Longsword, bastard sword, two-handed sword - a response to Lindybeige

Ancient Swords
6 followers
26 Video Views·Mar 31, 2025
Here are some examples quickly pulled off the web - there are lots of examples once you start looking, but I have never catalogued them.
Hey guys, Matt here. So I just finished watching quite an enjoyable short video from
Lindy Beige from Lloyd about medieval swords, during which he talked about long swords and
bastard swords and hand and hearth swords. And I feel that I need to clarify a couple of points
which I think were perhaps poorly made in that video and perhaps incorrectly made. So
the first thing to say is what I'm holding here is usually described in modern historical fencing
or hema as a long sword. You could describe it as a bastard sword, you could describe it as a
hand and a hearth sword, some people may even call it a two-handed sword. Now the first thing to say
is that these terms are largely, although not entirely, they're largely modern in their
applications. That's not to say they're modern terms, but the way that we choose to apply them
to certain weapons is more or less a modern artefact. I've researched quite a lot of
medieval English sources, particularly 14th, 15th century sources, because that's my focus of
interest in the medieval period, and the terms two-handed sword, long sword and bastard sword
are all used, but we never really know precisely what they're referring to. Now if we look at
continental sources, if we look at the actual fencing treatises which actually show these
swords in use, we can see that langenschwert or langschwert in German is commonly used,
which translates as long sword, and actually in Italy it's usually a spada adumani,
which means two-handed sword, applied to this sort of length weapon, a weapon that you can use in one
hand or two. In fact in Italian the large two-handed sword is usually called a spadone,
which means big sword or great sword, and in fact in Spanish sources it's usually known as a
montante, and in German sources the very big sword is usually known as a beidenhänder I believe, or
perhaps a weihander. So there we have in the historical sources a range of terminologies.
In fact the term bastard sword is used in both English and French sources, however
we do not know precisely what it's referring to, okay? Épée batard or bastard sword, we don't
really know what type of sword is being described, and some people have surmised that it's actually
not a two-handed sword or not a long sword at all, but it's actually a form of one-handed sword
with a certain type of blade on it. We just basically don't know really what a bastard sword
is. There's contradictory evidence one way and the other, okay? But the overall point to make
is that all types of medieval sword, straight double-edged medieval sword, in medieval sources
are usually called sword, okay? The obsession with classification and breaking down typologies
of swords, breaking down types of sword into as many different subsets and subgroups that we
possibly can, is really something that we get from our Victorian forebearers who wanted to
scientifically categorise everything, and of course it started off with the study of nature
and animals and so on and so forth, but quickly spread onto swords, and really, you know, it was
Hewitt Oakeshott who really took this to the extreme in the middle of the 20th century through
to the, basically from the 1950s to the 1980s, of actually breaking down medieval swords into
typologies, types of blades, types of crossguard, types of pommel. Now I'm not saying that's a bad
thing at all, it's very useful to scientifically study the development of weapons over time
to be able to do that, okay? But what we have to remember is that medieval people usually didn't
give a damn about those kind of descriptions, okay? This is usually called sword or spada,
okay, or schwert. It's not usually, in most medieval sources, it is not usually specified
as being a longsword or a bastard sword or a hand-and-a-half sword, it's just a sword, okay?
So, if we want to call this a bastard sword or a longsword or a hand-and-a-half sword,
largely this is a modern choice for modern weapons, or at least ancient weapons in modern
museums, okay? That's my first point. The second point that came up in Lloyd's video
was about the use of these in one hand. Now, making a subjective opinion on the use of a
sword in one hand is always going to be based on two factors. One, the sword, and secondly,
you, okay? Now, there are some swords I can happily, some big swords I can happily use in
one hand, and some big swords I can't happily use in one hand. But the important thing to note is
that these so-called hand-and-a-half swords or longswords are shown being used one-handed
in the Medieval and Renaissance treatises in a variety of ways. Firstly, they're shown used on
horseback with one hand. You cannot easily use a two-handed sword on horseback. It is shown in
some Medieval and Renaissance art being used two-handed on horseback, but of course to do so,
you have to drop the reins of your horse. So, generally speaking, this sort of sword
is employed one-handed when on horseback. The second time when you use it one-handed
is when you are grabbing or grappling your opponent. So, if you look at any of the famous
and freely available online Medieval treatises or Renaissance treatises from the likes of Furey
Delivery or Paulus Cal or Hans Talhoffer or so on and so forth, Philippe Avadi and so on,
you will see there are lots of techniques where the left hand and sometimes the right hand,
but usually the left hand, assuming you're right-handed, is used to either grab the opponent's
weapon or grab a part of their body or throw them or grapple with them or such, like doing things
that are up close, leaving this hand free usually to stab, sometimes to cut, sometimes to pommel,
sometimes to hit with a crossguard. In other words, to use this offensively whilst you detain
and occupy the opponent or their weapon with this hand. And sometimes, as I mentioned,
sometimes it's the other way around, although in Italian sources it's almost always grappling
with the left hand, but German sources do occasionally show grappling with the right hand.
So, that's the second time when you use this as a one-handed sword, essentially.
And the final time I want to mention is actually in conjunction with shields and bucklers. So,
contrary to what Lloyd said in his video, in actual fact there are lots of examples in art
of what are clearly long-handled, hand-and-a-half swords or long swords being used both with shields
of various types, right up to the pavis, big large shields, and right the way down to bucklers
as well. And if you look in Paulus Kall's manual, you'll see that in the sword and buckler plates,
he actually very clearly shows the buckler being used in the left hand and what's very clearly a
long sword with a long handle being used in the right hand. So, and finally, just to say that
Lloyd is quite correct that this type of long sword, bastard sword, was indeed used one-handed
for special techniques such as lancing out the sword one-handed. And what I want to clarify
is actually this was done with the big great sword, big two-handed sword also. And if you
look at Degrassi, for example, Degrassi describes techniques for using the big two-handed sword,
the sword that comes up to your chin when it points on the ground, or maybe up to your head,
a very big five or six foot long sword. And he actually uses it against a single opponent
like a one-handed spear. And he says you use the point predominantly, and you do in fact
lance the thing out. So you might support it with your other hand and you lance the thing
out one-handed, either from the front of the grip or the back of the grip as you like,
against a single opponent. And he says then you employ cuts using it like a great big,
like a pole weapon, like a staff weapon almost, or a quarter staff against multiple opponents.
So there we go. There are a variety of ways you can use the long sword, or two-handed sword,
or bastard sword in one hand. And it's very important to emphasize that these terms applied
to specific types of weapon are really a modern thing. And although these terms did have use in
the historical periods we're studying, we're not always clear on what weapon is being used
to attach to a certain term. And as a final parting example I use of that, if you look at
Joseph Swetnam's treatise of 1617, he uses the term long sword very clearly to refer to
probably what we would describe, what most people would describe today as a rapier or a side sword.
He's describing a sword that can cut and thrust, but is a one-handed sword with a long blade and
a rapier type hilt. So the terms could mean completely different things at different times
to different people, just as they do now. Okay, so at the end of the day this is a sword. Thank you.
