Why Are The Pyramids Located Where They Are? | Egypt Detectives

World Cultural History
11 followers
7 Video Views·Apr 20, 2025
The locations of the Egyptian pyramids, especially the famous ones like those in Giza (Pyramids of Kheops, Khephren and Mykerinos), were not random but were carefully chosen based on many factors: Near the capital Memphis (old); located on the west bank of the Nile; related to astronomical phenomena; favorable geology; related to strategy and vision.
5,000 years ago, the Egyptians invented something astonishing,
the pyramid.
For 100 years, the Egyptians continued to build more pyramids,
always very close to the first one.
Every one of these was a huge construction,
requiring thousands of workers and millions of tons of raw material.
And then suddenly, for no apparent reason,
they moved the whole operation north to a brand new site.
The pharaohs were not simply content to change site once.
Despite huge logistical problems,
they kept changing location in the Nile Valley.
Something very powerful was driving them
to ceaselessly choose new places to build pyramids.
But what was it?
To investigate this mystery,
Egyptologist Dominic Montserrat and archaeologist Miriam Cook
go on the trail of the wandering pyramids.
To trace hundreds of years of pyramid building,
the Egypt detectives have taken to their mobile headquarters,
letting the river take the strain of carrying them between the sites.
For the pharaohs building those monuments, however,
things were not so simple.
Each time a new location was chosen,
a whole city of laborers, stonemasons, architects, and surveyors
had to be moved, resettled, and supplied.
The whole extraordinary project had begun, logically enough,
close to the ancient capital, Memphis,
from where building work could easily be overseen.
But then, quite suddenly, that site was abandoned
in favor of a new location at Giza.
But even here, the pharaohs were not content,
and they moved again, and again, and yet again,
eventually ending up close to where the whole project had started,
at Saqqara.
For years, experts have argued
over whether it was purely practical considerations
or some deeper religious reason that drove the moves.
Why isn't there just one great pyramid field
where each pharaoh could rest, surrounded by his predecessors?
Archaeologists have not yet reached a consensus,
and the Egypt detectives are no exception.
This is the situation we have.
This is the pyramids at Saqqara, over the Nile,
and then the move up to Giza.
And we need to explain why.
These are religious monuments.
The Egyptians are incredibly particular about their sacred spaces,
so I wonder if there isn't some religious aspect of the Giza plateau
that influences the relocation.
Dominic's years of research suggest to him a religious explanation,
but Miriam is after archaeological evidence.
Was it significant that the first pyramid
built at the new northerly location
was the massive Great Pyramid?
Building the Great Pyramid was the most challenging engineering feat
that they'd ever attempted.
The puzzle must have something to do with that.
The move north must have solved engineering or structural problems.
What problems?
That's what we need to find out.
To discover what practical considerations
drove pharaohs to choose a pyramid site,
Miriam has decided to look more closely
at the construction and location of the earliest pyramid of all,
built around 2650 B.C. at Saqqara.
This was the first in what would soon become
an essential part of the pharaoh's burial rite.
Egyptians believed that the pharaoh was resurrected
as Osiris, king of the dead.
So to ensure his smooth transition into the afterlife,
great care was taken not only with mummifying his body,
but also with providing him with a suitable tomb
from which he could ascend to heaven.
This was the origin of the pyramids.
The Egyptians were great pragmatists.
Take this first pyramid right behind me here at Saqqara.
It's called the Step Pyramid,
and it looks very different to the other pyramids.
Its sides are stepped, not smooth.
And it's these very steps that tell a story.
Before this pyramid was built,
the elite of ancient Egypt were buried in flat-roofed tombs
called mastabas.
Look at this first step.
It's obviously the first thing to be built,
and the incredible thing is they could have stopped right here.
Without going any further,
they'd already created a low-lying, flat-roofed tomb
called a mastaba.
Until the Step Pyramid,
the kings had been very happy to be buried within these mastabas,
so the builders could have packed up their tools and gone home.
But they didn't.
They had an inspiration.
Why not build big and place more mastabas on top of the first?
And that's just what they did.
And then they built another, and then another, and then another,
and the result was the very first pyramid.
I think the evolution of all the pyramids
was the result of these practical what-if experiments.
The ancient Egyptians became increasingly ambitious,
testing the limits of their skills and their raw materials.
Dominic isn't easily convinced by the practical argument.
He's searching for a deeper, spiritual answer
among Egypt's ancient religious records.
Miriam, meanwhile, went in search of a concrete example
to prove her point.
Could she unearth practical reasons
why the pharaoh Khufu had first decided to move away from Saqqara
and build far to the north at Giza?
To find out, she has arranged to meet a leading Egyptian geologist,
Dr. Bahe Asawi,
to discover more about the ancient Egyptians' most essential raw material.
And limestone was used in building all of the pyramids.
What makes it such a perfect building material?
It's a very durable kind of rock,
and secondly, Egypt is very rich in limestone.
And thirdly, it has layering and jointing,
which help acquiring the types of limestone.
So the layers actually dictate the size of the blocks?
Yes, certainly, and you can see the layer.
This is the size, this is the maximum size.
The rocks can be cut from this layer.
So the pharaoh Khufu's grand plans
could have been limited by the size and availability
of the limestone blocks at Saqqara.
So when they wanted to build a bigger pyramid,
they were actually limited by the raw material here?
Yeah, and not only this, but also because of the space also.
You don't have quite a good space here to build bigger pyramids.
So they had to go to a different place?
Oh yeah, indeed they did.
After almost 100 years of pyramid building at Saqqara,
the new pharaoh Khufu found the site could not cope
with his ambition to build the greatest pyramid of all time.
So he moved his entire operation north to Giza.
Well, we're here at Giza.
What made this a better place to build?
If you look at the stones behind you,
you'll find that you have several layers of rocks.
And this limestone is a lot more easy to get out of?
Yes, the joints on both sides, and then the building planes,
then you can easily pull the rock from its original place.
So these are the finished blocks?
Yeah, that's how they do it, you see,
by chiselling along the joints by harder rocks.
And that's how they cut this into big pieces, of course,
depending on the joints and on the building planes.
And that's why they came here,
because it's bigger blocks than any other place in the area.
Dr. Desaoui's theory suggests
that it was the availability of larger stone blocks
and a greater expanse of flat ground
on which to build that persuaded Khufu
to abandon the burial site of his ancestors and move to Giza.
Practical reasons from a practical pharaoh.
Giza was the perfect place.
Plenty of limestone blocks to work with
and a solid base upon which to begin building
one of the wonders of the world, the Great Pyramid.
How do you account for the next pyramid?
They didn't build that here at Giza,
but miles away over there at Abu Ru'ash.
I don't see the problem with that.
There was plenty of good limestone up there as well.
Well, bear with me. We'll go on up to Abu Ru'ash
and I'll show you a more powerful reason than geology
for building pyramids up here in the north.
Simple geology might explain
why building moved from Saqqara to Giza.
But what Miriam can't explain
is why the next pharaoh then abandoned
this apparently perfect site and moved again.
Perhaps it's time to see if Dominic really can discover
more compelling answers deep in Egypt's ancient religion.
The Egypt detectives are trying to discover
why pharaohs built the pyramids where they did.
But competing theories mean tensions are rising.
Miriam Cook, an archaeologist,
is drawn towards a practical geological solution.
While Egyptologist Dominic Montserrat
believes the location of the pyramids
is the key to a greater mystery
whose solution lies in the religious beliefs
of the pharaohs themselves.
So why, after the Great Pyramid was built at Giza,
did the next pharaoh, Jadafre,
move the building operation yet again to Abu Ru'ash?
I'm here at Abu Ru'ash
and I'm standing on the pyramid,
but it doesn't look very finished to me.
That's right, it probably never was finished.
It's always seemed like an odd thing to do
to come all the way up here to build
if there's all that marvellous building stone
on the Giza plateau.
I just don't find the geological argument
accounts for everything.
Well, how would you explain it then, Dominic?
Well, if we'd been standing up here
4,500 years ago,
we'd have been able to see Heliopolis,
and I think that's a really important clue.
And why's that?
Well, if you buy me a cup of coffee,
I might just tell you.
OK, you're on.
Heliopolis,
the centre of sun worship in ancient Egypt
and the city at the heart of the pharaoh's beliefs.
A city now lost in suburban sprawl.
But what has this to do with pyramids?
Well, I've got your coffee here,
but first I want you to explain
why you think Heliopolis is so important
for the move to Abu Ru'ash and Giza.
If you look at the names of the pharaohs
who built at Giza and Abu Ru'ash,
you see something really interesting.
Because, first of all, you've got
Jeddah Frey at Abu Ru'ash,
and then Caia Frey, Kefren.
And Menkaure, who built the third pyramid at Giza.
Menkaure, exactly.
And what have these three pharaohs all got in common?
Re in their names.
The sun god Re was clearly central
to the beliefs of these pharaohs,
so much so that they even adopted his name.
For them, he was the god who sailed across the sky
in his solar boat by day
and across the underworld of the dead by night.
When they died, these kings also believed
they would join him on this journey.
A journey that would begin
when their bodies were laid to rest
in their immortal monument, their pyramid.
Well, Heliopolis was the city of the sun, wasn't it?
They must have been worshippers of his cult
because they all chose names which honoured him.
Well, you can have your coffee now.
Oh, thank you.
But we still know so little about Heliopolis.
Well, that's right.
It's just a suburb of modern Cairo now.
Might be worth checking out.
The site of Heliopolis today
has been overwhelmed by the suburbs of Cairo.
But do any clues survive
to link these sun pharaohs with their sun city?
And can these provide a solution
more compelling than Miriam's?
Get a good view from up here.
Miriam has arranged to meet Dr. David Jeffreys,
a veteran archaeologist
who spent years trying to unravel
the secrets of the lost city of Heliopolis
and its connections to the cult of sun worship.
David takes Miriam to a place
right in the centre of what was the ancient city
where they can get a bird's-eye view of the area.
You OK?
Right.
Well, it's definitely worth the climb.
We've got a wonderful view from up here.
We're looking over the town and temple area of Heliopolis.
At first, the view from the minaret
made Heliopolis seem even more mysterious.
One of the greatest religious complexes of ancient Egypt,
engulfed by urban sprawl and smothered with haze.
But in the mist, there is a clue.
An obelisk built many years after the pyramids
but linked to the days of the pyramid builders.
Archaeologists have discovered
that it marks the original site
of a massive, long-lost sun temple
devoted to the worship of the sun god, Ray.
After years of research,
David Jeffreys has put together a theory
to explain why pyramid building sites were changed.
Right, well, here's the obelisk.
In order to be comfortable,
shall we just go over to the shade?
That's a good idea.
Right, well, we're standing here in Sun City.
We need to find a spot out of the sun at least.
Let's talk about it here.
So if you've got a huge sun temple
and pharaohs who are building pyramids
who are associated with the sun cult,
what's the link?
Well, it's interesting because
the whole question of distribution of pyramids
is not really well understood.
They seem to skip about in an almost random way.
But one thing that is significant
is that when the sun cult becomes important
to the royal family,
they move to Giza and then to Abyr-Rawash.
And really, that's when the connection
with the sun cult becomes really clear.
Raj Edeth, who is the first one
to have Ra, the sun, Ray, the sun,
in his name and to call himself
the son of the sun,
he builds at Abyr-Rawash,
which is the most clearly visible
from where we are at Heliopolis.
And then all the Giza pyramids
are in a direct line of sight with Heliopolis.
Four and a half thousand years ago,
the pharaohs would have been able
to see the sun temple here at Heliopolis
from their pyramids at Giza and Abyr-Rawash.
David Jeffreys believes that this view
from tomb to temple
was central to their religion.
But not everywhere across the Nile
had such a clear view.
On the outskirts of Cairo
stands an escarpment known as the Citadel Rock.
This would have blocked the view
of the sun temple at Heliopolis
from many locations across the river.
So perhaps the pharaohs
that followed the sun cult
were choosing the location of their tombs
in order to ensure that they did
have a view of Heliopolis.
So it's all about lines of sight.
It could well be, yes.
For the followers of the sun cult,
so the theory goes,
seeing really was believing.
As the pharaohs became more obsessed
with worshipping the sun,
they had to choose pyramid sites
which would guarantee a good view
of the centre of Heliopolis.
So the pharaoh Jeffreys
had built his pyramid at Abyr-Rawash
to ensure he had a clear view
of the temple of his favoured god, Ray.
The next pharaoh, Cai of Ray,
went back to Giza
as did his successor, Menkaure.
But both chose sites
where they still had a clear line of sight
with Heliopolis.
But the map also shows
a weak link in this theory.
I think that there's a problem
with this lines of sight theory
of David Jeffreys.
The next three pharaohs built their pyramids
back near Saqqara
at this place called Abu Sir.
And they were still worshipping the sun god, Ray.
But the problem is
that the line of sight between Abu Sir
and the sun temple at Heliopolis
is blocked by the citadel rock.
So, is David Jeffreys wrong?
Why did the pyramid builders
at Abu Sir choose a site
with no clear view of this vital temple?
Miriam decides
to invite him to Abu Sir
to see if he had an explanation.
But he suggests
they actually meet
just a few miles north-east
of the pyramid site
among the ruins of another extraordinary building.
And where we're standing
is the key site.
We're actually on top of the sun temple now.
We only know of two of them as it is.
We're standing on the actual tower
of the sun temple.
So what's that structure down there for?
Right, well, rather like a pyramid,
the sun temple is surrounded
by its own temple complex.
And what we're looking at
is really a unique structure.
We don't have anything quite like it
from anywhere else in Egypt.
And it's an altar of what is sometimes called
Egyptian alabaster or travertine,
consisting of four segments
that are actually a hieroglyphic sign.
It's the offering table
with a loaf of bread on it,
which is the sign for hetep,
which means to be satisfied
or to make offerings.
With its rows of pens for hundreds of sacrificial animals
and huge basins for collecting their blood,
it is a very substantial
and hence important structure.
And most significantly of all,
from its top,
there is a clear line of sight
to the pyramids at Abu Sir.
But this wasn't the central sun temple
at Heliopolis
that previous pharaohs had gone to such lengths
to be in sight of.
So Miriam still needs an answer.
Even when the kings are building
at Abu Sir,
the point really
is this question of visibility
from the centre of the sun cult itself
at Heliopolis.
The Abu Sir pyramids are out of sight
from Heliopolis.
In building back
near their capital at Memphis,
these pharaohs had seemingly sacrificed
that all-important view,
a view previous rulers had gone to
huge lengths to protect.
Just to the south of Heliopolis,
south of Cairo,
you've got this promontory
that sticks out from the main cliff line
where the Islamic
citadel was built.
We call it the Citadel Rock.
And that interrupts the line of sight
between Heliopolis
and the Abu Sir pyramids,
even though the Abu Sir pyramids
are sun kings,
but their pyramids are back
near, close to Memphis
and they cannot be seen
from the centre of the sun cult.
But the sun temple can.
The pyramids at Abu Sir
would have had a view of this,
their own sun temple,
which itself then had a direct line of sight
to Heliopolis.
What David is suggesting
was that this temple created
a visual link, a relay
between the Abu Sir pyramids
and Heliopolis.
It is an ingenious solution to the pharaohs'
problem of building near their physical
capital of Memphis, but also
maintaining their connection with their
spiritual home at Heliopolis.
A uniquely Egyptian
answer to reconciling the physical
problems of pyramid building
with the spiritual demands of the gods.
This was the truth behind
the riddle of the pyramids.
Egyptian kings
chose their burial places
with an eye to the gods,
but also with concern for the massive
logistical effort involved in building
these legendary structures.
Building a pyramid
could be a lifetime's work
for thousands of people,
from stonecutters to priests.
But in undertaking
such colossal enterprises,
everyone knew they had to balance the
physical needs of the construction
with the spiritual requirements of the pharaoh.
Together,
these, in the form of the pyramid,
ensured Egypt would itself
remain a wonder of the world.
It's time
for the Egypt detectives to compare notes
and see whose theory is right.
Well, I must admit, I did think that the
whole pyramid building business was to do
with geology and building blocks,
but David has convinced me that there's more to it.
I had a feeling it wasn't as straightforward
as your geological argument.
Yeah, but don't forget that the first move to Giza
was about limestone and space, and not suncoats.
Fair enough. So we're both right.
Yep. Chin chin.
