There are few people who have played a more important role in broadly supporting the rights of religious believers in China than Marco Respinti, director-in-charge of the Bitter Winter magazine.
“In the first six to eight months of our existence online as a magazine, some 40 people who were connected to us on the ground were arrested in China. … Half of them simply disappeared,” Respinti says.
During the International Religious Freedom Summit in Washington, Jan finally had the opportunity to sit down with Respinti to discuss how the Chinese Communist Party systematically infiltrates, coopts, and destroys religious movements in China.
CHAPTER TITLES 0:00:01 - Introduction to Marco Respinti and Religious Freedom Advocacy 0:01:25 - The Fundamental Nature of Religious Freedom 0:03:59 - American Democracy and Global Inspiration 0:06:36 - Focus on Religious Persecution in China 0:08:03 - The Scope of Religious Suppression in China 0:13:36 - Transnational Repression Beyond Chinese Borders 0:16:12 - International Religious Freedom Summit 0:17:09 - A Catholic's Perspective on Interfaith Religious Freedom 0:18:44 - Hope and Purpose in Religious Freedom Advocacy 0:20:05 - Personal Impact and Successful Interventions 0:21:33 - Risks of Reporting from Inside China 0:22:58 - Closing Remarks and Reflection
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
there are few people who have played a
more consistent role in broadly
supporting the rights of religious
Believers in China than Marco renti
director in charge of bitter winter
magazine in the first 6 to 8 months of
of our existence online as a magazine
some 40 people who were connected to us
were arrested in China and half of them
simply disappeared so we know nothing
about that during The Intern AAL
religious freedom Summit in Washington
DC I had the great pleasure of finally
sitting down with Marco for a deep dive
where he reveals why he fights so hard
for the religious freedom of people of
all faiths as a Roman Catholic himself
and he breaks down how the Chinese
Communist Party systematically
infiltrates co-opts and destroys
religious movements in China this is
American thought leaders and I'm Yan
Kell Marco rinti such a pleasure to have
you on American
leaders my pleasure totally Marco I've
had this deep deep respect for you for
quite a long time through your work
exposing human rights violations in
China and especially those of religious
minorities in particular I believe that
the freedom of conscience or freedom of
belief is probably the most fundamental
right that exists what do you think I
think that the most fundamental right
for a human being for a person is the
the right to life because otherwise if
you're dead no rights in my opinion this
is the first the second but it's direct
the relationship is the freedom of
conscience or religious freedom because
they're strictly connected one ISM
inside the other because it's all about
addressing the most fundamental question
of all in human life does God or
whatever you call it Supreme Being uh uh
Universal Force whatever it's not a name
does that God exist or
not and if it exist or
not um this um has a relationship direct
relationship on how you organize your
life as an individual and as a and as a
member of the community you live in
starting from your family and going to
all the structures intermediate
structures between individual and state
that uh the human genius can can imagine
so again it's the truly the the the
second most important question of all
freedom of religion is not not just the
Liberty you have to believe privately in
a in a closet in your room and to pray
secretly but it's also and fundamentally
the Liberty to leave a accordingly to
your belief so it's public so it's
political in the sense the that Greek
addressing with the name of Polish the
rbla the the the the public thing and
it's not by chance that America put this
Freedom as the
first um right of the American citizens
in the First Amendment to the
Constitution it was here to a long
tradition of thought which put the this
um idea of the human being being
fundamentally uh shaped by his or her um
thought about God that tradition is the
the the core question out of which
America was born that fundamental idea
in America is still going around and it
confronts all the uh Liberty killing
regimes government and historical
experience of many other countries
I've come to understand that essentially
every liberal democracy out there right
now really took its inspiration from the
US ultimately is that do you view it
that way I think it is correct to say
that um
because for its
importance America is a light house for
many uh democratic regimes many liberal
democracies try to imitate America but
not all of them are America they don't
understand the natural low uh
Aristotelian would say um Roots out of
which this country was born for sure all
the liberal democracy that try to
imitate America but beer the
enlightenment jacobine French Revolution
Heritage in their um bones will have
hard times to understand this country
and to imitate it for the for the
best and why because the two things are
completely different and they cannot
cope one with the other the the American
um the American Experience is born out
of the this Aristotelian Christian
natural low based um tradition and the
jacobine Revolution and the
Enlightenment uh in the French uh
version is the idea of getting rid of
that past instead of evaluating it
underlining and using it correcting the
the mistakes of course as everything
nothing in in nothing is perfect when
it's human so correcting even that
tradition but the the French Revolution
just the and that um enlightenment idea
the enlightenment project has it has
been called by Scholars it's the idea of
getting totally rid out of that past
because it was JG negative and bringing
to to to nothing but it's a matter of
fact that all the totalitarian and Tyran
totalitarian regimes and tyrannies in
um that came after the French Revolution
was were inspired by that instead
democracies that are inspired by America
have a different quality in um in the
public life they Grant to the citizens
so why this particular interest in China
and the realities of the lack of
religious freedom in this country people
say that after the end of the Cold War
communism is
over it is not we have 1 billion
300 million
people in China the most populated
country in the world who still lives in
a very proud Communist Regime no
election no Freedom nothing so the
magnitude of the problem is so big that
we we need to to to to address the the
thing plus China is a a powerful nation
very smart in finding ways to lure other
countries the Democratic countries so we
I think it is needed to to
expose the real nature of China China is
a liberty killing
regime they persecute all
religions in different ways but all
religions and especially so-called
minority groups and they do it in a very
harsh
way and we see that sometimes in the
west that the topic is not addressed as
it deserves give me a sense of the true
scope of the issue or the magnitude of
the
issue um a very fine Chinese Scholars on
relis Fang Yang few a few years ago
described the relationship
between the Chinese communist state and
religions using um
the metaphor of three markets the gray
the black and the Red Markets he say
religion are divide can be divided into
these three markets when it come to the
relationship they have with the Chinese
Communist Party the red Market is where
the Chinese Communist party and the
state um tolerates or uh religious
groups or churches and
when I say tolerates means that most of
the time they infiltrate them and they
try to control them from inside this is
uh started back in the in the
50s establishing the so-called patriotic
Buddhist Catholic Protestant Muslim and
um twiist Association and was a way to
infiltrate those um those churches
because they could not be possible for
the government even if so much powerful
to destroy them completely so they try
to control from them from inside
infiltrating them and then there is the
black market the black market is the
place where
the groups religious groups are
described by the regime with a Chinese
expression which is called um which is
Si it mean it's an old expression it
comes from the old days in China it
means means heterodox teaching the
Chinese communist party revived that old
expression C and it it reinterpreted it
and retranslated it um using the word
cult which is very much um or or is or
was very much popular in the west um
Scholars have abandoned the use of Cults
because cult is a derogatory term which
has no limit and No No Boundaries so
basically it's a way
uh by which the power whatever it would
be uses to again put people aside so
it's meere them basically yes it's so
it's debunked and is is not used by
Scholars and there are um legal um
decisions that say that should not be
used in many countries that should not
be used in international treaties and
documents official documents so on so on
and so forth but what the Chinese
Communist Party does is to compile a
list of um C and they put all the the
groups that they can directly repress
why because they have large numbers of
um of faithful but they are not for many
reasons are not well known so not well
defended abroad and the the government
uh have a almost a freehand in
repressing them the black market of
religion is the place where you have um
the largest number of uh death uh in
suspicious condition in custody when
these people are arrested for just
having religious books or praying
together or just not signing I renounce
to to my faith um you have torture you
have violence on women you have all kind
of of um of bad things on these um on
these individuals and groups and again
most of this happens because these
groups are not well known not well
connected to Brad and then we have the
the gray Market which is kind of between
the red and and the black market and
it's the place where um the regime is
not able doesn't have the force to uh
destroy completely these groups and uh
and and it does not have even the force
to infiltrate uh them so it's more or
less tolerate these groups but as a
matter of fact Fagan Yang is and other
Scholars um elaborating on this model
which has been um wrote about a few
years ago are now saying that this gray
Market is slowly disappearing because
the power of the state is so um growing
that either they they this the groups
belonging to the gray Market goes in the
in the red Market meaning totally
directly infiltrated by the government
or they tend to uh to be put in the list
of the black
market Cults uh and then destroy the
other so the gray Market is it's a model
that Scholars use but it tends to as a
matter of fact practically it tends to
to disappear in recent years they they
will be red or black they will be
directly infiltrated or directly
repriced Marco just one quick sec we're
going to take a break and we'll be right
back and we're back with Marco rinti
director in charge of the bitter winter
religious freedom
magazine the Chinese regime doesn't just
persecute these groups within its own
borders it actually has quite some great
efforts I interviewed Wagers I've
interviewed Tibetans I've interviewed
felong gong practitioners I've
interviewed uh democracy activists from
Hong Kong for example all of which are
persecuted in some way in some cases in
incredibly severe ways here in America
in Canada in Europe other
countries what is the thinking
there well transnational repression is
has been documented in reports by groups
and assoc associations and think tanks
or activist group that deal with
religious liberty in China so it's a
wellestablished fact how long can
Democratic um countries
tolerate that people on their um land
are attacked harassed by foreign country
um we have seen countries where um
Chinese policemen can easily go in the
streets there are countries where secret
um police station Chinese police station
have been secretly established H for
which reason why um Can it Democratic
Society tolerate these infringement on
its
sovereignity and let's go back to the
people the people who Escape China
trying to find Safe Harbor in other
countries say Italy say the United
States of America say
Canada uh do we want them to fear not
safe in our free country because China
has a free hand to get after them I
think politics needs to address that
topic so we've been seeing each other
the last few years at these
International religious freedom Summits
here in Washington
DC what is the significance of this
event what is the value of
it as far as I understand it this is one
of the most successful experiment in
bringing together different religious
leaders from all over the world
persecuted people put them around the
table not to just to uh to chat but to
confront share experience and try to
affect public society and even
governments possibly uh with u real
concrete um examples and and and
testimonies I think this is the most
successful experiment in trying to
really build a
movement of religious liberty Defenders
you're a deeply believing Catholic
it's not necessarily obvious that people
of a particular Faith should be standing
up for people of all these other P
faiths it is sometime not but I would
say it should be mhm if you're a
Believer whatever
religion your first Duty would be I
think to defend the freedom of people of
whatever
religion to exercise their Rel because
otherwise I wonder what you really
believe in if you don't believe that the
relationship of a human being with God
is so important to be defended at all
costs um I wonder how much serious you
can uh consider your your personal
relationship uh to God in your own
tradition to answer more directly as a
Roman Catholic I I feel
that it's my strong
um duty to defend the freedom of every
human being to believe to to enjoy the
freedom I
have uh as a Catholic they may be Muslim
Buddhist um whatever if God has given us
Liberty and this is one of the quality
that make human beings similar to God we
should respect that and defend
that whatever cause so what do you
hope happens through your you know this
opportunity you have to meet with all
these advocates for Religious
Freedom learn from them and the most um
interesting and even emotional part is
meeting with uh survivors with refugees
with people who re really escaped um
persecution just for what they believe
this is unbelievable that people can be
killed arrested tortured raped uh organ
harvested for what they believe uh it's
blows my mind literally I I I don't
think there is there can be no reason
when you really meet people in person
and you look them into the eyes and you
are saluted by
a
person that you don't remember because
you meet so many people but she or he
remembers you because you wrote an
article and and comes and greets you and
thank you that is the things that you
that make you learn that the importance
of uh what is not just a
job a vocation you know is there an
example that comes to mind of some of
your work where you saw it translate
into helping
someone um that you can think of I will
not go into details not due to because I
can cannot reveal some names or because
of security for them but we were able
to stop the
repatriation of a person into the
People's Republic of China and it was
almost um done the thing was almost done
and these people had a a
relevant
um role in a religious group so we know
we knew for sure
that what it could easily happen to this
person once repatriated was simply
death who were able to stop it almost
last minute and this person is now free
free in a free country and and will not
name one but you can guess mhm well um
that's
amazing it is and
it's I mean it unfortunately it doesn't
happen every other day and it's quite
rare because we are confronted with u
powers where we are almost a MAG and we
are just a magazine uh with some
connection to to
group of U activists but we're B I'm
well but you actually have access to
people inside China who risk quite a lot
I know because we cultivate you know all
sorts of deep sources inside China
inside the regime even these people are
risking everything to share information
and you have that you've earned that
trust yes we we had that unfortunately
it's decreasing these days in numbers
the content you we have because the
Chinese regime is very smart in finding
these people and um let me remind you
that in the first 6 to8 months of of our
existence online as a magazine some 40
people who were connected to
us on the ground were arrested in
China and half of them more or less have
been released soon or later and half of
them simply disappeared so we know
nothing about
them um that is the the value of the
work we can do with people um in China
in under on the ground uh giving us
information uh that is
unvaluable but it's becoming difficult
and it has risk so all the credit should
go to those people not to us well Marco
this has been an absolutely wonderful
conversation it's such a pleasure to
have had you on it's my pleasure totally
thank you all for joining Marco rinti
and me on this episode of American
thought leaders I'm your host yane Kell
[Music]