Heated exchange between Sen. Ossoff (D-GA) and CIA Director Ratcliffe
Thank you Mr. Chairman and thank you all for joining us and for your service. Just to make
sure I understand some of the basics here, so Director Ratcliffe, you were a member of the
Houthi PC small group signal chain, correct? I was. Yeah, and so were the Vice President,
the Secretaries of State and Defense, the National Security Advisor, and Miss Gabbard, correct?
I believe so. I don't have a list of who was invited to be on. And so was National
Political Reporter Jeffrey Goldberg, correct? I don't know that.
Yes you do. I don't know Jeffrey Goldberg and I don't, I've already testified, I don't know
whether or how he was added. Okay, well he was a member of the signal chain and the discussion
included the Vice President's private opinion on the wisdom of proposed U.S. strikes in Yemen,
correct? I don't recall. Vance, quote, I think we are making a mistake. I am not sure the President
is aware of how inconsistent this is with his message on Europe right now. There was a strong
argument for delaying this a month. You don't recall? I don't, as you, as you don't recall
seeing that? Read that. I don't. It included the private opinions of the Secretary of Defense on
the timing of strikes in Yemen, correct? I don't recall. Director Ratcliffe, surely you prepared
for this hearing today. You were part of a group of principals, senior echelons of the U.S.
government in now a widely publicized breach of sensitive information. You don't recall
whether the Vice President opined on the wisdom of the strikes? That's your testimony today under
oath? In that setting I don't recall. Here's what Secretary Hegseth said, quote, waiting a few weeks
or months does not fundamentally change the calculus. Two immediate risks on waiting. One,
this leaks and we look indecisive. Two, Israel takes an action first or Gaza ceasefire falls
apart and we don't get to start this on our own terms. Your testimony, you don't recall
the Secretary of Defense sending that message or reading it? I recall there being an exchange. I
don't recall the specifics as you're reading it. Well, let's put it this way, Director Ratcliffe,
a discussion by senior U.S. officials on the timing and risks of a proposed military campaign
and disagreements between the President and the Vice President about U.S. plans and intentions
would be of obvious interest to foreign intelligence services, would it not? Yes.
And they were discussing the timing of sending U.S. air crews into enemy airspace
where they faced an air defense threat, correct? I'm going to, Senator, defer to
the other principles that you're referring to about what the meaning
and the context of what they were talking about. The timing of U.S. airstrikes, correct?
Yes. Yes, and therefore the timing of sending U.S. air crews into hostile airspace, correct?
Yes. And therefore the time period during which enemy air defenses could target U.S. air crews
flying in enemy airspace, correct? I don't know that. You do know that. Let me ask this question,
General Hawk. You lead America's signals intelligence collection.
Would the private deliberation of foreign senior officials about the wisdom and timing
of potential military action be a collection priority for you and the U.S. intelligence
community? Senator, it's our job to do indications and warning for both the plans and intentions of
adversary leaders and for military commanders. And would not information about the timing of
airstrikes allow a military to preposition or cue air defense systems to shoot down enemy aircraft?
I think, Senator, from our perspective, any advance warning is something that we certainly
are trying to protect. Director Ratcliffe, this was a huge mistake, correct? No.
A national... Hold on. No, no, you hold on. No, no, Director Ratcliffe, I asked you a yes or no
question and now you hold on. A national political reporter was made privy to sensitive information
about imminent military operations against a foreign terrorist organization. And that
wasn't a huge mistake? They characterized it as an embarrassment. This is utterly unprofessional.
There's been no apology. There has been no recognition of the gravity of this error.
And by the way, we will get the full transcript of this chain and your testimony will be measured
carefully against its content. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank the witnesses again.

