A Multi-Trillion Dollar Pipe Dream

PragerU
799 followers
Are we heading toward an all-renewable energy future, spearheaded by wind and solar? Or are those energy sources wholly inadequate for the task? Mark Mills, Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute and author of The Cloud Revolution, compares the energy dream to the energy reality.
#carbonfree #carbon #lauraingraham #energy
🚨 PragerU is experiencing severe censorship on Big Tech platforms. Go to https://www.prageru.com/ to watch our videos free from censorship!
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join/
📲 Take PragerU videos with you everywhere you go. Download our free mobile app!
Download for Apple iOS ➡ https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prage...
Download for Android ➡ https://play.google.com/store/apps/de...
china produces more than 80 of all the
world's polysilicon what solar panels
are made from and it's not an irrelevant
point to note that they do that by
using coal-fired electricity because
making solar polysilicon is
extraordinarily energy intensive so
china is doing it with uh we're
reportedly
slave labor but let's let's
set that aside and just look at the
energy issues
which is i use coal to make it and we
use diesel fuel to transport it and we
import it we're a net importer of almost
everything relevant with respect to
to anything that's so called green
energy whether it's key components of
wind turbines uh solar panels of course
and all the key materials and minerals
to make batteries for electric cars and
which china also
utterly completely dominates
indeed china
one of the things one of the things that
the white house said in response today
in one of the reports on this was that
oh this is all good because this is
going to get us faster or more reliably
to the 2035
zero carbon
world they're trying to create how
realistic is that i know you've done
great stuff for prageru on this
act well
let's just uh not to put a fine point on
that either the zero carbon world by
2035 has zero percent chance of
happening i mean we've the world has
spent more than five trillion dollars
probably closer to 10 trillion over the
last two decades to avoid using
hydrocarbons oil natural gas and coal
and that's resulted in a two percentage
point reduction in the share of world
energy coming from hydrocarbons and
solar and wind today combined supply
about three percent of world energy this
is not i mean trillions of dollars
are not going to make any difference to
de-linking the world from hydrocarbons
in fact as of right now 95 of all
things that move in the world all the
machines that move people and goods are
powered by oil
well at least venezuela and saudi arabia
will be able to produce it we're headed
toward an exciting all renewable energy
future wind and solar will power the
world of tomorrow
and tomorrow isn't far off
it's time to wake up
you're having a dream
here's the reality
oil natural gas and coal provide 84
of all the world's energy
that's down just two percentage points
from 20 years ago
and oil still powers nearly 97 of all
global transportation
contrary to headlines claiming that
we're rapidly transitioning away from
fossil fuels
it's just not happening
two decades and five trillion dollars of
governments investing in green energy
and we've barely moved the needle this
was supposed to be easy
why is it so hard
in a word
rocks to get the same amount of energy
from solar and wind that we now get from
fossil fuels we're going to have to
massively increase mining by more than
one thousand percent
this isn't speculation this is physics
copper iron ore silicon nickel chromium
zinc cobalt lithium graphite in rare
earth metals like neodymium we need them
all
and then those metals and materials have
to be turned into motors turbine blades
solar panels batteries and hundreds of
other industrial components
that also takes lots of energy which
requires even more mining as a world
bank study put it these green
technologies are in fact significantly
more material intensive than our current
energy mix
that may be the understatement of the
century
raw materials account for 50 to 70
percent of the costs to manufacture both
solar panels and batteries
until now it hasn't really mattered that
much because wind and solar still
account for only a few percentage points
of the global energy supply
they're an applause line for
environmentalists not a major energy
player and it's unlikely they will be in
the foreseeable future but for the sake
of argument let's say we sharply ramp up
mining where would these new mines be
located well for one china
that country is today the single largest
source of most of our critical energy
materials
the united states is not only a minor
player but is dependent on imports for
100
of 17 critical minerals
do we want to give china more political
and economic leverage europe has made
itself dependent on russia for forty
percent of its natural gas
how well has that worked out
ironically we have all the minerals we
need right here in north america but
good luck trying to get them out of the
ground
proposals to build mines in the united
states and increasingly almost
everywhere else meet fierce opposition
if not outright bans
to give just one example in 2022 the
bite administration canceled a proposed
copper nickel mine in northern minnesota
this was after years of delays
navigating a maze of environmental
regulations and yes the same
environmentalists and green leaning
politicians who tout all the benefits of
electric cars
are the same people who make mining the
materials central to build those cars
like copper and nickel all but
impossible
try to square that circle
so far we've only talked about today's
energy needs
what about tomorrows
future energy demand will be far greater
than today's that's been true for the
entire history of civilization
the future will not only have more
people but also more innovations
and entrepreneurs have always been
better at inventing new ways to use
energy than to produce it it's obvious
but worth stating before the invention
of automobiles airplanes pharmaceuticals
or computers there was no energy needed
to power them
and as more people become more
prosperous
they will want the things others already
have
from better medical care to vacations to
cars
in america there are about 80 cars for
every 100 citizens
in most of the world it's about five
per 100 citizens
over 80 percent of air travels for
personal purposes so that's 2 billion
barrels of oil a year
hospitals use 250 percent more energy
per square foot than an average
commercial building
in the global information infrastructure
the cloud
already uses twice as much electricity
as the entire country of japan the
world's third largest economy
the massive data centers at the heart of
the cloud alone consume almost 10 times
more electricity than the world's 10
million electric cars
e-commerce has taken off and is
propelling record growth in warehouses
increasingly filled with energy-hungry
robots
america's truck freight index more than
doubled in the past decade to deliver
the goods to and from those warehouses
these are today's known trends while we
can't predict the future we can predict
there'll be more innovation in robotics
drones quantum computing biotechnology
in new industries not yet imagined all
of it will require more energy a lot
more
fossil fuels nuclear energy and yes
renewables will be required
but if you think we could get it all
from wind and solar dream on
i'm mark mills senior fellow at the
manhattan institute for prager
university
you
