The Consumer Just Snapped — This Is the Worst We've Seen in 44 Years

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#finance
#financenews
Consumer confidence plummeted to second lowest on record for a series that dates back to 1952 as American workers are afraid for their jobs in way the economy hasn't seen since the worst months of 2009. If that wasn't enough, both consumer and producer price indexes for March declined into deflation...in spite of tariffs.
Consumer confidence fell yet again. In fact, it collapsed yet again. According to the University
of Michigan survey, it was the second lowest consumer confidence index on record, only behind
June of 2022. Not only that, the expectations index fell to the lowest in over four decades.
But more important than all of this, consumers are afraid about losing their jobs. The expectation
that they're going to lose their jobs soared to the highest since July of 2020. Consumers
can see the economy turning. And that's not the only bad news. We're getting deflationary signals
from consumer as well as producer prices, which ties up into this as well. Consumer prices were
down for the month of March, unexpectedly, of course. And producer prices fell even more,
also unexpectedly, as businesses are finding it not quite difficult, maybe even impossible,
to pass on higher costs to their customers because their customers can't afford them.
And their customers know what happens when they can't afford prices, and their businesses and
their employers are being squeezed by higher prices. Consumers can see what's coming down
the pike here. That's why unemployment and income fears are at their highest that they've been in
several years. Because as all of this plays out, as businesses get squeezed, as they can't pass
on their costs to ultimately consumers, they have to start taking more drastic measures.
And so the fears are coming from all different directions. As the global economy is experiencing
a sharp loss of momentum, it more imbalances along the same lines that we've seen over the
last several years that just make the bad situation all that much worse. And oh, by the
way, this is exactly what financial markets are dealing with. It's not really about the tariffs
so much as it is all of these negatives, all of these economic headwinds finally combining
into one single bad mass. So Steve, Mr. Van Meter, consumer confidence, unexpectedly,
right? It crashed another substantial amount. We're talking about six more points down to almost
a record low. And while there's always a partisan split, and there was again this time, even those
Republicans who have been somewhat optimistic from last year, their confidence is rolling over.
At the same time, Democrats and independents, their confidence is record lows.
Yeah, Jeff. And go back five months, what happened after the election, confidence soared across the
board. I mean, everybody was euphoric. Businesses, pretty small businesses, consumers, expectations
were up. Everyone said, finally, things are going to turn around in our favor here. We said,
not likely to happen. The economy is still slowing, but nevertheless, what do we see now?
The reality is setting in that you pull forward all of this demand. We did this during the pandemic,
and then we kind of worked through it, but then the tariffs came along. So we pulled forward
a whole bunch of demand. And now what's happening? Workers are waking up to the reality
is that once all of this production from front running the tariffs is over, there's no work.
There's absolutely no sign that there's going to be any work. And you kind of look down the channel,
the supply chain, and what do you find out? There's massive inventory levels. So you kind of
said, here's all these factors that are facing deflation or disinflation in the factory level,
at the producer level. But here's another one. If I'm a factory and I call up a wholesaler and say,
hey, look, I got some stuff to sell you. I got no shelf space. I've been buying a bunch of stuff
here and I'm not going to pay this higher price. Well, that's where prices start to come down
because manufacturers need to get these goods moved off of their floor out into the supply
chain. The problem is now, as you said, Jeff, consumers are starting to wake up to the reality
is the economy's slowing down and it's looking like it's going to get worse. And the problem
here is when people start to worry about their finances, which showed up in the Michigan survey
a couple of months ago, we started to hear this, that now the reality is they're looking at their
job, they're going to work, they're seeing, yes, I have work now and I got some backlogs.
And then after that, there's nothing. And now all of a sudden there's panic. I'm going to lose my
job. And when I look at the labor market, there is no opportunity. And this all back feeds into
one critical part. The US consumer says, I'm done spending. I've got to pay down on my debt. I've
got to raise my savings. And it's game over because now all of a sudden it's a foregone
conclusion that fear of recession leads us to a recession. Yeah. Consumer confidence isn't really
about consumer spending, at least not the first part, right? Consumer confidence is usually a
reflection of people's confidence in jobs and income. So when confidence is high, it's really
people saying, I believe that I have a good job. And if I don't like the job that I have,
I can get a better one. And that raises are likely to come in and that I don't really have
anything to fear as far as my employer's concerned. So confidence is a reflection of the labor market.
And then if confidence goes down too much and it goes too far, that's when consumer spending
starts to tail off, usually a couple of months later, sometimes around six months to a year later.
But we've seen confidence fall off a couple of times already. People are already concerned about
it. And the confidence is a reflection of the fact that, as we've talked about many times,
talking about consumer confidence specifically, people hear their employer talking. They hear
their coworkers talking. They hear their neighbors and their cousins talking. And they can hear what
their managers and employers and HR personnel are all saying is, this is not good. This is not good.
This is not good. We got to do something about it. So consumer confidence reflecting the labor
market. But what the University of Michigan survey also mentioned was that they're starting to see
signs, as you just said, Steve, that that confidence, a reflection, negative reflection
of the labor market is starting to impact their perceptions of personal finances, which is the
step that happens just before consumers say, OK, that's it. I got to tighten my wallet.
So we've got all of the stuff, all the ducks, unfortunately, just lining up in a row. We've got
labor market difficulties. You've got the tariffs that come in that make the bad situation worse.
You've got employers talking negatively about their margins. We can't pass on these costs
to consumers. What the hell are we going to do? And you've got consumers saying we see all this
stuff and we know what's coming next and what's coming next is, as you just said, Steve. In fact,
I think the University of Michigan survey said they talked about these are all the signs of a
recession. Yeah, absolutely, Jeff. And then you start to look to the equity markets and you've
seen a lot of people, particularly on the retail side, they've been buying this step. They think
this is a great opportunity. But a lot of people understand that there's a very strong relationship
between consumer confidence and the equity markets. In fact, you can do a chart and overlay the two.
It's almost shocking to see that as confidence goes, well, the stock market tends to follow
with some lag behind that. So a lot of people said, well, why did the stock market rally
starting around 2022? Well, look at consumer confidence. Consumers said it should rally
because we're getting more confident about the economy. And when consumers are more confident,
they believe their wages are going to go up. When their wages go up, they're going to spend more.
The stock market was just reacting to that. Now, all of a sudden, as you said, you have
expectations plunging to lows not seen since the 1980s. It's telling us the outlook is poor.
So even though we may in the short term see a rebound in the equity markets,
if consumer confidence is telling us what it is, well, don't look for that to last either.
Yeah, as we were talking before we started recording here, this isn't really about tariffs.
It's about the economic fundamentals that were weak to begin with, which is why we saw the action in
the marketplace this past week, where President Trump came out and said, yeah, I don't really like
what's going on here. We'll delay tariffs by 90 days, which set off this massive historic rally
in the equity market. But then Friday came along and it was like, OK, Thursday and Friday came
along. It's like, OK, maybe it really isn't about tariffs. And that's really the statement from the
University of Michigan. I want to read a quote here because it really reflects these fundamentals
that we're talking about. And what the director of the survey, Joanne Suh, said was that
unemployment expectations have worsened sharply over the last few months, which may not lead to
a pullback in spending if consumers do not expect to be personally affected by layoffs or income
losses. And that's absolutely true. If people say, well, somebody else is going to lose their job,
but I'm fine, it won't make any impact. But she continued, alarmingly, though,
consumers are now worried that they will be personally affected. And this decline was,
like last month's pervasive and unanimous across age, income, education, geographic region,
political affiliation. And then she finished up with this. Consumers report multiple warning
signs that raise the risk of recession. Expectations for business conditions, which
absolutely tank, personal finances, as we just mentioned, incomes, inflation and labor markets
all continue to deteriorate this month, which leads consumers to say, we've seen enough here.
We've been going through this for several years. We've been left behind. We've been impoverished.
We can't afford anymore. The job market fell off a long time ago. There are no job opportunities.
Basically, if something else happens, we're all frigging screwed.
Yeah, Jeff. And so you look back to the consumer credit data, and this is exactly what it was
seeing is the change in sentiment was starting to become a reality. We've been hearing from
consumers saying, look, we're not sure about where this is going. But last month, they backed it up
with their spending by saying, oh, wait a minute, we're not going to go out and borrow our brains
out. In fact, maybe in some cases, we're going to pay down our debt. And that's a huge problem for
this economy right now. Because again, you step back and look at a lot of these businesses.
They've been struggling for the past three years at the margin, particularly small U.S. businesses.
They were really hoping President Trump would come in and this would be a big boom for them.
It's turned out it's not. But the other issue now is they've got inventory and not just a little
bit of it, a mountain of this. And they need people desperately to come spend it. What you
need is a consumer to go out, pull up the credit card, spend like crazy. But now they're saying,
no, hey, wait a minute. I'm worried I'm going to lose my job. I don't have enough savings here.
And I've got a massive amount of debt at some ridiculously high interest rate thanks to the Fed.
And I've got no options because there are no other jobs.
And just to be clear, we've talked about this before, too. This is not just a manufacturing
issue. This is not just, you know, 12 percent of the economy that's dedicated to production of
goods. This is we've already seen signs of this across the services economy. Keep mentioning the
Federal Reserve's regional services PMIs that absolutely plunged in March. That was reflected
and corroborated by the ISM services that came in well below expectations, well within the danger
zone, falling new orders, in fact, incredibly weak new orders. The employment index plunged below
40, below 50, down around 46. So we're getting all of this confirmation a lot of different ways.
One other one that I wanted to really focus on here with you, Steve, deflation. We're seeing
deflation in consumer and producer price. We're also seeing in China, by the way,
accelerating deflation in consumer and producer prices there, which just reflect the global
fundamentals. But as the PPI and the CPI this week for the month of March, what they showed is that,
OK, tariffs did show up in March. There was the small amount of tariff increases, yet they didn't
hit the consumer price index. In fact, the consumer price index was actually fractionally negative in
the month of March, and it was negative for the first time since last year. And even though it was
only fractionally negative, it was the most negative going back to May of 2020. Same thing
with the core consumer price rate, which didn't decline, but it was nearly zero. What that shows
is that even though producer costs have gone up, at least input costs have gone up, they are not
able to pass it along to consumers because what they know is that if we do raise our prices,
consumers will disappear. That's what airlines had told us in March. That's what retailers have
been saying. They're saying, look, we've tried to raise our prices. We're going to try to pass
along as many of these costs as we can. At least that's what they tell their shareholders. We're
going to try to pass along these costs if we can, but we're not at all confident that we can. And if
we try to, there is a very real risk that volume just falls off a cliff. And that's what the
airlines said. And then as the airlines warned about it in the airline business, that showed up
in the CPI too, where we saw a massive decline in prices of airline fares, along with a whole
bunch of other things, including producer prices, which also reflects the difficulties in absorbing
all of these costs, because it's not really about tariffs. It's about the economic fundamentals.
Yeah, Jeff, it's kind of interesting. You know, you turn to the Federal Reserve in case of rising
inflation, what do they tell you that, well, we need monetary policy. We need to raise rates and
tighten the balance sheet because we have to bring inflation under control. But yet what you're
telling me here is the cure for inflation just is higher prices. Let them go up and let them go up
as much as they want. Because in the end of the day, when the consumer says I've had enough,
I can't afford it, price pressure will come down. And that's exactly what we're seeing today. And
again, as you pointed out, this isn't really about the tariffs. Now, Grant, there's a small
part of this that has something to do with the tariffs, but overall, it's really not about the
tariffs. And that's what we saw hit the markets this week is kind of the shock of these rising
reciprocal tariffs. It was not actually the issue that was breaking the system. It was just
the little nudge to push us kind of over the edge to say, hey, if you keep going down this path,
look at what you're facing. You need to back off and start to make some changes here. And that's
really what we're kind of seeing out there is finally higher prices are the solution for higher
prices. And they always have been. And the other thing we were talking about before the show that
I want to bring up, too, is that, you know, it's this whole thing is about tariffs in the same way
that 2008 was about subprime mortgages, which is that it really wasn't. Subprime mortgages was just
kind of the last spark in an already weakened situation, already weakened system. And subprime
mortgages is one thing too far that they couldn't absorb. And as we've been talking about, Steve,
you and I, for however long now, the economic fundamentals in 2024 and 2025 were nothing like
they were in 2016 and 2017. As you pointed out continuously, you know, the economy was on an
upswing in 2016 and 2017. And that was probably the time to do all of this tariff policy back then,
setting the politics aside. Whereas in 2024 and 2025, everything was on the downswing.
Not only was it on the downswing, you had the structural problems left over from the supply
shock and the price illusion that forgot how to grow economy. Everything was moving in the wrong
direction. And that's why we see what really was, what really should have been nothing more than a
small little thing like tariffs. I know it sounds, everybody's making out to be this massive thing,
but really like subprime mortgages in the grand scheme of things, a healthy economy would have
been able to absorb something like tariffs. Yes, maybe it would have caused some reallocations
and some disruptions and distortions, but otherwise it would not have led to the kind
of chaos that we're seeing now. What we're basically saying is that markets have been
warning. I don't mean stock markets. We know swap spreads and other deep financial indications
have been warning for a long time, going back to last year. The economy, the financial system,
the monetary system have been incredibly fragile. So when tariffs come along, it's just like you
said, Steve, it's just a little bit of a nudge for somebody that's already halfway over the cliff.
Yeah, Jeff, I think that's exactly kind of the point here is that a lot of people kind of thought
the U.S. economy was strong coming out of the pandemic. Jay Powell said so, right? That's all
he ever said. It's strong and resilient. It's strong and resilient, yet if we examine the
underlying data, there was a clear trend that was slowing down. So as we go into putting the tariffs
on, it's kind of interesting that that one little nudge told everybody, look, no, the economy here
is in far worse shape than you think. And it's not just the economy, it's the underlying financial
system that nobody thought had any problems, but clearly it can't handle hardly any more shocks
because it almost imploded this week alone. So this is a real issue here that, you know,
we see stocks go down, you see liquidity drop, you see swap spreads crashing, bonds crashing,
commodities crashing. I mean, you see this whole mess happen and it tells you the system is actually
extremely weak and all it needs is a spark or a catalyst. And even if it's not the tariffs,
there's something else that could show up here in the near term future and push us right over the
edge. Now, to be fair, I mean, it was difficult to tell and really difficult to see if you really
weren't interested in looking for it. You know, we come back for the 2021 high and, you know,
the narrative was that, OK, yes, the economy is slowing down, but it's just normalized.
It's just it's just slowing down from an inflationary high to a more steady state.
That's what the narrative was this entire time. Yeah. And unemployment is going to rise a little
bit, but then it'll just kind of level off at a place where we want it to be. We'll go from
way too hot in the labor market to just right. It was totally Goldilocks. Right.
But you could see under the surface that behind that facade of strength was all of these
warning signs of fragility. I mean, last year's carry trade blow up,
which is another little tiny thing that should have been nothing,
blew up into this big thing simply because the system has been that fragile. And the
reason it's been fragile is because the economy was never strong and resilient.
We never really covered from 2020 and we still have to pay for the pandemic, which means
we have a system worldwide that cannot absorb any more big problems, any more little problems.
Just cannot take another hit. We're at the point where you pile another straw on top of the camel
and the camel just utterly collapses. And while that seemed ridiculous not that long ago,
with everything that's gone on over the last couple of weeks, now all of a sudden people
are saying, oh, yeah, maybe this is maybe it really was that fragile. But Jeff, it's coming.
And that's the issue here is where there's going to be a payback period from the pandemic,
but we didn't have it yet. Now there's going to be a payback period from the pandemic,
plus the front run of the tariffs and what's happening. I think what the financial system
is trying to wake up to and what the University of Michigan survey is finally telling us as
consumers look and say, hey, my outlook for my finances and jobs are plummeting here.
And again, it's not their current condition. It's their expectations. This is a key part
that everybody's starting to look out on the horizon, like, oh, wow,
there's a giant hole in the economy and it's coming.
