l materials in these videos are for educational purposes only and fall within the guidelines of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. This video does not provide investment or financial advice of any kind.
Small business is the backbone of our economy, or at least that’s the story. Entrepreneurs taking a chance on themselves to start a business have provided employment to millions of people, created innovative products and services that you enjoy every day, and in return they can achieve levels of financial success that would be impossible with almost any regular old day job. You would be silly not to give it a go at least once in your life right? Well that message has been heard loud and clear by millions of people, because if you look at the numbers it would seem we are living through a golden age of new entrepreneurs. There are now TWICE as many new business applications being processed every month then there was before the pandemic. Politicians on both sides of the isle have been quick to take credit for this trend as the personification of the American dream, Unfortunately this record setting business creation has made a lot of people very angry, because those new businesses are being started… by poor people… So instead of being an indication of a thriving business environment it’s instead a sign of… everything wrong with our economy… if you believe the numbers…
Small business is the backbone of our economy, or at least, that's the story.
Entrepreneurs taking a chance on themselves to start a business have provided employment
to millions of people, created innovative products and services that you enjoy every day,
and in return, they can achieve levels of financial success that would be impossible
with almost any regular old day job. You would be silly not to give it a go at least once in
your life, right? Well, that message has been heard loud and clear by millions of people,
because if you look at the numbers, it would seem we are living through a golden age of new
entrepreneurs. There are now twice as many new business applications being processed every month
than there were before the pandemic. Politicians on both sides of the aisle have been quick to
take credit for this trend as the personification of the American dream. Unfortunately, this record
setting business creation has made a lot of people very angry, because those new businesses are being
started by poor people. So instead of being an indication of a thriving business environment,
it's instead a sign of everything wrong with our economy, if you believe the numbers.
According to the Census Bureau, last year, a record five and a half million people applied
for a small business application. Over the last few years, the number of applications
filed to start a new business has absolutely surged. Small businesses are not only job
generators, they're also at the heart of the American dream. In the last month,
we've increased the share of funding for small businesses with fewer than 10 employees by nearly
60%. I decided I'm going to tackle this problem by myself and start my own business. So new
businesses being formed is normally a really good sign that the economy is doing well.
People normally only start a new business when they feel confident about their future and the
future of the market they want to operate in. If you thought a recession was all but guaranteed,
and you weren't sure how you were going to pay your bills next month, you probably wouldn't be
starting a business. Lots of new business creation is also a sign that people have achieved a certain
level of financial security. Starting a new business often means making some significant
upfront investments into renting some commercial space, buying equipment, purchasing inventory,
and for a lot of businesses, hiring some staff. Most new business owners should also expect to
go for some time without taking any income while their business builds up sustainable cash flows.
This means if lots of people are starting businesses, lots of people are in a comfortable
enough financial position to bear these costs. Lots of new businesses is also more than a sign
that things are going well. They actually make things go well. New businesses create
employment for people who just want a job and they improve productivity in a few ways.
Business owners, especially new business owners on average, will put in more time and effort
working for themselves than they would in a regular day job. This means they are making
more output than they would be if they were just working a 9-5. New businesses can also
become successful businesses that bring valuable products or services to market.
If you start a business-to-business company that develops a new type of software that
streamlines AI-generated LinkedIn appreciation posts, then you could save millions of wasted
man-hours across the country, which means workers could actually do something better
and more productive with their time. Likewise, if you start a business selling a consumer product,
it could add competition to the market for similar products, or if you develop a new product
altogether, it could make people happier, healthier, smarter, or just keep them entertained.
Of course, most new businesses fail. But for society at large, the few that succeed are
usually a good thing. So then why is this record level of business creation in America
not exactly great news? Well, there are actually three reasons.
The first is simply why these businesses are being started. A 2023 paper by Ryan Decker of
the Federal Reserve Board and John Haltewinger of the University of Maryland found some
interesting patterns with these new businesses. The first was that these new businesses were
largely being formed in states and counties with lower average incomes. Now, most counties saw an
increase overall, but the outskirts of cities, particularly hard-hit states, outpaced the rest
by a significant margin. The authors of this paper suggested that a lot of this business formation
was just existing businesses closing in city centers that didn't see much foot traffic and
reopening in suburbs where the rent is lower and they can cater to a market of people working
remotely. This wouldn't actually really increase business activity because it's just moving it
around from one place to another, but closed businesses can stay registered for a long time
after they physically shut down. Now, this move to the burbs might not actually be doing any good,
but it's not doing any harm either. Unfortunately, it doesn't account for the entirety of this trend,
and a lot of the other people starting a new business aren't doing it to follow their dreams.
They are doing it because they have no other option, and it's probably making things much
worse than we realize. So it's time to learn how many works to find out how a record number of
This week's video is sponsored by Morning Brew. Morning Brew is a free daily email newsletter
that keeps you up to date on the must-know news affecting your work and life through a business
lens. It's designed so that you can skim topics you don't care about, dive deeper into what you do,
and still grasp the day's business news in under five minutes. I've been reading Morning Brew
every day, and it's a game-changer. For example, I learned that Florida is now considering scrapping
property tax, and Wall Street bonuses set records last year, and this year might not be as good,
to say the least. I can see why over 4 million people are hooked on Morning Brew,
and the newsletter is 100% free. So, worst case scenario, you unsubscribe and go back to dry,
long-winded, and boring business news. It takes less than 15 minutes to sign up,
so try Morning Brew today by clicking the link in the description or by going to
So actually figuring out how our economy is going is something that our governments really
struggle with. Collecting data on hundreds of millions of people, millions of businesses,
and billions of transactions is actually really hard, so they often make some calculated guesses
based on historic patterns. As impractical as it would be for the Bureau of Labor Statistics to
scrape every job posting off indeed and look through every classified section to find new
jobs being created, it wouldn't even be that accurate. The rise of ghost job listings means
that there are almost twice as many job postings as there were 5 years ago. But as anybody who has
tried to get a job in the last 24 months will tell you, businesses aren't exactly in a rush to hire.
That's a problem, because government agencies use job creation data to make very important budget
and interest rate decisions, so we really shouldn't be making shit up. One of the other
historical assumptions has been more business creation equals more job creation. Businesses
need employees, so this makes sense. Except the data has actually started saying the opposite.
In their report on the rise in new business applications, Decker and Haltewinger found
that counties with a higher rate of business creation were actually correlated with a higher
rate of job destruction. This data really just confirmed what a lot of people already suspected.
People weren't starting businesses to take advantage of some amazing opportunity.
They were starting them because they had no other choice. According to a broad market survey,
36% of the American workforce is now engaged in the gig economy. Some of these people are doing
this in conjunction with their regular day job as a way to earn extra money. But whatever the
exact details, that is still a significant increase from just 5 years ago. Gig workers
are encouraged to register a business and keep track of their revenue and expenses just like
any other business. But unlike other businesses, none of these people are going to be hiring
employees or investing a lot of money into the broader economy. In the past, people starting a
business usually had a bit of experience in their field and a bit of cash in their pocket to get
their business set up. At the very least, they had some investors that were willing to trust them
with upfront capital to get their idea off the ground. Most of these new gig economy businesses
today are started by people without enough experience to land a job and without any cash at
all. Now, it's not all bad. For a lot of people, being able to sign up instantly to perform work
in the gig economy instead of going through the outdated hurdles of job interviews is a big reason
why these platforms have become so popular. But these jobs also shouldn't be sugar-coated.
They are insecure, don't pay well, and are quite dangerous. This technology is truly unprecedented,
and in the short term it has existed, it's already reshaped what we think of as work.
It's really up to you if it's been for better or worse though. So you might think this is just
another example of a slow government struggling to keep up with changes in technology that have
redefined the labor force. But there are two reasons why government agencies have tried really
hard to intentionally ignore this trend. The first reason is that headlines about job creation
and business development are great for re-election. Nobody wants to be in charge when the data
collectors change their methodology and reveal that millions of jobs we thought exist actually
don't. The second reason is that it makes it look like big programs are actually working.
Late last year, the Small Business Administration made a press release bragging about the success
of a business loan program made to minorities. In it, they highlighted how previously underrepresented
groups had been starting a record number of businesses. Now before a whole big thing starts
in the comments, yes, these loans probably should have been made based on socioeconomic need,
but statistically they show the same thing anyway. The Small Business Administration thought they had
successfully empowered a new group of business owners. What they had actually done was just
record these groups registering for Uber Eats. Even highly skilled workers with a lot of experience
have not been immune from this trend either. The number of people working as independent contractors
jumped significantly as businesses moved away from full-time hires and the worker protections
that came with it. Typically, independent contractors should have the freedom to work
when and where they want as long as they deliver the agreed-upon product or service within the
agreed-upon time frame. But a lot of businesses have not so subtly mandated that their contractors
be in office just like any normal employee, just without the security or benefits. A study by the
National Employment Law Project found that a lot of these independent contractors were forced to
This meant they had all the independence of an employee combined with all the safety of someone
in business for themselves. Now, for certain people, especially those at the top of their
field, being an independent contractor is a great opportunity to provide services to multiple
different companies and charge a much higher hourly rate than 9-5 employees ever could.
These kinds of private contractors didn't suddenly become twice as common though.
Most of this growth is simply explained by people working full-time jobs with contractor conditions.
It also means that job opportunities aren't as plentiful as the numbers would suggest,
because even if lots of new jobs have actually been created, they are likely being worked by
someone who already had a job and just needed a second or third source of income to keep up with
living expenses. Now, I know for a lot of you watching, you already know this. But ignoring
this issue will probably end up making it worse. These charts aren't just here for me to make
depressing videos every week. They should inform policy. If we can't even acknowledge a problem,
it makes it much harder to fix. Now, if we want to encourage genuine business activity,
that's great. And there's a lot we can do. Actually banning non-competes, making it easier
for business owners to save for retirement, and making access for healthcare easier for people
who don't get it through their employers. But these things are hard. There is one other group
that would really like everybody to keep on looking the other way, and those are the platform
businesses that have made this all possible.