5 of the Creepiest Unsolved Mysteries

Mysteries Around Me
175 followers
Kevin Wynn, who was 25 at the time, went missing in the early hours of December 9th, 2018.
His family said he was kicked out of a bar called the Brass Rail on Broadway after an altercation,
and that's the last they've seen or heard from him.
Family, friends, and strangers have been hoping to find him or hear from him ever since.
The following Sunday, nearly 150 volunteers and family members gathered at Lakeside Park
to continue the search. The family searched the banks of the St. Joseph and St. Mary's rivers,
and also the area around the Brass Rail.
The following Thursday, they found his glasses broken in the parking lot of the bar.
Kevin's family stated that his vision was very bad and the fact that his glasses were broken
and left behind was a very bad sign, and there's no way he'd be able to make his way around without
seeing. Management at the bar told the family that Kevin had entered the bar four times the
night he went missing. There's an Arby's down the road from the bar that had given the family two
videos. They show Kevin walking by the restaurant alone, one around 1.40 in the morning, the other
around 2.45 in the morning. The Brass Rail has given their surveillance video to detectives.
But after two long years with no word, the family has become less hopeful.
Many people believe he had broken his glasses and without his vision,
simply stumbled into the river and drowned. But if this were the case,
the body would have been found during the multiple searches of the river,
or at the very least, the body would have been washed up somewhere by now.
In 2002, Michaela Lawrence, who was 12 at the time and her entire family,
received news that her father had been in a fatal car accident. His body was barely
recognizable from the wreck. The family, of course, opted for a closed casket funeral.
A few weeks after the funeral, things started appearing in the mailbox of the Lawrence
household. Small packages with Michaela's name written on them. The packages would come once
every few weeks. The first package was a small knickknack type item. It was a decorative model
glow-up Big Ben clock statue. It was a familiar piece that Michaela's mother recognized from the
house somewhere. A few weeks later, another package came. This package contained an old
antique stopwatch from the 50s. It didn't work anymore, but once again, it looked familiar to
Michaela's mother. None of the packages said who they were from or where they came from.
A few more weeks later, on Michaela's 13th birthday, a card in an envelope ended up in
the mailbox, and written on it was Michaela's name again. The card was a happy birthday card,
but once again, the mother recognized this card and the handwriting was familiar. It was the
handwriting of her thought-to-be deceased husband, but it was a card that the couple had given to
their daughter years ago, and it was signed Love Mom and Dad. This confirmed her suspicions that
the items that had been arriving in the mail were possessions from the house, those of her husband's.
She tried to check the safe in the bedroom closet to see if anything was missing,
but mysteriously the safe combination no longer seemed to work no matter how many times she tried.
She tried going to the police about the packages at her house, but police couldn't do anything
except advise to install some kind of security system. To this day, it's not known who sent
the packages or how whoever sent them got a hold of them.
Frauke Leibs disappeared on June 20, 2006, from the town Paderborn in Germany.
Her body was found almost four months later, on October 4, 2006. The circumstances of her
disappearance are mysterious, especially since she's believed to have made contact with her
friends between her disappearance and her death. 2006 was the year of the Football World Cup in
Germany. Frauke met with some friends at the Old Triangle Irish Pub in downtown Paderborn to watch
some of the games. Her mom dropped her off at the pub around 9pm. During the Sweden-England match,
she exchanged text messages with an acquaintance until the battery of her cell phone ran out.
She then borrowed the battery of her friend, but the friend said that she returned the battery
before leaving. At about 11pm, Frauke left the bar. It's assumed that she walked home because
she was said to only have about 5 euro on her at that point. Her flat was about one mile away from
the pub. Nobody knows which path she took because nobody saw her after she left the pub. Her flat
At 12.49am, her roommate received a text from Frauke, which stated that she'd be back late.
She did not appear at work the following day, and after she was not in the apartment,
Frauke's mother reported her missing. Over the next few days, Frauke contacted her roommate
five times over cell phone. The calls were usually short and during the evening hours,
and did not contain a lot of information about her situation. In the first calls,
she hinted that she would come back soon, but answered further questions evasively or
mysteriously. The last phone call was received on the evening of June 27th, while Frauke's sister
was present. Frauke got asked by her sister if she was held against her will, and she supposedly said
yes, but then immediately corrected herself by saying no in a louder tone. After that,
the contact to Frauke was lost. According to police, during these phone calls, Frauke's
was in various industrial zones of Paderborn. The police also assumed that the calls were
placed from within a car that was driven to those areas. The case was never solved.
Jack Wheeler held many important positions throughout his lifetime. He was a chairman for
the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund, a senior planner for Amtrak, an official of the Securities
and Exchange Commission, and more. His value to his community made it much worse when Jack
disappeared on December 28th, 2010, after exiting an Amtrak near Wilmington, Delaware.
He was later seen on December 30th at 10th and Orange Street in Wilmington. On December 31st,
his body was discovered by a landfill worker as it fell onto a trash heap in the Cherry Island
landfill. His death was later ruled a homicide. His death was ruled to be due to assault and blunt
force trauma. It was determined that all of the stops the garbage truck had made that day involved
large commercial disposal bins in Newark, a few miles from Jack's home.
Prior to Jack's death, he was sighted several times. On December 29th, he was sighted at the
Newcastle County Courthouse parking garage. He was disoriented and wearing only one shoe.
He tried to gain access to the garage on foot, claiming that he wanted to warm up before paying
the parking fee. He told the attendant that his briefcase had been stolen, and he kept
claiming that he wasn't intoxicated, but the attendant didn't believe him. It was later
determined that his car was in a different garage. This was the last CCTV footage taken of him.
Later that day, Jack asked a pharmacist in Newcastle for a ride to Wilmington.
He reportedly looked upset at the time. The pharmacist offered to call him a cab.
He then left the store. On December 30th, he was seen wandering around various office buildings.
Several people asked if he needed help, but he refused any assistance.
This case has still never been solved.
Lastly, we have the disappearance of Brian Schaefer. In 2006, Ohio State student Brian
Schaefer went into a bar and never came out. He was out with two friends one night, and they
went to a bar called the Ugly Tuna Saloona. This bar had a front main entrance and a back entrance
for staff and entertainment, both of which had cameras pointed at them. Around 10pm that night,
Brian called his girlfriend to tell her that he loved her. Soon after, Brian is seen on camera
entering the bar, and then later seen stepping out of the bar to talk to two girls before going back
inside. Minutes before the bar closed and they were preparing to leave, Brian told his friends
he was going to talk to the band. Brian walked away out of sight and his friends waited for him,
but he was never seen again. This was not a large bar, and the band does not remember
talking to him. On top of it, the cameras never caught him exiting the bar. No one knows what
happened to Brian after he walked away from his friends, or how he left the bar, or if he ever did
for that matter. An FBI agent who was specialized in facial recognition spent a long time analyzing
the security footage of the bar and watched every person who came in and out of the venue.
He never identified Brian leaving, but years later, after he had stopped working on the case,
he was at an Ohio State football game and saw someone across the crowd that he couldn't help
but think looked very much like Brian. In fact, he bore such a resemblance to Brian that the agent
had to go and talk to him. It turned out it was Brian's brother, proving just how good the agent's
facial recognition abilities were. Brian's girlfriend called his cell phone every day for
weeks, and it always went straight to voicemail until one night when it actually rang three times,
then went to voicemail. This was unexplainable. The truly weirdest part about this whole thing
is that the last footage of Brian was him re-entering the bar. No footage was ever found
of him leaving the bar, which has led to theories that he never did leave. To this day, no one knows
where he is.
