What do you know about teachers unions? If you think they support educators by negotiating better wages and working conditions, you may be shocked and disturbed to find out that today’s teachers unions are well-funded, highly politicized organizations that are hurting—not helping—the public education system in America and keeping even the worst teachers protected. PragerU’s short documentary investigates how these once well-intentioned teachers unions have become the biggest bully in school.
✅ Protect your kids from bullies, including the teachers unions, and take back their education by joining PragerU Resources for Educators and Parents (PREP): https://l.prageru.com/2UL4Nvr
foreign
it is about money and power they have
nothing to do with advancing education
the kids didn't have a voice at the
table it was all sound bites and lies
they're hiding the answers from parents
like me they would protect teachers they
knew were bad teachers they're sending
millions of dollars to left-leaning
groups or politicians every year I felt
that I didn't have a voice there they
didn't want to listen to us there's real
problems happening with our kids they're
only working for the union they're not
even working for their teachers
[Music]
foreign
I'm a former public school teacher of 15
years and the founder of Exodus
Institute I want America to know how
teachers unions are negatively affecting
public education in our country
I was born to be a teacher I had a lot
of success in my classroom I will still
always be a teacher just not in public
education
personally believe the union never
represented me our schools are supposed
to be politically neutral environments
and that's no longer what they are
America needs to see what's happening in
our classrooms and how our teachers are
being trained to be racist and how a lot
of this is being pushed by the teachers
unions
I know my experience with the teachers
union but I know there's so much more to
the story I reached out to subject
matter experts parents and fellow
teachers to learn more
and as with any story we have to start
from the beginning
[Music]
is actually sprung up in the mid-1800s
they were kind of just a way to
legitimize the role of a teacher and to
standardize how you got that career when
you get to the Great Depression cities
or towns for slashing their budgets just
to sort of pay for General Public Works
one of the first things to go was
teacher salaries so you know the unions
could step in and say this is what we're
fighting for better pay for teachers
better classroom conditions right after
World War II and then going into the 50s
we're in the Red Scare in the country
right if there's any small suspicion
that maybe you were sympathetic to the
Communist party or anything like that
you could be fired and that's how we got
the sort of tenure system that we have
today I was really born out of this
effort to protect teachers from these
unjust and unfair firings of course now
when we think about the 10-year system
we know it's one of the probably
greatest detriments to our public school
system and what is tenure tenure
basically means that teachers can't get
fired for anything barring some sort of
egregious violation unfortunately for
school children poor performance is not
an egregious violation
early in my career I understood how
tenure could protect more senior
teachers but I didn't realize a tenure
also protected teachers who put in
little to no effort
I spoke with John Schilling who started
his career in the Arizona Department of
Education to get a better picture of
just how far unions will go to protect
the worst teachers
do you think the unions protect teachers
that probably shouldn't be in the
classroom oh unquestionably
I mean the process to even get rid of a
teacher that has clearly done something
wrong is very laborious there's no
question that the union goes out of the
way to protect Bad Teachers if a teacher
can no longer be in the classroom
they've done something so egregious they
can't be around students but they can't
be fired yet they're in this limbo
period the teachers unions decided they
would send them to these rubber rooms
which was truly just a room where these
teachers would go and do nothing all day
and the entire time they're still
getting their full pay and their full
benefits and the rubber rooms are a
direct product of teachers unions yes
rubber rooms were fully engineered by
teachers unions the New Yorker did this
huge investigation around rubber rooms
and found that the average teacher could
be in a rubber room for three years or
more
the worst of the worst may end up in
rubber rooms but many subpar teachers
stay in the classroom and even if the
teacher across the hall is 10 times more
effective their paychecks could be the
same or lower
the years educational reform has been
pushing for something called Merit pay
where we wanted to pay our best teachers
more money and we wanted to be able to
reward teachers on how well they were
preparing children to move on to the
next level the unions don't like Merit
pay it doesn't really make any
difference whether you're a really great
teacher or not so good teacher if you've
been there for 30 years your pay is
going to go up we really aren't
fostering the goodness in some of our
teachers we're actually holding them
back which is crazy yeah they are just
not in the business of wanting to ensure
that every child has a quality education
or to improve academic outcomes for kids
and they've become particularly in the
last 25 years very very political and
with all of their political giving and
all of the grants that they hand out
really going you know to the left side
of the aisle that is not accurately
representing their membership because
not every teacher has views like that
some people are accusing teachers unions
of being more of a political
organization than a teachers
organization what do you have to say
about that teachers unions are
definitely more of a political
organization than an educational
organization you have the National
Education Association and the American
Federation of teachers both of these
unions are political powerhouses in the
last 20 years the Nea has sent over 200
million dollars to politics and the AFT
in the same vein they've sent about 90
million dollars That's not including
some of these left-leaning groups like
Planned Parenthood the Clinton
Foundation that are also getting money
every single year from these groups and
teachers unions where do they get their
funding from
all teachers unions are funded by their
members dues so everything they're
sending to politics is coming from their
members Pockets from their hard-earned
cash
these are political activities and
grants to advance Progressive agenda
they have nothing to do with helping
children learn they have nothing to do
with giving children opportunity they
have nothing to do with improving
outcomes and frankly it doesn't have
anything to do with improving teacher
pay or benefits for the teachers unions
it is about money and power and we got
an honest glimpse into this back in 2009
the top lawyer for the National
Education Association for for decades he
talked about why the union was effective
and he said straight up it is not
because we care about children and it is
not because we have a vision of a great
public school for every child Nea and
its Affiliates are effective Advocates
because we have power
it's not because we care about kids it's
because we have power it's because we
have three and a half million members
who are giving us hundreds of millions
of dollars every year that's what we are
how are teachers and students affected
by the unions and why is this an
important issue to be aware of the
teacher unions are the ones that are
often making the decisions without the
input from a lot of rank and file
teachers is the unions they largely
control most of the school boards in
America I think one of the things that a
lot of people don't realize is the role
that teachers unions played over the
course of the pandemic it became clear
that the teachers unions had seriously
influenced the CDC on school reopening
guidance if you talk to regular Rank and
file teachers I'm guessing that most of
them wanted to be back in the classroom
it wasn't just teachers who wanted to
return to the classroom parents were
desperate for schools to reopen as well
after months of watching their children
struggle many parents were shocked to
realize it was the unions who were
keeping schools closed
you experienced being a parent with
children that had to stay at home for a
long period of time what was it like as
a parent it was a real
disaster from the parent perspective a
lot of kids were struggling I know that
was true in my house you couldn't just
step back and assume that the teachers
union was going to push for something
that was going to be in the best
interest of the kids the unions were
really trying to make a lot of very
unreasonable demands in order to go back
into the classroom things like you know
we wanted to make sure that every
teacher was vaccinated every student had
to be vaccinated and this was at a time
where vaccines hadn't even been approved
for children they wanted a massive
infusion of new federal money the unions
were trying to prevent students from
leaving their traditional public schools
and going into online learning for
online Charter Schools or Online private
schools these are the kinds of things
that again just had a terribly negative
impact on students
teachers knew students were struggling
but as they waited for schools to reopen
their unions began pressuring school
boards to remain closed while they used
the pandemic to try to score political
points
our Union basically controls about half
the school board and so when the union
pushes very very heavily to keep things
close and those board members are more
than happy to go ahead and push to
maintain the status quo of keeping
schools closed your local union was
calling to defund the police weren't
they leveraging that against opening up
the schools I remember hearing about
this in the news they wanted to push for
all sorts of social changes and then
using the The Cloud of having the
teachers not come back in covid was one
of their mechanisms what were they
calling for I mean that's the abolition
of police wow
with schools closed many parents saw for
the first time just how political
classrooms have gotten but when parents
begin to dig into the curriculum to see
what exactly was being taught the unions
became desperate to shut them out
what we see is very scary for our
children how did you start getting
concerned about the curriculum that was
being taught to your five-year-old
daughter my school district sent out a
message to the community saying that
they had declared my school district to
be systemically racist they were using
highly politicized language but if you
go on the Nea website you'll see that
they have black lives matter curriculum
social justice curriculum they're called
the teachers in United students union so
why are they proposing curriculum for
students there's a lot of information
out there that's where people are
fighting against critical race Theory
and they're saying you're trying to ban
history you're trying to ban the
teaching of slavery or teaching about
Jim Crow laws you know how would you
respond to that we need to teach The
Good the Bad and the Ugly and and we
have been teaching The Good the Bad and
the Ugly critical race Theory says that
the entire system in America whether
it's the judicial system bureaucracies
are racist the teachers unions want to
teach history through lens critical race
theory that makes it seem like America
is not the country that it actually is
we actually live in a country with a
judicial system and a government that
tries to fight racism that's why we have
anti-discrimination laws you are being
legally bullied by the teachers union
can you share what's happening with that
so the teachers union is suing me for
submitting public records requests about
what my kids would be learning in school
before that happened actually my school
district they had a full five-hour
school board meeting where my school
board had people speak against me as if
they were Witnesses speaking against me
at trial they put all of my public
records requests on a big screen as if
they were admitting evidence against me
it was a real show trial and to know
that this was me that was on trial was
like an out of body experience and they
were really just trying to publicly
humiliate me in a school board meeting
but then two months later the Nea which
is the largest teachers union in America
did Sue me not only are they trying to
carve out a new law for themselves to
interfere in the public records request
process I think they were primarily
trying to bully me harass me and send a
message to other parents that they will
come after them with frivolous
litigation if they advocate for their
children in the same way that I did
teachers unions have a lot of power but
it is possible for teachers to fight
back my view has always been that the
role of a union is to cover wages hours
and working conditions for the workers
and that all these other social agendas
are a distraction from they're
representing the employees in the event
that you would pose a different view
than what was being presented than you
would be brow beaten and intimidated and
some of the union members were verbally
abusive to anybody who didn't tow their
specific line what happened when you
asked to get out of it and app no longer
Paid Dues what did they do I explored
every option I could to go through the
union and to go through the district and
I've been denied at every step of the
way so then I connected with the freedom
foundation and then on my behalf they
went ahead and then filed a lawsuit for
me so you basically came out as against
the defund the police movement what do
you think should happen to protect our
children and to protect our teachers
step number one is a lot less brushing
things under the carpet what the school
district did is because they didn't want
to have the school the prison pipeline
so now you could have a kid that could
stab somebody slash somebody and hit
somebody with a rock and they would have
no accountability do you have hope for
the teachers unions and what do you
think needs to change in order for the
system to actually get back all of the
Great things that it was originally for
there's gonna have to be an epiphany
moment brought about by the lack of
discipline and the lack of safety of
both the students and the staff and
people may think hey Union maybe we need
to go ahead in and focus more on
traditional Union objectives versus a
social engineering agenda of eliminating
consequences for misbehavior
[Music]
parents have also proven that they are a
powerful force to counter the teachers
unions I want to know what other parents
can do to join in that fight
so in a sense you became a community
organizer through this we we call
ourselves accidental activists we
started providing a lot of advocacy
information for parents who are starving
for it how you contact the school board
members and what you should ask them and
what you can say because parents felt
very helpless in Fairfax County when it
came to getting the schools open it's
okay to reach out to your school board
member and ask questions and express
concern and I think most parents never
knew until they got into the middle of
this problem that the kids didn't have a
voice at the table the teachers you know
has done a really good job in convincing
teachers that you need them and and also
don't challenge us because you know
we'll retaliate against you but if a
little bit of organization starts
happening around the scenes I'm hopeful
that that tide can turn they don't know
what to do when you fight back they
don't have a plan B so fight back people
assume that because a teachers union
supports something that it's actually
something that's good for students and
good for teachers and so we need to
really spread the word that teachers
unions and what's right for teachers and
students are very very separate things
what would you say to someone who
doesn't have a child in the educational
system right now should they be worried
about teachers unions everybody pays
taxes and your taxes are going to pay
teachers their salaries and a portion of
those salaries are going right to
teachers unions so without really
thinking about it you are supporting the
very political organizations that
teachers unions are sending their
members dues to
their political action committees
they're not pro-education they're just
pro-union they're only working for the
union they're not even working for their
teachers
the teachers unions are failing us what
can we do to fix the system there have
been a lot of reforms over the last 25
years but unquestionably the most
important of those reforms has been
school choice and I think the more we
can Empower parents to be able to choose
the right educational environment for
their child that's going to shake up the
system I think if we have more
competition in education we're going to
see more empowered teachers and we're
going to see better and improved
educational outcomes for all children
the biggest reason I think that they are
opposed to things like school choice
it's because there's no union dues in
that the average voter if they heard
about school choice they would be like
wow this is amazing I get to choose the
school that I want my child to go to yet
it's so polarized no this should be
bipartisan what's going on yeah sadly it
really does boil down to politics you
know the Union money really just goes to
one side of the aisle on the left and as
a result you find a lot of folks who are
sort of reluctant to cross the unions
and that's really unfortunate because
when you look at the polling data today
if you were a politician and you saw
numbers like this you would think that
you would be rushing to go file bills to
expand this but sadly that is just not
the case if we really want to empower
parents to make choices for their own
kids money must follow children our K-12
system despite 25 years of some pretty
significant reforms remains largely an
Antiquated 19th century system
[Music]
in 2022 we got our first glimpse into
the damage caused by the teacher
union-led shutdowns more than two
decades of growth in math and reading
vanished during the shutdowns minority
and low-income students suffered the
most
now more than ever we need the best
teachers possible to help our students
regain ground
we cannot let the unions drive for more
money and power destroy another
generation our future depends on it
thanks for watching our documentary the
teachers unions are the biggest bullies
in school but you can stand up against
them by standing with us sign up for
prep prageru's resources for educators
and parents and take action today