Israelis or Palestinians: Who’s More Tolerant? | Full Documentary | Short Documentaries

PragerU
800 followers
According to the left, “oppressor Israel” bad; “oppressed Palestinians” good. So you would expect, under this formula, that the Palestinians would be very supportive of their fellow oppressed group, the LGBT community in the Middle East.
But is that really the case?
In PragerU’s new short documentary, Ami Horowitz goes right to the source. He interviews Palestinians to see what they think about gay people and then shows that footage to progressive Americans. The results may surprise you. They certainly surprised the Americans!
Let us know what you think about this short documentary: https://l.prageru.com/3Rx6mGg
#israel #palestinian #tolerance
one of the great human rights paradoxes
is the
lgbtq support for palestinians in the
conflict with israel i went to the
castro district in san francisco to ask
gay men and women about their views on
the conflict
what's your view on the
israeli-palestinian conflict is there
one side that you kind of side with more
than the other i used to side with the
israelis okay
but then i'm starting to to rethink that
do you tend to side more of one side
versus the other palestine we are here
to support the palestinians and give
them a right to freedom and the right to
self sovereignty um and also for israel
to sort of maintain its ground and stay
in its own lane without infringing on
the journeys of others i mean my
ex-wife and i talked about it a lot
that's quite frankly how i learned more
about it but it was really about like
israel for being such bullies and yeah
i tend to
have more sympathy toward
those i perceive as persecuted like the
victims yes um that would be the
palestinians i believe so yeah i'm
really more so just for human rights
mainly so like i want
just people to have good rights and i
want people to be safe i feel
uncomfortable being a gay person in
israel just when i was visiting i was
worried like about what
being attacked or something do you think
most people most gay people
tend to side more especially younger
people tend to decide more of the
palestinians versus the israelis in
general on the conflict
um i would say yes in general the gay
community seems to be more
supportive of palestine because of human
because the human rights
each three months you're gonna hear a
story about a queer person that was
killed honor killing in palestine is
happening all the time
one of the ugliest open secrets of the
human rights world is the situation of
the gay community in gaza
untold men and women have been tortured
and killed at the hands of hamas
less well-known is the horrifying
treatment by the relatively more
moderate palestinian authority and those
who live in that area
this sexual cleansing by the
palestinians is not well covered if at
all by the mainstream media or even the
lgbtq media
ami horowitz in the palestinian
territories there's not much of a debate
on gay marriage here the discussion is
more about the killing and the torturing
of members of the lgbt community there
have been a staggering amount of
incidents of the police
capturing and torturing gay men and
women and honor killings by their family
members
sheikh mahmud is a popular imam in
ramallah the largest and most
cosmopolitan city in the
palestinian-controlled west bank
does any any of the people
who come to your mosque privately
ask you
listen i have a gay child and ask for
your advice
what should be
in your opinion what is worse a child
who is gay or a child who's a drug
addict
what is worse a child who's gay or
a child is a thief
child didn't see him
what about a murderer
[Music]
so this is normally where i do the man
the street portion of the video i've
done man the street videos all across
the world on explosive topics this is
the first time i've had a local producer
expressly forbid me from doing this
segment because he thinks that asking
people about homosexuality will
absolutely explode into violence
but i did it anyway
it's important to note here that the
comments you are about to hear are
representative of the feelings of the
vast majority of people that we came
across that day
foreign
do you think that it's better that we
take the gay people and we put them in
jail is that a better idea oh yeah
foreign
in a concentration camp
can you understand why a father would
want to kill his gay son because it's
not honor for him i'm
what's worse if you found out your son
was gay or your son was a murderer
do you like my shirt
yeah it's not too gay right
okay
in israel only several miles away gay
pride parades are staples of israeli
society the palestinians use that as a
weapon against israel is is the gay
community in palestine a jewish plot to
undermine palestinian society
in israel they have parades for the gays
right does that show a weakness
among the uh the jews and the israelis
the jews responsible for bringing the
gayness into the palestinians
it was very difficult to find a gay
palestinian willing to speak with us
because of the justified fear of what
could happen to them and their family
even if we protected their identity
mahmoud that's not his real name was
willing to speak with us despite the
risks
my mom's family suspected that
i'm gay so like just one night my uncle
was like threatening to
come and beat me up my uncle started
sending me voice messages on whatsapp
and he was screaming in all of them
so he started threatening me he
threatened
to rape me
he also threatened to throw me off a
bridge
and he said that no one will know that i
existed i was really scared i was really
shocked i was terrified like i did like
i went to my mom i told her
look at this and she listened to all the
voice messages and she was laughing and
she refused to do anything a lot of
stories happened to queer people in
palestine a lot of
stuff happened to them it's sad and it's
heartbreaking to be honest
like this person was killed because they
were gay
i know a lot of stories that happened to
gay people in palestine i have a lot of
stories that happen to my friends there
there's a lot of people like each it's
so sad each three months you're gonna
hear a story about a
queer person that was killed as they
were gay
honor killing in palestine is happening
all the time and there's a lot of
torture from like the people themselves
you know the like the community over
there i know a lot of stories about gay
people being raped by other people a
person from
the palestinian people did something to
a queer person and abused them a queer
person can go to the police because
they will be abused again
my friend was raped by a cop a
palestinian cop in the police station in
palestine
and i just remember my friend like he
went out of the police station
like he didn't like it was really bad he
couldn't even walk properly
if he told anyone who is he gonna tell
you no it was a like a cop
like he's not gonna be protected if he
says anything they don't just put them
in jail for like uh
like a couple of days or anything before
they do that they
like you know they they have fun they
start you know abusing them
mentally abusing them physically
and then like after they're like like
they're done and bored
if they're not interested in sleeping
with the guys that they arrested they
just
put them to jail well the police and the
palestinian authority are like
they're one of the same they are the
same the palestinian authority is the
same as the palestinian cops
both of them they do the same thing
we then showed the video to the people
you had just heard from at the beginning
of the film to get their reactions to
what you and they just saw
that's um wow
how about they need to be put in
psychiatric hospitals
if you attack a gay person you have the
mental health problem
they don't value human rights or human
life
if you're watching that does it change
your view on the conflict well 100
no it does well anything that i learned
that is new that i absorb is information
that helps me change my perspective does
it change your perspective on the
situation
it does it does perspective a little bit
in the situation yeah i mean like i i
honestly i didn't know that that was
even going on to be honest so it
made me aware of it it makes me wonder
if the information that i've
learned
isn't it entirely accurate
yeah like i guess it it
puts my
understanding of the situation in a
different light i had no idea that there
was such a
strong gay or lgbtq contingency in
israel or that it was so celebrated and
so protected as a celebration
i mean it's horrifying the way
palestinians look at
homosexuality if i can only believe one
side i'll believe the side who throws
parades as opposed to throwing them off
of woods absolutely i feel like yeah
absolutely i mean and i think that's
supportive really valid way to put it so
from that perspective we've changed
i i think so we check off this list and
this and this and this and every box
because this is the left wing this is
the liberal
100 this is it this is our conversation
piece this is how we move forward we all
have to be aligned with this and this
and this but there's this white washing
this is sort of like watering down of
the reality of the situation um this is
a beautiful piece it adds context to the
situation
palestine i had no idea for such a you
know it is um
promoted as being such a
forward-thinking and progressive young
sect or nation in becoming um you the
last thing that i would think that they
would want to do is ostracize or
marginalize anyone further who might
help their cause right seeking
independence it makes me want to do more
research happy that you stopped us
i you
you
