索尼相機鏡頭評測 如果通過分析10萬張照片來確定最喜愛的鏡頭

Good morning, welcome to this special video Have you ever wondered which lenses will give you the best results and with which ones you will shoot the most? In this video, you will discover an analysis that I have made over the past 100,000 photos, past 6 years of all the lenses I've used, how I've shot with them and which one delivered consistently the best results This will be very interesting so make sure you watch until the end because that conclusion may help you find the next best lens for you or at least save you some money in not getting the wrong lens So if you're ready, let's get started Welcome to a new episode All right, 100,000 plus photos, 6 years of work And I went in and deep dive into all the stats about my lenses How many shots I've taken How many are portfolio worthy 3 stars, 4 stars, 5 stars And in this video, I'm going to share with you all those results so you can make informed decisions if you need to choose a new lens if you need to sell an old lens and when you have to choose on the field which lens to use So we're going to drop this deconstruct this in 4 parts The first one is going to be how I analyze the data The second one is going to be the results in terms of volume of photos taken how many with each photos how many I kept, etc. And number 3 is going to be the ratios per lens the performance per lenses that I've used And number 4, I'm going to be drawing some conclusions that can help you in your own photography So if you're curious, let's get started First of all, how did I actually find out all about that data Did I go back manually and check every exit? No Thankfully, I'm using Lightroom Classic And in Lightroom Classic, you can just go to your library and open the library filter and then turn on the metadata And you can choose if you want lens, camera and a bunch of other cool metadata that you can use to actually filter your photos So let's say I want to know how many photos I've taken with the 16-35 I can see that number right here And then with the GM2, I see that number right here That's for my one working catalog from 2019 until 2024 For the period of 2017 to 2018 I have a separate catalog which made me use another tool I'm going to share with you in a second that is also extremely helpful for finding any kind of photos anywhere But let's look at those datas Then I went in and selected 3 photos 3 stars, 4 stars and 5 stars to get exactly the data I compiled that into a spreadsheet I'm going to show you the result in a second And I did that for all my lenses So we have 16-35, 70-100, 24-70, 20mm, 50mm, 24mm and 14mm f1.8 So we have a mix of zoom and prime lenses And in order to go and search in my other catalogs also that are indexed I used a little tool called PictoSearch Really cool software that's like a plugin And it literally indexes all your catalogs And then you can search Let's say if you're looking for flowers in all your photos You can type flower And it's going to pull up all the photos of flowers that you have in your catalogs And you just click on one And it will take you right there And you end up at the photo in your Lightroom library Extremely, extremely helpful If you've ever looked for photos everywhere Very helpful Now, it also shows you stats Meaning like when are those photos of dogs taken Wow, so between 2017 and 2024 I can see like when I took photos of dogs On consistent basis and stuff Well, that's cool, that's interesting But what I'm more interested here is And actually you can find similar images I'll drop a link in the description If you're interested in that software It's really good, nothing sponsored here It's just something I've been using for a year And I love it Especially when I have to find photos That I don't know where they are So now I can have criteria So 3 stars, 4 stars But I can also put like lens models So 16-35 And it's going to show me All the photos taken with the Canon 16-35 As you can see, I never shoot with a Canon Or barely ever And now 16-35 GM1 And 16-35 GM2 There we go And now we have all those photos that show up So the gray bar is All the photos taken And the blue bar is All the photos taken that match those criterias So as you can see I've used extensively this 16-35 over the years, right And then you can also put 3 stars And see how many 3 star photos or 2 star photos I've taken with the 16-35 GM Okay, so that's interesting I used all that data And compiled it into my spreadsheet So you can see the lens name here If it's a zoom or prime lens Then the number of photos taken And the number that are 3 stars, 4 stars, 5 stars And then a ratio of 3 plus stars, 4 plus stars, etc. I then went and took the table Dropped it in ChatGPT And asked it to create charts for me Because I actually think it does it better than me Here are the results Part 2, results and number of photos taken We have 25,416 photos taken with that 16-35 And I combined 16-35 GM-1 and GM-2 Because I want to know that lens range Meaning 16-35, 24-70, 70-200 And same for the 70-200 I have the GM-1 and GM-2 in that data So 25,400 photos over 6 years Because I've had those 2 lenses over 6 years Then I have the 16-30, 70-200, 1 and 2 That also covered on the 6 years And we can see that I only took half the photos I took with the 16-35 In that period of time So way less photos You can see half of it And now 24mm that I had I think for the first time in 2019 So we can just look at it And we'll very quickly see So that 24mm I got it in January Or just before January 2019 And as you can see I've used it extensively since For a period of time until 2021 And way less after 24-70, I only got that lens later in life So less photos taken 85mm It's a lens I've had for many years But not that many photos taken 50mm, 1.2 I've taken a bunch of photos Over a short period of time I would say 20mm and then 35mm And my least used is the 14mm f1.8 Now obviously that's over 6 years And some of them I've had them for only 2 years Like the 24-70 But I still have more photos with the 24-70 Over 2 years then I have with the 14mm That I have since 2021 So as you can see It really varies in usage Now let's move on to part 3 Because the part 3 is Testing the performance of those lenses Which one are 3 plus stars What is the ratio for each lens of Basically how many photos I have kept And how many were actually Photos that I really love Just as a reference 3 stars for me is I love it 2 stars I keep 4 stars is Oh my god And 5 stars is like Wow, I gotta print this This is my portfolio Let's look into the lens performance Oh, by the way If you don't know me My name is Pierre Tenambert I'm a travel adventure photographer And the creator of 30-day adventure to create photo A step-by-step method For training your eyes To see like a photographer Shoot like a photographer And take photos you love No matter what kind of gear you're using There's a link in the description If you want to learn more But I also share photography adventures On this YouTube channel So you can actually go back in time And watch adventures of me Shooting on the field with some of these lenses So subscribe if you want to also learn more And let's get started Lens performance 14mm ends up with 15% of success In terms of getting 3 plus stars photos Which is insane You'll see there may be a reason behind that 15mm we're at 10% Close to 10% for 20mm Then we drop at 7.7% for 24mm So now we're in the zoom category 35mm 7% 7% for 85mm 7200 6.7% 16-35 5.8% And 24mm f1.4 I don't know why 5.2% Which is kind of surprising Now it kind of inverts On some of those lenses When we look at the 4 plus stars photos So that 14mm is still consistently the highest So 24% Which is really high 7200 is around 9% Now versus 7200 That's 6% for 3 stars So it seems like I'm taking a higher It's more consistent for 4 plus stars with 7200 Now the 16-35 drops to 4% Okay, so clearly that lens has something Is it the lens? Is it how you use it? We'll talk about that in a second Then we have 10% 20 10% or 9% 35mm 9% 50mm So those results are fairly consistent That 24 f1.4 is consistently low Which is surprising Because it's a lens I absolutely love And that 85mm is kind of low too Maybe explained because I use that lens a lot In street photography at night And I don't always pick up portfolio photos for that I'll reveal why that 14mm is so high in a second But now let's look at prime versus zoom lenses Okay, usage and performance So zoom I have 45, 43,000 photos taken with it Okay, prime We're at a shy 20,000 photos So that means I'm shooting twice as much With a zoom lens than with a prime And what's interesting is the ratio of 3 plus stars Is extremely high at 9% on average for primes Versus a low 6.5% for the zooms, right? And last but not least The primes here for 4 plus Are actually closer to the zoom for 4 plus stars Which is interesting It also shows my criteria for 4 plus star photos Is very tight So the question now is like How do these kind of compare And what can I draw upon The first thing I want to mention is that 14mm Why is that ratio so high? Why do I take so many 3 star photos? Why are we at 15%? Let's look at some of the photos at 14mm Okay And you'll very quickly understand why So if you've never seen photos at 14mm It's a specific look It is extremely wide And you can't use it just for anything That means that when I use it I am very, very intentional When I decide to go for that lens I think about it many, many, many times And I actually will have the lens sometimes And not use it in my bag, you know But when I do use it I know exactly what I'm looking for And I know exactly how I'm going to shoot And why And a lot of those photos are taken Usually at 14mm are night shots And night shots for me are shots that easily get 4 stars, 3 stars Same for Northern Lights Those shots are taken at 14mm Are easy to get 4, 5 stars Because I absolutely love them, you know And then I have a few conceptual shots That I did also But the first conclusion really Is that with the 14mm When I go in I am extremely intentional Shooting with a prime lens That is not very standard Like 14mm Will force you to have creative choices Very intentional And that yields clearly better results Because I end up with a Drastically more photos that I love In that category, okay Interesting, right? Now, when it comes to that 16-35mm Why is it so low, that ratio? Well, the 16-35mm is a lens That I've used so much And we can see it In the graph that we looked at earlier So that 16-35mm Was literally the lenses I would use the most On trips Every time I have to run and gun I walk around I'm not sure what I'm going to shoot I grab my 16-35mm That changed the day I started shooting With the 24-70mm actually I got the 24-70mm in July 2022 About there And this is a lens I clearly have been Using a lot during trips As you can see when you have the high peaks Those are like photo trips And most of the photos Are taken with the 24-70mm This is a lens I will walk around All day long with And take a little bit of everything And nothing sometimes And you can see it's very wide ranging It could range from an event To landscape photos To portrait photos To kind of everything in between I used it a lot in Nepal for example Lots of photos that I absolutely loved with it It's a very versatile lens, right? Now the thing is It has a lower Shoot to keep photo rate, right? And that is understandable Because I can shoot everything and nothing Now if you look at the 70-100mm Actually the 70-100mm Performs very similar to a prime lens Why is that? That 70-200mm when you're going to use it You will be very intentional with it Why? Because you cannot very narrow, right? And 70-200mm is not for every day It may be when I did some safari I took photos with that 70-200mm I will use it intentionally for street photos For portraits And it's very interesting to see How my usage of lenses that don't have That are kind of tight or difficult to work with Because they're ultra wide Will impact my keeping ratio Now three lenses that are fairly interesting To look at are 50mm and 20mm I find that I'm getting good results with those two And I'm not surprised that 50mm f1.2 I absolutely love And that 20mm f1.8 Kind of replaced my 24mm In a lot of circumstances You see this was taken with a 50mm f1.2 For example We have a lot of really cool photos That are a little vibey And I think maybe that 50mm tight and focal length I actually pretty much like it But we look at it I actually don't really save 5-star photos For that 50mm Which is also another interesting point But that 20mm is going to have 5-star photos And a better ratio Even than that 50mm For 4-star photos Which actually surprised me Because I thought that 24mm Would perform better than that 20 But no, I've taken lots of photos I love With that little prime lens It is small, it is mighty You just put it in your bag You forget about it And you can take lots of great photos with it And I absolutely loved using it Even for portraits Ultra wide portraits like these Oh my god, I absolutely love So what's extremely important for you To realize here Is that if you choosing a new lens If you choosing a lens even to use in your bag You will have to make a choice Between versatility And kind of creative restriction But instead of thinking about it as a restriction See it as something that may improve The quality of your photos At least if you have similar data as to me You may be working more intentionally And that's something a lot of photographer talk about A lot of pro photographer will tell you With the prime lens you shoot differently And it looks like the data Is showing the exact same thing So it's not just an intuition It is actually something that I quantified And made sure I have So I invite you to do that analysis for yourself Because it may be different But if you're trying to buy a new lens Maybe go for a prime lens Especially if you already have zooms And you find that you're not really happy With your photos Work with that prime lens It will work you differently And it also begs the question of Is it because that zooms are more versatile That you will be using them in more difficult conditions And more random conditions That will make you take better photos Or if you shot only with a prime lens Would you have similar results That is a question I'm still asking myself And I'm going to be experimenting a little more And share with you the results So now there is an opportunity to rethink When we use zoom lenses Despite all most of my photos Being taken with zoom lenses The vast majority The cost of that versatility Is actually a lower quality Or less photos that I personally love On the outcome So should I refocus on using only prime lenses That is a good question Let me know in the comments what you think And if you want to watch an analysis Of how I shot photos And the mistakes I made in New York City recently Watch this video If you want to learn more about your autofocus Watch this one And make sure you grab your cheat sheet With camera settings you can use on the field Anywhere in the description And with that being said Get out there go shoot Try something different Try something new I'll see you in the next one Let me know if you like that little analysis