Who Were the Proto-Indo-Europeans?

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 28, 2025
A captivating overview of the origins and characteristics of the Proto-Indo-Europeans, as well as theories regarding how they managed to spread through Europe and Asia. A new theory of the origins of the language released in July 2023 is also discussed and challenged. 00:00 - Intro 02:19 - Discovery of Indo-European
There are times in human history that appear calm, like the surface of a lake on a still summer's day.
Then there are other times when those waters of history bubble and froth, crashing against the
shores of time in a furious gale, sweeping away all that stands before the surging forces of fate.
The origins of the world we know today was born in such tumult,
shaped by the fires of war, migration, and catastrophe.
Thousands of groups have been swept away by the bloody tides of fate,
many of which we know nothing about, some of which we have but the footprints they left behind.
Yet few such periods were as significant to the origins of so many people across the world
as the dramatic events that took place in Eastern Europe some 5,000 years ago.
From the far western shores of Ireland and Iberia, to the Indus Valley and the deserts
of Xinjiang China, a mysterious people hardly recognized in archaeology defeated the forces
of nature and the civilizations that came before them to conquer more lands than any empire in
pre-modern history. From those people, the languages of Hindi, Persian, Russian, Spanish,
English, German, and Gaelic have all come. They are known commonly as the Indo-Europeans.
But who really were these people? When did they exist? And where did they actually come from?
How could they possibly have had such a dramatic impact on the languages and cultures of so many
people across the world? New linguistic theories have recently been birthed to challenge the
long-standing views, all of which will be examined as we seek to answer, who were the
Indo-Europeans? Hi friends, I'm Kevin MacLean. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and consider
supporting the channel through Patreon, PayPal, or YouTube SuperStickers. Your support helps me
to make long, in-depth videos like this. I appreciate all of your support. Though Indo-Europeans
are a popular topic of conversation among those interested in ancient pre-history, archaeology,
mythology, and linguistics today, it has been popular for quite some time. The modern awareness
that many of the languages of Europe, Iran, India were anciently connected can be dated to the 16th
century. Individuals who had experience in India recognized linguistic commonalities,
but it wasn't until the 18th century that the question began to be more widely known and
discussed in some detail by academics. Mikhail Lomonosov, a Russian polymath born in St.
Petersburg in 1711, known for his groundbreaking achievement in astronomy, geology, physics,
engineering, and poetry, noted that Latin, Greek, German, and Russian must have had a common
ancestry in the ancient past. By the end of the 18th century, the topic was taken up by Sir
William Jones, and by 1813, the use of the term Indo-European was coined by Thomas Young,
using the western and eastern extremities of the proposed language grouping as the basis for the
name. Now, noticing a relationship between Indo-European languages is really only as
difficult as becoming familiar with a few. While there are a lot of differences, there are key
similarities in nearly all of the languages that are recognizable to nearly anyone. Family names
and structures are some of the most core vocabulary in a language, and Indo-European languages nearly
all share many important family words. Father in English, pater in Latin, pateras in Greek,
pedar in Persian, pita in Hindi, ahir in Gaelic, and we also have English mother, Latin mater,
Greek mitera, Persian modar, Russian mat, Gaelic mahir. There are many other words shared across
many of the languages, so that anyone familiar with several would have some inkling that there
was a connection. So why then did it take until the 16th century for anyone to notice?
It may not have. The ancient Greeks had extensive dealings with a wide range of people,
many who spoke Indo-European languages and some others who didn't. In their myths,
they claimed that the ancient Greek hero Perseus was the founder of the Persians.
Now, this is often explained by the similarities of the given name of the hero to the name of the
ethnic group, but it may have been more than this. While modern Greek and modern Iranian
languages have moved further away, in part due to different sets of loan words,
ancient Greek and ancient Iranian were more similar to each other. Recognizing this might
have given justification to some Greeks for thinking there was an ancient connection between
the people. As with most mythology, this was explained through a founder myth. This is the
same for many other European peoples that the Greeks interacted with. Greek accounts typically
depict all other Europeans as having an ancient blood relation with Greeks, often via the wide
traveling Heracles. Many nations in Europe agreed that they were related to the Greeks in ancient
times, with an account by Ammianus Marcellinus recording a Germanic community who proclaimed
themselves the descendants of Odysseus when he was on his ten-year journey. The Romans also
recognized a commonality, though they tried to express this in a less direct way. Famously,
the Aeneid tells of how the Romans were the descendants of the Trojan hero Aeneas. However,
the Roman knowledge of the ethnic character of the Trojans was entirely derived from Homeric epic,
which depicts them as speaking and being essentially Greek, worshipping Greek gods
and following Greek customs. The idea that the Romans were related to the Trojans was likely
devised in part for political purposes, but expresses the belief that they were closely
connected to the Greeks. Among these ancient peoples who spoke Indo-European languages was a
belief that they were all related in an ancient past, and we can suppose that part of the reason
for this belief was the awareness of similarities in language, which were greater than they are
today. One clear proof of the recognition of this linguistic similarity and awareness of it
is found in an ancient account by Pliny the Elder. He explained that the meaning of the word Druid,
an ancient Celtic priest, was likely connected to the Greek word for the oak tree which they revere,
an etymology that is in fact correct. Recognizing that an Indo-European common
ancestral language existed, of course, was the easy part. The hard part was finding out
who originally spoke this language. Who were the Proto-Indo-Europeans?
By far the most widely agreed explanation for the origins of Indo-European is labelled
the Steppe Hypothesis. The theory was first widely promoted by philologist Otto Schrauder
in the late 19th century. He undertook extensive study into the common roots for domestic plants,
animals and technologies across the Indo-European languages and concluded that the early
Indo-Europeans were pastoralists who domesticated horses, as so many common Indo-European words
were related to horses and horse-related gear. He thought that they must have resided
on the Pontic-Caspian steppe where horses were native. This theory was later supported,
fleshed out and articulated by Lithuanian archaeologist Maria Gimbutas and more recently
corrected and expanded on by many researchers in linguistics, genetics, archaeology and anthropology
such as David Anthony among many others. Seemingly because certain political groups
and ideologies in the early 20th century abused simplistic ideas about Indo-Europeans to further
their own racial views, there was a reaction against a concept rooted in emotion rather than
objective analysis which until recent advances of archaeogenetics was trying to douse the flames of
any Indo-European ethnic origin theory. However, we now know that these theories,
only half guessed at by earlier researchers, were at least partly or even largely correct.
There was a genetic flow into Central and Western Europe around 3000 BC from the Pontic-Caspian
steppe. In simplified analysis, this is often referred to as steppe ancestry or Yamnaya.
Modern Europeans have differing levels of this ancestry ranging from very low in places like
Sardinia to around 50% in places like Britain, Ireland, Lithuania, Belarus, Norway and others.
Most scholars now accept that this influx of steppe ancestry was responsible for the introduction
of the Indo-European language into Central and Western Europe. Although a continuing battle
now surrounds the ultimate origin of this language which we will look at shortly,
most agree that even if its ultimate origin were not in the steppe,
that it spread into Europe predominantly by populations from the steppe.
The origins of these so-called steppe people is to be found in groups of eastern hunter-gatherers
who had inhabited the eastern and northeastern fringes of Europe since at least the Mesolithic.
Genetically, they had descended largely from ancient North Eurasians and likely had a common
origin with Uralic peoples in a very distant past. This is possibly reflected linguistically.
There have been debates among linguists for over a hundred years about whether there is a common
connection between Indo-European and Uralic languages due to structural similarities as
well as some cognate vocabulary. As eastern hunter-gatherers were almost certainly the
progenitors of the Indo-European language, the similarities noted by some are likely to be
explained by a very ancient common root in a language spoken by Eurasian hunter-gatherers
tens of thousands of years ago. These eastern hunter-gatherers were spread over a vast territory
and likely spoke many related languages with many regional dialects. Some of this linguistic
diversity may be reflected in the different branches of early Indo-European. Breaking
with the typical trend seen elsewhere in the world, eastern hunter-gatherers produced pottery
while not practicing agriculture. They hunted, fished in rivers and seemed to have developed a
first known trade in amber. Genetic tests conducted on the remains of eastern hunter-gatherers
revealed that they were light-skinned and carried genes for blue eyes and light-colored hair.
Importantly, they also carried haplogroups R1b, R1a and I2,
all associated with later steppe cultures such as the Yamnaya.
By around 5000 BC, some of these eastern hunter-gatherers began to establish
identifiable cultural groups on the steppes of western Russia and Ukraine.
Steppe is a word derived from Russian meaning grassland or wasteland, whose ultimate etymology
is unknown. It's a vast expanse of flat, largely treeless country that extends like a belt from
eastern Europe to east Asia. What drove them to make this cultural change we cannot know for certain,
but if we look to later descended cultural practices, we may get a glimpse into the
lifestyle of these archaic Indo-European hunters. One cultural feature common to many
descended groups is the concept of the young outcast warrior band, one which is often closely
linked with the concept of the werewolf. I've done a specific video on the topic which details this
in different European cultures. This practice is very likely pre-steppe. While at times it was a
rite of passage, it was also related to the practice of the mass expulsion of young men
from a community facing overpopulation. Like most hunter-gatherer communities, the eastern
hunter-gatherers lived in relatively small family groups or tribes, likely representing not more
than a few hundred people typically. They would interact and share borders with other closely
related family groups with whom they would contract marriages. The physical limitations
of the pre-agricultural lifestyle strictly limited the size of these groups, and it also ensured that
they would have strictly enforced their boundaries. If they grew larger than the population of animals
and natural flora they consumed in the regions, or if poachers from other tribes were allowed to hunt
on their territories, they would face serious starvation. The boundaries between tribes was
very strict because without them it was impossible to manage the limited resources within
and ensure the survival of the community. All of this is very similar to how packs of wolves
organize, and the similarity was likely not missed by the ancient hunters.
Whenever the population of a tribe expanded beyond the means of their territories to sustain,
there were only three options. Expand into previously unclaimed lands, violently eliminate
other tribes and take their lands, likely beginning with poaching raids on their territories and
escalating into total war, or take a portion of the excess population and expel them from your
lands and have them live or die by their own merits. Often it was the latter that was resorted
to and tragically the most expendable people in any society are the young men. In times of crisis
they would be gathered up, dedicated to the god to watch over them and cast out to live as wolves.
It is little wonder these young men took the wolf as their totem animal and their god was always
closely linked to this animal. With the warming weather and the retreat of the ice sheet in the
Neolithic, the hunter-gatherer population was expanding more rapidly. Youths who needed to
establish their own lands either had to win their place through warfare or be willing to learn and
adapt to different lifestyles in order to survive in lands previously unclaimed. It's likely from
such bands of youthful archaic Indo-European warriors, expelled and landless, that the Pontic
steppe was first settled and the dawn of steppe pastoralism began, a prehistoric version perhaps
of the legend of Romulus and Remus. The first moves onto the steppe by the hunter-gatherers
were tentative, they first settled in the forest steppe and as they adopted pastoral activities
they began to extend their range a little bit further south so that they could graze their
cattle and other domesticated animals on the steppe lands. But with the invention of the wheel
and the wagon, perhaps around 3500 BC, the range of these steppe dwellers increased dramatically
and soon they were living out on the steppe in wagons and using wagons to haul the materials
that they needed to survive. A number of archaeological groups comprised of eastern
hunter-gatherers appeared on the steppe at roughly the same time. One of these, possibly the first,
is the Samara culture. Around 5000 BC they took up residence near Samara along the banks of the
Volga river. They were still practicing a hunter-gatherer lifestyle at this time but
already with them are the first signs of what would become the core of the steppe culture.
They produced artifacts depicting horses, they performed horse sacrifices and were responsible
for the earliest known horse burials. It is thought that these horses were wild horses,
primarily being used as food, but clearly at this early stage there is already developing a close
attachment and reverence for the horse. They buried their most honored dead in large mounds or
corrugans, covering their bodies with ochre, a red clay used for dye. The dead were effectively
painted red. This may be preserved in much later mythology which links the dead to the color red.
In Gaelic mythology there are riders of the dead called the Ferdarga, red men, and the Dagda,
a master of fertility and death, is also named Ruithroesa or Ruithri Ruith meaning red king red.
Contemporaneous with the people of Samara were those of the Dnieper Donets culture.
Like those in Samara, they were entirely descended from the eastern hunter-gatherers.
They also buried their dead covered in ochre, placed horse bones in burials,
and produced horse figurine. There is at least some evidence that they may have begun to engage
in some limited agriculture. Though both groups lived over a thousand kilometers apart,
both are genetically and archaeologically nearly the same, and it speaks to their common origins
as the first of the eastern hunter-gatherers to settle and make a life for themselves on the steppe,
but who had not yet adopted a pastoral lifestyle.
The first of these groups which appears to have become pastoral is the Kavalinsky culture.
Sometime around 4500 BC they begin transitioning from hunter-gatherers to primarily pastoralists,
herding domesticated animals, although it should be noted that hunting remained an important
activity for all of these groups, one which continued well into the much later Indo-European
cultures. The first evidence for horse domestication and copperworking is found with
them. That doesn't mean that the other groups were not doing this at the same time, but it's
evidence bias as we know only what has been recovered. Likely if one group in the region
was doing it, they were all by this time engaged in it. The Sredny Stog culture developed around
4500 BC and dwelled across much of Ukraine. They practiced pastoralism and some agriculture,
possessed domesticated horses as well as worked with copper, and engaged in long-distance trading.
There is some evidence that they range as far as the Balkans, with two individuals carrying
steppe ancestry similar to Sredny Stog examples found near Varna, Bulgaria, dating to between
4500 and 4000 BC. It was also among the Sredny Stog that the first use of corded-ware pottery
is found, and with those people the very origins of the later corded-ware culture may have begun.
All of these early Eastern hunter-gatherer descended groups are remarkable for their
physical robustness. They were noticeably larger and had stronger bones and build than most other
peoples in the same time period. In part this is likely due to the lifestyle and diet, highly
rich in fresh protein. Their custom of marrying from outside their own tribe would also lend
itself to a healthier genetic line. In a short 500 years, all of the groups of Eastern hunter-gatherers
who had moved into the steppe had adopted forms of pastoralism and were domesticating the horse.
A recent international study involving 150 scientists concluded in 2021 that the ancestor
of the modern domestic horse originated and was domesticated in the Volgodon region of Russia.
All domestic horses in the world are related to the horses broken on the steppe by ancient
Indo-Europeans, the first cowboys. Of course, the most talked about group to emerge on the
steppe was the Yamnaya. They likely developed out of the preceding rapin culture which began
around 3900 BC. It was with the pastoral rapin culture that the use of the wagon on the steppe
began in earnest and by the Yamnaya period this appears to have developed into family groups
actually living in wagons. It was a practice that would continue on the steppe for thousands of
years. For around 450 BC, the Greek historian Herodotus writes that particular groups of
Scythians lived in their wagons. It is possible that the wheel was first invented by the proto-Indo-Europeans
sometime around 3500 BC. While older theories generally placed the wheel as being first
developed in Mesopotamia and spreading north and west, there is a significant problem with this
theory. Most of the Indo-European languages, save for the Anatolian branch, have cognate words for
wheels and wagon related technology. Anatolian presumably does not share this vocabulary
because it split from Indo-European before the technology was invented, perhaps around 4000 BC.
These words cannot have been borrowed from one Indo-European language to another
as their morphological changes show that the terms descended from a common source.
Thus, this very significant technological innovation must have developed during the period
before the proto-Indo-European languages fragmented. It not only dates the language to the time period
of wheel technology, but because all the vocabulary surrounding the technology is entirely based on
Indo-European roots, it shows that the technology was almost certainly not borrowed, but invented
locally within the Indo-European language community. If the technology had been borrowed,
it is likely its foreign name would have been used. At the very least, we would expect at least
one term related to wheel and wagon technology to be borrowed. Because all of these words are
native Indo-European constructions, it's likely that the technology either developed simultaneously
north and south, or that it developed first in the steppe and very quickly spread to numerous
other regions. We do know for a fact that it was among the Proto-Indo-Iranian Sintashta culture
that the earliest evidence for the use of the spoked wheel was found, around 2000 BC.
And it's a curious thing that nearly all the Indo-European cultures made the wheel
a significant religious symbol. While the symbol may be originally based on the sun,
it later fuses with the symbolism of the physical wagon or chariot wheel,
with which the sun is strongly associated with in the earliest Indo-European myths.
This expresses how important the wheel was to the life of the Proto-Indo-Europeans.
Because of the open flat space of the steppe, they were able to utilize the wagon and later
the chariot like few other cultures could. They drove across the vast grasslands like ships upon
the sea. It could be that such ideas were also why ships were poetically referred to as steeds
in Norse poetry, and Greek Poseidon, possibly an early god of horses and the vast land-sea
that was the steppe, becomes a god of sea and ships. With the Yamnaya is also found the first
physical evidence for horseback riding. A recent study by Trautmann et al. points to horse riding
by Yamnaya individuals by around 3000 BC. The cult status of the horse, noticeable in the Samara
culture from around 5000 BC, is likewise found in many later attested Indo-European cultures,
with similar very strange rituals found in both Irish and Vedic sources of a sovereign
wedding a horse then sacrificing it. The commonalities between such extreme practices
suggest that it must have originated from a Proto-Indo-European cult practice developed
on the steppe. The cow was also an extremely important ritual animal and in the daily life
of the Yamnaya and other western steppe herder groups. Indo-European mythology envisioned a
primordial cow whose milk represented the cosmic waters and many goddesses and subsequent traditions
are connected with cattle. The burials of the Rapan culture began with typical flat graves,
the dead covered in ochre the same as nearly all the other eastern hunter-gatherer descendant
peoples. As they expanded they began to adopt the use of tumuli and the practice was maintained by
the Yamnaya. Also notable is the use of kromlechs, meaning essentially megalithic stone circles.
Many ancient Rapan and Yamnaya stone circles have been identified in Russia and many other menhirs
or standing stones are associated with them. Sometimes they would encircle a tumulus with
standing stones, something we see replicated in Britain and Ireland, even in cases when the
tumulus was built by the preceding population. They created the karnosivsky idol, a stone carving
possibly of a god which strongly resembles other later carvings throughout Europe and clearly they
had a tradition of using stones to mark sacred spaces. On the step there was a limited supply of
wood. While the Yamnaya have gained fame for being identified as a source of the Proto-Indo-European
language, recent genetic research suggests that the details are likely more complicated than this.
While the Yamnaya certainly spoke a dialect of Proto-Indo-European,
they do not appear to have been the primary vector for the language's dispersal across Europe and
Asia. Instead, their dialect of the language is argued to have given rise to the Balkan
Indo-European languages such as Proto-Greek. They were also the origin of the Afanasievo culture
which moved to the far east and is thought to be the origin of the mysterious Tokarian language
that was recorded around 600 AD in the Tarim basin of Xinjiang, China. The root of most of
the Indo-European languages is, however, with groups of close relatives of the Yamnaya,
the Corded Ware culture. While it was earlier believed that the Corded Ware culture had been
formed directly from migrations from the Yamnaya, genetic studies suggest that this was not the case.
Though most Corded Ware individuals carry a high percentage of so-called steppe ancestry,
that is, a genetic mixture that was very similar to that possessed by Yamnaya, there are slight
differences in male haplogroups that suggest that they were derived from a very closely related
but separate group. Though they were primarily pastoralists, they did not dwell directly on the
steppe, but within the forest steppe and even the forest. Evidence suggests they cleared great
stretches of land through fire and used these cleared areas to pasture animals and plant cereal
crops. They buried their dead in singular graves, sometimes with accompanying tumuli, very much like
the Yamnaya and other groups of a similar origin. Though they probably spoke a dialect understandable
to the Yamnaya and shared a very similar genetic origin and culture, they would have also had
cultural and linguistic differences. It could be that it was the forest steppe-dwelling cousins
of the Yamnaya speaking a very closely associated language or dialect, which was the ancestor of
the Indo-European languages like Slavic, Celtic, Iranian, Italic, Germanic, while the Yamnaya were
responsible for the spread of other branches such as Proto-Greek, Illyrian, Thracian, and Albanian.
However, these Proto-Indo-Europeans, whether Yamnaya or not, were similar enough linguistically
and culturally that we can probably make some broad sweeping generalities about them.
They wove textiles using plant fibers and wool and created fired pottery. They raised a variety
of livestock and possibly were instrumental in the breeding of sheep for wool production.
They engaged in some farming of cereals and had native words for plow and field.
They fermented milk to create cheese and they collected honey and produced a fermented beverage
of it. They used specially designed stones for grinding grain, nuts, and other plant material.
They trained horses and produced some horse gear still familiar today, though not the saddle,
and they built both two- and four-wheeled carts designed with yokes to be pulled by animal power.
They engaged in the production of copper and gold artifacts. They must have had houses with doors,
fences, boats, and many other tools and other artifacts that we don't always associate with
steppe culture. On a political level, they organized in tribes known as the Tewataha,
which were led by a tribal leader called the Hregs, known in descendant language as Raj,
Rex, or Ri, generally selected through a complex combination of aptitude, social status, and
ritual. These tribes were often bound up with other closely related tribes in client-patron
relationships, sometimes based on lineage, historical debts, marriage, and even mythological
reasons. This network of tribal alliances could at times bring vast numbers of people under the
political guidance of a single ruler, likely one who at least verbally traced his lineage back to
the gods. The legitimacy of rulers was upheld or cast down by a group of elders who served as
priests, while another group of people served as poets tasked with the memorization and recital of
tribal histories and divine hymns. They had structured views of social class, status,
honor, and one's relationship to the gods and to his community. They were strongly patriarchal,
and they likely believed that one could gain immortality through battle. They glorified
raiding, the abduction of women from rival peoples, and the total destruction of enemies.
Their heroes were warrior cattle raiders, as can be seen in the Vedic texts which praise Indra for
winning the cattle, and Heracles who plundered the cattle of Geryon. They organized war and
raiding bands who engaged in ecstatic forms of combat where the warriors mentally and spiritually
transformed into fierce, raving animals such as wolves. They may have fought naked, save for an
animal pelt, and entered into rages where they were perceived as being invincible. Yet, these
were not unsophisticated and unintelligent people. They had very strict rules about providing
hospitality to guests and strangers, which all the daughter branches shared. They gave elevated
status to priests and poets and people of art. Upon the king was placed the burden of upholding
truth, as the Gaelic lawgiver Morin described it. He had to guide the community like a seasoned
charioteer, looking all about him, judging the path in an instant, responding to every bump,
every stone on the field so as not to break the wheel rim under him. That path that the king must
find was the concept of the truth or right, meaning to them something like cosmic order,
known in Sanskrit as Krita. To the ancient barbarian stepherder, the ideal king was of
course a powerful warrior who could lead his people to victory, but he was also a wise man,
a guide, a pathfinder, a charioteer, a cattle herder, with the tribe envisioned as his chariot.
In what would be a shock to some, studies in 2015 revealed that the ancestry of the Yamnaya
was not, like earlier steppe groups, almost entirely eastern hunter-gatherer. While more
than 55% of their ancestry was eastern hunter-gatherer, they had picked up around 35%
from a group identified as Caucasus hunter-gatherers. It is around this group of
that the controversial new theory of Indo-European origins is centred,
and understanding the actual dynamics at play here is critical. It seems that as eastern
hunter-gatherer lineages extended further southwards towards the Caucasus, they came
into contact with a group identified genetically as Caucasus hunter-gatherers. They were closely
related to populations living on the southern range of the mountains, and would have been
a northward expansion of this population that crossed the Caucasus at some earlier point.
We don't actually know much about this population or exactly what they were involved in,
if they were actually still hunter-gatherers, or if they too had adopted a steppe lifestyle.
Regardless, at some point prior to the rise of the Yamnaya, there was a large admixing event
with this population. This in part is what led to a recent study by Paul Hegarty et al.
published in Science on July 28th, 2023. The study tries to categorize and date the divergent
Indo-European languages based on a systematic analysis of phylogenetic changes. They conclude
that while the western steppe herders do indeed appear to have spoken and spread the progenitor
language of Italic, Celtic, Germanic, Slavic, there is a break between these languages and
the languages of Greek, Hittite, and Indo-Iranian. They theorize that Proto-Indo-European first
developed around 6000 BC south of the Caucasus. Perhaps around 5000 BC this language moved north,
spoken by the Caucasus hunter-gatherers. When they mixed with the Eurasian hunter-gatherers,
the latter adopted the language of the Caucasus hunter-gatherers and established the root of
Indo-European. Before this, others from this same group migrated west into Anatolia,
creating the Anatolian branch of Indo-European, and Anatolians moved into Greece perhaps around
3000 BC. According to this theory, Greek would have developed from the Anatolian branch or been
very closely related to its origin. They also concluded that Indo-Iranian was unlikely to have
been the result of steppe migration, but was instead the result of migration from these
Proto-Indo-European speaking Caucasus hunter-gatherers who migrated into Iran and through
to India. Taking only a simplistic glance at this theory, it appears compelling. Curiously,
there are some words in Indo-European which appear to be cognate with ancient Sumerian.
Ab or ap means water in both languages. However, these can also be explained as linguistic
borrowings, as Indo-European has other words, water in English, voda in Russian, which may have
a common root with Uralic. It locates the origin of the language centrally and would, at a simplistic
level, answer the question of Anatolia. One key problem of Anatolian is not only its proposed
early dating, but that genetic studies have not found any significant level of steppe ancestry in
Hittite samples, although there are very few samples as of now to work with. But taking this
as proof that Indo-Europeans didn't spread from the steppe into Anatolia, the study instead looks
to this Caucasus hunter-gatherer population as the possible vector as it is found in Anatolia,
Iran and the steppe. What is critical to understand is that nearly all of this Caucasus
hunter-gatherer admixture among the Yamnaya came from women. All agree that the Yamnaya and related
populations were highly patrilineal societies, as are or were all the descendant Indo-European
societies. The concepts are powerfully rooted in the very language itself. It's inconceivable,
faced with this reality, that an almost if not entirely female admixture could form the nucleus
of such a dramatic cultural and linguistic transformation, especially given the nature
of the language and culture under discussion. In a traditional patrilineal society, women are
brought away from their own families. They dwell in the household of the male and his family and
must adopt their way of life and their language, their customs. It is agreed that the family
structure of Indo-Europeans operated in exactly this way. In such a scenario, word borrowings
could take place, perhaps especially associated with words linked to women and women's activities,
say water, which women were often responsible for fetching and for using to clean and cook with.
The feminine primordial goddess is frequently linked to water in Indo-European traditions.
However, a complete language shift is effectively impossible.
Most likely, the admixture results from one of two things, or a combination of the two.
Either the women were given over as tribute or, more likely or more frequently in my view,
they were taken by force through raiding, probably over the course of several generations,
and pillaging of a weaker group, unable to effectively defend itself. We know that elements
of an earlier cultural practice of raiding for women was preserved in nearly every
descendant Indo-European culture, making it likely that this was part of the proto-culture.
While earlier this raiding, not only for cattle but women, who poetically are often likened to
cattle, was mostly confined to other tribes that possessed eastern hunter-gatherer ancestry
when they came into contact with this Caucasus hunter-gatherer population.
They fully exploited them for this purpose. Indo-Europeans would undertake exactly the
same practices throughout Europe and Asia as they spread, often in places where steppe ancestry,
in percentage terms, is not high. Their male haplogroups will still be disproportionately
reflected due to their having obtained disproportionate reproductive access
to local women, to put it very politely. Linguists have long considered that the
Anatolian branch entered the region from Thrace. Recent genetic finds in Bulgaria show that steppe
ancestry, similar to Sredni Stog, was present in Bulgaria as early as 4500 BC, and it was likely
around this same time and from related groups that Anatolian developed, possibly developing
from a different dialect or sister language to Indo-European. That in the case of the Hittites,
the language becomes detached from steppe ancestry and even steppe haplogroups is uncommon
in the spread of the language group elsewhere, but not at all improbable. In the historical
case of the Hungarians, the entire ethnic group has become detached from its genetic origins as a
Ugrian steppe herder group, yet the language continues. In other cases, the Basque region is
dominated by Indo-European haplogroups, but the non-Indo-European language persists.
The Etruscans were found to be not significantly genetically distinct from other Italic peoples,
with a steppe admixture of around 35%, and yet the Etruscans spoke a non-Indo-European language.
Certain aspects of modern language spread cannot be reasonably compared to ancient ones, but
one aspect that is common is that power and prestige can play a very important role
in the spread of a language and often trumps simple numbers of speakers.
In places where small numbers of Indo-Europeans manage to gain power over an existing society,
the language may have taken and been established as the language of the ruling class.
After an initial domination, merging with the vastly superior numbers of the local population,
their line can become buried, even as the cultural and linguistic forms might persist and gain
dominance. We have seen such things play out within the historical period, and this is the
most likely explanation for the origin of Anatolia. The final serious flaw in the
conclusions of the new study, which I will mention here, are the proposals regarding
the spread of Indo-Iranian. Breaking with earlier linguistic analysis, it is claimed that there is
no closer relationship between Germanic, Slavic, and the Indo-Iranian branch. They estimate that
Indo-Iranian language broke off just shortly after Anatolian and was present through Central Asia
thousands of years before the recording of the Rig Veda. Inscriptions from the Mitanni,
which show strong Indo-Aryan influences including the names of Mitra, Varuna, Indra, and the
use of Indo-Aryan names since at least 1700 BC, does suggest that Indo-Iranian and its daughter
branch Indo-Aryan must have not only split earlier than is sometimes thought, but spread through the
region by at least this date. However, it is now well established that later migrations from the
steppe had a substantial genetic impact on the region, and it seems a very large leap to accept
that steppe populations moving in one direction would change the language of Europe, but moving
in the other direction had no noticeable impact, but that the language was already Indo-European
from a completely different source. The medieval influx of Turkic-speaking peoples from Asia
would reshape the language and genetics in the region. Their migration also stands as a test case
for how Indo-Europeans spread during its expansion phase. With these facts in mind,
Indo-European most certainly developed and spread via the steppe. The culture, language, and even
the genetics of these Proto-Indo-Europeans played a role in shaping many ethnic groups from the
Hindu, Pashto, Iranians, Russians, Armenians, Greeks, Poles, Germans, French, English, Gaelic,
Spanish, Portuguese, and so many others that now form the beautiful tapestry of the diverse
nations of our world. It's unfortunate that at times this amazing legacy has been weaponized
by certain groups and individuals. In reality, there are groups in Pakistan that have as much
Indo-European ancestry as some of those in Europe. All the descendant groups are mixed,
none of them are pure Proto-Indo-Europeans. Instead of fighting over who has more or less
Indo-European DNA, as I have unfortunately seen far too often, we should respect all
ethnic groups while recognizing and appreciating this amazing source of connection that many of us
from Indo-European-derived linguistic and cultural groups share and appreciate the thousands of years
of linguistic, cultural, and genetic divergence that reflects the history of each people and adds
445 beautiful blossoms to the world. I hope you liked this video, and if you did,
please like, share, and subscribe, and consider supporting me on Patreon, PayPal,
or through YouTube SuperStickers. Thank you all for watching, and as always, stand tall.
