The Tragic Truth About Beautiful Books

ancient literature
168 followers
I've been knocked sideways today by the books in these two boxes.
I bought them simply because they were beautiful, but as I researched them, I uncovered a tragic
story.
So today I'm going to take you on that journey of discovery we travel when we're researching
old books.
I'll show you both books up close and the clues we have to their history, then we can
discover who made them and why, and see their tragedy that left me in pieces.
I bought these books because they're beautiful book bindings and they're housed in their
original boxes, which is a really promising start.
If you're looking at a book afresh and you see that it's a book binding in its original
box, that's a really, really good sign because the chances are it's still going to be in
beautiful condition because it's had the box protecting it.
These would have been custom made by the original book binder, which gives an indication of
the value of the binding.
The fact that someone's probably, you know, possibly paid a reasonable amount of money
to have it made, but also the care and attention that is going into protecting the book.
So let me open them up and I'll show you what we have and what I experienced when I first
opened them up earlier on.
So this is the first one here and we can open it up and we can see a beautiful book bound
in red maroche.
I'm just going to set the book down while I take it out of the box.
This is the smaller of the two boxes and you can see that this is a red maroche binding
of a very, very good quality on a book called The Life of Florence Nightingale by Sarah
Tooley. You can see here the date and Roman numerals 1910.
We've got lettering in gilt to the upper cover, gilt rules on the spine.
We have really, really stylish, I think, decoration.
We've got one, two, three, four, five raised bands.
So these don't go all the way to the edge of the binding.
They stop just short and you have these three gilt dots to each of the bands and
obviously our spine lettering.
All the edges are gilt.
And then the thing that intrigued me most about this binding when I first opened it up
is we have here someone's name.
This is the front board and on the turnings, which we call the turnings, these pieces of
leather that extend round and cover the front, the edges of the front board.
Nellie Fison, her book is what we have here.
We've also ruled decorations.
We see repeats of these lovely, very delicate gilt dots and little floral pieces in
the corners. And then on the back cover, we have another inscription, as it were, in
gilt, ex done, a j g, which basically means from.
So in this case, it's saying ex done and from.
And then we have somebody's initials, a j g.
So this is a book given to someone called Nellie Fison, her book, from a j g.
No surprise that this is a gift because of the beauty and the quality of the binding.
So my first thought here is that this is something that's been commissioned to give as
a present to this person called Nellie Fison.
And as you can see, this binding is 114 years old and it is immaculate, absolutely
pristine, thanks to the box that's housed it.
And I think it's fair to say the care of the people who have owned it in the
intervening 114 years.
So that's our first book, The Life of Florence Nightingale.
The second book is in this larger box.
You can see actually this box is a bit stained and a bit worn.
And that's actually because the book in it is quite, quite heavy.
And if we open it up, the first thing you'll see, let me do this in front of the
camera, like a good creator.
So I opened it up and I saw it had this lovely cloth covering around it and I can't
really do a reveal because this book is too heavy to safely show you on camera and
fold it open. But that green cloth, when you pull it back, reveals the most beautifully
decorated cover.
You have quite a restrained decorative scheme on the Florence Nightingale book, but
this is a copy of Peter Pan and Kensington Gardens.
You can see the book is much, much bigger and we have beautiful tooling, this front
cover here and the same with Peter to the back cover.
And then we have our lettering to the spine.
So the decorative scheme here, we've got these wonderful butterflies in the corners of
the binding and then various sort of foliage and floral decoration all the way around
the outside of the binding.
And again, a really beautiful, this is more of a burgundy, whereas the previous book was a
bright red, but a really beautiful, highly polished burgundy Morocco here.
The lettering to the spine is relatively simple.
Peter Pan and Kensington Gardens.
And we have these raised bands here.
Guilt rules in the compartments.
And this was a really nice touch, I thought, and that was that you have these vellum
panels. So again, we've got leather turn ins.
These aren't signed Nellie Faison, her book and so on.
But we do have a signature here and it's blind stamped, it's a binders signature.
And I'm really not sure that you'll be able to make this out on camera.
So I might have to overlay a photograph or a video of it.
But this is the binder stamp of the binders who made the book.
Again, it's not toured in guilt, it's just in blind, which means the impression is made
into the leather, but nothing's added on top of it.
And it says J.P.
Gray and Son, Cambridge.
So this is the identity now of our binder.
Really, really important.
Now we know who bound this book.
Possibly they bound both books because they're both in very similar clamshell boxes and
came from the same source.
But ultimately, who knows on that point?
And then I started to look inside the book because this is a beautiful book.
This is Peter Pan and Kensington Gardens, the first Peter Pan book by J.M.
Barry, illustrated by Arthur Rackham.
And this is actually not the first edition, but an edition that came out in 1912.
You can see, does it say here?
Yes, it says a new edition here.
And it's a new edition because this has this is in a much nicer format than the first
edition. You have the plates interspersed throughout the text.
You have beautiful tipped in colour plates under captioned tissue guards.
You can see the front piece illustration here if I carefully show it to you.
So these are all tipped in on lovely mounts under tissue guards.
So you have Arthur Rackham's illustrations throughout the book.
But the thing that caught my eye was an inscription on the title page here.
And it says to now from Arthur 1913.
Now, you might be thinking that, you know, I wonder if that's Arthur Rackham, because
then this would be inscribed by the illustrator and that would be a very, very nice
thing. But this isn't to my eyes in a fairly romantic way.
This is much better.
And we'll get on to why as we go through this video.
But here we have to now from Arthur 1913 and the previous book was given to Nellie
Fison. So I'm now thinking they're the same person.
This is from Arthur.
And again, the previous book we looked at was from A.J.G.
So I'm now wondering whether both books were given to the same person.
So what we have to go on evidence wise here is our Nell, Nell or Nellie Fison.
We see her as Nell here and Nellie in the other book.
So what I did is I started to do a bit of research on who Nell or Nellie Fison might
be. And here's what I found.
I just Googled her name and there's a wonderful website called Capturing Cambridge,
which is run by the Museum of Cambridge.
And I can see that Eleanor Fison lived just outside of Cambridge in Fison Farm in
Fenderton. She was born in 1890, which means she would have been 20 years old when she
was given the Florence Nightingale book and the Peter Pan that was inscribed in 1913.
That would have had her at 22, maybe 23 years old, a young girl.
And this is what it says on the entry for Fison Farm in Fenderton on the Capturing
Cambridge website. Eleanor Fison was born in 1890 and lived with her family on Fison
Farm in Fenderton.
She trained as a nurse.
And this is interesting, of course, because this is the life of Florence Nightingale.
So a particularly appropriate gift to Eleanor, aged 20, and I imagine at that point
already trained to be a nurse, maybe even practicing as a nurse.
And following the death of her fiance, Arthur Gray, a bookbinder in Green Street, her
career took her to several places abroad, including Egypt.
And when I first read that earlier on, it absolutely stopped me in my tracks.
Because. The Arthur that inscribed this beautifully bound copy of Peter Pan to Nell
from Arthur, 1913, is clearly someone called Arthur Gray, who was a bookbinder.
And then we have this book, Nellie Fison, her book, Ex Dono A.J.G.
And we have Arthur Gray being the person who gave it to her.
So obviously, Arthur Gray's middle initial was J.
And he was a bookbinder.
So. Did he bind these books for her?
Well, let's have a look.
And again, on the Capturing Cambridge website, I can click through to Arthur Gray's
information. And it takes us to an entry for 10 Green Street in Cambridge.
And we learn that 10 Green Street is the premises of, founded in the 1860s, a bindery
run by someone called John Phillips Gray, J.
P. Gray.
And we remember that the person who bound this volume in the signature here was J.
P. Gray and son.
Now, it turns out John Phillips Gray was Arthur Gray's grandfather.
John Phillips Gray had a son, the son of J.
P. Gray and son, called Arthur Beals Gray.
He was in his 40s at the time these books were bound.
And the 1911 census record for 10 Green Street, the location of the bindery, tells us
that at that time, 1910, 1911 even, the year after this was bound and just before our
Peter Pan was bound, Arthur John Gray, aged 19, was a bookbinder working at the firm.
So here we have not just beautiful books in immaculate condition, but romantic gifts
made by Arthur John Gray for Nellie Fison.
So the ex-dono AJG that we see in this volume is very much saying this was made by me for
you. The care given to the books in housing them in these boxes and the preservation that
they've had for more than a century now, almost keeping them in a time capsule level of
condition, that when Arthur first gave Nell these books, they would have looked exactly
as they do now.
So what happened?
Well, this is where the story took a turn, because staying on the Catching Cambridge
website, we read that they became engaged.
Maybe around the time of these bindings, maybe shortly afterwards, but it's tough talking
about young men and women in the years 1910, 1913, 1914, because we all know what's
coming. And Arthur John Gray, the boy, really, he was a boy who bound these volumes, was
commissioned into the 1st Cambridgeshire Battalion in the First World War.
He joined in 1915 and actually, in looking around, I managed to find some medals that
So we have Nell working as a nurse later across the world, but at this time, we think still
at home. She was at home with the books.
And Arthur was sent to the Western Front with the 1st Cambridgeshire Regiment.
He joined the regiment as a sub-lieutenant in 1915 and served on the Western Front for the
next couple of years. He will have been allowed home at that time, over the next couple of
years, and been able to see Nell, see the family.
But in July 1917, he was sent to Ede.
Ede had already been a massive killing ground of the war.
And in July 1917, on the 31st of July 1917, was the first day of one of the bloodiest battles of the
whole God-Satan conflict, the Battle of Passchendaele.
And I mean, I have it sat in front of me now in black and white, and it makes me feel utterly, utterly
But Arthur was killed in action on the first day of fighting at the Battle of Passchendaele, the 31st of July 1917.
And it's, it shows you what books can do to us, and how special they are.
I bought these as aesthetic objects. I saw they were in their original boxes, guessed that they must still be in
beautiful condition, and thought, gosh, they'll look really nice. I'm sure I can find a customer for those.
And what I've discovered instead, thanks to literally, you know, a bit of guilt on leather here, and here,
and inscription in a copy of Peter Pan to Nell from Arthur, and a barely visible binder signature at the base of this turning.
Is this, this awful story of loss.
I mean, I guess that's the end of the video.
That's what you find when you look into the lives of people who lived in this time.
We made beautiful and permanent things for the girls we loved.
And we have that at the moment, I suppose.
But there's really no way I can find time to sign off this video. So, I'll just stop recording.
I hope you enjoyed seeing the story behind these books. Enjoyed is probably not the right word, right?
I'll see you next week.
