Dennis Prager at UC Berkeley! | Speeches and Events

PragerU
799 followers
Apr 10, 2025
Dennis Prager debates with students at UC Berkeley. This discussion exposes the way young people think after being indoctrinated in college. Check it out!
by the way I before my wonderful Co
dialogue errs with me I want to say I
was very self-conscious earlier because
when the three of us came out there was
applause and I'm going like this and
thinking maybe it's for them and so I
just watch I'm not arrogant I just
assumed I'm better now so maybe that was
the reason but I did feel self-conscious
since for all I knew none of it was for
me but anyway just give you an idea what
goes on in my brain so listen so here we
are at Berkeley which is maybe unfairly
has a reputation among a fair number of
Americans as someone think electorally
closed whether that's true or not is one
of the things I'd like to raise with
these two gentlemen these are fellow
students of yours if you're a student
here at Berkeley and they are a
left-of-centre I am right-of-center
obviously and my hope is that we could
clarify where we differ my I have a
motto on my show which you just turned
the lovely introduction for which I am
grateful
I prefer clarity to agreement I have I
have never sought to win an argument in
35 years of radio and I argue a lot I've
always sought to clarify where it is we
differ half the time interestingly what
happens is it will end with hmm so it
doesn't really seem like we differ a lot
at all does it
and then the caller will say I guess not
that's the beauty of aiming for clarity
rather than winning sometimes you have
to win I mean when you know when I
debated at Oxford I wanted to win
because I was debating against people I
thought held a horrible morally horrible
position but normally it's just you know
I believe my way you believe yours let's
figure out where we differ by the way
even though I few of you were married I
presume it's a great idea for couples
to pursue clarity over agreement so
honey where exactly is it that we differ
might not work all the time but couples
have told me that it has really reduced
tension in an argument before we fight
let's figure out where we really differ
anyway so that's that's my hope for the
evening well I will pose some issues
they are totally free to post some
issues so and I'm going to ask them
first to introduce themselves because
they'll do a much better job of doing so
so Dave and John please come out thank
you good to see you guys thank you
so give everybody your full name and
tell them what you're doing
hi I am John writer I am a second year
student here at the University of
California I studied geography and
American Studies which is an
interdisciplinary humanities degree I
write for the Berkeley political review
and I'm on the board of directors for an
organization here called bridge USA
which is involved in getting partisan
opposites together in the same room and
actually engaging with each other on a
fairly similar model to what we have
here today which is exciting
Eileen pretty left in my own politics
and it's funny because this is the first
time that I felt like that's a minority
opinion in a room at Berkeley so that's
a very another two program hi I'm David
luhan's I'm like John a second-year I'm
an industrial engineering and operations
research major don't worry if you don't
know what that is
most people don't I am also a member of
the Berkeley protocol review and a
member of bridge USA so yeah great guys
thank you very much and by the way I
established earlier their bona fides on
that when I asked who did you vote for
in the election not only did they say a
Hillary Clinton but they the reaction
tell me if I'm wrong was as if you got
to be kidding all right so I want to
make that clear there they're the real
deal
we we weren't looking for people who
might say they're left-of-center but but
really have a mag ahead at home alright
so if you guys feel totally free to ask
me or challenge me and I'll feel free to
you but I have a list of subjects so
let's begin with the most obvious one
especially at Berkeley and that's free
speech so is it fair to say that there
do you believe as I do that there is a
threat to free speech on American
campuses generally well I'd ask you to
clarify what you mean by a threat to
free speech and specifically on American
campus okay sure yeah if Ann Coulter it
was a very prominent right-wing pundit
and and whatever you think of her she I
believe she's one of the few people I
would call brilliant and when she goes
to a campus she needs armed guards I am
unaware of any equivalent on the left no
matter how far left that they need armed
guards I am unaware of any riots that
conservative students have ever created
to stop a left-wing speaker it's always
in one direction so that's what I
specifically mean okay yeah I would say
that there to a degree is threat to
speakers like Ann Coulter but
importantly I would clarify that that
doesn't actually come from the campus
community itself we were involved
actually in the invitation of Ann
culture to campus over this past
semester organization for GSA and so we
got some insight into the process and
there were threats against her practice
of speech on campus but insofar as we
know and from our experience on campus
we didn't see those coming from students
importantly those come from provocateurs
from off-campus
I myself for example was on the ground
during the Milo riots and distinctly
recall the rioters shouting out in anger
at the OPD the Oakland Police Department
before realizing swiftly that they were
in Berkeley and then correcting their
chant against so insofar as institutions
like the University of California are
concerned I think that they are doing a
very admirable job of trying to
guarantee the right to free speech to
any individual who wants to
here in practice that write and practice
that write in a manner that is
responsible and protected but there are
threats to their speech I just don't
think it is a problem exclusive to
university campuses okay
it may not be exclusive to university
campuses but to the extent that it
exists it's an anti right thing I'm not
going to belabor a thing did you want to
add anything to that okay so so I'll go
to one other aspect of this I get calls
from parents and students on my radio
show and this is a typical call Dennis
what should I say to my daughter she's
at XYZ college or university and she
knows that if she writes her opinion
which is conservative she will get a
lesser grade by the way I just want to
note the the answer that I always give
to parents who ask this at me and it
shows it's been asked so often that I
have a standard answer you don't ever
stand an answer to something asked only
once and I say this is what I would say
to your daughter if if she were to ask
me if you're gonna compromise on your
values for a grade in college when won't
you compromise on your values in life so
I I don't think one should shut up
about one's views for a better grade but
that's you know it's easy for me to say
I was it's a long time ago since I was
at graduate school but that is the
perception and it's not just the
perception every poll shows the vast
majority of professors in the liberal
arts are on the Left and unless you
think they are all truly noble and
welcome alternate views that too is part
of a quiet suppression of speech it's
not the say that these liberal
professors are inherently trying to push
down speech like you've cited like very
often the fact that there are a certain
amount of liberal professors or sorry I
left this professors versus liberal
professors but at the end of the day
that these kind of individuals are very
intelligent and they've sculpted their
own personal arguments
their own personal agenda out of
spending a lot of time with their own
community trying to have to argue out
the kind of research that they want to
show to us and so in many ways we have
to take into account that they the
research that is showing is in fact
coming through conservative eyes at some
point or another it is being rigorously
sought after and so it really must I
what if I got the same kind of question
that you did on the radio show I would
say immediately that the first thing
that the student should do is to go into
office hours and to talk to the
professor about it because at the end of
the day they both sides can be able to
see the different kind of conversation
which is going on on the particular
subject matter so they could really come
to a different conclusion which I don't
think will always compromise the a
conservative students views while at the
same time being relevant to the
curriculum because I think a lot of what
David says is important but I'd also
like to point out at Berkeley which you
know barring basically Evergreen State I
think is represented as the most left
campus in the nation I know plenty of
conservative students who do not balk at
sharing their opinions and are rewarded
because of the intellectual rigor that
they put into actually defending those
opinions in the front row for example I
see my friends pranaam John yellow and
Patrick bull dia to students who are
also second years here who I would say
it's fairly safe to say get phenomenal
grades of this institution you are
certainly challenged for your political
leaning I've seen it happen but I've
also seen you refuse to balk from that
challenge and not explicitly be punished
for it I can think of another student
for example named Alex Lee here who has
a perfect perfect GPA and a Cal that is
a hard thing to do and he is fervently
conservative the product represents one
more aspect of college life and that is
said to me earlier doing some video for
of the the movie out in coral and I are
making called no safe spaces he said if
it were known to most fellow students
here at Berkeley that he voted for
Donald Trump he would be almost
universally hated do you think he's
paranoid or do you think that there is
legitimacy to that sentiment
I disagree with that sense that
wholeheartedly first of all you can't
make any Universal claims with a student
body that's 26,000 people well you can
make a universal play with the
understanding that all generalizations
have exceptions the five people who died
in the helicopter crash in the East
River in New York were all died because
they wore seat belts but it's still fair
to say that seat belts save lives
so exceptions don't matter as a general
rule you don't think that you and I'm
asking I'm not asserting you don't think
that if it were known you voted for
Donald Trump there would be social
ramifications at this university well I
would respond back with that to say that
of the 26,000 students here it is the
exceptional cases that make the media
representation of this place those
individuals who would leverage some
social repercussions against an
individual for voting for Donald Trump
are few and far between on this campus
the truth of the matter is a lot of the
problem we have on this campus earnestly
is political apathy towards the
respective extremes now what happens
when we have these extremes representing
our campus is that feelings like this
are inculcated but that is the fault of
a media that likes to profiteer off the
narrative that Berkeley is a leftist
high bus so they'll ask the crowd okay
if it raise your hand if you think if if
a student wrote a piece for the Berkeley
paper this is why I voted for Donald
Trump there would be severe social
ramifications as a result raise your
hands I'd ask you to put your hand down
if you're not a student here okay still
only students here fine students who are
here who don't think there would be any
social ramifications right raise your
hands
okay so all right all right look it was
not a scientifically chosen all the
insightful acknowledge that but all
right I just wanted to go all right
we'll move on because there's so many
subjects in limited time yeah so we'll
figure out where all right so I think we
differ on the social ramifications of
being known as it as a trump supporter
let me just say where I come from this
is important I conducted I as an
avocation conduct orchestras I'm very
involved in classical music so I
conducted the Santa Monica Symphony
Orchestra last summer at the Disney Walt
Disney con
our whole and it got some national
attention but that's not what is
important what is important is the
number of emails I received after I was
attacked in The New York Times and NPR
and so on and it what's a conservative
doing conducting you know a liberal
cities Orchestra etc etc anyway it was
it was very sad the number of members of
some of the most prestigious orchestras
in the United States of America who
wrote to me like this violist and I
won't say which obviously Orchestra she
has been in the orchestra for more than
30 years not one person in the orchestra
knows she voted for Donald Trump her
life would would she would not be fired
but she would lose her friends in the
orchestra after 30 years if it were
known does so I have can I have come up
with the term Muranos I told you wish
history at Brooklyn College scenario I'm
well acquainted with morano's were Jews
who hid that they were Jewish during the
Spanish Inquisition acted Catholic on
the outside and Jewish at home America
has tens of millions I believe of
conservative Muranos people who are
conservative in private and who don't
allow anybody to know about that does
this sound bizarre to you or do you
believe that it's true I don't think
it's bizarre but I would also like to
bring up how many Muranos would probably
exist on from the leftist side that then
end of the day that this is just a part
of the larger problem of the kind of
polarization that we're seeing in this
country and why we honestly need to try
and confront it it's because we have
gotten to the point where people can no
longer be frank about the ideologies and
the perspectives that they do want to
talk about because we are pushed to the
point where you need to either class
where we want a modernity within our own
ideological perspectives
we have experience with that as well I
grew up with him a mile as the crow
flies of the Reagan Library that was not
the most left community now that being
said I never bulked from my principles
but importantly I would argue for every
conservative morano there is a corollary
left Morano at the end of the day when
you look at the actual margin of the
population of voters we had for Hillary
Clinton and Donald Trump and if we look
at the ideological bubbling that happens
the united states bill bryson wrote an
excellent book about this there are
communities corollaries to one another
that are predominantly Democrat
predominantly Republican and you will
always have your exceptions within those
communities that because they are the
minority opinion will feel threatened
okay so is a great example of clarity
over agreement we we clearly differ on
that I don't think the ratio I think the
ratio of of conservative Muranos to
left-wing Muranos is a thousand to one
okay but the rights of we're on were on
the record I'll give you one example New
York Times had a piece front page a
month after the election of Donald Trump
and it was about how many families are
are disrupted for their Thanksgiving and
Christmas dinners that year because of
voting for different candidates in this
election the New York Times article
itself gave in every single instance the
example but one where it was the Hillary
voter who wouldn't visit the parents or
the friends or the cousins who voted for
Trump not vice versa
I think you would have to interrogate
the values involved in that I would
argue that conservatism is generally
more of a family for it at all would you
agree with that more family a more
family friendly I said I would say as a
base political unit yeah service ism is
primarily orchestrated around the fan
yes absolutely I would argue that one of
our tribes of enjoys yeah that's fair
and I would report back to that that
less
I would refer back to that that
generally speaking liberal and left
ideologies value more communities of
selection for example not those who
you're born with but those whom you
surround yourselves with okay it's a
very beautiful way of saying that if
there's going to be disruption in a
family and the hurting of parents or
siblings it's going to come from the
left if it's ideologically oriented no I
so that's a bit of a misrepresentation I
you said I don't think why was it a
misrepresentation because I was going to
say those positions in which one would
have to out oneself as an ideological
opposite in cases like New York Times
where they're pulling families and
family oriented events are more than
likely going to be consulting
conservative oriented families with
liberals as the antithesis to this or
excuse me not the end of this is the the
outlier well I must say in America today
even liberals still have Thanksgiving
and Christmas dinners we're not talking
about Ash Wednesday but you know so I
think it's fair to say that this is
fairly dormant but okay it's again an
example where we might get let's go to
another another flashpoint in American
life gender how many genders do you
think there are I think we need to make
an important distinction right off the
bat because we should value clarity
there are two separate topics that are
often conflated with one another in the
same rhetoric there is sex that is
biological that is genitals there is
gender gender is identity gender is how
you perform one's self for example I am
cisgendered I don't think there's a
single individual in this room who would
question predicated on my appearance
that I identify as male that is a sexual
position I also identify as a man that
is my gender identity so to that end I
would say as far as performativity goes
we perform a spectrum of genders okay so
hold on so you agree there are only two
sexes yeah not agree well barring
extreme and correct okay fine right
where person has dual genitals Oh
is fine so there are two sexes but there
is any number of genders yes an
important I think we are also here okay
so here's my response to you is that
first of all gender is used with animals
not just humans Jen we don't ask animals
how they identify is that fair do we
have to agree on something
yeah but I would also fire back on that
that honeybee has performed three
separate genders okay fine so the the
that's awesome I mean if we're gonna
deport any biology no no no right but
when when a when a when a dog is born
yeah you know we don't we don't wait
until it identifies with the gender so
look what is what the left has done in
my opinion is it was always sex when I
was born on birth certificate it not say
gender it said sex so what the left did
this is just a historical fact they
changed the word they dropped the word
sex made a gender so as to be malleable
you may not even realize this but it was
always sex but in any event fine which I
want whatever whatever your ID so it is
what do you think of this in Charlotte
North Carolina teachers were told and
this is now in many communities around
the country that you should too
elementary school teachers first graders
second graders do not refer do not call
to your students boys and girls anymore
because that imposes a gender identity
just call them students do you agree
with that policy I think you and I are
going to reach an agreement on this but
I'd like to follow back with a question
before I answer yes please yeah cool you
are an individual who first and foremost
values the sanctity of individuals right
the individual above all else to express
oneself in performance society as they
desire free well it's not above all else
but it is sacristy yes it is the
individual sacrosanct if an individual
feels as though they express a gender
that is separate from that which is
imposed upon them right do they not then
possess the value of excuse me the
freedom to express themselves as they
totally yeah one has nothing to do with
the other calling first graders boys
girls does not negate a an adult-like
Caitlyn Jenner if I met Caitlyn Jenner I
would refer to Caitlyn as a she but it
might negate individuals in the room who
feel that they align with neither and
importantly I think that Israel
individuality okay so so you think it's
a good policy I think it's a great
policy okay
I think I'll be a bit severe here it's
not that severe against you obviously on
the issue I think it's a form of child
abuse really yes that if Society has
come to the point where for the sake of
a truly truly tiny infinitesimally small
percentage of the population we are
going to abolish the the the joyful
division of the human species into male
and female we have lost our minds that
that's how I look at and I think it's
unfair to kids
you're not until you decide we're not
going to tell you that you're a boy or a
girl I think that is abusive to children
I would fire back then I think it's
abusive to children to force them to
express until such point that they know
how they want to express ok so there's
there's a division would you want to
come it is it what is your take I'm just
curious with John okay not in some ways
we can't I can push our own ideas over
these individuals they are perfectly
allowed to make the choice whenever they
want
right but you this is we're talking
first graders so so in other words so
the New York subway system has dropped
ladies and gentlemen in any of its
announcements they followed the London
tube in doing that because there are no
that implies that we only have ladies
and gentlemen on our subway
whereas we may have ladies and gentlemen
and and others but by the way what I
don't understand is why I don't
understand this if I identify with my
non biological gender or sex it's still
only two genders
I don't understand why this ladies and
gentlemen if Caitlyn Jenner Jen Caitlyn
Jenner is a lady so Caitlyn Jenner has
no issue with ladies and gentlemen so
this is an important distinction I think
this is a lack of clarity that needs to
be understood by all of us here sex and
gender are two things that while they do
correlate with one another because of
how we've structured society to do so
they are not mutually determined gender
does not determine sex just in the same
way that sex does not trim in gender now
I would report back there is an obvious
biochemistry associated with genitals
and general expression that's something
we can't miss it well not just genitals
if you have a uterus and a vagina and
breasts and produce milk and produce
ovaries and have the appropriate
chromosomes we don't have a debate on
what you are yes if you have a debate on
what you are I as a human want to
respect your inner debate yes I don't
have an issue with that but you are
either one or the other
III admit to not being tolerant of I'm
both I and therefore dropping this
division from all frameworks in society
so I can't even say ladies and gentlemen
anymore
so I think that you and I are again
misunderstanding the concept of gender
with regards to one another gender
importantly is determined how you
perform your gender for example the fact
that I am wearing pants such as I am
right now in wearing a suit is
performing something that is an
inherently not male but a man gender
expression the fact that for example if
I were to choose to grow out masculine
facial hair is an expression of being a
man these are socially determined
effects we have ascribed manliness in
the same way that a dress is not
inherently something that is feminine
worth that I wore a dress up here would
only be considered weird because we have
associated that performativity with
being a woman these are socially
determined behaviors there's a question
that I want to pose to you and that's
from an individual issue you cited the
child abuse how why didn't you have a
problem distinctively with dropping the
middle ground between two genders
because there is no middle ground the
the you can you
I respect an individual who has gender
dis for
I have a uterus of vagina breasts I
produce milk I produce ovaries I
menstruate but I identify as a male and
I will dress as a male and I will do
whatever I can to affirm what is
generally associated with male and I'm
changing my name to Harry I will call
you Harry and say he out of respect to
you but I will not but that doesn't in
any way negate that there are men and
women that there is male and female what
we're having today is that there is no
male and female that this is where
gender fluidity now I agree the sexual
orientation fluidity that's a separate
that's completely separate though but
but as to sex there's a flute I don't
want fluidity and gender I am I
understand as fluidity and orientation
but I do not believe in fluidity and
gender it does not make a better society
to obliterate the male/female
distinction and we may simply differ and
that would be another example of where
we differ but please understand for
those who do believe as I do which I
think common sense and values would both
affirm you not you but those who are
doing that are underlining one of the
one of the edifices of civilization that
there is male and female and by the way
I guess we could get to this topic next
is it goes to the religion topic I admit
I get this value from religion which for
you may well be why it's unworthy of a
bothering with but we'll get to that in
a moment but I just want to clarify why
some of us think what the left is doing
to society is is is destructive I can
absolutely understand you coming from
that perspective and seeing how it's
informed for the audience there's
there's this concept in critical
literature it is called epistemology the
epistemology is the field of studying
and seeking to understand why it is and
how it is we know what
No in other words for example science
the scientific method is an
epistemological approach to
understanding truth so is that a clear
concept yes I think you and I are
unfortunately disagreeing on our
epistemological approaches to
understanding what general is now I
understand that your opinion has been
informed by judeo-christian morality and
teachings correct right I was raised
Catholic so Western civilization
generally yeah so let me ask you but the
orb nieces or nephews no okay if you did
would you be comfortable in saying to a
five-year-old niece or nephew listen
Samantha you you may feel that you are a
girl but you don't know for sure you may
in fact decide you're a boy one day so
did you say that I think that's a bit of
a straw man argument why I would respond
back by saying look this child Samantha
she performs female we must understand
okay why are you white right yeah we
ought to interrogate the fact that
everything that she is barage with
everything that she forms herself off of
exists in a gendered binary of her
children's book every children's show
advertising even the behavioral language
that do you ever feel that's unhealthy I
feel that we ought to interrogate why
people form the opinions and thoughts
that they do in other words the Epis
team right that they exist you're not
answering my question
yes is it unhealthy mm-hmm for 99.9% of
the humans of our civilization that we
do have this binary identity I'm going
to tell that child I'm going to tell
this Samantha you are allowed to play
with whatever toys you want wear
whatever clothes make you comfortable
and make you happy you will perform
whatever it is you wish to perform I'm
not going to make you adhere to a
standard that I'm going to Didact down
to you that is in and of itself an
expression of gender identity and I
think we are limited by our
understanding and by our rhetoric to
existing what is made wait why aren't i
limited why isn't it wonderful I
celebrate this division the world is a
better place that we have men and win
in it because if we value the
individuals who don't fall within that
frame I felt we would not exclude them
implicitly from society correct
who but that's that that's a non
sequitur I gonna ask I'm not asking to
exclude them from since I said I honor
whatever the individual will say but you
don't honor than I honor the oo 1% you
don't honor the 99.99 percent I would
disappear taking nothing fancy it's not
more inclusive I would argue destructive
nihilistic I think we take nothing from
these people by trying to include more
people within the framework verses it
takes a huge amount from people to to
not to call kids boys or girl oh no
importantly you can call anyone whatever
you would like oh you already know but
you teachers are told not to call their
kids there is an important distinction
the teachers are the face of an
institution in that context in the same
way that the New York subway the MTA is
the face of an institution yes these
institutions should value all those who
use them and they should be why are you
there oh when they are not when they are
not the face of an institution they may
practice however they want because they
at the end of the day have unfettered
access to free speech and that's
something you and I can agree on but
insofar as they represent an institution
that we all must participate with
importantly if you're in New York you
can't avoid the MTA if you are all
participating within that institution it
should try to be as inclusive as is
possible and if that means dropping
gender from official statements that go
it doesn't include me I am NOT a mere
passenger I am a male it's utterly
unincluded well I think this one
introduces than the vast majority of our
also identify as a lady or gentleman I
think that is I would disagree that
nothing is being taken from you there of
course if you don't think that is a
primary identity of mind male and I
don't want it negated
they don't have children all right well
right we'll take that later anyway okay
I hope to god I don't have children
all right ready to move on okay so the
University of California that I tweeted
this out by the way I
I finally been persuaded I'm now
tweeting regularly as of yesterday so
that is it's not a lord a record but I I
think it now seriously I tweeted out
yesterday and and it got some degree of
attention that the University of
California has issued a list of
microaggressions included among them as
examples is an official statement of
this university not Berkeley the whole
University of California not just
Berkeley and that annex here's an
example of a racist microaggression the
only race I believe in is the human race
do you think that that is a racist
statement either of you okay before we
delve into this I figured we talked
about this so I actually looked at that
tweet you're missing important context
for that statement namely at the top of
this document issued by the University
of California it explicitly says that
these words in their context and not
abstracted from that context can
constitute a microaggression
so if you what how in that one in that
specific I know you and I are gonna
disagree because that's cheating
research on you than you on us okay
that's fair
but seriously what what so give me a
context we're in the only race I care
about or believe in is the human race
yeah absolutely yeah come on if you're
trying to read the rest racial
inequality in a specific circumstance
and you respond back well I understand
what perspective you're coming from if
you are black brown so on and so forth
and I can see that there is a disparity
happening here that correlates to your
racial identity but the only race I
believe in is the human race then that
trivializes important racial
distinctions that have led
- disadvantage is being conferred to
that individual and that while not
explicitly a race a statement and of
itself importantly furthers and
justifies racist systems okay
so I'll ask you a question which just
occurred to me yeah let us say in the
nice heaven in the 18th century all
whites had said the only race I
recognize is the human race do you think
they would have or would not have been
African slavery there is a lot to unpack
in that question I'll respond back by
pointing to the fact that CLR I agree
there is a lot to one but there that so
we are in agreement on that
so CLR James wrote a very interesting
book called the black jacket ins that
details the history of the Haitian
Revolution the only real successful
decolonial slave rebellion in the entire
history of mankind and he talked about
the struggle as first and foremost one
that was of class and the way that class
became weaponized was through the lens
of race so in that context if one were
to say well no the only race and believe
in is the human race there is a distinct
possibility they would have found some
other justification for slavery you can
point for example to indentured
servitude of individuals who are Irish
which at the time now granted were
considered a non-white and in fact
racially distinct from Aryans and
Norwegian people etc Northern Europeans
but there is still far less of a
phylogenetic difference well as it
happens that indenture or indentured
servitude was the way out of poverty for
vast numbers of Europeans and it also
constituted an unfair labor practice
tantamount to only an unfair labor
practice from our perspective today and
judging the past by our perspective is
in my opinion invalid and that is that
is the arrogance of our time here's that
allows us to dismiss great people of the
past like George Washington and and and
that's fair here's how I would respond
to your previous question there is a
fascinating book called race craft by
Barbara and Jane fields I might be
messing up that name and I apologize in
which they investigate the fact that
race is an invented category between
human beings I think we can all agree
that there is no biological basis for a
difference in race and if we don't agree
with that I'm
sorry but I think you have been grossly
misinformed but now that being said
there is a very real effect of the
invention of that race just because race
is invented doesn't mean the
consequences of that invention of race
aren't real for example if you are born
black in the United States you are more
than likely going to be born in a
lower-class positionality than an
individual who is born like myself white
for example that is something that we
very seriously need to redress it
doesn't matter that there is no
difference in race between somebody who
is black and white because race is
invented but the fact of the matter is
the invention of that race has led to
very real non invented consequences and
we need to interrogate those
consequences so if we say the only race
we see in the human race in this context
with our sense contemporary systems of
morality and apply that all right we
count that race had happened so as a
general statement an individual whose
only affirmation of race is the human
race if you think that's an unhealthy
view I think you're ignoring important
facets of history and if we had gone
back in time and said that we would be
in a much better position but the fact
of the matter is we didn't so we need to
adjust like so we reinvent so we would
be in a better position if we got rid of
it today do you think race is inherently
important I think in the present tense
we need to redress the invention of race
what that means is acknowledging the
invented categories of race and
attempting to fix those disparities that
have emerged so yes it is but ultimately
because we want to get rid of racism
meaningful category so you you therefore
obviously would change the criteria for
admission to a college you would lower
the criteria for the historically
oppressed groups if you're asking if I
believe in affirmative action I point to
the fact that that was made illegal with
the Supreme Court case decision that is
in regions what York I'm not asking you
whether it's legal I'm asking you I
think same-sex marriage is legal it is
legal I think not for for so I'm I want
to know if you are for if you are for
changing the rules based on race before
we even get and I'll answer this
question I promise but I'd be building
up to it before we even get to
university admissions we have to
interrogate the fact that black
neighborhoods that are just
disproportionately disadvantaged get
lower quality schooling by virtue of how
we fund our public schools we need to
interrogate the fact that like there is
a serious
representation of certain read certain
racial identities here at this
university and any massive
under-representation of others
especially Hispanics at this university
when compared for example I usually
think that this you think that's a form
of racism or because not enough
Hispanics qualify to get it I think that
is an unfortunate consequence of a
system that has racially selected
against these people and I think we need
to do everything no seriously we need to
do everything in our power to address
that okay that is please please don't
yell out now that that is not just
University Admissions if you think that
Hispanics are under qualified you really
need to look at why you think that is is
it for example the fact that hit
primarily Hispanic univers excuse me
primarily Hispanic neighborhoods are in
fact afforded worse funding when it
comes to their universe into their
schools by virtue of the fact that they
have lower property taxes in these
regions like these are serious causal
chains that we all need to interrogate
when a conservative argues and
conservative black as well as a
conservative white yes argues that the
by far the greatest problem in black
American life is that is the out of
wedlock rate which is approximately
seventy to eighty percent so seven to
eight out of ten black children do not
grow up with a father yeah that that is
infinitely more problematic than white
racism you differ explaining white
racism for me really quick what you mean
by that like to selecting against whites
of the University California no no what
wait you want me to define white races
what do you what do you mean white
racism in this kind okay it the context
is that the Left holds that the problem
facing blacks is racism the greatest
problem facing black Americans is racism
conservatives believe that the greatest
problem is a cultural /values problem I
was though that I'm just asserting that
that is a major difference and I would
assume you would agree that is a major
difference I I would disagree in the
fact that that would be an
overgeneralization of what we're trying
to accomplish at the end of the day
we're looking at how white racism going
back to the 60s and further with black
Americans and Mexican Americans
in this country has draw has pushed them
into the current situation where they
aren't economically represented and in
some ways that is more important and
then like the current form of white
racism because I know what you're trying
to do is bait out a question of whether
or not white White's are directly
responsible for the play for how
Hispanics and people of color in this
country are in ok good please please
save your questions because otherwise
everybody yelled sorry yeah and we need
to we need to look back at how this is a
systemic thing going back in history
rather than like a current form of
racism which is being pushed on people
of color so you think race Trump's
culture I think culture Trump's race
again my agenda this evening is to
delineate the differences black kids who
grow up with both parents have
essentially the exact same economic
outcomes as other kids who grow up with
both parents here's what I would say to
that if there is a disparity in black
and white individuals growing up without
parents or without one parent we
critically need to understand why that's
happening there was a speaker who came
here last semester and for the life of
me I can't remember his name I apologize
but he spoke in poli-sci 179 and one of
the important things he pointed out is
that yes there is a serious disparity in
terms of single family households in the
black community now that is an effect in
part of the fact that these communities
are prime are are grossly over policed
when compared to white communities this
is a statistic wait for what somebody
came to this university and said black
communities are over policed yes I would
respond and if I may then they are over
policed by the least competent police in
American history perhaps universal
history right because the murder rates
in black communities are the highest of
any community in America so if
over-policed communities have the
highest crime rate the police are really
awful I really don't like the implicit
determinism that you're putting forward
in that comment sir what is the deal
there Derrick no no no there may be
inferred determinism but I don't even
know what is determined by what
you don't think there's a higher violent
crime rate in black community you have
to interrogate why those crimes happen
nobody goes out and decides that they
want to murder someone yes they do
people that's exactly why sir let me
clarify that without reason nobody goes
out and decides that they want to murder
someone you are not
excuse me okay Shh go ahead please yeah
don't respond otherwise won't go I
totally get it why you want to yell out
I totally get it barn I will try to do
the yelling for you without yelling okay
go ahead you have to wonder why it is
that violent crime happens violent crime
is not something that's innate to
certain communities because of how
they're structured it is a result of
serious circumstantial disadvantages
that have been conferred upon this
community in the same way that no
individual all right do you know those
black the out of wedlock rate for blacks
in the 40s was actually better than the
out of wedlock rate for whites in the
40s but that was a time of Jim Crow and
far more racism in America yeah maybe
has a looking to do with these
communities sir I'm sorry you have to
look at the over place in the
communities and sending these black
fathers to prison and then they can't be
there to raise their children this is a
thing that actually has also that's what
you owe that is the reason you think
that that that but wait they're not in
prison when they're impregnating your
right and then they're not so they get
into prison during those nine months
this is the thing that's seriously
there's a statistical evidence of this
happening okay dude I don't know what to
tell you okay we got we have such a
different read on their to me okay to me
everything is values I admit it but this
is a major left-right difference values
versus economics values versus race
values versus whatever and that's fine I
think I believe for by the way the out
of wedlock birth rate is increasing
among whites too when when there was a
famous Murphy Brown this is this figure
on American television well had a child
out of wedlock a white woman and it was
a big celebration because it was a very
popular sitcom in the United States or
whatever and the vice-president at the
time who was white like condemned it and
he
was pilloried by the left by the New
York Times and others for his
intolerance his judgmental nature but
this was a white woman having a child
without being married to the father we
believe that it is best that if you have
a child you be married before you have
the child do you think that that is a
fair suggestion to all people of all
races in our society I think generally
speaking it is easy to raise a child
when you have the help of another
individual or another set of individuals
around you to help you right that's
right so you would not you're not
comfortable with what I just said in
that it all things being equal it is
better to be married before having a
child you're uncomfortable with that
statement if you are then let me just
say this is a great example of why we
worry about what's happening to America
you're obviously very bright and you're
you have used your intelligence to undo
that one of the most basic principles of
our civilization get married before you
have a child it's it's like I said it's
just I'm not angry at you God knows and
I and I thank you for participating in
this from the bottom of my heart but I'm
sad I don't what was wrong with these
basic principles that that you act
honestly act responsibly don't commit
crimes have a child after you marry why
is these why does the left 101 do these
things so so here's how I'll respond
back first and foremost I do want to
have kids one day I do want to be a dad
I want to help them come up and wanna be
married their mother I yes I would like
to be married before I have children
because I like the stability that that
confers but I would like to respond back
I earnestly would many people do not
choose to have a child out of wedlock
now granted they're responsible and
their irresponsible practices although I
don't know how to say that claim unless
they're raped they chose it they chose
not have room you when you have sexual
intercourse
here's away way if you have sexual
intercourse there's a good chance you'll
get pregnant especially if you're young
so therefore if you weren't raped you
chose to have sex if you didn't choose
then you were raped we're not talking
about rape we're talking about choosing
to have sex you're right all right and
choosing to have the baby because one
could have an abortion I I want you to
choose to have the baby even if you're
single by the way because of my views on
abortion but that's a separate issue and
by the way my ultimate dream would be
that you gave the child up for adoption
okay so that I just want to say that
that would be my favorite outcome for
most people but I don't see this is what
you remind me of my Jewish relatives who
by definition or liberal and the that
you know what I tell them I tell them I
tell that why don't you preach what you
practice they practice such utterly
traditional lives but then when I preach
that tradition they call it wrong you
for you you want to get married before
you have children I think what if I if I
say well what's good for you would be
good for 99% of fellow Americans and
humanity then all of a sudden you're
uptight about it I don't understand why
is it good for you we're not for
everybody I'd like to finish my thought
with regards to choosing to have a child
primarily unfortunately this United
States has defaulted seriously on its
responsibility for good sexual education
among minors people earnestly need to
know the concept no I'm serious
people earnestly need to know and
understand practices of good start good
stay so they knew better in 1930 when we
out of wedlock rate was so much lower
for all races then they did have better
sex education I would argue that the
culture has changed but on top of that I
would argue that if we're going to meet
that change in culture with responsible
practice of child raising then we need
to have a better sexual education than
we do now and importantly I think
there's a serious problem with the
Republican Party specifically with
preventing the education of sex in
schools I think there also is a serious
problem in terms of preventing access to
contraceptives for example that prevents
access to contraceptive your defund
Planned Parenthood you're taking away a
series vector whatever people have
access to all right
how much does a contraceptive cost I
have to admit I haven't bought one
recently but I but I I'm in that quaint
state of marriage and and but I just I
how much a series how much is a country
several dollars but several dollars to
you and me is not several dollars to
another so you believe that's the issue
but again why is it the issue today and
it wasn't the issue fifty and a hundred
years ago that's what I don't understand
there was less sex education and less
money and much fewer condoms to answer
your question how much contraceptives
cost ten dollars for a box of three
condoms and forty dollars for a plan b
pill he knows his stuff all right man
all right okay all right I gotta I have
Mike I'm an answered question now I'll
promise I'll call on you I I am gonna
ask you a question now that was a
turning point in my radio career I I
began broadcasting thirty-five years ago
and I was in my early 30s and I rape
--fill to God and through locked into a
whole host of things that I'm I've had
such a long career it's not easy in the
media but I remember what happened one
night I just thought it a nighttime
radio which is the norm and I had a show
you just called in on anything and I got
into an argument with a caller on why
people commit crimes violent crimes and
then after we debated I said it was
values he said it was poverty so we
debated debated and then it occurred to
me to ask him this question he said sir
do I ask you do you believe people are
basically good and he said yes I do and
then I realized and it changed my career
for internally had no effect on me
professionally but it changed the way I
understood life and I realized of course
I don't believe people are basically
good I have the judeo-christian view of
human nature which is very it's not that
it's pure evil that's that's it that's
not true it's but a a it's objectively
not
there is goodness in human nature and
being that it's not the judeo-christian
view or the Jewish or Christian view but
we have a very low opinion of human
nature if you don't fight it you won't
be good so do you believe people are
basically good yeah yeah I'm gonna go so
far as to say that yeah everyone around
us generally speaking does not want to
be a bad person barring again some
extreme edge cases I think we're all
just misunderstanding what it is to be
good to one another and how we should
best respect one another's wants in ways
okay this is really important and I'm
very grateful how do you feel about that
saying and I see right in some ways
though I do ask the question whether or
not viewing ourselves as good or evil is
really a possibility because at the end
of the day we are it's much more of a
subject of what our actions is in some
ways we can't call ourselves genuine I
agree with you I agree with that we are
our actions I agree with you entirely so
if you if you primarily do good things
you're a good person you primarily do
bad things or a bad person and and if
you do 50/50 you're in the middle all
right that's fine but that's not the
issue the question was human nature so
so okay this this is Rick you are
affirming the the revelation that I had
that night that's the question that
really divides us because if you believe
that people murder and rape primarily
because of poverty / racism or just that
that time it was just poverty even then
I realized well I don't think that I
think people murder and rape and steal
did did Bernie Madoff did he embezzled
billions of dollars because of poverty
or racism no he did because of arrogance
and because of a whole host of other bed
aspects to his character it was a flawed
character we how many parents say to
their kids you know I just want you to
know you share too much you have to
learn to be a little more selfish I
think that's pretty rare parents tell
their kids approximately a hundred
thousand times
say thank you because being grateful one
of the most important characteristics of
goodness doesn't come naturally why
would you believe in the light of these
basic things and I actually have an
answer I have a theory but I'm not going
to put words in your mouth I'll wait
till you finish why would you believe
people are basically good in the light
of what I just said in the light of the
Holocaust the Armenian Genocide the
Communist genocides of China and North
Korea and the Soviet Union and the vast
amount of abuse of women and children on
earth why would you still believe people
are basically good I have a theory why
you believe it but I won't say it until
you answer it
so I'll respond back by first and
foremost saying perhaps I oversimplified
my perspective I at the end of the day
I'm kind of a sucker for Cooper Foucault
I mean he taught at Berkeley so it's
it's kind of a given I think that to
interrogate human nature is to take too
much away from the fact that our
character is socially determined
I think earnestly Bernie Madoff and
sought to and by not to put motivations
in his mouth because God knows I can't I
I think he sought to embezzle and to
steal in spite of not needing it because
socially he was told to accumulate and
accumulate and accumulate lead and be
the consequences I don't think he's an
innately bad person I think he has a bad
character I just think that is a product
of his upbringing in some of the mores
that he was told to participate with
them now I like to imagine that human
beings are basically good creatures that
want to follow the categorical
imperative that wants to follow the
Beatitudes that wants to do unto others
as they do unto themselves because we as
human beings critically have empathy we
understand what it is to be around
people and understand that broadly
speaking they feel and much of the same
manners that we do now that being said I
would call that empathy something that
is innately good but I would also say
that that is something that can very
easily be overpowered by a society that
tells you danby the rest of them I will
do for me so America is more responsible
for Bernie Madoff than Bernie Madoff I
think Bernie Madoff at the end of the
day is responsible for his own actions
but we need to know why he took those
away so that we can prevent stole doing
in the few in in Papua New Guinea
you don't think men are achieving other
men like he did I don't know anything
about Hapuna well I do but it doesn't
matter I just think that I alright yeah
so here is my theory on why you think
people are basically good okay because
you live in America which is a basically
good country and you don't have a
universal understanding of how crappy
the human races Oh trust me I like for
no understanding of house property human
races I've honestly seen it
I really have if I only lived in America
the odds are against it you don't know
how crappy I repeat you don't know how
crappy the human race is I would fire
about you this is interrogate the
circumstances of those individuals okay
for example if you see crappiness in
Syria that might be an effect to the
fact that they're going through a civil
war yeah of course that's true we went
through a civil war too and there was a
lot of bad stuff that happened
absolutely what in war bad things happen
we understand that but the fact of the
matter is human Bloods got better
because they're MP but Syria was crappy
before the Civil War
yeah I'm not I'm not gonna I'm not gonna
talk okay fine
okay so now it's time we had do we have
microphones what's the story oh my god
we are alright thank you every year okay
everybody
thank you so much
[Applause]
[Applause]
can we get one more round of applause
for the great dennis prager ladies and
gentlemen thank you all for coming have
a safe trip home and I will see you in
April for Rick Santorum
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
