Stirring up Membership-Recipes for Successful Club's & Growth: Cindie Kish-District 7210 Learning Assembly, 2025

Minisink Kindness Rotary Club
196 followers
563 Video Views·May 5, 2025
Kenote Speaker: Cindie Kish-District 7210 Learning Assembly, NewPaltz High School, May 3rd, 2025
She is the Rotary Coordinator for Zone 32 and was the chair most recently for the Mid-North
East Multidistrict PELS 2025 that was just in New Jersey. She's our very own Cindy Kish.
Cindy has an impressive history of service and leadership within Rotary. She has served at the
zone level, the district level, where she currently serves on our district executive board.
She's also held various roles including district finance chair, director of youth programs,
assistant governor, district conference chair, district trainer, and district governor for the
2019-2020 year. A member of Millbrook Rotary, Cindy has dedicated over 20 years to Rotary,
holding numerous positions and becoming a major donor and Paul Harris Society member.
Beyond her remarkable achievements in Rotary, she also has co-founded and managed Hunt and Harvest,
a full-service catering and event company. It is truly a privilege to welcome such an accomplished
Rotarian and friend. Please welcome me and join me in giving a warm welcome to Cindy Kish.
Good morning 7210.
How's everyone doing? Are we pumped? Yeah. Are we motivated? Yes. Are we ready to dive out of an
airplane? Years ago, if you remember, I actually did a challenge for polio. Does anyone remember
that where I was going to jump out of an airplane to raise money and then COVID happened and I
couldn't do it so I was a little bummed about that but you know it could happen again and here's what
I think. I think that we have a new Rotary fellowship that can happen. The skydiving
fellowship. You can start that. It's a real thing. You can do that. So I think we're on our way
to extending membership right now. Right through that. It's going to be perfect. Yeah. So
who attended president-elect learning and okay so some of you are going to hear this
again. It might be a few little things that are different but then you can quiz me or you can
tell me what I messed up on this time or what I did better or what I did okay. We'll go on. So why
am I wearing this this apron right? Why am I wearing this apron? Who knows? You can tell me
why I'm wearing this apron. Anyone? I am going to give you some recipes right? We're going to do
something a little bit different. I've got the clicker here in all my pockets. Let me find it.
Here it is. So yes, we're going to stir up and I'm going to give you some recipes for membership
because standing up here and just getting statistics can be a little boring and
personally that's not my style or who I am. So I thought we'd try something a little bit
different because we need to start doing things differently. Rotary, in spite of what a lot of
people say, if I were to ask you is Rotary a service organization? Most of you are going to
raise your hand but you see Rotary is the membership organization that does service
and we're having a major problem right now especially in North America. Our membership
numbers are down so we need to start taking chances. We need to start doing things differently
except for you, Judy, because I know that you were a membership magnet and you were awesome. I know it.
So you're going to humor me a little bit, those of you who are awesome,
because not all of us are. Just like Melanie was saying, some of us get a little cringy about
asking people but we need to do that. So we're going to stir things up and we're going to talk
a little bit about some recipes for successful clubs and for growth but we're going to start
a memorable meal that you have had at a Rotary. Anyone else like to share a Rotary meal? Yes,
Wendy, right? It's who you're with. It's what you're trying. You're next to the ocean
and you have wonderful sound and that breeze and that smell. There are so many things that
make up that memorable event. It's more than one thing. It's a multi-layered experience
just like your Rotary experience is multi-layered. It's not just one thing that keeps you coming
back. There are many things that keep you here as Rotarians and just like your Rotary experience
is unique to you, all of our clubs are different and unique and that's a good thing. It's a good
thing that each of our clubs have their own individual personality because then we can focus
on different things. We can be more impactful with food and security. We can be more impactful
with helping children when we're focused on multiple things but have a baseline, a basic
recipe for success. We should all make sure that we have these irresistible things in our club
to make sure that we are thriving and healthy. We need to work together. We need to be supportive.
We need a little bit of networking and we need to make sure we recognize our people and say
thank you for all. We need to have dynamic service. You see the last one here, growth and learning.
Each and every one of you here today have that opportunity. We have so many things that we can
do as Rotarians. It's absolutely amazing but we should have this recipe as an irresistible club.
Each and every one of us has that baseline. So if you're not there, if your club is not there,
hopefully I can help you out a little bit today. We're going to talk about three things to help
your club get that irresistible, craveable experience. The first thing is a club experience
we're going to touch on. Next, satellite and I know people are afraid of the word satellite club
we're going to do a little spin on that and then third we're going to mix it all together with a
little bit of planning. So the first thing, was I too close over there? First thing we're going to
talk about is the club experience because Rotary's research will tell us that that's the most
important aspect of anyone, the club experience. And the club experience is made up of five key
spices, five key elements that make up that club experience. The first one is meeting enjoyment.
Are meetings fun? Is everyone included? And do we have time for fellowship? Now here's where I'm
going to bring in a little restaurant. When I think of meeting enjoyment, it's my local burger joint.
I go in and I order my burger. Now I like my burger with meat and cheese and lettuce, tomato
and mayonnaise but you can go in and you can have whatever kind of burger you want at your local
burger joint. When I walk into my local burger joint and I order that burger and it arrives
and I pick up that juicy burger on that brioche bun and the juice runs down my arm. I can't wait
to enjoy it. It's not a BLT but it is a burger and I love it. I love that burger so much.
But when I'm walking out the door, I can't wait to get back because it was more than that burger
too at my local burger joint. I know the waitstaff and because it's my local place,
I know the people that are there. Just like our meetings need to be that way, we need to be
craveable. We're walking out the door, we need to, we can't wait to get back. That's the way they
need to be. Just like that burger, I want to go back there. I want to have that. I want to see my
friends. I want to say hello. Our meetings need to be craveable, a craveable experience. We can't wait
to get back. The next thing is confidence in club leadership. Now we need to make sure that
every single one of our members have the opportunity to be a leader. That we're not
just keeping it this tightly knit group that, oh Bob, no you can't, no you haven't been in the club long,
no you don't have enough experience. Everyone needs to be able to come to the table and have
that opportunity and when you're there, you need to be supportive of our leaders because
they're not up there just taking chances, they're taking risks. They're not diving out of a plane, but they're still
taking risks. It can be intimidating to get up there and lead your club. When it comes to the
restaurant industry, I think of the nice restaurant that I like to go to once a year, my favorite
restaurant. I walk in, I know I can order anything on the menu, anything because I know it's going to
come to me well prepared, perfect temperature because I have confidence in who's in the kitchen
and what's going on. I understand, I know that they have protocols and procedures in place
even if the executive chef isn't there. I know they're going to make that experience the best
experience for me. I have confidence in them and we all need to make sure that we have confidence
in our leadership and we talk to our leaders if we don't to make sure that we're having that
wonderful overall experience. The next thing is personal growth opportunities and here just like
confidence and leadership, we need to make sure that every one of our members has the opportunity
to step forward because where else can you go? You used to do Riff Fest, you know, Kyron, where are you?
Yeah, I mean who would have thought at your club that you could have done an event like that?
The personal growth that each and every one of your members has the opportunity to do
is amazing. We need to make sure that we're recognizing when things happen. So many people
join Rotary because they say I want to network, I want to grow, I want to learn and this is it.
This is our cherry on top, the personal growth opportunities and what we can do to help our
members grow. So I, like all of you, live here in the Hudson Valley and we have the great fortune
of being very close to the CIA, right? The Culinary Institute of America for those of you who don't
know. Not the CIA where we're spying and we're doing all that and in my business we have probably
30 times 40 CIA students a year that come through. In the first couple years we started doing this,
they'd come and go and then when we started getting these students in, I started taking
pictures of them when they would first arrive. One of their boards, they're cutting things and
they don't know yet the right knife skills but I'm taking a picture and I'm acknowledging that
they're here and after about six months when it's time for them to leave, I come back around
and I take another picture and I started sharing those two pictures with those kids. The impact
and the acknowledgement that they felt because they felt seen. They could see the growth,
they could see in their face how nervous they were from that first photo to the confidence that they
had six months later and yet we can all do that in our clubs. We can all take the opportunity to
acknowledge and show the growth that each and every one of our members have the opportunity.
So connections, this is our secret sauce as Rotarians. The connections that we make,
the feeling that we have. How many people, when you say Rotary, do you say that's my Rotary family?
You say it. I say it all the time. My Rotary family is invaluable to me because of the connections I
make. I may have come in for different reasons but this is why I stay. Because of the connections,
the people that I know, the people I can call no matter what happens, that's it.
So we need to make sure that we are enabling and have a space for us to have those deep connections.
You know we have family meal every day in my business. Each of my key people take turns making
family meal. I learn more from family meal than any other time. Who's sitting with whom,
who's over by themselves, who's talking about the vacation, who's acting disgruntled.
Yet as Rotarians, how many of our meetings happen around a meal? Are we taking the time to listen
and to look who's sitting with who? Do we have cliques in our club?
You may not even realize you're part of a clique in your club. So use that time,
use that family meal to make sure that you have that connection that's so needed in Rotary.
And the last thing is meaningful service. Now this is our hook for so many people and it's
how we can get so many people in is with that meaningful service. But if each and every one
of you went in to your cupboard, your cabinet, your pantry and you pulled out any ingredient,
I don't care what it is, rice, tomatoes, anything. Pick it up, look at it, flip it over.
There's an expiration date or there's a best if used by date. Some of our service has expired.
Some of it is no longer as appetizing as it used to be. Now that doesn't mean we have to throw
everything away. We still have time to mix in those tomatoes but we may not want to make that tomato
sauce. We may want to do something else with that. So take the time to look at your service
because it needs to be reflected of your current membership. You're not just doing it because well
that's what we've done for the last 20 years. And so it's a habit. We get into that same rut,
take a chance, flip it over, add some new spices, add some new members, ask what they want to do.
It's okay to retire something and bring something else on. It could be bigger and better than what
you had before. It's meaningful service. So now it's time to look in the mirror and this can be
tough and this is where assistant governors, if you're out there, you can really be helpful
because you know we go into our meetings, we're in our clubs and sometimes we don't see the crack
that's forming. You know when you go into someone's house or you go into a restaurant
and there's a smell, well if you work there you don't have that same sense of smell. You can't
smell it because we've become those blind. We've become visually blind to the things that are
happening. But if we have, you can have a secret shopper come in and look. You thought about that?
Ask anyone to come in and just give me a sense of what's going on. You can survey your members.
Some things might be a really quick fix. Maybe you just need another coat of paint.
Maybe you just need to add a few more things but there might be long-term
things you need to look at as well. Maybe you're not meeting at the right time.
Maybe you need to change up who's sitting where. Maybe you need to do a round robin. Maybe you need
to pick names and see who's sitting where so everyone has the opportunity to get to know each
other. Really look in the mirror. This can be tough but it's really important for the health
of your club to do that. Do we have that other microphone by chance? Still working on it. Okay,
well because I want to ditch a little bit about the club. I would like to hear who has a wonderful
club game or a club activity that you do that you can share here with everyone else.
No? Okay, in the very back, yes. The Dreaded Satellite Club. People just don't like that
word. There's something about it. It's just so off-putting to some people so I like to say
alternative offerings, right? Alternative offerings because we can discover lots of
new flavor profiles. We can offer alternatives, right? Because, wait a minute, I mean I love this
graphic here. Rotary's menu has been a little sparse. You have to agree with that, right?
A lot of people say, well I like it. You know why? Why do I have to do something different?
My club is so great. I don't want to change anything. Well, if your club is at 35
and it was at 45 five years ago, maybe you need to look and say maybe we need to add a little
more spice. You can keep it being the same but maybe you need to add a little paprika in there.
Maybe you need to add a little pepper and that's okay because we're not one size fits all. We're
not. We need to make sure that we're offering things for everyone to be at the table and we
have this new thing called the action plan which is asking us to have a greater impact,
to be adaptable, to be more engaging and to expand our reach because we need to make sure
that everything's on the table because we all have different preferences.
We all have different things that we like and that's okay. What if I'm going to have a dinner
I'm not just going to have one thing. I'm not just going to say, hey Judy,
I'm inviting you over for dinner. You know what we're going to have? Cabbage.
Just cabbage. Cabbage and tequila but just cabbage. You know, now I like cabbage and tequila but not
everyone else. You know, you might not like that. You know, there we go because comfort food, right?
Your BLT comfort food is so yummy and that's the way our clubs have been. Our clubs are comfortable
and they should be to us but they also should be to the new member that comes in. I realized when
I was 13 years old that my comfort food was not everyone else's comfort food. When I invited a
whole bunch of my girlfriends over at 13 for my comfort food, gumbo. Now, I love gumbo. I was
raised by an amazing southern woman who made the best gumbo and it was incredible but those 13
year old girls did not like gumbo. In fact, they hated it. It was slimy and it had okra in it and
what was all the stuff was in there. Oh, it was awful. It was a good thing there was no social
media back then or I probably would have had to switch schools, right? It was terrible. It was
disaster. Not everyone likes it but that's okay. I liked it but I needed to find something else
to bring my friends in. It wasn't quite a good experience. I'd like to share a story right now
about a Wednesday lunch club. Average Wednesday lunch club, they meet at 12 o'clock
at a local restaurant and they're a pretty good club. They have about 35 members. They think
they're doing good. They have some good service projects going on and they have a new member,
Jill. Jill joined because she loves the service that they're doing in that community
and she gets inducted and she goes to their first lunch meeting and she is so
excited and she's sitting there and she's enjoying the fellowship and the connections
and at the end of the meeting out comes the strawberry sundae. Now this place where they
meet is known for their strawberry sundae. It's an award-winning strawberry sundae.
Homemade strawberry ice cream with big chunks of strawberry, homemade whipped cream,
dehydrated strawberries all on the top. It is loaded with strawberries and people are loving it.
They're loving it. They can't get enough and Jill sits back. She watches everyone enjoy the sundae
and she leaves the next week and they come back enjoy their strawberry sundae. Same thing the
following week and about the fourth meeting Jill musters up the courage to raise her hand
and say, have we ever thought about chocolate? Well, what chocolate? No way. We are a strawberry
sundae club. That's who we are. That's what we are. That's what we eat. It's what we do.
We are strawberry sundaes. Well, Jill got her answer pretty quickly. Following week something
came up for work. She couldn't make it. Next week something came up with her kids.
She couldn't make it again. Next thing you know Jill is like so many of our new members
who has joined because they love the service and they want the connection
but something happened and she's no longer coming. This could be the average story,
the regular story and there you go we've lost Jill but someone noticed that Jill was missing
and they called Jill. Can we meet and have a cup of coffee? I want to know what's going on.
Jill said yeah sure and they met and they had their cup of coffee and they asked Jill what's
going on? You seem so interested. She said I was but I didn't realize how important that
strawberry sundae was to your club. I had no idea. She said well what's wrong? Everyone likes
strawberry sundaes. It's okay. Jill said no you know I've got a problem. I'm highly allergic to
strawberries. I feel uncomfortable even being around it so I can't come to the meetings.
She said well we've got to do something about this. Let me talk to our members. Let's talk
about this and so the person who invited Jill out for coffee went back to the club and said
we need to keep Jill. What can we do? Let's have an alternative meeting. Let's add a meeting. You
know we've talked about it. We have teachers in our club that can't make the meetings. We have
someone that runs the library that can't make our meetings. Why don't we add a meeting? We're not
taking anything away here. We're adding a meeting. Let's add a dinner meeting. Great let's do that
and that's what they did. They added a dinner meeting the first Thursday of the month. Now
here's the other thing. They're having it at that same restaurant but that restaurant makes pie.
So they have their first meeting and Jill is there and there were a couple of strawberry sundae people
that managed to come over and enjoy pie and Jill added a few more of her friends that could come
and next thing you know it's six months later they're enjoying their pie. They love their pie
and they're saying wait a minute maybe we could sell some pies and raise some money. You know
there's a lot of people who have food insecurity in our area. Maybe that could be what we focus on
in this evening club. Hey that's great. So now they have a mission. Now they have a cause and they're
going to do something with pies. Wait a minute we have local orchards. We could partner with them.
Wait a minute we have a local food pantry. We could collaborate with them. Next thing you know
it's another six months. It's the fall and they're having a fall festival focused around pies.
They're going to have an apple pie baking contest. They're going to have an apple pie eating contest.
They have the interactive ball and the interact is going to have a pie throwing contest
and it is amazing. This little idea for Jill has turned into a club of 25 people just because we
wanted to help one person. That's how easily these things can happen. It's the spark. It's the
inclusiveness. It's making sure our members feel needed, wanted and known right there and now we
have 20 new members that we would not have had. Who are we missing? We were missing Jill and her
friends and now they're at our table. So think about your club. Think about fusion. How can you
put things together? Because the first person who put bacon, lettuce and tomato
together had no idea what they were creating. No idea the impact that that would have
and it's all right here. We can all do it. So think about your role. Each and every one of you
wears that membership hat. Each and every one of you has the opportunity to extend that reach,
to expand your offerings. It's not just your membership chair. Each and every one of us as
Rotarians, we are charged with getting new members and helping grow our organization.
So now let's dish them in. Has anyone tried expanding your reach? Have you offered any
alternatives that you'd like to share? Someone had said about another, right, you have the
one evening meeting. Do you have something else that you've done that you've been able to
collaborate with another group?
Actually after the Pell's conference, I was listening to the speeches and there was this
idea that people should be invited to service projects without actually having to force them
to become members before they start doing good things. So we had done a new member luncheon
previously and I sent an email to the two of them. I want to share about our rolling club.
I used to be a member at the Port Jervis Rolling Club and then last year around April we come up
with a we would like to have a set up. We would like to break up because we would like to do
something with a kindness. So at that time Peter and all those and our boss, you know,
they really helped us out and we got away. Finally we have Minnesota Valley to be our sponsor
club but something happened. We were just starting in last June, last year, not even one year,
we heard about our sponsor club has a problem. So we have a meeting within our club. So because
we were so really can we all the freedom to do whatever we want to. We have a meeting whenever.
So we were after we discussing about it, the first thing we come up is we don't want to merge
with them because they will be tied up with their rules and regulations. Even though we might be
as a permanent club member. So that's how we turn up and that's our final decision. But on the day
before of the meeting it was April the 10th when I visit the Minnesota Valley, the member and then
after talking to her find out they only have three members. So if we don't merge with them
they will collapse and we will collapse. Then we will not have a club at all. We cannot do too much
for it. So I think after I find out that and then I talk to my club members, I think the most
important thing is think about this. When we need a club member to sponsor us, they were there for
us. Now it is our time to help them to be a club combined. So we did that and we're happy to do
that. Now we are Minnesota Kindness Rotary Club. Thank you. That's wonderful. Thank you. Thank you
for sharing. Thank you all for sharing your stories. It's so important that we share our stories and
that we collaborate and we work as a team because we are one rotary family. So I'd like to bring it
all around a little bit. Talk about a Michelin star. Now for those of you that are foodies,
you'll know that there are only three Michelin stars, right? Yeah, but we're rotary. That's why
I have five, okay? Because we're better than that. But as Rotarians, we have this wonderful thing
called the foundation and our rotary foundation for 16 years in a row has had four stars from
It does not get any better than that. When it comes to our foundation, we are rocking it.
We are the best. It does not get any better than that. But yet, if rotary were a restaurant,
we would be shuttering our doors soon because we're only open on Tuesdays from 12 to 1.
We don't invite people to come. We don't really advertise what we do. We don't share
our experiences and our stories. And when we do get someone to come in and they sit down,
we don't tell them how much it's going to cost when they order that one thing on the menu.
Before they get up, we will be dying as a restaurant. So we have to rethink things.
We have to bring in some new spices. We have to look at things a different way.
We have to take those tomatoes and stop making tomato sauce and start doing something else.
Gazpacho, chicken with tomatoes, tofu with tomatoes. There's boundless, endless opportunities
that we can do, but we have to start thinking and looking at it differently. We have to have
a strategy and it takes every single one of you to come together and think about that and talk
about that. And each and every one of you are here to learn more about your roles today.
And then when you go back, have a meeting, have a strategy meeting and follow the A, B, C and D
that I'm going to share with you right now. A is acknowledge where your club is right now.
This is your internal assessment of where you are. It's looking in the mirror. What do you do well?
What do you need to improve on? Where does your club sit right now? And then B,
be proactive about where you want to be. Think about your strategy
for three years, five years down the line. Where do you want to be?
If I want to make cocoa batter, I have to see what's in my pantry. I have to know where I am
and then B, I have to think about what I need and then C, I have to create a plan to get there.
Things don't just pop up and appear. We're not I dream of Jeannie and I can blink my nose and all
of a sudden there it is. We have to create a plan. So we've assessed, we're proactive about where we
want to be and then we create that plan of how we're going to get there and who's going to help
us and then we have to do it. Because a recipe or a cookbook that sits on a shelf will never be enjoyed.
So many times we have these plans and we come to these meetings and we get all charged up and we
are so enthusiastic and then we sit down and we don't do anything with it. We have to do it. We've
got to do it. So when you go back, think about who, what, where, how, when. How are you going to achieve
that? How are you going to get your membership back up? How are you going to offer different
things at your table? How are you going to make sure that every member of your community knows
about Rotary, knows what you're doing and want to be there? We want to be that restaurant that's got
a six-month waiting list, that people are dying to get in, that people are bribing other people to
get in. Not really because we're Rotarians and we need to, you know, not, but we want to be so attractive.
We want everyone at our table, no matter what their flavor preferences are. So when you go back
and your team collaborates to do that and you come up with your buffet of offerings
or your recipe, believe in it. Believe in your recipe because if you believe it can happen,
it will. And I know it because I've seen the power of Rotary. I've seen what each and every one of you
can do when you set your mind to it. Believe in your recipe and we will grow our organization
and we will succeed because we are an amazing Rotary family. Thank you.
