Fencing at the 2024 Paris Olympics: My Thoughts

Fencing Highlights
9 followers
Mar 31, 2025
So after nine action-packed days, the fencing has finally concluded at the Grand Palais.
It's been a lot of fun and I do have a lot of thoughts about it all. So let's start with the
good stuff. The standard of fencing is possibly the highest it's ever been in my opinion, which
makes for some really exciting fencing and some jaw-dropping feats of skill. These Olympics have
really shown that fencing is becoming less and less of a Eurocentric sport, which is going to
be really important for the long-term health of fencing. There have been plenty of viral moments
too. One of the things that got non-fencers talking was Sébastien Patrice and his huge bouncy attacks.
I think it's a good example of how it's good to have such a wide variety of fencing styles
Another story that reached far outside of the fencing world was Nada Hafez of Egypt,
announcing that she was seven months pregnant after upsetting Tartakovsky of USA. It's just
nice to see fencing get some level of mainstream recognition, even if it is just for a couple of
weeks. The venue was amazing, the Grand Palais felt like a really appropriate place for fencing
and the crowds were really great. I was there for the finals and bronze medal matches of the
men's team Sabre and the atmosphere as France won the bronze medal was just insane. Towards
the end of the match I was kind of worried that it might overshadow the final, but even just the
Hungarian and Korean fans were loud enough to make it feel really really special. So that's some of
the good stuff, but I'm afraid now I'm gonna have to return to my usual state of cynicism. It's been
hard to watch these Olympics knowing that sitting at home is one of the best fencers in the world.
Despina Georgiadou was world number three at the Olympics and she couldn't compete due to the
nonsensical qualification rules that meant Greece couldn't have two fencers in the women's individual
Sabre event. Even though France, Italy, Korea, Japan, Ukraine, USA, Algeria and Hungary were
all allowed to have three fencers. The rules just don't really make sense. Imagine if Nadal wasn't
allowed to compete in the tennis because Alcarez was already qualified. It would be crazy. It's also
sad that certain fencers are taking places that in my opinion they don't really deserve.
I've been banging on about this a lot but the state of refereeing at the minute is absolutely
dire, especially in Sabre. It's not just the calls that are clearly wrong, it's the number of bouts
that are decided by stupidly close decisions that makes refereeing feel so arbitrary and even random.
Fares Ferjani is clearly a great fencer and I really enjoyed watching him win the silver medal
but I don't think it's fair that he beat Gemechi based on a total coin flip of a decision. What
did Gemechi do wrong here to lose a point at 14-14? It just feels really unfair to me.
This is the touch that knocked Basadze out. Don't get me wrong, Basadze's behaviour here was totally
unacceptable and just shows how spineless the FIE are when the big stars of a sport act out
but I do feel for him getting knocked out on such a tight decision. I did a poll for this one too and
in my opinion if the most popular answer doesn't even get 50% of the votes that's a pretty good
sign that an action should be called as simultaneous but for some reason referees
think that they should split pretty much every action that they can. I've said it before but
in my opinion this kind of refereeing is making Sabre less interesting with more matches decided
by coin flips in the middle of a piece rather than actual fun end-to-end actions. Having said that for
women Sabre is generally a lot better than the men's. There is also the issue of substitutes
in team events. For some reason at the Olympics if you don't use your sub then they don't get a medal
and also once the substitution is made you can't make another substitution for the rest of the day
which is really really stupid. There was an incident in the men's team foil match between
France and China where in the last relay Mo Ziwei was hit in the head by Lefort's guard.
Now it's hard to tell for sure but it kind of looks like the medical delegate
decides that Mo is unfit to continue fencing and should be subbed off but since China had
already made their substitution the referee declares France the winner ending the bout.
Then Wang Haibin turns up. Wang is president of the Chinese federation and a member of the FIE
executive committee. After discussions with the referees they decide to continue the match.
Now I think the rules are completely stupid and that under these circumstances China should
clearly have been allowed to make a substitution but the rules are clear that you can't do that
and it's also pretty bad that Mo is left to fence potentially with a concussion which
isn't really the done thing in in actual serious sports. And finally as both a member of the comics
and a representative of the Chinese federation I don't believe Wang should be involved in the
to me that's a very clear conflict of interest. Another thing that I hate about the IOC is how
strict they are about enforcing their copyright. It's really inconsistent what you can get away
with. I've posted a few Instagram reels containing Olympic footage that have had millions of views
but then a six second clip can get my account suspended. Now maybe I was a bit silly trying
to get away with this when they are completely in their rights to protect their IP but I really
don't think it is in the IOC's interest to suppress the coverage of their events to this extent.
Viral moments occur organically when normal people can share fun and interesting clips images
whatever and I'm not sure that suppressing people's ability to do this is good for the
To me it's clear that the FIE is rotten to the core and it kind of sickens me to see the likes
of Milenchev and Valiev refereeing when they have a history of breaking FIE rules without consequence.
I've done full videos on both of these already but here's just another example of why Milenchev
should not be anywhere near the Olympics. This is from the women's team sabre event at the 2023
Tashkent World Cup. Milenchev is supposed to be refereeing the bout between France and Poland
instead he got Valiev to referee the match and spent the whole time coaching the Bulgarian team
in their match against Korea. Clearly against the rules and clearly shows that Milenchev is not fit
to referee but here he is again number one referee at the Olympics and I'm sure he'll once again get
his $10,000 prize from the FIE for being the best referee in the world. In my opinion the FIE is
becoming more and more unfit to manage the sport even at the Olympics they can't get their shit
together and actually apply their own rules. I'm a massive fan of Olga Carlan and I'm glad she won
bronze in the women's sabre event but Luigi Martellotti of Italy should not have been allowed
to referee this bronze medal match. Olga Carlan lives in Italy with her Italian partner Luigi
Samelli and is coached by an Italian. According to the FIE's own rules this is a category A
conflict of interests and should not happen. Either the FIE is grossly incompetent or they
are deliberately breaking their own rules either way it's really concerning. In fact this is one
of the big issues right now with the FIE nobody trusts it. It's fairly normal to blame the referee
a bit when you lose I'm sure we've all done it to some extent but more and more we are seeing
accusations of referee collusion and calls for investigations into refereeing decisions.
Now I'm not yet convinced that any of the matches at these Olympics were obviously fixed by
referees at least not to the extent that I believe that they have been at other events but the fact
is when fencers know that referees have been offered bribes and when refereeing is so wildly
inconsistent and when rules are repeatedly broken without consequence then you can't really blame
anyone who has lost on a few tight calls for thinking that they've just been robbed. In sport
even just the appearance of integrity is really important and the FIE is losing its credibility
as an organisation. If nothing is done to restore faith in the integrity of a sport then I really
worry that things could start falling apart. So yeah anyway sorry for being a bit negative
overall things aren't all that bad I just think there are some huge issues that have to be
confronted right now. If you want to support the channel please take a look at my Patreon
there's a growing catalogue of exclusive videos and a few Olympics videos there too. I'll probably
do more so make sure you sign up to the Slicer Sabre Patreon. Cheers, thanks for watching, bye.
