I would pick the GLC. Between X5 and X3,
I would actually go with the X5, that's maybe also another interesting aspect for you.
