Gerrit Cole Is DONE And The Yankees Officially Look Screwed

Baseball Channel
134 followers
It's amazing how quickly things can fall.
The Roman Empire, the Galactic Empire, the New York Yankee Empire, if you want to call
it that.
I mean, we're coming off a season where this team had Aaron Judge and Juan Soto hitting
back to back.
MLB The Show 25 rankings are out, and there are only three players with a max overall
of 99.
Two of those three are Judge and Soto.
They had both of them, and went to the World Series with both of them, along with Garrett
Cole, who after having a delayed start to his season, came back and was shoving it up
the Dodgers ass, ready to take what was once a 3-0 Dodgers series lead back to LA and potentially
give Dave Roberts a taste of his own 2004 medicine, only for it all to come completely
crashing down.
Within a couple hours, everyone's season was over, and in a matter of about a month, Juan
Soto would leave to go across town to the other New York team, on a record contract
that we all thought was the most money offered to him.
But according to what Soto himself recently said, it wasn't.
Other teams offered him more.
I remember hearing the Red Sox offered him $700 million before it was revealed by David
Ortiz they didn't even cross $600.
Every offer reported was less than the Mets, but apparently there were teams who offered
him more.
Not even just one.
Yes.
Teams.
Plural.
I don't know what to believe anymore.
You could tell me Elmo did 9-11, I'd believe it.
Well, about two and a half months after that, after Soto signed, not 9-11, things have only
gotten worse.
And by worse, I mean a lot worse.
Okay, now I feel like a tone-deaf dick since I just referenced 9-11.
That was a lot worse.
Okay, back to the Yankees.
Really quick as always, if you're part of the 51% of viewers not subscribed yet, go
ahead and hit that button if you enjoy the videos, as I knew it all along.
I knew it.
Last year, when Garrett Cole had to halt his spring training, stop pitching, and start
his season later than most because of elbow issues, I knew that wasn't the end.
And not because I'm some psychic, although people do give me the credit of having magical
powers to jinx their team, so I appreciate that.
But because elbow problems don't just magically go away.
Just because Garrett Cole didn't have to get Tommy John surgery a year ago, didn't
mean he was good for good.
Just like me waiting to do my taxes, you're delaying the inevitable.
Credit to Cole, he came back and finished strong, well, mostly strong.
But if the Yankees had any plans of banking their success on Cole being more like his
Cy Young winning 2023 self, that would be insanely ignorant to do.
No pitcher can be banked on nowadays.
The saying has always been that you can never have enough pitching, and that just couldn't
be more true in 2025, and that goes for anybody, no matter who it is.
Even a guy like Garrett Cole, without much of an injury history in his career, never
having to get Tommy John surgery in his life, never having any ultra serious arm issues
in his 12 years of dominance.
As great as all that is, if anything, that just means he's all the more likely to have
arm issues any year now.
Last year was the preview, this year was the real thing, and after more pain this spring,
the conclusion is that he needs Tommy John surgery, which of course knocks him out for
all of this season, and at least a good chunk of next.
So where do the Yankees go from here?
Well, first what you're looking at here is a live look at Rafael Devers upon hearing
this news.
Yeah, he's going through it right now.
Next, the answer to that question of where the Yankees go from here would be a lot more
simple if it was just Cole going down, but unfortunately he's not the only problem.
After finding out the team traded for the man who's currently married with children
with his ex, Giancarlo Stanton smashed both of his elbows.
Now in all seriousness, Stanton has not been right though.
Both of his elbows are somehow toast, and what makes it worse is not what reporters
or any rumors are saying, but what the big man himself has said.
He's what's made his injuries sound the worst, calling the issues in both his elbows severe,
and attributing the injuries to bat adjustments from last season, which I found pretty interesting
because like, how do both your elbows get that bad?
Especially a guy like Stanton who only hits now, so he doesn't throw it all in the outfield.
So I guess something to do with his hitting, I mean it makes sense, how else would he do
it?
But he didn't make anything sound positive at all.
He's already starting the season on the injured list, and if he needs surgery, which
it seems like he likely will, he said himself it would be season ending.
So sticking with the hitting, Juan Soto is long gone, let's pencil out Giancarlo Stanton
for the year.
There's this tweet out there that claim the Yankees are genuinely one Aaron Judge
toe stub away from being the 2024 White Sox, followed by the tune of Jared Karabas with
the classic,
Why you fooling me?
I'm right!
And is it a joke?
Of course.
But is there also some truth to that?
Yeah, there is.
Last year was so weird for the Yankees offensively, because like I said, they had two of the best
hitters in the game, the top two MVP finishes in the American League, and then everyone
else was bad.
It was very similar to the 2022 Yankees, just at a grander scale.
Instead of the Yankees having an otherworldly Aaron Judge on an otherwise overall lackluster
offense, the Yankees now had another worldly Juan Soto and Aaron Judge on an otherwise
overall lackluster offense.
Stan was solid last year.
He did miss a lot of games, but also made up for it in October with how awesome he was.
But other than that, the offense was not good.
It's pretty simple math.
I'm stupid and I think I understand it.
So you're taking two of the Yankees best hitters from them this year, leaving them with just
Judge.
If he goes down, this offense really isn't that much different than last year's White
Sox.
Yeah, it would be better, but would it be that much better?
It speaks to a larger issue about the Yankees, at least offensively.
They haven't had a balanced offense in a long time.
They've built it to really rely heavily on one or two guys, and that's just obviously
not smart to do as great as those one or two guys can be.
Yeah, I think Cody Bellinger is solid.
The right field short porch seems perfect for him, but he's also not at all the same player
he was years ago.
It's been a long time.
He's way more consistent now.
I do like Jess Chisholm.
I feel like he can definitely be one of the better hitters on the team.
But then again, if that's one of your best hitters, I don't I mean, I don't know if that's
a good thing with the context of who else is on the team.
And also based off Jazz's career so far, they added your local high school's history teacher
to play first base for some reason.
And oh, oh, sorry, that's Paul Goldschmidt.
Look, the point is, this offense has little depth.
Aaron Judge has got to stay healthy the entire year.
And with the pitching, Luis Hill, last year's rookie of the year and a guy who the team
tried to trade for Kyle Tucker this past offseason, is going to be out for at least three
months because of shoulder issues, which sounds like the best case scenario, three months.
Well, they no longer have Garrett Cole or Luis Hill for a while, but all that is definitely
easier to swallow for Yankees fans when they remember they have Marcus Stroman.
Great practical joke, Jim, got me go to the annex.
So the rotation to begin the season looks as follows.
Max Freed, who's, of course, great, but he doesn't have the most comfortable injury history
either. Carlos Rodon, who has been nothing near what he was before signing in New York
since signing in New York.
Clark Schmitt, who hasn't proven himself yet.
That's the Yankees number three starter.
Marcus Stroman really went from the outside looking into the number four starter.
So, I mean, hey, hats off to him.
He just continues to prove me wrong every day.
Then there's Will Warren, who then there's CeCe Sabathia for some reason.
I mean, a Yankee rotation that people were calling one of the best in baseball is quickly
turned in a concerning one.
The bullpen, at least in theory, has a strong back end.
But the same can be said for any girl on a hinge.
Got to actually see this play out to see if it's legit.
I mean, who's to say Luke Weaver won't fall right back to earth after being good for the
first time in his life last year?
I mean, hey, if he's great, plus the addition of Devin Williams, obviously that could be
really good. But again, Weaver just finally had a good year after eight years in the
league. Not the first guy to trust to be consistent right now, probably made a good
work. But again, they're just banking a lot on not that many guys.
I think what this is all continuously showing is how wide open the AL East is.
The Blue Jays have some good players, but they don't look strong overall.
The Orioles fell apart offensively at the end of last year and didn't really improve at
all. Only losing players like Corbin Burns was their best pitcher last year.
The Rays are homeless now with all these Yankee injuries.
Look, I'm not predicting the Red Sox to win the American League East, but just just
just remember this moment.
But no, really, I mean, it's a division getting more up for grabs every day.
And for the Yankees specifically, I'm not full on writing them off.
And I don't think anybody should do that.
They still, in theory, probably should make the postseason and have a chance to win the
division again with how winnable it seems in general.
But with the way they're built, again, without much depth, they really can't afford any more
serious injuries.
And they've definitely fallen off as any favorites for the division.
It'll be interesting to see what trades they shoot for, if any.
But overall, with all the losses they've already suffered now, Garrett Cole confirmed done
for the year. This team is really in trouble, just like me trying to hit an MLB the show.
I'll be streaming a lot of this year's game along with Shohei Otani and Fortnite.
So go hit the link in the comments below to follow me over on Twitch if you're into that
sort of thing. And thank you for watching.
