TRAVEL - EXPLORE - How Do Hot Air Balloons Steer (+6 Other Science Mysteries).

Wilder Paths
16 followers
This is me on top of a speeding train,
and this is me in a hot air balloon
to answer some of the most debated science questions on the internet.
For example, my hot air balloon pilot here says he can land me anywhere I want,
and yet there's nothing here that resembles a steering wheel,
which begs the question,
how do you actually steer these things?
So we steer...
And now I'm on top of the train to learn once and for all,
why do you land in the same spot if you jump inside the train,
but not if you jump on top of the train?
But I'm not stopping there.
Because today we're going to investigate five more physics and engineering puzzles
using simple demonstrations as we go.
Because our goal by the end of this video is not for you just to know the right answers,
but more importantly for you to understand why they're the right answers.
To kick things off, I've got a science riddle for you that most people get wrong.
What is the first man-made object to break the sound barrier?
In other words, an object that travels more than 767 miles per hour through the air,
exceeding the speed of sound, thereby creating a super loud sonic boom.
So what do you think?
Most people I ask say either a bullet or a rocket or even a jet plane.
But this set goes way back, like 5,000 years way back.
Because the first man-made object to break the speed of sound is a whip.
The sound you just heard was literally a sonic boom.
Which means at the peak of its motion,
the tip of the whip is moving faster
than 767 miles per hour.
Okay, so if you got that right, time for a bonus question.
What's almost surely the first time you yourself heard a sonic boom?
Here's your clue.
It's a near statistical certainty that everyone has the same answer for this
going back millions of years.
That's right, thunder.
Basically, the lightning superheats the air five times hotter than the surface of the sun.
And this causes the air to expand so rapidly,
it breaks the sound barrier once again, creating a sonic boom.
And if that juicy nugget of knowledge just made your brain feel really good,
make that sound cooler in post.
Yeah, buckle up because we've got six more to go,
including at number two.
Have you ever noticed when grabbing drinks from a cooler
that even though they have the same amount of liquid inside,
regular Coke sinks, yet diet Coke floats?
Now, why would that be?
Well, our first clue is that we know less dense objects like this cork float
and more dense objects like this bolt sink.
However, that's not only true about different objects,
it's true about different liquids too.
Like for salad dressing, how the less dense oil floats on the more dense vinegar.
And sure enough, when we compare the respective labels,
you'll notice one glaring difference.
Regular Coke has more than three tablespoons of real sugar,
which makes this can more dense than the diet Coke,
which just has artificial sweetener.
That means this one's just a little less dense than water,
causing it to float,
while this one's just a little more dense than water, causing it to sink.
But we can take this to the next level.
Here I have a wall that I filled with eight different household liquids
from honey,
dish soap,
to baby oil.
And they naturally stack themselves with increasing density as you go down.
So if we dump, let's say, a bunch of golf balls in,
they'll sink like a Coke can through all the layers
until they hit a layer that's more dense than they are,
at which point the golf balls stop falling and come to rest on top of that layer.
Are you kidding me?
Which means you can have a different item come to rest on every layer.
As long as you spend way more time than you care to admit
testing way more items than you care to admit.
This one's a dice roll.
But in the end, it's not hard to rationalize the wasted time
when it looks this cool.
By the way, you can make a simple version of this yourself at home
by filling a drinking glass with baby oil and colored water,
and then popping in a Lego guy to ride the ocean waves.
So this obviously works with household liquids,
but what if the liquid was metal like this?
Because this bowl is 24 pounds of mercury.
It's hard to even submerge my hand in here.
Which means if I take an actual cast iron anvil,
it should float like a Diet Coke.
Let's test it out.
Look at that.
I mean, I understand the science behind this,
but it still breaks your brain.
This is actual cast iron.
It's heavy.
And yet when you put it in mercury, it bobs like a cork.
Let's go bobbing for anvils.
For number three, a while back, I read about a famous mathematician
for the 1600s who noticed that when he would hang up
multiple pendulum clocks in his house,
they'd eventually sync up their swings,
and then they'd just stay that way.
So he wondered, just like I did when I first read this,
how are these purely mechanical clocks that weren't touching
somehow communicating with each other,
and after a period of time, agreeing to swing in perfect unison?
And since the unofficial motto of Crunch Labs is
think like an engineer,
I decided to create an experiment to test this for myself.
So we got four clocks and put them on a wall,
and after four days, nothing happened.
But when you're thinking like an engineer,
you know that's not a failure.
That's a clue.
So I re-read the story and picked up on an important detail
I'd missed the first time.
The clocks weren't mounted on a wall in the way we think of today.
It said they were mounted on the same wooden beam
that made up part of the wall,
and given the construction methods of the 1600s,
there's a good chance that board had a little wiggle to it.
And that wiggle is a very important detail.
Here's what I mean.
If I swing this sledgehammer pendulum below me
while standing on firm ground,
then it's just the sledgehammer pendulum that you see moving.
But if I stand on a skateboard where I don't have firm footing,
now you can see the pendulum is in fact pushing back and moving me too.
Now here's the wild part.
Because the clock is securely attached to the beam,
that beam acts just a tiny bit like the skateboard.
So those swinging pendulums are ever so slightly
actually moving the wall.
So that means as the clocks are just slightly pushing back
and nudging the beam,
they start to influence and nudge each other too.
So if there's a clock that's greatly out of sync with the others,
over time those little nudges get it to line up.
So after discovering all this,
we took those four clocks and this time attached them all to a beam,
which was attached to the wall with a little bit of wiggle built in.
And this time after four days,
nothing happened,
which once again was a clue,
not a failure.
Because it turns out for this to actually work with pendulum clocks,
you need a very precise ratio of clock to pendulum mass,
like this setup here.
So while I couldn't get my hands on the perfect pendulum clock,
here's another way to observe the same phenomenon
with 140 pendulums all sitting on a board,
I can freely wiggle back and forth.
All right, let's give it a shot.
Little help here.
This is truly one of the coolest things I've ever seen.
It's like a bunch of stormtroopers.
And just to give you a sense of how quickly they sync up,
here's an uninterrupted take so you can see for yourself
as the chaos turns to order in less than a minute.
So as you can see,
even though we started them totally random in less than a minute,
those nudges do in fact influence each other
until they're all swinging together
just like the clocks 400 years ago in the mathematician's house.
Coming into number four,
have you ever noticed every time you see a full moon,
it always looks the same?
In other words, it's the same side, even in pictures.
Well, what about the other side?
Well, it turns out we don't see the other side
because the moon is rotating perfectly in sync with its orbit around the Earth.
So we only ever see the googly eyes.
But that's wild.
Like what are the chances that those would sync up perfectly?
Well, we call this tidal locking.
While it seems unlikely,
you see this with pretty much all the other planets
and their moons in our solar system too.
And this simple demo will give us the right mental model.
And if the moon was perfectly spherical and balanced,
it would spin like this
and one side wouldn't be more likely to line up with Earth than the other.
But the moon's not perfectly spherical.
Over time, that constant pull of Earth's gravity
has caused it to be sort of slightly oblong,
which we've sort of exaggerated a little bit here.
But now you'll see since the center of gravity of our moon
doesn't exactly line up with the axis by which it rotates like it was here.
Now, no matter how I spin it,
it always happens to be that the heavy side of the moon
always face the strongest source of gravity,
which just so happens to be the center of the Earth.
Well, guess what?
Out in space, the actual moon's nearest source of gravity
is still the center of the Earth,
which means that the real moon will always have the same side pulled towards us
just like with our model.
And that means every living thing on this planet
that has ever looked up at the moon
has always seen that same familiar face.
And that will never change.
Now, before we get to the last three,
including answering how hot air balloons steer,
if you're like me and you love the feeling of that ah-ha moment
when you learn something new,
then I got great news for you
because packaging up that moment is why I created CrunchLabs,
where you get a super fun toy every month in the mail
that comes with a video
where I teach you all the really cool physics that make it work.
So if you want to have a ton of fun building your own toys
while experiencing a bunch of those lovely ah-ha moments at the same time,
just visit CrunchLabs.com to learn more.
And now I'm on top of a train to learn once and for all
why do you land in the same spot if you jump inside the train
but not if you jump on top of the train?
We'll get to the jump in a second,
but first, let's see if we can glean any clues
from this small-scale test with two Lego guys,
one inside and one on top of the train.
But they're in water.
Now, in a moment, I'm going to pull on this string,
which will move the train car forward,
and I want you to think what will happen to each of the Lego guys.
Ready? Here we go.
Did you catch that?
Now, because this test was in water,
you intuitively sort of had a sense the top guy would fall off
and the bottom guy would be fine, right?
Well, yeah, because the top guy would have to travel through all that still water
and that would push back on him,
whereas inside the train car, he's enclosed,
so everything in that car, including the water,
is moving along with the train.
So why would I show you this Lego guy standing on a model train in water?
Because it's fundamentally no different than me standing on a real train in air!
Because just like water, air is also a fluid,
it's just not as dense as water.
You can sort of see how it moves like a fluid here in this demonstration,
showing hot air coming from a blow dryer.
So when a train moves through the air, it's moving through a fluid.
To visualize this, let's replace me with a pair of helium balloons.
Once again, what do you think will happen here?
Well, of course, the balloon inside is totally upright
because just like in water,
the air around that balloon is traveling with the train,
whereas on top, the balloon is being pushed back
because it has to fight its way through all this stationary air,
just like the Lego guy on top being pushed back
by all the water around the train in the tank.
It's sort of like when you stick your hand out the car window
and feel all that resistance from the wind.
So going back to the jump,
if you were able to visualize all the air molecules like this,
you'd see how once we start moving inside the train when I jump,
I get no pushback from all my air molecule neighbors
because they're pretty chill and we're all traveling together.
But on top of the train, it's a whole different story.
I'm continuously bonking into a mad rush
of trillions of air molecules every second as I whiz by.
So if I jump now, it makes total sense why they would push me back
and I would land in a whole different spot.
For number six, here's an interesting thought experiment.
Let's say you just bought a small two-seater airplane
and you know the plane has to be traveling at 60 miles per hour
on a still day to take off.
So one day, you have the brilliant idea.
Why not just create a much shorter runway using a plane-sized treadmill
that can ramp up to 60 miles per hour,
sending it into the air from your own backyard.
But would that actually work?
Well, let's run the experiment together with a small-scale model.
Now, the way a plane typically takes off is it needs to reach a certain speed,
which of course then requires a certain length of runway.
So let's see what it is for this model airplane.
Looks like it's 10 miles an hour after traveling 15 feet.
Now, here we've got our own version of our backyard treadmill runway
that will ramp up to our 10 miles per hour takeoff speed.
So let's see what happens.
Make your prediction now if you haven't already.
As we start the treadmill, we're going to spin the propeller more and more
to keep it in the same spot so it stays in the camera frame.
Okay, so we're at takeoff speed and sadly, we're not taking off.
And at this point, we were suspicious maybe we measured something wrong.
So we cranked it up way more and still nothing.
So does that mean our backyard treadmill idea is a bust?
Let's talk about what needs to happen for a plane to take off
because planes need air flowing around their wings to create lift.
Once again, it's sort of like sticking your hand out the car window.
You don't feel any lift stopped at a red light.
But the faster you go and the more air that flows by your hand, the more lift you feel.
Which means no matter how fast our treadmill goes,
there's still no air moving over the wings.
We're stopped at a red light.
And I think part of the confusion many people have with this experiment
is they're comparing it to the vehicle they know best, which is a car.
Because for a car, the ground is what gives you forward motion.
But for a plane, it's the propeller that gives you forward motion.
Here's a thought experiment to demonstrate that.
Imagine you have a car and a plane on the most slippery ice ever invented.
Because the car's engine uses the ground to get forward motion through the tires,
no matter how fast you spin those tires, the car will not move an inch.
The plane, however, is totally unaffected by the ice
because the plane's wheels aren't powered at all.
The forward motion for a plane comes from the propeller in the air.
So it would take off with absolutely no problems.
It wouldn't know the difference.
So knowing that, let's adjust this experiment to give the plane a chance to move forward.
Which means, of course, we're going to need a bigger treadmill.
So let's get our treadmill back up to that 10 miles per hour takeoff speed.
And at this point, we're exactly back to where we started with the smaller treadmill.
So to get the plane to move forward, let's just give it more power,
causing it to move down our extended treadmill and take off at 10 miles per hour after 15 feet.
Which, as you recall, is the same speed and distance
as when we tested it with no treadmill at all.
So would your brilliant backyard runway treadmill idea work?
Absolutely.
Assuming, of course, your backyard is the exact length of an actual runway.
And now for our final engineering puzzle,
we're back in this hot air balloon as I contend with my mild fear of heights.
OK, well, I haven't found a steering wheel,
but it does seem pretty clear every time you add hot, we go high.
Hot air balloons utilize some pretty straightforward physics,
and the clue is right there in the name.
Hot air is less dense than cold air.
And we know from our Coke cans, less dense things will rise.
So when Matteo does this and heats up the air in the balloon,
he's basically diet-Coking us.
And then over time, the air outside cools back down the air in the balloon,
making it more dense.
And therefore, we start to sink down like regular Coke.
So all you have control over is whether we go up or down.
Correct.
But you said you could land me wherever I wanted.
That is also correct.
But what if the wind's going that way and I want to land over there?
That's got to be magic.
Yeah, so what we'll do is we'll...
OK, pause here, because to understand Matteo's answer,
you first need to understand two things.
First is that if the wind is blowing in one direction in your backyard,
a thousand feet above that, it's almost certainly blowing differently.
And a thousand feet above that, it will once again be totally different.
So the question then becomes,
how does Matteo know the wind speed and direction at different heights?
And that's where number two comes in,
because it's someone's job every day to launch two balloons like this
into the sky at noon and midnight London time.
But this is done in a thousand locations all around the world,
all at those same two exact times.
And these balloons all have something called a radiosonde attached to them
that measures things like altitude, pressure, temperature and wind.
Then they transmit the information back to the ground station,
which gets fed into supercomputers.
And that's the reason the wind and weather predictions can be so accurate.
So 2,000 of these massive weather balloons go up every day
and they eventually pop and just land somewhere, never to be retrieved.
Now, because of this, computers can figure out the wind direction and speed
at every level of the atmosphere as you go up.
So on a given day, Matteo just checks the daily charts.
And if these are the predicted wind directions and speed,
and he wants us to land exactly right here,
he just needs to raise and then raise again,
and then lower the balloon to catch the appropriate invisible rivers of air
to land in the perfect spot.
So hot air balloons don't steer, at least not in the normal way we think of.
It's more of a tag team with Mother Nature.
So in some ways, he's less of a magically steering pilot,
and he's more of a weatherman.
Which means the only real magic here is all the juicy knowledge
I just wirelessly transferred through that screen from my brain into yours.
This is Timmy, and he is a piano prodigy.
He loves to practice, and his parents don't have to nag him to practice either.
I love it.
Do your thing, Timmy.
But this is Katie, and she lost all interest in piano after Hot Cross Buns.
Which means practice is a battle and a chore she doesn't want to do.
And let's face it, Mom doesn't exactly want to hear either.
Well, I got great news for you, Katie and Mom,
because for the cost of one month of begrudging piano lessons and reactions like this,
you can get an entire year of Crunch Lab's Build Box with reactions like this.
And when the stoke level is this high, you're learning so much cool stuff
even without realizing you're learning so much cool stuff.
Because each month when a new toy arrives on your porch,
and then you put it together alongside me,
you're learning all the cool engineering principles that make it work.
And this secret sauce of hiding the vegetables
is the reason we've shipped millions of these boxes to converted parents around the world,
saying this has totally unlocked a new level of resilience,
curiosity, and passion in their kids.
And there's even two options.
You've got Build Box, where I teach them the basics
through building a super fun toy for kids up to 12 years old.
And then there's Hack Pack, where we learn some coding
with an awesome build-it-yourself robot for your teens,
or heck, even for you.
Half of these things get shipped to adults.
So if you want to go from being the household nagger to the household legend,
watching a young mind discover a passion they didn't even know they had,
go to crunchlabs.com or use the link in the video description
where we're currently giving away either one or two boxes free as an early spring special.
Thanks for watching.
