🔰Stacey Abrams and Fair Fight Action CEO Lauren Groh-Wargo | Full interview | Code 2019

Stacey Abrams
1 follower
So I'm going to bring on Ezra Klein.
We're going to do an interview with someone
both Ezra and I have done podcasts with
and someone I noticed a long time ago
as an incredibly promising politician,
and also to talk to a partner in an area around voting,
fair voting.
Voting, democracy.
Democracy, important topics like that.
So go ahead and introduce them.
So we're happy to welcome Stacey Abrams, the former Lieutenant
Governor of Georgia, and Lauren Rowe Wall to the stage.
How you doing?
You guys sit over there.
Unless you want to do the interview, Stacey.
Nope.
Whatever you want to do.
That might actually be a lot easier, though.
I'm looking for a job.
OK.
So we want to bring here, Lauren is not as well-known as Stacey.
He's obviously been on television.
He ran for governor.
But Lauren was the, I don't want to say the brainsy operation,
because you both have incredible brains,
but was behind the scenes, ran your campaign, correct?
The word you're looking for is mastermind.
Mastermind, exactly.
And now you guys are doing this thing.
We're going to get to politics and things like that.
But I'd love it, Lauren, why don't you
start about what you guys are doing.
You had this campaign.
You ran it.
Did not win, but we can get into that in a minute.
You guys then decided to do this.
So explain what Fair Fight is.
So Fair Fight came out of the 2018 election
when about 50,000 people in Georgia
contacted our campaign about problems that they had voting.
And we knew we were up against Brian Kemp, who
was the sitting Secretary of State.
And as the Voting Rights Act was gutted,
he was the most aggressive Secretary of State in the country
in rolling back voting rights, in particular
for people of color.
So we knew going into it that we were up
against a guy with a horrible track record on voting rights
and had been changing the rules to make it harder.
So we were pretty prepared for that, all things considered.
We can talk about that, how we were prepared.
But even knowing all of that, the level of scenario
we got into, late and early vote and on election night
and in the days after, was an unbelievable miscarriage
of justice and violation of the rights of Georgia voters.
So through those 50,000 people that contacted us,
in a race that Kemp won by 54,000 votes,
we started learning into 10 days after the election.
Many of you will remember that the AP did not
call our race for 10 days.
It's going to be on my gravestone.
We kept the race from being called for 10 days
because we insisted that every vote be counted.
And Stacey stood up and said that.
And we took our entire $42 million campaign apparatus.
And at 2 AM when she made that speech,
we turned it into a provisional ballot chase,
a conversation with voters and elections officials
about ensuring that every vote was counted.
So through that and in those days,
as we were preparing to figure out what Cece was going to do
and how we were going to determine the next steps
after tracking every possible vote we could,
we were faced with a choice on how we were going to proceed.
So I had many fully drafted lawsuits on my desk.
And we had to decide which one we were going to file.
So I'd hired every lawyer in Georgia
to figure out what we were going to do
and had an incredible war room at that point.
So Stacey decided that she wanted
to proceed with the federal suit because we thought
if we took a suit to the federal court,
not to change the election outcome,
but to fight on behalf of Georgians whose right to vote
had been violated, to fix future elections,
to make it more fair, that we could take
what at that time was only 50,000,
which we knew if 50,000 people contacted us,
that meant 50,000 people meant to contact us,
but forgot or got busy.
50,000 people didn't know to contact us.
So we knew that there was this immeasurable number
of people who had suffered.
And so we took that and we took a 501c4
that we had for many years ago
and repurposed it.
A civic engagement organization joined
with Ebenezer Baptist Church and many other co-plaintiffs
to file litigation that says we're asking the federal court
to deem the Georgia election system unconstitutional
and that people of color are disproportionately targeted.
Okay, so Stacey, why this?
What was your, talk about why you decided to do this
because obviously you've had some,
apparently some job offers or some things
that you're going to sort out for us.
But why did you want to do it this way?
So as Lauren described, election night,
election couldn't be called.
10 days later, we knew that there had been
a number of irregularities,
things we'd known about for years,
but it came at a sharp relief.
And my two choices, one was to file a contest,
which would be to overturn the election.
And the other would be to file a lawsuit
that would fix future elections.
My commitment to the question of voting rights
began with my family.
My parents were both involved in the civil rights movement,
but for me, voting rights has always been a means to an end.
You cannot have true freedom without the right to vote.
You cannot get healthcare, you can't get education.
You apparently still can't have reproductive health
and reproductive rights, even if you have the right to vote.
But all of those rights are underpinned
by the right to vote.
And when I think about the infrastructure of America,
if you think about progress,
the three components are being able to access
the right to register, the ability to access a ballot,
and the ability to have that ballot counted.
Those are what we call our voting rights,
and those are under attack.
And my campaign was not singular.
We weren't the only campaign that was in a state
where voter suppression was real.
We just happened to be the only one
that was facing a cartoon villain
who happened to run with the referee
and the architect of the system,
and he also got to be the contestant and the scorekeeper.
And so we had the most dramatic example.
But the fundamental issue was,
without securing the right to vote,
without making it sacrosanct and real,
the rest of the policy initiatives
that we hold to be necessary and important
never come to fruition.
And that's not only true for Democrats.
This is not a partisan issue.
In the state of Georgia, we had a Republican primary
that had to be held three times
because of the incompetence and the challenges
that come when you start to erode
and corrode the voting system.
And so Fair Fight Action is not my full-time job.
Lauren is the CEO.
But I'm the founder because I believe
that we have to tackle head-on
the most existential crisis in our democracy,
which is the distance that we are creating
between citizens and the right to vote.
There's also this question.
There's also this question
laddering up to the national scene
of even when you can vote, does your vote matter?
So the president of the United States
was the runner-up in the popular vote.
The Senate is controlled by the party
that got fewer votes in the last three elections.
The House could have gone the other way
despite Democrats winning the popular vote
if it had been a little bit closer.
The Supreme Court reflects that.
Is America a democracy?
Yes, but we have to remember that we're vulnerable.
Democracy is resilient, but it is always vulnerable.
And we have, in our country,
sort of operated on an autopilot
where we presume it will always be so
because it has always been thus.
But that assumption has only ever been made
by one singular population, and that's basically white men.
Everybody else has been fighting to get there.
And so for those of us who come late to the conversation,
we've always been aware of the fragility of democracy
and the fragility of our voices,
which is why it is so important
that we fight even harder in a moment
where it's coming into sharp relief
because the demographic changes that we're facing,
and that's not just racial demography, it's age demography.
It's the shifting of populations
from the Midwest to the South.
All of those pieces are changing how our politics are lived.
And so yes, we have a democracy,
but that democracy is constantly in need
of refreshing and protection,
and we have forgotten that part of our responsibility.
So the lawsuit you got moved forward, correct?
Where is it now?
Yeah, so not surprisingly,
the state tried to kick us out of court,
and not surprisingly, we kicked their ass.
And that's what we do, that's our name.
Fair fight, we fight, that's what I do.
And so we have an incredible legal team and incredible staff
and not only did the state
have their motion to dismiss denied,
it was denied in a beautiful 85-page order
that used our own language back to us from the court.
And this is really important in terms of voting rights.
A, the standing issues in the suit are really important.
Stacey Abrams, the candidate,
our campaign is not a plaintiff in this suit.
These are grassroots civic organizations
that represent domestic workers,
that represent Martin Luther King's home birth church,
churches around the state, civic organizations.
The court agreed with us
that because those organizations work to engage voters
and educate voters,
they have standing because of future harm
this could do to them.
And so that's important for organizations in Florida
and Tennessee and Texas
that are facing unbelievable onslaught on the right to vote
that this federal judge has granted standing
and agreed with us in terms of standing.
So there's a whole series of things.
Brian Kemp is now the governor.
Not surprisingly, as governor,
he has not talked about this issue.
He has not talked about 29,000 provisional ballots
that were given out,
29,000 mainly African-Americans
in the state where he is governor.
Don't know if their vote was counted.
They map like a racial map of the state of Georgia.
You plot those 29,000,
it's a map of African-American neighborhoods.
This governor has never looked people in the eye
to explain that.
And he put a bunch of crap legislation
through legislature.
It's like, oh, I fixed it.
Here we go.
And the court says, nope, buddy, you didn't.
That didn't work.
What's the goal?
What is the goal for you all to do?
Because a lot of people have this idea
of the stolen election and it keeps doing that.
Is that?
Look, I don't call it the stolen election.
Others do.
Others do and I appreciate it.
But that's not the language I use
because the minute it becomes about me or a single election,
we miss the point.
This is about whether voters' voices can be heard.
It's about whether citizens are allowed to be voters.
And the moment it becomes about a single politician,
if you like the politician, it's good.
If you dislike the politician, it's a non-issue.
This is about our democracy
and that's got to constantly be the return.
We've got to get back to the fact
that politicians are elected to be representatives
of the people's needs.
And if they cannot engage in their system,
if they cannot have their voices and their values heard,
then we do not have a democracy.
And so no, it is not about the election.
The election was a marker on what I would argue
has been a 20-year story of irregularities
and intentionalities in diminishing the right
to vote in the United States.
Because it didn't start with Georgia.
You've got Wisconsin, you've got Texas,
you've got North Carolina, you've got Michigan,
you've got Pennsylvania, you've got New York.
You've got states that have systematically denied access
to the right to vote.
And until we correct those wrongs,
we do not have a thriving democracy in our country.
You're touching on something though
that has begun to concern me pretty deeply.
You said a couple of minutes ago,
this isn't a partisan issue, but it is.
The Republican Party has begun to see
that its interests coincide with less democracy.
Somebody made the point to me recently
that you can't possibly imagine bringing the voter age down
from 21 to 18 in today's America
because young people are democratic
and Republicans would never permit that.
When you think about the Electoral College,
it has a similar flavor to it.
When you think about Puerto Rico and DC
and potential statehood there,
it has a similar dimension to it.
It seems to be a pretty dangerous place
to be in as a country,
that democracy is becoming a partisan issue,
that it's seen as something
that if you're going to expand the franchise,
good for Democrats,
if you're gonna contract it, good for Republicans.
So it needs to be clear.
I said democracy,
the corrosion of our democracy isn't partisan.
The purveyors of most of the voter suppression
absolutely are partisan.
It has been a longstanding intent of the Republican Party
to silence the voices of those
who are not likely to be a member of their party
and that means young people, people of color,
and those are their two main targets,
primarily people of color
because race is the strongest predictor
of political leadings.
So yes, voter suppression legislation,
voter suppression behavior
is almost intentionally targeted
to communities of color and low-income communities.
But the corrosion of democracy has a broader sweep
because the problem is once you start
to break the machinery,
it breaks for everyone using it.
And that's why I think it has to be
that we also remind Republicans
that this is a danger to them as well.
The area where they had to run that election,
it was because the same incompetence and malfeasance
that was used to deny the right to vote
to millions of Georgians to have their full hearing,
it also had the ancillary effect
of affecting that election three separate times
because those same tools can be used against you
if they become part of how the machinery operates.
So let's talk a little bit about Georgia now
because right now, Georgia's gotten in the news
and you came out and I think both of you
had talked to me about this.
This is pre the reproductive rights issues.
You have come out pretty strongly
that tech companies often boycott states,
usually in the first,
now maybe companies are right there too.
You've talked about the idea of not boycotting these companies
which is something tech companies tend to do right away
or typically more than other companies.
Can you make the argument to tech people
why they shouldn't, if they're for reproductive rights,
why they shouldn't boycott?
What's your thinking?
I was surprised.
Leaning forward, okay.
I believe in boycotts.
I grew up in Mississippi.
I live in Georgia.
I only get to vote, go outside and eat because of boycotts.
So yes, I know they can work.
But we have to remember that boycotts
have to be directly connected to the goal.
And the challenge with reproductive rights
is that Roe v. Wade does not ban,
overturning Roe v. Wade doesn't ban abortion.
Overturning Roe v. Wade returns the authority
to determine access to abortion to the states.
And so even if Roe v. Wade is overturned,
if you have not changed the composition of the legislature,
then you cannot change the outcome
because you can get one law reversed,
but that does not stop a new law from taking effect.
The only way to fundamentally change access to abortion
and to make it the law of the land
is to change the composition of the legislature
and the governor in the state of Georgia.
Boycotting doesn't do that
because what you do is you suck out resources
and you actually remove potential voters
who could make it better.
It is better to stay, fix the voting system
because it was a 1.4% difference
even when voter suppression was at its height.
And we flipped 15 legislative seats during my election.
We can do even more.
And if we change that,
then you actually change the long-term outcome,
not only of reproductive choice,
but actually maternal mortality, access to healthcare.
We have to stop responding to the moment
and actually think about the mission.
And the mission for most of our states
is to actually expand who gets to participate.
That does not happen when the resources leave the state.
It just doesn't because that's what happened to the South.
And it's why the South has remained mired in so many ways
in a politics that has been very static
and very conservative and very hostile
because the very people who could have helped change it
left the playing field.
There are times where that makes sense.
This is not the time, I believe,
when we actually are on the cusp of change.
What do Democrats...
I really like you guys, thank you.
What do Democrats nationally misunderstand
about politics and their political opportunities in the South?
As a recent convert from Ohio who is now a true Georgian.
Is that like getting knighted?
There's a process.
Involves the Chattahoochee River.
So I think what Americans need to understand
is Georgia is the future of America
in terms of racial and ethnic composition,
in terms of how our demography
and how our conversation is changing.
And so I think there are a lot of lessons
everybody from an Ohio Democrat to an Alaska Democrat
to anybody running for president
should take from Stacey's race and from the state
because the entire country
is sort of moving towards that situation.
In Georgia in 2026, whites go to 49% of the population.
2026, Georgia's majority minority.
Correct, majority people of color.
And so I think what we did in our race
is build a new coalition.
We built a multiracial, multiethnic coalition.
And it is not the future of Georgia,
it's the now of Georgia.
And that meant we did things differently.
We had a lot of startups and investors here.
That means we didn't do the typical campaign playbook,
which has been, you raise as much money as possible
and you hold it so you can give it to some media consultants
to put it up on TV.
In the last couple of weeks, that's been the playbook.
Throw a little bit of money,
visit a black church on Labor Day.
You got your GOTV plan, et cetera.
That was not our approach
and I think it was a very different approach.
It was a controversial approach.
We spent money early.
We had an intentional strategy to use the year-long primary
to build for the general,
to start actually talking to general election voters
in the primary and get them engaged early.
We spent money on staff.
Spent a ton of money on digital, building lists,
all of those things.
And so why it's great to work with Stacey is she goes big
and we went big and we raised more.
And as investors know, as you invest in infrastructure,
then you can scale it more rapidly.
And then when you get into a larger revenue stage
in the general election,
you've got a foundation you've built on.
And so when you look at sort of how you raise money
in campaigns, we made early investments,
which meant we had crappy press reports
about low cash on hand.
And-
We would never report in a decontextualized way like that.
No, not you, Ezra.
Were there Trump Abrams voters?
Not to my knowledge, but this is what there were.
There was the largest support level
from white Georgia voters for Stacey Abrams.
By not just a little, by a lot.
So if anybody knows Georgia,
one of our large Atlanta counties is DeKalb County.
It's where part of city of Atlanta is
and a very democratic county.
In 2014, some of you may have known,
Jimmy Carter's grandson, Jason Carter, lovely human,
and Sam Nunn's daughter, Michelle Nunn, ran for office.
Those are big Georgia names.
They got 55% of the white vote.
Everybody thought, no way that this black woman should run.
She shouldn't run.
No way she'd be competitive in a general.
No way white Georgians would vote for her.
We heard this all day long for a year.
Stacey got 69% of those white voters.
So talk to Stacey about sort of
what the modern election looks like.
You used a lot of social media.
You're obviously a compelling politician.
What does a modern election look like going forward?
And we do wanna talk about 2020
and what the heck you're doing,
because I'm not clear.
Talk about what does a modern election look like?
Does it look like it's voted digitally?
Does it look like people vote on cell phones?
And then how does a politician approach elections?
I think it has to begin with how do you get voters?
And we used to say there is no path to victory.
There's math to victory.
Elections are math.
That's it.
You need more people to like you
and do something about it than the other guy.
And that means one of the things we did differently
was that we used digital,
we used technology to do persuasion.
Typically, you don't persuade
the people who should vote for you.
We spend all our time trying to convince Trump voters.
What I said is, look,
if a Trump voter likes what I say, you're welcome,
but I'm not going to change what I say
to convince you to come on board.
Instead, I'm going to use my time
and our energy and the resources
to tell people who already agree with me
that they should do something about it,
persuading them to vote.
And I think a modern campaign understands
that with the diffusion of information
and the fracturing of our sense of common purpose
that has unfortunately been a part.
That you have to spend more time and more money
on actually persuading people that voting matters.
Because I think to Ezra's question
about the nature of our democracy,
people do feel distant from it.
And if we want their engagement,
they have to be persuaded that engagement matters.
The second piece then becomes the architecture
of how they actually cast their vote.
I think there may come a time
where we can get to the security of voting online.
We are not anywhere near that.
In fact, we need to return to the very analog
of hand-marked paper ballots, I think, to secure.
In fact, there was a story out today
that North Carolina had online for anyone who wanted it,
the passwords to all of the systems for their voting system.
And that's one of the systems
that was actually investigated by Homeland Security.
Brian Kemp refused to let Homeland Security
evaluate our system.
And so before we move to digital voting,
to online, to voting by your phone,
we have to get the act of voting right again.
And I think the last piece,
so it's the process, it's the architecture,
and then it's the auditing ability.
And that's the most important piece.
One of the different things about our campaign,
and Lauren alluded to it,
was that we did not let them call the election
on election night.
You've got to get past this idea
that elections are decided by 11 p.m. Eastern Standard Time.
It's just not true.
We have provisional ballots.
You have absentee ballots.
You have mail-in ballots.
We have to recognize that our elections,
our future won't be decided in the evening in time
for a nightly broadcast.
And one of the responsibilities then is for candidates
not to deny the responsibility of elections,
but we also have to allow the process to play out.
And I think one of the parts of a modern election system
will be that as we expand how people can cast their ballots,
what they're doing in California and Oregon and Colorado,
that means we have to teach patience in our process.
Because if we want more people to come on board,
they have to believe there's a reason to do so,
and they have to be able to trust
that their vote will be counted and evaluated
and that the truth is actually told by the end of the day.
The next election that's coming up is 2020.
Really?
I've heard.
Okay.
Will you be running for anything in that election?
It's entirely possible.
What?
What would it be?
What would it be, yeah.
If you had to rank them by probability?
It would be an office.
Well, I'm not being coy.
I do not.
You're being a little coy.
I'm being funny.
Coy presumes I'm doing what I want,
and I'm not telling you.
Here's the thing.
I think we have a really strong slate
of candidates for president.
I think there are a handful of folks
who are good people who should not be president.
And for me, the conversation is when we get
to this next phase of the election,
I'm not disquieted by the number of people running.
It's a handful more than ran before,
but it's not overwhelming.
And it's good for our democracy to have people
who want to step up.
But we are gonna hit a point where we start to winnow out
who's actually viable and who's not.
And for me, viability is,
are you talking about the core issues of the day?
For me, the underlying issues that are suppression,
but also do you have a plan for victory?
Not a plan to beat Trump, but a plan to win America.
And we are starting to see what those plans look like.
Some people are better at announcing their plans
than others, but we're seeing that play out.
But it also means you understand
the composition of the electorate.
I will enter this race if I think that I can add value to it.
If I do not think I add value, I won't run.
And I don't have enough information at this moment
to make that determination.
Let me ask you about another level of it, though,
which is the presidential race exerts tremendous gravity.
But the Senate is important for Democrats, too.
And if there's gonna be a Democratic president,
they're gonna need a Democratic Senate to get much done.
Democrats have failed to recruit
the strongest candidates in Montana,
with Steve Bullock, who's decided to run for president
for an unclear reason to me.
They failed to recruit the strongest candidate in Texas
with Beto O'Rourke deciding to run for president,
with John Hickenlooper, again, deciding
for somewhat unclear reasons to run for president.
And then potentially, we don't know
what the strongest candidate in Georgia will do yet.
There seems to be a difficulty Democrats are having
getting folks to run for Senate
as opposed to the White House.
Why do you think that is?
I can speak for myself, and then I'll tell you
what I think about the basic argument.
I'll do the basic argument first.
The Senate races, most of the qualifying
won't happen until next spring.
The candidates who will be competing in those races,
if they decide that they want to run,
there is still time.
There's a sense of urgency because we know
how important the Senate is,
but there's actually no political urgency
to making that announcement now.
And it's just not, there isn't,
because a Senate race, you can stand up a Senate race
if you decide basically by the fall
that you want to run for the Senate.
Any strong candidate can stand up a campaign
to be ready for a primary if they have one.
And if they're strong enough, they may not have a primary,
in which case they've got a lot more time.
So that's true, and I think we need to remember
that people like to think about many things
and the public may not like the sequence of the conversation.
I am not running for the Senate
because I don't want to be in the Senate.
It is not because I want to run for president,
it's not because I want to run for dog catcher.
I made a decision early because I know
there were a number of people who want to run for Senate
who were waiting for me to decide.
And they were showing me an amount of deference
that I did not need, but I appreciate it
and I want to be respectful of it.
I've been in the legislature.
It is an incredibly important job
and the Senate is structurally necessary for our success.
It is not the job I want to do
because when you run for the Senate,
you need to plan to be there for six years,
12 years, 18 years.
That is a complete transformation
of the path I see for my life.
And I don't think you run for office
just because an office is there.
I'm in politics because there are things
I want to accomplish and I need jobs
that will let me do that
and the Senate is not that job.
The other thing is I'm not hubristic enough
to think I'm the only person who can win.
There are other people who can win the Senate.
If I've done my job as a leader in Georgia,
what Lauren and I have put in place
in terms of infrastructure,
the playbook we have demonstrated,
if it's true, another candidate can use it.
And so my responsibility is to help
the best candidate possible win that election
and that's my commitment.
But one of the things, Lauren, you told me,
I think people are surprised
because not many people don't grab at these things
immediately.
I think that's what the shock is.
You say, I just don't want to do it,
which I think is surprising to a lot of people.
Yeah.
But Lauren, you said you don't want to work
on politics anymore.
You want to do this.
You led a campaign that was pretty astonishing
that you got this close.
I don't know that I ever said that exactly to you, Kara.
Okay, all right, okay.
You said something like that.
It was surprising.
I mean, I am not a hired gun
who just goes and works for anybody.
It's not how I've operated ever in my career.
And so I am selective about what I do.
And it's, for me, coming,
what we lived through in the year and a half race,
and for me as a human and an individual,
in terms of thinking about how I would look people in guy
and how I would look at my child
and having a level of power and influence
in our party at this horrible time,
for me, I knew that voting rights
was not like the thing I signed up to do
as I went into my political career.
But I knew that what we witnessed was so egregious,
egregious is not a strong enough word.
I'm sure Stacey has a much better word.
So just horrible.
And that I was in a position of power to challenge that,
I felt like it was just duty.
We just had to do it.
And that we had to run it like a campaign
and bring all of the psycho in a good way
that we have to this effort.
And so I'm doing that,
but that doesn't preclude a whole lot of other things
as a professional.
Would you run her presidential campaign?
Stacey and I have been friends and partners for a long time.
And so I'll leave it at that.
Stacey, you've written some, I think,
quite interesting interventions
into the identity politics debate.
Something you hear a lot in Northern California,
it's something that presidential candidates
talk about disparagingly pretty often.
What is identity politics mean to you?
And what do you think we get wrong
when we talk about it in politics?
The phrase identity politics has been,
is a weaponization of the Democrats' structural advantage
in elections from now into eternity.
And Republicans recognized
that the homogeneity of their party
meant that they were left out of multiple conversations.
And so instead of solving their internal trauma
of not actually bringing more people into the fold,
they instead do what they do extraordinarily well,
which is brand this idea and make it a negative.
That paying attention to the disadvantaged,
the marginalized, the disconnected,
and identifying their issues
and connecting it to a political solution
was somehow an invalid construct.
Francis Fukuyama decided to dress it up,
and he's a very smart man,
but he decided to analyze it through a lens
that said that if we just return to the issue of class,
everything else will be satisfied.
And I'm being deeply, deeply disparaging
about his analysis.
It was much more complicated and thoughtful,
but still wrong.
Identity politics is simply this.
We all have identities,
but there are structural barriers
that impede access to opportunity for certain communities.
We know those are true.
We know those are real,
but we cannot fix them if we don't identify them.
And identity politics is the practice of saying,
I'm going to elect you in part because you see me.
I'm going to hire you for this job of representing me
because you can articulate the challenges I face.
And I will not hire someone
who refuses to acknowledge that I have a challenge.
Those challenges tend to be grouped together.
So we can talk about LGBTQ communities,
communities of color, the physically disabled.
You name the group,
but if there is a legitimate cohort
that faces barriers to opportunity,
identity politics is a reductive phrase
that is used to say that that should not be
a legitimate reason for election.
I would argue it is the only reason for election.
You are hiring representatives.
If they can't see you, how can they represent you?
That is the very basic construct of my argument.
One thing I want to pull out in that
is that you note that there is a growing demographic
advantage for the Democratic Party
as a collection of different groups.
And there can sometimes be among Democrats
a sense of demographic inevitability.
They believe that the wave is just going to come for them
and they don't actually have to do all that much
except wait until the moment when the electorate changes
to give them the advantage
that the Republicans can't do anything about.
You've talked about demography not being a destiny,
but a kind of opportunity.
So I'm talking about what the difference
between doing it in those two ways is.
Destiny says it's going to happen inevitably.
Opportunity says it can happen, but you got to work for it.
It's kind of like dating someone.
Yes, you two may be in the same room,
but he or she is not going out with you
unless you do something about it.
And in democratic politics,
we have waited for destiny to just
put the person in front of us
and thus we are together.
We've ignored the responsibility,
which is why Lauren is so extraordinary
as a leader of campaigns,
which is that you've got to go and get it done.
You've got to do the work of conversation.
You've got to do the work of engagement.
You've got to do the work of turnout.
Voting does not happen because people just wake up
and think I should vote.
Voting happens because they believe
something will come of it.
They are giving of their time.
They are giving of their trust.
They are investing their hope.
They have to believe there is something that will come of it.
And those very demographies that we're waiting
to emerge have been the most disassociated
from real opportunity.
And so we have to recognize that we want
to convert that energy and opportunity,
that energy and that change into actual destiny.
We've got to do the work to make it so.
All right, last question and we'll get
to audience questions.
How do you think tech has impacted all of this?
Lauren, you start and Stacey, you finish.
What do you think tech is responsible for
in a negative way and possibly
in a positive way going forward?
Well, the first thing I'm gonna say
is not exactly tech's fault.
I think it's Republican austerity government
has been part of the way they've broken election system
in this country and made them vulnerable.
There's certainly a laundry list of examples
I could give you in Georgia.
Leaking data, letting data get hacked,
lack of data integrity.
So that's not tech's fault.
That is austerity government bundled together
with a hatred for African Americans in the South.
But I think the tech conversation on how we vote,
if we had thoughtful leaders,
we had governors like Stacey who want to think about
how do we bring tech in to invest and partner
with government to have the best in class security
in those things.
So I think tech could be really part of that solution
if we had government agencies and elected officials
who were thinking that way.
So that's one thing.
And then as an operative, obviously,
things have just changed a lot since I've been doing it.
I'm 39, I started this when I was 22.
And in terms of how we do targeting,
how we do communications,
and I think sort of the media fragmentation
creates just so many opportunities to reach communities
that beyond sort of a field contact and a doorknob,
we can now not only find them through
that sort of traditional way,
but also through how we do targeting on Spotify
and how we engage in digital advertising.
So I think I've seen a lot of good
in terms of especially at a campaign like Stacey's
where it hadn't been done before.
And so we had to sort of create a new model.
And so we invested really broadly
in all different types of platforms.
We were on white country music radio,
and we were on Pandora.
We were sort of across the spectrum
trying to understand how we could really reach people
and into new audiences.
And what was the second part of your question, Kara?
Do you see any negative aspects of it?
Like what happened with Cambridge Analytica
and the abuse of?
I mean, everything gets used for bad in our sector.
I mean, when you have,
people still send out robocalls lying to people.
So I think I have a very high,
like it gets all effed up.
Like Cambridge Analytica, sure.
I know our side does a lot of things.
Look, I mean, I said two things
at the beginning of our campaign.
I said, one, Stacey wasn't gonna get assassinated
and two, Russia wasn't gonna hack my effing campaign.
Neither of those things happened.
They tried both, right?
They tried both.
And so I think part of what tech has to understand,
I think what operatives have to understand,
it's so, it's a battlefield.
You know, we're dealing with an enlivened KKK,
an emboldened KKK.
We're dealing with really active foreign interference.
So you can't just go run for Senate
because it's available
and just go hire a campaign manager off the street
and everything's good.
I just, no.
Like you gotta wanna do these jobs.
You better have a team that's like ready
to take the bullets.
I mean, this was, this is no joke.
I, and I don't say that to dissuade anybody
from running for office,
but just that this is why I like Stacey.
I mean, she doesn't make a flippant decision.
These are really big decisions.
It's nasty out there.
We got all the social media folks in the room,
you know that.
But that, but that means, you know,
that's a great tool for us with law enforcement.
You know, we were actively working
with law enforcement the entire campaign
and there would have been a KKK threat
against Stacey Abrams no matter what,
but we were able to use social media
to track those folks down
and make sure somebody was knocking on their doors.
So I don't sort of see it at all black and white.
I think it's really complicated
and we got to use the tools
and I'm all for being as aggressive as we possibly can
in terms of how we use those tools.
All right, Stacey.
The very quick addition I would make
is that there's an asymmetry to access of technology
and access to what technology provides.
And that asymmetry tends to disadvantage
the very people who are most in need of its capacity.
What I wish tech understood is it has the ability
to help even the playing field more aggressively.
I don't see it happening as often as it should,
and that's one of the challenges I have with boycotts.
Boycotts remove from the playing field access
for those who are most in need of it.
And whether that's resources or information
or simply knowledge that something is possible,
this asymmetry gets worse and worse over time
because those who've learned to take advantage
have ratcheted up their advantage
and those for whom it is a harm.
It's not a neutral, it is a harm.
When you've got three streams of information,
good information, bad information, and disinformation,
the asymmetry that happens
when no good information gets to you
and you're trying to discern the difference
between bad and disinformation,
that is a terrible choice to have to make.
And often the results,
people exempt themselves from the conversation.
That means they're exempting themselves from our democracy.
That is a danger, but it's also a solvable problem.
And I wish tech would be more engaged,
and I think they are.
There were tech companies who came to the table,
not just to help our campaign,
but to really help think about the infrastructure.
But as we move towards a more modern electoral system,
we have to be intentionally forward-thinking
in how do we address not simply what is possible,
but what is necessary to make possible real for everyone.
Okay, great.
Questions from the audience?
Oh, here, right here.
Go ahead.
Hi, my name is Connor Hammond.
I'm from Omidyar Network.
And as an ethnic studies major who went to work in tech,
I'm really happy you're here
and teaching all of us about this really important issue.
But my question is about regulation.
It's something we've been hearing a lot about today,
both from companies being skeptical of it,
both from companies inviting it
and wanting to work more closely with government.
As people who actually know
how the legislative process works,
where would you draw the line
in terms of what's government's responsibility
and what's company's responsibility
and employees' responsibility to get ahead
and set the right rules and policies
so that government doesn't have to come in
and clean up messes?
I mean, that's our job.
But I will say this.
I think we have to stop thinking
of regulatory schemes as punishment.
Regulatory schemes come in place
when an entity or a structure becomes too large
to effectively self-regulate
or when too many people need it
and their decision-making and determinations do not,
they don't have sufficient information
to make those choices.
There is nothing about the technology space
that hasn't had a precursor example of regulation.
We have regulated information.
It's called the FCC.
We've regulated the delivery of information.
We simply have to recognize
that I do believe now is time
that the maturity of the tech industry writ large
is such that it is now too large
to leave it to best intentions.
It is, and too many people intersect with it
for individuals to be making those choices.
And so I do believe it's a common cause.
If anyone believes that government makes decisions
without the information and the advice of the industry,
you've never been to D.C. or to a state capital.
And so it is a joint enterprise,
but I do believe that we have reached a place
where regulatory structures are necessary.
Which one?
Is it antitrust or is it just-
I think it's all of the above
because there's delivery, there's content,
there's the very power.
I mean, that's what I'm talking about, power.
The very power.
Now, I don't think we have reached the place
where we know enough to determine
the tipping point of antitrust,
in part because some of these things are so opaque
I don't want us to make decisions
where we're simply breaking it up.
The terrible analogy I used with Ezra was,
look, it's like trouble with triples.
You don't want it to proliferate
just because you're trying to solve one problem,
you create many more.
And so I think, and this isn't as simple
as breaking up the baby bells
or breaking up a railroad system.
We really do have intersectionalities
and interdependent technologies
that I think it's very naive to say
that you can simply say, now you shall disperse.
We're not ready for that.
I think the first step is regulation.
I do think we should have an eye towards antitrust.
And I do think there are some companies
that are reaching an inflection point
where antitrust conversations can happen faster.
But I want us to begin with regulatory.
Well, that was a complex and nuanced answer,
which is unusual for politicians.
Go ahead.
I appreciate it.
Teddy Schleifer here from Recode.
You met with Beto O'Rourke last week in Georgia.
A lot of candidates are sort of seeking
your stamp approval on voting rights issues.
Beto O'Rourke came out,
he says he wants to see the national voting percentage,
turnout percentage to be 65%, pretty high.
A, I'm curious if you think that's realistic.
And B, as an observer on the sidelines right now,
which of the 2020 candidates do you think
is kind of offered the most compelling platform
on voting rights?
Not gonna answer the second question?
How about you, Lauren?
You sure?
Lauren can answer it.
Lauren, do you have one?
I like many.
We're trying to make some news, so.
Here's the thing.
I am pleased that everyone I've met with
has not only made a commitment to this conversation,
but has done the work.
They've done the work in different ways.
And again, we are early in this campaign.
And so that's why I'm not gonna pick and choose.
I think we've seen a number of different ways
that this has been made manifest.
The first part of the question was.
Is 65% real?
Yes, 65%.
It is.
I mean, look, there are nation states that hit 70, 75%.
Part of it is the investment in the elections.
We do not invest in disadvantaged communities.
We do not invest in non-voters.
We have, I mean, there's a sense,
there's a myth of efficiency in the way we run elections,
where it's the most efficient thing
to go back to the people who voted before.
The problem is, if you're only going back
to the people who voted before,
you're leaving out a larger and larger group of people.
I believe that if we had campaigns
and we had a campaign infrastructure
that actually invested in and made real
and manifest the ability to vote,
the ability to be reached,
and held our politicians accountable
because they actually know we're going to show up,
yes, I do think we can hit 65.
I think that because I just ran a statewide election
in a midterm year where we hit 65%.
What do you think about the effort
to make voting day a holiday?
I think it makes sense.
I don't think it's a solution to every problem,
but it brings into sharp relief
one of the most critical issues.
It has to be a paid holiday.
It can't simply be a holiday
because for a lot of folks,
it's not a factor of whether or not they can get there,
it's can they afford to vote.
Hi, my name is Bert Blackrack,
and I had a story to share.
My grandfather was the first African-American judge,
civil judge in Canada,
and I grew up hearing a lot of the stories
and what it took to put forth his mission.
So I don't have a question,
but I just wanted to share my deep appreciation
and love for what you've done,
what you're doing,
and how you're educating all of us on the movement.
I know how much you put up with.
Thank you.
Thanks, Bert.
Thank you. Last question.
Thank you for being here today.
I was curious how Democrats and political parties
in general can win back the center
because it feels like we've become more polarized
in our politics over time,
and there's a real center
that's left out of the conversation.
You know, just thoughts on that generally.
I think that there is a false narrative
that the center has been abandoned.
What is often described as being too far to the left
tend to actually have fairly broad beliefs.
So most Americans want access to healthcare.
Most Americans want reproductive choice.
Most Americans think that if you go to work,
you should be paid for that,
and that the pay you receive
should actually cover the cost of living.
Those are not leftist ideas.
Those are centrist ideas
that happen to be espoused by a party
under a system where we bifurcate into left and right.
Now, what the right has done,
there has been a very different shift to the right,
but I do not believe the center has been abandoned.
One of the parts of our campaign
was that I had the same conversation
with middle-class white women,
poor white men in North Georgia,
poor black folks in South Georgia,
middle-class Latinos, everyone.
We had the exact same conversation.
I wasn't running a leftist campaign.
I was running a campaign
that talked about the issues and the values,
but we've been trained to see ourselves as polarized
based on our party identification,
and we spend less time thinking about the policies
that we're actually arguing over.
That is not to say that there aren't policies
that are being provided on the left
that are a bit more far left than we're used to,
but by and large, if you listen to most of the things
candidates are talking about, it's not far from the center.
In fact, it's exactly in the center.
The center is that most people want it,
and therefore our lives will be better if we have it,
and so I actually push back on that idea,
and that's not to say polarization doesn't exist,
but I don't think the polarization
is center versus left or right.
I think the polarization is mine versus yours,
and that's really become, I think,
the tension that we see,
but we argue it as though it's a centrist argument.
All right, last question.
What could the one thing tech could do,
this audience could do, each of you,
Lauren, Thurston, and Stace?
So I think folks in tech need to get behind
common sense voting rights reform.
We need tech leaders to talk about hand-marked paper ballots
and why that's so important in terms of election integrity,
and I think we need tech to put their money
where their mouth is in terms of voting rights
because no matter where you are on the political spectrum,
you all want a workforce that is educated
and can be a citizen,
and because it's not just Georgia.
Georgia, we just have the most egregious example
that's all over this country.
There has been an intentional campaign led by Republicans
to undermine democracy and support the right to vote,
so that means we can't just make a small contribution
to your favorite presidential campaign.
That means folks have gotta go all in, in my opinion,
because it's all at stake.
We're looking at an underfunded census.
We're looking at redistricting.
We're looking at a presidential shore,
but then a whole bunch of gubernatorials in 2022,
and as we look at the next decade
and the demography that's changing
and sort of where our politics is gonna go
and the unevenness of power and where people are moving,
none of this has ever been easy.
This is not a new fight.
This is just the new iteration of the fight of our country,
and so people gotta throw down, in my opinion.
They've gotta go big.
We've got foundations who are under attack
from the Trump administration.
We have nine subpoenas that were filed against us.
The other side is throwing everything they possibly have
to shut us down, to shut our friends down,
to shut down people who are trying to fight for democracy,
so this is not the time to cower in the corner at all,
but it's gonna take bold leaders.
It's gonna take people standing up to say,
I understand that talking about democracy
may seem like a partisan issue, but I'm gonna do it,
and there's actually a right side
and a wrong side on this right now,
and we have our tagline in Georgia right now,
which is stay and fight,
because sure, this is about abortion access,
but this is about healthcare.
This is about are we gonna demonize and criminalize doctors?
What are we gonna do about the future of democracy
in Georgia and across the country?
So we need people to partner with us
and institutions across this country
that are making that fight in a big way, not a small way.
Okay, Stacey?
I think she said almost all of the other piece I would add
is you all are going to be visited by candidates
not only running for president, but for Senate, for Congress.
Ask them these questions.
Ask them about voter suppression, about our democracy,
and what they plan to do.
You all have extraordinary power
to not only shape the technology,
but also shape the conversation,
and I want more people in your position
to understand the influence you can have
on all of the people who are making these decisions,
not simply the question of regulation
or antitrust and monopolies,
but really the conversation
of what kind of country do we have,
and if they know that you care
about the issues that weren't articulated,
that puts more pressure on them
to actually have the conversation and live it out
and make it real for all of us.
And I have one additional piece
that we're talking about on regulation
is that look at how your platform's being used
to support campaign finance laws,
and in terms of enforcement on that,
that is to the FEC and others,
but in our race, there were huge right-wing platforms
using Facebook and other means
to spread a message that was directly coordinated
with the Kemp campaign,
but they are not registered super PACs,
they are not registered with any entity,
and they get spun a whole bunch of different ways,
and it's likely millions of dollars' worth
of communications that are never reported.
And so ultimately, I think we've gotta lift that up
a whole bunch of different ways.
That's gonna be the big challenge, I think,
and a lot of it we didn't fully understand
until post-election in terms of the scope.
I think for campaign operatives,
what we have to understand is the playing field
is all voters, right?
And so we did more research.
We did an incredible amount of research,
checking in on the far right,
checking in on sort of all segments.
I'm glad we did that,
because we were tracking what was happening there,
but in terms of how people are using your platforms,
whether or not you realize
that to support campaign finance laws,
it's happening all the time.
Great.
Lauren Giroir-Wargo, Stacey Abrams,
thank you very much.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
