I paid a visit to Rebecca Bullene of @Greenerynyc to go over some of the best systems for green walls and vertical gardens. Now that we're considering a new living wall system indoors @FlockFingerLakes , I'll be weighing all the options on the market.
__
"Plant One On Me" is a channel produced by Summer Rayne Oakes of Homestead Brooklyn that is primarily focused on houseplants and outdoor gardening. Our mission with the channel is to bring people closer to plants by bringing plants closer to them through engaging, entertaining, and educational content.
If you enjoy the content and want to support the channel, you can do so by becoming a Sustaining Member for as little as $5/month: https://bit.ly/2MvqUPz
Write your questions and suggestions in the comments below the videos and on Instagram @homesteadbrooklyn #PlantOneOnMe.
Note: Some items on this page may include affiliate partnerships. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. #gardening#gardeningtips#garden
We've covered quite a bit on green walls and vertical garden construction on this channel,
from the vast living walls in Singapore, to the Amazon spheres in Seattle, to my humble
green wall build out in my Brooklyn apartment almost 12 years ago. I want to revisit some of
the latest advances, however, because we'll be considering a new living wall build in one of
the buildings we're doing at Flock, which is part of the renovations we're doing over on our sister
channel. I visited Rebecca Belin from Greenery Unlimited and Greenery NYC, whose companies have
been installing vertical gardens and installations throughout New York City. She shares her insights
on the systems out there and weighs in on the pluses and minuses for each system.
We're standing right here next to this green wall, and that's what we're going to be talking
about today, is green walls. And you have, how many green walls do you think Greenery
Unlimited has put in since the inception? I think that we have probably installed, I'm going to go
ahead and say over 50 green walls throughout New York City at this point. So yeah, no one thing or
two, I hope. All right, so let's talk about the different green wall systems that are out there,
and the one that you probably utilize maybe the most, and some of the pros and cons of those. Yeah,
absolutely. So I'm going to start with the tray system. That's the system that we have here,
and that's the system that, after many years of trial and error, that I use the most now. And
the pros and cons, I think, of the tray system, we'll start with the pro, which is that it's very
easy to maintain. So the, all the way the tray system works is essentially this is just a plastic
tray that's housing individual four-inch nursery pots. And so if you ever have an issue with
individual plant species or pests, it's as easy as being able to remove those plants to treat them,
or exchanging them out. So when you're doing large-scale walls in a commercial setting, which
is, you know, most of what we do is in big lobbies or reception areas, having the ability to make
these changes and to be able to deal with it on a very specific plant level is really useful,
and it really helps just keep that operational labor and cost low. I would say the con to
the tray system, it's individual plants and plastic pots, right? This isn't really a system where the
roots are going to spread and you're going to see change over time. It is essentially a collection
of four-inch plants that are very artfully put together, and we've created, you know, a grow
system around it to support them. But they are essentially just a collection of individual
plants. It's not a true sort of like living tapestry the way that some of the other systems
can be. So that's, you know, the tray system in and of itself, really easy to install, really easy
to maintain, and I think if it's the aesthetic you're looking for, something that is going to
sort of stay the same over time, it's a great option. One of the other systems that, you know,
I've utilized over the years is a hydroponic system, and so it's sort of the opposite. Harder
to maintain, but it actually is truly a living wall in that generally hydroponic systems are
set up with either sort of felt system or rock wool. You're not using soil in a lot of those,
and what happens over time is that the roots can actually send runners and start spreading.
So whereas you might, you know, just especially with aggressive plants like a maidenhair fern,
you may have one section when you start, but over the course of three months, six months, six years,
that plant type will actually start to spread throughout the piece, and so it really becomes
a living ecosystem where plants are competing for water and nutrients, and some plants out-compete
others, and it really changes over time. Also, because you're not restricting any root growth,
you'll start to see the possibility of very big plants. So some of the really amazing, impressive
hydroponic walls that I've seen over the years, you know, they're actually growing trees outside
of that, right? You might see these big ficus canopies coming off, and it's just... I actually
think of like the, I don't know if you're familiar with the wall at Devotion. I am, yeah. So that's
one that I've seen since the inception. They put it in, and now I see like their dracaenas are like
really coming off the wall. Yeah, that's exactly it. It's like a Patrick Blanc wall, like when I
think of Patrick Blanc, I think that, I don't think he does pots. No, his system is a hydroponic system,
exactly that. So right, he was the sort of original inceptor of this concept of a living wall,
and all of his pieces are hydroponic. It's essentially that he's, in the way the hydroponic
is, especially the Patrick Blanc piece, it's pieces of felt that are sandwiched together,
and then you have irrigation lines that are running often, very often, so you're never
allowing a dry out period. And so that's another thing to understand, is like you may be utilizing
a lot more water with a hydroponic system. It depends on, you know, if you're setting up a
recirculating system with filtration. That's a good point, yeah. Like, you know, you could do a
recirculating system, but then you have to figure out, like, are you recirculating some of that
fertilizer? How does that work? And that's part of the problem with the hydroponic walls,
because generally the, I would say, the most efficient of the hydroponic systems are
recirculating that water, but if you did get some kind of disease, and there, or something's wrong
with the water, some, you know, balance is off with your nutrient injection, you're going to
keep recirculating that into the wall. So that is, it's, you know, it's pros and cons to all
the different systems, but that is one of the downfalls of the hydroponic system. Now, you
had mentioned just something right now about, like, the pH, and, like, monitoring that. How is
a wall like this, or the hydroponic, being monitored? Is it just, like, your employees
and your colleagues going in and monitoring it, or are you doing it on, like, an app, or how are,
how are you doing it? What's available out there? Yeah, there's actually a lot of interesting things
available now, and I think that's a really emergent field right now, are different types of sensors.
So I think that the issue, so right now, at Greenery, we're actually relying on human sensors,
so they're actually testing the walls, and sort of doing that by hand in each one of our pieces,
and I think part of that is because, at this point, I don't think there's a leader of the pack
in the sensor field, and I also think you sort of run into these issues when you have large-scale
walls. You need to be able to be testing a lot of different areas, and especially in a tray system,
putting sensors in each individual plan, or even in zones, can get really cost prohibitive. Yeah,
because this is what, is this a 10 by 10, or what is this? Yeah, this is a 10 by 12. Okay,
10 by 12, and how many plants do you surmise is in here? I would say there's probably 1,500
plants in here. That's way more than I thought. I knew there was a lot, but I'm like, yeah,
I was trying to do the math in my head, like a four-inch pot, like, and that may be an
overestimation. Yeah, you would never be able to do that, but the thing about this system
is that these plants might not be in here for life if you could easily pull out a four-inch,
you know, and put in another four-inch. Exactly, so I think, and that's part of it, like, the goal
is that, right, this is a piece that stays the same, but the reality of it with the tray system
too is that some of these plants are going to get leggy, some of them are actually going to
outgrow the wall, you know. In particular, I actually love the way the Aglaonemas look in
living walls, but this is a plant that I know over time is going to get too large eventually for
this, so at a certain point, I'm going to take out these four-inch pots and I'm going to upsize
them to six-inch, probably sell them in our retail store, and I'm going to replace them with new
four-inch plants to maintain the aesthetic, but there is going to be change over time. Now, some
of the plants that are in here are original to when we first put it in in 2019, but certainly
not all of them. I know when we first put it in, right, I had some beautiful Rex begonias that I've
since replaced with the Peperomia, and some of that is just learnings over time, and also as the
other plants start to grow, you start to see where your dark spots are, where the shade is, and that's
what you'd see in any living wall, is that it is going to change over time, and that's
one of the beauties of it, right? It's not a static art piece. It's something that's ever-evolving,
ever-growing, ever-changing. Yeah, I mean, I think that's kind of an interesting aspect of it because
this one, you have a little bit more freedom to move plants around, so you have more control over
this art, whereas if you're doing something hydroponically, you might have say on what
you're doing initially to make that art, but then it is kind of like, it's to let go. You have to let
go to a certain extent. You do, and I think I've seen that, you know, sometimes over time, you know, I
use the example of the maidenhair fern because I've seen that plant utilized a lot. It is such a
beautiful plant, and it flourishes in a hydroponic setting. It's such a water-loving plant, but people
don't necessarily understand when they first put it in. They want that texture, maybe sporadically,
and maybe don't fully understand how aggressive that plant will grow, so it will eventually
out-compete most of its neighbors, and so now, you know, five years down the line, you maybe once had
a wall that had 13 different species in it, and now you got two. I think people will be surprised
by that because people who often grow maidenhairs, it's not in a green wall system. It's in like
maybe a pot, and most people have killed their maidenhair, so they're like, yeah, they're like, hey,
aggressive? A maidenhair? No, but that's the whole thing. I think that's part of, if you were to grow
a maidenhair in, I would say, like a sub-irrigated vessel, you'd start to see that it's actually
an easier plant. It's the care you provide, and that's part of like being successful with living
walls, is not every species is going to do well in this type of system, right? This is, in general,
living walls are kind of wet feet systems across the board, so you're going to want to be selective
in the plants that you're using to make sure that they enjoy those conditions, and I think it is,
they exhibit different characteristics when you grow them vertically with different growth systems.
A maidenhair is a great example. Put that, you know, in just a normal terracotta, and that's a short
life for that plant. Put it in a hydroponic system where it's getting water 10 times in a 24-hour
cycle, that plant's going to really flourish. Now, when you did the Bank of America building here,
right? Okay, and is that similar to this system that you did, or is there any modifications,
because you've done that more recently compared to this one, which was done in, what year was this?
2019. 2019, okay. Yeah, so there's, but you know, I think with every wall we put in, there's always
some kind of learning, so even some walls that we've done, we've changed over time, so there have
been projects where we've started with, you know, felt pockets, and had those pockets in, in Bank of
America's example, that a project that's changed over time, right? So, and sort of realizing, and
we can talk about that felt pocket system, which is, I think that that is another one that has sort
of a finite life, and it can be really challenging to maintain over time, so I think. And for folks,
just to, sorry to cut you off, just for folks to know, because I'll intersperse, my green wall had
some felt pockets, and there are pluses and minuses, and I'm happy to have Rebecca go over some of that
as well through her experience. Yeah, I think that's it, it's just, so what I've realized, I sort of
jumped back to say that because the work that I'm specifically doing is mostly in, you know, public
facing commercial settings, I have sort of deduced over time, and also because I don't have access to
it all the time, I'm sort of confined to when people are going to let us into the building,
that the tray system is the best for that setting. You know, if I was to have the freedom to
create my own living wall for my space, I'm not sure I would use the tray system, because I'm
interested in seeing how things evolve, but I think one of the things I learned about the, you
know, using felt pockets, and using multiple different types of felt pockets, different sizes,
you know, different placements on them, it, one, I would say the downfall to that, in my opinion, is that
it's messy, so when you're thinking about doing that professionally in like a bank setting, that
can be really problematic, because that is not the carpet, it's not a customer that loves to have a
lot of soil flying around, so I think you have to sort of be a little bit pragmatic sometimes to say
what is going to be the cleanest, most efficient system, and so I think that the same, in the same
way that the hydroponic system allows for big growth, I think the felt pockets do the same,
I think the felt pocket system is interesting, because it's almost this hybrid of a soil-based
system with a hydroponic system, so you sort of have both the pros and cons of both of those,
but ultimately, I think that what I've seen over the years with the pocket system is, I think if
you can set it up correctly from the beginning, you can sort of avoid some of the pitfalls,
and one thing that I've noticed with the felt pocket system is what happens sort of behind the
pockets themselves, and so if you don't have an appropriate, like, waterproof membrane set up
behind it, you will grow mold, you will have damage happening, so there's just some, like, architectural
requirements that I would suggest get put in. I think the other thing about the felt pockets is
they can actually get really heavy over time. Yeah, I mean, honestly, I was really surprised that
one of, I think I had a 5, a 10 by 5 or whatever, and they're like, one of these things is, like,
at least 80 pounds with just a little bit of water in it, and I'm like, wow, you know, it builds up
fast. It builds up fast. You have, you can't just have it on, you can't just plug it onto a drywall
and expect it to stay up. Exactly, you're gonna definitely have problems, so like I said, there's
an infrastructure requirement that comes with the pocket system, and I think that's the other
thing why I lean towards doing the tray systems. It's really lightweight, right, because essentially
it's a plastic tray with a collection of plastic pots and soil, so it's, you're not putting a big
load on the wall, and it's the same with the hydroponic system. It's a really light load,
and so that's part of the things when you're thinking about the wall that you want to design
and build, where it is, is like, you know, I think the felt pockets are good, again, because you can
have expansive growth, especially if you have bigger pockets. One, the root system can travel
through that felt for better or for worse. It can move and grow, but you do have to realize that
it may be messy, and as I was telling you earlier, you know, one of my first living wall projects that
I was working on, the, I didn't install it. I inherited it, and I was maintaining it, but no one
had thought through when they basically put an irrigation system in, once the water reached that,
it was a drip line, so it started at the top, and the water would sort of rain down pocket to pocket
and sort of sacrifice a pocket, so it would be really wet at the top, and then by the time the
water got down to the bottom, it would just start dripping out the bottom, and there was no way to
catch that water. It was really messy, and so part of it is just so much of the long-term success of
living walls comes down to the planning stages in the beginning, and I'd say, you know, it's the two
biggest most important factors are water and light, right? It's like, are you going to be able to provide
adequate lighting, and for our work, grow lights are a requirement for any project that we put in.
We will not put in a green wall without without lighting, even if it's directly in a south-facing
big, beautiful floor ceiling windows, just because in New York City, the changing of the light
throughout the seasons has a really big impact on the plant palettes that we're working with,
so we need to provide consistent light with the grow lights, and then just water, just coming
through what is that irrigation plan going to be. Is it a recirculating system? Is it a
municipal fed system? Sometimes we don't have access to water where people want to put walls,
so we'll have to devise a tank system where we're essentially have five or ten gallon tanks
of water that we're manually refilling and then pumping that water back up, so those are just some
of the big considerations. No matter what type of system you're using, it's really important to think
that stuff through. That's great. You mentioned lighting on the green walls, and you said you will,
you know, put it in no matter what because you actually have more control over the light.
What are some of the kind of latest innovations that you're working with? I mean, obviously, a lot
of people go with LEDs. We don't have to use, like, the purple lights anymore. And I don't recommend
the purple lights for foliar growth. I definitely think going full spectrum, and I think there's so
many amazing grow lights coming out in the market right now, and I give, like, all thanks to the
cannabis industry. I think that, you know, there's a lot of money there, and people are very interested
in how to successfully grow plants, and a lot of the technology that's being created there is really
applicable to the work that we do, and I think gone are the days where it was these big, like, metal
halloid, huge grow lights, really expensive, real big energy consumption. Now there's a lot of really
cool products out there, and I think the things that I tell people to look for when they're looking
at grow lights, rather than necessarily, like, looking at a brand or the style, is, like,
what is the throw, right? What is the actual output of the light? And thinking about, so for the green
walls that we do, I want to hit a minimum of 150 foot candles on the whole wall. So I'm okay if
there's some hot spots, you know, closer where the lights are, but even as I start to drop down on the
base of the wall, on the face of the wall, I want there to be even 150 foot candles down at the base,
recognizing, right, there's going to be shady patches here and there, but I know that if I can get that
kind of even spread across, even if I dip down into 60 or 70 foot candles in here, it's still going to
be enough to support the plant life. So I'd say, you know, what is the throw, making sure you're
going to hit that 150 foot candle threshold, and then you want to have a high CRI, which is the
color render index. So you want to make sure that's 90 plus, right, because the whole goal is that you're
mimicking sunlight, so you really want to get as high a quality light as you can, and in terms of the
color of it, it's usually somewhere between 3,500 and 5,000 kelvin. So it feels a bit more like
homey. Yeah, I think it's candle light is like what, like 2,500? Yeah, like 2,500, 2,700. Yeah, so like,
and then if you're going to 3,500, it might be a little bit better on your eyes versus if you're
going up further to where it's like sunlight, it might be too stark in a home environment.
Exactly. But like maybe in an office environment, it'll be okay. I think it depends on like the
proximity to windows. So the lights that we have on here are 5,000k, and I don't think that it
necessarily, it feels, it feels really blue, white, and a little garish at night. Right. But because we're so
close to the window, the natural light, which is already kind of at that really blue-white
temperature, it doesn't feel like natural. It's a really good point. Yeah. Well, thank you so much. I mean, I think
that this gives us a lot of food for thought as I'm kind of also going into my renovation and
thinking about the next green wall. It gives me a lot of food for thought of like what to do next.
Happy to help. It's so great to have you. Like you said, there's a lot of pluses and minuses on every single one.
There's never a silver bullet solution to everything. So thank you so much, Rebecca, for your time
and for your expertise on this. My pleasure. If you have further thoughts on green walls, share
them in the comments below. And if you're enjoying the channel, do us a favor and give it a thumbs up
and help us grow by subscribing. And if you're keen to get a deeper knowledge on houseplant care,
check out our suite of online offerings and courses from Houseplant Basics to the Houseplant
Masterclass over at homesteadbrooklyn.com. See you in the next episode.