Rebellion takes many forms. Counterculture movements tend to try to go against social norms and household values that teens especially might see as restrictive. But in China, a new type of rebellion is taking place. People are simply giving up and embracing a low-pressure lifestyle. This is part of the “lie flat” movement, where young people are refusing to compete, refusing to push themselves, and oftentimes refusing to work or study. And for the Chinese Communist Party, this represents a type of quiet rebellion against the high-pressure system that is nearly impossible to quell. We’ll discuss in this episode of Crossroads.
🔴 Stay informed. Stay Free. Join us: https://www.joshphilipp.com - - - - - - - - - Views expressed in this video are opinions of the host and guests, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
welcome to Crossroads Rebellion takes
many forms now look counterculture
movements you know they tend to go
against the social norms and the
sometimes household values that teens
especially might see as restrictive but
in China a new type of rebellion is
taking place people are just giving up
and they're embracing a low pressure
lifestyle now look this is part of the
lie flat movement or laying flat
movement and young people basically are
just refusing to compete refusing to
push themselves and they're often times
refusing to even work or study and for
the Chinese Communist party this
actually represents a type of quiet
Rebellion against the CCP itself and the
you know high pressure system that
really they can't quell it there's not
much they can do to stop it now voice of
America explains it like this they say
some young adults in China are unhappy
with the culture of long working hours
High housing prices and a very high cost
of living so the young people are quote
lying flat to express their anger they
have rejected traditional goals like
getting married having children
purchasing a home or car and following
the corporate money-making path it says
lying flat this movement is known as
Tong ping in China the Chinese online
discussion website ji who is filled with
comments from young adults who have
joined the movement it says posters on
the site say they choose earn less and
buy less to live more simply Tong ping
is a rejection it says of the so-called
996 life in China which is again you
know 9:00 a.m. to 9900 p.m. 6 days a
week work schedule which is the normal
practice says of you know working these
these hours again six days a week it
says the government owned China Daily
one of the main Chinese state-run media
reports that Chinese officials worry
about the tong ping movement obviously
they say the newspaper said the
government has long linked higher
education and employment with wider
social order it goes deeper than this
we'll get into in a minute but it notes
as well the website China banking news
reports the average monthly earnings of
China's college graduates in 2019 was
just over
$777 so you even get to College which is
very hard in China there's entrance
exams and everything else you're still
not promised much now notes the Chinese
government reacted quickly to Tong ping
as you might expect in late May the
state-run global times published an
opinion piece about the movement saying
quote young people are the hope of this
country and neither their personal
situation nor the situation of this
country will allow them to collectively
lie flat and know so once graduates find
jobs many feel they're expected to work
too many hours as well and so even if
you get involved in the rat race the
concern is you're going to literally
work yourself to death death now the
whole movement with this this lying flat
movement it's similar in some ways to
the you know quiet quitting Movement we
see in the west only on a much broader
level you know in the west you have a
few movements like this where people are
kind of collectively checking out of
society there's quiet quitting as I
mentioned and quiet quitting is where
you go and you do your N9 to5 you know
you work but you don't really push
yourself you do the bare minimum and
this is hard for businesses to deal with
because you know do you fire people
they're still doing their jobs they're
just not pushing themselves to improve
they're not pushing themselves to do
really well at their jobs or to Excel
and so it's kind of a stagnating or even
downward trend for the companies
oftentimes it's very hard to deal with
there's also for example the inell
movement inv voluntary cell of it where
young men especially right now and they
have fem sales as well of women doing
this they just choose to not date or not
get married and kind of give up on
trying to build a life like that now
when it comes to the broader social
level of course that can be destructive
to the future of a society but in China
where the Chinese Communist Party of
course pushes people to compete and
pushes people to try to you know
overcome their neighbors to some extent
and it goes deeper than this we'll
explain it a bit this is something that
challenges the nature of the CCP itself
and when the CCP notably is trying to
revitalize its economy which requires
this type of highlevel competition if
people lie flat this is destructive to
everything the regime is trying to do
right now now look it's also a type of
revolt against what the CCP would call
Nan which is a type of communist
revolutionary mentality the idea of Nan
is basically as an individual you are
waging Communist Revolution you as an
individual don't waste a single moment
you're constantly fighting the
revolution constantly trying to overcome
everybody else it's this communist idea
of struggling against man struggling
against nature and struggling against
Heaven it's the Communist struggle
embodied at a personal level what this
lying flat movement represents is a
Revolt even against that fundamental
trait now Business Insider says this
about it they say the the idea of lying
flat is widely acknowledged as a Mass
societal response to Nan or involution
right internal Revolution and know that
Nan became a term used commonly to
describe a hyperco competitive lifestyle
in China where life is linked to a zero
some game says according to Chinese news
atlet cgtn a viral photo of a student at
the prestigious shinua University
studying at his laptop while riding a
bike right he's riding his bike while
studying on a laptop
best encompassed Nan right the idea that
you don't waste a single moment even
while doing one task you're fighting the
internal Communist Revolution it says
the pressure to succeed renders the mere
minutes spent on a short bike commute a
waste of time the constant constant
struggle and knows that njan goes hand
inand with China's 996 culture the term
refers to China's hustle culture where
people work 12 hours a day from 9:00
a.m. to 900 p.m. 6 days a week
technically you know they have like a
40s something hour work week but the
expectation is really doubl in that and
if you're not competing right if you're
not fighting against your neighbor if
you're not competing with your
co-workers you're going to get left
behind and that's the way the system
works now it notes the 996 lifestyle was
strongly championed by Jack ma the
founder of Alibaba who got pushed out by
the season CP who once in 2019 called
the 72-hour Work Week a blessing he
notes that long work days are not only
common but expected of Staff despite
China's labor policy mandating employees
not work more than eight hours a day
right because again there's the minimum
there's the law then there's the
expectation among the employers you're
working like a slave even if legally on
paper you just working 8 hours a day and
it's a poor enforcement of Labor laws
has led to rampant cases of overwork
stories of people literally dying at
their desks or suffering from depression
and exhaustion are not uncommon now look
a key difference in China though right
when it comes to quiet quitting or this
lying flat movement which goes beyond
that it's kind of all-encompassing
throughout your life it includes even
like things like not taking care of the
elderly for example uh which is
culturally expected in China and among
many Asian countries by the way and so
people people are checking out of all of
these social expectations everything
that would be expected of them they're
not doing it a key difference in China
though right when it comes to this whole
movement is that the ccp's Communist
system relies heavily on social struggle
it is a foundation of the ideology of
the system itself competition is massive
now as we mentioned they have the 996
work expectation for students there's
massive pressure on scoring high on for
example college entrance exams and if
you don't get into college you're going
to be a factory worker or a glorified
slave or a bum and because of that of
course there's huge competition on
studying of kids going to school
studying and then doing second school
where after school they go to another
voluntary school and they just study
literally all day and sometimes all
night until they go to bed there's no
life for them outside of the
expectations in business imagine you go
to school and you're studying like that
you get into college you're studying
like that you get into business it
doesn't end in business competition and
struggle are also extremely intense so
what happens right what happens when a
system that depends on people pushing
themselves to the absolute extreme where
they're literally dying at their desks
or you have kids killing themselves when
they don't reach the Pinnacle of you
know the
expectations right they say B is for bad
right only a is allowed what happens to
a system that depends on that is its
basic way of functioning when people
just stop caring enough to do it while
this is what's happening in China and
this movement again represents a type of
internal Rebellion not external
Rebellion which makes it very hard for
the CCP itself to deal with I'll be
talking more about this though after a
quick break experts agree one of the
best ways to protect against Financial
uncertainty is to diversify your
portfolio learn how physical gold and
silver can secure your retirement funds
from today's economic challenges with a
gold Ira from American hardford goal you
can Safeguard your wealth with no
penalties or taxes when you transfer
your current qualifying retirement
accounts call now on our precious metals
Specialists will send you a free
information kit no cost or obligation
American Hartford gold AUST trusted
industry leader with an A+ from the
Better Business Bureau has a five-star
rating from thousands of happy clients
whether you are getting physical
precious metals in a gold Ira or
delivered to your doorstep we offer only
the highest quality gold and silver for
your peace of mind we also offer a no
fee buyback commitment a low price
guarantee along with free shipping and
free insurance so don't wait call the
number on your screen today and secure
your financial future
[Music]
welcome back a new type of rebellion is
taking place in China it's a quiet one
people are just giving up right they're
embracing a low pressure lifestyle and
this is part of the lying flat movement
people are just refusing to compete
refusing to push themselves often times
refusing to study or work and refusing
to participate in any of the things that
would be expected of them under the
Chinese Communist party system now for
the CCP
this represents a type of rebellion this
is like an uprising this is a very
dangerous movement in the eyes of the
regime but it's one that's almost
impossible for them to quell it's a
quiet revolt against the high pressure
system that the CCP has created but what
do you do with this right well look the
reason is it's not an external Rebellion
it's not a movement where people are
protesting in the streets it's not like
1989 with the Democracy AC or even
religious Believers you know refusing to
give up their
practices with China right now this is a
type of internal Rebellion people within
their own minds within their own states
are just choosing to no longer push
themselves now the Soviets notably right
during the Soviet Union in Russia they
ran into a similar problem people of
course you know under the Soviet
Communist party in Russia they were
dealing with absolute equality you were
assigned spouse your husband or wife was
assigned to you often times by the
government uh you were assigned a job
you were assigned a role in society you
were assigned a house everything was
assigned to you they actually had the
full you know redistribution of wealth
and the incentive to become a doctor or
to become a factory worker was about the
same and so people started realizing
well why am I pushing myself why am I
trying so hard why am I going to work
and kill myself working at this Factory
job when it makes no difference whether
I work hard or not what difference does
it make and so they started having a
slogan going around in Soviet Russia
they pretend to pay us and we pretend to
work they stopped trying they gave up on
the system and in China now this
represents not only that but something
even deeper now let me show you how
Chinese media are framing it because the
CCP is freaking out South China Morning
Post said that for months the chatter
surrounding lying flatter Tong ping has
permeated Chinese Society so discourse
and become ubiquitous with ubiquitous
enough to finally warrant a public
condemnation by President XI jingping
himself the very head of the Communist
Party stepped out to address it and it
has to be big for them to do that
because they'd rather not address it
normally he said quote it is necessary
to prevent the stagnation of the social
class unblock the channels for Upward
social Mobility create opportunities for
more people to become rich and form an
environment for improvement in which
everyone participates avoiding
involution and lying flat Xi Jinping
said in comments published on October
15th by the communist party's Flagship
journal on political Theory quishi now
it notes that his words address a trend
that strikes at the very heart of his
Chinese dream ideology uh the China
dream is the big slogan of Xi Jinping
the China dream is what you're supposed
to Aspire to right it's the idea that
China is going to become the world
leader the superpower a high-tech
Communist Regime right that's the China
dream and it's embedded within you know
XI jingping ideology Xi Jinping thought
which kids have to study as if it were
you know scripture
basically and notes that he has
described this as a quote great
revolution of the Chinese Nation
and if people of course just give up on
trying to achieve the China dream
because they no longer believe it's you
know something you can realize or
something that's going to make them
miserable while they try to do it well
the ccp's system fails now this Chinese
media notes in the long run lying flat
could not only affect Chinese
consumption and growth notably the two
big terms the CCP has right now to try
to revitalize its economy it says but
also lower the birth rate that is
already eating up the country's
demographic dividend and threatening its
social welfare system according to
economists and social commentators and
let me explain how serious the birth
rate is in China you know for a long
time the CCP had the one child policy if
you had more than one child you would be
fined sometimes they had Collective
punishment where if you're maybe not so
much in the cities but in The Villages
if a woman had a second child or was
pregnant the entire Village would be
punished and to avoid that punishment
sometimes the entire Village would
actually kill the infant once it was
born so the incentive of course to not
have a second kid was very serious they
would literally kill your child in some
cases sometimes even the doctors would
do it uh there's horrifying stories for
example stories for example of doctors
drowning an infant what you know front
in front of the parents often times
right after it's born now because of
this right the CCP has you know since
changed that they make it so you can now
you can now have more than one kid they
still kind of cap it but the problem
they have is that because it's become
culturally embedded to not want to have
kids and because the the social pressure
is so high people just don't want them
and so they can't even make people have
kids now imagine the effect of this
generation to generation now you know
normally if you have two kids well it's
kind of equal replacement right but when
you have one child policy down a couple
Generations normally one child would
have of course two parents and then four
grandparents but bring that up one
additional level where you know for a
couple Generations now you've had it and
then you have double that eight grand
eight great grandparents four
grandparents two parents one child and
that one child expected in his you know
career to take care of all the elderly
as they retire once they reach that age
of course that type of social pressure
is very high for them and of course for
the Chinese Communist party and the idea
of of course you know the expectation
not only that socially the youth will
take care of the elderly which is even
mandated by law to an extent by the CCP
because the CCP doesn't want to shoulder
those costs what this ends up doing is
it makes it so the kid really is
expected to kind of not only carry the
weight of the whole family but carry the
whole weight of the country as they have
an aging population and so now that the
CCP has reached the kind of you know
breaking point of that whole system
they're dealing with this problem where
if people choose to not work the
workforce of the country essentially
breaks it's failing they don't have
enough people to work and really you
know 10 20 years what's going to happen
well the economy is going to fail
because people can't do it anymore and
that brings up a point again why this
lying flat movement is so serious if
those kids who are carrying the weight
of you know two or three generations
just give up what happens to the
system now look the article says here it
says that authorities have used all of
the tools at their disposal to steer The
Narrative back toward the official line
the CCP is trying everything it can to
stop this movement but there's only so
much they can do look what's most
interesting about this movement is that
in some ways it takes advantage of one
of the core principles of Communism
itself this is a contradiction within
the contradiction of communist thought
they're almost using an a loophole
really within basic communist ideology
to tear down the Communist system irony
on top of irony Carl Marx himself right
of course who wrote The Communist
Manifesto KL Mars had the Communist
concept of from each according to his
ability to each according to his need
and that concept is taken as kind of the
foundational idea of Communism right
everybody works some people are maybe
more privileged than others and so you
want to have Equity you take a little
more from the people who can achieve
more and you give it redistribute it to
the people who Maybe Can't achieve as
much right from each according to his
ability to each according to his need
but what happens when you get to the
late stages of Communism well what
happens is you know let's imagine like
you're China Chinese Communist party or
even the Soviets before you achieve
communism you have the revolution you
got it right then people choose instead
to reduce their abilities right from
each from each according to his ability
you reduce your ability and when you
reduce your ability you increase your
need because you don't want to work hard
and not get the benefits of the fruits
of your own labor and why do you want to
support people who just don't feel like
working what happens then what happens
when those who have abilities just
choose to not participate in the system
and they choose to join those who get
the free handouts without the hard work
that is how communism
dies now look this movement lying flat
it's also turning into social memes you
know in mimics right mimics mimics
essentially it's a concept they're not
not just funny pictures online right a
lot of us when we think memes we're
thinking funny graphics and jokes and
online things like that but memes are a
reference to mics and the concept of
mics is an idea that develops and
evolves over a course of time to then
impact the culture and so mdics
represent a type of cultural idea you
can't make them you can't just fabricate
a cultural idea they need to capture
something that people feel inside and
present that in such a way that people
can relate to it right that's the nature
of memes and
mimetics there's a mtic system now or a
cultural idea going around China that
takes this idea of lying flat and makes
it into kind of cultural phenomenon this
is something in other words that is
resonating with people at a deeper level
than just some kind of surface or
momentary idea you now have a new social
movement called being more Aven
happening in China where kids are
pretending to be Birds on the internet
this actually represents something
deeper I'll be talking about this only
on epct tv.com so if you're watching on
YouTube Facebook X Rumble there's a link
in the description below click on that
you'll get access to the rest of this
episode and also our whole library of
shows and our hard-hitting documentary
iies on issues that really matter like
the Chinese Communist party's 100-year
plan to defeat the United States the CCP
is one of the biggest threats to this
country you know they're using things
like propaganda video games
entertainment movies culture to subvert
and influence the Next Generation this
unrestricted war against our country is
one of the scariest but least understood
issues of our time because it's not
tangible it's being done through soft
power and ideological subversion now I
spent over a decade investigating the
ccp's subversion and it's such an
important issue that I made a
documentary called The Final War which
exposes this 100-year plot of the
Chinese Communist party to try to take
down America if you'd like to find out
more about the CCP is plotting against
America watch the final war you can find
the link to that in the description
below and I'll show you a trailer before
we go exclusively to epct tv.com for the
rest of this episode I'll see you there
the greatest threat facing the United
States is the CCP The Epic Times
investigation team had studied the CCP
for years but what we uncovered was
yielding evidence beyond our imagination
with chairman M with the Prime Minister
our talks have been characterized by
frankness the Clinton Administration
said oh don't worry about it this will
be a poison pill for China China's
strategic goal is to make sure that that
the US has four enemies and one of them
must be a terrorist group we are giving
of our life's blood so that the Chinese
Communist Party can survive and thrive