Mark Carney, Canada’s 24th Prime Minister and leader of the Liberal Party, joins Scott to discuss the country’s economic outlook, how Canada fits into a shifting global order, and whether the U.S.-Canada relationship can be repaired amid rising trade tensions.
Follow Mark Carney, @MarkJCarney.
00:00 - In this episode 00:55 - What's your origin story? 03:06 - What role does Canada play on the global stage? 04:45 - What challenges in Canada are you most focused on right now? 07:16 - What’s the latest on U.S.-Canada tariffs? 10:36 - Is Canada moving away from relying on the U.S.? 12:57 - How do other nations feel about Trump’s tariffs? 16:47 - Haven’t the U.S. and Canada mostly had free trade until now? 18:19 - Are there any parallels between Brexit and Trump’s trade moves? 23:40 - Trump says other countries have taken advantage of the U.S. in trade. What do you say to that? 25:48 - How do you see this trade war playing out? 30:02 - Can we repair the U.S.-Canada relationship? 33:32 - What changes should the U.S. make?What are Canada’s biggest economic problems? 37:33 - How is your housing plan different from past ones? 41:37 - What are your plans for climate and energy? 44:40 - Advice for your 25-year-old self? 44:57 - Who's someone you've lost and what would you say to them? 45:11 - What does success look like to you?
Is that the sense you get, that nations are lining up to cut a deal with us right now?
There's a risk premium in U.S. assets that wasn't there before.
And the question is, how big is that risk premium going to settle?
Where is it going to settle?
And that, in part, is going to depend on how coherent the new system is.
Does the U.S. credibly commit to a new system or a series of deals?
I do believe that there are a series of like-minded countries.
We very much like the U.S. to be part of that group, but like-minded countries
who will develop deeper trading and security relationships as a consequence of this.
It's the world of second best.
It's not what we would all want, but it's the logical thing to do.
Prime Minister, where does this podcast find you?
I'm in Montreal right now, Professor.
The majority of the world spends their news is 10 minutes domestic and 20 minutes international.
The U.S. we're kind of self-absorbed, narcissistic.
We don't talk a lot about other countries.
I think most people have heard of you, have seen you on TV, but don't know much about you.
Can you give us sort of your backstory, your origin story?
Sure.
So I was born in the Arctic, the north of Canada, a place called Fort Smith, Northwest Territories.
I grew up in Edmonton, and those who might follow hockey was the days of Wayne Gretzky
when he was playing for the Oilers.
That was when I was a kid.
I went away to university in the U.S., and then I worked on Wall Street or versions of
Wall Street.
I worked for Goldman Sachs in London and Tokyo and New York and ultimately Canada.
And then I went in about 20 years ago to become the deputy governor of the Bank of Canada,
which is the equivalent of the Federal Reserve in the U.S., and ended up being the governor
during the financial crisis of 2008.
So worked with, you know, through that process of the financial crisis, we had a
quote, good financial crisis.
If you can have a good financial crisis in Canada, we got through it better than anyone
else, emerged stronger, our banks stayed together.
And then ultimately, I kind of slightly bizarrely, I was asked to become governor of the Bank
of England.
So I became the first foreigner's governor of the Bank of England.
And I did that through the period of the Brexit referendum, as it turned out, and the aftermath
of that, and then came back Canada 2020, right in the middle of COVID.
I think you probably had a better experience during COVID if I listened to your podcast,
if I read it correctly than I did.
And then I worked, I did a lot of work on climate change for the United Nations, sort
of pro bono, and organizing the financial sector to help address climate change.
But also at the same time, I worked for Brookfield, which is a big asset manager.
And I was chair of Bloomberg.
And then as of the start of January, I first ran for the leadership of the Liberal Party,
which is one of the main parties here.
And winning that, I became prime minister about a month ago.
And now I'm running for election.
We have much, last point, much shorter elections than the United States.
Our campaign is 37 days, and we've got two weeks roughly left to go.
So a big friend of the pod is Ian Brenner, the geopolitical strategist.
And he was on the pod last week, and he described you as a, open quote,
generational mind for Canada on the global stage, close quote.
In your view, what role does Canada play on the global stage?
So we play, I mean, we play several roles.
We're a member of the G7.
In fact, we are chair of the G7 this year.
So I'm chair of the G7.
We're a member of the Commonwealth, which is the old UK grouping.
We're a member of the Francophonie, which is the, obviously, the Francophone grouping
of about 60 countries.
So we have our role in several different, let's call it organizations,
self-appointed organizations or groupings.
I think one of the roles we play potentially in the new or the emerging global order
is partly based on our assets.
We are an energy, an emerging energy superpower in all forms of energy.
We're one of the largest critical mineral suppliers in the world.
We're pretty good in AI.
A lot of people claim that, but we're, I think, legitimately claiming that.
And so we can play a role as a country that believes in open markets, open systems,
believes in trade, open ideas, diversity.
We can play a role with like-minded countries to kind of reconstruct that bit of the
international order, which has been, I'm in Montreal, they would say bouleversée.
It's been upended in the course of, more intensively in the last few months,
but a process that really began with the financial crisis 15 years ago.
And just for our listeners, the elephant in the room is tariffs,
so I'm going to get to that.
But I want to start with, if you were to, so typically in the US,
and I imagine the same way in Canada, when a new leader is elected,
assuming you get elected, they have sort of a honeymoon period
and an opportunity to get more done in their first year,
more grace, if you will, than in the next two or three years.
What would you identify as the two or three biggest issues facing Canada?
And what's your agenda?
If you could pick two or three things you're really going to go hard at
your first year as prime minister, what are those things?
As you just suggested, I'll set tariffs aside and focus in on three things.
First is having free trade actually within Canada.
We have basically 13 economies here, 10 different provinces and territories,
all with their own rules.
It's hard to move credentials and sometimes goods and services across the country,
far harder than it should be.
So a process, a very quick process of free trade.
And by the way, just to put orders of magnitude on this,
you know, a reasonable estimate of the economic benefit of that
is bigger than the economic hit from the worst version of the Trump tariffs.
So we can kind of give ourselves more than others can.
Second thing is we have a huge housing problem here.
And particularly obviously for younger Canadians, first and foremost,
we need to double the rate of housing and we need to,
I won't go into all the details, I'm happy to,
but we need some major reforms in order to do that.
We can do it in a way that actually leverages, you know,
the Canadian supply chain technology and all the lumber
we potentially won't be able to send southbound to the US.
And then the third thing, look, the world's fluid.
I'm afraid this kind of comes towards tariffs,
but I think the trading system is going to get reordered fairly quickly.
And so in the course of the first year, the question is,
well, who are we going to deepen our relationships with
other than the United States?
And those relationships, last point, are both economic and security.
The world's a much more dangerous and divided place.
Security concerns are top of the list.
So who in Europe or European Union as a whole, UK, who in Asia,
where are we going to partnership?
If I can say one last thing, Scott, is, you know,
just being shaken so hard by what's happening in the United States,
Canadians are very open to all of those priorities.
Like people are up for big things.
They're coming together and they're willing to do big things
because they know they have to do big things
because the world's changed so much.
Well, let's use that as a segue into tariffs.
So I haven't checked my Apple watch in the last two minutes,
so I don't know the state of things right now.
My understanding, Canada's our largest trading partner.
Now, we tend to be obsessed with China,
but you're our largest trading partner, no?
We're your most important, yeah.
Yeah. So give us the state of play.
You're the man representing our largest trading partner economically.
As to the best of your knowledge, describe the state of play
between what is happening between the U.S. and Canada.
Where does it sit at this moment?
So I'll start with the bad news or the,
as we would call the unjustified news,
which is what tariffs are in place.
We have still in place today,
tariffs that were originally justified because of fentanyl.
Fentanyl coming across the border from Canada.
Just for the listeners who haven't tracked this,
less than 1% of the fentanyl imported into the United States comes from Canada.
In fact, you've got a sophisticated audience,
so I can say things like 19 basis points of the fentanyl
comes across the border from Canada.
We've taken major steps to reinforce the border,
drones, helicopters, other things,
and it's fallen by a further 90% over the course of the last three months.
But those tariffs hit a wide range of goods in Canada,
hit a wide range of goods.
And there's a few carve-outs for that,
but it's hitting hundreds of billions of good.
And those are 25% tariffs from the United States.
Then we are also caught, secondly,
we're also caught in the steel and aluminum tariffs,
which are this quote, national security tariffs,
so-called 232 tariffs.
We are the largest supplier of aluminum in the United States.
We're one of the most important suppliers of steel to the United States,
and you can roll those up into hundreds of thousands of jobs in the U.S.
depending on Canadian steel and aluminum.
And then the third thing is we are caught in the auto tariffs.
As people probably know, but I'll just personalize it.
Well, they wouldn't know this fact.
There was something called the AutoPAC,
which was signed the year I was born, 60 years ago.
And we have had an increasingly integrated auto system
with the United States for 60 years.
It got tighter with the Canada-U.S. free trade agreement 40 years ago,
and then with NAFTA and the successor.
So literally, these companies and the supply chains,
the main parts suppliers, they're virtually fully integrated.
And now into the middle of this is coming 25% U.S. tariffs,
which are in an industry, as you know, that has 5%, 7% margins.
I mean, this is absolutely damaging.
So we have three sets of tariffs.
We are not subject yet to the so-called reciprocal tariffs of the U.S.
So the state of the relationship is strained, to say the least,
because all of these tariffs are in violation of what you call USMCA,
we call CUSMA, the same trade agreement.
The good news, or the better news,
is that three weeks ago or so, President Trump and I spoke,
and we agreed that following the Canadian election,
there would be the beginning of a negotiation
of a comprehensive, a new comprehensive relationship, economic security.
So we are in the queue, so to speak, for those discussions.
It strikes me that these actions are about to inspire what they envision,
that it's a tremendous amount of deal-making,
but deal-making around us, that it just seems logical.
That's a thesis, and I want you to validate or nullify it.
But if I'm a G7 nation, and I have a trading partner
that I used to be able to count on, that was mutually very prosperous,
and now I just not only can't count on them,
but have no idea who I'm waking up next to,
that it's incredible motivation to start establishing dialogue with other nations.
Respond to that thesis.
Is Canada aggressively and actively trying to reroute around America right now?
Well, I would say, you know, trade is a world of and.
So, you know, it's a positive-sum game, as you know.
You do it right, both sides win.
It's not a zero-sum game.
So I might not choose the phrase around America,
but obviously, you know, look, if we've got excess capacity,
or we have things we're going to develop,
I'll use the example of critical minerals, where we're a big player.
With whom are we going to trade?
Who can we rely on?
You know, we're sitting here,
we supply 70% of the potash to the United States,
you know, one of the most important components of fertilizer, 70%.
And there is a 25% tariff being put on potash.
So when you think about it,
well, geez, maybe I might want to take another,
I'll call it a commodity,
even though critical metals and minerals are more than that.
If we're going to develop those,
maybe we want to develop them with a supply chain
to someone who's not going to slap a tariff like that on.
So that invalidating your thesis,
yeah, we have begun to intensify discussions with other countries,
other trading blocks.
We have a pretty good set of trade deals in place.
We have a free trade deal with Europe.
We're part of what was called
the Trans-Pacific Partnership in Asia.
So we have a number of those,
but we're looking to reinforce them.
And look, we are hopeful,
maybe hopeful isn't the right word,
but we're open to, open is a better way to put it,
to a restart of the U.S. trading relationship,
provided there's willingness on the other side,
and we can come to one of those positive-sum deals.
So I would imagine you speak to a lot of other G7 leaders or G20 leaders.
What's the general consensus around American leadership right now?
And I realize that you have more restraint
and are a bit more, or tangibly more diplomatic,
but what is the thesis among this group of world leaders
around what is going on here?
How do they explain it?
How do you explain it to each other?
Or can you explain it to each other?
Because quite frankly, here in the U.S.,
a lot of this doesn't even make sense to us,
and this is our leadership.
Well, I think the first thing is to recognize,
as I have said, and a number of those other leaders have said,
including G7 leaders,
is that the system as we knew it is over, right?
When the anchor of the system is fundamental,
has done a series of measures that the U.S. has done,
but also set out a series of objectives,
and I'll come back to that,
but a set of a series of objectives
that are just inconsistent with the way
the system has been operating for decades, right?
Basically, since the fall of the Berlin Wall,
intensified since then.
So you recognize that that system anchored on the U.S. is over,
that then leads to how do you react to it?
There's partly the negotiation with the U.S.
in which you've been focused on,
but then it's also how do we deal with each other,
which we've also touched on.
In terms of what the U.S. is trying to accomplish,
I think it's, you know,
I take, go back to Peter Thiel of 10 years ago,
saying take Donald Trump literally and seriously,
but take him literally and seriously.
And, you know, they're looking to balance,
to the extent possible, to balance trade,
which is not the way we think about things,
but is the way the U.S. thinks about things.
And, you know, you do get into odd situations like Canada,
where we actually run it.
America has a trade surplus with Canada in goods.
The only reason there's an overall deficit with Canada
is because of basically oil imports.
Well, if you don't want our oil imports,
that will be a bit of a problem for a period of time,
because, you know,
the only other option for the refineries
that take Canadian oil is Venezuela.
And that's, you know,
they've just banned those imports as well.
So it's not, the logic isn't entirely consistent,
let's put it that way.
But I think at the core,
recognizing this desire for more balanced trade.
And so from the U.S. administration,
question I think in our mind is,
there are some industries, autos particularly,
aerospace would have another element of this,
and then a number of commodity.
And there are a couple of industries
that are so integrated
that it's hard to see why for U.S. competitiveness,
let alone North American competitiveness,
it makes sense to pull them apart.
That would be our argument.
And then there's other industries,
forest products, steel, aluminum,
as three big examples where we're,
agriculture, potash, I gave that example,
nickel, I could go on,
where we're such huge suppliers
and such a safe, secure supplier.
Again, it doesn't really to us make sense
that that would be displaced or tariffed.
So, you know, we've seen that this,
the trade policy is evolving
as some of these choke points
become more evident.
And, you know, I suspect we will see more.
Maybe I'll say one other thing if I could,
which is, it strikes me a bit
in the consistencies of U.S. policy
is a desire to have some minimum tariff if possible,
which has a revenue raising element to it.
And I think, you know, tied into U.S. tax policy,
that is also a possibility here.
My understanding is about 99% of our trade is tariff-free
and that 1% is around things like dairy.
Haven't we largely been kind of a trade-free zone
between Canada and the U.S. today?
Yeah, yeah, we have.
And then we have, you know,
like any trading partners,
you get the odd trade irritant and,
you know, trade dispute,
but we have processes to deal with those.
And so we had, you know,
we have ongoing things around forest products,
sometimes steel and aluminum,
and, you know, that's handled.
But yeah, trade is basically tariff-free.
And, you know, when it's your biggest trading partner,
pulling that apart is quite costly.
It's costly for both, you know,
from a Canadian perspective,
and, you know, I'm out on the road,
I'm running for office,
I'm talking to lots of Canadians up and down.
There is a very strong sense of,
yeah, this is going to cost us,
but we're willing to take the price
to restructure our economy in a different direction.
Like, it's been such a sense of,
I mean, the word that's used is betrayal.
So, you know, we signed a deal,
we've had this partnership,
we observe it in good faith,
we set up businesses,
we, you know, we know lots of Americans,
we like Americans, we listen to American podcasts,
you know, there's such a thing.
And all of a sudden, you know,
we get these, you know, these attacks,
which is the way this is viewed,
is okay, so it's going to cost us
for a period of time,
and we'll build out and build with others.
We'll be right back after a quick break.
You were the first non-Brit
to serve to run the Bank of England.
You're sort of the Bo Jackson
of global economic leadership.
I've compared this,
and it might be a crude analogy,
but I want you to add some color,
fill in the blanks here.
I've described these tariffs
as the biggest own goal since Brexit.
What similarities do you see,
and how does that inform,
A, how you respond to this,
and B, what you think ultimately the outcome is?
Well, I think there are a lot of similarities,
and it starts with the economics
of what's happening.
Actually, briefly describe Brexit,
because just give us the headline news on Brexit.
So the headline on Brexit
is for a variety of reasons,
and many of them not to do with economics,
although it was sold as an economic,
you know, win.
But a lot of people, you know,
because of reasons of identity and others,
voted in 2018,
if I get my dates right,
2016, I guess.
No, for the UK to leave the European Union.
And the UK was even more tightly bound
in trade and economic relationships
with the European Union
than Canada is with the United States,
including free movement of labor,
easy movement of the capital,
huge trade going both ways.
And you never had to get your product,
if your product met the product standard in the UK,
didn't have to worry about
you could sell to any country in Europe.
And so the decision taken, as I say,
for a variety of reasons,
narrowly, but taken to leave the European Union.
And I remember when it happened,
and our view at the time,
and remember, this was during a period
where it was interest rates were at rock bottom,
inflation was too low,
people were worried about deflation, blah, blah.
Our view was, okay, what's going to happen
is the economy is going to slow,
unemployment is going to go up,
inflation is going to go up,
and we at the Bank of England
are going to have to raise interest rates
when this happens.
And by the way, the currency will also go down.
The currency went down by 20, 25%.
It's still on the floor relative to where it was,
still on the floor
because you had a big negative trade shock,
a big loss of wealth, basically,
future wealth in the currency market priced at first.
And exactly what we expected to happen, happened.
I mean, it happened to happen
roughly at the same time as COVID was finishing,
but you had a big,
again, I'm relying on your audience,
a big negative supply shock to the economy
because you ripped up trading relationships
and the productive capacity went down
relative to where demand was.
So that was inflationary.
And combination of that meant UK rates are higher
and it's got a bigger inflation problem
it has had than other economies.
When you look at what's happening in the US,
the friction put into its trading relationships
is going to cause the same thing.
It is going to slow the rate of growth of that economy.
It is going to affect the dollar.
It has affected the dollar negatively, as we've seen.
It's going to push up prices on the margin.
And so slower economy, higher inflation,
higher interest rates, all things being equal.
Now, there's a big caveat with what I did,
or there's a qualifier is a better way to put it.
The UK was a much more open economy,
much more dependent on Europe.
The US is more of a closed economy.
It depends on the world,
but it's different orders of magnitude.
So it's same direction, different orders of magnitude.
So I think there are a lot of parallels here.
And I guess maybe the other parallel,
if I can add one more, which remains to be seen,
but the UK, I would say,
and I'll get hate mail from UK, some UK listeners,
but I would say based on the polling,
it's pretty well understood that the economic impact
of Brexit has been negative in the UK.
Let's say two thirds of the people now understand that.
But the path back to being closer to Europe
is very difficult politically.
It's hard to rebuild that consensus.
They move very slowly.
And you think about the situation in the world right now
for the UK, boy, there's a lot of logic
being closer to Europe.
From a trade perspective,
and even from a security perspective,
they built this sort of what's called
a coalition of the willing with respect to Ukraine,
because the UK, the US is pulling back
from support for Ukraine.
By the way, Canada has stepped up
and is part of that largely European coalition
of the willing alongside Australia.
So there's a logic to going back to that,
but it's hard to go back
once you've broken up these relationships.
And so the next six, 12 months, in my judgment,
are gonna be quite important for the United States
and for the global trading system,
because the question is,
okay, we understand that there is a big change,
a big break with the old system,
but how much of a break is it going to be?
And is there going to be
a relatively open trading system for,
I'm using quotations here for those listening,
like-minded countries,
broadly like-minded countries?
You know, I think of the G7
as being pretty like-minded countries,
not surprisingly.
You know, we value liberty, free speech,
open markets in general.
So are we gonna have a relatively open system
amongst ourselves,
or is it only gonna be with a few countries,
or is it going to be with no countries?
That's kind of what to play for here.
But the system won't,
it won't revert to what it was previously.
When we're talking about these tariffs,
there's a general sense that,
or Alyssa, a talk track from the Trump administration
that the U.S. has been taken advantage of
by its trading partners, including Canada,
that they've just got the better end of the deal,
and that tariffs will help restore
some sort of parity or equity in the relationship.
Respond to that.
Well, I mean, we don't,
obviously, we don't see it.
We don't see it in the following respects,
because really, again,
the way the Trump administration is defined
being, quote, taken advantage of is,
do you run a trade deficit?
And we can argue about that definition.
I wouldn't, if I lead on my economic training
and my experience, I would say,
well, that isn't being taken advantage of.
It's mutual exchange.
But the U.S. runs a surplus with us.
The U.S. sells more to us.
If anyone's being taken advantage of,
we're being taken advantage of, right?
Because, I mean, by that definition.
And the only place where they run a deficit is,
yes, we do ship oil to the United States.
Now, we happen to ship oil to the United States
at a big discount to global prices.
So we're being taken advantage of,
again, on that definition,
on the goods trade side.
And we're getting taken advantage
because we're selling oil at below good prices.
So we want our money back.
No, we don't.
Where we still see the broader benefits
of the relationship.
And, you know, I don't think that,
I'll go back to the auto sector.
It's not going to feel taken advantage of,
as if these tariffs stay in place.
And, you know, as you say,
you got to check your phone every once in a while,
just to see where things stand.
There's a possible exemption on the auto parts side
that's coming in in the United States,
which we would have said, right,
well, we did say right from the start,
would have to happen because the whole system
will grind to a halt without it.
So some of the mutual advantages
will become more, are becoming more apparent.
And hopefully the U.S. administration
can continue to be nimble.
– My understanding is that you ship us cheap energy
or cheap oil.
You're obviously a very resource-abundant nation.
We apply our IP and refining capability,
and then we sell it at three times the cost.
It sounds like it's been pretty mutually beneficial.
– Yeah, no, that's absolutely right.
– How do you see this playing out?
If you were tempted to speculate
what the relationship is around global trade and tariffs
on a macro level,
and then specifically with Canada and the U.S.,
when you try to plan an economy
similar to the way the CEO tries to plan a business,
what are you expecting?
You have to do scenario planning.
Nobody knows.
But what do you think are the most likely scenarios
for how this plays out?
Because I mean this, and seriously, Prime Minister,
we're all befuddled by this.
The majority of people who understand economics
are having a difficult time seeing
how this is a big win for the U.S.
We're just, we're having a difficult time
understanding how we win here.
Maybe more people come to the,
they claim there's 75 nations lining up
to cut deals with them.
Is that the sense you get?
That nations are lining up
to cut a deal with us right now?
– Well, short answer, I don't know.
I don't know, is on that second question.
There's a few things that happen here.
One is that there's a risk premium in U.S. assets
that wasn't there before.
And the question is,
how big is that risk premium going to set?
Where is it going to settle?
And that, in part, is going to depend on
how coherent the new system is.
And is there, does the U.S. credibly commit
to a new system or a series of deals?
Remember, we have a trading deal with the U.S.
that was signed by the current president,
which isn't being observed.
So I think that's one thing,
is there's a risk premium on U.S. assets.
And if there's a risk premium on U.S. assets,
then the cost of all other assets around the world
is greater, right?
Like since we're still priced off of U.S. treasuries,
for example.
So that's one thing.
I think second is,
I do believe that there are a series
of like-minded countries.
We very much like the U.S. to be part of that group,
but like-minded countries who will develop
deeper trading and security relationships
as a consequence of this.
It's the world of second best.
It's not what we would all want,
but it's the logical thing to do.
Third thing that's going to happen is that
there is going to be much greater focus,
and I know this for a fact,
well, this will be a fact
if my party is successful in the elections,
a much greater focus on domestic drivers of demand.
So building at home, building big infrastructure,
building millions of houses,
building out our own economies,
more domestic procurement, right?
In a world where we've got excess steel
and aluminum capacity,
which we will if the U.S. doesn't change on trade.
Well, guess who's steel and aluminum
we're going to buy for a variety of things?
Guess what defense procurement we're going to do?
Right now, we spend about 75% of our defense dollars
go to the United States.
That doesn't make a lot of sense
if we settle out in a more arms-length relationship
with the U.S.
And that's true, if it's true for us,
it's true for Europe,
it's true for the U.K.
And so we'll all move more domestic
and more with each other
and the degree to which that happens.
So this is a world, just to be clear,
and I think you intuitively understand
what you get this from the start.
We've got a world where we have higher risk premia, right?
Cost of capital is more expensive.
And we've got a world where people
are doing second best things.
Countries are doing second best things.
So it's a world that's more expensive
and it's more, it's not autarkic,
to use a fancy word,
like it's not totally in and of yourself,
but it's, you're putting a much greater emphasis
on taking care of yourself.
We'll do that and we'll do it with like-minded countries
and move forward.
The surveys I've read said that two-thirds of Americans
still think of Canada as an ally.
We're sort of like, oh, you know, Trump,
let boys be boys, we still love Canadians.
But two-thirds plus of Canadians
no longer see the U.S. as an ally.
I mean, quite frankly,
it feels like Canadians are just pissed off
that they feel the term used was betrayed
and that even if we're able to establish,
go back to normal,
hasn't the knife, you know,
isn't it the knife gets pulled halfway out of the back
but this injury takes years or decades to fail?
I mean, what is the vibe, if you will,
around how Canadians feel about Americans
and how long do you think it gets,
it takes us to repair this relationship?
I certainly recognize those figures.
There is a feeling here that it's the actions of the U.S.,
there's several things.
One is the trade actions.
Secondly was this long period,
and I'm not going to repeat the phrases that were used,
but these threats to our sovereignty,
our very sovereignty,
which, you know, kind of unique.
There's us in Denmark who suffered
actual threats to sovereignty.
Panama, we roll ourselves in with that.
And that's, you know, on your hierarchy of betrayals,
threatening somebody else's sovereignty,
it's pretty much the top.
I guess the top is acting on that threat.
So that's all mixed in.
I think secondly, what has been striking
has been the relatively muted response
in the broader U.S. to these steps, right?
You know, the CEO class, if I can put it that way,
the other major influencers, stakeholders,
that's changing a bit,
but it was pretty quiet for a long period of time.
So, you know, and when you look at that
from this side of the border, you think,
oh, okay, well, this is more deeply held
or the friendship is less firmly rooted.
It's like any relationship.
I think if it's when you have a loss of trust,
you know, it can be repaired to a degree.
It takes a period of time
and it takes action to repair, right?
But, you know, it's more than fine words.
I think that that action can start with,
in May, the Prime Minister of Canada
at that point will meet with President Trump.
I want to be the Prime Minister of Canada at that point.
I'm working hard to get there,
and they'll sit down and start a process
of redefining that relationship
and building trust out from that.
We'll be right back.
Support for Prop G comes from HubSpot.
HubSpot is taking on the fundamental myth
in business software that you need dozens
of different tools to succeed.
You don't.
You only need one that actually works.
With HubSpot's powerful AI solution, Breeze,
built right into their customer platform,
you have everything you need all in one place.
Breeze Copilot acts like a digital wingman
that keeps you two steps ahead,
while Breeze Agents take entire work streams
off your plate.
That's not AI vaporware, that's leverage.
We're talking about real ROI,
cutting sales cycles in half,
resolving service tickets faster,
and working less hours every week
to make it all happen.
Go to hubspot.com slash AI to get started today.
We're back with more from Prime Minister Carney.
So just as a means of not,
or taking advantage of the fact
that we have you on this podcast,
we have real problems in the U.S.
around income inequality.
For the first time in our nation's history,
a 30-year-old isn't doing as well
as her parents was at 30.
Tremendous polarization politically.
People just don't like each other.
I mean, I would argue that comparatively,
the nation's actually done quite well,
but what ails us,
the call is coming from inside of the house.
We don't like each other within America.
You're asked to be a journeyman
and come be treasury secretary
or head of the Fed.
What policy plans do you think
the U.S. should adopt?
And then I want to use that
as a jumping off point
to what are the biggest economic challenges
that Canada faces
and how you plan to address them.
Well, I think the, okay,
you go to the heart of,
I mean, that's a big, big question.
I guess the way I look at it is follows.
I mean, I'm going to come at this
from an odd angle maybe,
but when I look at what's going to drive
economic prosperity,
productivity growth
for the next 25 years,
what are the big drivers of that?
I put down three big drivers.
AI, no insight.
I put at the top of the list,
probably the life sciences revolution,
where I'm less expert.
And I would put carbon.
I would put drive towards lower carbon.
The U.S. has taken a step back
from that for the moment,
but it's going to come back
because the underlying issues around are there.
And so, okay,
if those are some of the big things
that are going to drive economies going forward,
and the U.S. can have mastery
in all of those,
but the question is how broadly
that's going to be shared within the U.S.
across various social strata
and how ready people are going to be
to take advantage of it, right?
So, is AI going to be purely an elite
or largely an elite operation,
or is AI going to be used
to train a lot of people
to do a number of things?
I mean, I know that sounds very
Panglossian or techno-optimistic,
but the question is
whether it's a deliberate policy
that's steered by the federal
and local governments
in a way that are going to ensure
that in Appalachia,
you're learning skills
that are consistent with that.
And, or the energy transition over time,
it's not a term that's used anymore
in the U.S. as far as I can tell,
but it will come back.
If I can flip it back, Scott, to us,
we have the same set of issues
or set of drivers.
Those are global drivers.
On top of that,
we have a series of things
I mentioned, critical minerals.
We have large conventional energy.
So how are we balancing all that
in a way that builds the jobs
as we move out?
One of the things,
I'll say two other things,
which are related but distinct.
We got to sort out our housing issues
in this country.
We have a massive economic,
we have an absolute social need,
but we have a massive economic opportunity
to create a new industry,
new way of building houses
and at scale and driving that.
And we're going to shoot on that.
And I guess the last thing I'd say,
which candidly worries me a bit
about the United States
and gives me greater comfort
or strength in Canada,
is a word I'm not sure you'd like to use anymore,
which is around diversity.
We have a huge, huge opportunity here
because we're one of the most diverse
countries in the world.
We value diversity.
We have a very strong sense of equal rights
in a broad sense.
We can be a magnet for talent.
And as the US is pushing out brains,
if you will,
it's quite a hostile environment
in the academic world in the United States now,
we can take advantage of that.
And then that cascades down
through the AI revolution,
life sciences, other elements.
Podcasters, creative class.
Scott, come up here.
It's now above zero.
Creative has done a lot of work
in that sentence, Prime Minister.
So look, you have a housing crisis,
we have a housing crisis.
And it seems like leaders have agreed
that it's a crisis for the last 10 years.
Now I read that housing in Vancouver
is a percentage of the average salary
as the third most expensive city in the world.
And that so much of it is in zoning
and nimbyism.
And the previous Prime Minister,
they wanted to address the housing crisis.
What's the friction point?
Is it capital?
Is it labor?
Is it zoning?
What is different about what you're proposing
that is going to register any more progress
than previous administrations?
So it's all of the above.
And so you attack it in a comprehensive way.
I'm going to simplify in terms of restrictions,
zoning, development charges.
And we work at multiple levels of government.
It's part of the reason why those costs are there.
They come from the municipal side.
And so in effect, we put up a bunch of money,
just put up a bunch of money to commit
to cut the development charges in half.
And that's subject to a series
of other restrictions being removed,
but we at the federal level will pay
for that to be cut in half.
The second thing, I mean,
we believe very strongly that productivity
in the Canadian housing sector,
construction sector, basically is flatline
for the last 20 years.
Okay, we're still building houses
like we did before.
And given the scale of what we need to do,
we got to move much more rapidly,
particularly in urban density and other things.
Modular prefab housing, mass timber,
other innovations that are there, they exist.
And so one of the things we're going to do
to kickstart that industry,
and this is Canada's, not the United States,
we have a different attitude toward these things.
We have a problem with deeply affordable housing, right?
Certain countries you might call social housing.
We just have not built that for decades,
basically, in effect.
And so we need to catch up.
And so what we're doing,
part of what we're doing is,
we're going to build huge amount at that level
and set the specs, if you will, for that.
We're going to build on our balance sheet
as a developer,
and we'll set the specs for that,
which drive the industry upstream
in prefab, mass timber, et cetera,
which gets the economies of scale there.
But by and large,
we will rely on private sector build.
We'll make a bunch of land available.
We'll make cheap capital,
25 billion for developers in this case,
which is bigger money up here.
Cut those development charges in half,
drive that,
and then we will give tax breaks
to people buying their first time home.
So basically, they're getting 5% off
their first time home,
which, you know,
from a down payment perspective starts to add up.
So attacking it both on the supply demand side.
The way we look at it is,
this is generational.
The scale of the problem is generational,
such that we are building out a huge pipeline
of apprentices in the skilled trades.
And one of the core messages I give
virtually every time I speak,
so I'm going to do it now,
is this is going to be a great time
for a career in the skilled trades in Canada.
Because we're going to build
for the next 25, 30 years.
We are going to add,
if we get this right and we intend to,
three to four points of GDP of investment.
That's a huge number, right?
It's possible.
We used to invest at that scale
relative to GDP in the early 70s.
We can do it again.
You know, we can finance it.
We got all the pension funds.
We've got lots of money to finance it,
but we need to kickstart it.
And of course, it's housing.
We start with housing.
It's not just housing.
It's energy.
It's other elements.
But that's what we're going to do.
So we want to get young people
into the skilled trades at scale.
We're going to pay for all their apprenticeships.
We're going to work with the unions
to pull them through.
We're adding a bunch of capacity
at post-secondary education
so they can get these trades at a scale.
So we're getting hundreds of thousands,
which again, in the U.S. doesn't seem like a lot,
but in Canada, these are big numbers.
Let's talk a little bit about climate and energy.
You've evolved from being a climate finance advocate
to scrapping the consumer carbon tax
and calling for Canada to be an energy superpower.
How have your views changed on this?
I wouldn't say my views have changed, to be honest.
So, I mean, it's very results-oriented.
So the consumer carbon tax in Canada
was responsible for about 6% of our emissions reduction.
So 94% of the work was being done elsewhere.
Now it sent a signal to households,
but it just wasn't that important.
But it was quite divisive
because people viewed it as a tax
and they saw the tax with the tax.
They didn't all give credit
to the rebates that they were getting.
So politically, it was unhelpful,
it was undercutting the overall message.
So we got rid of that a few months ago.
It was the first thing I did, actually,
when I got into office.
But what we are doing is making sure
that the carbon market for large emitters works well.
Large emitters work well,
and as a consequence of that,
we're getting them, in effect, to pay people for,
this is what will happen if we're elected,
to pay people for driving EVs,
retrofitting their homes,
other climate-smart choices.
And then on top of that,
there is a big IRA-type element
to our climate strategy,
investment tax and credits and others.
So we're looking basically,
and having reasonable success with this,
where we're putting out a dollar federally
and we're getting four to five dollars
of private investment on top of that.
And what's really relevant to us,
aside from caring about the climate,
and people up here do care about the climate as a whole,
is that we think that this is going to be
a fundamental driver of competitiveness.
And if you look at who we're going to be
trading with more over time,
Europeans, the Brits, others,
guess what?
They care about this.
In fact, as you know,
carbon border adjustment mechanism
is coming into in Europe.
And so we take a view that,
okay, we've got to do this medium-long term
for competitiveness
because that's where the world's going.
Secondly, the Europeans and others
are going to want us to do this.
Thirdly, actually, we've got a lot of the technology.
So part of being an energy superpower
is around small modular reactors.
I mean, we're a big hydropower,
we're decent on hydrogen,
we could get better carbon capture and storage,
all these things we can do.
And I guess the last point,
which goes back to the US,
is right now,
and I'm going to grossly generalize,
the US doesn't care about climate.
Six months ago, it cared about climate.
Guess what?
You're going to care about climate again down the road.
And when you care about climate down the road again,
we want to be in a position
where we're much more competitive
and maybe have leapfrogged
a number of US companies.
So I just want to do a quick lightning round.
Advice to your 25-year-old self.
You got 10, 15 seconds
with your 25-year-old self.
What would you say to yourself?
You know, relax
and stay focused on what you like.
I mean, I've probably spent more time
doing things I didn't really love
than I should have.
You got a chance to go back
and meet with someone who you've lost
or who's no longer around.
Who would that person be?
And what would you say to them?
Well, I think, you know,
be my father, I'd say I love him.
You're at the end of your life,
not going to walk on the beach again,
not going to get to hang out with your wife, your kids.
What does success look like for you?
When you look back,
what is the box you want to have checked?
I think strongly the answer to that is
that you're proud of the values
of your children
and people who've worked with you.
And I think that is the only real legacy,
the extent to which you have influenced
how others treat others in the world
and how they react in the world.
I wrote a book and that was the conclusion of that.
Mark Carney is Canada's 24th prime minister
and leader of the Liberal Party,
sworn in this March.
As an economist,
Prime Minister Carney steered the Bank of Canada
through the financial crisis
and later became the first non-Brit
to run the Bank of England.
Between those roles,
he served as UN Special Envoy
to Climate Action and Finance
and as Vice Chair of Brookfield Asset Management.
I trust a lot of Canadians are listening
and I feel comfortable speaking for a lot of people.
And that is,
Americans understand the largest undefended border
in the world is the U.S.-Canadian border.
That's for a reason.
I love that question
that Warren Buffett's friend
who's a Holocaust survivor said,
the way I judge my friends is,
I asked one question,
who would hide me?
A lot of Americans remember
that Canadians hit Americans
in the Iran hostage crisis.
And I hope that your listeners
and your voters recognize
there is a huge swath of Americans
that think of you not as,
not even as a friend,
but as siblings.
And that we hope
and are committed to maintaining
what is arguably
one of the strongest alliances in history.
That, I don't want to say,
don't take what's going on seriously.
You have to.
But there are a lot of Americans down here
who are brothers and sisters
in arms in Canada.
We really do think of you as a sibling.
Thank you, Scott.