Closure Industry Exposed: China's Impoverished Elderly Become Professional Debt Bearers

China Truths
61 followers
"Closure Industry Exposed: Impoverished Elderly in Poor Regions Become Professional Debt Bearers
Shocking Truths Unveiled: No One Dares Take on State-Owned Enterprise Projects, Worse Yet to Come?
Qinhuangdao Pleasure Boat Capsizes: 12 Dead, 6 Missing, No Life Jackets on Board
'Apocalyptic' Scene in Nanchang as Suolongjing's Chains Break—Authorities Alerted
Wanda's Crisis: Selling 16 Wanda Plazas Not Enough, Beijing Headquarters Also Sold
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
Closure industry exposed, impoverished elderly in poor regions become professional debt bearers.
Shocking truths unveiled, no one dares take on state-owned enterprise projects.
Worse yet to come?
Tsinghuang Dow, pleasure boat capsizes, 12 dead, 6 missing, no life jackets on board.
Apocalyptic scene in Nanchang as Su Longjing's chains break, authorities alerted.
Wanda's crisis, selling 16 Wanda plazas not enough, Beijing headquarters also sold.
It's all covered in today's China truths.
Closure industry exposed, impoverished elderly in poor regions become professional debt bearers.
With China's economy faltering, the number of enterprises,
companies, and shops closing down has been increasing in recent years.
This situation has given rise to a unique group known as professional closure operators
who specialize in planning how to safely and legally abscond with funds for companies on
the brink of closure, thereby creating an industry chain.
Recently, several stores of the well-known early education institution Jimbery
in mainland China closed suddenly.
Victims unable to reclaim prepaid funds sought legal rights but were told the
institution's practices were legal, hence legal support was unavailable.
The victims had no choice but to turn to the media.
Media investigations have uncovered a special group behind these harvest-and-run schemes,
professional closure operators.
They use various improper methods such as changing the legal representative of the
company and fake operations to allow the business owner or company boss to shed its skin in a legal
manner, easily evading legal accountability while transferring huge debts to gamblers
or elderly people in remote areas who are incapable of repayment.
Recent reports by mainland media have detailed the workings of the closure industry chain
and its professional debt bearers.
According to these reports, since 2019, professional closure operators have
developed an organized industry chain.
These operators handle the transition of failing businesses by appointing a professional debt
bearer as the new legal face of the company.
This person takes on the business's substantial debts, legally avoiding any wrongdoing.
Leading the process are those known as bottom dogs, experts in identifying and evaluating
poorly managed businesses for closure.
They scout for businesses, secure contracts, and perform financial audits.
Intermediaries then find suitable debt bearers and take care of official registrations,
while bottom dogs manage the deceptive activities leading up to the closure.
This might include final sales events right before shutting down to maximize earnings.
The business is then declared closed once the original owner is safely detached from it.
Bottom dogs must be well-versed in finance or law and capable of detailed business analysis
to ensure both the safety and practicality of closures.
Typically, they take a service commission of 10% to 30% of the enterprise's debts.
For example, if a boss has a debt of 3 million yuan, around 420,000 US dollars,
the professional closure operators might charge 300,000 to 900,000 yuan,
around 42,000 US dollars to 126,000 US dollars, depending on the services provided.
The next phase involves the bottom dogs transferring responsibilities to an
intermediary who ensures the business owner can discreetly withdraw by assigning the
debts to the new professional debt bearer, who then becomes the legal representative.
Once a business has been officially closed, any resulting legal disputes do not affect
the original owners but are the responsibility of the debt bearers.
These individuals, often either gamblers or poor elderly with no repayment capabilities,
suffer minimal personal impact if they end up blacklisted for non-repayment.
Manager Lin, who has experience in the professional closure industry,
revealed to mainland media that gyms, barber shops, beauty salons, cake shops,
chain restaurants, and nearly all prepaid service providers are potential clients for
professional closure agencies. Manager Lin disclosed,
Because there is a complete industry chain and the operation process is simple,
this group can handle dozens of orders in a short time, earning hundreds of thousands in a few
months. This professional closure operator revealed that their business has peak and
off-peak seasons. During off-peak times, these operators even advertise in groups,
claiming they can handle changes of legal persons and shareholders,
and transfer issues of poor management and insolvency.
On social media platforms in mainland China, complaints like paid tens of thousands of yuan,
and the institution ran away half a month later, still in class in the afternoon,
ran away by evening are commonplace. A partner at a law firm in Shandong
interviewed by Chilu Evening News stated that the above operations of professional closure people
might involve crimes of obstructing liquidation, illegal business operations, and contract fraud.
However, due to difficulties in obtaining evidence and high costs of asserting rights,
many times these illegal activities may not be effectively pursued.
Shocking truths unveiled. No one dares take on state-owned enterprise projects.
Worse yet to come? Many Chinese netizens have claimed online that no one dares to
take on projects from CCP state-owned enterprises because the upfront project
funds are not returned. Some netizens also say that even more dire situations might emerge in
the future. A video circulated online on April 14th shows the owner of a construction company
revealing that in the past, everyone rushed to take on projects from state-owned enterprises,
but now they dare not. In conversations with fellow company owners, they expressed a preference
to keep their teams idle rather than take on such projects. Taking on other projects might only mean
a loss in operational costs, but taking on projects from state-owned enterprises could
be bottomless pits, potentially forcing them to deliver food to pay off debts.
They explain that now working on these projects means lending them money and doing the work for
them, with little chance of recovering the advanced funds. On the Q&A site Jiu, an account registered
as a certified safety engineer named Jiao Fengyun also posted last December revealing the same
situation. The post mentioned that state-owned enterprises are desperately seeking teams
globally, yet no one is willing to take on the work. It's not that the construction teams are
unprofessional or lack technology, but rather they frequently need to advance funds and provide
deposits. Even the requirement for advanced payments and deposits would be manageable,
but the key issue is that once the work is completed, they do not settle the accounts.
When they finally do agree to settle, the process is extremely cumbersome and can drag on for years.
This isn't just about doing construction work, it's about blatantly using your money to make
money and pushing you around. Along the way, many will block you demanding red packets and gifts,
causing you to spend more and more while recovering less and less money, and it might
even end with not recovering a single cent. Who can still undertake such work? The post gathered
279 comments, with netizens saying, extortion and demands are secondary, the main issue is
eventually not getting paid, which can financially kill you. Getting money after a few years used to
be the norm, but now getting paid within three to five years is considered lucky, and often you might
not get paid at all. If they delay for 10 to 8 years, what can you do? Many small and private
enterprises basically collapse because they are dragged down by these state-owned enterprises.
Municipal investments are now just debts. According to Voice of America, in the CCP's pursuit of GDP
growth, local governments have incurred massive debts through local financing platforms to fund
major economic projects to meet set GDP growth targets. Over the years, local government debt
has reportedly exceeded 100 trillion yuan, approximately 14 trillion U.S. dollars.
According to IMF data from 2022, CCP local government debt has reached 92 trillion yuan,
around 13 trillion yuan, accounting for 76% of GDP. With the current economic downturn in China,
particularly the real estate slump, local government revenues and land sales have
sharply decreased, leading to a debt crisis. In January this year, Reuters reported that the
CCP State Council had instructed local governments and state-owned banks in the past few weeks to
delay or stop construction projects that are less than half complete in 12 provinces and cities to
control debt risks. Xinhuangdao pleasure boat capsizes, 12 dead, 6 missing, no life jackets
on board. On April 13, a tourist boat capsized in Xinhuangdao, resulting in at least 12 deaths
and 6 missing individuals. It was reported that the passengers were mostly seniors from a travel
group, and notably, there were no life jackets on board. On the same day, the authorities of
Lulong County, Xinhuangdao, Hebei, reported that the incident occurred in the afternoon at Taolinkou
Village, Lujiang Township. Initially, it was confirmed that the accident cost 31 people to
fall into the water, 25 have been hospitalized, 12 have died, and 6 remain unaccounted for.
Netizens revealed that the incident took place at the Taolin Reservoir in Lujiang Township.
The boat involved was suspected to be operated by local fishermen and primarily carried elderly
passengers. High winds were blamed for the capsizing of the boat. Tourists have expressed
to the media that they did not see any life jackets on board, with some questioning,
why are there no life jackets? A netizen disclosed that her mother-in-law, who survived the incident,
reported that her aunt was among the missing. The travel agency organizing the trip was unlicensed,
and the boat was unsafe, lacking life jackets. Others commented, the boats are operated by
local fishermen. Comments from the public include concerns about the increasing number
of senior travel groups, which are often seen as exploitative and lack safeguards.
Many seniors are easily deceived due to their lack of understanding.
One netizen shared, last week, I almost took a boat at Taolinkou Reservoir.
As soon as you get to the reservoir, many fishermen surround you, urging you to take a boat ride.
Another remarked, these are all elderly people.
There have been many incidents involving senior groups, too many have happened already.
Others criticized the travel agencies for illegally organizing trips without proper
safety measures, such as providing life jackets, with local fishermen operating the boats.
Apocalyptic scene in Nanchang as Sulongjing's chains break, authorities alerted.
In Nanchang, Jiangxi, a severe storm on the afternoon of April 13 dramatically darkened the
skies, effectively turning daylight into darkness. Captured by local residents,
photos and videos from around 1.30 pm depict a sudden shift as the city was engulfed in darkness
amid a backdrop of thunder and pouring rain, creating a night-like atmosphere.
That morning at 8.52, the Nanchang Meteorological Observatory issued a
predicting thunderstorms in parts of the city over the next six hours, accompanied by short-term
heavy rainfall and gusty winds, urging the public to take precautions. Netizens commented,
this is the darkest day I've ever seen in my life. The thunder was terrifying.
What's happening to Nanchang lately with all these storms and thunder?
Has Nanchang broken some divine law? Everyone in the comments is talking about the Sulongjing,
what happened? There's a problem with the Sulongjing. The chains broke, they need to be
fixed quickly. Previously, on March 31, a sudden storm in Nanchang shattered windows and high-rise
buildings, resulting in three deaths from individuals blown from their building, with
numerous air conditioning units also being dislodged or falling, causing at least four
deaths and injuring many others. Between the night of April 2 and the early morning of April 3,
the area experienced 44,230 lightning strikes in just six hours.
According to mainland portal website Sohu, during this major thunderstorm, the iron chains of the
Sulongjing at Nanchang Wanchou Palace, also known as Taizhu Temple, broke due to the sound.
Another mainland portal, NetEase, reported that the chains indeed broke but have since
been reconnected, and the ground has been repaired. Regarding the Sulongjing in Wanchou Palace,
it is said that about 1,600 years ago during the Eastern Jin Dynasty, a flood dragon stirred up
storms in Nanchang. The Taoist sage Su Sun, who resided there, used his magical powers to subdue
it. He then cast an iron column in the southern well of Dongyue City, which stood several feet
above the well. Below, eight iron chains connected the column to the earth's veins. Su Sun also cast
a spell saying, If the iron column leans, the dragon will rise again, and I shall return. If
the column stands straight, the dragon will be forever subdued. This is the origin of the ancient
name of the Taoist temple, Taizhu Temple, which means Iron Column Temple. From then on, the menace
of the dragon ceased to exist in Nanchang. Despite the chains being fixed, there have been instances
where issues with the Sulongjing followed by repairs still led to various natural and man-made
disasters. Wanda's crisis, selling 16 Wanda plazas not enough, Beijing headquarters also sold.
The financial crisis of Wang Jianlin, China's former richest man, appears to be unresolved,
even leading to the sale of the Wanda Beijing headquarters. To date, 16 Wanda plazas have been
sold, and even with the 60 billion yuan investment agreement signed at the end of March have still
not been able to stabilize Wanda's financial footing. Jiamian News reported on April 13 that
Beijing Wanda Plaza, located on Duwang Road and home to the Wanda Group headquarters, has also
been sold due to financial pressures. Beijing Wanda Plaza forms a modern business district
with Guomao Tower, HP Tower, Jingwang Center, Jianhui Soho, etc., which is a symbol of Beijing's
According to Tianyanka, Beijing Wanda Plaza Industrial Company Limited has recently undergone
changes in its industrial and commercial registration. The original wholly owned
shareholder, Dalian Wanda Commercial Management Group Company Limited, has withdrawn, and a new
shareholder, Kunhua Tianjin Equity Investment Partnership Limited Partnership, now holds 99.99%
of the shares, while Kunyuan Chengxin Xiamen Investment Management Consulting Company
Limited holds 0.01% of the shares. Concurrently, there have been numerous changes among the
directors, supervisors, and senior executives. The equity penetration chart from Tianyanka shows
that the new controlling shareholder of Beijing Wanda Plaza Industrial, Kunhua Tianjin Equity
Investment Partnership Limited Partnership, is 99.99% owned by Xinhua Life Insurance Company
Limited, and 0.01% by CICC Capital Operations Company Ltd. This means that Wanda's Beijing
headquarters now has new owners, Xinhua Life Insurance and CICC Capital. Previously, at the
end of March this year, in Dalian, where Wanda Group originated, Tai Alliance Investment Group
CICC Capital, funds under Ares Management, Ares, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Abu Dhabi
Investment Authority, Adia, called Platinum Peony, and Mubadala Investment Company, along with Dalian
Wanda Commercial Management, officially signed an investment agreement. The first five companies
collectively invested approximately 60 billion yuan, approximately 8.3 billion U.S. dollars,
acquiring a 60% stake, with Dalian Wanda Commercial Management retaining 40%.
A person familiar with Wanda said that it will take time for the 60 billion yuan agreement with
PAG Investment Group and other new strategic investors to be realized, and it will only
temporarily relieve the crisis. Now, assets like Beijing Wanda Plaza have been sold, within six
months, 16 Wanda plazas have been disposed of. Besides, according to Bloomberg, Wanda's purchased
yacht manufacturing company, Sunseeker International, has also been sold. However,
these divested assets have still not brought Wanda to a secure financial position.
Beijing Business Daily also noted that Wanda may still have undisclosed worries.
In addition to selling Wanda plazas, Wang Jianlin also sold Wanda movies last year,
acquiring nearly 10 billion yuan, around 1.4 billion U.S. dollars, in funds. According to
the 2024 Huruan Global Rich List released by the Huruan Research Institute in March,
the Wang family's wealth has shrunk by 72% over the past year, now standing at just 30 billion yuan,
around 4.2 billion U.S. dollars. Currently, Wanda Commercial Management is Wanda's most valuable
asset, but following the signing of the agreement with the new strategic investors, Wang Jianlin
has lost control of Dalian Wanda. Now, assets like Beijing Wanda Plaza have also been sold.
It is foreseeable that Wanda will continue to sell off more prime Wanda plaza properties in
the future. Don't forget to leave a comment in the section below to share your opinions
on today's topic with us. Make sure to like and subscribe to see more interesting topics
from China Truths.
