Ban Gu, who wrote The Book of Han, is one of the most important historians. Yet like all historians, he was not infallible. Dong Xian was one such casualty.
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount.
Unveiling the Forgotten, the Forbidden, and the Divine — a journey through China’s lost wisdom and a return to timeless tradition.
In the Qing Dynasty, long after the glory of the Han Empire had faded into dust,
a minor official named Yuan Gongtao was sent to Shaanxi on an assignment, overseeing local
affairs and praying for rain during a long drought. One day, while wandering near the
foot of a low hill, he stumbled upon a strange little temple, dusty, half-collapsed, overgrown
with moss. Inside stood a single statue, a slender, elegant figure in Han Dynasty robes,
carved with almost feminine grace. Something about it felt…uneasy. Yuan frowned. Was it an evil
shrine? Though the place had clearly been neglected for years, he decided then and there to tear it
That night Yuan had a dream. A young man in Han robes appeared before him,
pale face, composed eyes, and an air of quiet dignity.
I am Dong Xian, Grand Marshal of the Han, he said. I was wrongfully condemned and executed
by the usurper Wang Meng. However, the Emperor of Heaven, moved by my innocence,
elevated me to divine status. I was granted the title Great Lord of Rain,
protector of the region's weather and seasons. The name Dong Xian struck a chord. Yuan Gongtao
stared at him, trying to reconcile the serene figure before him with the scandalous image
history had preserved. According to Han Shu, the Book of Han by Bengu, Dong Xian's extraordinary
beauty had won him the adoration of Emperor of Han. In one famous episode, Emperor and Dong Xian
napped together on the couch. When the Emperor awoke, Dong was still sleeping peacefully.
Rather than disturb him, the Emperor ordered his sleeve to be cut off. This gesture gave rise to
the phrase the cut-sleeve habit, a phrase that came to symbolize same-sex love. Over time,
the palace of Weiyang had long crumbled to dust, but Dong Xian's tarnished image lived on,
portrayed as a symbol of decadence, a beautiful man who seduced a ruler and weakened the throne.
Bengu had written Dong Xian into history as a cautionary tale. But in the dream,
Dong Xian pleaded for justice. I am not the villain they made me out to be, he said bitterly.
Nor the parasite Bengu described. I served the Han court with unwavering loyalty,
no less than Wei Qing or Hua Qiubing. I led troops. I commanded the imperial guard.
And though the Emperor loved me, I never crossed the bounds of morality.
As they spoke, a gaunt, shackled figure appeared, dragged forward by two ugly demons.
The man was emaciated, his head bare, his eyes hollow. Dong Xian pointed at him.
This is Wang Meng, the traitor who usurped the Han throne. For his crimes, he's been condemned
to the desolate mountains of Yinshan Mountain, where snakes bite him day and night. Now he
serves under me. His punishment is to clean the latrines of the underworld. For even the smallest
error, he is beaten with iron whips. The image of the once-powerful usurper, reduced to such a fate,
sent a chilling reminder of the cosmic justice that had befallen him.
Yuan Gongtao awoke with a shiver. The next day, Yuan Gongtao donated funds to repair the shrine.
He offered pigs and sheep in sacrifice. That night, Dong Xian appeared to him once more.
Thank you for restoring my temple, he said. But I have no one to share the sacrifices with.
It is rather lonely here. There was a man named Zhu Su, a loyal retainer.
After my death, when no one dared touch my body, he buried me with dignity. For this,
Wang Meng had him killed. I was deeply grateful for his kindness and petitioned the Emperor of
Heaven. His son, Zhu Fu, was blessed to become the Grand Minister of the Han under Emperor Guangwu.
Please honor him as well. Yuan Gongtao was moved.
He commissioned a statue of Zhu Su to stand beside Dong Xian's. He also had a statue made
of Wang Meng as a prisoner, kneeling at the foot of the shrine. From that day on,
every prayer for good weather was answered. Rain came when needed. The skies cleared when asked.
Bengu, who wrote the Book of Han, is one of the most important historians.
Bengu's work meticulously chronicled the Western Han dynasty,
shaping the way history would be understood for centuries. Yet like all historians, he was not
infallible. Neither Bengu nor his predecessor Sima Qian were immune to personal bias or the limits
of their time. Sima Qian, in his Shijie, Records of the Grand Historian, adopted a deeply personal
voice. His histories were filled with emotion, philosophy, and moral reflection. Bengu, by
contrast, was more methodical. His tone more formal, his structure tighter. But that precision
came with its own flaws. Where Sima Qian might wrestle with moral ambiguity, Bengu leaned toward
narratives. Both men left invaluable legacies. But they also left behind human errors,
portraits skewed by their perspectives. Dong Xian was one such casualty. History wasn't
Bengu's only passion. He also believed the Game of Go revealed the very nature of kingship,
morality, even the universe itself. In his essay Yizhi, The Principles of Go,
Bengu argued that the Go board was a cosmic map. The board must be square. This reflects
the structure of the earth. The pieces must move by rules. This reflects the virtue of heaven.
To Bengu, Go wasn't just a pastime. It was political theory in action. The black and
white stones embodied yin and yang, opposing forces that must be balanced. A rash move could
destroy a kingdom. A patient strategy could preserve one. There is no victory without
restraint. There is no peace without structure. Each game mirrored the rise and fall of dynasties.
Every clash of stones, a lesson in power, caution, and foresight. The true master wasn't
the one who won quickly, but the one who thought a hundred moves ahead. Today, Go remains one of
the world's oldest strategy games. But thanks to Bengu, it also lives on as a silent reflection
of leadership and the delicate art of rule. That's it for the story of Dong Xian, Bengu,
and the ghost who pleaded for justice. If you enjoyed this, leave a comment, like, and share.
See you next time.