Can Capitalists and Socialists Find Common Ground? Will and Amala LIVE | Speeches and Events

PragerU
799 followers
Apr 1, 2025
[Recorded earlier this week] Will and Amala are back reacting to a Jubilee video which tries to get capitalists and socialists to see eye to eye.
0:00 - Is Will’s Mustache Horrifyingly Ugly?
3:19 - Can Capitalists and Socialists Find Common Ground?
5:22 - Are Humans Inherently Selfish?
11:02 - Does Competition Bring Out the Best in People?
19:09 - Everyone Has the Opportunity to Succeed
25:17 - Should Society Help the Underprivileged?
30:11 - Profit and Ethics Oppose One Another
Tune in, share with your friends, follow us on social media, and make sure you turn on notifications so you get notified when we go live every day!
I would like to thank both of you gentlemen for participating in this social experiment.
Before we get into it, I just want to explain the rules to you.
So what I'm going to do is read a prompt off of this cell phone.
If you agree with the prompt, I want you to remain in your seat.
If you disagree with the prompt, I would like you to stand up.
This is very, very serious.
Just make sure that your answers are correct.
Once you've placed them, it is final.
Prompt number one is, Will's mustache is horrifyingly ugly.
Please make your choices.
Will, do you think that your own mustache is ugly?
I think the dirty capitalists might think that it's ugly,
but that's because they're part of the systems of oppression and racism
that founded this country.
Great answer.
Thank you for taking this.
I once knew a person, this is anecdotal,
but I once knew a person with a mustache and he was ugly.
So I'm standing.
Will's mustache is all absurd, that's why I'm standing.
Our next prompt here, gentlemen, is,
Amala is a talentless hack and is doing this for white validation.
Gentlemen, would you like to explain your answers?
Explain?
Yes, please explain your answers.
You got some explaining to do.
You got some explaining to do, man.
You know, I've been doing this show with you for the last few months
and I have found that it's really Hot Scott and Intern Tyler who carry this show.
And if you were to die tomorrow, we'd get on.
I do concur.
Taylor, would you like to explain your answer to the prompt?
Well, these Hot Scott and Intern Tyler are clearly pulling strings behind the curtain.
So I guess I do have to change my answer.
After Will made such a brilliant point, I believe in honest discourse.
Middle ground, baby.
Wow, thank you guys so much.
And see, that was absolutely amazing.
Let's get into the show.
Amala is an amazing person.
Yeah, we don't really think she's doing this for white validation.
Thank you guys.
Although you do have four white guys validating you every afternoon.
Guess what?
I'm 50% white and I validate myself.
So I guess I have white validation.
Today, we are coming at you with a very interesting Thursday special.
And this is because Will and Taylor and I are nowhere to be found.
We are actually in Nashville for Taylor's wedding.
All right, so this is from...
I do.
Everybody give Taylor a big congratulations in the comments down below as well.
No, this is Thursday.
He doesn't get married until tomorrow.
Yeah, that's right.
Well, I know, but still congratulate him.
He's getting married.
This is going to be like the biggest day of his life.
Congratulate him tomorrow.
At this moment, we will be at my rehearsal dinner.
Right.
And I will be in my Airbnb sitting by myself,
maybe reading a book or something while Will and Taylor do that.
What else would I be doing?
Watching BET.
I don't know.
Yeah, I often find myself watching BET.
I love a good Madea movie.
Madea goes to jail.
Whenever that's rerunning, I make sure to catch it.
Oh, I feel that.
Great, great flick.
But for today, what we're going to be doing
is actually reacting to a Jubilee video out of their middle ground series
where they bring people from opposing sides,
maybe three feminists and three anti-feminists.
And then they'll bring them to ask them prompts
and see where they disagree and where they align.
So this specific one is going to be
can socialists and capitalists find middle ground?
Let's get right into it.
We actually aren't looking for a middle ground with capitalism.
We're not looking for a lighter, gentler oppression, exploitation, racism.
We are seeking revolution.
Wow.
That's how I start off every conversation, too.
We're not looking to find middle ground with you guys.
Actually, we want to overthrow your entire system
because you're racist and sexist and homophobic.
Let's see.
No, I know that girl.
You know what girl?
In the yellow.
She's going to be for the capitalists, I'm assuming.
Yeah, well, I think so.
But I'm not going to say her name
because I don't know if they say people's names on here.
I think they do.
You'll see.
They introduce themselves.
My name is Liberty.
I'm studying psychology at UCLA.
There you go.
She's a Prager Force member.
Oh, I've never met Liberty.
Older, back in the day.
OK.
Liberty?
Never met her.
Never heard of her.
I'm Sean.
I'm 24 years old.
And I'm in the Socialist Party.
Would you have guessed?
No comments.
2016, I was the Socialist Party's presidential candidate.
I'm Shay.
And I'm with the Socialist Party.
And I'm 28.
My name's Jack.
I'm 19.
I go to community college.
My name's Richard.
19.
I go to Cal State Long Beach as a chemistry major with a music minor.
Can I get my socialists on the left and my capitalists on the right?
You get it.
Humans are inherently selfish.
Are you guys walking forward on this one?
Selfishness is sort of one word for it.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, me too.
Wait, you're supposed to walk forward if what?
You walk forward if you agree with the statement.
If you agree with humans are inherently selfish, you walk forward and you sit down and then
they discuss it.
And then the people who disagree come in and discuss it.
OK.
Yourself, your own survival, and your own gain.
And, of course, that includes the gain of those you love is one of the main motivators
of people.
A really good way that we could figure out human nature is by comparing it to animal
nature and stuff like that.
And you see, you know, animals doing whatever they can to survive.
It's just culture that has changed us.
But I believe at its core that, yes, humans, just like any other animal, are selfish.
I work with children.
And my experience of working with people who haven't been acculturated or have been
into this idea that they need to be selfish all the time are generally not.
Every organism has to have a sense of getting resources for itself in order to survive.
But that's much different than being selfish.
They really should have told the guy with the hat facing forward that you can't see
his face without shading.
Well, that's how he chose to represent himself.
Just saying.
He's socialist, so he's got to be ominous and dark.
What is interesting to me is that when you ask innate questions about the human psyche,
whether or not humans are inherently selfish, the capitalists walk forward, the socialists
stay behind.
And what that points out to me is not really an ideological difference, but a difference
in the way that you view the human psyche and the way that you view the human condition.
So operating on that difference as a foundation is going to set you up, obviously, for disagreements
because you fundamentally disagree on the way that humans are and the reality for humans.
And of course, humans are self-interested.
We thrive on survival.
And if it is me protecting my survival versus me protecting the survival of somebody else
that I've never met, inherently, humans are going to try to protect their own survival
and their own self-interest.
And although, like Liberty says, it applies to the people that you love as well.
And that's why we build strong communities.
That's why we support our communities.
And even that, although somewhat altruistic, is still self-interest, because I want to
live in a strong community that I like living in.
Yeah.
And this guy says his evidence for why humans are not selfish was that he works with kids
and observes that they're nice.
But have you ever met a child?
What's the first word that kids learn?
Mine.
Right.
You have to teach a kid to share their toys.
You have to teach a kid to play nice.
You know, they're not like that by nature.
So how do you appeal to the fact that you work with kids?
And if you spend five seconds with kids, all you see is that they're selfish.
Yeah.
And kids are dumb.
Like, you're not going to learn how the world works by watching kids.
You need to watch adults.
Well, actually, you can learn a lot.
A lot of behavior psychologists study kids.
You can learn a lot.
But I'm saying, like, you're not going to know how an economy should work.
Right.
And just think about it as through the eyes of a baby or a child.
When they need something, they yearn for it.
They scream for it.
And they will do anything and have you do anything for them to get that.
People are self-interested.
People want to survive.
That is what they want to do.
And that inherently needs self-interest.
I think.
I mean, I think even if you look at if you spend any time in a social democracy,
you know, let's say you go to Norway and you spend time there where the people see
the collective good as tied into their own personal well-being.
You know, I think we have so many examples like that.
Societies working collectively toward a greater good.
The thing about a society like Norway, which has more capitalism than America.
Sure.
Maybe I agree with you.
Sounds good to me.
The Nordic countries, in my opinion, is well, since they're very, very ethnically homogenous,
they all have very, very similar culture.
It's not an accurate representation of, you know, what humans inherently are,
because I believe that culture can mask human nature.
So you think that diversity would work against working in harmony toward a collective good?
In diversity, we have different ideas of what good is.
Absolutely.
That's something that people fail to recognize is that those Nordic countries,
they are ethnically homogenous and they do have this sort of assimilated culture
where everybody is sort of working toward the same value system.
And their culture is very much shared among the people that live there.
That's a bad argument.
No, I hate when conservatives use that homogenous culture,
because just because you have a homogenous culture doesn't mean that socialism would work,
because these countries aren't socialist.
These countries are working towards capitalism.
Well, they're nationalists.
They're more capitalist.
They have a shared sense of identity as a nation.
No, but the guy, the capitalist guy was explaining that, oh, this.
Yeah, so his argument's bad.
Right, that's what I'm saying.
Right.
We know that they're not socialists.
I mean, most people don't.
And that's why the prime ministers and presidents have come forward and said,
do not use us as examples of socialist countries, because that is not what we are.
They are very much free market countries with just large social safety nets.
They are not socialist countries by any means,
but their ethnic homogeneity also contributes to the success of their country.
And that's just a foundation in any nation.
It's easier to have a safety net whenever you have a ethnically,
or not ethnically, but a homogenous culture.
Now, that is, of course, true.
I'm just saying that using it to explain that socialism works is,
from that standpoint, is not a good argument.
Right.
Yeah, of course.
Which is what I hear from people.
I think competition brings out the best in people.
Especially when, you know, we're competing for something,
like, let's try to create this compound that could help,
you know, the masses in some kind of health relation form.
You have all these research labs trying to figure out,
what's the most efficient way to figure out this process?
What's the most efficient way to do this?
I think we need more of that sort of sense of competition,
especially in the sciences and whatnot.
You know, we frequently hear about the evils of monopolies.
It's because, you know, when you control an entire market,
why even bother being better at anything?
You've got no competition.
You've got nothing to strive for, and no one can choose anything else.
I agree with you both on the examples that you gave,
but the thing that I'm kind of struggling with,
I mean, if we're talking about efficiency,
quality, then yeah, I think it brings out the best in people.
But then again, it tends to bring about greed.
Y'all do such a great service.
It's a trip to me, because as you're likely aware
that there's this growing support for socialism,
an economic system that places people over profit,
that you're willing to continue to throw out
the same talking points that have failed people so miserably.
See, here's what I don't like,
they so often run into on these middle ground.
Those three people were having just a very kind conversation.
There was no contention.
There was no condescension at all.
And then this guy comes in and he goes,
well, you do socialism a very great service
by throwing out your general capitalist talking points
every time you talk.
Just be kind and have a discussion
about two differing ideas and two differing ideologies.
Well, he sees himself as awakened
to the Marxist idea of critical consciousness,
which is I have achieved an enlightenment
that you don't yet have, and so let me enlighten you.
And then that's what wokeism is based on.
Oh, that's frustrating to listen to and to watch.
Again, it's a benefit to us,
and I guess we should say thank you.
All the neckbeards of the world are saying thank you
to the capitalists making these arguments.
Nice.
If you care about something,
if you're passionate about something,
you don't need the threat of someone doing it better than you
to do the best that you can do.
Ask any creative.
That is so dumb.
That is one of the dumbest things I've ever heard.
If I'm sitting here, I make videos.
Amla, Taylor, we have a show.
If we make a show that sucks,
people aren't going to watch it.
If we have a show and we say,
we want to be better than these other people's show,
we want more people to view our show,
we want our show to be the best,
we're going to make the best show.
And that's how it works in a marketplace
of all these different things.
Not everyone can be a winner, okay?
For someone to win, someone has to lose.
That's just how the world works.
And you know, this has been tested in human geography.
And I took a course in this,
I think probably in middle school.
And it's just foundational to who we are as humans.
They've done a test and there's some sort of system.
And I forget what the name of it is.
And I talk about it a lot.
But they had two ice cream vendors.
And they set up these two ice cream vendors
at opposite ends of a beach.
And the beach had a main entrance
right through the middle of it.
And just through the natural human condition,
these two ice cream vendors move towards each other
and move to both sides of the entrance.
And it's because competition,
humans thrive on competition.
And it also makes for better product
and better efficiency
when you are actively being competitive
with another person in the market.
And that is just how we naturally act.
We just watched the Olympics
and now the athletes are not going to achieve,
like Simone Biles doesn't achieve what she achieves
just because she just decided to hop on a beam one day
and be good.
It takes honing your craft
and it takes looking at
what everyone else has ever done before you
and trying to transcend that.
And you're competing against other people on your team
to even make the team to represent the United States.
It takes to achieve something good.
And then speaking of competition too,
a great example of what you're talking about
with the ice cream thing
is the hot chicken restaurants
that we frequent for lunch.
There was one down the road.
It was like a kind of a mom and pop hot chicken place.
And we liked it.
We'd go once a week or so.
And then another one opened up
right a little bit closer to our office
and we walked in and tried it
and it was like way better.
Like they had their systems down.
It was a chain, but it was like really good value,
free refills, free extra pickles.
The food was really clean and good.
They like greet you when you come in
and it was like an amazing experience.
And we sat down and we like, we're like,
dang felt kind of bad for that other inferior restaurant
because like we liked them.
But you know what, this is objectively better.
And so what happens, you're going to get rewarded.
And it's no coincidence that the same hot chicken place
moved a couple blocks down the street.
People thrive on competition
and in businesses that present the same product
will begin to move toward each other.
That is just simply how it works.
Competitiveness is also one of the defining traits
of masculinity.
Men are supposed to be competitive
because imagine caveman times.
You are competing against nature.
You're competing against other tribes, whatever it is,
to go and get the biggest mammoth or whatever it is,
taking it back to your den so that you can feed.
Like you have to be competitive.
You have to be-
So you can get the women, right?
So you get the women too, exactly.
Because you want to procreate.
Like being competitive is part of being a man.
Men who say that competition isn't important are beta men.
It's like Jordan Peterson talks a lot
about competence hierarchies
and the way that you become the alpha male
is being the one who's the most competent.
And what is the best sorting mechanism
to see who's the most competent?
Competition.
And I never thought about the fact
that they share the same root word,
but that's who's more competent.
And you want to have a structure
that incentivizes maximum competence in a society
because that means you're gonna have the best,
like the best we can achieve scientifically,
the best we can achieve technologically,
the best we can achieve with food,
the best we can achieve with athletics,
anything it can be with art, with music, with science,
all that stuff that you need.
Competition is the mechanism
that makes the best things rise to the top.
It's not called survival of the fittest for no reason.
It's because there's competition among people
and the fittest prevails.
Oh, and ideas too, by the way.
Right, right.
Competition leads less to excellence
and more towards doing whatever you can
to edge past the other person.
Couldn't have said it better myself.
He justified what being exceptional means.
He justified what excellence means,
and that is looking at the standard around you
and then building yourself one above that.
That is exceptionalism.
I do wanna say here though,
like there is truth to the idea that in competition,
it can bring out the worst in people.
Like if you're a guy
who've ever been on a basketball court with,
it brings out the ugly, Scott's will nodding,
like it brings out the ugly side of people.
Competing with Will in games, like Jackbox games,
he gets very competitive.
I can bring out the ugly side of people,
but just because that happens,
that doesn't mean like,
you know, Jordan Peterson talks about,
you should be a monster.
In other words, you should be as powerful
and competent as you can be,
but you should also be restrained.
You should have the ability to win,
but you should also have the character
to keep that in check.
Right, and don't forget that competition comes into play
when it comes to character
and being kind and compassionate.
Competition is not only in terms of ingenuity
and production,
it has to do with being a good person
and you can compete with other people
on being good and being gracious.
Right, and that's what Will talked about
with the benevolent, the idea of benevolence.
Like if you, I can be the best basketball player
on the court, but if I'm a butthole to everyone,
they're not gonna invite me to play to the next game.
So it's a game, the game of society
and the game of living in a community
that actually works is you have to treat people
in a way that's nice.
So they'll invite you to keep participating.
Unless you don't want to be with everyone else,
like Will, like me, introvert Will.
All right, if we're talking about the United States
and we're talking about financial success,
then yes, I would believe so.
What was the prompt?
If we're talking about the world,
it doesn't necessarily have to be.
The prompt for this one was everyone can make it.
Everyone can succeed.
Mean financial well-being or like stability.
I think that it really just means how you're happy
and how you're okay with yourself.
And you make a goal and you pursue your goal
and if you fail or achieve it.
That's exactly what I was thinking.
I find that there are so many resources out there
that you can enact on.
It's just, there's some people
who just don't do anything about it.
Oh, good old YouTube ad.
Yeah, I love that.
Capitalism.
Listen, I love DoorDash.
My first thought here with this question is
you gotta be ******* kidding me.
You know, so many people in this country
who solely because they exist, they're under threat.
Whether it's through, you know, the police.
They're just trying to survive.
Oh my God.
Everyone's very different.
Again, everyone has different opportunities
to what they can even consider success.
In the U.S. though, there are a lot of opportunities
for most people.
Though, of course, you can't say all.
And there are always those who are extremely unfortunate
and should be helped.
I'm sure every one of us has sat in a restaurant
before a Starbucks.
Those people work their asses off.
Any of these low income jobs are not easy
and they work for pennies.
If something goes wrong with their car, they're done.
You know, if they have a health problem, they're done.
You're talking about financial success though.
Success is extremely relative and can be defined
in many different ways in a capitalist society.
Dude, some high schooler working at Starbucks
who can get insurance from the company,
first of all, health insurance from a company
that you work for.
That's what you're supposed to do.
Secondly, he's not working for pennies either.
This is like his summer job.
You're not supposed to have a minimum wage job
for the rest of your life, okay?
Yeah, my sister works minimum wage and has an apartment,
is able to care for herself.
She has a car.
She makes payments on it.
It's fine.
No, she's dying.
And I guess the left falls into this idea of,
well, if you can't support an entire family on this wage,
it's not a good wage.
It's unethical.
They're not paying you.
And we can go into hours and hours of talking
about why minimum wages are actually detrimental
to not only black people and people of color,
but to society in general.
But the idea of a livable minimum wage
was never the purpose of creating a minimum wage
in the first place.
If the kid scooping ice cream at the carnival
can't support a family of four on his wage-
This is outrageous.
Yeah, I mean, and that's not personal.
We need jobs that are at every level of competence
because competence should be rewarded
in proportion to the competence that you have.
And the low-paying jobs reward a low amount of competence
that are required to do that job.
But if you-
They train you better.
Yeah, exactly.
And that's the whole point.
You should be incentivized in a capitalist structure
to increase your competence
so that you can be increased with a reward.
But that's competition.
And socialists don't want to hear the word competition.
Because then you have to take responsibility for your own life
and try to get educated or better yourself.
Take responsibility that you chose to go and work at Starbucks.
Right.
You know?
Yeah.
You chose to go and make other people coffee.
That's not my fault that you chose that, okay?
Just as a side note,
everybody who has arguments on the minimum wage,
go and listen to Tom Sewell talk about the minimum wage
and why it's detrimental and your mind will be changed.
Anyways.
Sorry, that wasn't a financial success,
the most important thing.
No.
I've worked in the food industry for a number of years
and I cannot say that any one of my companions
was ever happy to be doing that.
And if they're going to school.
So?
I don't care.
So get a different job.
Get a different job and knucklehead.
Become the manager.
This is the entitlement.
They think, oh, I'm in high school and I need to make some money.
I should be able to just sit around all day and make money.
Or I should be making tons of money for something
that I don't really like doing.
I should be handed government unemployment checks ad infinitum.
I should be the president.
You're so dumb.
No matter how much money you make,
you're not going to be happy doing that particular job.
Should we just eliminate that job from the job market
because nobody's happy and pleased to be doing it?
That it just makes absolutely no sense.
We also can be happy.
You can be fulfilled even if you don't enjoy,
you know, your dishwasher.
Let's say you can still be fulfilled in your life,
even if you're washing dishes.
There are tons of many happy people who are dishwashers.
I'm sorry that you are so entitled that you've never had a,
you know, a real job.
I think we've all worked in the food industry.
Haven't we all?
I worked at Starbucks when I was 15 in high school.
And then Will and I both worked for pizza joints.
And it's just like,
I've worked at so many different places.
I've worked for all different types of wages,
worked for tips, worked for nothing.
I mean, all sorts of stuff.
This is what's so reductive about Marxist ideology is
it frames everything in terms,
it makes labor and work about like at the end,
the be all end all of life.
And so unless you have a job that is paying you the wage
that you can live off of,
and then that job is also making you happy
and having meaning in your life,
then there's some evil forces oppressing you.
And it's like,
or maybe you just have to hustle sometimes in life
and you have to go get a job that you don't like
because you're pursuing something bigger than that job.
And that's not the be all end all of your life.
And you have meaning in going on your journey
and building up your confidence
and doing what you have to do today to make ends meet.
Because you're actually going somewhere as an individual.
But the Marxist frame doesn't really leave room for that.
It's all society has to define meaning for you
through your work.
On top of that,
so they're working full time
and on top of that, they're going to school
and they're paying school.
I would consider that successful
if you can go to school and you can maintain your GPA
and you can also be working a part-time job
and somehow affording your school.
Yeah, you're doing well in life.
Society should help the underprivileged.
I don't even like the framing of the question.
Society does help the underprivileged.
Are we pausing?
No.
And also who should do the helping and how is very important.
Not all acts of service are equally beneficial.
I would agree to that.
I myself, you know, I'm sorry to use a personal anecdote here,
but I've personally dealt with polite capitalists,
angry socialists.
Yeah, somebody who knows how to argue too
because he knows that anecdotal information is not an argument.
What a good guy.
The fact that, oh, giving someone this much aid,
they become lazy.
My father is an alcoholic.
So we, since due to an injury in his leg, he gets SSI.
And what ends up happening is he receives enough SSI
to the point where he's not motivated to do anything else
beyond just going home, drinking a beer or something like that.
And I think, yes, people should help people,
especially if they're underprivileged
or they need the resources to push them.
But to what end, that's the fine line.
But your personal anecdote only covers
the small demographic of the alcoholic.
Most of the people that...
Every example you guys have brought up
has been specifically about people who are particularly poor
when most of the country is middle, lower middle class and up.
Well, that's actually, that's not a fact.
But that you would focus on this in a city,
one that gives more than half of its budget to the police
in a country that just passed a military bill,
a spending bill that's almost $1 trillion.
That money goes to defense contractors.
The government paying for things is not capitalism.
But we're in a capitalist system.
Where the government pays huge amounts of money
for the things you're talking...
Yeah, I'm not in favor of those things.
How about instead of spending the money on the military,
how about putting those back into basic needs?
Healthcare, education, housing.
I agree.
The government taking our taxpayer dollars
and funneling it into...
They're paying for things that the military
explicitly says that they don't need.
That's not...
Capitalism is about prices and transparency and choices.
When the government takes our money and buys it...
This is actually an example of capitalism working.
That is not...
That might be what you call capitalism,
but when I come here saying I'm a capitalist,
I'm not saying I'm in favor of that.
This 15-year-old genius just shocked the entire...
Wow, this 15-year-old genius.
Teachers hate him.
Gosh, I already forgot what I was going to say.
What was the prompt again?
You're obviously not a 15-year-old genius.
Governments are like, the society should help people.
We're talking about definitions of capitalism.
Yeah, I mean, they were the last second.
I hate the semantics.
He says, oh, well, you're using alcohol...
You're using alcoholics as a small demographic.
Well, let's...
Every example they used was a small...
Was an individual imaginary person.
And Liberty luckily pointed that out.
But now we're in today's time.
Look at what happened during the COVID-19 pandemic
and all the stimulus checks
and the elevated unemployment checks.
That was your test of UBI,
of universal basic income in our country.
And look at the millions of people
who are now refusing to reenter the workforce.
And it's a perfect example
of what this young guy just said
with his father and the alcoholism.
When you give people not only what they need to live,
but more than they need to live
without expecting any work
or any societal contribution in return,
they will not give you any work.
They will not give you any societal contributions.
Yeah, this is what we saw at the Dream Center
with a homeless rehabilitation place that we visited.
It took them years to develop this,
but they learned that if you just take someone in
and give them free stuff,
that's what the government does
and it doesn't improve their life.
Then they lose all incentive to advocate for themselves
and to get out of drug addiction
and to get on a path
toward being productive members of society.
And so what they do is they implement these structures
where, okay, if you're gonna have a bed here,
you're gonna work in one of our departments
for three hours a day
and we're gonna have you go to this rehab
and we're gonna provide all your needs for you,
but we're gonna hold you accountable
as a member of our little microcosm of society.
And that puts them on a path of growth
to where they're acquiring competence again.
And before you know it, they're able to contribute.
They're able to serve food.
They're able to just work
in all these different capacities.
And so a lot of them ended up working at the Dream Center
or they get reintegrated into society
as a functioning member.
And if you don't hold people accountable,
then they're just going to take and take and take.
And I don't really blame you
because it's your fault
for creating an incentive structure
that allows them to persist
in just receiving the free handouts.
Accountability is everything.
Profit and ethics are opposing motives.
So I think it's core to profit.
You have to exploit.
And again, there is nothing ethical about exploitation.
Yeah, I mean, I can't think it.
I'm really having trouble thinking of a situation
where someone could profit off of something
without exploitation being in the mix.
And I just, I'm running out of ideas.
If you're running a business
and you're the one up top,
you would obviously walk away with more money
if you pay your employees a little bit less.
What a dumpster fire of ideas right there.
It's just so intellectually dishonest
to say that because we function in capitalism
and somebody has to work in order to be paid
and there is a leadership that has to use that work
in order to make products and then profit.
That is not exploitation.
That is exchange.
You are exchanging your work for payment
and they are then exchanging their products for money.
And that is what gives them their profit.
That's what gives you your income.
Right, and if they artificially pay you
more than your market value,
then that cuts into their profit margin
and the ability to reinvest those profits
into their company and be competitive
because then their competitor down the street
is going to be paying their people market value
and that leads their business to fail.
And now there's no jobs for anyone.
I think that profit and ethics can be intertwined
when seen with the corporate social responsibility module.
When they treat their employees better,
they give them more benefits,
they raise their wages
and in turn it motivates the workers to work harder.
Treating your employees better than shit
is not necessarily ethical.
Raising the quality does not mean
that you've raised it to a sufficient standard.
It's an emotional appeal.
What employees in America are being treated that badly?
Except at Amazon.
And not even anymore because now they've been paid more
because that's been called out
and that's been taken care of.
To think that working is immediately
at its foundation exploitation, it's not.
And that is very true.
If you incentivize people working,
they will work harder for you.
That is just simply the case.
Yeah, and I can agree with parts of this
that there are times when profits can be put above people.
There's for sure greediness in the world
and people do do that.
There is no doubt about it.
He was just talking about defense contractors before
and that's something that I would personally agree with him on
and some of the other people
that I frequently mention on this show.
So that can be true.
But in and of itself,
just being able to have profits
does not mean that you cannot be ethical having profits.
Yeah, not to mention that in the United States,
we have such an extensive framework
of employment legislation
to where if anything unethical happens to you
with your employer,
you can immediately find a lawyer
and seek legal action on that.
And it comes from anything
from wage theft to discrimination.
We actively try to help our employees
and to make sure that they are guarded
from injustice and greed.
Yeah, that is unless they mandate the...
Then you have nothing.
Yeah, unless they mandate a certain thing,
certain medical procedure.
Of treatment,
because if you're paying someone less than a living wage,
that is unethical.
All I'm saying is,
it is to some degree more ethical
and can be seen as more ethical to...
Wait, sorry, one thing.
Paying people less than a living wage,
first of all,
the people chose to go and work
at whatever establishment it is,
paying them as much as they want to pay them.
Most businesses,
especially small businesses,
are running on nearly 1% profit margins.
1% profit margins, okay?
You think that CEOs
or owners of your mom and pop pizza shop
down the street is exploiting you
and they live in huge mansions,
taking all of your money
and diving in pools of gold?
Of course not.
And then people go and choose to work there.
It's dumb.
I could talk about this for years.
Beating competition
by raising the wages of your employees
and giving them better benefits.
Also, one must be paid slightly less
than they are making in worth for a company
for it to be worth it to hire them at all.
If you can't pay your employee
the minimum amount of money
that they need in order to live,
you have no business being in business.
And I think also there's a tendency from the-
I am forcing you to make your store better
until you can pay everyone this amount of money.
You are telling people
you are telling people
how much they have to pay people.
Who designates what is a living wage?
I mean, that's like-
Yeah, well, also forgetting that
products have variability in value.
So not every product is going to be valued
at the same as your wages,
which is why a minimum wage inherently
is problematic when it comes to
the American market system anyways.
I would love to see this guy
try to run a business for like a month.
I know.
Just put you in charge of-
Instead of a campaign.
Hiring, firing decisions.
Do pay them whatever you want
and see how fast the business craters.
I know.
You know, you have no idea.
Like you're not-
This is the problem with these Marxists
is they're not accountable to reality
and because their ideas
don't have to be tested in real life.
They can just sit back and complain and gripe
and air their grievances about everything
and criticize everything.
But they're not productive.
They're not out there
putting their ideas into practice
because when they do,
the best examples we have
are totalitarian societies
that have to murder people
to cooperate with this ideology
because it doesn't work.
I would love to see a Marxist business in operation.
Show me one that's successful.
There was this brewery back in Colorado.
It was called like Comrade Brewing.
The guy was like a communist, I guess.
We went there for some drinks one time
for some beers at the place.
Good beers.
So I don't know how-
He obviously ran-
But it's like-
He obviously ran-
Tell me more.
He obviously ran his model
as a capitalist business, right?
Even though this guy was a communist himself
but had good beer.
Thanks, Will.
Great story.
To skew away from the objective fact,
I mentioned the MIT living wage calculator, right?
Yes.
That's a scientific model.
Wow.
That $29.25.
So as a company,
if you can't afford to pay your employee a living wage-
Same $29.25.
The minimum that they need in order to live, right?
Get the **** out of business.
Why are we even talking to you when you have all the facts
and we don't know anything?
I don't know.
It's hardly worth my time.
Well, we would-
Sure.
Wow.
It's hard to really lean towards one side or the other
if everyone is just sort of
stating all these coherent biases
and not accepting any sort of thing
from any other particular side,
which is why I'm sort of just-
I'm trying to understand your side
and I'm trying to grasp really my side of it.
And again, going back to sort of that mutual understanding
of what can we do next?
That sort of mutual understanding needs to be there
if we're going to ever continue to see
what's best for the US.
And that's why when you start conversations
where you're trying to change people's minds
or at least discuss ideas,
you should try to build a foundation
of what the objective truth is
before you even go into battling your ideologies.
And they attempted to do that with their first question,
are humans inherently selfish?
And you already identified the schism there.
If you guys can't even agree
that humans are innately selfish,
how are you going to agree on your ideological viewpoints?
How are you going to agree on your different theories
of how our society should work
when you can't even agree on the basic human condition?
These people don't even-
They don't even have the same definitions
of capitalism and socialism.
Like these people should be-
Definitely at first talking to each other and saying,
what do you define socialism as?
What do you define capitalism as?
Because if you don't, then it's like,
how do you even argue these ideas
if you don't even know what the hell you're talking about?
Everyone's just going to be a smug loser the whole time.
Well, you'll be talking past each other.
Like you can't-
Until you're on the same page
about what it is that we're talking about.
It's like when people ask Jordan Peterson,
do you believe in God?
He says, well, it depends on what you mean by believe
and what you mean by God.
And that's true.
You have to define your terms
and be very explicit about what it is you're saying.
So I was like, do you believe that capitalism is good?
I was like, what do you mean?
What are you asking me that I believe?
Yeah.
And what are our goals with this conversation?
Our goals to come out of this understanding each other
or our goals to dunk on each other
on what we believe and what we don't?
Because you can clearly tell
that that's the socialist guy's viewpoint.
That's what he wants to do.
He came here to school people,
not to learn what they feel.
I think one reason why you often see
like folks on the left,
socialists, communists, anarchists, et cetera,
they're so passionate and there is anger.
Seeing the suffering and the oppression
and the exploitation, the racism, et cetera,
you sort of feel this urgency.
We're constantly under sort of this self-criticism
and self-reflection about like,
well, how do you package what can be complex ideas
into ways that are very palatable?
And that's me every hour.
And I think like if there's a failure on the left,
that would be one of them.
I wish that rather than having an agenda that...
One of them.
Just one.
The racism thing, I could go on about that for ages.
Capitalism is not racist.
We try to prove and we see ourselves
as winning by convincing the opponent.
I wish that we could consider winning
as finding the middle ground
and finding where we're similar
and finding the truth.
I think if you're in the pursuit of truth,
then you've won,
contrary to convincing other people that you're right.
Oh my goodness.
Is this a young Taylor?
A young Taylor in the making?
Taylor, you looked way better back then.
What happened to your long hair?
Yeah, I needed to catch up with you guys.
Oh, let's finish it up.
Despite that, we definitely disagree
on pretty much everything.
It's good to know the real common ground here
is we as like millennials and Gen Z and stuff,
we're actually like talking about this,
whether we were able to convince the other side
of anything or not,
at least we give a shit about it.
This is stuff that we need to talk about.
This is stuff that we need to be aware of,
especially given our leaders.
All right, guys, that's a wrap.
Thank you.
It's good to be here.
Pleasure, really.
Thank you.
Oh, we finished that up.
Oh my goodness.
I feel like we barely scraped the surface of what?
Of all the different underpinnings in that video.
It got too mushy at the end for my liking.
Oh my gosh.
Can I be honest?
Of course, when they all shake hands, you're like, oh.
Well, because both people on each side,
you know this, okay?
It's human nature.
I feel like both of these people
are both a little disappointed,
both sides in the conversation.
So they get kind of mushy, but in their hearts,
they're actually disappointed in the conversation.
Yeah, but to me, the thing to do is to push harder,
to establish, okay, well, let's define truth.
So that we can actually achieve an exchange of ideas.
Because the alternative to that is,
well, I sure hope my side wins
and I can exert power over you because we don't agree.
And so I need to be the one in power
because we can't negotiate.
Like you said, we can need to,
that's, you know, the democratic society,
ideally you have representative democracy.
You have the competition of ideas.
You have people who disagree,
have to negotiate and find a middle ground.
And that's just how it is.
Or you compete for the best ideas that actually work
and when you're accountable to reality.
So the ending makes me sad
because not just that they weren't able
to achieve the conversation,
but it's a reflective of our society.
We're so polarized right now
and people are so incapable.
We share, we live in such different worlds
that overlapping in the Venn diagram
has become so small that it's like extremely difficult
just to have an honest exchange of ideas.
You hear those leftists arguing about what capitalism is
and we're like, that's not capitalism.
Then you hear, you go online,
you see some conservatives arguing about what the left does
and the left's like, that's not us either.
And it's like, we're arguing amongst ourselves
trying to impress our own side all the time
instead of like-
We're both beating the crap out of straw men.
Yeah, exactly, all the time.
And it's like, what about actually more coming together
and like figuring it out, you know?
And like, truth is power, truth is power
and that's what we should be aiming towards.
Like they said at the end, he's like, we want truth
and not just worried about dunking on the other person.
The way that you really dunk on someone
is by having the truth.
So if you're both battling straw men
or don't have definitions right then,
you're not gonna have any sort of power at all.
Yeah, that conversation would have been a lot more fruitful
and I think they would have come out with some more
if they had walked in with placing that as the basis
and finding their objective truths
and their agreement on that.
But guys, that's the end of the video.
Thank you guys so much for watching.
If you like this stream, please like, subscribe,
click the notification bell to be notified every single day
when we go live at 2.30 PST, 5.30 Eastern.
And if you don't wanna watch our faces,
you can listen to us speak on Google Play,
on Apple Podcasts and on Spotify.
We are gonna go enjoy Taylor's wedding, so.
Yeah, we're gonna see you guys tomorrow from the past.
And we're gonna be wearing the same outfits.
Are we? No, we're not.
Yeah, we are.
We're recording a different thing tomorrow.
I thought we were recording a different thing today.
What time is it now?
What day is it today?
It's 4.15.
Who are you?
Are you speaking from the future?
Who am I?
I don't even know my own objective truth.
All right, I do, I do.
Fine.
Thank you guys so much for watching.
We will see you tomorrow.
Bye.
