WARREN BUFFETT: BERKSHIRE ON SALE? HOW TO VALUE BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY (BRKB STOCK)

Coin Crunch
8 followers
May 4, 2025
Berkshire Hathaway or BRKA / BRKB stock is a $1.1 trillion market cap and this weekend is the 2025 annual shareholder meeting. How do investors value Berkshire Hathaway and how can the stock compound in the years ahead? Let's dive in!
This weekend is the Berkshire Hathaway annual shareholder meeting for 2025.
I expect a record turnout of tens of thousands of attendees, partly because Berkshire, not only do
they have just such an incredible track record, but year to date crushing it again. You could
see the US indices down a couple percent while Berkshire's up a cool 16, 17%. And so a lot of
folks are wondering, yeah, this is now a trillion dollar market cap company. How much more does it
have to run? They're looking at the earnings multiple of low teens, recognizing that,
you know, this used to be valued purely as an insurer based on book value. Now it's
valued more closely as an earnings juggernaut. So the question is, how do you value Berkshire?
And, you know, is it still compelling from here? And in this video, I'm going to walk you through
my framework for breaking it down, understanding this a trillion dollar company,
yet you can still break down it, you know, break, break the company down into its core basics
in terms of thinking about where it can potentially go in the years ahead.
So the first half of this video is thinking about the different elements that drives Berkshire. Yes,
there's a lot of pieces. Yes, it's a trillion dollar company. So there is complexity,
but the fundamentals, whether or not you are a penny stock or a trillion dollar company,
the fundamentals still apply. And so let's go through the fundamentals for Berkshire.
Let's talk about a framework for thinking about where can go at towards the end of this video.
As always, if you enjoy educational content, my name is Daniel. You're watching Unrivaled
Investing. Let's jump right into understanding, you know, potentially how to value Berkshire.
And I think it really only comes down to three components for thinking about
valuing a business, even a complex business like Berkshire, you have the underlying earnings power
of the business, which is the fundamentals. You have the valuation, that's the sentiment,
the multiple that you're going to give to the underlying fundamentals. And then you have the
free cash flow that management can return to shareholders each year. And if you look at the
free cash flow over the last few years, last year in 2024, it was around $11 billion in free cash
flow. And you can see it's bounced around between 20 and $30 billion for several years now. In some
years, it was even more than $30 billion. The way to think about this is there's a lot of capital
being reinvested into certain subsidiaries like Burlington Northern or their electric utilities.
These are very capital intensive businesses. So a lot of cash gets tied up there. That said,
this 20 to 30 billion does reflect the free cash flow that they can either return to you as a
dividend, which they, you know, only I think under Buffett's watch, they only did it once.
It was a small dividend. And so that was decades ago. And so when you're thinking about it,
it's 20 to $30 billion that could be spent for buying back stocks. It could be spent on dividend.
It could be spent on buying, you know, whole companies. It could be spent on buying stakes
in companies. So that 20 to $30 billion, that's sort of the base rate. When I think about how
much free cash flow their operations are generating after reinvesting into their businesses. And so
when you look at that free cash flow, let's say 20 to $30 billion relative to a $1.1 trillion market
cap. So 20 to $30 billion free cash flow, $1.1 trillion market cap, that's around a 2% plus type
of yield. So that's, you know, base rate when you're thinking about, you know, what, what your
type of returns are going to be factor in that 2% type of yield, then it's going to turn into a
question of, well, you know, what's the earnings fundamental growth look like. And does, is my
earnings power actually significantly greater than this free cash flow that's accruing to me each
year? And the earnings power is significantly greater than that 20 to $30 billion we're just
talking about. Maybe it's going to be, you know, 30 to 40 billion in the years ahead. And so when
we think about Berkshire's earnings, the sources of their earnings, it really comes down to a few
different buckets. You have their operating businesses that include wholly owned subsidiaries,
you have their stock portfolio and the gains on their portfolio, and then you have investment
driven income. So you have a lot of different pieces here. Uh, you know, and, and let's,
let's go through some of this. So the first looking at their insurance operations, wholly
owned insurance operations like Geico and Berkshire Hathaway insurance or Berkshire Hathaway
reinsurance. So this means they're providing insurance coverage to the insurers, to, in some
cases, competitors that want to write some sort of business. That's a real advantage for Berkshire
where they say we have, we are just such a monster in terms of our size, our free cash flow, our cash
reserves that we can write risks. We can write exposure that no other insurer can do. So that
is a real competitive advantage in terms of how fast Ajit Jain who runs the insurance operations,
he can write, you know, say, yes, we can do that policy. You know, if there's some major
catastrophe and insurer says, Hey, I need a hedge. My exposure Berkshire Hathaway reinsurance is,
is a go-to for those really strange and large potential losses that they want to have covered.
And so looking at the, uh, insurance operations for Berkshire, it's really bounced around,
in some years Geico was really poorly managed, you know, in 2022, they had around a $2 billion
loss in Geico, but now it's a powerhouse around $8 billion in pre-tax earnings.
And then looking at the Berkshire Hathaway insurance and reinsurance, that's around
three to $4 billion in pre-tax earnings. So Geico is the powerhouse of their insurance operations.
And then the second key aspect, which I would say right now it's bigger than their insurance
underwriting, but could be lower in the future. And we'll talk about why in a second,
that's the interest income it's important to recognize. So this is, there's difference
between capital gains and, you know, and appreciation versus income. And in this case,
this is the income on their float and their cash reserves that they're holding, you know,
this is $300 billion plus getting a 4% plus yield. So talking about $16 billion in terms of
float investment income and interest income on their fixed income portfolio and cash.
So overall right now, the insurance operations ballpark looking at, you know, somewhere between
25 and $30 billion in annual pre-tax earnings power for their insurance operations. And then
you have everything else, their non-insurance operations, Burlington Northern, that's,
their railroad, that is one of the largest non-insurance operations generating around $7
billion in pre-tax profits. But you can see it's really struggled actually over the last seven
years in that it's actually down their earnings profit. You know, their core profitability here
has really been flat over the last few years, suggesting limited underlying growth. You look
at the energy segment, similar story, uh, limited growth. You know, you clearly have some sort of
margin compression that they faced in 2024. Manufacturing includes several different
subsidiaries. That's not just one company. This includes things like Lubrizol, the oil additive
for cars, uh, precision cast parts for airplane engines. And so you have all that getting tied
up into manufacturing that's around 12 billion in profitability. So there's a lot of different
pieces in their non-insurance operations. They have, you know, uh, if you want to talk about gas
stations, the pilot, Jay, uh, you know, flying Jay stations. Um, they also have service and retail
where they own literally dozens or hundreds of different subsidiaries. Uh, you know, thinking
about like sees candy. That's one of my favorites. So all in their non-insurance operations is a
let's say 25 to maybe $30 billion in pre-tax earnings. And as well, that's it's generally
been a low growth sort of trend here. It's hard to get the exact organic growth because
different subsidiaries get, you know, added to this over time, but clearly it's very low single digits.
Um, just based on the fact that, you know, operating profitability really hasn't jumped. I mean,
you know, it's up a couple of percent over the last decade. It's not just,
it's not a dramatic increase. And so then the next and third, you know, key component for
valuing Berkshire is the potential investment gains. So, you know, so far let's, let's take
a break, just a quick second to think about this. We've talked about the insurance operations,
the underwriting income and investment income that it's generating. So think about the interest
and dividend payments. So that's insurance. Next is the non-insurance, which is a huge umbrella,
literally dozens of subsidiary subsidiaries operating around the world. You have ISCAR,
which is precision tool parts in Israel. You got, you know, literally operations around the world
that you're talking about with, um, their non-insurance operations. And then the last
earnings driver is the potential appreciation on their investment portfolio. So saying,
you know, could their portfolio of stocks go up in value, not including dividends, that dividends
and that fixed income that was already counted in the insurance operations when we're thinking
about it. So it's the, what are the potential investment gains across an existing $300
billion stock portfolio, think apple and Coca-Cola and then potential gains in cash and fixed income.
This is much harder to get gains on because it's cash. You typically need to invest it in something.
So there are some important caveats to think about, which is that all in when you're looking
at their stock and cash portfolio, you're really talking about around $650 billion. That is a
asset that Berkshire has that Buffett and his future lieutenants can figure out how do they
want to deploy, you know, right now it's, it's heavily in, in cash and fixed income,
but that can change. And if that changes and they reallocate that to stocks, then the potential
gains will be much higher. If they, you know, allocated to stocks, the losses could be higher
but they also lose that income power, which I called out was around $16 billion in the insurance
operation because that cash is no longer generating, you know, interest that you're
receiving. So you need any, if you're going to think about how this plays out, you need a factor
in both the insurance operations and the income they're receiving, the investment income they're
receiving as well as the potential investment gains and what happens with cash. So it's hard
to think about this $350 billion in cash and fixed income appreciating significantly, unless
they there's significant bargains and then they redeploy it back into stocks. So this is important
to consider, you know, as you're thinking about this different part. So it really comes down to
at this point, thinking about this $300 billion and what type of gains you could expect from it
on an after-tax basis and looking at it, uh, you know, over the last few years, the pre-tax
historic investment gains have jumped around on this portfolio. Last year is around $50 billion
year before that $75 billion, but in 2022, when everything was melting down, they lost nearly
$70 billion. Now this is all mark to market. It wasn't like, you know, there was an actual cash
burn of this size. It's just that their portfolio declined by a sizable amount. And so overall,
you know, thinking about this, I think the conservative approach is to look at the $300
billion now and think what's the type of return you could get over time on that $300 billion
appreciating. So is Berkshire potentially a bargain right now? You know, how do you value
Berkshire and, and, and, you know, first, you know, it's important to recognize none of this
financial advice is more educational in nature where I'm sharing. How do you, how should you
think about valuing Berkshire or at least how am I personally doing so? And also a quick plug just
earlier today, literally earlier today, Jasmine, a member of the unrivaled investing community
shared the following. I've had a good run with unrivaled and would recommend your service to
anyone interested in investing. This follows Henrik who said, thank you for creating the
service. Subscribing to your platform is the best financial decision I've made in my life.
And also thank you for letting us lock in the rate for the subscription. He's talking about
how the rates do go up each year. And I do expect the premium rate to go up later this month. So now
is the time to lock in the favorable rate. If you're looking for compelling ideas, come check
out unrivaled investing.com looking at Berkshire, putting it all together. So you have their
insurance operations, you have their non-insurance operations, and then you have the potential
fluctuations in their portfolio. I'm assuming that their portfolio can possibly continue to
compound on a pre-tax basis around $24 billion. The way to think about that is 24 on 300 billion.
It's just shy. It's like a high single digit type of potential return on that portfolio. It's hard
to compound $300 billion. And so looking at the different pieces, pre-tax income, I'm ballpark
saying maybe it's around $80 billion. Once again, you could see pre-tax income has jumped around
from 110 to negative 30 in 2022. Once again, because you had that sizable portfolio decline
that offset their underlying operations. In 2022, their pre-tax operations from insurance and
non-insurance operations was only $35 billion, only 35. So it was more than offset by the losses
in their investment portfolio. So recognize if you're looking at, let's say 12 times earnings,
and you're saying, isn't this cheap? You got to recognize that earnings is going to be value,
you know, jumping around year to year. And I think it's important to have some sort of,
what do you think is the normalized earnings power over time? So if you think normalized
earnings power might be close to $80 billion a year, pre-tax slap on some sort of tax rate
for that, maybe it's 20%, maybe it's 15%, maybe it's 25% really depends on, you know,
what's going on in the US, you know, then you're talking about earnings power of maybe around 60,
65, you know, maybe 55, somewhere around 60 billion in normalized earnings based on putting
all these different components together. And so, you know, based on the current share price,
530 for the B shares, that's $1.1 trillion market cap. That does suggest that the underlying
earnings multiple of, you know, when you're saying, oh, isn't it cheap at 12 times,
you're really sort of giving too much weight to their investment gains they had last year.
And so I think their normalized earnings might suggest that the appropriate earnings multiple
is actually closer to a high teens type of level. And then you start thinking about, okay,
what's the organic growth rate for these businesses in the future, recognizing that
20 to $30 billion is getting returned to you or accruing to you each year, you know, that cash is
building up in the business and that's around this 2% yield. So what do you think is the organic
growth rate for the business over time? And I'm assuming somewhere between 5 and 10%.
You could argue this is too aggressive given, you know, what we've seen with some of their
core operations like Burlington Northern and their electric subsidiary, you know,
over the last few years where you really haven't seen that core earnings growth.
And then assuming, you know, some somewhere of a market discount, recognizing that this
isn't going to be a hyper grower. And, you know, it's maybe somewhere between 15 and 20 times
because earnings can be lumpy. You can have variability to it. Yes. There's, there's a lot,
you know, of great operations here, but this doesn't deserve, you know, let's say a hyper
growth earnings premium. This might warrant some sort of discount. Uh, so I'm assuming 15 to 20
times, 20 times, I think is, is a very fair valuation. 15, I'd argue is more of a discount.
And then throwing that all together, thinking about the earnings power, what it grows at,
and then a multiple five years out, then you're really talking about in the low case,
around a trillion dollar market cap, throw in the cash that's accruing to eat you each year.
And you're effectively break even though, once again, this is a hypothetical stock price and
go higher or lower depending on, you know, sentiment, you know, five years from now,
is the multiple going to be way higher? Maybe, maybe it's even lower also depends on their
execution. Well, their growth rates be higher or lower the high side, assuming let's say closer
to 10% organic growth, which once again, I think is aggressive 20 times earnings multiple.
I think that's fair. You know, a lot depends on how much, you know, you have disruption in terms
of technological innovation and risks in the years ahead. You know, for example, guy goes to power
house for them. How much will that be impacted if people are buying Waymo's in the future? And
Google recently talked about how they're going to make it possible for people to buy Waymo's and
autonomous vehicles. You know, what will happen to insurance rates in that situation? You can
the case that it'll be worth, you know, Geico will be worth more because the car itself might
be more expensive, but the flip side is accidents might be much rarer. Hopefully, you know, that's
a future that, you know, I look forward to is where car accidents and car fatalities are a
non-event or an extreme rarity. So in this situation, looking at the high case, you know,
you're talking about a business potentially worth $2.1 trillion five years from now, plus the cash
accrual that, you know, 20 to $30 billion that we talked about. And that's, you know, now you're
talking about a mid-teens type of earnings multiple. So I would say this framework at the
existing price of around 530 per B share really isn't crazy compelling. It's not deep bargain
territory because on the low side, you're effectively saying break even the high side.
You're saying teens base case, which I think is very reasonable. You're probably talking around,
you know, high single digit type of return over time. So that's a framework, how I'm thinking
about Berkshire in the years ahead. And frankly, it's not surprising that, you know, when you look
at Buffett and when he found Berkshire to be attractive, you know, when he was repurchasing
shares, we can see, yeah, he hasn't done any buybacks in the last few quarters because it's
not at that really asymmetric risk reward. It's break even to 15% type of return, which is,
which is okay. But he previously was buying, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars of stock,
closer to $415 per Berkshire B share, closer to $620,000 per A share. This was in May and April
of 2024 and running that same framework, that price through this framework does show you,
this is the reason why Buffett was looking to do it, in my opinion, is that, you know, closer to
that $400 per share. And you could see it in my prior videos where I called out Berkshire saying,
yeah, the valuation is quite reasonable. Since then it's gone up, you know, a bit, I would say
now the risk reward is okay, you know, potentially teens upside on from a compounding perspective,
but when Buffett was buying it, you could see that using this same framework, the low side was
effectively saying mid to possibly high single digits type of return. And then a base case was
a teens type of return and a super high case was a 20% type of return. So in that type of situation,
it's a, you know, tails, you win, you know, heads, you do really well, you win a lot,
you get tired of winning, you're winning so often to quote a famous person. And so I, you know,
I look at this and, you know, it's first of all, seeing that he was purchasing shares
at that price and that sort of validates this framework as well for me personally, you know,
thinking about that, like, and it's also, it fits with my own process and you can learn a lot from
Buffett's process, which is that I, you know, as I've called out earlier in April, when there was
that tariff volatility and, you know, some stocks were literally dropping 10% in a day, my framework
for additional new purchases was based on this idea where in the low case, I wanted ballpark 50%
upside. Now that's not exactly, you know, what you had when Buffett was repurchasing shares,
it was closer to, let's say 30% upside ballpark in the low sort of draconian conservative scenario.
And then in a more realistic scenario, you're talking about a teens type return
and then a high scenario you're talking about closer to 20%. And that is, frankly, that is
the framework that I'm sort of instilling in my own mind when I'm looking at new ideas of,
you know, if it needs to have on the low side, that sort of 30, 50% upside for me to consider
adding capital, you know, just from my own personal investment journey where I'm saying,
yeah, these, these expectations are so low. And I think wall street's so disconnected from the
underlying fundamentals of this business that I think 30 to 50% is just some very low hurdle to
step over. And it's really a question of, will this be 100 to 200% type of upside over time?
And that's where, you know, the bulk of my focus. And when you have that type of situation where
the low side is that 30 to 50% and the high side is 200%, those are the types of situations where
you then ask, well, okay, so are there blow up risks or is there something I'm missing?
And if not, those are the types of situations that, you know, you really personally, I'd say,
okay, how much of my portfolio do I want to make this? You know, can this be 20% of my portfolio?
And I do have, you know, an insurance and historic compounder that's nearly 20% of my portfolio
that, you know, trades cheaper than Berkshire and has a, you know, a very compelling track record
over the last several decades, you know, high teens. So look, everyone needs to figure out
what's right for their own investment journey. And I hope this video walking you through how
to value Berkshire, whether or not it's currently a bargain and why Buffett was previously buying
in 2024. I hope this has been helpful for you. Thanks so much for watching Unrivaled Investing.
