尼康好兄弟 尼康z8,索尼a7r5,佳能eos r5 三台野生動物相機對比評測

相機在握
76粉絲
38 次觀看·2026年1月13日
現在Nikon終於加入了鏡面無縫的世界
它們的Semi-Pro鏡頭
在價值4,000美元的價位範圍下
以及它們的標誌性鏡頭下
我們現在可以從Sony Nikon 和Canon
Sony A7R5
Nikon Z8
和Canon R5
這些鏡頭如何為野餐拍攝套用
它們如何在野餐中表現
我們來談談
鏡面無縫鏡頭
對我來說,這對我來說是一個新的範疇
我相信很多人都一樣
只是鏡面無縫鏡頭的加工
讓我能夠在野餐中
更有效地拍攝
並提高保留率
或者是更多地在鏡頭上
看清楚鏡面無縫鏡頭
而不是不斷地檢查
看看我是否正確
不僅是眼睛偵測
和手機偵測的能力
還帶來了
震撼的拍攝速度和拍攝速度
我們都知道
Sony 開始了鏡面無縫挑戰
它們已經在A7和A9的領域
最新的版本是Sony A7R5
有些人說
包括我
A9 II
是真正的標誌性
Canon和Nikon
因為它的拍攝速度
是6.2毫秒
然而A7R5的20MP鏡頭
在2019年10月發售
讓它落後了
自動焦點系統
和A7R5的61MP鏡頭
但A7R5
只拍攝7毫秒
自動焦點系統
拍攝速度是66毫秒
使自動焦點
非常不好
拍攝黑暗燈和EVF標誌性
所以對於這個評測
我不會讓很多人高興
我會把A7R5
淘汰在這個評測中
這個4,000美金的
中規模鏡頭
野生攝影
為什麼
這個人
在我看來
真的不是野生攝影
自動焦點
如果你有看我之前的影片
我不是很喜歡
自動焦點
和EVF標誌性
和黑暗燈
這些東西
對於我來說
太難了
所以
這不是野生攝影
在我看來
如果你要拍攝
一整天不移動
對
你可以使用
但是
我們在說
一個好的野生攝影
和半規模鏡頭
你不想買
自動焦點
你買A7R5
因為它有一個標誌性
但你買的是
標誌性
這鏡頭
不是最好
如果A93
真的會出現
我還沒聽到
很好的風聲
我還沒聽到
如果它真的出現
然後是30Mp更高的
然後我們
會重製這場攝影
然後
R5 Mark II
也會出現
但現在
Sony A7R5
所以抱歉
Sony的粉絲
這鏡頭
對我來說
是不合適
我們在
這就是我們要講的
我先放在這裡
這是一個不錯的相機
不要誤會
它有一個不錯的感應器
這也是A7R4的感應器
所以你用的是比較舊的感應器
這兩個相機有更新的感應器
尤其是Z8
抱歉,我剛纔是說Z9
因為它是Z9
但它是一個不錯的相機
但對我來說
它不是一個適合我們
在現在的時代
有些相機的價格
比Z9還便宜
無論如何
我們繼續
接下來是這兩個
好,我們來談談
Canon R5和Nikon Z9相機
然後我們會進行一些
實際的對比
首先是感應器
Canon R5
這個相機正在推出
7月2020
所以它已經3年了
但仍然持續
在規格和現實世界的表現上
我們在談的是現實世界的表現
最好的預測是
在下個春天我們可能會有成功
我們希望
相機支援45MP CMOS感應器
15.5ms的拍攝速度
讓拍攝效果非常順暢
有充足的空間
來種植和複製
任何超過35MP的東西
對我來說就是
Canon的Digic X Processor
也就是同樣的Flagship 1DX Mark III
即使它是DSLR
和半Flagship Canon R3
是的,這個相機的價格是Flagship
但實際上它並不是野生相機
除非你能拍攝20MP
但這對我來說並不是
接下來是Nikon Z8
它剛推出5月
它支援同樣的
CMOS感應器
45.7MP
這對我來說
是最快的
3.7ms
對我來說
這對我來說
是最快的
3.7ms
因爲這就是一個後攝像頭攝像頭的功能
它能夠讓你拍攝更高頻的ISO 更少的噪音
另一件我發現的事是Nikon的攝像頭
我看到的Catch Light和Rim Light的顏色是比這些顏色更溫暖
你必須記住這兩個攝像頭的一件事
就是Z8的Nikon攝像頭是Saturn的正確攝像頭
而Z9是Nikon的代表攝像頭
而Canon的R5攝像頭並不是代表攝像頭的代表攝像頭
並不是後攝像頭的代表攝像頭
而是一個真正的半導向攝像頭
如果你使用R3攝像頭
你會看到後攝像頭的代表攝像頭
它能夠達到R3攝像頭的畫質和ISO表現
儘管它是一個低頻的攝像頭
但這也幫助到ISO表現
這是兩個攝像頭的分別
這是代表攝像頭的攝像頭和處理器
這是代表攝像頭的處理器
但並不是代表攝像頭的攝像頭
這很合理
這很明顯地證明了
後攝像頭的代表攝像頭幫助到ISO表現
所以在紙上
畫質上我會選擇Z8
但顏色科學和顏色色彩
是更親近RTX的表現
但這兩者都非常非常好
我們會在這段視頻之後
來看看畫質和畫質的分別
我通常會把攝像頭和後攝像頭的攝像頭
和攝像頭的差異
選擇另一個攝像頭
來檢查攝像頭的材質
to capture up to 1 second of images before the shutter press
but only in JPEG shooting mode
ranging from 30 frames a second to 120 frames a second
so what that means is
hold the shutter down halfway
take your shot, it'll record
if you did 120 frames a second
it'll do 120 frames in JPEG
if you do 30, it'll do 30
if you do 60, it'll do 60
it's 1 second, remember what frame rate you're at
so that's what the pre-capture is on this guy
this doesn't have it
they do have it on the other cameras that came after this
but the R5 does not have the pre-capture
functionality in it
you can set the amount of sound on the shutter
from completely silent to fairly audible on the Nikon Z8
now the shutter differences as far as how far they'll go
the Canon will do up to 1.8 thousandth of a second
on the shutter
and Nikon will do a whopping
32 thousandths of a second on a shutter
those hummingbirds don't stand a chance with that shutter speed
in full raw, both cameras shoot at 20 frames per second
which is the format most semi-pro photographers are shooting
so ignoring rolling shutter differences
they're neck and neck
unless you need to shoot past 1.8 thousandth of a second
or required audible shutter sound
and on the Canon R5 when I owned it in the past
I never shot 20 frames a second
unless I just really needed it
because I really needed that audible sound
so I always shot in the first curtain electronic
to get that audible sound
and I was only shooting 12 frames a second
so in that scenario, for me, as my shooting was
I would probably give it to the Z8
because I can shoot 20 frames a second and hear it also
and if I do need to go past 8 thousandths, I can
I usually don't, but
but in this little small thing
I would give it to the Z8 in that
Now we'll talk about buffers
when shooting full raw
which is compressed raw on this one
lossless raw on this one
at 20 frames per second
and using the fastest CFexpress Type B card
both cameras will get about 100 and 110 images
before they hit the buffer wall
and at that wall
is where these two cameras start to differ
for the Canon R5
it'll basically go into a limp mode
and it'll, after it hits that 100 or so frames
when it drops down
it'll get about 5 to 8 frames per second
the Z8 will continue to shoot past that wall
so once it shoots 20 frames a second
it gets about the 100, 10, 115
after that, it will go into reduced mode
or limp mode
but that limp mode is 15 to 16 frames per second
almost until you fill the card up
so what that means
you can do those extremely long bursts
with the Z8
of those long swan takeoffs
or any other long encounters you find
so to me, in this scenario
the Z8's gonna win again
if you need more than 110 shots, that is
now on the electronic viewfinders of both cameras
the Canon sports a 5.7 million dot EVF
which is very, very nice
it's very bright and very vivid
there's no blackout in shooting
rather, it flickers at the edges
but it's not very noticeable to me
actually, your eye will go away from it
now on to the LCD
on paper, the LCDs of both cameras
are pretty much the same
they both sport a 3.2 inch screen
with 2.1 million dots
both support a touchscreen
are very responsive and vivid
and work well in direct sunlight
the big difference is the articulating screens
the Canons will swivel and flip forward
for viewing to the monitor and down the lens
the Nikon has a hinge display
but does not flip around
so who wins?
well, for wildlife
it's not a huge deal either way
the Nikon allows for low and high shooting
for the monitor to still be in line with the lens
as the Canons will be off to the side
it's more of a plus for landscape guys
and the flip around is really more helpful
if you're filming yourself
and we really don't do selfies
with Kodiak Bear behind us
so to me, it's not a big deal breaker
so the articulation difference between the two
is a wash to me
OK, on to the ergonomics
both feel great in the hand
the Nikon Z8 is just a touch heavier
than the R5, but not by much
the button placements
are in completely different places
everything is backwards
even how you put the lenses on
one's clockwise, one's counterclockwise
but both cameras are very customizable
in the buttons and made for your shooting needs
I'd say both cameras need the battery grip
and this is an area where Canon wins to me
is the battery grip that comes on the Canon
feels better than the Nikon's to me
but it's really a personal choice
and why is that different to me?
Well, the Canon's is more smooth
and feels like, you know, the full
integrated grip bodies
and the Nikon's has more of a cut-out bump on it
so it's just a little more comfortable there
but feel is a personal choice
so I really can't give it a win to either one
and they both feel really good
Now, on to the menu systems
Well, Canon's to me is a lot easier to use
but the Nikon has more fine-tuned abilities
Again, really, that's a personal choice
so what's better for you?
Because even if you talk about the Sony
it's kind of in between the two
and people gripe about the Sony's menus
but be honest, I actually found my way
around the Sony, OK?
I didn't really have a huge problem
It just was different
So I think, again, just like I talked about
with the autofocus, which we'll talk about
in a bit later, on both these cameras
it's a matter of putting time behind the camera
and yes, I did put time behind the Sony
as far as the autofocus system
and I talked to a lot of my Sony shooter friends
about this A7R5
The A1 does act different
We'll review that another day
All right, on to the battery
This is kind of a weird one here
The Canon R5 body sports a 2130 mAh
which is lower than the Nikon's 2280 mAh
On paper, it seems the battery life
should be better than the Z8
but in use, the R5 battery
lasts a little bit longer
It seems that the voltage energy pull
out of the Z8 is much larger than the R5
and I can switch batteries
in the middle, towards the end of the day
with the R5
and still have a lot of battery left over
on a good full-day shoot
On the Z8, when I swap the battery out
I'll still run out by the end of the day
on a busy shoot day
So there is that
So I would say for the battery
The R5 wins out as far as that goes
But again, just have three batteries
to this guy and it's a wash
All right, on to autofocus
We'll talk about how it actually performs
when we get out in the field
and use it here in a bit
But for now, we're just going to talk briefly
about the functionality of the setups
Both cameras have subject detection
of animals, people and vehicles
And of course, what we care about
is really just animals
Both have eye detection
and the Nikon has 3D tracking
that Canon doesn't have
which just means if you can get
the autofocus point on the subject
and activate the 3D tracking
It'll find the body
and the head of the eye
and it'll just lock on to it
Both cameras allow
setting autofocus areas
so it'll also help lock the eye
if it's inside the focus area
With the Nikon, it's pretty essential
that you use that right type
of autofocus area
with the correct type environment
to locate your bird or animal
Canon's a lot more forgiving
that you just use the eye autofocus
and it'll search the entire scene
within the viewfinder
and find the animal
Again, we'll talk more about this
once we get to the field
and use it a bit more there
So on paper, that's how
the two cameras stack up
So let's head out to the field
and talk about how they actually perform
in the real world
and then we'll draw our conclusions
The R5 was paired up
with the Canon EF 500 F4 Mark II
It's an adapted lens
but doesn't act adapted
as it's one of the Canon's big whites
The Z8 I had paired
with the Nikon Z 400 4.5 lens
This is a very well-performing lens
and native to the mount for the Z8
For me, this gives both cameras
their best chance of achieving
the autofocus potential
and image quality
Of course, the Z8 combo here
is lighter in weight
but 100mm shorter in focal length
as well as depth of field
So keep that in mind
when we get to the images later on
So a bit of information
about filming these shorebirds
I only recorded the EVF
on the Nikon Z8 with the Atomos
and why is that?
Well, this is actually a plus
for the Z8 versus the R5
So when you hook an external recorder
up to a Nikon camera
especially the new mirrorless cameras
you can still see the EVF
If you hook it up on the Canon R5
you can no longer see
the LCD of the EVF
You can only see it
through the monitor of the EVF monitor
Or sorry, the Atomos monitor
What does that mean?
Well, to get the best tracking
to test the autofocus
to get the best images
I really need to look
to the viewfinder of both cameras
Because trying to track
a bird in flight
or something moving fast
with doing this
is just impossible
But to be able to hold it up
to your eye and track it
You can do it all day long
So that's why you only see
EVF footage out of the Nikon
But I've got other EVF footage
I can show you out of the R5
That I've recorded before
And you've probably seen it before
But now you get to see this one
See what it looks like
So just a little bit of note
About filming that
If you don't see EVF footage
From the Canon R5
So I'm heading out on the field
To try to compare these two cameras
I carry both cameras out in the field
And as I said earlier
I got lucky and ran across
These yellow legs
Now the light was OK
It was kind of a high sun
Partly cloudy afternoon
And we were down amongst the trees
So I was getting a lot of
Modeled light too
So it wasn't the easiest shoot to do
But luckily the birds got enough
In the light for sometimes
To get some decent shots of them
So I started out with the R5
Get out of here Z8
And I had the camera
In full electronic shutter
That way I could reach
The 20 frames per second
The only downside is
There's no shutter sound
In full electronic
But I felt this would also let us know
At the max frames per second
How the rolling shutter performed
With this sensor on this camera
And from reviewing the images
Even on a pan shot
It's really not that bad
The autofocus setup
That I had on the R5
Was either the eye autofocus
Or the single point
To push through the busy spots
To regain focus
To help the autofocus system succeed
And you can find out more about that
I've got plenty of videos
On how to set this camera up
And all the other Canon cameras
And the Canon locked up the bird's eye
Almost every time or the body
It didn't seem to care much
About the busy backgrounds
When they were really close to the bird
And I didn't need the single point
Too much to correct
Or push through to a spot
Much at all
I'd catch the bird perch
To work my angles
To get different backgrounds
Until the bird I was concentrating on
Would finally fly to a new perch
This was a very tricky spot
To catch these birds in flight
It was an extremely tight area
And they would just zip by you real fast
You didn't have much time
To even spin on them
I did manage a few times
Where I could swing the lens around
On one in mid-flight
And once in frame
I was able to lock it up really quick
And get a couple frames of shots
The hit rate of the images
Was pretty good on the R5
After reviewing the images
We'll look more about
Image quality difference in a bit
After we talk more about
How the Z8 performed
Overall the Canon R5
Performed very well
As far as locking up the birds
Snapping quickly to the bird
And getting the exposure
I wanted to inside the EVF
And the rig felt very good
In the hand and the setup I used
Which I have videos on that
You can watch
And I'll link that in the description
It helped me keep my eye
On the viewfinder
And not looking around
For buttons and dials
To get the settings right
But that no shutter sound
When hitting that shutter
Doesn't feel right
And I also wasn't sure
How many shots I was getting
On each shutter pull
After a bit
I switched to the Nikon Z8
And the 404.5 lens
This setup feels really good
The lens is really light
And this rig was easier
To lug around for extended periods
Had the autofocus set to wide L
As I was in a busy tight environment
And a second single point button
Set up along with
The 3D tracking buttons
This gives me three modes
In my fingertips
For the different modes
I need in this tight environment
With these birds
The wide L to get the focus plane
And lock the eye detection up
3D to set the focus plane
3D to lock up the bird
If I get the focus point
Right up on top of the bird
Or hand off in the wide L
And lastly a single point
For the same reason
With Canon R5
To push through to focus
The spot to help out
With the subject detection modes
For the most part
The wide L would lock up the bird
There were times that the autofocus
Would hit the background
Right in the birds
And this is due to the focus plane
Being too far away
Or too close to me
From the bird
In this case
The thing to do
And this is true for the Canon also
Is to point the camera
Towards the ground
Or something close to the bird
And use a single point
To move the focus plane
Closer to the bird
And then go right back to the bird
To get the subject to detect
Or the wide L
Or the 3D
To lock it up
Now with the R5
I didn't have to do this
Very much at all
But on the Z8
I had to do it more often
Than I wanted to
Now this is a trick
You need to learn real fast
To get yourself back in the game
And give the autofocus
As best chance of success
As far as catching these guys in flight
Pretty hard with the Z8
In this tight environment
A couple times
I grabbed a brief focus
But not long enough to get the shot
Now this is a super tight area also
And the flight was maybe
Less than two seconds
And a circle around it
So to get a lock up
You had to get the camera
Around the bird
Then try to circle with it
Extremely, extremely
Difficult and hard
I did manage to get
A couple times with the R5
But not really with the Z8
This is the one area
The Canon autofocus
Performed much better
Than the Nikon
On these yellow legs
Again, a very tough test
But once the Nikon Z8
Locked up the bird
It stayed locked up
Just the flight stuff
Was a little bit off
And I wasn't able to get a lock
Now a quick word about
Birds in flight here real quick
In case you're thinking
That the Canon wins
On birds in flight
In this flight
In the close background scenarios
It did win
In an open sky
Or less busy backgrounds
They're very, very close in performance
The Canon edges out the scenario
On small birds at distance though
When we were in Kodiak
With the kingfishers
With the bird
Flying a perpendicular flight path
Low across the water
Gets a semi-busy background
The Nikon locked up
The plane of focus
The bird was on
Quicker than the Canon
Could lock up the bird itself
And that was even with
The more advanced R7 autofocus
Than the Canon R5 had
So in this scenario
The Nikon's autofocus won out
As far as the setup
And use of the camera
On the Z8 in the field
Same as the Canon
I was able to stay inside the EVF
And get my settings just right
For what I was shooting
And the backside illuminated sensor
Really helped out
Being able to shoot a lower ISO
In the same light as the R5
And having that shutter sound
While shooting stills
At 20 frames a second
Really helped out the field
Over the R5
I really didn't know
How many frames I was getting
Out of the R5
And hit rate in a minute
But first
Which camera I enjoyed using more
That day
Photographing those yellow legs
And a couple robins
That popped in for a bit
It was probably not
Going to like this answer
I really like them both
The Canon was more enjoyable
On just knowing
I could get focus fast and easy
And if I had more time on bird
Than with the Nikon
There's times
I have to use a single point
In the Nikon
To acquire the bird
Or some close to the bird
Then retire fot the bird
重新聚焦和重新啟動廣角鏡頭或3D追蹤
我唯一一次用R5做這個工作
是當一隻鳥躲在一棵鳥樹的高處
有很多的葉子
但Nikon對我來說是更有趣的
在EVF的曝光和光源方面
那些後面的光源感測器和EVF的顏色調
讓我更容易調整場景
如果我要選擇哪個比較好
我會選擇說
Canon R5的A鏡
我會選擇Z8
因為我想要拍到這張照片
這意味著
要長一點的頭髮
可以把這隻鳥躲在Z8的高處
但更快地調整到Z8的高度
我覺得這就是這兩部相機的差別
在於它們在幾個場景中的表現
我用了Canon R5超過兩年
我用了Z9和Z8超過一年
這兩部相機基本上都是相同的
除了重量
是在70%的場景中
Canon會把最快的鳥躲在最高的位置
尤其是在遠距離的場景
但在Nikon的幾個場景中
我會把這部相機的焦點調整得更快
而在剩下的10%-15%的場景中
兩部相機都會出現問題
而為了測試它的曝光
Nikon相機對我來說是更容易的
而那些噪音
不存在於全智能的R5相機
是一個頭痛
兩部相機通常都會封鎖Birds in Flight
但Canon相機通常都會被封鎖Birds in Flight
而在一些不正常的動物
就像這隻狗狗
Canon R5會在遠距離的場景中
找到牠們的頭和眼睛
而Nikon仍然有一點點的困擾
就像這隻狗狗
但對於雌性動物
牠們都很擅長尋找
但對於一些不正常的動物
Canon就花了更多的時間
把某些東西放進這個系統
來看看牠們的狀況
但兩部相機都做得非常好
我們只是非常沉迷於
自動焦點的問題
而我們期望做到的事情
就是在每個環境都能成功
但在這個測試
使用黃色的腳架
R5的焦點調整得更好
在這個緊繃的忙碌環境下
好的
我們來看看
色彩和焦點的畫質
我們看到的是什麼
畫質方面
兩部相機都做得非常好
但我注意到的一點是
對比線條
Canon的焦點
比Nikon的焦點
而在過去幾年
我拍攝Canon R5
在過去一年
我拍攝Z8和Z9
我必須說
我拍攝Z8和Z9的畫質
比我拍攝R5的畫質
後期的編輯過程中
所以我比較常在鏡頭拍攝
這可能是個人的事情
好的
拍攝速度
在這個測試
當飛行時沒有焦點
記得拍攝速度
是當你把劍放在焦點上
是非常非常接近的
我有一些R5的鏡頭
我可以看到一些伸縮
和焦點
但沒有什麼非常注意到的
如果你沒有相似的畫質
來對比
至於焦點失焦
同樣的
雙鏡頭的焦點
但只有幾個
它轉移到身體
轉移到眼睛
或轉移到焦點
兩部相機的焦點
但我拍攝了更多
YELLOW EGG和CANON R5
和Z8的畫質
因為CANON R5
會在飛行時
飛得更快
飛行時
我可以更快地拍攝
R5和Z8的畫質
因為我可以更快地拍攝
所以我拍攝了更多的畫質
在R5和Z8的Burst中
如果飛行時
CANON會擊殺Z8
在這個情況下
但正如我之前提到的
有些時候
Z8會超越CANON
自動焦點
在飛行時
好
現在
關於這兩部相機的歷史
R5和Z8
我使用了這兩部相機的歷史
我的結論
也就是
這兩部相機
同時使用同樣的焦點
這兩部YELLOW EGG
誰是贏家
對我來說
是Z8
記住
這對我來說
對
自動焦點更好
你能夠拍攝焦點
更快更靈敏
和CANON R5
這很大
但是
更快的自動焦點速度
和Z8的畫質輸出
讓自動焦點的
稍微慢化
在某些情況下
是值得生活的優勢
但這很明顯
CANON R5
有點長
而它的M2版本
我們相信
就在角落附近
而看到Z8
擁有Z9自動焦點
的旗艦鏡頭
處理器
自動焦點系統
而R5
擁有CANON的中等級
和沒有背面限定規格感光元件
R5
非常穩定
從最新的相機
到最佳的製造
最佳的元件
都會讓其他人
三歲的元件
和技術
這證明瞭
R5的優勢
仍然維持
這麼接近
最佳最佳
Nikon正在推出
而對於SONY
過來小夥子
我其實很期待
A9 Mark III
會推出
特別是30MP
但今天
如果我要選擇
Z8
和R5
如果鏡頭不符合規則
Z8會是我的選擇
你可以使用
CANON EF鏡頭
和Nikon Z鏡頭
配合搭載
Fringer搭載
所以這裡還有一個好處
我們有很多鏡頭選擇
選擇Z8
實際上
你無法錯過
任何鏡頭
尤其是Z8和R5
以今天為例
R5
可以購買
大約3300美金
而Z8
仍然可以購買4000美金
如果可以買得到
以金錢來說
R5
仍然是很好的
希望大家喜歡
是的,我知道
所有人
CAMPER TRIBE
SONY
NIKON
CANON
但是不要這樣
所有的廠商
都在推出
很棒的鏡頭
包括
FUJI
OLYMPUS
LUMIX
和所有其他品牌
現在
任何對比
只要挑選一些東西
就開始獲得
你自己
最喜歡的鏡頭
在你手上
哪個鏡頭
最適合你
最後
我給你一些建議
選擇哪個鏡頭
先看看鏡頭
哪個品牌
有你最感興趣的鏡頭
或許
你會投資在哪個品牌
然後
在身體上決定
鏡頭會陪伴你
一段很長的時間
例如
這是我的500mm F4 Mark II
EF鏡頭
它只有14歲
但它依然很棒
如果你已經投資
在品牌的鏡頭
你會很好
因為
大家現在
都擁有很棒的鏡頭
無論如何
感謝收看
做一些
好YouTube的事情
例如
訂閱
分享
留言
請
考慮
成為這個頻道的一位成員
幫助我們
提供週期內的內容
和
如往常
下次
你們出去
開啟閉幕
