From Prosperity to Poverty: The Fall of China’s Middle Class

China Truths
61 followers
"0:00 Intro
0:25 From Prosperity to Poverty: The Fall of China’s Middle Class
5:37 An SUV in Fujian Crashes into Crowd, Causing Multiple Casualties
7:19 Apple: Most iPhones Sold in the US Will No Longer Be Made in China
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
China's middle class has grown at an astonishing pace over the past few decades.
From the late 1970s to the 1990s, expanding job opportunities lifted Chinese farmers out
of abject poverty and enabled a large swath of the urban working population to accumulate
a degree of wealth.
Today, however, that once miraculous economic ascent is faltering dramatically amid a housing
market collapse and the sharp erosion of China's export competitiveness in the face
of intensifying competition from the United States and Europe.
The regime now finds itself besieged by an avalanche of challenges.
In addition to the lasting effects of past crises, China is grappling with a steep population
decline, which has triggered a structural shortage of workers.
To address this, the government has aggressively turned to Automation and Artificial Intelligence
Further accelerating a wage divide that has already wreaked havoc in developed economies
across North America and Europe.
For China's vast middle class, the slowdown has hit like a tidal wave.
The economy is stagnating and living standards are deteriorating.
Exports have barely budged over the past five years due to relentless tariffs and escalating
trade barriers from the West.
Meanwhile, many U.S., European, and Japanese companies have begun decoupling from Chinese
Striking another heavy blow to China's economic engine.
Although Chinese exports to the United States have recently seen a modest uptick, this surge
is merely short-term inventory stocking ahead of another round of Trump-era tariffs.
Not a sign of any real recovery, but the most devastating blow has come from China's real
estate meltdown, which erupted in 2021.
The implosion of major developers has frozen home buying and construction activity, undermining
the construction sector that once served as a critical pillar of national growth.
The crash has decimated property values, gutting personal wealth and throwing millions into
financial limbo.
With the majority of household assets tied up in housing, the collapse in home prices
has inflicted massive losses on family net worth.
In desperation, many have slashed consumption and hoarded savings, sapping what little domestic
demand remained and deepening the economic malaise.
With these forces dragging on growth, even Beijing's already lowered target of 5% real
GDP now looks increasingly out of reach.
No group has been more exposed to this economic unraveling than China's middle class.
Once the proud symbol of the nation's rise, they are now being squeezed hard.
Wage growth, once a reliable ladder to prosperity, has slowed dramatically.
From 9% in 2018 to a paltry 4-5% in recent years, bonuses have plunged, falling nearly
18% year-on-year.
In 2024, income tax revenues in Beijing dropped 16%, reflecting both falling incomes and eroding
job security.
European luxury brands, once popular among aspirational urbanites, now report sales declines
of 18-20% in China.
And yet, Beijing has shown little sign of a coherent plan to stop the bleeding.
The middle class, long seen as the engine of consumption and social stability, now faces
unrelenting pressure from both stagnant wages and rising uncertainty.
With Trump's tariffs tightening their grip and Beijing's retaliatory measures stifling
trade, the hardship is bound to intensify.
Even if the leadership somehow overcomes short-term obstacles, deeper structural headwinds threaten
the very foundation of China's middle class.
Demographic realities are tightening the noose.
The one-child policy, which lasted from 1979 to 2015, crushed the birth rate and left China
with an aging population and a shrinking labor pool.
Today, there are fewer than four working-age people per retiree.
By 2030, that number will plummet below three, a demographic cliff with no soft landing.
With little immigration to fill the gap, China faces a full-blown labor crunch.
In theory, scarcity should push wages up and bolster middle-class incomes.
In practice, the opposite is unfolding.
To address labor shortages and rising costs, Beijing has doubled down on technology, promoting
AI and robotics as solutions to declining workforce numbers.
But this shift is remaking the labor market, cutting out countless frontline and blue-collar
jobs while increasing demand for technical and managerial roles.
Positions out of reach for many.
This trend mirrors what has unfolded in the West.
A hollowing out of the working class, a surge in income inequality, and widespread social discontent.
But in China, the effect is even more severe due to its demographic pressures and near-total
lack of immigration.
What makes matters worse is China's fragile social safety net.
Unlike Western nations, China lacks the infrastructure to support workers displaced by automation.
While the government has floated proposals, such as expanding pensions for gig and temporary
workers, these remain largely theoretical.
And with Beijing still failing to stabilize the current crisis, it's unclear whether any
long-term fixes will ever materialize.
An SUV in Fujian crashes into crowd, causing multiple casualties.
On the evening of May 2, an SUV in Fuzhou, Fujian reportedly ran a red light and collided
with multiple vehicles and pedestrians, resulting in severe injuries.
The SUV continued moving forward, pushing another vehicle and striking pedestrians and
Thick smoke and dust were seen at the scene.
Reports indicate that information related to the incident has since been restricted on Weibo.
A netizen named wuwangwudi posted several videos showing the SUV speeding into vehicles
waiting at a red light and pedestrians at Wuyi Square.
The footage captured a chaotic and tragic scene.
Some speculated about the cause of the incident, though no official explanation beyond improper
control has been confirmed.
A witness, Mr. Bi, told media that he was waiting at the intersection when the incident
occurred.
I was terrified, he said.
According to Mr. Bi, law enforcement quickly arrived at the scene, blocked the road, evacuated
bystanders and asked those recording videos to delete them.
According to Lianhe Zhaobao, the traffic police department of the Fuzhou City Public Security
Bureau reported that at around 6.50 p.m., a vehicle struck another car and a passing
electric bicycle, resulting in multiple injuries.
Two people died after medical treatment failed while others are being treated.
The driver has been detained and the case is under investigation.
Reports in social media posts related to the incident have been removed from platforms
such as Weibo, Douyin and Xiaohongshu.
This has led to public concern and online discussions about the availability and transparency
of information surrounding the crash.
Apple.
Most iPhones sold in the U.S. will no longer be made in China.
In a bold shift with far-reaching implications, Apple CEO Tim Cook announced on Thursday,
May 1, that the majority of iPhones and other Apple products sold in the United States will
no longer be made in China.
Instead, production is rapidly pivoting to India and Vietnam, clear winners as geopolitical
tensions escalate and the U.S.-China tariff war deepens.
Cook revealed that, within the next few months, India will take over as the primary production
hub for iPhones sold in the American market.
Meanwhile, Vietnam is set to become the new manufacturing powerhouse for iPads, Macs,
Apple Watches and AirPods destined for U.S. consumers.
During Apple's quarterly earnings call, Cook stated,
CNN reported that, as of now, around 90% of iPhone production, the crown jewel of Apple's
product line, still takes place in China.
But according to Cook, that's about to change.
In the future, the majority of iPhones sold in the U.S. will be made in India.
This dramatic reshaping of Apple's global supply chain underscores the profound impact
of former President Trump's aggressive tariff regime on Chinese imports.
The U.S. currently imposes tariffs of at least 145% on most Chinese goods.
Though smartphones and some semiconductor-based electronics have been spared the full brunt
of these tariffs, Apple's China-made products still face substantial import duties, some
as high as 20%.
Our supply chain is vast and intricate.
Concentrating so much of it in a single country has proven to be a major strategic risk, Cook
said.
The BBC noted that Patrick Moorhead, CEO of Moor Insights and Strategy, called the shift
of iPhone production to India impressive.
This is a stark reversal from what Cook claimed just a few years back, when he said that only
China can make iPhones, Moorhead said.
Apple still has a long way to go, but this is a very strong step forward.
Apple isn't alone in this strategic repositioning.
Amazon, too, is accelerating efforts to insulate itself from geopolitical and economic shocks.
The company is urging greater diversification among sellers on its platform.
CEO Andy Jassy emphasized Amazon's preparedness, citing the company's massive scale and key
role in supplying essential goods.
Beijing's famous business community used to be bustling with people, but now the streets
are deserted.
What's going on recently?
Brothers, this is a night market.
Why is the night market, which was once bustling, so deserted?
There is no business at the stalls and there is no business in the shops.
Why is it so deserted?
Is there going to be a war?
You said that China's population is not small at 1.4 billion, so why don't you see anyone
coming out?
From 8 o'clock in the morning until now, let alone opening, there is not even a child.
Affected by the overall economic environment in China, Beijing is becoming more and more
depressed.
A large number of shops have closed down, more and more people are fleeing Beijing,
and many restaurants have no customers.
And the situation of workers seems to be even more serious.
According to reports, some part-time workers in Majuqiao are facing the dilemma of one
day full and three days hungry.
Today, we will talk about related topics.
Let me show you how difficult it is to run a physical business now.
This is why I don't recommend you invest in physical stores if you have some spare money.
I live in a community in the East Fifth Ring Road of Beijing.
As soon as I leave this community, these three stores are all closed.
They have been closed for more than half a year and they have not been rented out yet.
In this hot pot food supermarket, a plate of beef or something costs 70, 80 or more
than 100 yuan, which is very expensive.
Who comes here to buy?
These are ordinary people.
These two stores have been vacant for more than two months, but they have not been rented
out.
The location is very good next to the community entrance.
You see, this one is newly rented out, selling flower tea.
I don't even need to think about it.
It will definitely not make money.
Who drinks tea?
Who buys flowers?
Four or five stores near my community have closed down, but it is still open.
There is another empty store here with a large area of 246 square meters, with upper and
lower floors.
I tell you, there is no store in this area that has been developing stably for a long
time.
Beijing Zhongguankun Entrepreneurship Street was officially opened in June 2014.
It used to be very lively here, but now there are no people on the street.
The blogger said in the video that Zhongguankun represents the forefront of Beijing's technology.
He experienced the glory days of Zhongguankun and was shocked to see it become empty in
just a few years.
It's really good.
This bookstore is still there, called China Bookstore.
But this Zhongguankun Entrepreneurship Street has completely failed.
There is also a security guard with a red hoop.
All the people in Zhongguankun Entrepreneurship Street have moved away.
It used to be very lively here.
Majuqiao, in the southeastern suburbs of Beijing, is a job-seeking spot for migrant workers
looking for odd jobs.
There is a saying in Beijing that, if you are in trouble, you must go to Majuqiao.
However, in recent years, Majuqiao has seen a situation of too many people, too few jobs
and lower wages, reflecting the current dilemma of the mainland's employment market.
Have you ever seen a labor market at 4 a.m.?
This is the most inclusive place in Beijing, Majuqiao.
Can you imagine it?
The most common people here are 50- and 60-year-olds, and a backpack is enough to hold all their
homes.
When it is below zero on the street at 4 a.m., some people are still asleep, while others
have already carried their life bags.
Here, a breakfast of 5 or 6 yuan can fill their stomachs.
After all, only when you are full can you have the energy to work.
Today, the lowest wage is 130 yuan for 8 hours and 260 yuan for 12 hours.
You can do express delivery sorting, mud removal and brick moving as long as you have the strength.
Whenever a boss says he wants to recruit workers, they will quickly surround him.
Because in the world of Majuqiao, not being active means no food to eat, and only by working
hard can you win more opportunities.
As long as you are selected, it means you have a way to live today.
I saw someone on the internet saying that Beijing is good, but too tiring.
Some people come with dreams and can only leave crying in the end.
It is difficult for people who do odd jobs in Beijing to find jobs, and it is also difficult
for college graduates to find jobs.
Blogger Guo Guo said that there are three college students in her family, all of whom
are unemployed.
There are three college students in my family who are all unemployed.
I'm looking for a job in Tianjin, my sister is looking for a job in Zhengzhou, and my
brother is looking for a job in our hometown.
I worked in Beijing for five years before moving to Tianjin.
I came to Tianjin for the postgraduate entrance examination last year.
I started looking for a job in February this year, but I haven't found one yet.
