The Blind Spot" by Leon Krier

Si Da Ra
2 followers
"The Blind Spot" by Leon Krier, published in Architectural Design, vol. 48 no. 4, 1978 #keepreading #architecture #journal #leonkrier #architecturaldesign #postmodern #modern.
Comments are disabled for this video.
The Blind Spot by Leon Krier in Architectural Design, Volume 48, Number 4, 1978
Never before have so many people, so many professional bodies, institutions,
magazines, so many papers concerned themselves with architecture.
Never has there existed such a plethora of schools and professionals who ostentatiously
carried architecture on their coat of arms.
Never has there existed so many students, teachers and historians of architecture,
and yet architecture seems not only something badly defined, far from agreed upon,
but most of these people do not know what architecture is, let alone what it was made of.
Not being sure what it should be, some pretend it is dead,
while others claim it should be dead.
If you look for contemporary definitions, you will find thousands of books on modern
architectural subjects, however only a few would come anywhere near a definition of modern
architecture.
In this state of confusion, it is only natural that the RABA's architectural library is selling
some of its precious content and, for the past few years,
been more interested in acquiring books on rules governing daylighting and such subjects
rather than on architecture.
The confusion becomes complete if you look into Pevsner's Dictionary of Architecture,
only to find out that the term architecture is not even mentioned.
Thus, architecture is veiled in a cloud of nonsense.
How can a dictionary treat a subject which does not even enter its own intelligence?
We will, therefore, have to rely on other definitions for enlightenment.
Quatremer de Quincy devoted to this subject, architecture, about 30 pages of his dictionary,
and defines it as an imitative system of building, as the art of building,
leaving aside its manual aspects.
But if architecture is essentially an intellectual discipline, it cannot,
or does not want, at no moment, to free itself from its subject and origin, building.
Thus, architecture consists essentially of a body of knowledge concerning the material
transformation of nature into buildings, and in turn, the translation of an imitative
system of building into an art of building.
According to this definition of architecture, this particular art is not only dead,
but it is also etymologically absurd to use the term modern architecture,
let alone postmodern architecture.
If we look at the architectural schools, into architectural offices,
into the statutes of professional bodies, we find that not one is occupied, or even concerned,
with the circulation of knowledge about the nature and making of architecture.
Architecture depends on function, durability, order, humanity, nature and beauty.
Modern architecture has none of these things, Quinlan Terry wrote.
The iconographic and symbolic emptiness of modern architecture can, of course,
be explained by the fact that it never belonged to architecture.
Rather, it belongs to packaging, and, in its most ambitious examples,
it might have been an art of packaging.
Modern architecture did not belong to building.
Having its roots in the artisan disciplines, building as a culture was circulated through
history by collective memory, to be destroyed only by the industrial division of labour
and compulsory popular education, or rather re-education.
Architecture and building have disappeared as intellectual and artisan cultures.
While European cities are mercilessly wrecked by the brutal construction
of the new territorial infrastructures of the advanced industrialized state,
the architectural profession has entered a crisis which, since 1968, nobody has been able to escape.
After the darkest and most destructive period of European urban history,
including the two world wars, the building crisis
leaves us today to contemplate the damage which has been caused to the cities and the countryside.
If we do not see any major change in the future, it will be because all major political,
economical and cultural positions are still occupied by a generation that
considers the city and the territory as a field of endless experiments.
We have to deal here with a generation of people who, in the past 30 or 40 years of
their professional life, changed their styles more often than their ties.
This wild profusion of manners is being applauded by journalists as postmodernism
and promoted under the motto of complexity and contradiction.
It would be naive to see in the new interest in architecture a necessary sign of its revival.
The only characteristic that most recent experiments have in common is their
fragmentary nature and provocative eclecticism which, as never before,
juxtaposes styles upon styles in most vulgar and raucous way,
resulting in most cases in nothing but kitsch.
And it is kitsch which must be identified as the most important
general cultural phenomenon of the industrial age,
as the real zeitgeist of the machine age, pervading all levels of life and culture.
Any revival of architecture and building culture which is only concerned with the artistic form
and which ignores the necessary manual, as opposed to industrial culture of
architecture's origin and production, can only trivialize and further marginalize
the object which was once man's most important concern.
Architecture and building, which once promised the ultimate shelter for man
against afflictions of nature, is reduced to a mere problem of packaging and industrial gadgetry.
However, to the emptiness of the machine age,
one has to respond with a soothing and mildly intoxicating decor,
and I wouldn't make too much difference between neo-rococo or neo-cubist.
Kitsch is no style, and it is all styles at once.
It is ugly, but the function of kitsch is not to be beautiful,
but to stand for beauty, to replace beauty, to signify a status.
The elusive signification of a social status and the very frustration of what it promises
are the central functions of the kitsch object.
Instead of satisfying the senses, it merely satisfies an instinct for beauty and social position.
Thus, kitsch is fulfilling its economical function to increase consumption and ease production.
The delaying of satisfaction and the necessary frustration which occurs with the kitsch object
is a necessary basis for the apparently unceasing cycle of industrial production and consumption.
The frustration caused by this necessary superficial consumption
is only relieved by a ritualized chain of trivial improvements.
Nothing can be expected of the official institutions.
A reformation of architecture can only happen slowly,
supported by a revival of craftsmanship as part of an anti-industrial resistance.
According to Adam Smith, ignorance is the mother of industry.
Industrial division of labor results in extreme alienation of the work process.
The resulting stultification of the worker has so far prevented,
and will continue to prevent in the future, the emergence of any proletarian culture.
The existential misery of this class will lead it to resist
less and less to its total exploitation for production and uncritical consumption.
On the other hand, industrial division of labor and the end of the artisan culture of building
has degraded architectural work to no more than intellectual speculation.
Because craftsmanship is the very basis for any culture, intellectual or manual,
the destruction of craftsmanship means effectively the destruction of humanity.
Industrial production, far from fulfilling its promise of liberating mankind,
is only perpetuating, in a more radical and inescapable form,
man's enslavement in stultifying labor.
If the world is to contain a public space, it cannot be erected for one generation,
and planned for the living only.
It must transcend the lifespan of mortal man.
Without this transcendence into a potential earthly immortality,
no politics, strictly speaking, no common world and no public realm is possible.
The city of stone became, to the profits of total mobility,
synonymous with death in flexibility or even laziness.
A built and protected world, which took many generations to build,
and which necessarily transcended the lifespan of its builders,
was, however solid or potentially permanent,
adapted and transformed according to incidental needs.
To destroy such cities and buildings after having used them so successfully and for so long
would seem as absurd and superfluous as to destroy a cup after having tasted from it.
Cedric Pry's Interaction Center in Camden, London,
probably represents an unnecessarily tough statement to the contrary.
The image of industrial bricolage reminds one, painfully,
of the sinister compilation of military camps and detention centers in Northern Ireland,
which are a most authentic realization of an industrial zeitgeist
in all their ephemeral brutality and kitsch toughness.
It would be no surprise if the useless waste of this public building
cost more than its equivalent in stone and marble.
In this apocalyptic dawn, crowded with quietly fading meteorites,
a reformation of architecture based on its own rational principles
would seem to be a daring enterprise if it was not of such an excruciating necessity
and if it was not part of a collective striving.
In the light of fast-changing fashions,
stands out as a heroic, pleasurable and wise restatement
of the essential elements of architecture.
It is an encyclopedist's vision of what building might have been
before it became an art, before the discovery of bronze
and before its translation into stone.
Now that we are in a period where architecture and building
is vanishing from the face of the earth like an underground stream,
this little sturdy structure must be, and should be,
a slap in the ideological face of that generation
who thought that they had killed architecture once and for all.
As such, it gives me a great pleasure and I take it as a lesson.
You cannot plunge in at a deep end.
You cannot slap Corinthian columns onto reinforced concrete buildings
and call it architecture.
It is something much more fundamental.
It is this something much more fundamental which a new generation of architects,
activists, historians, artisans and artists are fighting for at many different levels.
As this something more fundamental can certainly not be acquired
in an absurd educational machinery nor by scientific investigation
or in professional offices and institutions,
it has to be discovered in the field
or in the documents that remain of pre-industrial European civilization.
The complex social, cultural and economical fabric
still leaves enough traces to be investigated,
not in an art-historical sense, to clarify and store away,
but to elaborate the instruments of a new urban artisan culture.
This cannot be news from nowhere and it is only in an urban society
that any large-scale resistance to industrialization is still possible.
Virtually all large-scale building operations of the last 30 years will have to be condemned.
They are inhuman, inefficient, ugly, badly built and costly to police.
These human deserts will have to become the main concern of future interventions.
Not only have they destroyed parts of lively urban centers,
but they are also in need of technical and social repair.
They need, so to speak, to be de-zoned and re-urbanized.
If our attitude to history and culture has to change,
it must first of all get away from teaching cultural and political history
as a series of apocalyptic breaks, as a series of points of no return.
What we want is to add to our wealth, without diminishing our pleasure.
Formal education, from having been the pleasurable privilege of a few,
has become the tortuous necessity for all.
Manual work, which was the basis for human creativity and self-realization,
has, through industrial and social division of labor,
become a stultifying and socially degrading exercise.
All my life, I have been waiting for the revival of architecture.
I do not think it will happen, but if the right idea could be put out at the right time,
I think it would happen.
How wonderful it would be!
The world could be beautiful again.
And nothing but a blind spot really stops it.
Some people are about to keep alive a little awareness, memory and intelligence
in an age where, under the joint banners of education, efficiency and security,
the memory and faculties of what we know as humanity are systematically drowned
in the immensity of entertaining stupidity on one hand, brutality and destruction on the other,
where, without restriction, can nowhere be anything produced of importance.
A humanity whose end is no longer the pursuit of pleasure but the omnipresence of necessity
must find, ironically, the only pleasure in its own destruction,
in the recognition of its ultimate uselessness.
A state of pleasure is also one of contemplation of one's own being and doing.
Narcissus is calm and holds his breath so as not to confuse the reflection of his own beauty.
Now, if being and doing are but mere necessity,
the moment of contemplation has changed from being one of satisfaction to become one of urgency.
In that perspective, the meticulous self-destruction of humanity
becomes obviously a moment of relief, a relief from unbearable urgency,
ugliness and futile agony.
