4 steps to land a McKinsey internship

Career Pathways
3 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
What do you think are the main reasons McKinsey hired you?
That's such a hard question.
I actually tried to postpone slash drop out of my McKinsey recruiting process.
Screw consulting, I'm going to go do something else.
I was networking and meeting with some of these firms as early as like when I was 18.
You need one person to convince everyone else in the room.
How do you get one of these people to advocate for you?
You're never going to get anywhere by being desperate or like begging someone to give you a referral.
You need to find an organic way to have someone see your chops and your potential
and have them believe in you.
Like you mentioned earlier, some of these organic ways are to...
Like it's kind of a numbers game.
Get good at your coffee chat game, get good at your business, build up your resume.
Biggest hack is go on LinkedIn, follow like the specific offices,
connect with the recruiters at these firms.
I probably did like minimum 50 cases.
Consulting recruiting is a wildly different beast.
Hey Keeners, welcome back to another episode of Jumpstart Your Career with me,
your host, Gary Guo.
And today we are talking to Lani Zhang.
Lani and I met about two weeks ago when I saw her literally blowing up on TikTok
with her business series and talking about her time at McKinsey as a consultant.
So today we are sitting down to have a conversation with her
about her entire career journey.
More specifically, how did she land a McKinsey internship in her third year summer?
It is one of the most coveted, prestigious and competitive internships in the entire world.
And she'll be breaking down the four steps that she took to get that internship.
And before we get into it, please, please, please subscribe to this channel
if you haven't already.
And if you're listening on Apple Podcasts or Spotify,
please scroll up and give me a five-star rating.
It really does help me so much.
Hopefully this episode will jumpstart your career.
And let's get into it.
Lani Zhang, welcome to Jumpstart Your Career.
Thanks for having me.
This is so exciting.
To get started, can you tell me a bit about yourself?
Yeah, for sure.
I'm Lani, I'm from Toronto.
I went to school at Queen's University studying business,
did a couple of internships there and ultimately found my footing in consulting
where I did a summer with McKinsey and then worked there full-time for two years.
Then I left to become a director of strategy in BizOps
and really dived into the business AI space.
I left that role about two months ago now
and started pursuing kind of an entrepreneurial sabbatical.
One of the couple of side quests I've been working on is content creation.
So starting a TikTok was kind of random,
but that's how probably a lot of your audience might know me as well.
I'm Lani Zhang on TikTok and I kind of just sit on my couch and yeah.
Have you always known that you wanted to go into consulting?
Absolutely not.
It's so funny because I remember in high school,
one of my friends was really into this TV show called House of Lies, I think.
And it was about management consultants.
And I remember watching an episode and thinking it was a fake career.
Like I thought it was a comedy concept.
They didn't know it was real.
And I didn't know much about the world of business until I showed up on campus at Queens.
And it hits you really, really fast because the first week you get there is frosh week.
All of these random, really intense student clubs are recruiting for frosh reps.
There's, you know, consulting-oriented clubs,
finance-oriented clubs, a bunch of different stuff.
And I definitely like wasn't prepared for it.
I actually had a TA for calculus and I remember-
Trauma.
Everyone in my year was like,
this girl is so cool.
She's so gold because she interned at McKinsey.
And I was like, what is McKinsey?
But obviously, because everyone said it was so cool,
you know, maybe that's just my personality.
I was like, okay, this is maybe something I want to do.
You're like googling McKinsey in the background while everyone's like, yeah.
And then I was like, oh my gosh,
apparently it's harder to get into Harvard and all of these things.
But I remember thinking like, I actually really respect this girl.
I think she's really cool.
And naturally joined some of the consulting clubs as part of a student consultancy,
joined up international case comp team.
And actually a lot of the students,
part of those organizations go off to work in consulting.
Makes it really easy to be plugged in.
And that's kind of how it happened.
So the way that I see it is the consulting recruitment process
can essentially be broken down into four steps.
So there is the resume part, networking, case prep, and finally interviews.
I think in my mind, it's even simpler than that.
It's just landing the interview and then getting the offer.
It's such a marathon and it's such an intensive process.
What do you mean by like, it's such a marathon?
I used to think that if you wanted a job, I mean, like I've been working since I was 15.
My perception of getting a job was you saw a job listing,
you would apply to online, go to an interview.
And if they liked you and liked your experience based on your resume,
you would get hired.
Consulting recruiting is a wildly different beast.
I was networking and meeting with some of these firms as early as like
when I was 18 in first year, right?
I remember actually going to a networking event where they were serving wine
and I wasn't even a legal drinking age yet.
So if you think about it, you know, when I joined McKinsey full-time, I was 21,
but it was a three-year process, right?
Of learning about the industry, of networking,
building up my profile and my experiences
before they kind of finally made the investment.
I think it was such a huge reality check for myself.
And I think so many other business students when they go into university,
first of all, like everybody talks about internships and recruitment
because you're already in university, like what's next, right?
Like your career.
And you just assume that like these companies will just hire
maybe like a week before the job start date
and you'll just magically get a job.
Like you have your resume and everything.
But then you find out that McKinsey
and all these other top prestigious firms
literally recruit like a year in advance.
Like what the heck?
Like sometimes you're not even like prepared
or like you haven't even heard of the firm a year in advance.
Yeah, I will say it's not impossible to land a position
if you weren't a try-hard like me.
You know, I've heard of people who decided they wanted to do consulting
and then maybe just applied practice, 10 practice cases,
ended up getting an offer and starting a couple months later.
But I don't know.
I think those folks are pretty built different.
I couldn't be me.
Yeah.
I want us to maybe just go in order
so that we can follow a very, I guess, structured flow
when it comes to recruitment, very consulting-like.
I think the first step when it comes to applying for jobs
is always the resume.
I know this was a long time ago.
I think it was like four years ago for you probably at this point.
But do you remember the resume that you used to apply to McKinsey?
Yep.
So starting off, I had my education,
went to Smith School of Business at Queens,
had my GPA.
I was close to top 10%, but I wasn't.
So Queens is like a 4.3 scale.
I think mine was like 4.05 or something.
I had a couple of case competition outcomes in my education section.
Like awards, yeah.
Yeah, awards and achievements, things like that.
For work experience, since I was recruiting a full year in advance,
so the summer before the actual internship,
I had just started my second year summer internship,
which I was a customer operations intern at Ritual,
which is a Toronto-based food ordering startup.
Then I had an internship in first year summer as well,
it's so funny.
My dad and I joke all the time,
it was probably one of the hardest experiences of my life
because it was so boring and I was so sad
and I really didn't like the job and I was getting paid minimum wage.
But it was for this company based in Markham, Ontario
that essentially did import and export with brand home decor stuff,
and then they would sell to these retailers.
Okay.
So I had that.
Yeah.
Definitely not the sexy brand name internships
that you would think McKinsey likes.
Then I had my extracurricular experience,
which I think is like what really helped me stand out.
As I said, I was on CREO, student consultancy.
I was on QCCU,
had just joined this international case competition team at Queens.
And then I had a couple other extracurriculars as well, but...
So like more extracurriculars than actual work experiences.
Oh, for sure.
I mean, I was like, what, 19?
Like what kind of work experience do you have?
And the other interesting thing is,
depending on the extracurricular experience,
these can be way more valuable than a work experience,
especially if you're doing an internship where you're treated like an intern
and you're giving like a really little scope.
Well, there's like kids, for example, like me,
that like we're literally doing these four to eight month long
consulting projects with real clients getting paid real money.
And it was like, I've learned more and got more experience from that
one extracurricular than I did from,
it's probably the average of like two courses worth of workload.
You were telling me about these extracurricular experiences,
and I don't know if you've seen it recently,
but because it is Frosh Week, I think a few weeks ago,
a lot of people on the internet are talking about these
really top prestigious student clubs
and how getting into one of these clubs is like getting into the CIA.
I swear to God, some of these clubs and organizations
are harder to get into than the college itself.
Am I applying to the CIA or a student ran organization?
Because why am I filling out a personal statement
and then going through two rounds of interviews?
Dude, I bet NASA is in this competitive.
Literally.
Rounds upon rounds of interviews.
It's really intense.
It's more intense than actual job interviews.
What do you think is the reason why people
are so desperately trying to get into these top clubs?
I will answer a question, but I have a really hot take.
I hate Frosh hiring with a passion.
I think it's, one, not the most equitable process.
Who knows anything first week of first year, right?
It's completely based on your previous experiences,
what high school you went to, what your parents did,
all of those things, your existing relationships.
And the second thing is, it's also really hard
for the actual clubs to find the best people
because they've been on campus for three days
and all three days was like partying, right?
So obviously you can try and look at their experience,
but it's high school.
So you don't have enough data points
to actually figure it out.
I tried Frosh Rep recruiting.
I actually didn't land a single position.
Yeah.
So to answer your real question though,
why are people so desperate for it?
It's like, do you want to be an FO baby
or do you want to figure it out yourself?
You know, when you get onto a club like this,
granted, it's so competitive, but it's an advantage.
So many of these student groups have alumni
and the places that you want to go to,
you get a lot of like coaching and mentorship.
Another really important thing is you get community.
There's no way I would have survived
the marathon of consulting recruiting on my own.
It's funny, we were just talking about this.
We're in like right now.
And the last time I was here
was when I was going through consulting recruiting
and all of my friends in Creo QCCU
that were also going through this process.
They all lived here and this is where I did
like the majority of my mock cases and everything like that.
That is so crazy.
Being a part of one of these prestigious student clubs
is like turning into a Nepo baby.
Like you get so much more access to resources.
Like personally being a part
of the Realm of Commerce Kids Competition team,
it is so useful because if you really want it,
you can get an interview.
Like these alumni will help you
and they will give you the resources to network,
to give you a referral to the recruiters.
And that is just not available
to the rest of the student population
who don't have these networks and connections.
Obviously you can still get into consulting
or other industries without being a part of these clubs.
But would you recommend every high achieving university
students join one of these clubs?
No, I think I'm very careful with what I recommend
and it sounds so consultative of me
but it so depends on who you are.
Do what feels right for you
and what your priorities are.
I don't think I regret any of my experiences
but there's always trade-offs, right?
I spent a lot of my free time in college
doing work for these clubs
and it's almost like a part-time job.
Unpaid.
Unpaid, exactly.
Or you get paid in like going to a restaurant once a year.
So I think it depends.
I think it's a really great experience
and really great resources and support
if you think you wanna pursue a career.
You don't join these clubs
trying to use it to help you land a job.
You join these clubs for a taste
of what the real job might look like
to inform whether or not you even want to do it.
Yeah.
Wow.
Oh my God, that is like so much better
and so much more politically correct
and like open-minded
than I think a lot of people think.
So I remember when I was in first year,
so many people just showed up to campus for Ashweek
and they were like,
I'm gonna be an investment banking analyst
at Goldman Sachs or something like that.
And I remember being like,
how do you know?
Or like, how would you know, right?
Because these decisions you make
are informed by all the life experiences that you've had.
And when you're 18, in my opinion,
like sure, it's good to have a hypothesis or a goal,
but you have to be open-minded enough to realize
like maybe the more you learn about this,
like it's not the right fit.
Yeah.
In your second year summer,
you worked at this startup called Ritual
that's based in Toronto.
At the time, you were very insecure about it
because it is not the traditional second year internship
that a lot of successful candidates
who have gotten an MBA did in second year.
Usually it's like,
oh, they did like a big four consulting internships
or they worked at a big bank.
Like, can you take us back to maybe how you felt at the time
and maybe like,
do you still feel insecure about that experience now?
And like, what really shifted?
Oh my gosh.
Second year summer recruiting was so, so hard.
I literally landed this Ritual summer internship,
I think in April.
That's so late.
Right. So all of my friends had these jobs from the fall
working at a big four firm or like at a bank
or at least like some type of traditionally,
you know, successful role.
And I had probably applied to,
I don't know if I had to guess like 80 to a hundred internships
and done a couple of interviews.
And I just kept like flopping.
And I was like, what is wrong with me?
Like, why can't I get a job?
And just honestly, such a blessing.
I had sent a cold email out to just someone at Ritual.
They brought me in for one interview
and decided to like give me the job.
Were they even hiring at the time?
I think they had internship openings,
but I don't think they were actually
specifically hiring from Queens.
I think maybe they had like a co-op posting with Ryerson.
I actually have no idea.
It was literally from a cold email.
It must have been a really tough experience,
like mentally and just like thinking about like
the upcoming recruitment cycle.
Yeah. However, it's so funny
because I always say things happen for a reason.
I probably had the best summer out of any of my friends.
I loved working at Ritual.
It was so much fun.
That year they were growing really fast,
expanding to I think like eight different countries.
Working at a tech startup environment is
I think a great fit for me.
You go in, everyone's pretty casual.
You're working on things that you feel like are important
because there's less like corporate bureaucracy.
I think the company only had about 400 people at the time.
I went out for drinks with my co-workers.
I felt like I was friends with them,
whereas a lot of my friends
in these like more traditional corporate roles
felt like they weren't working on things
that maybe were as meaningful.
You know, it was very,
I guess like what you would expect out of corporate America.
And I think like pretty soon into the internship,
I actually realized this was such a blessing in disguise
because since it was a startup and way less structured,
there was way more opportunity for me to be entrepreneurial
and work on something actually media and important
as opposed to working on like a traditional like intern project
in a really large corporation.
And that definitely made me stand out in recruiting.
And I think like that's what a lot of
consulting companies want, right?
Like they want you to take charge
and lead a vertical or whatever they call it.
So consulting companies care about personal impact,
problem solving abilities.
They care about your entrepreneurial spirit.
And sure, having a brand name probably helps,
but I think increasingly,
they're actually pretty interested in folks
with less traditional backgrounds.
So I remember there was one McKinsey BA
who was a year above me that was also from Queens.
He did like an internship at Shopify.
So he kind of started like the tech startup
to consultant pipeline.
There were people I think that landed MBB internships
from being like a director at a summer camp year before
or working in politics.
I think a lot of people believe that
if you want to land an S tier internship
in your third year summer,
S tier meaning MBB consulting or high finance,
you have to follow a very set path.
It's kind of like a linear progression
where for example, you get a good first year internship
and then an even better one,
maybe at a big four consulting
or a big five banking one in second year summer.
And then you move up the ladder
and by third year, you get a really good internship.
And it's like this pathway that you have to follow.
Do you think that's necessarily true?
No, I actually super disagree with it.
Your third year internship is not the end goal.
You know, like it's so silly to think of it
as this like S tier goal
that you prioritize
and design your whole life around to get there.
You're 20 years old, right?
Every single internship
is just a new learning opportunity for you
to help inform what you want to do,
to help prepare you for whatever big thing you want to do
in the long, long term.
So I think one, don't hyperfixate
on the I have to land an S tier internship
because you know, it's not for everyone.
Also the S tier name sounds so ridiculous.
Yeah, it's like cringe.
Yeah.
But ultimately, I think what the S tier internship
thing kind of translates to
is like being in a really great
like internship experience
where you are really supported,
like you learn a lot.
It's a really great development opportunity.
It opens up more doors for the future,
but you can kind of replicate that anywhere, right?
Maybe you could do something entrepreneurial
and try and start your own business.
Maybe you can work at a less well-known place,
but have really big personal impact.
If I was in first year, I'd never say like,
okay, I need to get an internship at McKinsey.
These are the steps I need to do.
Like, no, follow your heart sounds cheesy,
but have a hypothesis on what you want to do.
Be like, okay, I'm interested in strategy.
Try to apply for these roles
or I'm interested in tech, apply for these.
I would literally just solve for the next step
and not do the whole like five, 10, whatever your plan.
And I think one of the ways to do that
is through networking
and maybe talking to people in different industries.
For sure.
I'm someone who has always followed people.
The reason I ended up on Crown QCCU
was because the upper years that I knew,
some of them were in finance,
some of them were in consulting,
some of them were in marketing.
The ones that I thought I wanted to be most like,
either personality-wise or lifestyle-wise
or values-wise were in consulting.
So it was like, okay, I think these are my people.
This is like the club I'm going to join.
It's funny because in fourth year,
I joined this club called QTMA,
Queen's Tech and Media Association.
One of the best extracurricular experiences I ever had.
I actually left the case competition team
in fourth year to do that instead.
And that's because I started meeting all these people in tech
after my internship experience.
I was like, oh, I actually want to build.
I want to do startup life.
And then kind of followed those people into QTMA club.
Yeah. And you're in tech now.
So I think it definitely helps so much.
Back in those days when you were recruiting,
how did you approach networking for consulting?
It was kind of just go with the flow
because the wave that you get caught on
from being in these like target schools and target clubs is like,
like, for example, you get invitations
to maybe more exclusive events.
Like you will kind of already know these people.
One thing I did in college in second year
that I think really helped me
was this case competition called Q3C.
Queen's runs it, but it's, there's a bunch of students go.
And my team won.
And then I also won like most valuable delegate
from that competition.
Wow, that girl, it girl.
Which was crazy.
I don't think anyone, I didn't expect that.
It's so funny because I think back on it
and I was like, I almost didn't go
because like I paid for most of school myself.
And I also had to pay for these conferences myself.
And that comp was like $200.
So I was like scrambling money,
like trying to do these side jobs to get $200 to go.
And then I won an Apple watch from this,
like getting most valuable delegate.
Immediately posted it on Kijiji,
sold it for like 300 something dollars.
And I was like, yes, I'm positive ROI.
But that's besides the point.
After I won Q3C, all of these reps
from these different firms,
I think kind of like knew who I was.
Talent.
Yeah, literally, which is so silly
because like it's a one week long case comp.
But then for example, like it was easier
to kind of like get coffee with them or to do like Zoom.
So yeah, I just started like going to the events on campus,
trying to build these one-on-one relationships.
But I never had an Excel spreadsheet
with a list of everyone's names, firms, notes.
Like that's just not really my style.
I think I always approach things
a little bit more organically.
And I'm so bad at following up sometimes.
Like let's say I got coffee with someone five years ago
and never followed up again.
Like-
Yeah, and the people who do that
are like a little bit scary to me.
I'm like, well, it's so like, I don't know.
Maybe it's like genuine,
but sometimes it feels a bit calculated.
It's like they have like reminders
on calendars for themselves.
Oh, it's been three months time to send
like a follow-up message or something like that.
It's crazy.
I respect it.
It's very type A.
I just can't do it.
Speaking of like case competitions,
I think it's like the most underrated way
to break into consulting
or just like learn more
about your career interests in general.
I think we're a bit biased
because we're both on the case competition team
at our respective schools.
But do you think that every single business student
should do at least one case competition
during undergrad?
Yeah, I think everyone should do everything
at least once, you know?
But I think like the case competition piece,
it's interesting.
I think the value you get from it
is the doing a case study,
acting like a consultant,
thinking about corporate strategy,
things like that,
which lends itself pretty naturally
to the content of work that you do in consulting.
However, I will say that case competition experience
isn't a work experience you talk about in interviews.
So when I was recruiting for consulting
or any of these jobs,
obviously these recruiters and hiring managers
probably thought it was impressive
and cared that I was on these clubs,
but it wasn't like I talked about it
because a case comp is like one week long,
max,
which just isn't like a big
or juicy enough experience.
It's not like you have to do it
and it's going to be like
the perfect extracurricular experience.
Like that's not the case.
But again, like you don't do the case comp
for this firm to hire you.
You do it to figure out if you enjoy it or not.
And like speaking of like just like networking
and case competitions in general,
a lot of students don't know about this,
but there's a lot of diversity events and challenges
that a lot of consulting firms like MBB run.
For instance, McKinsey,
there's a case competition every year
called the McKinsey Challenge.
I think it's by invite or by application basis,
but I've heard that the students who do go,
they're pretty much already screened.
And you know, if they do well in the case competition,
then they can really get close to the recruiter.
And they'll pretty much be like,
I wouldn't say guaranteed,
but like they have a much higher chance
of getting an interview.
For sure.
I was part of the McKinsey Challenge team for a year
on the like firm side of things.
And you can think of it from McKinsey's point of view,
which is just that it's an investment in recruiting.
It's one way for them to identify top candidates
without having to screen through
like 10,000 resumes, right?
I think it's an awesome thing to do.
It's free.
It is application on an application basis,
but I think it's objectively easier
to get invited to McKinsey Challenge
than it is to like be hired as a summer intern, right?
Yeah, for sure.
So it's a fun weekend in Toronto.
You get to see the office.
Sometimes you get to meet a lot of people.
It's just another down point.
I think they do it every,
I think March or somewhere in that timeframe.
So I think like a lot of these firms
have these like specific good recruitment events
for like networking purposes or just for like experiences.
So definitely go check them out.
Biggest hack is go on LinkedIn,
follow like the specific offices,
connect with the recruiters at these firms,
even like send them an email.
Sometimes you can,
it's almost like an email newsletter or whatever,
like make sure they have your email
so that when you go on LinkedIn,
you can see when people are posting about these events,
maybe it'll be on your campus career job portal,
whatever, if you go to a target school.
Another really underrated thing is like follow McKinsey
or whatever firm like on Instagram
because these firms are not popular on Instagram.
Yeah.
You know what I mean?
Like, I don't know, but they post about these things.
And as someone who's like on Instagram
more than I am on LinkedIn,
it's a great way to find out about it.
I think there's such a huge information gap sometimes.
It's like people hear about these opportunities
and they're like,
wait, like I didn't hear about it when it happened.
And now FOMO, like major FOMO.
So yeah, like Lonnie said,
follow these firms on Instagram.
I think it's also just good to like familiarize yourself
with like the culture and everything.
If you want to keep an eye open
or an ear open for these opportunities,
like you just kind of have to be into it.
Like let's say you're a sneakerhead
and you're waiting for like the next sneaker drop.
Like it's obviously something you care about
and you research and you go out.
Like these really cool opportunities
won't just magically be brought to your face all the time.
I know like personally, you're not very type A,
but I kind of want to ask this question anyways,
because I've heard that there's three types of people
that you should network with
when it comes to consulting recruitment.
Obviously, first we have the recruiter
who has the ultimate power in this process
to give you an interview,
but then you also have these recruitment captains
or the people on the recruitment team
that's dedicated for your school
because they also are in close contact with the recruiter.
And these are the people who actually have
a lot of power in the process.
And then the third one is alumni from your school,
if you have any.
Would you agree with like
this three-pronged networking strategy?
That's so consultant of you.
Yes and no.
To simplify it, all you need is to get an interview
and to get an interview,
you need one person to convince everyone else in the room
that you should get an interview.
For some people, that's the recruiter.
For some people, that's an alumni
that's currently like on the recruiting team there.
For some people, that's like a partner.
You essentially just need like someone in the firm to be like,
Gary is an absolute weapon.
He would be so good.
He needs to get an interview
and convince the recruiting manager or whoever.
Here's the thing, if you have like a garbage resume
with like no experiences,
like I don't know if anyone could kind of help you,
but having like someone's informal referral
like definitely helps.
And how do you approach that process?
You know, like how do you get one of these people
to advocate for you?
I think you have to do it organically.
I don't know who advocated for me.
I actually don't know how I got an interview,
but like I have a guess
and I bet you anyone who polled for me
wasn't someone that I like cold reached out to on LinkedIn.
It was someone that like I had
a substantial relationship with.
So for example, maybe it was an alumni
that I was on like Creo or QCCU with
that was currently at the firm.
Maybe it was like a judge
at one of these case competitions.
You know, you're never going to get anywhere
by like being desperate
or like begging someone to give you a referral.
Yeah.
You need to like find an organic way
to have someone see your chops
and your potential and have them believe in you.
Yes.
And like you mentioned earlier,
some of these organic ways
are to do case competitions,
attend firm events,
or just like any other thing
to like be physically in a room with someone else
and like meet them like that
instead of like a random calculated,
perfected LinkedIn message.
There's so many events,
like webinars and Zooms.
I was on a ton of them
when I did recruiting at McKinsey.
Yeah.
The other thing I'd say is
if you are someone that needs to get in contact
with like a recruiting manager or someone,
try and get a warm lead.
I have done probably like over 100 coffee chats
with different students and young professionals
looking to get into consulting.
If I have a really, really good chat with someone
and I can kind of see their potential,
I'll offer like,
I'm actually going to personally connect you
with someone I know at this firm
and I'll like set it up for them.
Granted, I wouldn't necessarily ask for that
if I was like the student doing the coffee chat
because it's kind of based on the discretion
of the mutual connection you have.
Yeah.
But I would say like it's kind of a numbers game,
like get good at your coffee chat game,
get good at your business,
build up your resume,
be a really good candidate.
If they see potential and talent in you,
they'll naturally invest in you
and help you figure out how to navigate the process.
For sure.
So maybe like diving deeper into your recruitment journey,
the next step is naturally case prep,
which is I guess like a very unique aspect
of consulting recruitment
because not every firm asks you to do that.
And I remember the first time I did it,
it was like so weird and so unnatural.
And I was like, what is going on?
Like, this is so confusing.
How did you approach case prep back then?
I'll be structured here.
Step one, you need someone that is a friend
who is also going through the process.
You do probably 10 cases with this friend
and it's like blind leading the blind.
You have no idea what you're doing.
You barely know what a case interview is.
For me, that was one of my best friends,
Rachel from Queens.
Okay.
We literally, shout out Rachel.
It's so funny.
We joke about it all the time.
We had no idea what a case interview was
and we would just give each other these mock cases
from these random books that we found.
And they were horrible.
But the point of the first 10
is just to actually figure out what a case interview is.
So that when you actually start practicing,
you can be structured about it.
For example, I grew up competitive figure skating.
You're not going to learn how to do a triple axle
before you know how to skate forwards and backwards.
And you just need to fumble a couple of times.
After you get that out of the way with someone
that you are close to and feel really safe with,
then you start building a network of other students
or other young professionals
going through a similar process.
So that way you can practice
with a bunch of different people,
get different types of feedback
to help you improve your game.
When you're getting to a point where you're like,
all right, I feel pretty good about this.
That's when you start asking
maybe like previous interns or alumni
or upper years to help you.
Because at this point, it's not mutual.
Like you're not giving them a case back.
They're like specifically coaching you.
And it's hard to get access to coaching
because it requires someone to give up their time.
So these are mentors
that hopefully you've collected along the way.
After years that go to your school,
that's kind of where you go.
And then the last step is to go to the alumni.
And I would say I had a really, really great mentor of mine
that I had met through one of these clubs.
He was, I think he had left the firm at the time already,
but I think he was like left at engagement manager level.
I did probably one or two cases with him
and it was like more helpful
than maybe like 10 cases with Pierce
that I had done before.
Because you just get,
it's like a seasoned vet giving you advice.
So that's how I would do it.
I probably did like minimum 50 cases,
which sounds like a lot.
I've had friends at McKinsey said like,
oh, I did five.
And I was like, good for you.
Like-
500 or five?
Five, five.
I was like, that can be five or 500.
No, they were like, I did five.
And I was like,
like I didn't even know what a profit tree
at like case number five was, you know?
So it really depends on the person,
but that's like a structured playbook.
If you are confident in your abilities,
then go straight to like,
you can skip the, you know, maybe first few steps.
And I guess like after case prep
comes the actual interview.
So at this point, you've already,
you know, submitted your resume.
You've got the interview.
What did your interview process
look like for McKinsey?
This was like quite a few years ago now.
So it's actually changed.
I recruited for McKinsey, Bain, BCG there.
They were pretty much all the same process.
There's the first round,
which is usually with like an associate
or an engagement manager level person
at all three firms.
If you're successful, then you hear back
and then you do like a final round
with a couple more cases
with partners and leadership at these firms.
And like, what was your mindset
going into recruiting for McKinsey?
Oh man, it was so ups and downs.
Honestly, I didn't know anything.
Like, you know, you don't know much
besides like what people talk about.
And McKinsey had a reputation of being like,
they only took like the gold medalist of every year,
like the smartest person,
the president of these highly competitive clubs.
And I was like,
Ooh, I don't think I'm like McKinsey material.
Like maybe like Bain will be fun.
Bain seems like still a good company
that maybe has a good culture or whatever.
But my mindset was like,
recruiting is an awful experience.
I will take the first offer I get
and then like, I'm out of there.
Got final rounds for Bain, didn't get the offer.
Got final rounds for BCG, didn't get the offer.
So it was very ups and downs.
And it was like,
McKinsey was like the last cycle that I did.
And at the time,
there was this myth that I had believed
where if you didn't have a competing offer,
there was no way you could get an offer at McKinsey.
So I actually tried to like postpone
slash drop out of my McKinsey recruiting process.
I was like, screw consulting.
I'm going to go do something else.
Like I was also working full time
at my second year summer startup
and I'd missed so much work.
You know, the doctor's appointment stuff,
trying to do these interviews.
And I was like, I can't waste another day.
Thankfully, this magical woman
that has helped me so much in my career,
who was the recruiting manager at McKinsey at the time,
actually gave me a call.
I think she told my interview buddy to give me a call
and to convince me to just do it.
And yeah, obviously it didn't guarantee
if I was going to get an offer or not.
But the thing that changed in my mindset
was literally like,
I'm going into this,
not thinking I'm going to get a job out of it.
So what does that mean?
I get four interviews
with four different partners at McKinsey,
who in any other world would charge me
thousands of dollars an hour to speak to me.
So I'm just going to learn from them for free.
And I'll get to meet these people.
I'll hopefully osmosis some brain cells
and it'll be fun.
And I won't get an offer, but that's okay.
And that mindset,
this is literally just like consumer surplus.
It's like free time.
Yeah.
That mindset really helped me,
I think, feel a little bit more natural,
feel less pressure and all of that.
And ultimately ended up in me getting an offer,
which was so insane.
I actually got my offer.
I got a verbal offer on the spot
following my last interview.
So that was actually really exciting
to be in the room.
And it was with one of the most senior people
in the Toronto office at the time.
And he was just like,
well, welcome to the firm
or something like that.
And I was like, no way.
Yeah, that's so crazy.
I guess I won't dive into too much detail
about the McKinsey recruitment process,
but were there any really fun moments
or unexpected questions
that you got in that process?
I think it's such a personal experience
getting to meet a lot of these
really impressive leaders
across all of the firms.
Because you realize they all have
these really interesting experiences
and you kind of bond over different things.
I will say there were interviews I had
that were far less traditional
than I thought.
Like there were definitely some folks
who clearly didn't use
one of those case interview guidelines
with the rubric
and kind of just tested
the different components.
Deviated from the script.
Exactly, deviated from the script
and tested the same,
you know, maybe skills,
but in a more organic way.
One of the interviews that I loved to do
like I didn't really do a case
with this interviewer.
My guess is he was kind of
just trying to like
tell me about what he was working on
and see how I approached
the different questions.
So we pretty much did like
three different cases in one.
Each was like a different question.
So one of them was something about like,
how would you figure out
how many pianos there are in the UK?
But it wasn't like
a traditional market sizing question.
It was a little like
a brainstorming question being like,
what are all the different mechanisms
or like ways you could figure this out?
So, you know, looking to sales data,
interviewing people, all of this stuff.
We just went on and on and on
and kept being like,
come up with another idea,
come up with another idea.
And I was like getting so stumped.
And at the end, I was like,
I know this is like an ethical issue.
So I'm not saying it's a good idea.
We would have to really think about
the privacy considerations of this.
But maybe we could tap into
all the smart devices in the UK,
like the Google Homes,
the phones, whatever,
and triangulate based on piano sounds
they heard to figure out
how many pianos there were.
And he was like,
OK, that was a really creative answer.
We can move on now.
So I think like,
like they're just trying to see
if you're a good problem solver
and if you can demonstrate
like analytical thinking,
you know, you can demonstrate brainstorming,
if you can structure your communications.
Outside the box thinking.
Exactly.
But that one, I was definitely like,
I have no idea where this is going.
First, we were talking about,
yeah, you know, an airplane
and then we're talking about pianos
and he was kind of just going his way.
My guess, though, I will say is
I think they've become
a little bit more buttoned up
since I went through recruiting.
I believe the recruiting teams
have tried to not discipline,
but encourage these interviewers
to be a little bit more by the book.
Interesting.
I think you're also telling me
about how you guys were literally
like role playing in that interview
or something.
So interesting.
Every case interview is a role play, right?
But there was one point
where in that piano interview,
he was saying,
imagine I'm a factory manager
and I produce like airplane bodies for you,
but I'm trying to steal your IP
and we have a really bad relationship.
Let's role play this conversation.
So I was like, oh, well, if I were,
and he's like, no, no, no,
we're going to role play.
And I guess maybe just wanted to see
how I would perform under pressure,
handle a difficult conversation.
But that was super out of the box too.
If you prepare for a consulting interview
or you prepare for any type of interview,
even if it goes a little off script,
you're still okay.
And you hopefully will have the,
you know, practice and muscles
to be able to play it through.
I guess we already talked about this
a little bit earlier,
but how did you feel when you got
the offer from McKinsey?
It was such a relief,
which I don't know if that's a sad thing to say.
You would expect that you'd be so excited
and want to celebrate and all this,
which don't get me wrong.
Like I got there eventually,
but I remember when I walked out of the office
after just hearing that I got this offer,
it was so surreal.
And I remember the first thing I did
was call my parents because I had to,
I wanted them to know
they were so supportive
throughout the whole process.
And it was something I was so stressed about.
They obviously were very stressed for me as well
because they wanted the best.
So I let them know.
I contacted a very few couple of people,
but mostly the people that helped me
through this process.
Cause I think they were the ones
that deserve to know first.
I didn't even tell too many of my friends.
I went straight home and just went to bed.
I just took a nap and I was like,
I just felt this sense of relief.
And I was like, all right,
I'm going to take a nap and deal with this later.
And then I woke up from my nap
and apparently the whole world knew.
I feel like because,
whether it's the students
or the current consultants at these firms
or the alumni,
they all talk and they all find out.
It's a very small circle.
Such a small circle.
So I woke up to a lot of
really kind messages from people,
but it was a little overwhelming
because people are really positive and supportive.
But at the same time,
everyone's talking about it
when you get a final round
and then everyone's talking about it
when you don't get the offer.
Oh, that's so rough.
I just, I didn't want to be perceived,
but obviously that's what was happening.
So yeah, that's kind of how I felt.
It's funny because that's going to be you
after this podcast comes out.
I think I realized through content creation that,
I don't know,
you're always going to have people
who are a fan of you
and people who won't like you
and that's totally okay.
Like this world is a really diverse place.
But I think like,
if people are going out of their way
to criticize you
or in an unconstructive way,
like hate on you,
it's a leading indicator of success.
You know, people love,
people love to hate.
Yeah, haters gonna hate.
Maybe this is my most important question
that I want to ask you today,
but what do you think
are the main reasons Mackenzie hired you
out of all these thousands of applicants?
That's such a hard question.
So I think one,
I had a profile that was pretty fit for it
because of my extracurricular involvement,
case competition I did,
the relationships I already had.
It was pretty natural to be like,
okay, this is probably someone
who would interview.
And then also I think I had just done so many cases
that I think I was at a point
where I was pretty good at cases,
regardless of whether or not you get the offer.
If you're consistently making it to final rounds,
it usually means like you've got the case interview
part down pat.
I remember one piece of feedback that I got
from my last interview at Mackenzie.
He was saying how there are so many really high performing,
really smart people that come in.
And one thing they care about is,
I guess like the energy you bring into a room.
Like, are you someone that's super sharp,
but also really collaborative
that people would have fun
and feel comfortable working with
for really long hours?
Cause that's what the job is.
And I think to this day,
it's probably the best positive piece of feedback
I've ever gotten.
But he said, the way that I engage in problem solving
puts energy into a room.
And I was like, you think I'm like a culture hire?
Personality hire?
Literally, and bring the positive vibes.
But it's such a thing.
This can be a stressful job.
Interviews are a stressful environment.
If you can go in, be positive,
keep it lighthearted, make jokes.
I think people actually do respond to that.
And that's what he had told me.
I would say, lastly,
there's such a big component of luck to it.
There's such a big component of luck.
There's way more people
that are qualified for the role
that actually land it.
So, you know, I was lucky to get an interview.
I was lucky to, you know,
get matched up with the interviewers that I did.
Sometimes you have an off day.
Sometimes you have a good day.
I was lucky that the economy was maybe good at the time.
So they had capacity to hire a little bit more.
It all kind of, it's all like momentum
that builds up onto each other.
Sometimes I think like I make these videos
because I want to give like a very specific,
like, oh, like one, two, three,
you need to do this, that, and that.
You need to think of this.
You need to do these things.
But then it's like,
sometimes I think these things are kind of like fate almost.
And it's like, you are such a unique individual person
and you have your own path.
And it's like, yes, there are like tips
and inspiration and other things.
But at the end of the day,
you got the job because you're you,
not because you did X, Y, Z, you know?
It's like, it's so important to think of it like that.
100%.
I think it's so easy to try and do pattern recognition.
Like this person got this job
because this is what they did.
But the best thing you can do
is try to get as close to your personal potential as you can.
So for example, like if you are so passionate
about content creation,
go start a channel and blow it up.
You know what I mean?
If someone's so passionate about the sport,
go to the Olympics and do that.
Like that's what these places often care about.
Not like how well could you replicate this recipe
of joining this club, doing this internship, whatever.
Okay.
That is it of our conversation
with Lani Zhang about her internship recruitment journey
at McKinsey.
Hopefully you really enjoyed this episode
and you've learned something that you can use for yourself
when it comes to recruiting for consulting companies
or just navigating your career in general.
As always, feel free to hit that subscribe button
or follow this podcast anywhere you listen or watch on.
Stay tuned for next week's episode
where we continue our conversation with Lani
about her career in consulting post-grad.
So we'll talk about, you know,
what do consultants actually do?
What are the exit opportunities available?
And just general valuable life lessons.
So stay tuned for that.
Keeners, I'll see you next week.
