Prime Minister's Question Time, also referred to as PMQs, takes place every Wednesday the House of Commons sits. It gives MPs the chance to put questions to the Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer MP, or a nominated minister.
In most cases, the session starts with a routine 'open question' from an MP about the Prime Minister's engagements. MPs can then ask supplementary questions on any subject, often one of current political significance.
The Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch MP, asks six questions and the leader of the second largest opposition party asks two. If another minister takes the place of the Prime Minister, opposition parties will usually nominate a shadow minister to ask the questions.
Before we come to Prime Minister's questions, I wish to inform the House about my recent
trip to Ukraine. It was at the invitation of Ruslan Stepanchuk, Chairman of the Rada
in Ukraine. I joined speakers from across Europe in a memorial service to mark the third
anniversary of the Butcher Massacre and to hear the important testimony of the survivors
of this terrible atrocity. I also delivered a speech at the Butcher Summit, which was
owned by the President of Ukraine, and took with me specific cross-party messages of solidarity
from the House of Commons, the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the Leader
of the Liberal Democrats. The appreciation felt by the people of Ukraine at the support
offered by this House, the people of the United Kingdom, should not be underestimated.
Indeed, at his nightly address on Monday, President Zelensky explicitly expressed his
thanks to the United Kingdom for the support provided to them.
Order, order. We now come to Prime Minister's questions. John Greenock.
Question number one, please, Mr Speaker.
Prime Minister.
Mr Speaker, just picking up on your comments, can I say that on Monday night I spoke to
President Zelensky, and he wanted me to pass on to you his thanks for attending in Ukraine,
particularly on the third anniversary of the massacre at Butcher, which I've been to Butcher.
It's a terrible, terrible third anniversary, so I pass on those thanks.
Mr Speaker, we've been preparing for all eventualities ahead of the confirmation of US tariffs later
today. Let me be clear with the House, a trade war is in nobody's interests, and the country
deserves, and we will take, a calm, pragmatic approach. That's why constructive talks are
progressing to agree a wider economic prosperity deal with the US. That's why we're working
with all industries and sectors likely to be impacted. Our decisions will always be
guided by our national interests, and that's why we have prepared for all eventualities,
and we will rule nothing out.
Mr Speaker, our deepest sympathies are with the people of Myanmar and Thailand. We are
sending immediate life-saving support to assist their efforts.
May I also extend my personal condolences to the family, friends, and colleagues of
Christina McKelvie. She was much loved and will be sorely missed, especially by our
colleagues in the SNP here and in Scotland.
Mr Speaker, this morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. In addition
to my duties in this House, I shall have further such meetings later today.
John Brady
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This week, the full state pension will rise by £472 a year, putting
money in the pockets of pensioners in Glasgow and across the United Kingdom. Does the Prime
Minister agree with me that this rise is only possible because of Labour's plan for change
and our commitment to the triple lock?
He is absolutely right. We can commit to the triple lock because we have restored stability
after they crashed the economy. That means that, next week, 12 million pensioners will
receive up to £470 more—that is an extra £1,900 over this Parliament, including 1
million pensioners in Scotland. The contrast could not be clearer. The shadow Chancellor
called the triple lock unsustainable, and the Leader of the Opposition wants to means-test
the state pension so that she can cut it.
The Leader of the Opposition, can we bear the lock?
The Triple Lock was a Conservative policy, rather than—
Order. You were inadvertently sent. Carry on.
Rather than the Prime Minister congratulating himself for what we did, why do we not talk
about what he is doing? From Sunday, Labour's jobs tax will mean that many British businesses
face a terrible choice to cut wages, put up prices or sack their staff. What is the Prime
Minister's advice to those businesses?
She says the triple lock was Conservative policy. It was once thought to be the party
of sound finances, but they blew all of that. She asked what we are doing. We are clearing
up the mess that they left. We are dealing with global instability and we recognise the
pressures that are bearing down on businesses, individuals and working people. That is why
we are rolling up our sleeves. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce the national living
wage increasing by £1,400. That is a pay rise for millions of workers. We have announced
£150 for the warm homes discount, which is extended to 6 million households. That is
one in five families. Wages are going up faster than prices.
Never forget the party opposite. Worst living standards on record. Inflation up to 11%.
Public services left on their knees.
The only mess is the one that he made with his Budget. They had an emergency Budget last
week that fixed nothing. He says he is bringing stability. All we see is fragility. During
the election, the Prime Minister also promised that he would not increase taxes on working
people, but even the OBR says that the jobs tax will be passed on to workers. On average,
families will be £3,500 poorer. Why should anyone trust him again?
The Prime Minister's fantasy figure is about as much use as Liz Truss's economic planning.
She turns up every week to cart from the sidelines about the decisions we have made at the Budget.
Yesterday, she held a press conference, and she could not say whether she would reverse
the decisions that we made at the Budget. I understand, because she cannot bring herself
to say that she does not want the investment of an extra £26 billion in our NHS. I am
not surprised at that. That is £2 million extra appointments, 1,000 more GPs, a pay
rise for nurses, etc., but let me get her position right if I can follow it. She wants
the extra £26 billion in the NHS that was paid for by the national insurance rise. She
wants that. She does not want to reverse the national insurance rises, so she has now reduced
this absurd position of voting against the Budget, carping against the Budget, which
she actually agrees with.
I do not agree with making people poorer. I do not agree with pensioner poverty. Out
there, they are calling it awful April. That is because of decisions he has made, because
he made promises and broke them. His promises are worthless. People are getting poorer.
Before the election, he pledged to freeze council tax. Instead, it is going up everywhere,
even in Birmingham, where there is 17,000 tonnes of rubbish uncollected on the streets.
Does the Prime Minister regret promising the British people that he would freeze their
council tax when he has so obviously failed?
I have to ask her if she does not want people to be poorer. Why did she not resign when
she was in government? The last Government put up council tax for 12 years in a row.
I think she was Minister for Council Tax. In the year she has been, what did she do?
She put it up. Even now, the Conservatives have a local government association manifesto,
so currently their position—page 9—is that we ask the Government to remove the caps
on council tax. So who is leading the charge? Hampshire County Council wanted a 15% hike.
We said no. Slough Council wanted a hike. We said no. Windsor and Maidenhead, where
Tory members now live, wanted a hike, and we said no. It is no surprise that council
tax is £300 cheaper under Labour councils than under Tory councils.
He does not want to talk about Birmingham, and that is because he knows the situation.
I will say it again. There is 17,000 tonnes of rubbish on Birmingham streets. Normally,
a state of emergency is called for natural disasters, not Labour ones. His policies have
left our economy dangerously fragile. The Chancellor once again left herself no room
for manoeuvre. Economic experts and real economists say she will either have to break her fiscal
rules or put up taxes. Which will it be?
I think she must have picked up the script she was using a few weeks ago. It was only
then that she was saying, in the spring statement, that she was going to put up taxes. In relation
to the situation in Birmingham, it is completely unacceptable. I fully support the council
declaring it a major incident to resolve the situation, and we will put in whatever additional
support is needed. But when the party opposite was in government, we lost more days to strike
action than in any year since the 1980s. NHS workers were on the picket line, not on the
front line, and that sent waiting lists through the roof, so we will take no lectures on industrial
harmony from them.
The whole House would have heard that he did not say whether or not he could keep his fiscal
rules. That means that it is either that or putting up taxes. Nine months ago, we left
Labour the fastest-growing economy in the G7. We did. I remember watching his MPs laughing
at their first destructive Budget. They have had another one that has made our economy
dangerously vulnerable. The Bank of England says that his policies have pushed up the
cost of living for families. Does he disagree with the bank, or does he accept that his
policies mean higher bills?
The Prime Minister must be the only person left in the country who thinks that they did
well on the economy when they were in power. That was what was tested at the last election—living
standards were the worst on record, inflation was 11%—and the NHS was on its knees. The
Prime Minister is so obsessed with talking down the country that she has not read the
up in 2026, up in 2017, up in 2028, up in 2029 and up. Thanks to our planning reforms,
the largest growth measure the OBR has ever costed. What did the Tories do when the Bill
became before Parliament? They abstained. You do not grow the economy or build houses
by assuming. They are the same old party. They have not changed. Nothing is new.
He talks about inflation. We left it at 2%. It is now twice what the OBR forecast when
we were in government. The fact is that his decisions have made our economy fragile, just
as we face global trade wars. In November, I urged him to seize the draft US trade deal
the Conservatives negotiated. Instead, he lost our most experienced trade negotiator.
It is no wonder he cannot get a tariff deal for British cars. On this side of the House,
we secured investments for that industry—£600 million from BMW, £2 billion from Nissan
and £4 billion from Jaguar Land Rover. Labour's record is a car industry in crisis, even before
tariffs. There are 25,000 more jobs now at risk. He says he is preparing for eventualities.
Can the Prime Minister tell us exactly what he is doing to protect the British car industry
from his failure to negotiate?
We are taking a calm, pragmatic approach and keeping our feet on the ground. Constructive
talks are ongoing on a wider economic prosperity deal with the US. That is really important
at this moment. We are working with all sectors that are likely to be impacted. We are guided
by our national interest at all times. That is why we have said that we will not rule
anything out. It is important at a moment like this that we do not have knee-jerk reactions
and that we are actually cool-headed about this. That is why we will not rule anything
out. The Prime Minister is the Trade Secretary who failed to get a trade deal with the US.
Today the Trump Administration will announce new tariffs that will hurt working people
in the US and around the world. Does the Prime Minister agree that at a time when big tech
has grown fat by corrupting our politics and preying on young people, the wrong approach
would be to pander to his bullying tactics and to detect millionaires in his Imperial
court by cutting the digital services tax? Can he assure the public that the poorest
will not get cuts while the richest get a free ride?
I thank the Prime Minister for raising this important issue. There are issues in relation
to Northern Ireland in particular that we have to deal with very carefully. We will
always put the national interest first. That is why I am pleased that talks are ongoing
and that they are constructive. I do believe that a trade war is in nobody's interest
and that all the sectors and industries impacted are of the same view. We will continue to
make that progress in the national interest.
The Leader of the Liberal Democrats, Sir Ed David.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I associate myself with the earlier remarks of the Prime Minister,
particularly about Myanmar and Thailand. I support the aid that is going and hope that
despite the budget cuts we can be as generous as possible because of the humanitarian crisis
there.
The Prime Minister has shown commendable leadership over Ukraine with his plan for a military
coalition of the willing against Putin. Will he now provide similar leadership with an
economic coalition of the willing against Trump's tariffs for free trade so that we
can avoid a global trade war and a global recession?
Mr Speaker, every week he tries to tempt me to make what I think is a false choice between
our relationship with the US and our relationship with other countries, particularly Europe.
I think that is the wrong choice on defence, security and intelligence for reasons that
we have rehearsed across this Chamber. I also think it is wrong on trade and the economy.
We have a good deal of trade, a balanced trade relationship with the US, and I believe that
our interests are best served by calmly trying to secure a deal which is in our national
interest, whilst at the same time preparing and leaving all options on the table.
Sir Ed David.
I hope the Prime Minister is able to cut a deal, but I increasingly fear that the deal
will not be good enough to avoid a global trade war. That is why I think one of the
options must be to work with our European allies, our Commonwealth allies and others,
because if we do not tackle Trump's tariffs, we could be saying goodbye to free trade for
a generation.
If I may turn to a domestic matter now, three years ago the American private equity firm
KKR bought a 25% stake in Northumbrian Water. Since then, people across the north-east have
seen their water bills soar, whilst in the last year alone Northumbrian Water has dumped
nearly 1 million tonnes of raw sewage into Durham's Whitburn coast conservation area.
KKR are now poised to buy into Thames Water because Ministers have ruled out a special
administration regime. Can the Prime Minister guarantee that Thames Water will not be allowed
to repeat the same trick of putting up bills and dumping raw sewage at the same time? They
allowed it, he should not.
Prime Minister.
Mr Speaker, in relation to his comments at the beginning of the question, I really do
think it is not sensible to say that the first response should be to jump into a trade war
with the US. That cannot be the first response of the United Kingdom and I will resist his
urgings to do that. In relation to water, he is absolutely right to point out the appalling
record of water of the party opposite, just like the record on everything was appalling,
and that is why I am really pleased that we have passed the Water Act already to take
the necessary measures, but we will go further.
Yesterday the Work and Pensions Select Committee visited Manchester, where we saw the power
of devolution in action, in this case helping people find work. With just five percentage
points separating Labour and Conservatives last time, does the Prime Minister agree that
to get the maximum advantage from Labour's devolution offer, the west of England needs
an ambitious Labour Mayor in Helen Godwin for more jobs, to fix our buses and to get
the homes we need built?
I believe it is best for communities when their leaders have skin in the game. Helen
Godwin grew up in Stapleton, went to college in Filton and has a great record fighting
for the community where she is raising her family. Our plan for change has delivered
record funding for the west of England. That is more money for better buses, for potholes
and for getting young people into work. That is the difference that a Labour Mayor working
with a Labour Government delivers for the west of England.
Kevin Robinson.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Prime Minister will know that many in the House will be assuaged
by his suggestion that he will act in the national interest in relation to tariffs,
but most will not have considered that in acting in the national interest what occurs
in Northern Ireland is no longer solely in his control. He knows that exports from Northern
Ireland are UK exports, rightly so, yet imports to Northern Ireland could lay at the consequence
of EU retaliatory action. In keeping all of his options open, now we have to live in a
world with the consequences of the last government, with his support. Will he indicate that he
is prepared to take steps to either exempt Northern Ireland from EU action or take retaliatory
action if they do not?
The Prime Minister.
May I thank him for raising this issue, which is of real importance to his constituents
and everybody in Northern Ireland? It is a very serious issue. That is why we need to
be calm and pragmatic. That is what workers and businesses in Northern Ireland would want
to see from this Government at a time like this. We are, as he would expect, looking
carefully at the details of any retaliatory tariffs announced by the EU, if they are,
and what impact they might have on businesses. As he knows, where goods do not enter the
EU, businesses can claim a full reimbursement of any EU duties paid. I reassure him that
the interests of Northern Ireland are at the forefront of our decisions. He may want to
know that, this morning, the Business Secretary spoke to the Northern Ireland Executive, because
this is a serious issue and we need to work together to resolve it in the interests of
everybody in Northern Ireland.
Mike Chapman.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. While the last Government resorted to damaging keyboard diplomacy, this
Government are leading, bringing 40 nations together this week to tackle illegal immigration.
Like the Prime Minister, I have seen first-hand how counter-terror powers can disrupt threats
before lives are lost. That same approach is essential in dismantling the smuggling
networks, Mr Speaker. Does he agree that it is time the Conservatives and Reform dropped
the posturing, put national security first and backed our Borders Bill?
The right hon. Gentleman. The party opposite tried an open borders experiment. We are now
tackling illegal migration. They talked about flights. We have already removed 24,000 people
with no right to be here. Under their Rwanda scheme, which was only supposed to return
300 people a year, what we have achieved in nine months would have taken them 80 years.
We have replaced a gimmick with a real deterrent.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Prime Minister has spoken very movingly and with genuine
sincerity and affection about his time as a young man in the Langdale Valley in my constituency
and how that helped to shape him. I wonder if he is aware that the hill farmers who maintain
those stunning landscapes in the lakes and elsewhere will be earning, on average, significantly
less or barely half the national minimum wage due to cuts in their income, despite the fact
that they provide the backdrop to the remarkably important tourism economy. Will he agree to
meet me and upland farmers in the lakes and the Dales so that we can design a scheme together
to end this poverty and equip our hill farmers to produce food and protect our epic landscapes
for generations to come?
He and I share a love of the Lake District and we still go back there with our children
now. This is a serious issue, obviously, and that is why we have put a record amount into
farming at the Budget, but also set out our road map. I will happily make sure that he
gets a meeting with the relevant Minister to go through that and to take on board any
points he has to make in relation to it.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Hundreds of residents in my constituency at Union Park are facing
massive £1 million worth of charges to repair their heating system, to repair fire safety
works that have not been put right by the developer, who has now declared bankruptcy
and walked away. Their new freeholder has washed their hands of responsibility and instead
is leveraging huge ground rent bills and fines against those residents. Does the Prime Minister
agree that this is exactly why we have to move forward with our plan, much delayed
from the party opposite, to abolish the outdated leasehold system once and for all as part
of our plan for change?
The Deputy Prime Minister is saying absolutely in my ear. We will end the feudal leasehold
system, which has left millions of homeowners subject to unfair costs and unreasonable practices.
Our reforms include clear standards for repairs and maintenance, and this will give homeowners
a greater say in how their homes are managed. I know that the Housing Minister will have
heard what he said.
This Labour Government have failed the British public at every turn. They have abandoned
the WASPI women, leaving them without compensation they deserve. They have turned their backs
on pensioners by failing to support the winter fuel allowance. They have let down children
by keeping a two-child benefit cap in place, and they will inflict further hardship on
the most vulnerable by slashing £5 billion from benefits.
Perhaps the most immediate and visible failure, one that poses an immediate and direct health
risk to the people of Birmingham, is the appalling financial mismanagement of Labour-run Birmingham
City Council. After more than a decade of Labour control, their incompetence has led
to mountains of uncollected rubbish piling up on every street, so vast that it can be
seen from satellites orbiting space. It is nothing short of a disgrace and a damning
indictment of Labour's inability to govern. Will the Prime Minister take urgent action
to protect the public health and the people of Birmingham by immediately deploying the
odd—
Order. We are meant to ask a quick question, otherwise no-one is going to answer.
I have said that the situation in Birmingham City Council is completely unacceptable, but
the right hon. Gentleman might want to tell his constituents that we have delivered 2
million extra appointments for the NHS, so waiting lists are coming down for his constituents.
We have delivered the national living wage, a £1,400 increase, including for his constituents.
We have got record investment into this country, growing the economy, including for his constituents.
My constituents in Hayward and Middleton North are grafters. They want to work and they want
to see opportunities created and the skills and investment in infrastructure that we need
in future. I welcome the Prime Minister's commitment to fix the transport system in
the north of England that has been holding us back, and I invite him to the Atten Valley
development zone in my constituency to discuss how we can create skilled jobs in north Greater
Manchester.
I am grateful for that question. We will unlock growth across the country in partnership with
local leaders, giving powers to those with skin in the game, and we will fix the north's
broken transport system—another thing they left in a complete mess—with nearly £1.7
billion for local buses, roads and trams, and an additional £415 million to upgrade
the TransPennine route and fixing millions of potholes. I will consider her kind invitation.
Since the Prime Minister and I last spoke, more than 6,000 people have signed an open
letter to the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care in support of North Devon
District Hospital, which faces a 10-year wait for urgent repairs. May I ask the Prime Minister
why the hospital is still being denied a ministerial visit, and will the Government consider the
Trust's emergency plans? Will he meet me and the Trust so that we can discuss keeping
the operating theatres open beyond 2027 to meet capacity?
As in our previous exchange, the hon. Gentleman's fantasy promises of the party opposite meant
that his hospital would never have been delivered. They should not mean that. They should apologise
to his constituents. We had to take tough decisions to make the programme deliverable,
which is what we have done. We will continue to support the Trust to maintain facilities
in advance of the new hospital investment, and the Minister for Secondary Care will be
visiting the hospital. That will be an opportunity, I hope, for the necessary discussions.
Stone Lodge Academy, a special school in Ipswich, will be one of the first schools
in the country to benefit from a new breakfast club this month.
It is an important step to tackling Suffolk's decade-long SEND crisis,
as is the multimillion-pound funding settlement given to opening new specialist places across
the county. Will the Prime Minister outline what steps he will be taking to further break down the
opportunities for all children as part of our plan for change?
I am pleased to say that the first 750 breakfast clubs will open this month. I am pleased that
there is an early adopter in his constituency, as well as in the constituency of the Leader
of the Opposition. I am sure she will welcome that one of these weeks. That will put £450
a year back in the pockets of working people. Today, we have awarded £37 million to 300 primary
schools to create up to 4,000 nursery places from September, making it easier for working
families to access Government-funded childcare.
2,700 workers at Scunthorpe Steelworks are facing redundancy,
many more in the supply chain, and many of them are my Brig and Ghoul constituents.
It is welcome that negotiations are continuing, but whatever the outcome,
significant support will be needed to support the local economy. I know that all those affected
would appreciate and be reassured if the Prime Minister could give an indication that he was
personally taking an interest in this, and that at some point in the not-too-distant future he
would meet me, neighbouring MPs and the council leader to discuss the way forward.
Prime Minister, I am grateful to him for raising the issue. I do take a personal interest. I went
to Scunthorpe to talk to the management and the workers there a short while ago and understand
firsthand the challenges and how deeply worrying it will be for those working there, their families
and the community as a whole. That is why there are negotiations. I do call on the company to
offer the financial support that has been advanced so that we can achieve a sustainable future for
the workforce, the industry and the local community. I believe there is a bright future for
steel, and there needs to be a bright future for steel. I take a personal interest in it.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Too many of my constituents are struggling to get access to a GP appointment
when they need one. Our GPs are trying their best, but they are struggling with capacity,
outdated buildings and outdated tech, all because the party opposite broke the front door
to the National Health Service. Can the Prime Minister reassure my constituents that our plan
for investment and reform will ensure that they will be able to see a GP when they need one?
We are focused on delivering real results for patients by scrapping
unnecessary targets, bringing back the family doctor and requiring online bookings to help
the 8 a.m. scramble. We are investing an additional £889 million to reinforce
the front door of our NHS, which is the biggest increase for over a decade. That will mean
hundreds more GPs since we came to power. This week, we have announced record investment
for community pharmacies to deliver more services for patients and free up GP time.
The recent NHS England report laid bare a catalogue of failures that left a patient
with a history of violent aggression. He was unconfined, untreated and completely unmedicated
for nine months until he killed Iain Coates and the young friends Grace O'Malley-Kumar and
Barnaby Webber from Taunton in my constituency. Will the Prime Minister join me and the people
of Taunton in paying tribute to the families who have campaigned on this? Will he confirm
that a public inquiry is to begin, and will he confirm that, in the context of 50% cuts to
integrated care boards, mental health services, both in the community and secure, will not suffer
from those cuts? I thank the Prime Minister for raising this tragic case. I pay tribute to the
families often in cases like this, including this case. I find it hard to think how I would
actually respond if I was a family member in circumstances like that. I am not sure
I would have the courage that they have to campaign in the way they campaign, and I pay
tribute to it. We do need to get to the bottom of all the issues here, wherever they may lie,
and that is what we will do. In Hamilton and Clyde Valley, my constituents are
accessing the healthcare that they desperately need. One in six Scots is on a waiting list.
Meanwhile, in England, the waiting lists have been coming down for the last
five months, and more than 2 million appointments have been made available.
Does the Prime Minister agree that the SNP-led Government should stop blaming
everybody else for their failures, when Scotland's broken public services are their responsibility?
She is right. Over 60,000 Scots have been stuck waiting for tests or treatment for over a year.
That is a 46% rise in one year. I had to check that figure, because it is so staggering—a
46% rise in one year. Despite this backlog, almost 50,000 fewer operations are being carried out,
compared with before the pandemic. Compare that to England, where we have driven down waiting
lists with over 2 million extra appointments and scrapped NHS England to cut bureaucracy.
Scotland's NHS is in desperate need of reform, but the SNP has no strategy, no plans and no ideas.
Earlier, the Prime Minister seemed reticent to answer a direct question on his jobs tax,
so next time he comes to my constituency to enjoy the beautiful Buckinghamshire
surroundings of Chequers, will he go five minutes up the road to Wendover,
visit Rumsey's Handmade Chocolate and explain to Kate Rumsey why his and his Chancellor's choices
have led to a 15% increase in their costs, that they have already had to lay people off
and reduce the hours of those they still employ? Is that what he meant by growth?
I am happy to tell anyone why. There was a £22 billion black hole left in last week.
It has crashed the economy and ruined our public services. As we have meant that and
rebuilt the country, it has carved from the sidelines. Even now, it cannot bring itself
to say that it does not want the investment. It cannot bring itself to say that it will reverse
the decisions we have made. It actually agrees with the decisions we have made,
because we are clearing up the mess that it left.
One year ago yesterday, my constituent James Henderson was killed with other
aid workers from World Central Kitchen taking humanitarian aid into Gaza.
Jim's family have told me that Jim would want confirmation from our Government
that we are taking all conceivable steps to make sure that aid, power and supplies are
safely returned to Gaza. Will the Prime Minister confirm that he is doing all he can to ensure
this? Will he also confirm that he will continue to push for a full investigation
to be completed into the deaths of Jim and the other British WCK workers,
and for appropriate action to be taken?
Well, I thank the Prime Minister for raising this appalling incident. Our thoughts remain
with the families of Jim, John Chapman and James Kirby. The attacks on aid workers are never
justified. The families do deserve justice. We are pressing the Israeli Government to
accelerate their investigation, including whether criminal proceedings should be initiated.
Can I also say that Israel must stop blocking aid into Gaza? Hostages must be released,
and we must have an urgent resumption of the ceasefire.
Final question, Albert Acosta.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Double-child rapist and murderer Colin Pitchfork is up for parole
for the fifth time. I know the Prime Minister does not have any direct control, nor should he,
over the Parole Board, but he does have a view. As I have asked all his predecessors,
I now put the question to him. Does he agree with me that men who brutally rape and strangle
to death young women should, as a matter of principle, spend most of their natural life
in prison? I am grateful to him for raising this appalling case, and I absolutely agree with him
that there must be maximum penalties for anyone falling into that category. I have seen many of
these cases for myself first-hand when I was a prosecutor for five years, working with the
police on really terrible cases, and I know the impact that it has on victims. I thank him for
raising it.