Pedal Slower, Ride Faster?!

BICYBLE SHOW
111 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
This video is about how to improve your strength on a bike.
I'm going to look at the scientific research as well as what the pros are doing
to see if we can't work out some tips.
Strangely, this is also the most controversial type of training you can do.
Does it work? Does anyone really know?
♪ music ♪
The reason I started thinking about this is because of a video
fellow GCN presenter Conor filmed with Little Trek pro Giulio Ciccone.
They were tackling Ciccone's eponymous training session
on the indoor riding platform Ruvie.
It features both slow and fast cadence drills.
Ciccone actually said it's something he does a lot of.
I really like it because I'm a bit old school,
so I like to keep these efforts in my session.
Because he's old school? What does that mean?
Old school because it doesn't work?
Or old school because there's now a more effective new school?
Or just old school because it's a really traditional type of training
like our old favorite zone two?
Let's try and get to the bottom of it, shall we?
♪ music ♪
Firstly though, what actually is strength?
In the context of going to the gym, it's fairly easy to understand, isn't it?
It's effectively how much you can lift.
On the bike, we don't have that because we have gears.
Well, most of us do anyway.
Gears allow us to produce higher powers
without having to rely on producing more and more brute force.
If we take it back to the gym context,
think of it of instead of lifting a 100 kilo weight 10 times,
you can lift a 25 kilo weight 40 times, do the same amount of work.
In my case, it would be a 10 kilo weight 10 times,
on a good day, 35, and 2.5 kilos 40 times.
♪ music ♪
To better understand this, it helps to know what power actually is.
Measuring watts, it's how much energy you're transferring
from your body through to the bike.
It's a combination both of how fast you're turning the pedals
and how much force you're applying to them.
Now, here's the important bit.
That force is torque measured in newton meters
and is essentially what we're talking about when it comes to strength.
However, as we've just heard, torque is only one component of power.
The other is cadence.
To give an example, riding at 400 watts and pedaling at 100 RPM
requires the same amount of torque, the same force through the pedals
as riding at 200 watts but pedaling at just 50 RPM.
You can see then that because we have gears on our bikes,
you don't need to actually produce much torque to put out loads of power.
Yes, you will do to win a sprint at the Tour de France
or to drop Mathieu van der Poel or Lotte Kopecky at the Tour of Flanders,
but for longer efforts, not so much.
It's why someone like Tadej Pogacar, an absolute monster of a rider,
still looks like a bit of a stick man.
However, there has long been a school of thought in cycling
that you can improve your power output by doing specific strength training.
Deliberately producing more force for a specific training response,
the result of which is hopefully that you improve your power,
not at sprint levels but at VO2 max and crucially, aerobically as well.
Why did Ciccone say that low cadence work is old school?
Because I'm a bit old school, no?
It has been around since the early 1980s, which is very old school because so have I.
To be fair, low cadence work has probably existed since long before then,
mainly due to the limitations of the bikes of the time,
but we're getting sidetracked here.
In the 80s, the legendary Italian coach Aldo Sassi supposedly invented
modern low cadence work, coining the phrase SFR training.
It's an acronym that stands for Salita Forza Resistente.
Climb, Strength, Resistance. That's right.
His concept is to do blocks of slow pedaling in a hard gear up a hill
to get your muscles to produce more force.
The exact cadence you use is up for debate, between 40 and 60 revolutions a minute,
as is the duration of each interval, in fact, but typically five-minute blocks,
and at a power that is also, surprise, surprise, up for debate,
but typically just below to just above FTP,
which is in inverted commas because this too is a controversial topic,
but when I say FTP, you all know what I mean,
which is kind of more important than being correct sometimes.
Pedants, please accept my apologies.
Anyway, this type of low cadence training, as I said, has been going on now
for over 40 years and continues today all over the place, in fact,
from Zwift workouts right through to cutting edge of world tour coaching.
The theory behind it is that by getting your muscles to produce more force,
you're getting a different training stimulus.
This different training stimulus comes from the fact that you can easily produce
more torque for five minutes pedaling at a slow cadence
than you ever could by pedaling at a normal cadence.
Here, for example, I'm doing 350 watts at 50 RPM,
something I could easily do for five-minute intervals,
but if I was pedaling at 100 RPM at the same torque,
I'd be doing 700 watts, something that I can only do for 30 seconds.
There's some anecdotal evidence that this type of training
causes more muscle damage when you do it,
leading, therefore, you'd hope, to more muscle synthesis
and also an increase in testosterone production,
both of which are reasons that sound pretty compelling to me.
Why all the controversy?
Well, here's the thing.
There's not really been any scientific evidence to show that it works.
The odd paper suggests some benefit,
but typically, they might have had a small sample size
or they've only tested for four weeks or so.
Basically, in a meta-analysis in 2016,
Hanson and Ronestad said exactly this.
There was no real evidence.
Critics of low-cadence training point not only to this lack of research evidence,
but also potential for injury coming from placing more force through your knees.
Plus, lovers of specificity will argue that you should train what you want to improve
and pointing to this, therefore, making you better only at pedaling slowly,
which is definitely not what you want.
Now, to those people,
I would remind them that while specificity is definitely a thing,
it's not black and white.
Take, for example, doing loads of Zone 2 work
and yet still seeing your FTP improve.
Yes, there might be a risk of injury,
but personally, I think as long as your cadence doesn't drop below 40 RPM,
it's probably fairly minimal.
Plus, by pedaling slowly,
you can also give yourself time and space to concentrate more on your technique
so you can actually do it better,
relaxing your upper body, no rocking and rolling.
While there hasn't been much scientific research to validate low-cadence work,
or really any,
a paper published at the end of 2024 by Hebbis and Hebbis
does seem pretty robust,
taking 26 well-trained female cyclists
and putting them through an eight-week polarized training program.
Half of them did the sprint and high-intensity intervals at a low cadence,
the other half at their normal self-selected cadence.
Whilst all participants improved their VO2 max by a similar amount,
low-cadence trainers improved more across the board
at aerobic powers plus their FTP.
FTP, in inverted commas again.
What's really interesting though,
is that whilst there seems to be limited scientific evidence
for the benefits of low-cadence work,
there is a lot for going to the gym and lifting weights,
which is weird really because it's not that popular among riders,
both mortals and pros alike,
although it is increasing in popularity at the top end.
Now, it might be that more research has simply been done on this topic,
but it's also quite likely that it's simply just more effective
and it certainly seems pretty much beyond doubt
as to whether or not weight training can be beneficial for cycling.
Now, what constitutes weight training,
in the scientific literature at least,
seems to be focusing on lower limb exercises,
doing three sets of your traditional four to ten rep maxes
about twice a week,
which actually doesn't sound that bad.
Now, one study I particularly liked,
albeit one with a small sample size,
so draw from it what you will,
showed that doing strength training
in addition to your normal on-the-bike training
was far more effective at improving your power outputs
across your power curve compared to doing core work
in addition to normal on-bike training,
which showed there was no benefit at all to it, in fact,
compared to doing no off-bike training at all.
Any reason to bin off core work is a good one in my book.
Definitely food for thought there.
What should you do?
Limited evidence for low-cadence work,
but beloved of pro cyclists and world tour coaches alike,
or weight training which has fewer fans but more evidence?
I'm theorizing here,
but I think low-cadence work is going to be more beneficial
for those who are already doing a lot of training,
like 10 hours a week plus.
That's because if you're doing less training,
so my theory goes,
you also have more time to recover,
so you can make more of your training sessions harder.
Do a full fat VO2 max session or threshold efforts.
Go deep.
The more hours you have to train, though,
the more you need to hold back.
Pro cyclists spend a much higher proportion of their riding time
at zone one and zone two
because any more and it would simply be too hard.
Low-cadence training fits in really nicely
because it's potentially a great training stimulus
that isn't demanding as big high-intensity efforts.
Like I said, I am theorizing here,
but I can see less benefit, therefore, for time crunch trainers.
I also think it depends a lot on your training history.
If you're fairly new to riding,
you can make gains fairly easily.
It's only when you've been doing it a lot
that you need to start looking harder
for how to make those improvements.
If you want to give this a try,
whilst I wouldn't recommend doing the same session over and over again,
you could get started with this classic.
Six times four minutes at 50 RPM
at about 90% to 95% of your FTP.
That's FTP with three minutes of recovery in between.
Now, you will need to do this on a good climb
or on your indoor trainer simulating a good climb.
As we've seen, there is quite a large body of evidence
to show that gym training can be really beneficial for cycling.
Its lack of popularity, I think, can be explained by its one major flaw,
which is it's not cycling.
Although, there is a potential upside to it,
which is that it's not cycling.
By this, I mean that if you're watching this,
you probably really like riding bikes.
Therefore, doing some kind of training that doesn't involve cycling
is potentially going to be harder to motivate yourself for,
potentially less fun.
Certainly, in my case, I wouldn't want to miss out on going for a bike ride
because I'm having to go to the gym
because I love bike riding and I don't really like the gym.
Although, this one is very nice, as you can see.
Now, it might well be, though,
that you can go to the gym on a day
where you wouldn't be able to fit a bike ride in.
Perhaps, you can sneak out of work at lunchtime and fit a session in.
You may well find that you can squeeze more gym work in,
in addition to your normal riding,
and therefore, turbocharge your cycling in a way
that you wouldn't be able to otherwise.
If that's the case, then 100%, I would recommend doing it.
As we've heard from the science,
you only need to do two sessions a week in order for it to be beneficial.
The one thing I would bear in mind, though,
is that when you start out doing it,
you'll probably find that your cycling will suffer, temporarily at least,
because going to the gym in the early stages is really demanding
and you may well find you are absolutely knackered, but push through.
One reason to proceed carefully, though,
is that while there might be a slight risk of injury
by doing low cadence work on the bike,
going rogue in a gym is far, far riskier.
Seek some good advice before you dive in to a strength conditioning program.
After all of this, what should you do?
Well, I am no coach nor a sports scientist,
but I can tell you one thing for certain.
Try it.
Experiments.
Without wishing to sound like a self-help book for children,
you are unique.
What training is going to work best for you
depends on your physiology, your training history,
how much time you have to train, and what you are actually training for.
The best coach in the world isn't going to know exactly
how to get the best out of you instantly,
but what they will do is to try things,
to experiment, and then observe what happens.
Now, I remember well the feeling that time is really precious with training.
You don't want to experiment,
committing to a certain type of training for months
if you think it's not going to work for you.
It can feel too risky, like you're wasting your time.
But, now I'm old, I can see that with the benefit of hindsight
that experimenting more would have been time well spent for me.
The key is just to do it in a systematic way.
Take note of how fit you are, then change something.
One thing only though, do it for a few weeks, six minimum,
observe how the training goes, and then test yourself again.
Did the training feel easier or harder?
Did you enjoy it?
Crucially, did you get fitter?
Actually, maybe it should be, did you get fitter?
And crucially, did you enjoy it?
Not just your 20-minute power, but your 10 seconds,
your 30 seconds, your one minute, your five minute, your three-hour power.
If it's positive, keep doing it.
Negative, stop.
By approaching training in this way,
you can start to build a picture of what works for you.
It's highly likely that both low-cadence work and gym work will be a benefit,
but you'll only truly know by trying it out.
Now, I will say having a power meter really helps here.
It does allow you to train and monitor your form in a really precise and controlled way,
but you don't need one.
Having a couple of different climbs that you ride as hard as you can from time to time
will give you a great insight into your fitness.
Ideally, I'd have a four to five-minute climb that I did,
and then if possible, 10 to 20-minute climb.
For my money, both weights and low-cadence training have their place,
and I would recommend that you try them.
After all, variety is the spice of training.
Remember that. Write it down, in fact.
Now, I'd be super interested to hear your thoughts on all of this.
Do you do gym work? Do you do low-cadence work?
Have you done it and stopped?
What's it been like?
Get involved in the comment section because I think collectively,
we can crowd-source a whole load more information down there.
Please do get involved.
Also, give this video a thumbs up if you've enjoyed it.
I think I'm going to go hit the gym.
