🔰What’s going on with Social Security — and how we're fighting back.

Elizabeth Warren's News
3 followers
Presidents are often measured by their first 100 days in office, and we are about to hit that mark.
Now, it would take us far too long to list all of Donald Trump's actions,
both here and abroad so far, from mass pardons, to unqualified cabinet picks, to deportations
without due process, to on-again, off-again tariffs. It is clearly nothing like we've ever
seen before. To discuss the consequences of these actions and policies, who better
than Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts? Senator Warren, great to see you, and may I call
you Elizabeth since we've known each other for a long time. So Elizabeth, my first question is
about the revelation on Sunday that the head of the Defense Department, Defense Secretary Pete
Hegseth, had actually done another signal chat with details of the Yemen bombings, and it included
his brother, his wife, and his personal lawyer. What was your reaction when you heard about this
second signal chat? What is it going to take for Donald Trump to fire this guy? It is so clear
that he is not ready for prime time. Look, we all knew this at the time he was originally nominated,
that he was nominated principally because he was very, very, very, very loyal to Donald Trump,
and he looked good on television and gave a kind of rah-rah talk around defense. But the truth was,
he didn't have the experience. He didn't have the background. He made it clear that he didn't think
that a lot of those who were serving in the military, particularly women, belonged there and
had a contribution to make. And so it was never a good idea to put this guy in. And then he comes in
and literally puts our entire national defense at risk, not once, but twice, that we know of.
And no one is sure what else. I mean, if he thinks that it's okay to have his wife who
does not have a security clearance, to have his lawyer who does not have a security clearance,
this is hard no. This is something for which anyone who actually worked in the Department
of Defense for Pete Hegseth would have been summarily fired, and everyone would have said,
yeah, no kidding. That's what people get fired for. It is time for some
accountability in the Department of Defense, time for Pete Hegseth to go.
But will that happen? Will there be accountability? Now, we should point out that
National Security Advisor Michael Walz was responsible for initiating that other signal
chat that mistakenly included Jeff Goldberg of The Atlantic. This one was initiated by Secretary
Hegseth. So we should point that out just for clarity. You should, Katie, but let me just say
it here. You're not supposed to have those calls over signal, no matter who initiated them.
It doesn't matter who picked up the phone. It's when you're talking about plans to bomb
another country, that's like really secret information. And that is supposed to be done
in what are called SCIFs, in secure places over secure lines. I have seen things, heard things
that are so much less down that line, that have to always be done with all of the security
safeguards in place. And Pete Hegseth, that we know of, has twice violated that.
Will there be accountability, though, Elizabeth? That's the big question.
Many people are calling for him to be fired. But will that happen? It didn't happen before.
Why do you think it might happen now? Let's face it. The Trump administration
is not big on accountability. And I think that's no surprise. We have a convicted felon
sitting in the White House, and someone whose first act, once he was sworn in,
was to issue pardons to 1,500 people who had taken part in an insurrection, including
an insurrection, a riot that had destroyed property at the U.S. Capitol, and resulted
in the deaths of police officers. So accountability is clearly not high on Donald Trump's list.
Nonetheless, he is at least a little sensitive to people across the country saying, enough,
we're not going to do this, no more. And I think that's what's happening right now.
Democrats, Republicans, Independents saying, this guy has to go, has to go.
Well, we've heard a little bit, right? You're getting a little bit of pushback.
I think of this at the moment as cracks in the red wall, that Republicans in the House,
in the Senate have bowed down to Donald Trump from the day he got elected. Anything he wanted
was always good. Everybody he nominated was always terrific. Didn't want to hear anything
bad, nothing, nothing, nothing. But with trade, with the question about whether or not you're
going to obey court orders, and now with HECSF, you're starting to see the cracks appear.
You're part of a bipartisan resolution to repeal Donald Trump's global tariffs,
along with people like Rand Paul, Tim Kaine, Chuck Schumer.
Tell us where that stands and what impact it might have.
So remember, we'll have to be wonky for just a minute here. We've got two things going on
with tariffs. First, the economists have told us, Wall Street has told us and is telling us
pretty firmly right now, even Jerome Powell, head of the Fed, have all said either we're
moving toward recession with these tariffs, or we're already into a recession because of them.
Driving up costs for families all across this country and driving up unemployment simultaneously.
In other words, who really pays the price in a recession? Family by family by family. They pay
more at the grocery store, pay more at the gas pump, and more people lose their jobs.
So this is bad economic territory to be in. Why does the president have the power
to come out one day and declare 10% tariffs, then 54% tariffs, then on China, 145% tariffs?
That's not what the president's job actually is. Only Congress authorized any president to do this
in a state of emergency. And the idea behind this bill, which was passed a long time ago,
was like if we're at war, right? And we need to be able to get tariffs in place quickly.
President's authorized to do that. But the law specifically says it can be rolled back. That is,
Congress can just say, not an emergency right now. And if Congress says that in what's called a
resolution, we're done. President loses the authority to do exactly what he's doing right
now. So Ron Wyden and I have the bill to get the resolution, and it will get a vote
in the next couple of weeks. And if it carries the House and the Senate,
then Donald Trump will lose his ability to do these up, down, in, out, sideways tariffs.
Will we get Republicans? Here's the thing, Katie. It's now a time when Republicans all
across this country are actually going to have to stand up and go on the record. They're not
going to know what's happening to the economy. They know what will happen to families,
the way that Trump is heading this economy. Either they will decide, no, their number one job is
still to bow down to Donald Trump, no matter what. Or their job is to stand up for the American
people. And that's going to be the vote that's going to occur in the next couple of weeks.
Not to get wonkier, but aren't tariffs a form of taxation, Elizabeth? And doesn't the power
reside with Congress? And why aren't people making that point?
So it is true. The power resides with Congress to set tariffs. And look, Donald Trump's form
of doing tariffs is the worst possible in terms of driving up costs. He has made it on virtually
every country, on virtually every product they sell, which drives up prices all across the board.
Explain to me, Katie, what is the emergency in our trade relationship with Belgium? What
is the emergency right now in our trade relationship with many, many countries around
the world? If you want to do something on trade, you want to make changes on trade,
you've got to have a specific goal in mind, and you've got to have a way that you want to bring
those tariffs in. For example, to be able to develop a certain kind of manufacturing here
in the United States, and you've got enough time to do it and so on and so forth. But that's not
what Donald Trump is doing. Indeed, here's the thing that I think nobody's talking about enough,
and that is the cost of uncertainty. Those tariffs will raise prices across the board.
Jerome Pell, head of the Fed, has already said so, because they are so across the board and
affect everything. But the fact that we've had 25% tariffs, then no tariffs, then 10% tariffs,
then no tariffs, 54% tariffs, then no tariffs, this red light, green light, and even now,
he said he has suspended the higher tariffs for 90 days. Nobody can plan against that.
There's no business in this country or anywhere in the world that can say, okay, now's the time
for me to invest $100 million in building this new plant, or even a few million dollars in going
out and buying a lot of new tools to increase my productivity, or investing in hiring a new team
and getting them educated to do this part of business I want to do. Nobody makes investments
in the teeth of that kind of uncertainty. So even if Donald Trump said tomorrow, woke up and said,
oh, I've now paid attention to what people are saying, I'm going to drop the tariffs.
So long as he has the power to wave his magic wand and turn those tariffs back on,
everybody in our country is paying a price.
What are the ramifications, though, of that kind of unpredictability, if you will? You say
people can't prepare. So what are the consequences of not being able to prepare?
Well, the consequences are terrible for our economy. It means there are going to be more
people who are laid off. It means we're going to slow down on productivity because people are not
going to make, investors are not going to make the kinds of investments that take a year or five
years or 15 years to be able to get back the return on investment. There's a real price to pay.
And if you look at Wall Street, it's just kind of one visible measure of that. You're watching the
stock in company after company after company go down because people are saying, how are they
going to expand? How are they going to get more productive? How are they going to sell more?
And of course, there's another part to this. Consumers look at it. Consumers are the engine
of our economy, the engine of the worldwide economy. Everybody wants to get to that American
consumer because we buy a lot of stuff. But when there's a lot of economic uncertainty,
consumer confidence just goes all the way down, just completely collapses. And that is what's
happened, Katie. Right now, consumers are expecting much higher prices. They are more worried about
unemployment and that causes retrenchment, causes them to hold back and not to spend as much money.
And then can I layer one more problem into this? Okay, so we've got the tariffs. Then we've got
the chaos that's Donald Trump. The third part is the corruption. Part of what has given us a strong
economy for literally for centuries has been that we run a pretty honest game here. That is,
our officials don't take bribes. They don't pick this one as opposed to that one because they made
political donations. Look, there's some problems at the margins, but that's generally what you rely
on. When there's a lot of chaos in the system around something like tariffs, it leaves open
the possibility for Donald Trump to do exactly what he did. So right in the middle of these high
tariffs, he said, everybody's going to have at least 10 percent, China's going to have 145 percent,
and there will be no exceptions. They're going to apply to everyone. And then a day later, he said,
I talked to Tim Cook, and I'm going to say, well, Apple products get an exception.
So Tim Cook put a million dollars into Donald Trump's inauguration campaign or inauguration
events. He has come. He has basically visited with Donald Trump. Who knows what else has happened?
But the point is, now one big company gets a special break, but nobody else,
none of the medium-sized companies, none of the small companies, they don't have that kind of
access to the president. And look how that undermines confidence overall. It's no longer
an economy where the person who produces the best product or the cheapest product or the best service
is the one that grows and prospers. No, it's the one who has the most political connection.
I think they call that crony capitalism.
Crony capitalism. And you know what? Donald Trump did that in his first term. So Trump Enterprises
is down in Argentina. They're trying to get recognition of their trademark. And there's
a lot of trouble back and forth. What does Donald Trump do? He lowers the tariff for that one
country. And four days later, that one country says, oh, now we'll go ahead and recognize
your trademark. This is just corruption, not even well hidden from public view. It's pretty
much out there. And corruption is like a cancer on an economy. It just, over time, just saps power
and energy out of that economy. And every single American ultimately pays for it.
Speaking of corruption, I know that you have called for an investigation into insider trading
because in the middle of this red light, green light tariff debate, Donald Trump
actually put on Truth Social. Now is a great time to buy. Tell me about the status of that
investigation. And if you believe there's clear evidence that insider trading took place.
Well, the most obvious evidence is the fact that there appears to be an uptick in price,
meaning more people were trying to buy just shortly before the public announcement,
in which anybody can buy at that point. And that's enough to trigger an investigation,
particularly under the circumstances when one person is driving the market.
It's appropriate to say, hmm, so did he personally benefit from this? Members of his family,
his inner circle, members of their family. This is the kind of thing that we always investigate
when there's been this kind of upheaval in a market. And inside information is clearly a part
of what's going on. Remember, the problems we're seeing right now are not like 2008 in the sense
that in 2008, it was all those bad mortgages that for years had been fed into the system. And then
finally, too much risk and the whole system toppled over. 2020, it's a pandemic that's
being felt around the world. And we're watching supply chains freeze up and people can't go
into work. Remember that on the day Donald Trump was sworn into office, this time, it's a strong
economy and all of the signs are go. Inflation seems to be coming down, is down. Unemployment
is down. That economy is humming and GDP is growing. And now one man, Donald Trump, has
totally turned that around. So part of what we have to ask is in the machinations back and forth,
is he helping himself, his buddies and his family? But also, it's what he's doing to the rest of the
economy and how much everyone else is paying for the chaos and corruption that he's generating.
I want to ask you about his recent attacks on the chairman of the Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell.
Trump said he's been moving too slowly to lower interest rates. He's threatened to fire him.
He posted about it on social media. And he told reporters in the Oval Office last week,
if I want him out, he'll be out there real fast. Believe me. Can you explain
to everyone watching why this isn't normal? So let's start in 1863. So back in 1863,
we're in the middle of a civil war. And what the Congress and Abe Lincoln figure out is,
we're going to have some banking regulators because these banks are getting very, very
unsteady. And we need financing to be more reliable. So we built, our country did, built
the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. It's called the OCC. And this is the bank regulator.
And here's the insight, Katie. Back then, we said, you know what? We're going to have this
bank regulator. We want them funded, not through Congress. Because if they're funded through
Congress and some donors, some big bank back in your home state puts pressure on the elected
official, the elected official will turn around and put it on the financial regulator. And then
the financial regulator won't be making decisions that the financial regulator believes are in the
best interests of our economy and our country, but will be under political pressure. So that's
the baseline. Every single financial regulator that this country has put in place since then,
the FDIC that insures your banks, the OCC that's still there, the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, the financial regulator for the credit unions, and the Fed, all are independent.
Of politics, as much as we can make them. And the Fed explicitly, the President of the United States
does not have the power to fire the head of the Fed. If he tries, two things are going to happen.
The first one is that they're going to end up in the Supreme Court. Because I believe
that the head of the Fed, to protect the Fed into the future, will fight it. But the second is,
it will tank the markets. It will cause the markets to crash. And the reason for that is,
it will be one more that decisions are being made based on politics, rather than on someone's best
judgment about the economics. We want those financial regulators insulated from politics
as much as humanly possible. And again, I say this because the consequences of pushing this
country into recession are felt household by household, family by family, in those higher
prices and higher risk of unemployment. So many of my followers wanted me to ask you,
can Donald Trump legally fire Jerome Powell? No. Would that stop him from getting rid of him?
Well, look, he can't legally fire the folks at the FTC, the individual commissioners at the FTC,
but he claims to have done it. Now, to their credit, the two Democrats who are on this,
remember, bipartisan, Democrat and Republican, at the Federal Trade Commission have said,
basically, he can't do it and I'm not fired. And they're in court right now. But it is the reminder.
Donald Trump indicates when he does this, that he doesn't feel bound by law. He's clearly operating
differently from any president we've had before. He puts himself above the law. And right now,
that's being tested in court. But this is a real threat to all of us, whether you're a Democrat
or Republican, an independent, libertarian, you pay no attention to politics. We have a
constitution that says Congress writes the laws and enacts them. The administration is supposed
to administer those laws and the courts are supposed to make sure that the administration
follows those laws. Donald Trump is basically saying to Congress, I'm not gonna follow the
laws you wrote. I'll fire the people I want to fire or whatever. And the question is,
will he obey the courts when they tell him you're not allowed to do that?
Well, it doesn't seem like he is. It doesn't seem like he is so far, does it? I mean,
the court said that this Kilmar Obrego-Garcia needs to be returned to the United States.
The president of El Salvador basically said, I'm not gonna do that. Donald Trump isn't compelling
him to do that. I mean, isn't that a clear indication that he is not going to follow
the rule of law or he is not going to listen to what the judiciary branch says?
It is an indication. And by the way, here, I want to give a shout out to my good friend,
Senator Chris Van Hollen, who just went down to El Salvador and met with the man who is being held
and showing the importance of fighting back. But let's go back to our earlier part of the
conversation about cracks in the wall. Senator Kennedy, a Republican from Louisiana,
just said yesterday, whoa, whoa, whoa, we have to bring back this man from El Salvador.
And it is important for the president of the United States to follow the law. So there's another
crack in the wall saying, at least the way I read it, there's at least one Republican
senator standing up saying, I still abide by the Constitution of the United States.
And many of those people didn't get due process though, right?
The focus is on this one, but you're exactly right, Katie. And that's why it's so important.
Because if Donald Trump can disappear Abrego Garcia off the sidewalks in the United States,
he can disappear you or me or anyone else. And that's really the point here.
Chris Van Hollen made this point clearly. He said, look, I'm not here to defend,
to have a factual argument about who this man is. I'm here to say that in the United States,
nobody gets disappeared without a chance to get in front of a court. It's called due process of
law to say, whoa, they've got the wrong person here, wrong name, not me, don't have the right
facts. Because in this particular case, the government, the federal government has already
admitted, oh, this was a mistake. And all of the talk about who this guy is and Donald Trump's
claiming he's a gang member and so on. They're not bringing that into court. They're not offering
evidence in court. This is all just talk to try to keep people in Donald Trump's camp.
The bottom line is, due process is there to protect all of us. And we need to bring this
man back. We need to bring them all back right to get the due process they are entitled to,
to make sure that nobody gets disappeared off the streets of the United States of America.
I want to turn to Social Security and the Social Security Administration because you're a ranking
member of the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs and a member of the Senate
Finance Committee. On Friday, you published an op-ed on Fox News about the Trump administration's
gutting of the SSA, the Social Security Administration. So what has been done already
to that administration, Elizabeth, that is a cause for concern?
So let me just start by reminding everybody that the administration on its own cannot cut
Social Security benefits. If they want to cut Social Security benefits, they got to come
to Congress to do it. So what Donald Trump and his co-president Elon Musk have done
is they found a backdoor way to cut benefits. And the backdoor way is basically to administer
the system in a way that drives up the number of errors, that is mistakes that you don't get,
what you are legally entitled to, and make it more and more impossible to get those errors corrected.
And look, that over time means a lot of money that people are legally entitled to that they
don't get. I always start this conversation by saying, damn it, Social Security is not charity.
It is something people earned all of their lives. Every single paycheck they earned from the time,
for some folks, they were 14 years old. A piece of that paycheck has gone into Social Security.
On the understanding, the rock solid, no matter what, take it to the bank understanding,
that for sure, when the time comes that you have to rely on Social Security,
it will be there for you as promised. And Donald Trump and Elon Musk have tried to get rid of that.
And the way they've done it is they have tried shutting down Social Security offices so you can't
go in for problems. For a while, they were trying to shut down the phones entirely so you couldn't
call if you had a problem. And they are trying to fire, allegedly, about half of all the people who
work at the Social Security Administration. And understand, Social Security Administration was
already understaffed. These are good people who are trying to help folks who depend on their
Social Security. And here is, Elon Musk has been leading the charge on this, a man who makes
$8 million a day just on his federal contracts with our government, $8 million a day.
He's trying to cut benefits for people who, on average, make $65 a day. And why?
So that they can grease the skids to give more tax handouts to billionaires and billionaire
corporations and pay for it on the backs of seniors in their Social Security, little kids
and public education, babies and healthcare, and promises we make to our veterans. That's
the realignment they're trying to make happen in the United States of America.
I have to ask you about the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, because, Elizabeth,
you were instrumental in establishing that. What will be the fallout there from Musk's
doge cuts? And why is this entity so important in your view?
So back before the 2008 crash, we had all these consumer protection laws,
but they were scattered in a bunch of different agencies. And frankly, nobody enforced them. One
of the consequences of that is a bunch of lying, cheating mortgages got spread all over this
country. Risk built up in the system. People got cheated. They defaulted on their mortgages and
brought down our economy and brought down the worldwide economy over it.
Lesson to be learned is that if we're going to have just kind of a level playing field here for
consumers, you've got to have a cop on the beat who actually knows the law and is willing to get
out there and enforce it. It's not any fancier than that. So we gathered up these laws from all
the different agencies and built one agency that just have one job, and that is to enforce those
laws so we have a level playing field for consumers so they don't get cheated when they have a credit
card, a checking account, a Venmo account, a mortgage, a student loan, just kind of any of
those basic financial transactions. So we get the little agency passed into law. It's part of
Dodd-Frank. Get it set up. And it's been operational for about a dozen years. In the dozen years,
it has discovered about $20 billion in fraud. I mean, just cheating people. And it's everything
from little tiny frauds, I say little tiny, but it matters, that they kind of nipped a few bucks
off your checking account for some fee you didn't owe, all the way, you see them, $25,000 that you
made in a down payment on a home and it went into escrow and now nobody will give it back to you
when the deal fell through. So a big range here. $20 billion. And you know what the consumer agency
has done? They have made every one of those companies give the money back to the consumer
they cheated. They run a hotline. They've helped more than 200 million Americans. In other words,
it's government that works for people. So what Elon Musk has done, and by the way,
government has recovered so much more than what it costs. And it's, like the other bank regulators,
financed outside the tax system. So it's not a part of the taxing authority. So anyway,
Elon Musk comes in and decides he's just going to shut it down. In fact, he posts on X CFPB,
the initials for the Consumer Financial Protection, or CFPB RIP, with a gravestone emoji.
Man, that's serious policymaking. And tries to shut it down. Now, it's all important,
but ask yourself, why is Elon Musk going after the CFPB? Because he's going after Social Security
to help grease the skins for the tax break. Over at the CFPB, you know Elon Musk has X,
the social media platform, millions of people on that. He wants to start something called X Money,
which is all of your financial stuff online. And he wants to be able to link it up
with your social media stuff to monetize your social media, your financial transactions,
every part of it. And who would be the regulator for his X Money? You want to make a guess?
Come on, Katie. The CFPB. So he wants to saw the CFPB. Now, the courts have told him,
you can't just shut the thing down. So now what they're trying to do is, well, okay, how about
if there's nobody here doing the work? And that's where they're in court right now in this fight.
But once again, Katie, what all of this is about is just this tiny handful of people
who want to profit, billionaires who want to profit, and they want to do it on the backs
of everyone else. Because you know how this affects everybody who's listening to us right now?
If you have a checking account and you get cheated by your bank, there's no cop on the
beat right now. If Zelle helps steal your money, no cop on the beat right now. If somebody won't
give you back your escrow money on your mortgage, no cop on the beat, no cop on the beat, no cop on
the beat. And by the way, you don't have to take my word for it. We had Jerome Powell in a hearing
shortly after Elon Musk had stepped in, and I asked him the question in the hearing,
who's out there enforcing the federal laws to keep American families from getting cheated?
And he said, no one. So this is one more example of trying to twist around
our country so it works even better for a billionaire like Elon Musk or a billionaire
like Tim Cook, we were talking about earlier on the tariffs, for a handful of billionaires,
Donald Trump and Donald Trump's immediate family, to benefit a handful of billionaires,
and everybody else in this country pays for it. A handful of billionaires who donated to Donald
Trump. I mean, not just any old billionaire. That's right. Not random billionaires. That's
exactly right. The billionaires who actually invested. Remember, Elon Musk put about a third
of a billion dollars into helping Donald Trump get elected.
And now they want payback.
That's right. That's exactly right. And that's the question that faces our nation right now.
When historians write about this moment, they're going to talk about this is the moment
when the question up for grabs is, is this country going to work even better for a handful
of billionaires who get to make all the decisions to benefit themselves? Or are we going to reassert
our democracy, Democrats and Republicans, and we're going to say, no, we are rule of law.
We still have Congress that writes the laws and the job of the administration is to administer
those laws as written, to follow the law, to follow what courts say, not fire people when
you're not legally able to do this, not to shut down programs that you have no legal right to do
this. Do we have a country where our government is actually following the law? And that was just
not an open question until Donald Trump and the last three months. And to me, this is why I'm in
the fight, Katie, because this is the fight for our country and for our children, for our
grandchildren. Are we a country that just thinks the only people worth benefiting are billionaires?
Or are we a country that thinks there's dignity in everyone and that everybody ought to have
a fighting chance to build a future? And are we a country of laws, right? And a constitution.
One day I want to talk to you about Harvard and everything that's going on in higher education
since you taught at the law school there, but we'll do it another time. Senator Elizabeth Warren,
thank you so much for talking with me as always. Oh, thank you for having me. It's always good
to visit with you.
