Phillip Magness: Did Trump's Tariffs Just Supercharge a Recession?

Smart Money
8 followers
Dr. Phillip Magness of @independentinstitute discusses the impact of US President Donald Trump's latest round of tariffs, outlining their potential effects on the American economy and stock market.
""This could be the event that supercharges us into a recession — it could be the major trigger,"" he said.
❓ Will tariffs trigger a US recession? Tell us in the comments!
This interview was filmed on April 4, 2025.
#Investing #Tariffs #Economy
0:00 - Intro
0:18 - History of US tariff usage
3:59 - Are tariffs a bargaining chip?
6:17 - Unpacking the tariff formula
8:34 - Will tariffs cause inflation?
12:53 - US economy, stock market
15:58 - Gold remains a safe haven
17:30 - New trade ties to emerge?
20:57 - Still time to reverse course
23:48 - Outro
I'm Charlotte McLeod with InvestingNews.com and here today with me is Dr. Phil Magnus.
He's the David J. Thoreau Chair at the Independent Institute.
Thank you so much for being here.
Great to have you.
Yeah, happy to be here.
Really good to be speaking with you.
I think it's the perfect time because we are going to hone in on what's going on with tariffs
today.
So this is a hot topic for sure right now and it's an area where you have a lot of knowledge.
So we'll get into current events, but before we go there, I'm wondering if we can talk
a little bit about the history of tariff usage in the U.S.
I know that's a really, really big topic, so we'll see what we can do.
But I think people will be, they'll remember what Trump did with tariffs in his previous
term.
But if we look way back in history, we can definitely see ebbs and flows in how tariffs
were used.
So let's start there.
Absolutely.
So it actually dates all the way back to the Declaration of Independence.
If you read the grievances against King George, one of them was that he has disrupted our
trade against the rest of the world, the right of the colonists to trade freely with the
rest of the world.
So when the Constitution was written, this was very much on everyone's minds.
In 1787, they draft a clause of the Constitution that allows Congress to have the power to
impose taxes, excises, imposts, and duties.
Encompassed in that are what we refer to now as tariffs.
And the reason behind it, the original reason, was they needed to raise revenue for the new
government, the national government.
And tariffs are a relatively easy way to assess taxes because they have a single collection
point at the port, at the border.
And that's where all goods come through, so you assess a fee on it.
But that basically created the first tax system of the United States is a tariff system.
And really up until 1913, when we switch over to the income tax, tariffs are the dominant
revenue source of the federal government.
Okay, really interesting.
And I'm wondering if you can talk a little bit more about that relationship between tariffs
and government revenue and that switch over to income tax, because that feels pretty important
to understand what's going on right now.
Yeah.
So the tariff system, it was suited for the 19th century.
It raised enough revenue in most years to pay for the federal government.
But they'd also had another problem associated with it.
It attracted lobbyists and special interests who wanted favorable rates carved out for
their own sector of the economy, their industry.
It could be the iron or steel industry in some cases, other places it's textiles.
And it's basically every time that they revise the tariff schedule, they change the tax rates,
they descend on Washington like vultures and start lobbying their local representative
to give them a favorable rate that either allows them to have a greater ease at accessing
raw materials, or the more common one is to penalize their competitors abroad.
So if I'm a Pennsylvania iron mill, or Pennsylvania steel mill by the end of the 19th century,
I want a tariff put in place against British steel.
They're my competitors abroad, because then I can charge higher prices at home.
And what really happened, it all comes to a head in 1909.
There's a tariff schedule revision.
President Taft asks Congress in his annual message, he says, I'm tasking you with revising
and modernizing tariff schedule.
All the lobbyists descended on Washington, DC, and it turned into a corrupt free-for-all.
So much of a backlash against it, that in fact, members of the Taft's own party, the
Republicans were in control of that time, started to defect and said, maybe we need
a different revenue system.
And that's where the income tax amendment is born.
Okay, so we've spent a little bit of time looking backward.
I don't want to spend too, too much time on history, though, because there's so much going
on today that we should also cover.
So looking at today, this has been a pretty wild week in terms of Trump and the whole
tariff situation.
So starting with an overview of what's going on here, does Trump want to have all these
tariffs in place, or is this a negotiating tactic?
I'm wondering what you think is the end game here.
That's the great mystery that I think everyone is confounded with in Washington right now
is because he keeps switching between the two or three different rationales.
And we've seen this since he took office back in January.
He announced he was going to do tariffs, but he didn't, he wasn't really clear on why he
wanted to do tariffs.
Sometimes he says it's to protect and rebuild American industry.
Other times he says it's to raise tax revenue to offset the deficits.
And then in other cases, he says it's a negotiating tactic to try to get foreign countries to
change their trade practices with the United States in some cases, but he's also ventured
into other policies.
Sometimes he says, I'm putting tariffs in place to penalize Mexico, for example, for
immigration enforcement, or he claims there's a drug trade coming out of Canada and he wants
them to do things.
But he has vacillated back and forth between these five or six different reasons.
No one really understands or knows what the permanent end game is supposed to be.
What we saw earlier this week is just great market uncertainty because even up until the
minute that he rolled out the rates, no one quite knew what the tariff rates were supposed
to be.
They didn't know if he was going to go big, go modest and just try to walk it back as
a negotiating tactic, or if he was actually going to put in extremely high rates.
And unfortunately what we got were very, very high rates.
Some as high as 50 or 60% against other trading partners, and then a baseline international
rate of 10% against all tariffs.
And to give you some perspective, that baseline of 10% is about three times what the previous
average tariff rate was before Trump took this action.
Okay.
So that's what's going on right now.
And talking about those calculations, I think probably many people have seen that very interesting
formula that's come out.
So wondering if you can talk about that.
What do you make of that?
Because I'm not such a math person.
So to me, that looks very complicated.
Yeah.
So they intentionally made it look complicated because what they published on the White House
website and they circulated to the press was a picture with all these Greek letters.
And it looks like it's something out of a science journal.
Some economists do use this type of formal expression, mathematical expression, but I
liken it to dressed up alchemy, even.
I mean, I use that very intentionally as a term, because it turns out the Greek letters
are actually just stand-ins for very simple numbers, very simple calculations.
And one of those calculations is, so they use concepts from economists we refer to as
price elasticity.
And two of those Greek letters are offsetting elasticity measures.
They measure, they basically multiply the number four, which is one of their parameter
assumptions by the number 0.25, which is their other parameter assumptions, four times 0.25
equals one.
So it has absolutely no effect.
The Greek letters are just in there for window dressing.
And what it comes down to is they came up with a improvised formula to get Trump the
numbers that he wanted.
And that improvised formula mistakes the use of the trade deficit, the difference between
imports and exports within dual country for the tariff rate, and basically just subtracts
those two and then divides it into itself.
And you get these numbers that are just basically drawn out of thin air with the only pretext
being that he wants to justify higher tariff rates on specific countries.
Yeah, I think if the intent was to confuse, certainly that happened.
So essentially you're saying we started with the end result and then went backwards to
figure out the calculation.
They decided what they wanted to do, and then they made a formula to fit what results they
sought essentially.
Very tricky.
So looking more at this whole tariff situation, I know this week and leading up to it, there's
been a lot of concerns that these are going to be inflationary for the U.S.
So curious to get your take there.
What do you see coming and what what historically have tariffs meant for inflation?
Right.
So tariffs, they have a complex relationship with inflation because, you know, there can
be distortive effects that alter the price level.
And that's the traditional definition of inflation is a change in the price level.
I actually think the inflation discussion is a little bit of a canard here for a much
more precise micro level effect on prices.
So what tariffs essentially do is they're a tax.
They're a tax on goods as they cross the border.
And they work in two ways.
One, you can actually pay the tax, which collects revenue for the federal government.
Or two, if the tariff is so high, it changes the import pattern to seeking a domestic producer,
a domestic company that makes the same or a very similar product at a higher price.
So either if it's either the tax collected tariff or the trade diversion effect, the
protective effect of the tariff, they have the same tendency here.
They raise prices on domestic products.
And the burden of that is passed through by companies that are purchasing things eventually
into the lap of the consumer.
So what it means is if you are buying a toaster oven or a refrigerator or a new car that uses
steel and aluminum as raw material inputs, the production of those products is now going
to be more expensive because there's a tariff on steel or there's a tariff on aluminum.
And rather than absorbing that on the company side, they pass it through to consumers in
terms of higher prices.
So what it means is if you're looking to buy a new car next year, it's probably going to
be significantly more expensive because now it encompasses the price of that tariff on it.
So you see micro-level increases in prices on individual targeted products that are subject
to the tariff.
Okay.
And speaking about industry, let's talk a little bit more about that because that's
one of the possible Trump goals here is to bring more industry manufacturing into the
U.S. and boost that.
So if I'm understanding, so we do get that in this situation, but then also the higher
prices.
Exactly.
So it's all a trade-off.
And this is the model he used in his first term.
So remember in 2018, he put tariffs in place on steel and he suggested this was a national
security justification, which might be a possible argument here because China is a
major steel producer.
Although this time around, he's targeting Canadian and Mexican steel, not Chinese steel
because it turns out America imports very little steel from China.
Mostly gets it.
It's either domestically produced in the United States or it's imported from Canada and Mexico
or the major other producers.
But what's going on here is Trump is saying he's doing this on behalf of the American
steel industry to try to bring the companies home, to try to reshore them and revitalize
American steel.
There is something of an effect there because the steel industry, higher prices will benefit
it.
Higher prices from that tax or from that trade diversion will benefit the steel industry.
But the question is, what's the net overall effect?
Because if it helps 10,000 steel workers, creates 10,000 new steel jobs, but it costs
150,000 jobs in other industries that use steel for higher prices, then on net it's
harmful.
And that's the big concern here because historical instances when we've done this, they've been
very beneficial to the steel industry, but they cost other sectors of the economy significantly
higher prices.
And people respond to that, like automobile manufacturers, they respond to that by laying
off workers.
And we've already seen that.
The major U.S. automobile manufacturers have announced in anticipation of higher steel
and aluminum prices, they're going to do temporary layoffs of factories that were operating just
a few months ago.
This is clearly very complex, and I'm going to ask you another big question.
We'll see what we can do to address it.
So what is your outlook then in this situation for the U.S. economy?
Because we've had these inflation concerns.
There's also recession concerns that have been in the background for a while.
Now they're kind of coming more to the forefront.
What do you see coming?
Well, this is the great risk we're facing.
And this is why everyone's sitting on edge here, is because this could be the event that
supercharges us into a recession.
It could be the major trigger.
We know historically, one thing that the United States did on the outset of the Great Depression
in 1929, you know, the stock market crashed first.
That's the first event that triggers everything.
Everyone knew that problems were on the horizon.
And Congress thought, well, we're going to have basically a stimulus package, a 1929-style
stimulus package, was to wall up the American economy and protect it from foreign competition.
So in 1930, they passed a tariff, but it backfired.
Rather than protecting the United States, it just triggered a trade war with other countries,
and they retaliated against us.
And within the course of about four years, the whole volume of international trade just
disappeared.
It dried up, and it thrust us even deeper into a recession.
So that's the nightmare scenario.
I don't think we're quite there yet, because this is too new.
But we've had, just as of this morning, we've had two successive days of very, very catastrophic
drops in the stock market, and really the industry-specific sectors of the stock market.
You look at the S&P 500, that on top of the Dow Jones, both of them are way, way down
because of this tariff announcement, and it's almost exclusively that.
Okay, so that gives us some idea of the very, very bad case scenario for the U.S. economy.
Anything further you would say about what's going on in the stock market right now?
Because I know that's a big area of concern for investors.
Yeah.
So unfortunately, the way that Trump has rolled this out has not helped him.
When he started talking about tariffs back in January, and then it started flip-flopping
between all these different rationales, it not only creates the fear of higher prices
from the tax effect of the tariff, it also creates uncertainty.
So if you are a manufacturer and you have to order aluminum as a raw material for six
months from now to plan what you're going to make in your factory, you don't know what
the price is going to be.
And if the price changes every two weeks because there's a different tariff announcement,
or it changes every 24 hours because he threatens one and walks it back, it creates uncertainty.
So for the last two months, the markets have just kind of been teetering on the edge
of something bad could really happen.
And then what happened with the so-called Liberation Day announcement is it confirmed
some very, very high tariffs were about to be put into place,
and the market reacted in extremely negative ways that still seem to be rippling out.
I don't know what extent you can talk about this, but I think for investors, they're looking
at this, they're wondering, okay, where are places of safety that I can go right now?
Any thoughts there?
So the interesting thing that, you know, the conventional safe storage place in any time
of economic turmoil, precious metals.
And we've seen that in the gold price.
It actually, not so much since the tariffs, but in the weeks leading up to the tariff
announcement, gold surpassed $3,000 an ounce.
It has been a very, very robust market.
We hear anecdotes like Costco is having trouble keeping ounces of gold in stock because so
many people are ordering it.
And I think there's actually a sound reason behind this.
Now gold, some of the jitters in the gold market over the last two days, it's leveled
down a little bit, but that's just because the expectation has hit already.
But, you know, these are historical stores of value in the sense that they're a bit more
insulated from the chaos of the stock market.
The fact that maybe six months from now, there could be an entirely new tax that completely
disrupts your supply chain planning.
Gold is actually a precious metal, you can sit there and hold it.
And it's a, another way to put it, it's a type of, it's a store of value that is
relatively immune to the ebbs and flows of politics and politicians meddling in the economy.
So that's why people are turning to it right now.
Yeah, I think if there was ever a time for gold, certainly now is one of them.
So we've been seeing it shine notwithstanding these last couple of days.
So thank you for going into that one.
And we've been talking a lot about the impact on the US of everything that's going on.
I wonder if we can look a little bit more globally.
So we have the US going inward into itself.
And I'm wondering what you see other countries doing in this situation.
Do you see them going inward?
Or maybe they go outward and forge new relationships with countries that aren't the US perhaps?
And that's exactly what we're seeing settle down.
So one of the other interesting things is the European stock market over the last three
months has performed generally better than the US stock market, precisely because they're
not under this daily shifting threat of tariffs.
The question is, what do countries do in response to the fact that they just had maybe
a 50% or 60% tax slapped on them by Trump's order?
Well, there are one of two things they can do.
One is they can try to retaliate by turning around and putting a tax on American goods.
And this is just a race to the economic bottom.
And it's kind of the tit for tat back and forth between overtly hostile economic actions.
And I'm concerned that some countries are actually threatening that.
We saw just this morning China announced new tariffs on the United States in retaliation.
Canada, which had been the subject of the earlier tariff order,
retaliated against the United States.
And I see this as a no-win game for both countries involved.
What it means is they're basically putting their own economies
on the line for a political battle.
And that political battle essentially erodes away.
Now, the other thing you can do is accept the fact that, yes,
the United States is maybe behaving badly in the international arena.
But look for other outlets for your markets.
And there's been some discussion, like one proposal I've seen floated.
And I actually like this.
I think it would be a brilliant idea.
As the United Kingdom, Britain, there's been some discussion.
Should they revive a trade agreement with all of the other countries that are the
various former parts of the British Empire?
So sign a free trade agreement between Great Britain, the United Kingdom proper,
with Canada, with Australia, with New Zealand, with India,
with different parts of the world that are what we now refer to as parts of the Commonwealth
and adjacent countries.
You could create a free trade zone between those.
And that could be a very robust area of economic activity.
Yes, it would leave the US behind and out of it.
But, you know, it's kind of the US's own mistake.
The European Union also has discussed similar things.
And the EU is interesting because it's an assortment.
It's a very large assortment.
It's an entire continent of countries that essentially have existing free trade zones
in between them.
So all EU countries, internally, they have their own customs union, their own market.
The fact that that exists is a much more robust trading block than what happened in 1930,
when Germany, France, England, Switzerland, you name it, Italy are all individual countries,
and they all have their own internal tariff policies against each other,
as well as the United States.
OK, interesting to go into that and get your perspective there.
I think we're almost wrapping up here.
I don't want to keep you too, too long.
But before I let you go, I'll put it back to you.
This is a really complex situation.
And I'm wondering if there are any final takeaways you would share,
things that you want people to know.
I know there's probably a lot of misconceptions that you are used to seeing on this.
Yeah, yeah.
So, I mean, my great message here, the final message would, I hold out hope that the United
States will see some of the most recent policies, particular the so-called Liberation Day order,
as an error and will reverse course.
I think there's still an off ramp where Trump could do that and save face,
realize that it was rolled out in a way that was very clumsy,
rolled out in a way that wasn't really based on sound economics.
It was based on this weird formula that they justified.
If that happens, then actually, I think you start to see some of the stock markets rebound.
You see investor confidence return.
You see uncertainty, which is the looming presence over all of this,
actually start to diminish because people can start expecting the circumstance that they're
going to be in for the foreseeable future.
In other words, I'd say that this policy has been pursued for very needless ways that are going to
be costly to the vast majority of Americans at the benefit of a very, very small few
in certain sectors and industries.
And that's just generally not a good political policy or an economic one in the long run.
So the political consideration is there.
Maybe Trump will see that the stock markets are responding very negatively
and realize that, hey, he needs to do something different, try something different
than this course he set us on and at least salvage or get us back to
a period of economic growth before a recessionary event occurs and sets in.
OK, so we haven't gone over the cliff yet.
We could still walk back from a full-on framework.
There's still a chance to turn around and do a U-turn, do a U-turn because we were,
you know, the economy was not in perfect situation coming into the Trump administration.
We just emerged from a very high period of inflation.
But at the same time, some of the vital signs were very good, stable, at least.
The stock market was increasing.
Unemployment has been low.
And actually inflation, because the Federal Reserve finally acted,
inflation had been pushed back down and held down at a pretty low level.
We just don't want to slip into the risk of really it's the stagflation risk where you
get both economic decline and high inflation and high unemployment and all of those problems
and chaos and uncertainty just increase that risk.
OK, well, really good to go into this with you.
I found it very informative.
So thank you so much for taking the time and I'll let you go.
Hope to have you back in the future because I'm sure things will change
dramatically from time to time.
Absolutely.
Thank you very much.
Once again, I'm Charlotte McLeod with InvestingNews.com and this is Dr. Phil Magnus.
Thank you for watching.
If you like this video, make sure you hit the like button and subscribe to our channel.
We'd also love to hear your thoughts, so leave us a comment below.
