鏡頭評測 庫克s4 vs sp3 | 電影鏡頭評測(索尼a7s3)

相機在握
76粉絲
9 次觀看·2025年12月11日
What's up Film Jammers
Today we're comparing the iconic
Cook S4 cinema lenses
to the brand new Cook SP3 lenses
And you might be asking yourself
Film Jams, why are you comparing a
Super 35mm lens like the Cook S4
to a lens that covers full-frame sensors
like the Cook SP3
Well, the answer is
We are a little crazy
And remember, Cook S4 cinema lenses
from 75mm and up
cover a full-frame sensor
Mmm
We shot our comparison on the Sony A7S III
in full-frame mode
Now, on the 32mm S4 lenses
You will see some vignetting
But on the 75mm
The lenses are pretty close
After our side-by-side lens comparison
We're going to give our thoughts
On the new Cook SP3 cinema lenses
Enjoy
To see these iconic lenses
Compared side-by-side
The biggest differences to me
Were the flaring, the bokeh and the size
And we'll talk a little bit more
About those in a minute
Now, I actually preferred
The more round bokeh
On the Cook SP3 lenses
But if you're a die-hard
Octa-bokeh type person
The Cook S4s definitely have
A nice large bokeh
As they do open up a bit wider
We shot both lenses wide open
So the Cook S4s are at T2.0
While the Cook SP3s are at T2.4
It doesn't sound like that much of a difference
But the little extra on the Cook S4
Did make the subject pop a little bit more
Especially on the 32mm lens
The color to me on these lenses
Looks really similar
And I was very happy about that
Because if I'm ever in a situation
Where maybe I want to shoot on both
S4s and SP3s
I think they're close enough
And especially in situations
Where maybe you don't care about
The different shaped bokeh
Maybe you're not seeing the bokeh as much
Cut them together
Cut them up like pumpkin pie
And pumpkin cheesecake pie
Super similar
The flares I thought were nice
On both of these lenses
But honestly to me
I prefer the SP3 flares
They're a little bit more stylized
And I like that
But if you want something more natural
I think the Cook S4s are the way to go
And I'd also say that
The S4s are a bit more resistant to flares
Now it's common for people to actually want flaring
And I think that the Cook SP3s
Are embracing that
And they're designed to match more
With the Cook Pancros
But the Cook S4s offer a cleaner look
It's giraffes or rhinoceros
It's fried chicken or chicken fried rice
Ariana Grande or Taylor Jenkins
Swift
That's her middle name
Which one you want
The price difference between these lenses
Is pretty substantial
The Cook SP3s are $4,500 per lens
While the Cook S4s are around $18,000 per lens
That means you could buy
Four of the Cook SP3 lenses
For the price of one Cook S4
That's like buying a Fender Stratocaster
With one string
Or a fully loaded
Ukulele ready to jam
When I film my documentaries
You know I like to use my Cook SP3
That puts the Cook SP3s
Into the market of many owner ops
I know what's going on my Christmas list
Mom
The size of the Cook SP3 lenses
Is actually one of my favorite things about them
They're almost tiny compared to the Cook S4s
Which makes them ideal for gimbal work
Also great for single operator work
I was able to pull my focus a lot easier
On the Cook SP3 lenses
And I don't know about you
But my back could certainly use a break
From operating with large cinema lenses
Thank you Cook from me
And my chiropractor
Dr. Jenkins
The Cook S4s only come in PL mount
But the Cook SP3s do not come in PL mount
But you can get them in a variety of other mounts
Like the included RF and E mounts
Or you can also buy a Leica L or M mount
Having the ability to swap the mounts
Makes the SP3s pretty versatile
And if you had to
You could always use a PL mount adapter
Like a RF to PL or a E to PL
Or a P to PL
That's not a real thing
But if you want that solid native PL mount
The Cook S4s are the way to go
All right now let's check out some B-roll
Of the Cook SP3s
Now if you want to see some more B-roll
Some more cinematic footage
Of the Cook SP3s
Make sure to check out our last video
Link up here
Overall I'm excited that Cook is offering
New, smaller, more affordable cinema lenses
Now they do have the Cook Mini S4s
But I never really loved those
They were still really large
And they were a lot slower at T2.8
And twice the price of the Cook SP3s
At about 8,000 a lens
The Cook SP3s performed exceptionally well
In my opinion compared to the Cook S4s
Especially for their price
They even had things that I liked
Better than the Cook S4s
Like I like the flares
And the bokeh better on the Cook SP3s
And obviously the smaller size
Is really nice to have as an owner operator
The Cook SP3s are really a new type of cinema lens
And I can't wait to see what other manufacturers do
In response to the Cook SP3s
Hey DZO what you gonna do
Leica what you gonna do
Where's the beef
What you bring to the table
My stomach's growling
I'm thinking about beef
I think they're going to be very popular
And I'm really looking forward to filming
On the SP3s more
I'm Christian with Film Jams
And we'll see you next week
Charlie
What
You got that spaghetti
I ate it all
You're recording
I think it's upside down
It's Puddle of Mud or Creed
Which one you want
Probably neither
I'm just a man with a man with another man
Looking at a man saying hey man
