Satchel Paige Dominated MLB in His 40s (And 50s) | Baseball Bits

Baseball Channel
134 followers
This video is brought to you by Factor Meals. Adjust your stride this autumn without missing
a step by choosing from Factor's 34 weekly fresh never frozen meals. They're shipped right to your
door and stay stocked in your fridge until you're ready to heat for 2 minutes in the microwave and
enjoy. Tonight's dinner is spicy sweet potatoes with peanut sauce and coconut rice as well as
miso roasted green beans from Factor's Chef's Choice meal plan. I find it to be flavorful
and well-balanced. They also offer vegan, keto, calorie smart, and protein plus selections
depending on your needs. And complementing those meals, try Factor's nutritious beverage options as
well. This is one of their cold pressed juices with carrot, orange, and ginger. So get Factor
and enjoy eating well without the hassle. It's more convenient than a trip to the grocery store
and cheaper than takeout, especially if you use code foolish50 for 50% off your first Factor box.
Again, that's factor75.com code foolish50. No ball player has ever been the subject of
more apocryphal stories than Satchel Paige. They all sound like this. In 1930-11,
whole Satch was barnstorming for the Kalamazoo Haberdashers. When the ghost of Ed Delahanty
waltzed up to the plate, Paige instructed his fielders to take a knee and proceeded to strike
out Big Ed on a 120-mile-per-hour left-handed knuckleball. While walking off the mound,
he caught a baby falling from the grandstand. The baby's name? Bob Gibson. Unlike most Negro League
superstars, Satchel Paige did eventually play Major League Baseball, and the way he dominated
batters in his 40s and 50s suggests some of those tall tales from his younger days had to be true.
See, Paige was the oldest rookie in MLB history,
but he'd been pitching professionally long before Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier.
Paige's workload is the stuff of legend. The lanky hurler kept his own records and
stated that he pitched in over 2,000 games throughout his career.
After pitching semi-professionally in his hometown of Mobile and then in Chattanooga,
he joined the Negro National League's Birmingham Black Barons in 1927.
But Satchel's services were typically non-exclusive. His manager, Bill Gatewood,
frequently loaned him out to other teams during the season. Such was the life of a barnstorming
Negro leaguer. Paige's personal records say he pitched for over 250 teams. In the 1930s,
he pitched for the Pittsburgh Crawfords, whose 1934 squad was headlined by a who's who of
black baseball. Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Oscar Charleston, and Cool Papa Bell,
which is what your girl calls me, all on the same team. And in the 1940s, he was a Kansas City
monarch. The Black Barons, Crawfords, and Monarchs competed in the Negro National
and American Leagues, which have, in recent years, been recognized as major leagues.
But those teams typically only played 70 to 80 games per year, leaving plenty of time for
Satchel to chase a check. He played in Cuba, he played in the Dominican Republic, he played in
Venezuela, he played in Puerto Rico for a team called the Witch Doctors, he played in Bismarck,
North Dakota, which is practically Canada, and he played in Mexico where he blew out his arm.
In fact, in 1938, he woke up one morning unable to lift it at all. He miraculously got his mojo
back, of course, but his career could have ended a decade before his MLB debut.
His barnstorming numbers weren't closely tracked, and the level of competition was likely all over
the place, but you'd be surprised at how complete the stats from his league play against top level
competition with the Black Barons, Crawfords, and Monarchs are. It's just that those games
only constitute a small percentage of his overall playing career. As such, rate stats rather than
counting stats will be the go-to. Among Negro leaguers playing in major leagues,
note the lower case, Page had the third best career earned run average. The only two pitchers
ahead of him were the incomplete careers of Dave Brown and Jose LeBlanc. Dave Brown disappeared
after he was to be questioned about a hurdurm, and Jose LeBlanc was himself hurdurm on the field.
No connection between the two. Anyways, in terms of strikeouts per 9 innings,
Page completely lapped the competition. He was a power pitcher after all, but I don't think any
other pitcher has ever dominated their contemporaries in strikeouts to this extent,
especially not over the course of 20 years. The Negro League barnstorming tradition extended
to interracial matchups. Satchel faced off against white big leaguers frequently. In 1930,
he supposedly struck out 22 batsmen in an exhibition versus Babe Ruth's All-Stars,
although it's worth pointing out Page said he never actually ended up facing the Bambino.
Like most things pertaining to Satchel Page, it depends on who you ask. Ruth's daughter,
Julia Stevens, said Satch struck her father out. Buck O'Neill said Ruth took him deep. And Ruth
Well, anyways. What can't be disputed is the fact that Page fanned 15 hitters in a game versus a
Hackwilson-led, Casey Stengel-managed All-Star team in 1932. It says so on Seamheads.com,
and if it's on Seamheads, it's definitely true. Uh oh. In fact, the Pittsburgh Crawfords won
5 out of 7 games versus their white competition that year. But the most documented of these
matchups came on the cusp of integration. In 1946, Bob Feller, the premier power pitcher of his era,
organized a 15,000-mile, 27-stop barnstorming tour that pioneered air travel in sports.
And with him every step of the way was Satchel Page, who captained his black All-Stars featuring
Hall of Famers like Buck O'Neill and Hilton Smith against Feller's white team which featured Hall
Fans flocked to see how a then 40-year-old Page would fare versus white MLB competition.
But with 27 stops on a whirlwind tour, it wasn't feasible for Satch to toss daily complete games.
Instead, he started the majority of matchups but only pitched a few innings each time to
give everyone a chance to see him. 27-year-old Feller did the same. The following year,
promoters asked both men to face off but for a full 9 innings. The game took place in Los Angeles
on November 2, 1947. And Page out-dueled Feller by shutting out his All-Star team,
striking out 15 while allowing just 4 hits. He was 41 years old.
As far as the talent level between black and white baseball at the time, here's the way I see it.
The top Negro Leagues that Satchel competed in weren't inherently worse than the white American
and National Leagues. Instead, both types of leagues were made lesser by having not been
integrated. The Negro League superstars were just as good if not outright better than MLBs.
Any of the big 4 in Pittsburgh would have dominated. In fact, Oscar Charleston did
just that across a sample size just healthy enough to make the point.
If you look at the most valuable players born between 1930 and 1935,
the integrated generation that followed the likes of Satchel Page, 6 of the top 12,
including the top 2 hitters in Mays and Aaron, as well as the top pitcher in Bob Gibson,
wouldn't have been allowed to play in MLB if they came around earlier.
The top tier talent was always there, it's just that the average black benchwarmer,
replacement level player, or town teamer was probably worse than his white counterpart who
was selected from a larger ethnic population and benefited from a higher paid and more stable
employment. So was Satchel Page better than white pitchers like Bob Feller? Just check out these
rave reviews. Feller called him the best pitcher he ever saw, Joe DiMaggio said he was the best
and fastest pitcher he ever faced, and Ted Williams, who advocated for the inclusion of
Negro leaguers in the Hall of Fame, said Satch was the greatest pitcher in baseball.
When Satchel struck out 15 of Bob Feller's men in 1947, he was auditioning for a role
he thought would never come. Jackie Robinson had broken the color barrier earlier that spring,
but Page hadn't been given the opportunity to follow suit. On July 7th, 1948, Bill Veck's
Cleveland franchise shocked baseball by signing Page on his 42nd birthday. It was seen as a
publicity stunt in comparison to their signing of young Larry Doby, who was already tearing up
integrated baseball as the first black American leaguer. Sports writer J.G. Taylor Spink derided
the move, saying it demeaned the standards of big circuit baseball. But Satchel's performance soon
proved him wrong. On the surface level, his career MLB stats were good, just not legendary,
but I can definitely massage these numbers. We'll begin with ERA+, which normalizes ERA so that 100
is always league average, making it convenient to compare pitchers in different run environments to
one another. Among pitchers from their age 41 seasons and onwards, Satchel Page had the 3rd
best ERA+, in major league history, beating out the likes of Cy Young and Nolan Ryan. The only
two pitchers ahead of him on this list are knuckleballer Hoyt Wilhelm and fireballer Roger
Clemens, who it seems had an anti-aging regimen more potent than Satchel's, which revolved around
avoiding both fried foods and running. Ole Satch was always a power pitcher, but he really made it
clear when he led MLB in strikeouts per 9 innings as a 44-year-old. Strikeouts are also a good
opportunity to use ERA-adjusted stats where 100 is average. The league-wide strikeout rate was 9.5%
when Satchel Page was 41, 14.7% when Nolan Ryan was 41, and is now 22.6% in 2023 when Adam Wainwright
is 41. So, using a stat like K%+, is going to answer the following question. How good were
these geezers against the whippersnappers? In Satchel's case, pretty darn good. His strikeout
rate was 46% higher than league average, even though he made his debut at 42 years of age.
Those are just his MLB stats of course, but if we generate a leaderboard of the best career
K%+, regardless of age, we get a wicked list of names. And using Satchel Page's Negro Leagues and
MLB numbers, he slots in right next to Nolan Ryan. Another great stat is K%-BB% aka strikeout good,
walk bad. Here are the top 10 pitchers in MLB since 2021 by this metric. You can squabble about
the ordering, but it seems like a plausible top 10 list of the best pitchers this decade.
In fact, if you used this stat to determine the best pitchers across baseball history,
it would tell you Walter Johnson and Pete Alexander from the deadball era,
Sandy Koufax and Tom Seaver from the post-integration era, and Pedro Martinez and
Randy Johnson from the steroid era. So it does mean something that Satchel Page led the American
League in strikeout percentage minus walk percentage from 1948 to 1953, and he did so
between the ages of 42 to 47. Imagine what he could have done in his prime. After shutting
out the Chicago White Sox in his rookie, and I'm using air quotes right now, rookie year of 1948,
he told reporters, you should have seen me 5 or 6 years ago. I was twice as good as I am now.
It took a maverick owner like Bill Vech to bring Satchel Page to Cleveland in 1948,
and Page followed Vech to the St. Louis Browns in 1951. The following year, he pitched the best
game of his American League career. The date? August 6th, 1952. The opponent? The Detroit
Tigers. The pitching line? 12 innings, a dozen of them, 7 hits, 2 walks, 9 strikeouts, 0 runs.
In a game that ended in a Browns walkoff. This made him by far the oldest pitcher to
ever toss a 12 inning shutout, besting 40 year old Cy Young. It also represents the
highest game score achieved by a pitcher after their 46th birthday, and that's with all due
respect to Jamie Moyer, who tossed a complete game shutout versus the Braves at 47.
Satchel relished the performance. 4 years after his signing was labeled a gimmick,
he proved once again, in his own words, that he wasn't out there just for laughs.
In the majors, he pitched as a swingman more often than a traditional starter,
a role that suited him perfectly. A team hopping barnstormer at heart, he was used to pitching far
more often than American League starting pitchers operating on a strict 4 or 5 man rotation at the
time. During a spell in Cleveland's rotation, he was once caught napping in the locker room
by his old pal Dizzy Dean. After being asked if he was tired from overwork, Satch replied,
I'm tired from underwork. This is the first time in 20 years I've gone 4 or 5 days without pitching.
This lifestyle also explains why the Negro Leagues weren't a great environment to develop MLB
starting pitching. Don Newcomb did well to sign with the Dodgers at age 20. Satchel Page had no
such luxury. Instead, he put up great numbers with unorthodox usage. In 1952, he became the
only pitcher in the integration era to record 10 saves, 10 wins, and 2 shutouts in the same season.
See, when he did start, he was gonna shut you down. Page started just 26 games, but tossed 4
shutouts in MLB, giving him the best shutout percentage of any MLB starter in the integration
era, a list that includes Bob Gibson and Sandy Koufax. The man was just built to pitch. In 1954,
the year after what many thought would be his final MLB season, he joined a team organized
by Abe Saperstein, owner of the Harlem Globetrotters. According to Satchel Page,
Satchel Page pitched in 148 games that year. And of course, over a decade later, another
Maverick owner in Charlie Finley gave Satchel one last crack at a MLB lineup, signing him to
start a game for his Kansas City Athletics at the age of 59, making him the oldest major leaguer in
history. He proceeded to pitch 3 scoreless innings. The only member of the Red Sox to get a hit off
him was Carl Yastremski. In between frames, he was tended to by nurses while he sat in a large
rocking chair, playing up his old age as part of the publicity stunt. Nobody understood that
baseball was an entertainment product better than Page, who happily went along with the joke.
But when ol' Satch took the mound, he was always going to have the last laugh.
Thank you for watching and thank you to William Cage for the music.
